Fisher persons are lined up on a dock with their lines in the water.
they are talking loud
Being lined up and talking loud are not contradictory actions unless the talk scares away the fish. Even then, it would be inadvisable instead of contradictory.
exists e1 s1 x1 x2 x3 x4 x5.(n_water(x5) & on(e1,x3) & with(x3,x4) & in(x4,x5) & n_line(x4) & of(x4,x1) & n_thing(x1) & n_dock(x3) & a_up(s1) & Manner(e1,s1) & Theme(e1,x1) & v_line(e1) & n_person(x1) & (x1 = x2) & ne_per_fisher(x2))
exists e1 p1 x1.(n_thing(x1) & exists s1.(Theme(s1,x1) & a_loud(s1)) & Topic(e1,p1) & Actor(e1,x1) & v_talk(e1))