We didn't have much choice, having to pin down a 12-night stay at reasonable price and at very short notice, but we do not regret staying at the St James.
Our room was small and basic, but everything worked and it was well serviced every day.
Location cannot be beaten, and the Cranberry Gourmet next door offers reasonable food and drink and (importantly) a quiet place to sit and talk, so there was no need to stay in the room other than to sleep. There are of course a zillion good bars and restaurants within an easy stroll.
If you want luxury go somewhere else, and pay for it. But if you want the basics in the heart of Midtown at an affordable price the St James is certainly an option
hotel reviews