I have stayed at the Sofitel a number of times now and it is by far my favourite mid town hotel (stayed at half a dozen of the typical NY business hotels) and at a reasonable price! Location is perfect, rooms are of good size, clean and pretty quiet. On my last stay I had asked for a view of the Chrysler building and they did get me a room with a view which was great. Breakfast is very tasty but expensive (however not any more expensive than any other business hotel in NY). Staff were professional although some of the reception staff could improve on the friendliness.
Finally, if you are put off by the crowds in some of the larger NY hotels, this place feels like an oasis of peace and quiet!
hotel reviews