premise: Fisher persons are lined up on a dock with their lines in the water.
hypothesis: they are talking loud
explanation_1: Being lined up and talking loud are not contradictory actions unless the talk scares away the fish. Even then, it would be inadvisable instead of contradictory.
premise_logic: exists e1 s1 x1 x2 x3 x4 x5.(n_water(x5) & on(e1,x3) & with(x3,x4) & in(x4,x5) & n_line(x4) & of(x4,x1) & n_thing(x1) & n_dock(x3) & a_up(s1) & Manner(e1,s1) & Theme(e1,x1) & v_line(e1) & n_person(x1) & (x1 = x2) & ne_per_fisher(x2))
hypothesis_logic: exists e1 p1 x1.(n_thing(x1) & exists s1.(Theme(s1,x1) & a_loud(s1)) & Topic(e1,p1) & Actor(e1,x1) & v_talk(e1))
premise_sim: exists e1 s1 x1 x2 x3 x4 x5.(with(x3,x4) & v_line(e1) & on(e1,x3) & of(x4,x1) & ne_per_fisher(x2) & n_water(x5) & n_thing(x1) & n_person(x1) & n_line(x4) & n_dock(x3) & in(x4,x5) & a_up(s1) & Theme(e1,x1) & Manner(e1,s1) & (x1 = x2))
hypothesis_sim: exists e1 p1 x1.(v_talk(e1) & n_thing(x1) & exists s1.(a_loud(s1) & Theme(s1,x1)) & Topic(e1,p1) & Actor(e1,x1))