I stayed here Nov 14th, based on the glowing recommendations here, and can't see the justification. Service (multiple staff members) was abrupt and unhelpful, but maybe I just got them on a bad day. Room was okay, but pretty dated, and both beds smelled not fresh. I'm not a picky person, but I would say the bed was equivalent to a motel bed. I was on the 8th floor, so maybe some floors are more recently renovated.
Kitchenette was a nice plus. Location is great. For the price I paid ($158), this was decent value for NYC, but certainly not worth 4/5. Other hotels in NYC that rank the same are far, far better, and usually not much more on Hotwire (which was how I got this room).
Wifi is $10/night, and locked to one device.
hotel reviews