We recently spent three nights at the Carlton Hotel, recently added to the Marriott Autograph Collection. My general thought is that this is not a very convenient hotel for those wanting to visit the theater, but great for those interested in the garment district; nice for those who want to see a different side of New York City, the residential side; nice for those who are willing to settle for a very compact room--but not so nice for those who want convenience and a little space. And did I mention the noise. We thought there was a big party going on most of the night outside--but it turned out to be the night club. We were on the 10th floor and had been told that our upgraded superior room would be quiet. I'm glad, given the size of the room and the noise level, that we did not have a standard room in a less quite area.
I note that another reviewer says that this is a short walk from Times Square. I would estimate it to be a little less than a mile, not convenient for making several round trips a day if your principal goal is to see the theater. Madison Square Park was beautiful with flowering trees and would be perfect for a child to run off a little energy while parents rested after hiking to and from Times Square--assuming that it was spring and not a cold winter day.
Warning to platinum and gold guests. The continental breakfast that is served in lieu of a concierge lounge is (1) only 4 days a week and (2) is the worst collection of breakfast items I have ever seen in a Marriott--not a single protein in sight, just pastries, bread and fruit. I would suggest a number of other Marriott properties with better concierge lounge service including the Renaissance at Times Square and the Renaissance 57.
Free coffee is served, however, 24 hours a day in the Business Center. And mu husband loved the $1 oyster special they have on Friday nights. I hate oysters but enjoyed seeing him scarf up 2 dozen with such a happy smile.
Overall, I would say that there are better selections in New York at the price if you have my interests. But, I don't want to undersell the hotel. The staff was terrific and it has a lovely lobby.
hotel reviews