Native American Clashes with European Settlers

Emergence of
Tribes
By 1600, organized tribes such as the Delaware and Shawnee had
moved into present-day West Virginia. In addition, the powerful
Iroquois Confederacy began exerting its influence on the region.
The Confederacy was an alliance of five Iroquois-speaking nations
-- Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, and Seneca -- formed in
present-day New York in the late 1500s. In 1722, the Tuscaroras
joined the Iroquois Confederacy, which became known as the Six
Nations. When Europeans first explored western Virginia in the late
1600s, they discovered few Native Americans. Historian Otis Rice
suggests this absence was due to the Five Nations, "which sought
domination of the Ohio Valley as part of their effort to control
the fur trade with the Dutch, and later the British. . . ." (WV: A
History, 9). The Confederacy controlled the valley but other tribes
were permitted to settle there. For example, a Shawnee village
existed at present-day Point Pleasant and a Delaware village
flourished at Bulltown in present-day Braxton County well into the
1700s.

European Exploration &
Settlement
As the Confederacy fought smaller tribes for control of western
Virginia, European colonists set their own designs on the Ohio
Valley. In 1607, English colonists landed at Jamestown, Virginia.
Based on various explorations, the British and French laid claim to
the territory comprising present-day West Virginia and Native
Americans were forced west. Many of the tribes were destroyed by
constant warfare and catastrophic diseases. At the same time, trade
with the Europeans proved a strong attraction, enabling the Indians
to acquire valuable new products, such as guns, steel hatchets,
cloth, and kettles. The fur trade in particular made many tribes
powerful and more aggressive. The Indian nations successfully
played one European power against another. For instance, the
British formed an alliance with the Iroquois Confederacy to cut the
French out of the lucrative fur trade. However, the Six Nations
also negotiated treaties and traded with the French.

Treaties
As part of their negotiations, the British secured three treaties
which opened the western Virginia frontier to European settlement:
Treaty of Albany (1722) and Treaty of Lancaster (1744) with the Six
Nations and Treaty of Logstown (1752) with the Delaware and
Shawnee. At Lancaster, Virginia negotiators convinced the Six
Nations to surrender their land to the "setting sun," which the
Confederacy interpreted as the crest of the Alleghenies and the
British interpreted as all of western Virginia. Following the
Treaty of Lancaster and the end of King George's War (1748) between
England and France, Virginia pioneers pushed west of the
Alleghenies.

Native American Concept of
Land
A major factor in the treaty disputes was Native Americans' concept
of land. Indians fought among themselves over hunting rights to the
territory but the Native American idea of "right" to the land was
very different from the legalistic and individual nature of
European ownership. John Alexander Williams describes this in his
book, West Virginia: A History for Beginners:

The Indians had no concept of "private property," as applied to
the land. Only among the Delawares was it customary for families,
during certain times of the year, to be assigned specific hunting
territories. Apparently this was an unusual practice, not found
among other Indians. Certainly, the idea of an individual having
exclusive use of a particular piece of land was completely strange
to Native Americans.

The Indians practiced communal land ownership. That is, the
entire community owned the land upon which it lived. . . .1

French & Indian War
In 1754, hostilities broke out between English and French troops in
western Pennsylvania. English troops under a young commander,
George Washington, were overwhelmed by the French at Fort
Necessity, beginning a lengthy war for control of the American
colonies. While the English had made it clear they intended to
settle the frontier, the French were more interested in trade. This
influenced the Delaware and Shawnee to side with the French.
Although the Six Nations officially remained neutral, many in the
Iroquois Confederacy also allied with the French.

Early defeats in the French and Indian War led Virginia Governor
Robert Dinwiddie to construct forts in the South Branch Valley.
From 1756 to 1758, Native Americans wreaked havoc on the new forts,
attacking Fort Evans in present-day Berkeley County and forts
Seybert and Upper Tract in present-day Pendleton County, as well as
sites throughout the Monongahela, New River, and Greenbrier
valleys. In November 1758, the British captured Fort Duquesne at
present-day Pittsburgh, the key to French control of the Ohio
Valley. The following year, French troops lost Quebec, crippling
their military strength. The loss of French military support
temporarily calmed tensions between Native Americans and settlers
in western Virginia. The Treaty of Paris in 1763 ended the French
and Indian War and gave England title to virtually all territory
east of the Mississippi River.

Proclamation of 1763 &
Pontiac's War
With the French eliminated, Native Americans were left alone in
their fight against British colonial aggression. In the summer of
1763, Pontiac, an Ottawa chief led raids on key British forts.
Shawnee chief Keigh-tugh-qua, or Cornstalk, led similar attacks on
western Virginia settlements in present-day Greenbrier County. By
the end of July, Indians had captured all British forts west of the
Alleghenies except Detroit, Fort Pitt, and Fort Niagara. On August
6, British forces under Colonel Henry Bouquet retaliated,
destroying Delaware and Shawnee forces at Bushy Run in western
Pennsylvania, which ended the hostilities.

Fearing more tension between Native Americans and settlers,
England's King George III issued the Proclamation of 1763,
prohibiting settlement west of the Allegheny Mountains. However,
many land speculators such as George Washington violated the
proclamation by claiming vast acreage in western Virginia. The next
five years were relatively peaceful on the frontier. In 1768, the
Six Nations and Cherokee signed the Treaty of Hard Labour and the
Treaty of Fort Stanwix, relinquishing their claims on the territory
between the Ohio River and the Alleghenies to the British. With the
frontier again open, settlers flooded into western Virginia and the
speculators made small fortunes in rent on the lands they had
acquired.

Battle of Point Pleasant
The Shawnee had never given up their claims to western Virginia and
interpreted the rapid settlement as acts of aggression. Hostilities
reached a climax in 1773 when land speculator Michael Cresap led a
group of volunteers from Fort Fincastle (later renamed Fort Henry)
at present-day Wheeling and raided Shawnee towns in what became
known as Cresap's War. One of the worst atrocities of the conflict
was the murder of several family members of Mingo chief
Tah-gah-jute, who had been baptized under the English name Logan.
Logan, who had previously lived peacefully with the settlers,
killed at least 13 western Virginians that summer in revenge.

Virginia Governor John Murray, Earl of Dunmore, plotted to crush
the Shawnee and end hostilities. Dunmore drew up a plan to trap the
Shawnee between two armies. The governor personally led the
northern army while land speculator Andrew Lewis led a smaller
force from the south. But Shawnee leader Cornstalk struck the
southern regiment before it united with Dunmore's troops. On
October 10, 1774, Cornstalk's force of approximately 1,200 men
attacked Lewis at the confluence of the Kanawha and Ohio rivers at
present-day Point Pleasant. After the battle, which resulted in
significant losses on both sides, the Shawnee retreated to protect
their settlements in the Scioto Valley in present-day Ohio. As a
condition of the subsequent Treaty of Camp Charlotte, the Delaware,
Shawnee, and Mingo relinquished all claims to land south of the
Ohio River. The Battle of Point Pleasant eliminated Native
Americans as a force on the frontier for the first three years of
the American Revolutionary War, which began in April 1775, clearing
the way for peaceful settlement of the region.

Revolutionary War & the
Aftermath
At the same time as Dunmore's War, tensions mounted between
American colonists and the British. When the Revolutionary War
began, many American soldiers who had previously served in the
British army fought for the Continental Army. Native Americans
remained generally neutral for the first two years of the war. In
August 1775, the Shawnee, Delaware, Mingo, Seneca, Wyandot,
Potawatomi, and Ottawa had agreed to the Treaty of Pittsburgh,
recognizing the Ohio River as the Indian boundary and pledging
neutrality. By the end of 1776, the treaty had fallen apart and
Native Americans began randomly attacking settlements. In June
1777, British negotiator Henry Hamilton met with tribal leaders at
Detroit and gained the support of the Chippewa and Ottawa as well
as some Mingo and Wyandot. This agreement nullified the Treaty of
Pittsburgh and effectively brought most Native Americans into the
war on the side of the British.

On the night of August 31, Wyandot and Mingo forces attacked
Fort Henry at present-day
Wheeling. During the three-day siege, the Indians destroyed most of
the homes around the fort and killed a number of soldiers in the
fort. With the support of the British, Native Americans had
enormous initial success against colonists in the Ohio Valley.

One of the worst atrocities of the war on the frontier occurred
at Fort Randolph at present-day Point Pleasant. In November 1777,
Cornstalk and two companions visited the fort to inform Captain
Matthew Arbuckle that the Shawnee had decided to support the
British. Arbuckle was suspicious and held Cornstalk prisoner. After
two hunters were killed near the fort, colonial militiamen
assassinated Cornstalk and his son Elinipsico.

In the spring of 1778, the British, Wyandot, and Mingo launched
an offensive on frontier forts. On May 16, Indians first attacked
Fort Randolph then proceeded east to the Greenbrier Valley
settlements. They attacked Fort Donnally, west of Lewisburg, for
hours before reinforcements drove the Indians back.

In 1778, George Rogers Clark temporarily broke the
British-Indian alliance with victories in the Illinois territory at
Kaskaskia, Cahokia, and Vincennes. Colonials rejected an attempt by
Wyandots and some Shawnee to negotiate a peace in 1779. Although
the main British army surrendered at Yorktown, Virginia, on October
19, 1781, occasional clashes occurred on the frontier. The
bloodiest Revolutionary War battle in western Virginia began on
September 10, 1782. Wyandot, Delaware, and British forces attacked
Fort Henry. The most dramatic story associated with this siege of
Fort Henry is the daring run of Elizabeth Zane, who allegedly
carried gunpowder to the fort amidst heavy gunfire. The settlers
held the fort and, after three days, the Indians and their British
allies gave up. Soon thereafter, the British ordered a halt to all
attacks on the frontier.

After the Revolutionary War officially ended in 1783, settlers
again poured into western Virginia. Most Native Americans moved
their villages westward into Indiana, although they occasionally
raided forts in western Virginia. Frontier settlers, such as
Lewis Wetzel, Samuel Brady,
and Simon Girty, formed independent military units to combat these
attacks, often perpetrating brutal assaults on Native Americans.
Hostile actions between Indians and settlers continued in western
Virginia until 1794, when General Anthony Wayne defeated Native
Americans at Fallen Timbers in present-day northwestern Ohio. The
subsequent Treaty of Greenville effectively removed all remaining
Indian claims to western Virginia.

Notes

1. John Alexander Williams, West Virginia: A History for
Beginners (Charleston, WV: Appalachian Editions, 1993), 64.