We attempted anal, but didn't get to the end. My boyfriend and I have been talking about anal, and we finally tried it this weekend. We did our research to start of slow and whatnot, so we got lube and he started with his fingers. He got one finger in and then eventually the other. We took our time and went really slow. I was not in pain or anything, but I had one problem that I just couldn't get over.

When he was thrusting with his fingers, it felt like I was pooping or had to poop when he was pulling them out. When he was putting them back in, it felt totally fine. I told him to call it quits because the feeling just totally put me off.

So, does this feeling ever go away or are there any ways to forget about it?