I am a Diamond Hilton addict and subsequently hooked to the HHONORS pgm which was the main reason to book that hotel for a WE (room 360). At more than 300 USD the room (3 nights), I can only say I was disappointed. Cheap room, no view. Luckily the weather was gorgeous and the Fisher man Wharf remains the Fisherman Wharf. The worst if I can say is I had another very good experience at the Hyatt one block away last year .... Modern rooms, nice restaurant etc.
In short if you hesitate, pick the Hyatt and drop the Hilton.
hotel reviews