Stayed at the HGI in July 2006 for a solo trip to NYC.
I initially booked the hotel due to all the positive reviews on this site, and got a good rate through the hotel website directly. I have to agree with the other reviews on this site; the hotel is very central in a great location in Midtown right in the midst of everything a tourist would want to see.
As a single, first time NYC traveller, I was extremely impressed with the area and the hotel has connections to both busses and the subway pretty much outside their door-subway station is right down the street. At no time did I feel that the area was unsafe.
I actually arrived earlier than check in time (11:30) and was able to check into my room at that time. I found the hotel staff very accomodating and my room was as reserved.
The room itself was very large (by NY standards and by mine), with a king bed, microwave, small fridge, coffee maker, and lots of room to move around. The room was cleaned each day to a high standard and and requests I had throughout the stay were quickly accomodated by either the desk or cleaning staff.
I also have to say that the bed was the most comfortable bed I have ever slept on!
My room also faced 8th Avenue (5th floor) and I have to honestly say, I didn't hear much noise from traffic or the streets below.
I also can't comment on the hotel restaurant as I didn't eat there throughout the stay-there were too many others to choose from.
Overall, my stay was perfect and no complaints whatsoever!
hotel reviews