The most constant and pertinent finding in both idiopathic and postencephalitic Parkinson disease is a loss of pigmented cells in the substantia nigra and other pigmented nuclei (locus ceruleus, dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus). The substantia nigra is visibly pale to the naked eye; microscopically, the pigmented nuclei show a marked depletion of cells and replacement gliosis, and some of the remaining cells have reduced quantities of melanin, findings that enable one to state with confidence that the patient must have suffered from Parkinson disease. Also, many of the remaining cells of the pigmented nuclei contain eosinophilic cytoplasmic inclusions, surrounded by a faint halo, called Lewy bodies (Fig. 38-5). These are seen in practically all cases of idiopathic Parkinson disease. They were generally absent in postencephalitic cases, but there were neurofibrillary tangles within nigral cell in that disorder. Both these cellular abnormalities appear occasionally in the substantia nigra of aged, non parkinsonian individuals. Possibly the individuals with Lewy bodies would have developed Parkinson disease had they lived a few more years. Many of the inherited forms of Parkinson disease also lack Lewy bodies.
Noteworthy is the finding by McGeer and colleagues that nigral cells normally diminish with age, from a maximal complement of about 425,000 to 200,000 at age 80 years. Tyrosine-hydroxylase, the rate-limiting enzyme for the synthesis of dopamine, diminishes correspondingly. However, these authors and others have found that in patients with Parkinson disease the number of pigmented neurons is reduced to 30 percent or less of that in age-matched controls. Using more refined counting techniques, Pakkenberg and coworkers estimated the average total number of pigmented neurons to be 550,000 and to be reduced in absolute numbers by 66 percent in Parkinson patients. (The number of nonpigmented neurons was reduced in Parkinson cases by only 24 percent.) Thus aging contributes importantly to nigral cell loss, but the cell depletion is so much more marked in Parkinson disease that some factor other than aging must also be operative.
Other regions of neuronal loss are widespread as mentioned, but their significance is less clear. There is neuronal loss in the mesencephalic reticular formation, near the substantia nigra. These cells project to the thalamus and limbic lobes. In the sympathetic ganglia, there is slight neuronal loss and Lewy bodies are seen. This is also true of the pigmented nuclei of the lower brainstem as well as of neuronal populations in the putamen, caudatum, pallidum, and substantia innominata. On the other hand, dopaminergic neurons that project to cortical and limbic structures, to caudate nucleus and nucleus accumbens, and to periaqueductal gray matter and spinal cord are affected little or not at all. The lack of a consistent lesion in either the striatum or the pallidum is noteworthy. An alternative hypothesis offered by Braak and Tredici, mentioned in an earlier section of this chapter and attributed to Braak and Braak, is that the substantia nigra compacta is affected only late in the pathobiology of Parkinson disease. Their study found that the earliest changes in the brain occur in the dorsal glossopharyngeal-vagal and anterior olfactory nuclei, and only later did they appear in the midbrain nuclei. This theory accommodates a variety of clinical features and potential environmental triggers to the disease but has been challenged by Burke and colleagues (2008) and by others. An epidemiologic study of individuals who underwent vagotomy and reduced rates of Parkinson disease compared to the general population has been brought to bear on the argument, suggesting that the procedure blocks entry of synuclein into the brainstem (Svensson et al). Lang has suggested that this distribution of cell loss explains some of the nondopaminergic features of the disease and offers other avenues for therapy.