The Mongol in Our Midst

The Mongol in Our Midst: A Study of Man and His Three Faces is a pseudo-scientific book by the British physician F. G. Crookshank which was popular in the 1920s and 1930s.  Consonant with the scientific racism prevalent in its time, this work advanced the now-discredited idea that so-called "Mongolian imbecility" (a form of intellectual disability now known as Down syndrome), was an atavistic throwback to, and/or the result of rape in the wake of invasions of Europe by, members of supposedly more primitive Mongoloid race, such as the Huns, Avars or the Mongols themselves, and by way of Ashkenazic Jews claimed to have interbred with the steppe tribe of the Khazars. Finding success with a popular audience, The Mongol in Our Midst was expanded from its 123-page first edition in 1924 to over 500 pages by its third edition in 1931. The third edition included responses to critics and expanded anthropological and clinical material, speculations and arguments.

In The Mongol in Our Midst, Crookshank argued that "Mongolian imbecility," thought at the time to affect whites only, was the result of the distant racial history of the patient's Caucasian parents, each of whom must also carry Mongol traits.  That Caucasians bore this racial history was either the result of those individuals sharing a common Mongoloid ancestor, or of all Caucasians having distant Mongoloid ancestry.  "Mongolian imbeciles," then, were atavistic throwbacks to that Mongoloid heritage, the modern emergence of which Crookshank believed was due to their incomplete development in the womb.  As a consequence, Crookshank deemed "Mongolian imbeciles . . . a race apart.  For better or for worse, they are not quite as are other men and women around them."  Crookshank considered his English patients "Mongol expatriates."

In support of his thesis, Crookshank relied on physical traits and behaviors he dubbed the "Mongolian stigmata," among which he included small earlobes, protruding anuses, and small genitals in both sexes, traits he deemed common to both "Mongolian imbeciles" and members of what he termed the Mongoloid race, which included Chinese and Japanese, as well as Mongols. The Mongol in Our Midst cited the cross-legged sitting posture of some "Mongolian imbeciles" as further evidence of his thesis, since the Buddha is often depicted in statues sitting cross-legged.

Langdon Down, who first described Down Syndrome, coined the term "imbecile of the Mongoloid type," but Crookshank turned one of Down's central theses on its head. Whereas Down stressed the obvious fact that the parents of his patients were Caucasian and that their offspring were therefore not "real Mongols," Crookshank argued at length that Down's patients were precisely that.  Where Down presented his observation that white parents could have offspring who bore a superficial resemblance to other races as evidence of "the unity of the human species," Crookshank argued the reverse, allying himself with the views of his German translator Eugen Kurtz to claim that the different human races were in fact different species descended from different species of apes.

The Mongol in Our Midst successfully reached a broad popular audience, and received some critical approbation at the time.  One contemporary review in the journal Nature, for example, praised Crookshank as "argu[ing] with much skill in favour of his view" on atavism, but was more dubious of his promotion of polygenism, noting that it had "not found favour among anthropologists generally" and that "this part of his theory has been most strongly criticised".  Contemporary critical acclaim was hardly universal, however, as one reviewer  "wondered whether 'this theory was ever seriously entertained by anyone other than the author himself'"  and other contemporaries of Crookshank viewed its arguments  as "preposterous" and "flimsy in the extreme."  A review of the first edition in The Nation wondered briefly whether the whole book might be a mere hoax, since "The author's thesis need only be stated to be refuted with a laugh." Crookshank himself, however, was "deadly serious," publishing his fully rewritten and much-expanded subsequent editions in response to critics, and creating a work that created something of a "pleasant furor among laymen."

Modern scholars regard this work as "a grand edifice of absurd allegations about the orangutan, the racial 'Mongolian,' the "Mongoloid,' all of whom were said to share a variety of homologies."

Crookshanks' theories were refuted entirely by the trisomy 21 discoveries of 1959 that defined the genetic defect causing Down syndrome, although the term "Mongolism", despite Crookshanks' contributions to its stigmatization, took several decades to fade away entirely.

See also
Mongolian idiocy
Recapitulation theory

Notes

References

External links
The full text of The Mongol in Our Midst (1923 edition) at the Internet Archive

Category:Scientific racism
Category:1924 non-fiction books
Category:Pseudoscience literature