A black dog runs out of the water with a stick in its mouth.
The dog is red
the dog is either red or black. the only way this would work if it's two different dogs.
exists e1 s1 x1 x2 x3 x4.(n_mouth(x4) & of(x4,x2) & n_thing(x2) & n_water(x2) & with(e1,x3) & in(x3,x4) & n_stick(x3) & r_out(e1) & of(e1,x2) & Actor(e1,x1) & v_run(e1) & n_dog(x1) & a_black(s1) & Theme(s1,x1))
exists s1 x1.(n_dog(x1) & Theme(s1,x1) & a_red(s1))