Discussion in 'Philosophy and Religion' started by Roughroughmagic, Feb 2, 2019.
As someone who is not a INFJ himself, I think he did a great job of analysing our behaviour.
But I have to say that the main thing that really caught my attention is his description of how INFJs are in danger of getting lost in their fantasy world and become completely detached from the real world.
And from my experience, I am absolutely guilty of that. I tend to socially withdrawn and when things get tough, I tend to get lost in my inner world of ideas and fantasies, hopes and dreams. But I reached a point in my life when I realised that if I want to have a happy life I really need to get outside of my shell and work on myself, go beyond my comfort zone and challenge my limiting beliefs about people and world.
Do you have similar tendencies? Or maybe you completely disagree with the statements made in this video?
ClevelandINTP, Rowan Tree, Ren and 3 others like this.
This is definitely an analysis by an INFP. Unmistakably.
There is nothing that can be done about this, INFPs just live in their own world most of the time. I'm not disagreeing with what he observed, although I am disagreeing with each and every interpretation of it, including the "modes", which aren't indicative of INFJ behaviour but rather INFP behaviour. He is projecting his own cognitive processes onto another type. It happens.
The detachment is quite real, though not as he described it. And your own take on it seems a very healthy choice towards development to me.
Rowan Tree, tovlo, Fidicen and 2 others like this.
I also wasn't very fond of his 'modes' but I thought it is just my personal perspective. Because myself, I actually struggle with being too open with people, sharing too much too early - not being so guarded, as how he describes it.
But as I said, I could really related to being detached and focusing more on ideas and abstract concepts instead of appreciating real tangible things.
Rowan Tree, tovlo, Fidicen and 1 other person like this.
It is indeed fun to learn what others think about one type, as you learn more about them in return.
It was actually most visible to me in the way he described the fantasy mode. The way he described it, it wasn't the usual Ni-Ti loop that we experience - which is just us in our heads thinking -, it was rather the INFP's use of Fi-Si with Ne mixed in, which is kind of like a tertiary loop as well, but with input from the ideation function Ne. They are more capable of getting lost in memories and making up worlds of their own. If an INFJ did that, it is almost always with a darker twist or a "what if" in the back of our minds. We use Ne mostly to plan ahead for contingencies that might occur.
Rowan Tree, tovlo and Fidicen like this.
I agree. He is projecting. He is observing who we are and misinterpreting it.
Rowan Tree, tovlo and Ginny like this.
Everyone fantasizes about something in their life but I most certainly don't get lost in them. I'm probably the biggest pragmatist and realist you will ever meet as I see la Tèrre derriere de la vôile, the world behind the curtain. Now since my divorce I've started to create my own comfort zone at home and I've mostly stopped trying to make others happy, time for me to focus on myself.
Rowan Tree, StRoNgO, tovlo and 1 other person like this.
It's nice to know what other type perspective about us. Everyone has their own fantasy, yet this is more INF tendencies.
His breakdown for the INFJ cognitive functions is interesting. I only have some liiiitle biiit ticks with how sometimes he kinda put INFJ in a box of defense mode.
ClevelandINTP and Rowan Tree like this.
No it's just you. You're very lost in reality.
Rowan Tree, Ren, Ginny and 2 others like this.
But Wyote. None of this is real. It's all in your mind.
Rowan Tree, Ren, Wyote and 1 other person like this.
I'm definitely in my fantasy world, but I don't feel lost.
Rowan Tree and Wyote like this.
Asa, Ren and Wyote like this.
His video is funny. "Fantasyland" can happen to anyone, but as an INFJ, it certainly doesn't take me away from reality as much as he portrays. Yes, I'm a goofball, but I stay in reality. I can only daydream if I give myself permission to, and that's not often.
So... that is what a "P" is, huh? LOL.
Wyote, Asa and Rowan Tree like this.
Wyote and Rowan Tree like this.