A framework of critical thinking skills for teaching and learning physiotherapy.

View/Open

Date

Author

Metadata

Abstract

The use of critical thinking is called for in the practise of physiotherapy and has been
cited as a learning outcome in the design of the physiotherapy curriculum. Further, the
South African Draft White Paper on Higher Education (July,1997) is committed to
endow graduates with skills that build the foundation for lifelong learning and
included in such skills is that of critical thinking. Although welcomed by the
profession, the introduction of critical thinking within the programmes may be
premature because of the lack of debate and subsequent understanding about the
critical thinking skills necessary for the practise of physiotherapy. Hence critical
thinking remains implicit within the context of physiotherapy. Physiotherapy
educators are assessing the skill implicitly within the process of clinical reasoning and
decision making, without articulating what critical thinking really is, in the context of
physiotherapy clinical reasoning. Further one needs to identify the repertoire of
component skills that one should possess, in order to be an accomplished critical
thinker.
Data obtained from interviews with level co-ordinators, and an examination of the
course plans within one department at one institution, provided an insight into how
critical thinking is understood within the profession. Further, it identified if, and how,
critical thinking was currently incorporated into the physiotherapy curriculum. In an
attempt to develop a deeper understanding and a guiding framework for critical
thinking in Physiotherapy, a workshop was conducted amongst qualified
physiotherapists. They were required to model the clinical reasoning and decision
making processes that they employ in the clinical area, in the process of working
through the clinical problem that was presented. The data that emerged was
qualitatively analysed and categorised. This was for the purpose of generating
meaning, and for the development of a framework of critical thinking skills, that may
be used in conjunction with the process of clinical reasoning to enhance one's clinical
judgement.
Critical factors emerged from analysis of the data. These included the preponderance
of the product over the process method for teaching and assessing, the implicit nature
of teaching and assessing for critical thinking in physiotherapy, and the similarities
and differences in perception and conception about the meaning of critical thinking
and its associated skills. The findings of this study contribute to the understanding and
development of critical thinking within the specific context of physiotherapy and
inform the development of the physiotherapy curriculum towards the realisation of its
intended goals.