Home buttons barely work now, but the bumper buttons work again.
I've needed to replace the bumpers in like 5 xbox controllers over the last couple years (intentionally flawed xbox controller design?) and it always seems to mess up the home button, making them hard to press and not spring back like they should. These were not any different. However...These had less extra plastic hanging off of them than the others I've bought, and they didn't show up broken or break during installation. So the home buttons are stiff but the bumpers work again.
amazon reviews