Large-scale change initiatives stimulating change in several organizational systems in the health and social care sector are challenging both to lead and evaluate. There is a lack of systematic research that can enrich our understanding of strategies to facilitate large system transformations in this sector. The purpose of this study was to examine the characteristics of core activities and strategies to facilitate implementation and change of a national program aimed at improving life for the most ill elderly people in Sweden. The program outcomes were also addressed to assess the impact of these strategies.
A longitudinal case study design with multiple data collection methods was applied. Archival data (n = 795), interviews with key stakeholders (n = 11) and non-participant observations (n = 23) were analysed using content analysis. Outcome data was obtained from national quality registries.
This study presents an approach for implementing a large national change program that is characterized by initial flexibility and dynamism regarding content and facilitation strategies and a growing complexity over time requiring more structure and coordination. The description of activities and strategies show that the program management team engaged a variety of stakeholders and actor groups and accordingly used a palate of different strategies. The main strategies used to influence change in the target organisations were to use regional improvement coaches, regional strategic management teams, national quality registries, financial incentives and annually revised agreements. Interactive learning sessions, intense communication, monitor and measurements, and active involvement of different experts and stakeholders, including elderly people, complemented these strategies. Program outcomes showed steady progress in most of the five target areas, less so for the target of achieving coordinated care.
There is no blue-print on how to approach the challenging task of leading large scale change programs in complex contexts, but our conclusion is that more attention has to be given to the multidimensional strategies that program management need to consider. This multidimensionality comprises different strategies depending on types of actors, system levels, contextual factors, program progress over time, program content, types of learning and change processes, and the conditions for sustainability.
World-wide, national authorities have tried to implement initiatives to improve quality and efficiency in their health and social care systems, with various degree of success e.g. [1–3]. As in several other countries, Swedish national authorities have tried to influence healthcare providers by delivering information on recommended practices, policy documents, descriptions of visions and areas in need of improvement, the latter sometimes accompanied with indicators for monitoring and evaluation. However, as means of improving health and social care the use of a passive diffusion of information approach has not produced the desired changes . There is a need for more active implementation strategies [5–7]. Ferlie and Shortell  argued that unless policy and decision makers consider and implement a coherent and multilevel approach to change there is a low chance to improve the quality of a nation's healthcare system. As such, no single change strategy fits all situations and a mixture of strategies are often called for when changing health care practice .
Many studies of changes in health and social care deal with relatively small-scale change initiatives involving a few organizations or single strategies e.g. [10, 11]. Large-scale change initiatives seeking to stimulate change in several organizational systems are more challenging to evaluate. Prior studies in this field have often lacked systematic analyses [12, 13]. Large-system transformations (LST) is defined as: "interventions aimed at coordinated, system wide change affecting multiple organizations and care providers, with the goal of significant improvement in the efficiency of health care delivery, the quality of patient care, and population-level patient outcomes." , p. 422. LST will be used in this article to refer to large-scale change programs and quality improvement attempts. Gaining more insight into different approaches to LST, its features, strategies and outcomes can enrich our understanding of strategies to facilitate the improvement and change of large and complex health care systems.
Previous empirical studies dealing with implementation of LST discuss success factors e.g. , change driving mechanisms e.g. , and/or contextual conditions e.g.  important for LST programs, but few frameworks are available to describe strategies for enhancing LSTs. A recent literature review of LSTs in healthcare introduces a model with four primary and 15 secondary drivers for change  that can be used to aid program planning and implementation. The model, presented in Figure 1, provides a framework for understanding of factors influencing the implementation of LSTs.
A model over factors influencing Large Scale Transformation initiatives in healthcare. Adapted from the model over large scale improvement initiatives by Perla et al. .
The driver 'Planning and infrastructure' includes vision and aim; carefully developed interventions; solid management; and sufficient resources, both in central administration and in participating organizations. This driver focuses on program organization and the clarity and content of the program. The associated secondary drivers mirror many normative advices from the change and project management literature. Studies have acknowledged the importance to ensure a solid organizational foundation and to assure that appropriate organizational and contextual conditions are in place or are being developed when launching LSTs in healthcare e.g. .
The driver 'Considering individual, group, organizational, and system factors' include eight secondary drivers: individual and group factors and their dynamics; champions and change agents; leadership roles; capability and capacity development; learning networks; social networks; organizational and system capability; and organizational and system culture. This primary driver reflects the embedded complexity of the health or social care system and emphasizes the need for good system knowledge and actor strategies at multiple system levels. The review also highlights the involvement of several actors and consideration of system factors, for example a study identifying success factors of the Kaiser Permanente's Performance Improvement System [14, 18]. Results consistent with the first two primary drivers can for example be found in a study of a women's health program in Michigan, where widely accepted standards and demonstrated value of the innovations, committed leaders/champions, and a participatory culture were important factors for success .
The driver 'Process of change' has a secondary driver, the chosen change theory, which in turn has three dimensions: spread; underlying change theory; and the mechanisms used for spread. The model is vague on this driver, leaving room for interpretation on how to address the underlying change theory. Finally, driver four, 'Performance measures and evaluation', contains two secondary drivers: data infrastructure and measurement and feedback systems. This driver is connected to monitoring and evaluation of the various parts of an LST program and to the enhancement and use of feedback.
Other studies provide examples of all four drivers in the model. Lucas and colleagues  identified five interactive elements critical to LSTs in the US health care systems: impetus to transform; leadership commitment to quality; improvement initiatives that actively engage staff in meaningful problem solving; alignment to achieve consistency of organization goals with resource allocation and actions at all levels of the organization; and integration to bridge traditional intra-organizational boundaries among individual components. These elements were suggested to drive change by affecting the health care organisations' mission, vision, strategies, culture, infrastructure, and operational functions and processes. A review of models for successful implementations  underlined the need for systematic approaches with focus on achieving a solid preparation and planning that involves ensuring readiness to change, building implementation structures and planning for interventions, support, feedback and evaluation – but also learning from experiences. However, many change programs start with less rigorous and systematic preparation and build structures and strategies as the process proceeds over time, a mixture of emergent and deliberate strategies where performance consensus becomes important . This mixture of intended and emergent strategies is probably more common for LSTs since both interventions and target context are multidimensional, dynamic and complex.
Studies on factors influencing LSTs provide general frameworks for change agents (e.g. program management and project teams) to consider when planning for LST programs. Less information is available to show how to actually lead LSTs in complex contexts and how to choose and execute strategies to facilitate implementation and change processes. The perspective of the change agents has often been overlooked in research on development in healthcare . Therefore, research from other areas, like change management, can provide more detailed input. For instance, basic assumptions on change and how such assumptions influence the core change strategy or strategies used by change agents have been described by de Caluwé and Vermaak [24, 25]. They illustrate five basic paradigms of change approaches: the blue-print approach (rational planning); the yellow-print approach (stakeholder involvement and negotiation); the green-print approach (interactive learning); the red-print approach (focus on individual's needs and motivation); and the white-print approach (emergent and less controllable change). A prior study of a large-scale health promoting program showed that the program management's use of these basic change approaches during implementation was not a one-choice option but rather the use of multiple strategies that varied over program phases . Besides the focus on preventive actions, the program management team also faced challenges such as defining intermediate and end goals and clarifying the roles of each member of the team . Different teams of change agents may also chose different approaches to enhance LSTs in health care depending on the context (e.g. organization, condition, patient group, staff) and may thereby vary in their success rates . Strategies for overcoming resistance to change have been proposed, where change agents can choose to, for example, provide education; facilitate and support; and/or negotiate and come to an agreement [29, 30].
The few prior studies found on change agents' strategies to facilitate the implementation and change process involved in LSTs provided a rationale for the current study. Accordingly, the purpose of the study was to examine the characteristics of core activities and strategies to facilitate implementation and change applied by the program management of a national program aimed at improving life for the most ill elderly people in Sweden. The program outcomes were also addressed to assess the impact of these strategies.
A multi-method, longitudinal research design has been suggested as appropriate for studies of large-scale programs . Richly described case studies addressing embedded change mechanisms in different contexts are advised . Accordingly, a case study research design with multiple data collection methods was applied.
A national program for improving quality of care for elderly people in Sweden, the "Better life for the most ill elderly people program" (Be-Life program, 2010–2014) form the basis for the study. The Be-Life program addresses hospital care, primary care and eldercare organized by both public, private not-for profit and private for-profit organizations. As such, the program represents an LST attempt that can shed light on the strategic choices made to facilitate the program's implementation in a complex setting with a large variation in its sub-systems.
The Swedish government is responsible for overall health and medical care policy, while the responsibilities for the provision of health care is decentralized to local and regional authorities. There are 21 regional authorities (county councils) that are responsible for providing primary care and specialized healthcare and 290 local authorities (municipalities) responsible for delivering social care and home health care. All these self-governing authorities are involved in the Be-life program.
The program aimed to improve the quality of care for older adults with complex health issues by improving cooperation between municipalities and county councils and streamline the use of resources in line with patient needs. There were also attempts to achieve a holistic frame of reference consistent with other national agreements by incorporating the aims to increase the use of national quality registry data for improvement in health and social care, and to build sustainable regional support structures for and competence in quality improvement.
The previous model used by the government for distributing improvement grants in which municipalities and county councils applied for funding had failed to produce intended outcomes. Therefore, the government had decided to make a successive shift towards incentive grants linked to performance-based targets. This induced an agreement between the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs and the Swedish Association of Local Authorities and Regions (SALAR), the latter an association representing the governmental, professional, and employer related interests of municipalities, county councils and regions. SALAR was given responsibility and funding to coordinate and support the regions in working towards the program goals.
During the first two years, the financial incentives part of the agreement focused on utilizing national quality registries for preventive and palliative care. The registries contain physician-level data regarding diagnoses, treatments, and outcomes, with the aim to be used for decision making, research and quality improvement e.g. . Two registries, the Palliative Registry Sweden and Senior Alert, were initially included in the program. The Palliative Registry (initiated in 2006) uses a questionnaire to register how the deceased person's needs for care were fulfilled during the last period of life, regarding for example pain reliefs. The preventive focused Senior Alert registry (initiated in 2008) centres on falling accidents, nutrition, decubitus ulcers, and oral health. The aim is to have risk assessments performed on a regular basis for each elderly person under care. Senior Alert uses several types of indexes (e.g. Downtown Fall Risk Index, MNA Mini Nutritional Assessment).
A study of the needs of the most ill elderly people commissioned by SALAR resulted in three additional performance-based target areas in the 2012 agreement and onwards: dementia care, pharmacological treatment and coordinated health and social care. For dementia care, performance bonuses were based on the use of two additional national quality registries, the registry for Behavioural and Mental Symptoms in Dementia (BPSD) and the Swedish Dementia Registry (SveDem). The SveDem registry (initiated in 2007) focuses on dementia and uses the instrument Qualid - Quality of life during severe dementia. Additional indicators for old people at special housing units are also registered (e.g. activity level, medicines, person-centred care, measures taken for protection and re-straining activities, such as alarms). The BPSD registry (initiated in 2010) registers information on psychological and behavioural symptoms for people with dementia (e.g. hallucinations, sleep disruptions, depression) and supports analyses and activity plans made for improving a patient's situation.
In the new target area of pharmacological treatment, financial incentives were given for reducing inappropriate medications and/or combinations of medications (replaced by anti-inflammatory medications in the 2013 agreement) and inappropriate medications used to treat psychoses. Two indicators were used to measure coordination of health and social care: 'avoidable inpatient care' and 'readmission within 30 days'. The indicator 'avoidable in-patient care' encompasses "unnecessary" admissions to hospital care due to a number of specified diagnoses assumed to be preventable by sufficient non-institutional care. Among the included diagnoses are asthma, diabetes, anaemia, high blood pressure, cardiac failure, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. The indicator 'readmission within 30 days' aims at both planned and acute hospital care (regardless of diagnosis), and is assumed to indicate cases when patients are discharged from hospitals too soon (with regard to their health status), inadequate pharmacological treatment, lack of information to patients, or insufficient care and follow-ups after discharge. Improvements within other target areas were assumed to have long-term effect on both these indicators, but direct measures were also needed to reduce avoidable hospital admissions and readmissions.
Designing valid indicators for pharmacological treatment and coordinated care was a challenging task. The basic idea was that indicators in these areas should capture how well municipalities and county councils managed cooperation and coordination of care, keeping the individual patient's situation in focus. To facilitate regional improvement work the agreements comprised funding for three to six improvement coaches per region. A special initiative geared toward higher-level managers and key actors in municipalities and county councils called "From word to action – the practice of leadership" (Practice Leadership) was included in the 2012 agreement.
From 2012 and onwards, the agreement stated basic requirements that municipalities and county councils had to meet to qualify for financial incentives. Requirements included political resolution on regional action plans for improvements in care services for older adults with complex health conditions and documentation of a management system for systematic quality work in accordance with the National Board of Health and Welfare's regulations. The estimated costs for the program was in 2010 294 MSEK (32.3 M€ calculated 2013-12-01); in 2011 296 MSEK (32.6 M€) and in 2012 1261 MSEK (138.4 M€). More detailed information on the program can be found on the Ministry of Health and Social Affair's and SALAR's websites (http://www.regeringen.se/sb/d/14622; http://www.skl.se/4.5e95253d14642b207ee4a7b.html).
The study covers the period from 2008 to 2013. Data was collected between October 2011 and December 2013 and consists of interviews, observations, documents, and data from national quality registries. Results on the preparation period (2008–2009) and the first two years of program implementation (2010–2011) were based on retrospective data (documentation and interviews).
Semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders at the national level were conducted by the first and the second author. The informants represented the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs (n = 2), the program management team (n = 3), and strategic functions at SALAR (n = 6). The criteria for selecting informants were involvement in the program from its on-set. The interviews lasted between 45 and 75 minutes. They were recorded and transcribed verbatim. The questions addressed six themes: program background, interventions and activities, strategies, conditions for learning and change, reactions and results, and future plans for the program. Participation was voluntary and based on informed consent.
The project documentation was gathered from the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, the National Board of Health and Welfare, SALAR, and the Be-Life program's internal and external websites. The documentation included newsletters, the project plan, annual action plans and result reports, monthly internal reports from the program management, agendas and notes from seminars, workshops and meetings, including Power-point presentations, all together 70 documents. E-mail communications at the program's internal website were also part of the data set (700 forum posts 2010–2013). Other relevant documents (25 documents; e.g. agreements between the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, SALAR; government assignments; the Swedish Agency for Public Management's annual program evaluation reports; reports from the National Board of Health and Welfare), were collected from the respective web sites. In total, 795 documents were gathered.
During 2012 and 2013 non-participant observations of key project activities were made on twenty-three occasions by one or two researchers. These sessions included seven workshops for regional improvement coaches and five national seminars aimed at regional leaders in health and social care held by the project team (21 full days in total). Three full-day dissemination conferences and eight telephone conferences were also observed. During the observations the activities and reactions from participants was noted using a common format consisting of notes on time, type of event, type of activities, description of activities, actors involved, and comments.
The program's outcomes were collected at municipality and county council level from the national quality registries for relevant indicators. The indicators were related to the target levels for performance bonuses defined in the agreement. The data was obtained in December 2013 and covered the period of 2009–2013.
The interviews, observation protocols and documents were analysed using qualitative content analysis [33–35]. The analysis identified parts of the text that described program activities and important events that subsequently were categorized according to type, intention or goal, involved actors, and finally chronologically ordered. The program management informants also described the strategies they used and these were treated in a separate category. The information was compiled in a detailed chronological matrix of activities, intentions and actors, which constituted the base for the identification of strategies. At this level of analysis we defined a strategy as a cluster of similar activities related to an intention or aiming for a goal. We then identified the intentions and intermediate goals (i.e. goals that if achieved would aid the progress towards the programs main goals) and types of action strategies connected to those in an iterative process comparing goals and strategies over data sources. This procedure generated ten proposed strategies that were validated by the program management team during an interactive session. The definitions of two strategies were slightly re-formulated to fit the comments of the team. Descriptive statistics were used to analyse the quantitative data.
The project was partly financed by government money dedicated for the eldercare area and distributed via SALAR with no restrictions impending the research content or publications. The Regional Ethics Committee in Stockholm has granted ethical approval for the study [ref no. 2011/5:11].
The identified core activities of the program are organized into three program phases: preparation; initiation and early implementation; and implementation.
The main focus during this phase was to explore and obtain stakeholder motivation, engagement and involvement, and to negotiate, decide and initiate the program. The main challenges, as described by the program management, was to get politicians' and higher decision makers' acceptance and understanding of the potential role of national quality registries and regional improvement coaches in improving quality of care for the most ill elderly people.
The discussions between the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs and SALAR about an agreement to introduce performance based financial incentives were initiated in 2008. The increased transparency of the national comparisons (i.e. publishing of results of quality measurements from all health and social care providers) introduced in 2006, together with new national quality registries targeting care for elderly people had provided insights into the performance of regions, municipalities and private organizations.
SALAR suggested that quality registries should be included in the Be-life program agreement and that regional improvement coaches should be used to support the use of registries. A program director with previous experience in quality improvement and coordination of care was recruited in 2009 to form and negotiate the up-coming agreement (signed by both parties in February 2010).
The program's main content, goals and involved actors were negotiated and decided on during this phase. Several fora for communication were initiated. The program structure and approaches to implementation and facilitation were gradually formed, based on assumptions on the importance of interactive learning and a high degree of transparency. Program actions were characterized by a creative trial-error approach. As the management team gradually formed and more actors became involved, vague program strategies were specified and central problem areas identified (e.g. defining measurement strategies). The regional support structure consisting of improvement coaches was put into action. The number and frequency of program activities increased during this phase and implementation in the regions accelerated. Central agreements were annually revised and the first two agreements shared a similar content and scope.
Collaboration between the program management team and the Senior Alert and Palliative Registry Sweden were established in regular strategic meetings. Additional meetings with the two dementia registries that were to join the program in 2012 were held, as well as joint meetings with all four registries. A main focus during this phase was providing IT-solutions for easy and open access to the registries' outcome data.
To provide support for the regional improvement coaches in their assignment to locally implement the utilization of quality registries SALAR initiated a national network platform for the improvement coaches. An important aim of the network was to enable sharing of experiences. Eight network meetings were held during 2010 and 2011. In addition, a web-based, interactive project site was launched to facilitate experience-sharing and contacts between meetings.
An important aspect of SALAR's work was to communicate the central program messages to all involved target groups. The program management team presented the program at national conferences, seminars and exhibitions, arranged regional conferences, seminars and educational activities and made numerous visits to regions and took part in many regional and local activities. A senior communication advisor was hired and a communication strategy formulated in 2011. SALAR's established network of regional health and social care directors was another node used for the launch of and communication about the program.
Another important feature during this phase was to monitor the external environment and gain relevant knowledge (and competence) for the program management team. Team members arranged conferences and international study visits to learn about large system change and patient involvement. The program director was a member of the government's national coordinator team for the care of elderly people. There were ongoing discussions and coordination with the National Board of Health and Welfare and with other governmental assignments in the eldercare area. Efforts were made to monitor the internal SALAR environment to track other relevant programs and projects in order to optimize coordination.
The program management team expanded and new members were employed. In spring 2010, a sub-project leader was hired to manage SALAR's support to the regional improvement coaches. In 2011 an administrator, a communicator, and two more sub-project leaders were recruited.
Mentoring support for the program management team played an important role from the start of the program. Long-term support consisted of critical friends (experts at SALAR, international experts on large-system change and improvement). In addition, individuals with specific competences were engaged on short term basis when needed. A reference group of elderly citizens was established. The government commissioned the Swedish Agency for Public Management to perform yearly follow ups and evaluations. Researchers in several universities were asked to follow the program and relate various aspects to scientific areas of interest.
In 2012, the implementation process intensified. The agreements for 2012 and 2013 involved approximately four times more funding per year as the previous ones and included three new target areas: dementia, pharmacological treatment and coordinated care. The number and scope of program activities increased, more people and target groups became involved and the external communication multiplied. At the same time, the needs for coordination of program activities increased, and at the end of 2013 more discussions on how to sustain the program were detected.
Two dementia care registries were included in the program. During this period, the program management team continued to regularly invite the registries to strategic meetings. They also worked with the registries to coordinate and develop a web portal for easy access to outcome data.
The 2012 agreement involved a shift in the improvement coach role, from supporting the mere use of registries towards facilitating improvement efforts based on registries and indicators. This shift influenced the activities within the improvement coaches' network. Six network meetings were held during the period, along with coaching support via telephone or video conferences when needed. The sub-project 'Practice Leadership' launched in February 2012 was designed to inspire, engage and support the regional management levels when planning for and leading the regional work. Motivation was enhanced by the use of real world examples and a focus on the individual elderly person and his/her situation. International experts on large-scale change and improvement were invited to meetings with regional actors. As a part of the Practice Leadership initiative, a national support structure of established county council development centres was initiated with the aim to provide strategic support to the regional strategic management teams.
The 2012 agreement was launched at a national conference in January 2012, jointly arranged by SALAR and the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs. The intention was to send a clear message to all regions that the program had a strong backing at national level. Representatives from the program management team and the ministry visited municipalities and county councils together, and took part in various regional and local activities. Three conferences that focused especially on managers and medical advisors in primary care were arranged, addressing the challenge to engage these (and other) groups in primary care. Methods for program communication were further developed during this phase, for example the production of short videos and the use of social media such as Twitter and blogs. Special emphasis was put on presenting good local examples of improvement efforts in digital newsletters, reports and on the Be-Life website.
Efforts increased to anchor, monitor and coordinate the program with relevant actors and projects within SALAR (e.g. the pharmaceutical and legal expert groups, the patient safety project) through SALAR's numerous networks for municipal and county councils. Efforts were also made to create a dialogue with SALAR's political organisation and to collaborate with the National Board of Health and Welfare on appraisal of the regional results on indicators. The growing complexity of the program and the increasing number of sub-projects contributed to higher demands on program coordination. The program management team participated in 26 national and numerous regional conferences, seminars, educational activities and network meetings. Members of the team attended international conferences and made study visits abroad.
A journalist, a web assistant and an expert on pharmaceuticals joined the project management team in February 2012.
In order to get support, input and feedback on their work the program management team continued to use mentoring support, with regular meetings with consultants, experts and 'critical friends'. Annual evaluation reports by the Swedish Agency for Public Management fed back information that was discussed within the team. Feedback meetings were also held with the research group. The reference group of elderly citizens took on a more active role, participating in various activities and meetings describing their views and experiences.
One of SALAR's new responsibilities during this period was to develop a monitoring system for the indicators 'avoidable inpatient care' and 'readmission within 30 days' and to coordinate and provide support to the regions' analytical work in these areas. To support the analysis of measurement results a team that focused on the monitoring system was organized along with a network of regional analysts. A web-based tool for monitoring of patients readmitted to hospital within 30 days and patients discharged from hospitals was developed (in collaboration with Blekinge Institute of Technology), tested and launched in the regions during this period.
Ten main strategies to facilitate implementation were derived (Figure 2) based on the extensive list of activities and the respondents' descriptions of the strategic choices made during the program. The first strategy concerns the repeated communications of the urgency, purpose and progress of the program to all types of actors and through multiple channels (1). The second strategy, to encourage empathy for the most ill elderly people's situation and provide real world examples (2), focuses on motivating and engaging people by using real-world examples of problematic and heart-warming situations. The third strategy, to enhance cooperation and holistic views on the program between and among national and regional actors (3), is exemplified by the coordination between several national initiatives and involvement of actors from these initiatives. The fourth strategy, to establish regional support structures of strategic level management teams and improvement coaches competent in systematic improvement (4) is an example of the use of regional change agents and a 'coaching the coaches' strategy at two hierarchical levels in the regions.The fifth strategy, to build a national support structure using established county council improvement and development centres with expertise in quality improvement (5) to provide strategic support to the regional support structures (see 4) was initiated as a part of the 'Practice Leadership' initiative. The aim of strategy 4 and 5 was also to enhance sustainability beyond the program on both regional and national levels. The sixth strategy, to draw on different actors' collective competence and perspectives by inviting different stakeholders to meetings, seminars and collaborations (6), including elderly people and politicians, indicates an openness for discussion and perspective taking. The national quality registries and the analytical experts were also actively involved in many meetings and in coaching the staff that were to work with improvement and quality registries. The seventh strategy, to encourage transparency and use all kinds of media for communication and information sharing (7) is connected to strategy one, but the focus here is on being open and transparent with uncertainties, good and bad results, changes of strategies, and problems and mistakes and the attempts to act on them. The eighth strategy, to carefully design interactive and engaging program activities (8), reflects the program management team's basic assumptions on how to foster change, by enhancing interaction, motivation and learning. The ninth strategy, to engage experts, mentors, evaluators and critical friends (9) reflects the active involvement of knowledgeable individuals and groups for various types of support to the program management team. Finally, the tenth strategy, directed mainly at the regions, concerns how to actively use monitoring, evaluation, measurement and feedback structures in combination with governmental financial incentives (10). This is exemplified by the web-portal giving access to registry data, and the provision of tools, models and reports to aid regional actors' comprehension of measurement and results (Figure 3).
Overview of the BeLife program.
Strategies used by the Be-Life program management to facilitate implementation, change and sustainability.
In Table 1 a selection of indicators used to measure the Be-Life program outcomes in the five target areas are presented.
Before the program, the Senior Alert registry was virtually unknown among the municipalities. During the first two years the utilization of the registry increased dramatically. There was a similar development among the county councils. In 2010 and 2011, performance bonuses were related to the number of registered risk assessments. From 2012 additional bonuses were granted to municipalities where a risk assessment was performed for a minimum of 90 percent of the elderly people living in special housing units. During the first two years, the average number of registered risk assessments per month increased by over 200 percent each year.
At program start the Palliative Registry Sweden was well-known among municipalities and county councils and by the second year, almost all municipalities and all county councils had units participating in the registry. Performance bonuses were paid if the required percentage of all registered deaths in the region was reached. The target levels for performance bonuses were gradually raised each year. The proportions of municipalities and county councils reaching the target levels have fluctuated between 60–79 percent (municipalities) and 71–89 percent (county councils) over the program period. From 2012, bonuses were also granted based on whether the patient and/or their relatives received verbal information about the imminent death, a key activity in the palliative care process.
When the SveDem registry was included in the program in 2012 most patients that were given diagnostic work-ups at specialized dementia care units was being registered, but the coverage within primary care was very low. During the first year in the program, the number of participating primary care units and number of registered diagnostic work-ups increased substantially. There was an even more prominent development regarding the utilization of the registry for Behavioural and Mental Symptoms in Dementia in municipalities, where the number of registered patients increased from 77 to 11 613 between the years 2010 and 2013.
All regions reduced their use of the specified medications during 2012, but only two regions (10%) reached the target of a ten percent reduction. To receive performance bonuses in 2013, the regions had to reduce the prescription of the three types of medications for at least four months during the six month long measurement period (April-August 2013), as compared to the same period in 2012. Patient data from registries, based on place of residence (i.e. municipality), were used and aggregated to county level. All regions managed to reduce prescription of inappropriate medications and anti-inflammatory medications, and two thirds of the regions reached the goal related to medications used to treat psychoses. Variation in results on municipality level is presented in Table 2. Thus, even regions with high adherence to target levels had municipalities that did not reach them.
Number and proportion of municipalities that reduced the prescription of targeted medications during the measurement period April-August 2013 compared to April-August 2012.
In 2012 no region reached the target level of a ten percent reduction in the coordinated care index (calculated from the two indicators 'avoidable inpatient care' and 'readmission within 30 days'). A majority of the regions (16 of 21) showed small reductions, less than 2 percent. The two regions with the largest reductions reduced their index levels by 7 and 5 percent respectively. Two other regions increased their coordinated care index by 7 and 9 percent respectively. However, large variations between the regions' monthly results could be found. In 2013, the criteria were refined and performance bonuses paid to the regions that showed a statistically significant improved monthly value for at least four months, as compared with the same period in 2012, for the two indicators respectively. Ten regions (48%) reached the goal for the indicators 'avoidable inpatient care' and another ten the goal of 'readmission within 30 days'. Three regions (14%) reached the goals for both indicators. Results on national level are presented in Table 3.
The Be-Life program involved a massive amount of activities directed at many different groups of actors during its first three years. As reflected in our case description, the program included a mixture of intended and emergent strategies as a large part of the program was built during the process and only some aspects were systematically prepared and planned for at the time for the initiation of the program. The program was organized as a project (i.e. limited in time and organized and implemented by a team that eventually will be resolved) with the regional organizations responsible for achieving and sustaining changes and improvements. When a project organization is used to implement policies it is vital to incorporate a complete understanding of the multiple levels of actions needed and the different kinds of variables that can be expected to influence both output and outcome . It is also important to recognize that the initial idea from the government, namely to combine several initiatives for a larger coherent program approach towards the most ill elderly people, provided a proper base for SALAR to choose a more holistic strategic approach aimed at multiple actors and hierarchical levels.
The program management provided visions for the future situation for elderly people that pleaded to peoples' values and life situation and referred to the gap between the current situation and the vision in several areas. The program aims and indicators were primarily related to changes in care procedures and in the elderly person's situation. Aims for phases in the change process were less articulated, for example how good support structures and procedures should develop over time. The interventions included conventional actions proven successful, but also new rather untested and overarching measures. The program was supported by a solid management structure with strong and charismatic leadership. Through the agreements, the Be-Life program and SALAR were provided with substantial monetary resources for coordinating and supporting the implementation and change process. These results are all in line with the 'Planning and infrastructure' driver in Perla et al's model , which includes vision and aim, carefully developed interventions, solid management, and sufficient resources.
Perla et al's model  also highlights the need to 'Consider individual, group, organizational, and system factors'. The program activities and strategies were directed at many different individuals and groups, sometimes inviting several organisational functions, such as higher level managers in multiple areas, to get synergy effects. At national meetings with regional strategic managers various techniques for enhancing learning and interaction were used – in smaller or larger groupings. The regional support structures can also be seen as learning networks, social networks and includes the involvement of local champions and change agents. The many meetings, educational activities, seminars and web sites focused on the aim of building regional capability and capacity. The important role of leadership during change and development was emphasized by the launch of the 'Practice leadership' initiative, involving key decision makers in regional organizations. The program management team emphasized values, but organizational culture was not directly confronted, more indirectly approached when cooperation between care providers was addressed. Facilitation of the implementation required dealing with the diversity of sub-systems and their varying capabilities. This required separate meetings, visits and coaching activities in the regions – which were frequently carried out by the program management team. The many activities aimed for the many different actors and stakeholders more or less involved all eight secondary drivers in Perla et al.'s model . One aspect worth mentioning was the initial lack of strategies, both on national and regional levels, on how to reach the private care providers. This might be due to the relatively recent development of opportunities to choose care provider in Sweden. Reaching private actors will need more attention and further adaption of program strategies, as the provider organisations are either small businesses or organisations with a large geographical spread of units that are not as easily fitted into a regional approach.
The pace of change in LSTs is relatively slow as it often is difficult to have a clear plan from the beginning, it demands lots of involvement from many stakeholders and the main attempt of change agents is to minimize resistance [29, 30]. The Be-Life program strategies fits well with strategies described by Kotter and Schlesinger [29, 30] for achieving change during complex circumstances: using education and communication, participation and involvement and facilitation and support, sometimes combined with negotiation and agreement.
'The process of change' driver in Perla et al's model  is the heart of a change program and can be approached in different ways. The Be-Life program was actively pushed by its management team who used a mix between a help strategy and a make-it-happen strategy to achieve change. Perla et al.  did not specify any change theory or theories in the framework. In the Be-Life program we found indications of several slightly overlapping change theories in terms of de Caluwé and Vermaak's colour categorization of basic views on change [24, 25]. In the first phase the focus was on negotiation in order to gain support and delegation to act. This resembles the strategy of emphasizing negotiation and consideration of many stakeholders' views and can be considered a natural first step in the initiation of change programs . This so called Yellow-print strategy continued in the second phase as the program goal, its main content and actors were negotiated and decided on. It was complemented by the more dominating interactive learning strategy, the Green-print strategy, which allows for trials and experimentation. The Green-print strategy continued to be strong in the implementation phase in combination with an increased amount of rational planning and structuring, activities emphasized by the Blue-print strategy.
With regard to the third dimension of this driver, mechanisms used for spread, Perla and colleagues  emphasizes the lack of a clear synthesis or taxonomy of frameworks for large-scale spread and sustainability. This makes it hard to address this dimension. Perla and colleagues suggests that complex interventions that have not been extensively tested might benefit from more collaborative methods of spread. The Be-Life program's use of several underlying views and theories on change involved both top-down strategies, such as the Blue-print, as well as mixed or bottom-up strategies involving a higher degree of interaction, such as the Green- and Yellow-print strategies. These strategies also indicate underlying assumptions about how to achieve change – by focusing on individuals' needs, interaction and learning, systematic procedures, networking and creating a favourable situation for change.
From the start, the Be-Life program had a 'System for performance measures and evaluation' in place – driver four in Perla et al.'s model . The national quality registries included in the program provided an infrastructure that involved the registry holders, their web sites and their expertise. Measures on regional levels were regularly provided by the registries on a web site. The measurement and feedback system were further developed during the program period and made more easily accessible for regional actors. In addition, the program's progress was regularly followed and measured by external actors and fed back to the program management. The use of monitoring and feedback strategies that can follow the program's development process, progress, output and outcomes are often overlooked, but necessary to enhance development . Using structured ways of assessing the current quality situation in health care organisations, and involving many actors while doing so, can enhance the readiness for change in national programs .
Sizable amounts of money from the state were invested in the Be-Life program, as the regions' performance was connected to financial incentives. Resources were also used to build regional support structures and to support improvement of registry output and competence in analyses. The application of financial incentives to support changes in healthcare has often targeted micro levels, such as general practitioners, physicians and patients e.g. [39, 40]. In Sweden financial incentives have been used more recently in several national change initiatives directed at regions and provider organisations, but all aspects of these reforms have not yet been assessed. A recent study on financial incentives as driving force for improvements in healthcare indicated that finances do play a role, but aspects such as attention to improvements from management, dedicated staff, and practice-based projects can be equally or even more important for successful outcomes . It is too early to evaluate the impact of the financial incentives in the Be-Life program, but the structured observations made of discussions among the regional actors during meetings indicate that the incentives influenced the motivation to act and participate in the program, at least on political and higher management levels.
The analysis of outcome data shows a positive development in the use of the quality registries in the areas of preventive, palliative, and dementia care. Results for the indicators on pharmacological treatment were also positive. As could be expected, effects on the system level indicators of coordinated of care were more modest, so far. Based on these results we infer that the Be-Life program during the studied period has had an impact on care for the elderly citizens in line with its goals in all of the five target areas. Results on national level also show that change happened faster in some areas (e.g. preventive care) than in others (e.g. coordinated care). These differences can be related to many factors like pre-existing work with registries, the complexity level of the target area and the number of involved care-giver organisations. More specific investigations are needed to address the program outcomes and the long-term effects on regional level, as well as to understand the mechanisms for more or less successful regional or local implementation.
This study is limited to the first four years of the Be-life program leaving one year yet to enhance progress towards the goals. Yet, longitudinal mixed methods studies of LSTs have a potential to expand our understanding of change strategies in complex systems. Such studies can also address the understudied aspects of sustainability and long-term impact . A follow-up of the Be-Life program can shed more light on the potential of the program strategies described in this study. There is also a need for a coordinated, multilevel model or taxonomy with a certain degree of flexibility for describing LST strategies used in complex systems, in order to be able to compare cases systematically. Multiple case studies of LSTs using a comparative framework can further enhance our understanding of the nature of strategies used to facilitate the implementation and change in large scale change programs. The way of presenting the strategies in this study resemble the concept 'theory of change' and its use within program theory [42, 43]. In this study we describe the program management team's views, strategies and approaches, with less focus on the program as an entity, even though the two are related. We also suggest the use of de Caluwé and Vermaak's colour categorization of basic views on change [24, 25] as one way to describe underlying change theories in driver three of Perla et al's model .
This case study presents an innovative approach used for implementing a large national change program characterized by an initial flexibility and dynamism regarding content and facilitation strategies, as well as a growing complexity that required increased structuring and coordination as it developed over time. The description of activities and strategies showed that the program management team engaged a variety of stakeholders and accordingly they developed and used a broad array of strategies to facilitate the implementation of the program content. There is no blue-print on how to approach the challenging task of leading large change programs in complex contexts, but our conclusion is that more research and practical focus is needed on the multidimensionality of strategies that program management needs to consider. The strategies used in the Be-Life program depended on the program content, contextual factors, system levels, types of actors and their influences, the program's progress over time, types of learning and change processes inferred, and the conditions for sustainability. These aspects can give some indications on some of the basic aspects of the strategic multidimensionality needed for achieving LSTs in health and social care.
The authors would like to thank the respondents for their time and effort. This work was conducted within a project partly financed by the Swedish Association of Local Authorities and Regions, with additional financial support from the Swedish Research Council for Health, Working Life and Health care (FORTE) program "Value and choice in health and social care" [Grant no 2012–1688] and the FORTE centre for Global Health at Umeå university, Sweden (writing retreats). The last author was funded by ERA-AGE2, Future Leaders of Ageing Research in Europe (FLARE)/Swedish Council for Working Life and Social Research (FORTE).
MN, HS, JH and HH designed the study. HS and MN collected the data. MN and HS conducted the analyses and drafted the manuscript. All authors read, contributed to, and approved the final manuscript.


GOES-17 arrived at its GOES-West position of 137.2º W longitude on 13 November 2018, and began to transmit imagery via GOES Re-Broadcast (GRB) at 1500 UTC and the AWIPS Satellite Broadcast Network (SBN) at 1700 UTC on 15 November (NOAA/NESDIS article). A toggle between Full Disk images of the 16 ABI spectral bands from GOES-17 at 1500 UTC is shown above, with a 16-panel multi-band animation from 1515-2300 UTC shown below..
Full Disk GOES-17 Low-level (7.3 µm), Mid-level (6.9 µm) and Upper-level (6.2 µm) Water Vapor images are shown below.
The improved spatial resolution of GOES-17 (vs GOES-15) was very obvious at higher latitudes — a closer look at GOES-17 Water Vapor imagery (below) showed good detail associated with a gale-force occluded low in the Gulf of Alaska and a weaker low in the Bering Sea (surface analyses). Note that signatures of the higher terrain of mountain ranges across south-central and southeastern Alaska could be seen on the 7.3 µm and to a lesser extent the 6.9 µm images.
After sunrise, GOES-17 "Red" Visible (0.64 µm) images (below) provided a compelling view of the snow-covered Alaska Range (which includes Denali at 20,320 feet / 6,194 meters), the Wrangell Mountains (which includes Mt. Wrangell at 14,163 feet / 4,317 meters) and the Chugach Mountains (which includes Mount Marcus Baker, 13,176 feet / 4,016 meters). In particular, note the long shadows cast by Denali and the Alaska Range in the upper left portion of the images.
For a short time a GOES-17 Mesoscale Domain Sector was positioned over Hawai'i, providing images at 1-minute intervals (below).
Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands could be seen on the far western limb of Full Disk GOES-17 images (below). A few isolated tropical thunderstorms could be seen developing and collapsing in the vicinity of the islands.
A portion of West Antarctica could be seen on the far southern limb of GOES-17 Full Disk images, along with a storm system in the South Pacific Ocean (below). Through gaps in the clouds, the northern edge of the Antarctic sea ice (source) was also evident in the Visible imagery.
Over the Lower 48 states, AWIPS images of 1-minute GOES-17 "Red" Visible (0.64 µm) and Shortwave Infrared (3.9 µm) data (below) showed the smoke and thermal anomaly (darker red pixels near the center of the images) associated with the ongoing Camp Fire in northern California.
Farther to the south in central California, a comparison of 1-minute Shortwave Infrared images from GOES-16 (GOES-East) and GOES-17 revealed differences in the size and orientation of hot pixels of the Adler/Mountaineer/Moses Fires burning northeast of Porterville KPTV in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada. These differences were due to the view angle from the 2 satellites — 62 degrees from GOES-16 over the Atlantic Ocean, vs. only 41 degrees from GOES-17 over the Pacific Ocean. There was a navigational jump with GOES-17 from 1831-1837 UTC, so those images were removed from the animation.


text:
Human Relationships
Home » Psychology » Forensic Psychology » The Characteristics and Development of Neuroethics
The Characteristics and Development of Neuroethics
In this article, learn about the foundations of neuroethics and its primary branches of study. Discover the reasons why this particular discipline has a lot of potential for future research.
The Psychology of the Witness
Cesare Lombroso and His Theory of Criminology
What Does a Forensic Psychologist Do?
Neuroethics is a discipline that's making headway in the international scientific community due to the increase in neuroscience research of recent years.
However, neuroethics as a field of study that came onto the scene as early as 2002, when a group of specialists from different fields came together to study the ethical and social implications of brain research. They felt that classical bioethics was too generic to address the specific ethical issues of neuroscience.
In 2003, the Society for Neuroscience organized the very first neuroethics conference. The International Neuroethics Society was founded in 2006. Members of the organization are professionals who are concerned about the social, legal, political, and ethical implications of neuroscience advances.
As you can see, neuroethics is relatively recent. In this article, we're going to look at the development of neuroethics from the beginning to the present day. This overview of the history of neuroethics will give you a deeper understanding of this burgeoning science.
The Origins of Neuroethics
To understand how neuroethics became a science, you have to keep the interdisciplinary nature of the neurosciences in mind. The field of neuroethics resulted from a large number of disciplines that studied the nervous system.
Over time, the need for cross-disciplinary understanding grew, and researchers were increasingly concerned about ethical issues. Thus, the classic questions about the nervous system and the mind-brain relationship came into play.
In addition to all of these factors, bioethics also advanced a lot. Bioethics studies the ethical aspects of life sciences such as biology and medicine. The advance in bioethics pushed neuroscientists to try and keep up with important ethical and moral questions.
On the other hand, the consequence of the parallel progression of neuroscience itself meant that the research moved towards subjects related to the mind, such as cognitive and emotional functions and pathologies.
Thus, neuroethics was born due to the need for a discipline concerned with establishing adequate precepts for research in these fields.
A 2002 Meeting in San Francisco
Stanford University and the University of California organized a meeting in San Francisco in 2002 that marked the beginning of neuroethics as an independent scientific discipline. About 150 neuroscientists attended the conference. Together, they laid out the foundation of neuroethics.
During the conference, the attendees came up with a definition of neuroethics and its scope of study:
"The study of the ethical, legal, and social questions that arise when scientific findings about the brain are carried into medical practice, legal interpretations, and health and social policy. The examination of what's right and wrong, good and bad about the treatment of, perfection of, and welcome invasion or worrisome manipulation of the human brain."
Although they came up with a definition, the researchers still had a lot to flesh out. One particularly complicated aspect was that almost the entire focus of neuroethics was on nervous system illnesses.
Another problem was the lack of attention on prevention and the functional aspect of the nervous system, to the clear detriment of sciences such as psychology. As you can see, we still have a long way to go to reach a broader and more inclusive perspective of neuroethics.
Characteristics and Development of Neuroethics
The development of neuroethics is a reflection of the evolution of four primary areas of study:
Neural science and the self. The relationship between neuroscience and freedom and human responsibility. It also studies the biological foundation of personality, behavior, and emotions.
Neural science and social practices. This research focuses on social pathologies and memory and learning processes. It also studies personal and criminal responsibility, which sometimes overlaps into forensic neuropsychiatry.
Ethics and practice of neuroscience. This area of study is concerned with the ethics of clinical practice. It covers things such as neurosurgery, psychopharmaceuticals, genetic therapy, neural prosthetics, etc. It also tries to adapt research and therapeutic approaches to nerve pathologies.
Neuroscience and public discourse. This refers to the relationships between the neurosciences and the academic formation of neuroscience researchers. It's also related to things such as disclosure and the relationship to social media.
In conclusion, neuroethics is a relatively new multidisciplinary science with enormous future potential and long-term goals. It is and will continue to be a fertile field of research.
Neuromarketing: The Neuroscience of Buying Things
Today, we're going to tell you about a fascinating new field: neuromarketing. It's the neuroscience of buying things. Read more here! Read more »
Bonete, E. (2010). Neuroética práctica. Descleé de Brower.
Cortina, A. (2010). Neuroética:¿ Las bases cerebrales de una ética universal con relevancia política?. Isegoría, (42), 129-148.
Evers, K. (2011). Neuroética. Cuando la materia se despierta(Vol. 3071). Katz editores.
Marcus, S.J (2002). Neuroethics. Mapping the Field. The Dana Press.
Orts, A. C. (2012). Neuroética y neuropolítica: sugerencias para la educación moral. Tecnos.
Witnesses are a fundamental part of a trial. What they have to say may support the different physical evidence presented before the judge. However, a witness' testimony can't be taken as a dogma of faith. Sometimes, and even if you…
The Scale of Evil – From Self-Defense to Psychopaths
Michael Stone, a forensic psychiatrist and professor at Columbia University, is a point of reference as far as the knowledge of the "anatomy of evil" goes. It was he who developed the scale of evil, a tool which is as…
Cesare Lombroso is extremely important in the history of criminology. His theory on the classification of criminals was the main tool people used to profile them for a long time. Some of his ideas are actually still being discussed. Cesare Lombroso…
Charles Manson and the Psychology Behind His Evil Cult
It's a mystery and quite a challenge for psychologists. Understanding the reasons for the cult and the dark fascination surrounding Charles Manson is one of the trickiest puzzles that the science of behavior and personality has ever tried to solve. Now, after…
5 Personality Tests, Compared and Contrasted
Personality tests are one of the most widely used tools in psychological practice. Although personality is certainly hard to measure, and there are dynamics that make each individual unique, personality tests are more useful than we think. But first we…
Psychology studies the underlying mental processes that determine an individual's behavior. Forensic psychologists study a branch of psychology that evaluates a subject's mental capacity in legal matters. A forensic psychologist is in charge of psychological assessment for prosecutors, judges, and…
How Poverty Changes the Human Brain
Is it true that poverty changes the human brain? Well, many of the brain studies of the last 50 years concentrated on studying the effects of an enriched environment. They found that greater social and intellectual stimulation leads to structural and…
Opioid Addiction and its Effects on the Brain
The serious health crisis in the United States due to the opioid addiction epidemic is putting the country and its institutions at risk. Unfortunately, there's currently no feasible short-term solution for the problem. The United States consumes 80 percent of…
Validating Emotions: What Does it Mean?
Validating emotions or people's stories is such an important and valuable resource that many therapists make it the focus of their therapy sessions. Many of the people who go to therapy do so feeling strange and out of place. They're…
Three Ways to Explain Peace to Children
Children are developing humans. As adults, educators, and parents, it's our obligation to provide them with a safe and sensible world where they can grow securely and happily. With this in mind, let's look at some resources to explain peace…
The content in this publication is presented for informative purposes only. In no sense is this information intended to provide diagnoses or act as a substitute for the work of a qualified professional. For this we recommend that you contact a reliable specialist.
© 2020 Exploring your mind | Blog about psychology and philosophy. Articles and opinions on happiness, fear and other aspects of human psychology.
International: Português | Türkçe | Deutsch | 日本語 | Italiano | Español | Suomi | Français | Polski | Dansk | Norsk bokmål | Svenska | Nederlands | 한국어

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


A new trailer has been released for Detective Pikachu, which launches for Nintendo 3DS in March, and new story elements have been revealed.
Detective Pikachu launches on 23 March, and ahead of its release, Nintendo has shared some new details about the game's storyline, including supporting characters.
The game takes place in Ryme City, where Detective Pikachu and his friend Tim are searching for Tim's father, Harry, when a case about a rampaging Pokémon comes to light; the mysterious Mewtwo seems to be connected, and also knows Detective Pikachu somehow.
New characters to be introduced are café owner Pablo Millan, police inspector Frank Holliday, and Meiko Okamoto, a camera operator at a local TV studio; these characters and more will be key to finding clues and solving problems.
As previously announced, the larger-than-usual Detective Pikachu amiibo launching on the same day will also allow players to unlock cutscenes to watch again; these can be unlocked during normal gameplay, but can be accessed more quickly by using the amiibo.
Detective Pikachu launches for Nintendo 3DS on 23 March.


This year has seen a record level of expat buy-to-let mortgage approvals as expat landlords look to increase their portfolios. Recent surveys of expat landlords clearly reveal they are in the market to increase their holdings as quickly as possible.
The reasons are numerous for this trend, but it felt within the industry that Brexit has a lot to do with it. The survey revealed that over 50% of current landlords are achieving net returns of between 5% and 8% on their current portfolios. This is obviously a much larger return than any traditional savings account can currently offer.
With house values still on the increase year on year expats are also seeing the equity within their properties increasing at a very steady rate. So with all this positivity it is little wonder buy-to-let mortgages are increasing rapidly.
Home ownership in the UK has fallen to its lowest level for over 28 years which may well shock some people. When you look at the overall cost of buying a property in the UK perhaps it is not quite so surprising.
Expat landlords are reaping the rewards of relatively low mortgage interest rates and set up costs which look like rising in the near future.
We always recommend being very selective before deciding on what mortgage best suits your needs. With so many deals on offer it always pays to look at all the options, for example a long-fixed rate deal may be very prudent with the fear of a rate rise looming.
If you need assistance when choosing your next mortgage call one of our experienced advisers and they will be pleased to assist.


text:
Жіночий турнір з баскетболу на Літніх Олімпійських іграх 2016 пройшов у Ріо-де-Жанейро з 6 по 20 серпня 2016 року. Матчі групового етапу пройшли на Молодіжній арені, плей-оф на Арені Каріока 1.

Команди з 12 країн, які кваліфікувалися на турнір, були розподілені на дві групи для участі у груповому етапі змагань.

Регламент

Регламент змагань:
 12 команд були поділені на 2 групи, які складаються з шести команд кожна, команди зіграють між собою один матч.
 Чотири найкращі команди кожної групи зіграють між собою у чвертьфіналах.
 Переможці чвертьфіналів пройдуть до півфіналів.
 Переможці півфіналів зіграють у фіналі, а переможені — у матчі за 3-є місце.

Груповий етап

Група А

1 тур

2 тур

3 тур

4 тур

5 тур

Група В

1 тур

2 тур

3 тур

4 тур

5 тур

Плей-оф

Чвертьфінали

Півфінали

Матч за третє місце

Фінал

Підсумкове становище

Посилання
 Міжнародна федерація баскетболу

Баскетбол на літніх Олімпійських іграх 2016

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaWikipedia


text:
How would you rate your overall experience?
Describe your issue or tell us what you think
This is a snapshot of the current page to help us better understand any issue you might be having. No snapshot showing? Retake Snapshot
Include snapshot
IMPORTANT: If you're reporting an issue, not including a snapshot may hinder our ability to fix it. We respect your privacy and don't share this snapshot with anyone outside of Whatzup.
Send to Whatzup
Your browser does not support iframes, required to play movie trailers.
Close Trailer
Save Listings for Later
Sign up for an account to save listings to your own personal reminders list.
You have multiple accounts. Please select the account you'd like to login to. Then enter the password for that account.
Please check "I am not a robot".
We'll send you a link via email to reset your password.
Link Expired
This password reset link has expired.
I'd like another link please
There was an error loading the media, please try again.
National Shows
Karaoke & DJs
Stage & Dance
Art & Artifacts
Submit Calendar Listings
Events/Things To Do
Writers & Books
Whatzup Picks
Places & Food
Stream Local Music
Create Musician Page
H. Stanley Liddell Award
Report app issue
Distribution Application
Local Movie Showtimes
Local Musicians & Bands
Subscribe to whatzup2nite
Download the Whatzup App
© 2020 whatzup, LLC.
DOWNLOAD THE FREE
Whatzup App!
You must enable JavaScript to use many of the features on whatzup.com.
You have an ad or content blocker enabled.
Ad and content blockers hide calendar listings and other content on our website. Please whitelist our website so you don't miss out on any content.
National Acts
Connecting the songwriter to the listener
Tags: the-clyde-theatre
By Steve Penhollow
WHATZUP FEATURE WRITER
Unlike many established musicians, Ben Folds doesn't mind admitting that he sometimes gets sick of playing his most beloved songs.
"I might have said right before I played the gig, 'I never want to play that [expletive] song again,'" Folds told The Washington Post. "And then when you start playing the show, you realize this is [the audience's] favorite song ... . You just remember you can cash in on your lost innocence."
Folds is best and most widely known for his band Ben Folds Five, purveyors of the hit song, "Brick." At a point when the band was at its hottest, they decided to call it quits in 2000.
The pop Band grind
"It aged us all," Folds told the Arlington Heights Daily Herald, referring to the grind of being a pop band. "We were just [expletive] tired. It was 24 hours a day of doing that for six years. Maybe The Who gave it that much for longer, but one of them died though, you know?
"We were the type of band that, if we weren't feeling it, we felt we weren't doing our job," he said. "And we weren't feeling it consistently. We were just over it."
Folds went on to try a little bit of everything: Solo tours and albums, alliances with orchestras and ballet companies, bands comprised of guys who were also named Ben, a stint as a judge on a reality show, and collaborations with likely and unlikely people, including British novelist Nick Hornby and actor William Shatner.
Folds has nothing but praise for Shatner.
"He's great," Folds told the Daytona Beach News-Journal. "First, he's a complete pro. I mean the guy has 50 or 60 years of experience in his art form.
"But even after all that, he's just so spontaneous," he said. "His takes are always different. He makes it a new experience every time and part of that is very professional."
Excellence of musicianship isn't always what draws Folds to a collaborator or a touring partner.
"Chance kind of puts people together sometimes," Folds told the Toledo Blade. "I've met enough people doing what I do to realize that just because I like their music, doesn't mean I'm going to like them or vice versa. Some of my favorite people to tour with personally, I don't like their music. I just like them. Separating the two is kind of difficult sometimes."
As much as Folds enjoys seeking out questionable helpmates and putting together strange ensembles, he said that seeing him live in a solo setting may be the ideal way to experience his music.
"It does something for the songs when you do it that way,'' he told the Hobart Town Mercury. "You have the ability to really highlight the song, just put a marker right there.
"While you can certainly do that with ensembles, orchestras, or rock bands, there's something special about solo performance," he said. "It's not something that all writers and performers are as comfortable with, because it does require a little bit of mastery of the instrument."
The instrument in question is the piano, although Folds plays many others and plays them well.
Stop comparing him to Joel
Ben Folds Five was notable for being a piano-centered and guitar-free pop act.
When Folds started out, he was compared to Elton John and Billy Joel. Nowadays, young pop and rock pianists are compared to Folds.
Folds said it's flattering but too facile. It does a disservice to the individuality of each artist.
"That's as flattering as it gets," he told the Allentown Morning Call, "but I take it with a grain of salt. When I was starting out, it was very, very frustrating hearing [myself compared to] Billy Joel over and over again. It was insulting because people making the comparison didn't mean it in a nice way. And that was doubly insulting for Billy Joel, implying that he was washed up in some kind of way."
As a lyricist and composer, Folds is often compared to Randy Newman. That's an analogy that he takes unqualified pride in.
"I think it's great," he said. "He's one of the best. I love his point of views and his characters are just so well written and sometimes so bizarre. It's a huge compliment."
Folds' fans tend to respond to his songs as if they are selections from the soundtracks of their lives. The connection between songwriter and listeners is a bit mysterious, Folds said.
"I think what we do is we write what moves us," he said. "I suppose anyone who is genetically or spiritually inclined or connected will pick it up, you know? I think there's probably a lot of people who listen to it and say 'What a bunch of [expletive].' I know. I read a couple of those reviews. You don't know what's going to connect. People see things different ways. For me, if it's someone who takes things to the heart via the head, they'll get it. Thinkers seem to connect."
Embassy hosts 14th annual Down the Line
Down the Line 14 returns to the
Philharmonic welcomes pianist with huge fanbase
Piano Themes from Cinema's Golden Age
Lisitsa will play songs from classic cinema...
Young ventriloquist finds her audience
Darci Lynne Farmer
Darci Lynne to headline show at the Embassy...
6'2" humorist unpacks anecdotes
Jeanne Robertson
Robertson to tell her stories in Van Wert...
Darci Lynne
Vol. 24 No. 24
Subscribe to whatzup2nite for a chance to win a pair of passes to:
February 8 • Paramount Theatre, Anderson, IN
Already subscribed? Check our latest email for details.
Contact us • Advertising • Report a bug • Privacy
© 2020 Whatzup, LLC. • Icons made by Whatzup & Google.
Mashing up technology, juggling, and comedy
Mark Nizer's 4D Theatre
Nizer's 4D Theatre intends to wow crowd at the Honeywell...


There are many academics that suggest the correct way to conduct market research (Lockett & Blackman, 2004; Beall, 2010), but in truth, there are a variety of different ways that are effective dependent on the situation. Kolb (2008) states the research process is comprised of four steps, which are; determining the research question, choosing the research approach, planning the research method and implementing the research. This highlights the importance that planning has in the market research process, as physically implementing the process comes after extensive planning and preparation. This report will critically discuss the above four stages to conducting effective market research. An in-depth analysis of each stage will be conducted, to understand how each factor within the process affects the overall shape and effectiveness of market research.
This is the first step to conducting effective market research and can often be rushed by many companies. As most organisations are eager to implement the process, they can be quick to decide on the research questions. However, it is imperative that the company or researcher decides on a clear research question, as the research question guides and centres the overall shape of the market research. Furthermore, it is absolutely crucial to the rest of the research process. Answering the wrong question can waste tremendous amounts of resources for a company, and make the market research completely ineffective (Springett & Campbell, 2006). One of the main reasons for companies choosing the wrong research question is because they make false assumptions (Kolb, 2008). This means, to avoid false assumptions from being made, that a company will have to take the time to think critically about what the issue is, or what they are trying to understand through the implementation of market research. As previously stated, the research question should not be rushed, as it is a crucial step for implementing effective market research. This can be overcome by basing assumptions on previous research or experiences, which will guide the company to an educated and precise research question (Swartz, 2001). Some internal research data that a company could use are; sales receipts, complaint information, databases, orders or financial analysis. Furthermore, the research could show a variety of different problems, which could then be condensed into one research question to provide precise and effective market research (Martin, 2007).
Kolb (2008) states there are three different research approaches. These are; descriptive research, exploratory research and causal research. The approach that a researcher will take will be largely dependent on the research question, as they differ quite significantly. Descriptive research is "concerned with the present and attempts to determine the status of the phenomenon under investigation" (Singh & Nath, 2010, p. 195). In essence, this will be used by a researcher or company when they want to discover specific details about something, such as consumer average spending. This is because it will analyse statistical data, and is most commonly in the form of surveys. A survey is most commonly used because it can obtain results of a large sample to draw conclusions that can be generalised amongst the population. However, descriptive research is often expensive and time-consuming. This is because of the large amount of data that needs to be collected and analysed (Kolb, 2008). Furthermore, the type of research that surveys provide is often limited, as it only measures a small percentage of the population. It can also be an inconvenient approach to research, which makes it difficult to conduct research effectively. Consumers value their time, and generally do not want to spend it filling out surveys. However, online channels are minimising the inconvenience of surveys, and making a descriptive approach, once again, an effective method of conducting market research (Kolb, 2008). Exploratory research is "about putting one's self deliberately in a place - again and again - where discovery is possible and broad, usually (but not always) non-specialized interests can be pursued" (Stebbins, 2001, p. vi). This type of research could be used to measure consumer attitudes, opinions or beliefs towards a brand. These studies vary in size, but will usually be smaller than descriptive research. To conduct exploratory market research effectively, the researcher must explore deep into consumer's emotions and attitudes, which would be hard to do with a large sample. The focus is more on choosing the right participant, and not trying to conduct the research on a large amount of people. Furthermore, it usually comes at a lower cost to a business, and doesn't take quite as much time. However, it still suffers with inconvenience, as it can be hard to find participants to conduct the research with (Stuart, et al., 2002). Causal research is a research approach that focuses on investigating into cause-and-effect relationships. That is to say, it will measure one variable with another and how these variables interact with each other (Brains, et al., 2011). Furthermore, it can be used to give insight into strategic change that a company may wish to pursue. This is because it can investigate whether the change will be beneficial or not for a company. However, it can still be used to research the effectiveness of change after it has happened. Causal research is often used as a preliminary approach, with the results being made more conclusive with the use of descriptive or exploratory research (Brains, et al., 2011). It is imperative that a researcher or company knows what research approach it wants to take. As stated, it is largely dependent on the research question. However, if a company takes the wrong approach to answer the research question than they will not conduct effective market research, as they would be using the wrong tools and values to gather the data. Kolb (2008) compares choosing a research approachto a car mechanic, if a mechanic was fixing a car, he would choose a wrench, not a spatula. Furthermore, similarly to how the research question shapes the research approach, the approach will also have a significant impact on the research method. This highlights the important of each stage, and why planning and preparation is crucial to successful market research.
There are two methods to market research; quantitative and qualitative. These methods differ greatly; quantitative research is an "approach for testing objective theories by examining the relationship among variables…which can be measured…so that numbered data can be analysed" (Creswell, 2014, p. 4) and qualitative approach will "allow a researcher to examine people's experiences in detail, by using a specific set of research methods such as in-depth interviews or focus groups…" (Hennik, et al., 2011, pp. 8-9). More recently, especially in larger studies, these methods have been combined to form a mixed-method approach. This is a method which "combines elements of qualitative and quantitative research approaches for the purpose of breadth and depth of understanding and corroboration" (Johnson, et al., 2007, p. 123). What method a researcher or company will take is largely dependent on the situation. If a company wishes to understand consumer perceptions then they may prefer a qualitative study (Brunso, et al., 2002; Knox, 2000), whereas measuring consumer average spend would primarily be quantitative in nature (Muijs, 2010). Which method a researcher will conduct must be decided, as it will influence the approach and philosophy the research will inherit. Furthermore, it will also be a determining factor on the form of market research, such as via questionnaires, focus groups or interviews (Muijs, 2010). Qualitative research will primarily take on an interpretivist philosophy, and an inductive approach. An interpretivist philosophy gives importance to human belief, and focuses on evaluating a small sample in detail to understand the views of many (Easterby-Smith, et al., 2002). Furthermore, an inductive approach "begins with the collection of data, rather than with a theory, and uses data to identify regularities or themes, or to suggest theories…" (Hayes, 2000, p. 789). On the other hand, quantitative research will generally take on a positivist philosophy, and will also usually take on an inductive approach. A positivist philosophy is quite different to interpretivist, because it focuses on the collection of large amounts of data and quantifying the data with thorough statistical analysis (Lee, 1991). Using the examples above, if a company wanted to conduct effective market research to analyse consumer average spend, than they would conduct quantitative research with a positivist and inductive approach. This is because the researcher will collect a large sample of data to statistically analyse the average spend of a company's consumers. Doing interviews would be small-scale and ineffective as it wouldn't represent a large enough sample. As previously mentioned, the research method will be a determining factor for what tool to use to conduct the research. Quantitative research will usually take the form of a questionnaire, which is a "survey instrument used to collect data from individuals about themselves, or a service or product…each respondent is exposed to the same questions…to ensure the differences can be interpreted as reflecting differences" (Siniscalco & Auriat, 2005, p. 3). On the other hand, qualitative research is usually in the form of focus groups or interviews, which are "a form of group interview that capitalises on communication between research participants in order to generate data" (Kitzinger, 1995, p. 299). This shows the disparity that exists between the different methods, and why a researcher must be clear on what their research method. Trying to obtain data using the wrong research method will yield negative results and will more than likely cause the market research to underperform.
After the planning and preparation has been conducted, the market research, such as questionnaires or focus groups, can be implemented and analysed. Physically conducting research is perhaps the most complex stage of the market research process, but is made significantly easier through rigid planning and preparation (Craig & Douglas, 2005). Furthermore, this stage may consist of going out into the field to collect results, or simply waiting for participants to fill out a survey. It can be both the longest, or shortest, stage of the marketing process, with it being made significantly more effective with proper planning. All the data collected would be analysed by whatever means appropriate. If a survey was used then the most effective method would be through the use of statistical software. However, qualitative research, such as focus groups, will primarily be analysed by the researcher or company, which will allow them to interpret the data how they sit fit. This can raise issues of bias, which is the extent to which researchers or participants may seek to influence the process of data collection, analysis and findings (A Bryman, 2008). However, if the company wishes for the market research to be conducted effectively, then it will be sure of eliminating all possible threats of bias. Furthermore, this would be the stage where secondary research could be used, as it would help supplement the primary market research. Secondary research is "the re-analysis of data for the purpose of answering the original research question with better statistical techniques, or answering new questions with old data" (Glass, 1976, p. 3). The use of secondary research is usually decided by the researcher, but generally helps fortify any of the findings from the primary research ensuring that the market research is more effective and thorough.
From the discussion of how to conduct effective market research, it becomes quickly apparent that the most vital stage to conducting market research is the planning and preparation stage. A company must clearly define what there aims and objectives are, as it will help shape and design the overall market research process. There are a plethora of alternative methods to conducting market research, but each different method has its merits. A survey will not explore in-depth attitudes of consumer behaviour, but it will gauge a good understanding of average spend. Utilising the wrong tools, approaches or philosophies to answer the research question will end up with ineffective market research being conducted, with the company losing substantial amounts of resources. Furthermore, the planning and preparation stage is so important because it will make the physical conduction of the research much easier. If a company knows what they are trying to discover, in what method, and with what tools, than they will be able to conduct the most effective market research in the most efficient manner.
A Bryman, E. B., 2008. Business Research Methods. s.l.:Oxford University Press. Beall, A. E., 2010. Strategic Market Research: A Guide to Conducting Research That Drives Businesses. Bloomington: iUniverse. Brains, C., Willnat, L., Manheim, J. & Rich, R., 2011. Empirical Political Analysis. 8th ed. Boston: Longman. Brunso, K., Fjord, T. A. & Grunert, K. G., 2002. Consumers' food choice and quality perception, Aarthus: MAPP working paper 77. Craig, C. S. & Douglas, S. P., 2005. International Marketing Research. 3rd ed. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Creswell, J. W., 2014. Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications. Easterby-Smith, M., Thorpe, R. & Lowe, A., 2002. Management Research: An Introduction. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications. Glass, G. V., 1976. Primary, Secondary, and Meta-Analysis of Research. Educational Researcher, 5(10), pp. 3-8. Hayes, N., 2000. Foundations of Philosphy. 3rd ed. London: Thomson. Hennik, M., Hutter, I. & Bailey, A., 2011. Qualitative Research Methods. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications. Johnson, R., Onwueghuzie, A. & Turner, L., 2007. Toward a definition of mixed-methods research. Journal of Mixed Method Research, 1(2), pp. 112-133. Kitzinger, J., 1995. Introducing Focus Groups. BMJ, Volume 311, pp. 299-302. Knox, B., 2000. Consumer perception and understanding of risk from food. British Medical Bulletin, 56(1), pp. 97-109. Kolb, B., 2008. Marketing Research: A Practical Approach. 1st ed. s.l.:SAGE Publications. Lee, A. S., 1991. Integrating Positivist and Interpretive Approaches to Organizational Research. Journal of Organization Science, 2(4), pp. 342-365. Lockett, A. & Blackman, I., 2004. Conducting market research using the Internet: the case of Xenon Laboratories. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, 19(3), pp. 178-187. Martin, R., 2007. How Successful Leaders Think. Harvard Business Review, Volume June. Muijs, D., 2010. Doing Quantitative Research in Education with SPSS. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications. Singh, Y. K. & Nath, R., 2010. Research Methodology. 1st ed. New Delhi: APH Publishing. Siniscalco, M. T. & Auriat, N., 2005. Questionnaire Design, Paris: International Institute for Educational Planning. Springett, K. & Campbell, J., 2006. An introductory guide to putting research into practice, s.l.: PodiatryNow. Stebbins, R. A., 2001. Exploratory Research in the Social Sciences. 1st ed. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications. Stuart, I. et al., 2002. Effective case research in operations management: a process perspective. Journal of Operations Management, 20(5), pp. 419-433. Swartz, J., 2001. Popular Online Grocery Pioneer Webvan Shuts Down, s.l.: USA Today.


This is so good, it bears repeating!
Roasted cauliflower the whole family will love.
This is one of my most favoritest (is that even a word) vegetable.
It's so versatile and affordable.
This recipe is probably the easiest recipe ever. EVER.
If you don't like cauliflower swap it for your favorite veggie instead.
I have tried this with okra, broccoli, potatoes, squash, and zucchini. All of the turned out great.
I love cauliflower with just salt and pepper and I haven't tried with any of the other alternative seasonings. If you try it with other seasoningslet me know your favorite.
If your family likes it a little spicy, sprinkle Habanero powder.
Remember a little goes a long way!


text:
The Armed Forces Covenant is a promise from the nation ensuring that those who serve or who have served, and their families, are treated fairly.
The Covenant recognises the sacrifices they make on behalf of the country. It is not designed to give the armed forces, veterans and their families preferential treatment compared with other people, but it should ensure that they are not placed at a disadvantage as a result of their service.
In December 2014, Greater Manchester Combined Authority became the first combined authority to sign the Covenant. Working with our partners, we have established an Armed Forces Hub to co-ordinate a strategic response to the opportunities and challenges that face the Armed Forces community.
The Hub is co-ordinating activity around work and skills; age-friendly places; healthy ageing; housing, planning and transport; culture and learning; and communications. It has already delivered e-learning for all those who are seeking to develop their knowledge of the needs of the Armed Forces community - you can access the e-learning for Frontline Workers here.
Our priorities are:
to become the first city-region in the UK that has one approach to delivering the Armed Forces Covenant
to become a centre of excellence for research into the Armed Forces community and for piloting new ideas and fresh approaches
to work in partnership to eradicate disadvantage through service and make Greater Manchester the place of choice for families and individuals transitioning out of military service
Key work strands:
Common policies and approach
Health, mental health and social care
Work and skills
Reserves and their employers
Cadet forces
Armed Forces community in the Criminal Justice System
Armed Forces Covenant – Getting Animated
E-learning for Frontline Workers
Veterans' and Families Service Directory
Tweets by GMArmedForces


text:
Byron's Blether
Word on the Tweet
Home Scottish Premiership Celtic 'I love this team' Lennon delivers verdict on if his Celtic side...
'I love this team' Lennon delivers verdict on if his Celtic side can beat O'Neills
Daniel Byron
Dermot Desmond said he believes that the current crop of Celtic players would beat the side that went all the way to Seville.
Neil Lennon was a midfielder during the 2002 cup final, but he played it safe when answering questions.
He said: "It is difficult to make comparisons. I think it would be a 2-2 draw myself!
"It's all about people's opinions. I love the team I played in and I love this team.
"Our team did some really great things and this team has done some great things.
"We want them to continue in the same vein.
"They have won the last 11 domestic trophies and had a really good Europa League run last season.
"But in terms of what they achieved over the past three or four years, it is absolutely amazing."
Lenny added: "It is great to have Dermot's backing. He's been so good to me, and for me.
"We do talk on a regular basis, so he's got his finger on the pulse of the club and the team.
"We talk at length the day before a game or we analyse the game now and again.
He made it clear and we didn't shy away from it, that he didn't think the performance against Ross County was good. If you are open and honest with Dermot and straight, you get rewarded for that.
"He's a very intelligent man and he's done unbelievable things for the club.
"If you have him as a support or an ear then it gives you a lot of comfort, particularly in a heavily pressurised job like this."
"And that has been forged over a long time. I've been at the club for 20 years.
"I was manager here for four years in my first period and now I'm into my third season.
"It's not as if there's a comfort there, he keeps you on your toes.
"He likes high standards and he likes high standards of performance from the players and staff.
"He doesn't make unrealistic demands of you or unrealistic expectations.
"If you go through a bad period he's the first one to pick up the phone and talk to you and support you and, likewise, when we have great results he's there to congratulate you.
"If there's something that he's not happy with then we talk it through and look to improve on it."
Previous article'Follow in the footsteps of Stein' Desmond offered Sir Alex Ferguson Celtic job
Next article'If it's rugby let them play on' Sutton takes swipe at Government as Rugby is let off
'Excellent performance' Lennon reflects on Celtic performance as they scrape past Riga
'All of that comes up' Scottish Tory leader Douglas Ross complains about abuse from fans
'Celtic aren't immune' Celtic need fans in the stadium – Lenny
© 2019, The Dugout Scotland | All rights reserved.