I recently stayed at Hotel 17 for 5 nights for was generally quite impressed. The service at the lobby was fine, despite reading some bad reviews. Our room (807) was larger than average, so plenty of room to store luggage and many new purchases! The decor was a kitsch mix and quite charming with clashing striped wallpaper and weathered wooden furnishings.
I had major reservations about the idea of shared bathrooms, but apart from the morning rush it was never occupied. I would avoid room 806 though - its door is directly opposite the bathroom and I should imagine it's quite noisy, especially as the walls seem to be paper thin.
In terms of the location - this hotel is fab and has plenty of great places to eat/drink within walking distance. Try the cocktails at 'Olives' on Park Avenue for chic start to any evening.
I would happily recommended Hotel 17 if nothing else but for it's location and price (it was very cheap) but 4 words of advice for anyone thinking of staying here - BEWARE THE BED BUGS!!!!
hotel reviews