How to configure Xcode external build system to build and clean using standard short-cuts? [Xcode 10.1, MacOS 10.14.1]

I have a project that uses bmake (could be any make though) and the Makefile provides a number of targets.  I would like to use Xcode to build host and clean the build folder, but I'm having trouble working out how configure Xcode to allow me to this.

From the command line, I would build using bmake host and clean using bmake clean.  The reason I'm using Xcode for this is because I like to use an IDE for debugging.

In Project -&gt; Info (External Build Tool Configuration), I have:

Build Tool  :  /usr/local/bin/bmake
Arguments   :  host
Directory   :  None     &lt;- I'm using the current path


With these settings, Product -&gt; Build builds my target, but Product -&gt; Clean Build Folder does nothing even though Xcode reports that the clean succeeded.

In order to actually do a clean, I either need to define another target with the Arguments field set to clean and then switch between targets when building/cleaning, or, use a single target and change the argument field depending on whether I'm building or cleaning.  (A really clumsy way of going about it.)

If I leave Arguments with it's default value $(ACTION) all targets get built (except clean), and cleaning does nothing useful.

I've read https://stackoverflow.com/questions/15652316/setup-xcode-for-using-external-compiler but that question does not address this problem.

Is there a better way of doing this?
The approach we are using:


Run external build system (i.e. Make or CMake) via custom script from "External Build System" target or just as a "Run script" build phase.
At some point of custom script execution save a text file (say CMakeStatus.txt) to BUILT_PRODUCTS_DIR, which will be used as a flag indicating that Xcode did clean.
In your custom script check that CMakeStatus.txt is present or not. If not, then rebuild your external build system.


Here is example of using Cmake and rebuilding it if Xcode did a clean.

#!/usr/bin/env ruby -w

require 'fileutils'

# system("printenv | sort")

AppProjectName = ENV['PROJECT_NAME']
AppBuildRootDir = ENV['AWL_CMAKE_BUILDS']
AppBuildDirPath = ENV['BUILT_PRODUCTS_DIR']
AppPlatform = ENV['PLATFORM_NAME']
AppBuildConfig = ENV['CONFIGURATION']
AppTargetDeviceId = ENV['TARGET_DEVICE_IDENTIFIER']
if AppProjectName.nil?
   raise "❌ Variable \"PROJECT_NAME\" is not passed to script."
end
if AppBuildRootDir.nil?
   raise "❌ Variable \"AWL_CMAKE_BUILDS\" is not passed to script."
end
if AppBuildDirPath.nil?
   raise "❌ Variable \"BUILT_PRODUCTS_DIR\" is not passed to script."
end
if AppPlatform.nil?
   raise "❌ Variable \"PLATFORM_NAME\" is not passed to script."
end
if AppBuildConfig.nil?
   raise "❌ Variable \"CONFIGURATION\" is not passed to script."
end

WhiteListedVars = ["PATH", "HOME"]
ENV.keys.each { |key|
   if !WhiteListedVars.include? key
      ENV[key] = nil
   end
}
AppNewEnvVars = `bash -l -c printenv`.strip.split("\n")
AppNewEnvVars.each { |var|
   components = var.split("=", 2)
   key = components[0]
   value = components[1]
   ENV[key] = value
}

# system("printenv | sort")

AppCmakeBuildDirPath = "#{AppBuildRootDir}/#{AppProjectName}"
AppCmakeCacheFilePath = "#{AppCmakeBuildDirPath}/CMakeCache.txt"
AppCmakeStatusFilePath = "#{AppBuildDirPath}/CMakeStatus.txt"

if !File.exist?(AppCmakeStatusFilePath) &amp;&amp; Dir.exist?(AppCmakeBuildDirPath)
   puts "✅ Deleting previous build at \"#{AppCmakeBuildDirPath}\"..."
   FileUtils.rm_rf(AppCmakeBuildDirPath)
end

if !File.exist?(AppCmakeCacheFilePath)
   puts "✅ Generating Cmake for Platform \"#{AppPlatform}\"..."
   cmd = "cmake -G Xcode -B \"#{AppCmakeBuildDirPath}\" -DCMAKE_Swift_COMPILER_FORCED=true -DCMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=#{AppBuildConfig} "
   if AppPlatform == "macosx"
      cmd += "-DCMAKE_OSX_DEPLOYMENT_TARGET=10.13"
   elsif
      cmd += "-DCMAKE_OSX_DEPLOYMENT_TARGET=11.0 -DCMAKE_SYSTEM_NAME=iOS"
   end
   puts cmd
   system cmd
   File.write(AppCmakeStatusFilePath, 'This file used just as a status flag to clean Cmake.')
end

puts "✅ Building Cmake for Platform \"#{AppPlatform}\" ..."

cmd = "set -euf -o pipefail &amp;&amp; cd \"#{AppCmakeBuildDirPath}\" &amp;&amp; cmake --build \"#{AppCmakeBuildDirPath}\" -- -quiet CONFIGURATION_BUILD_DIR=\"#{AppBuildDirPath}\" "
if AppPlatform == "macosx"
   cmd += "-destination 'platform=OS X,arch=x86_64'"
elsif AppPlatform == "iphonesimulator"
   if AppTargetDeviceId.nil?
      raise "❌ Variable \"TARGET_DEVICE_IDENTIFIER\" is not passed to script."
   end
   cmd += "-sdk iphonesimulator -destination 'platform=iOS Simulator,id=#{AppTargetDeviceId}'"
else
   if AppTargetDeviceId.nil?
      cmd += "-sdk iphoneos -destination generic/platform=iOS"
   else
      cmd += "-sdk iphoneos -destination 'platform=iOS,id=#{AppTargetDeviceId}'"
   end
end

# cmd += " | xcpretty"
puts cmd
system(cmd) or exit 1