Single-molecule imaging of full protein synthesis by immobilized ribosomes

How folding of proteins is coupled to their synthesis remains poorly understood. Here, we apply single-molecule fluorescence imaging to full protein synthesis in vitro. Ribosomes were specifically immobilized onto glass surfaces and synthesis of green fluorescent protein (GFP) was achieved using modified commercial Protein Synthesis using Recombinant Elements that lacked ribosomes but contained purified factors and enzyme that are required for translation in Escherichia coli. Translation was monitored using a GFP mutant (F64L/S65T/F99S/M153T/V163A) that has a high fluorophore maturation rate and that contained the Secretion Monitor arrest sequence to prevent dissociation from the ribosome. Immobilized ribosomal subunits were labeled with Cy3 and GFP synthesis was measured by colocalization of GFP fluorescence with the ribosome position. The rate of appearance of colocalized ribosome GFP was equivalent to the rates of fluorescence appearance coupled with translation measured in bulk, and the ribosome–polypeptide complexes were stable for hours. The methods presented here are applicable to single-molecule investigation of translational initiation, elongation and cotranslational folding.


INTRODUCTION
Protein synthesis rates during translation by the ribosome control many key cellular processes. Protein folding in living cells is inherently coupled to protein synthesis and chain elongation. There is considerable evidence that some nascent chains fold into their native structures in a cotranslational manner before release from the ribosome (1). Furthermore, chaperones, such as GroEL, are estimated to assist folding of only $5% of newly synthesized protein in growing Escherichia coli (2). Translational elongation events such as pausing and frameshifting are linked to protein folding, export and expression.
Elongation rates have been measured using in vivo and in vitro translation assays in prokaryotic system. In vivo, protein synthesis occurs at a rate of $10-20 amino acids per second (3), and dilution in extracts leads to slower rates in vitro (4). Nascent chains are extruded from the ribosome through a long, narrow exit tunnel in the large subunit. This tunnel can accommodate $22-26 amino acids, and constricts folding of higher order structure for the nascent chain (5,6). A growing body of data suggests strong interplay of the nascent chain composition, the exit tunnel and elongation rates (5,6).
The dynamics of full protein synthesis and cotranslational folding of nascent polypeptide remain unclear. Current bulk methods do not measure protein synthesis in real time; instead discrete time points are obtained to measure protein concentration biochemically, or enzymatic reporter systems are used, such as luciferase. Ensemble averaging in these bulk experiments blurs the detailed dynamic behavior of individual molecules. Single-molecule analysis of translation removes ensemble analysis and allows detailed examination of dynamics. However, singlemolecule studies on protein synthesis to date have focused on individual kinetic steps, or overall protein synthesis in cells (7); new methods are needed to couple ribosomal dynamics with protein synthesis and folding rates.
Here, we present a simple single-molecule system to monitor real-time translation and folding of proteins.
Ribosomes are specifically immobilized on glass surfaces, and protein synthesis and folding is monitored in real time through synthesis and rapid maturation of a single green fluorescent protein (GFP) on the immobilized ribosome. However, GFP requires slow posttranslational modification of the folded protein to become fluorescent. Here, we use a fast-maturing mutant of GFP that provides improved time resolution for fluorescence. Nascent chains are stalled on immobilized ribosomes using the Secretion Monitor (SecM) arrest sequence, which lodges in the peptide exit tunnel and halts elongation. Thus, we can observe appearance of GFP fluorescence as a surrogate marker for coupled translation protein folding and chromophore maturation.

Sample preparation and experiments
Isolated ribosomes with a 23 nt extension in helix 44 of the 16S rRNA (8) were hybridized with biotin and Cy3modified oligonucleotide at 308C for 30 min and purified by gel filtration (MicroSpin S300 HR, GE Healthcare UK Ltd, Buckinghamshire, UK). The glass surface was coated with 3 mg/ml biotinylated BSA for 2 min and derivatized with 0.33 mg/ml streptavidin for 2 min. After binding of ribosome-oligonucleotide complexes to the derivatized surface, template DNA and the Protein Synthesis using Recombinant Elements (PURE) system i ribosome (see text) were added. At each step the surface was rinsed with the sample buffer (50 mM Tris-acetate (pH 7.5), 100 mM potassium chloride, 5 mM ammonium acetate, 0.5 mM calcium acetate, 5 mM magnesium acetate, 0.5 mM EDTA and 6 mM b-mercaptoethanol) to remove any unbound material. The fluorescence images were recorded by a sensitive CCD camera (C9100-12, Hamamatsu Photonics, Hamamatsu, Japan) combined with Olympus IX70 microscope. GFP fluorescence image was taken with 200-ms time exposure right after the stage was moved quickly to avoid photobleaching molecules due to the absence of O 2scavenging system. GFP and Cy3 fluorescence was detected upon 488 and 532 nm excitation. After GFP images were recorded with 200-ms time exposure for 20 s, Cy3 images were detected at same image position by changing the dichroic filter and laser source quickly for image colocalization. The colocalization position for both GFP and Cy3 images was calibrated by non-specifically immobilized fluorescent beads. The cover glass was treated by plasma cleaning to get rid of fluorescent impurities and non-specific attachment of ribosome and other components beforehand every time. Nearly 170 Â 170 pixels of GFP and Cy3 images were picked up from center of 512 Â 512 pixels of whole image area and subtracted images filtered by Gaussian blurring with five pixels radius from original images to obtain high signal-to-noise using Adobe Photoshop.

Use of a purified E. coli translation system
We have used a reconstituted, cell-free protein synthesis system to observe single-molecule translation. This PURE (Post Genome Institute, Tokyo, Japan) system is commercially available and is composed of individually prepared components required for gene expression in E. coli (9,10). As such, it is possible to exclude, add, or optimize the concentration of components to verify their effects on the translation system and production of higher order complexes ( Figure 1A). The modified PURE system 'i ribosome' is lacking ribosomes, which allows our use of purified mutant ribosomes ( Figure 1A).
To test the efficiency of the PURE system, we monitored appearance of GFP mutant Ser 65!Thr fluorescence as a function of time during a translation reaction. GFP S65T optimized the excitation wavelength at 488 nm and increases the quantum yield of fluorescence intensity and maturation rate approximately four-fold over that of wildtype GFP in vivo (11). Translation of mutant GFP was detected by the fluorescence of GFP S65T ; the reaction was initiated by using the PURE system i ribosome extract and adding ribosomes and template DNA. The synthesis and subsequent maturation of GFP S65T by wild-type E. coli ribosomes gradually increases in an hour ( Figure 1B), which agrees well with prior observations (12). We also prepared C68 mutant ribosome for single-molecule imaging, which is designed to hybridize to an extension genetically engineered into the 16S rRNA (8,13) for immobilization on the surface. To test the effect of the C68 extension loop on synthesis activity, the translation of GFP S65T by C68 mutant ribosome was compared with that of wild-type ribosomes. Figure 1B indicates that the C68 mutant ribosome has 75% GFP S65T synthesis activity in comparison with the wild-type ribosome in the bulk solution; no translation was observed in the absence of the ribosome or in the presence of the ribosome including 10 mM kasugamycin, which inhibits translational initiation. These data agree with our prior genetic and biochemical data on the C68 mutant ribosome that demonstrated its functionality (8).
Slow oxidative maturation of the GFP chromophore hinders usage for real-time experiments. Newly translated GFP must first fold into a catalytically active conformation that facilitates the formation of the chromophore. Second, mature GFP must then be correctly folded to maintain its fluorescent properties, presumably to protect the chromophore from solvent effects. Wild-type GFP maturation rates are 120 min, whereas they are 27 min for GFP S65T (11). To accelerate the chromophore maturation rate of GFP S65T , we designed a construct of GFP uv3 (14), which has F64L/S65T into the cycle 3 (F99S/M153T/V163A) mutation (15). This GFP uv3 has maximum excitation and emission at 488 and 515 nm, respectively (14,15). As observed below, the maturation rate for this mutant is $15 min (Supplementary Figure 2).

Stalling of ribosomes during translation using the SecM sequence
To allow GFP to fold on the ribosome, the protein must be extended by 23-26 amino acids at the C-terminus to fill the ribosome exit tunnel (5,6). The C-terminal segment of unextended GFP enzyme is held within the ribosome, preventing folding of the polypeptide into the native conformation. Therefore, we introduced a 'spacer sequence' downstream of the GFP gene, as described in Supplementary Figure 1. To trap folded GFP on ribosomes, we incorporated an 'arrest sequence' that stops translational elongation, derived from the E. coli SecM gene. The arrest sequence, FXXXXWIXXXXGIR AGP interacts with the ribosomal exit tunnel, stalling translational elongation (5,16) (Supplementary Figure 1). Translational assays using the PURE system showed a far lower yield of fluorescent protein when the arrest sequence is included, suggesting that mature GFP uv3 did not dissociate from the ribosome, thus preventing polysomal turnover on each mRNA (Figure 2A and B).

Specific surface immobilization of ribosomes maintains activity
To monitor translation at a single-molecule level, we specifically immobilized ribosomes onto glass surfaces. C68 mutant ribosomes were hybridized with a biotinylated oligonucleotide that was complementary to an extension genetically engineered into the 16S rRNA (8,13) ( Figure 3A). Ribosomes were then immobilized through a surface-bound streptavidin linkage with the biotinylated BSA; ribosomes without a biotinylated oligonucleotide do not bind to the surface, indicating that the BSA surface is specific. Translation was monitored by the appearance of GFP uv3 fluorescence, after initiation of the reaction by addition of DNA template and Á ribosome PURE solution. When a high concentration of unlabeled mutant ribosomes ($5 nM) was introduced on a glass surface, the number of fluorescent molecules gradually increased within $20 min ( Figure 3B). These results reveal that the SecM arrest sequence mediates stable association of the folded GFP on the immobilized ribosomes. Deletion of the arrest sequence eliminates the large number of fluorescent molecules observed during translation ( Figure 3C). This strongly suggests that the arrest sequence stabilizes GFP on the ribosome, and that in its absence, folded GFP is released into solution and does not adhere to the surface. To measure the stability of arrested GFP on the ribosome, the translation mix was washed away after GFP synthesis. Dissociation of GFP from the ribosome leads to loss of fluorescent molecules; this experiment revealed that stalled GFP is bound to ribosome for hours (Supplementary Figure 3), consistent with prior biochemical studies on the SecM system (17,18).

Single-molecule analysis of GFP synthesis
To test the specificity of GFP uv3 ribosome colocalization, translation was performed at greatly lower concentration of surface-immobilized ribosomes to $50 pM. In this experiment, ribosomes were immobilized using a biotinylated, Cy3-labeled oligonucleotide, and the position of ribosomes was established by Cy3 fluorescence. Colocalization of Cy3 and GFP uv3 fluorescence ( Figure 4A) allowed correlation of protein synthesis and ribosome position. The proportion of colocalized molecules over total number of Cy3 fluorescence was increased gradually with time. This result represents the formation of stable ribosome-polypeptide complexes. Only a single molecule of GFP uv3 was observed colocalized with the ribosome as shown by the single-Gaussian fluorescent intensity histogram for colocalized molecules ( Figure 4C and D). Our results provide direct evidence for the formation of single stable ribosome-polypeptide complexes.
The time course of GFP synthesis as measured by colocalization agrees with that determined in bulk solution ( Figure 5). The arrest sequence significantly increased the stability of ribosome-polypeptide complexes irrespective of the ribosome concentrations. The GFP uv3 synthesis including maturation time was achieved at plateau within 20 min, which is consistent with the time observed in bulk assay ( Figure 2B). Despite the mutations in GFP, this rate is still dominated by fluorophore maturation.
We measured this directly by performing surface-based translation in the presence of an O 2 -scavenging system, which allows protein folding on the ribosome but prevents maturation (Supplementary Figure 2). Upon washing with folding. Prior studies have demonstrated that immobilized translation systems are functional for individual steps of protein synthesis, but our results show that full activity including folding activity is maintained. This method will complement existing single-molecule approaches that probe the dynamics of individual steps in protein synthesis, and allow comparison of these fundamental rate constants with the overall process of translation. The current time resolution of the method presented here is limited by the maturation time of the fluorescent protein chromophore. Faster maturing fluorescent proteins can be used in future applications. Alternatively, fluorescence in the folded protein can be monitored directly by incorporation of fluorescent amino acid analogs during translation. Extension of this method should reveal the dynamic interplay of translation and protein folding.