text:
GA/PK/175
SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON PEACEKEEPING OPERATIONS
ENDS TWO-DAY DEBATE ON NEED FOR RAPID
DEPLOYMENT OF PEACE OPERATIONS
NEW YORK, 12 February (UN Headquarters) -- As the Special Committee on Peacekeeping Operations concluded the general debate of its 2002 session in two meetings today, Uganda's representative pointed to the failure of the Security Council to act decisively in the face of serious threats to peace, security and human lives, particularly in Africa.
Reluctance to deploy sufficient peacekeeping operations to the continent was unacceptable, he said. Once a mandate was clearly determined, it was imperative that a credible force be authorized to support a peace process and an operation. That dictate, however, seemed to be lacking, particularly when the Council was dealing with African peacekeeping.
Fiji's representative said an area of concern was the lack of commitment from the regular budget for gender mainstreaming which, although lauded as a critical cog in the process, was still subject to voluntary funding. Such a context would politicize gender mainstreaming, which would, in turn, recede into the background with its associated tasks earmarked for completion this year.
While speakers once again expressed support for the reforms currently taking place within the Department of Peacekeeping Operations, delegations also continued to highlight areas in the peacekeeping process which they felt were lacking or of some concern.
Kenya's representative said that, while he appreciated recent efforts by the Secretariat to clear long-outstanding arrears, as well as accelerate troop cost reimbursement, it now needed to avoid delays beyond three months. Delays in reimbursement caused great hardship to troop- and equipment-contributing countries, especially developing countries. It also reduced their potential and ability to effectively participate in peacekeeping operations.
Ghana's representative said the payment of death and disability claims to the estates of deceased peacekeeping personnel was another issue of concern to his delegation. His country's own assessment of the procedures involved showed unnecessary bureaucracy, especially regarding the processing of claims for compensation. That was an area to which the United Nations searchlight must be directed if the anguish of bereaved dependants was to be reduced.
Speakers once again addressed the issue of imbalance and inequitable geographic representation among posts in the Department. Some speakers drew attention to imbalances in the field and called for the positions of mission leaders, Force Commander, Deputy Force Commander and Chief of Staff to be reserved for contingents with a sizeable force of troops in any specific mission.
While the issue of enhanced cooperation between the troop-contributing countries and the Security Council was reiterated today, the representative of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia cautioned against disregarding the Organization's cooperation with host countries. His country, as host to the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK) and Metohija, had established a coordinating centre for Kosovo and Metohija, whose primary task was to work with UNMIK and the multinational stabilization force in Kosovo in solving questions of common interest.
He said cooperation between a peacekeeping mission and a host country should not be limited to specific questions on the unfolding of the mission alone; there were a series of other issues of broader significance, in which such cooperation could be very useful. That was particularly relevant in the case of UNMIK and in the context of the efforts of the international community to combat terrorism, illicit trade in narcotics and small arms, as well as other forms of organized crime in the wider area of operation of the Mission.
Ukraine's representative said his country was proposing that the International Day of Peacekeepers be observed annually, to pay tribute to all men and women who had served and continued to serve in peacekeeping operations, and to "honour the memory of those who lost their lives for the cause of peace".
Uruguay's representative said the idea of a "reserve financing fund" would be useful, since such a fund could advance funds to those developing countries whose ability to contribute to peacekeeping operations was hampered by budgetary and financial difficulties.
Statements in today's general debate were also made by the representatives of the United States, Bangladesh, Philippines, Nepal, Zambia, Jamaica, China, Libya, Belarus, Poland, Pakistan, Australia, Saudi Arabia, Republic of Korea, Thailand, Zimbabwe (on behalf of the African Group), Turkey, Singapore, Romania, Malawi, Mexico, Democratic People's Republic of Korea, and Botswana.
The Permanent Observer of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta also spoke in today's debate.
The Under-Secretary-General for Peacekeeping Operations, Jean-Marie Guéhenno, spoke at the end of the general debate, responding to questions raised by delegations today and yesterday.
The Special Committee will meet again at a date and time to be announced in the Journal.
The Special Committee on Peacekeeping Operations met this morning to continue the general debate of its 2002 session. (For further details, see Press Release GA/PK/174, dated 11 February 2002.)
RICHARD S. WILLIAMSON (United States) said "we have entered a phase of consolidation and implementation". That being so, he said there was now a need to ensure that resources for peacekeeping operations were adequate and that they were used effectively. There was also the beginning of a fair and inclusive consultation process between troop-contributing countries, the Security Council and the Department of Peacekeeping Operations (DPKO).
He said that this session of the Special Committee would address the heart of United Nations peacekeeping concerns. Since logistics was key to peacekeeping operations, the United States encouraged the Secretary-General to include an overview of activities in Brindisi in his future reports to the Committee. Such an overview would facilitate an evaluation of supply stocks for future operations.
Addressing diseases that affected peacekeepers, he recommended that a review of DPKO training on that topic be encouraged. The issue of civilian policing in peacekeeping operations was also crucial, and he was pleased to note that significant strides had been made in that area. "As we look at past and present opportunities and contemplate the future, we all recognize the relationships between peacekeeping, peace-building and conflict resolution", he said. "With each new peacekeeping operation, we have to address where peacekeeping ends and where peace-building begins." He cautioned against making the error of substituting "our judgement" for the expertise of a relevant and proper authority in a given area.
BOB F. JALANG'O (Kenya) welcomed efforts that had recently been made by the Security Council to have meaningful consultations with troop-contributing countries. He wished to see institutionalized consultations with troop contributors, but felt the current initiative was a step in the right direction until nations could agree on more accommodative measures.
He also appreciated recent efforts by the Secretariat to clear long outstanding arrears, as well as accelerated troop-cost reimbursement, but called on the Secretariat to avoid delays beyond three months. Delays in reimbursement caused great hardship to troop- and equipment-contributing countries, especially developing countries. It also reduced their potential and ability to effectively participate in peacekeeping operations.
He hoped the Secretariat's review of procurement procedures for United Nations peacekeeping operations would lead to greater efficiency, propriety, accountability and transparency. He stressed that priority should be given to developing countries, particularly troop contributors close to the mission area, when procuring goods and services in support of peacekeeping operations. Regarding the selection of mission leaders, the positions of Force Commander, Deputy Force Commander and Chief of Staff should be reserved for contingents with a sizeable force of troops in any specific mission. Only then would decisions made at Headquarters have the interest of troops in the field at heart.
IFTEKHAR AHMED CHOWDHURY (Bangladesh) said the political will of Member States to match the mandates of peacekeeping operations with financial, material and human resources remained critical to the success of United Nations peacekeeping. Steps must, therefore, be taken to bridge the commitment gap with regard to personnel and equipment, particularly by those with the means to do so.
His delegation, he said, associated itself with yesterday's statement by the representative of Jordan, speaking on behalf of the Non-Aligned Movement. During the ongoing review of peacekeeping operations, it had become increasingly clear that the core capacity of the Department of Peacekeeping Operations must be enhanced, including in management practice, strategic planning and policy and capacity development. He expressed disappointment that candidates from some of the most important troop-contributing countries (including Bangladesh) had found no place on the list of 92 additional posts created as a first response to the Brahimi recommendations. On the issue of rapid deployment of peacekeeping forces, he said experience indicated that considerable progress could be made by enhancing the strategic reserve and the timely availability of air- and sea-lift capability.
He stressed his country's concerns with the issue of training, safety and security of peacekeepers. In that regard, he requested a briefing on the issue both from the DPKO and the Office of the United Nations Security Coordinator, as had several other delegations.
ENRIQUE MANALO (Philippines) noted that complex and difficult peacekeeping challenges faced the United Nations in the next few months, especially in light of developments in Afghanistan and United Nations peacekeeping missions in Africa and the Balkans. The situation in many areas of United Nations operations continued to present dangers to regional and international peace and security.
Now more than ever, he said, the United Nations approach to peacekeeping must include all participating States. Unfortunately, "consultations" with those States had not amounted to substantive input into operations. Discussions on peacekeeping operations needed to allow troop contributors a significant role in decision-making. The Philippines joined with troop contributors in calling for institutionalized coordination between troop-contributing countries and the Security Council by establishing ad hoc subsidiary organs of the Council.
United Nations peacekeeping was becoming more complex and hazardous, he said. Troop-contributing countries should not be treated merely as suppliers of military manpower, expected to obey mandates they had little or no control over. Troop contributors must contribute to decisions about mandates, resource requirements, and the upsizing or downsizing of troop levels. It was also becoming increasingly necessary for the Council to foster a more cooperative partnership with other United Nations organs, notably the General Assembly, as well as other international bodies, including the Bretton Woods institutions, for a comprehensive approach to conflict resolution and post-conflict peace-building and development.
HIRA BAHADUR THAPA (Nepal) said that United Nations peacekeeping had gone through considerable changes over the years. Many peacekeeping operations had taken on complex and comprehensive mandates, but it must be borne in mind that extensive peacekeeping operations, such as in Kosovo and East Timor, were launched on an exceptional basis only.
Regarding reform, he said the Secretary-General's proposal to set up a new unit for system-wide policy and analysis to improve coordination and information-sharing within the United Nations system needed further elaboration. Although some reform in the consultation process conducted by the United Nations Secretariat had occurred in recent months, there was still a need to strengthen cooperation between troop-contributing countries, the Secretariat and the Security Council. What was lacking was meaningful consultation, which would require the Secretariat to consult troop contributors on the parameters of rules of engagement.
The need for gender balance in United Nations peacekeeping was justified, but that must not lead to a lopsided picture between the developed and developing countries, he said. Also, since troop contributors put their soldiers in harm's way in difficult peacekeeping operations, they should obtain their due share of mission leadership posts, as well as various posts in the Department of Peacekeeping Operations.
MWELWA C. MUSAMBACHIME (Zambia) associated himself with the statement made previously for the Non-Aligned Movement. He underlined his delegation's support for mainstreaming a gender perspective in its activities, and asked for information on the achievements of the Gender Affairs Offices in the United Nations Mission in Sierra Leone (UNAMSIL) and the United Nations Organization Mission in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (MONUC). The activities of such offices must be coordinated by the Department. It was for that reason that his delegation had always asked and would continue to ask for the inclusion of gender experts in the Department.
The incorporation of demobilization, disarmament and reintegration (DDR) programmes in the very early stages was vital to the success of any peacekeeping operation, he said. To avoid sliding back into violence, effective reintegration programmes were required for disarmed and demobilized combatants. Ex-combatants must be reintegrated and gainfully employed to stop them from taking up arms.
His delegation remained concerned by the imbalance in the distribution of Professional posts in the Peacekeeping Department, he said. The distribution of Professional posts of Brahimi I had, to say the least, been very disappointing. Non-Aligned Movement countries had not been fooled by the attempt to hoodwink them by giving out a few posts. The fact was that the imbalance in the distribution of Professional posts remained. Measures to address the imbalance must be taken and they must be taken now.
He then said he wished to register a complaint. On 7 November 2001, a helicopter had crashed in Sierra Leone, killing all on board, including two Zambian lieutenant-colonels. A search and recovery operation had been mounted, which, unfortunately, had only yielded the main hull of the helicopter. While the operation had been called off on 30 November, the DPKO had taken two months to inform his delegation, thus, keeping the bereaved families and the nation in suspense. That kind of conduct was completely unacceptable, he said.
JOAN ELAINE THOMAS (Jamaica) said that while the Brahimi report on peace operations had provided a blueprint for the United Nations in achieving a more effective management of those operations, it was equally important that the international community should devote adequate attention and resources to conflict-prevention and peace-building measures, as those would, in the long run, serve to eliminate the very causes of conflict.
"Root causes such as poor governance, socio-economic degradation and underdevelopment must be sufficiently addressed, if we are serious about stemming the cycle of violence which contributes to and perpetuates conflict", she said.
She said Jamaica also fully supported the establishment of a rapid- deployment capability of the United Nations and the Secretary-General's proposal for the concept of a strategic reserve; the disarmament, demobilization and reintegration (DDR) of ex-combatants; and DPKO's efforts to mainstream a gender perspective into peacekeeping operations. "Jamaica has consistently advocated that DDR should be a pivotal part of a peacekeeping mandate, with adequate resources disbursed through the United Nations regular budget", she said. "We commend the efforts of the DPKO in developing a training curriculum on gender awareness and sensitivity for military and civilian police. We also reiterate our request for the appointment of gender experts in the DPKO at sufficiently senior levels."
WANG YINGFAN (China) said that whatever the task, sufficient material supplies constituted an important precondition for any action. The creation of a strategic deployment stock was among the important recommendations made in the Brahimi Panel report on strengthening the rapid-deployment capacity of peacekeeping operations. His delegation, therefore, looked forward to the early preparation of the Secretary-General's budget report. "At the same time, we believe that no matter what shape the final plan might take, it must follow the principle of living within our means, fully tapping the potential of existing mechanisms and optimizing the existing resources within the United Nations system to the maximum."
He said his delegation would continue to support DPKO reform, in an effort to improve the efficiency and quality of the Department's work. He pointed out that in the recruiting process of the first phase of the Department's reform, the Secretariat had not done enough in terms of transparency or observance of the principle of equitable geographic distribution. In the recruiting process in the future, the Secretariat should make an earnest effort to take into account the concerns of Member States which were either not represented or under-represented in relevant departments.
He said it was crucial to strengthen communication and coordination between the Security Council, troop-contributing countries and the Secretariat, and to pay more attention to the views of the troop-contributing countries and the parties concerned. A better United Nations Standby Arrangements System (UNSAS) was a critical link in efforts to strengthen the peacekeeping capacity of the United Nations. "We support the Secretariat in the efforts to adjust and improve UNSAS in accordance with the development of the situation and to enhance the rapid-deployment capacity of peacekeeping operations", he said. His Government had decided to upgrade its participation in UNSAS by sending non-combat trained units to take part in UNSAS. The fist batch would include one engineering unit, one medical unit, and two transport units.
NANA EFFAH-APENTENG (Ghana) said that launching troops in a new peacekeeping operation imposed financial strains on developing countries. Since the United Nations required troop-contributing countries to mobilize the necessary operational resources and also maintain them under the "wet-lease" system, it was becoming increasingly difficult for many States to respond positively to invitations to participate in new missions, which had become more complex and difficult. Also, the ability of Member States to contribute to standby arrangements by providing accurate information on their resource capacities depended entirely on national domestic exigencies. In order not to delay implementation of that concept, the Department should consider reviewing it, taking into account factors which had so far impeded the ability of Member States to cooperate in its early implementation.
He said there had been many debates on the enhancement of Africa's peacekeeping capacity. The importance of that issue could not be overemphasized, since peacekeeping remained a vital instrument by which the United Nations could help African States resolve conflicts and to create the conditions for peaceful development. In that regard, his delegation wished to recall that in 1998 the Department proposed the terms of reference for a working group to consider the implementation of various recommendations on the issue. At the Department's request, Africa submitted its comments on the proposals about two years ago. Not much work, however, had been done since then. "We hope that the Department's intentions to resume consultations on the issue as indicated in the Secretary-General's report (document A/56/732) would take place soon to enable the working group to be put in place before the next session of the Assembly."
As noted in the recent Security Council debate on Africa, he said what was lacking on the continent was the ability to deal with conflicts promptly and resolutely, and in such a manner that they did not obstruct social development. "The Secretariat must live up to its responsibility and ensure the early establishment of the working group", he urged. He said that the payment of death and disability claims to the estates of deceased peacekeeping personnel was another issue of concern to his delegation. His country's own assessment of the procedures involved showed unnecessary bureaucracy, especially regarding the processing of claims for compensation. That was an area where the United Nations searchlight for reforms in its audit, and accounting process must be cast if the anguish of bereaved dependants was to be reduced.
ABDULHAMID O. YAHYA (Libya) said the United Nations needed to be ready to address the ever-increasing crises in the world in an efficient and timely manner. That meant enhancing the capacity of its mechanisms to assist. His country supported the proposals to develop peacekeeping capacities and rapid-deployment mechanisms and enhance the logistics base.
He said Africa looked to the United Nations as the effective instrument to help countries find peace and security. It was, therefore, incumbent on the Organization to fulfil those responsibilities on the continent, take lessons from the debates taking place and address the conflicts in a practical manner. In that light, he hoped the recent debate in the Security Council on Africa, under the presidency of Mauritius, would lead to efficient and appropriate mechanisms.
He said the Security Council must shake itself loose from its reluctance to address certain situations and issues and start taking calculated risks. Without the political will to move forward in an expeditious and firm manner, there was a real danger of paralysis in the Council and in peacekeeping operations, he warned. He also called for more cooperation between the Department of Peacekeeping Operations, the Council, and regional and subregional operations.
ENRIQUE LOEDEL (Uruguay) said his country was the number one troop-contributing State in its region, which demonstrated its commitment to peacekeeping. That, coupled with 50 years of shouldering its peacekeeping responsibilities, qualified Uruguay to speak with authority on what needed to be done to improve peacekeeping operations. While his delegation valued the adjustment efforts so far to improve peacekeeping operations, it would also recommend a periodic review of the mechanisms in place due to the ever-changing nature of situations.
The dynamics of peacekeeping operations now required even more coordination, he said. That necessitated improving the existing machinery. His country had also demonstrated its ability to attune itself to new environments, and had supported the initiative to enhance the Organization's rapid-deployment capability. Such initiatives, however, must take into account the procedural and financial factors that also needed to be better handled.
He said a reserve financing fund would be useful to developing countries because it could advance funds to those States whose ability to contribute was hampered by budgetary and financial difficulties. Also, the issue of outstanding payments to troop-contributing countries for missions which had long ended was one that needed to be addressed more closely, so that it could be remedied and to ensure that there were no repeats or similar situations in the future.
VOLODYMYR G. KROKHMAL (Ukraine) said that time had come to exploit the progress made in improvement of consultation mechanisms between troop-contributing countries, the Security Council and the Secretariat. In that context, the Security Council Working Group on Peacekeeping Operations should continue the practice of meetings with the Special Committee to take advantage of the views of its membership on different aspects of peacekeeping.
He also reiterated the concerns raised by other delegations with regard to the safety and security of United Nations peacekeeping personnel, which remained one of the most acute problems in conducting United Nations peacekeeping operations. The medical problems of peacekeepers, in particular the issue of their pre-deployment immunizations, should draw more attention on the part of the Secretariat, he added.
Mr. Krokhmal also said his country was proposing that the International Day of Peacekeepers be observed annually, to pay tribute to all men and women who had served and continued to serve in peacekeeping operations under the United Nations flag, and to "honour the memory of those who lost their lives for the cause of peace".
ALEG IVANOU (Belarus) agreed that relations among the DPKO, troop-contributing countries and the Security Council must be enlarged. He had, therefore, been gratified to note the Council's approval of new approaches to such interaction, with regular meetings between the troop-contributing countries and the Council's Working Group on Peace Operations. He stressed the importance of the principle of strengthening the potential of operations, and expressed support for the creation of a roster of officers on standby and the establishment of a solid financial base, essential for rapid mission deployment.
He said his country had recently signed an agreement relative to its participation in the standby force and resource system. He added that Belarus was considering the creation of a national training centre for personnel earmarked for peacekeeping operations, and that he counted on the Department's cooperation, particularly in the structuring of curricula.
ZBIGNIEW PLUSKOTA (Poland) said his country was convinced that closer links between the troop-contributing countries and the Security Council would strengthen and accelerate the planning phase of new operations launched by the Department of Peacekeeping Operations. This would also allow the strengthening of the troop-contributing countries' influence on the Security Council decision-making process, and thus make it possible for their suggestions to be taken into account in much broader terms than was the case at present.
In that context, Poland welcomed the note by the President of the Security Council (S/2002/56, dated 14 January 2002) on the new cooperation mechanism of the joint meetings of the Security Council Working Group on Peacekeeping Operations and troop-contributing countries. Like other delegations which had taken a similar position on the issue, his country also "continuously supports the development of the Strategic Deployment Stocks (SDS)" and the reinforcement of the United Nations Logistics Base in Brindisi, Italy. Those initiatives should become an important tool at the disposal of the Department of Peacekeeping Operations in streamlining the launching and conducting of future peace missions, he stated.
He said Poland attached great importance to ensuring that crimes committed against the United Nations and associated personnel were not left unpunished, and reaffirmed his country's support for activities aimed at enhancing the safety and security of such staff through full observance of the Convention on the Safety of United Nations and Associated Personnel, which Poland ratified two years ago.
M. SEMAKULA KIWANUKA (Uganda) said his country continued to be disturbed by the failure of the Security Council to act decisively in the face of serious threats to peace, security and human lives, particularly in Africa. That reluctance to deploy sufficient peacekeeping operations to the continent, with the exception of Sierra Leone, was unacceptable. Sierra Leone, Ethiopia and Eritrea, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Afghanistan were fine examples of the Council showing determination and summoning the necessary will to act. Yet, when it came to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, where MONUC was entering its third phase of deployment, the issue seemed different.
To date, he continued, only 5,537 personnel had been authorized for the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The fact that the ceasefire still remained largely in force indicated how easy it might have been, if sufficient numbers had been deployed, to enable the Mission there to play a larger role in the political, humanitarian and human rights areas, as well as in child protection. That remained a missed opportunity and the question was: how long would that remain so? He said the examples he had made were intended to make one point. Having decided the mandate clearly, it was imperative that a credible force be authorized to support a peace process and peacekeeping operations. Those elements seemed to be lacking, however, when the Council was dealing with African peacekeeping.
While recognizing the increasing role of the civilian police components, and welcoming the current efforts by the Department to train personnel and enhance peacekeeping capacity in Africa, he stressed that more was needed. "We should create large pools from which local police can be recruited to participate in peacekeeping operations", he said. He emphasized that, prior to deployment, participants in peacekeeping operations should continue to be given specific training on local and cultural sensitivities, including gender issues.
MASOOD KHALID (Pakistan) noted that since the publication of the Brahimi report, the Special Committee had made considerable progress in improving backstopping and support for United Nations peacekeeping operations. He commended the DPKO for undertaking a comprehensive review and taking steps to improve its efficiency and efficacy.
He noted that, while the Secretariat had made an attempt to redress the imbalances in its recruitment, certain troop contributors had not been adequately accommodated. Many troop-contributing countries continued to remain severely under-represented at United Nations Headquarters. He also urged the Department to do more to improve the procedures related to speeding up reimbursements for both troop costs and contingent-owned equipment. Further, he pointed out that there was still a gap between the views of the Department and those of several Member States on the "on-call lists": that issue should be resolved, he said.
Pakistan had been a leading proponent of cooperation with troop-contributing countries, he said. His delegation had advocated a meaningful and effective triangular relationship between the Security Council, the Secretariat and the contributors. Unity of purpose among those parties must be assured. While much remained to be done in this regard, significant progress had been made.
Pakistan remained committed to peacekeeping operations, he said, not just as a contributor of troops, but also as a host of one of the oldest United Nations peacekeeping operations. Unfortunately, despite the continued presence of the United Nations Military Observer Group in India and Pakistan (UNMOGIP), peace in South Asia remained fragile. The root cause of the tensions was the unresolved Kashmir dispute. The international community must extend a helping hand to establish lasting peace, by enabling the people of Kashmir to exercise their right of self-determination as pledged to them by the Security Council.
AMRAIYA NAIDU (Fiji) said the distribution of personnel and posts in the DPKO and in field operations raised the bigger concern of equitable distribution of posts in and beyond the peacekeeping sector, in the wider United Nations system. Historically, the distribution formula was pegged to the level of contribution of Member States. While that criterion was good for its time, in the wider, progressive tide of reforms that the United Nations was embarking on, it was timely to appropriate that requirement more equitably and with forward-looking strategies. His delegation would welcome a report on that issue by the Office of Internal Oversight Services, quantifying the present level of distribution of posts and personnel. "In the long term, we envisage a policy that is qualitatively distributive and that will reap mutually reinforcing benefits for the United Nations and its Member States", he said.
Noting the call to Member States to improve their training standards in order to stay abreast of contemporary military peacekeeping needs, he said there seemed little point in training and developing leadership and managerial competencies of Special Representatives of the Secretary-General, their deputies and Force Commanders, since logically those competencies should, in fact, be merit indicators for appointments to those posts, rather than serve as indicators for needed training. Another concern of his delegation was the lack of commitment from the regular budget for gender mainstreaming, which although lauded as a critical cog in the process, was still subject to voluntary funding. Such a context would politicize gender mainstreaming, which would, in turn, recede into the background with its associated tasks earmarked for completion this year.
He said that the commitment of Council resolution 1325 was to shift from rhetoric to the effective involvement of women and gender concerns in peace and security issues. He would have appreciated a brief account of the tangible aspects of reform related to gender mainstreaming -- outside of training -- in human resources and the professionalization of peacekeeping. What was the result, if any, of a study by the Office of Internal Oversight Services on the subject? Was there a planned quota of posts to be held by women in Brahimi I and Brahimi II and in the rotation posts? "Our long-term planning in peacekeeping should not shy away from gender as it has done traditionally. Rather, it should openly court it as a way of reaching the needed critical masses for the shifting paradigms that the Brahimi report envisaged", he said.
JOHN DAUTH (Australia) said the challenges still facing United Nations peacekeeping efforts had a common element -– how to ensure that reforms genuinely optimized the capacity to plan, deploy, conduct and conclude peacekeeping operations. He said consolidation was a particularly useful idea at this stage of the Committee's work. Emphasis should be placed on implementing reforms already agreed upon, and allowing a period of evaluation and assessment. It was encouraging that many of the Brahimi recommendations had been or were being implemented. Lessons from the more successful peacekeeping operations, including the United Nations Transitional Administration for East Timor (UNTAET), were already being evaluated and incorporated, but it must be done in a more systematic and deliberate way. The Best Practices Unit was a critical element in accelerating the learning process.
Professionalization was also a key concept in this phase of peacekeeping reform, he said. In that regard, he strongly endorsed the Department's emphasis on training for military, police and civilian personnel. The training of peacekeeping personnel was critical to enhancing the overall effectiveness of peacekeeping operations, but it must be done in a cost-effective way.
He said rapid deployment remained a litmus test of the effectiveness of peacekeeping reform. Was the United Nations able to deploy peacekeeping operations in the 30/90-day framework recommended by the Brahimi panel? Several factors influenced the United Nations ability to meet those targets. Among those, the development of the strategic reserve at Brindisi was critical. Another area where further development was needed was that of civilian police –- in the peacekeeping context -- and of law enforcement and judicial institutions more generally. The Brahimi report's call in that regard for a "doctrinal shift" remained relevant.
FAWZI BIN ABDUL MAJEED SHOBOKSHI (Saudi Arabia) underlined his delegation's strong commitment to United Nations peacekeeping operations and paid tribute to peacekeepers around the world. He then associated himself with the statement made yesterday on behalf of the Non-Aligned Movement.
Continuing, he underlined the importance of adequate training for peacekeepers. Peacekeeping operations must have clear mandates. Adequate resources and political will were also essential. Operations must be undertaken in full compliance with the United Nations Charter. Respect for the sovereignty, integrity and independence of concerned States were crucial elements in the common effort to promote global peace and security. He appreciated efforts to enhance United Nations rapid-deployment capability and efforts made to improve the strategic reserve at Brindisi.
Meaningful consultation between Member States and the Secretariat were very important, he said. He supported strengthening the relationship of the United Nations with regional and subregional organizations.
TAEMYON KWON (Republic of Korea) said his delegation appreciated the Peacekeeping Department's recent efforts to establish a comprehensive mechanism to enable the first peacekeepers to arrive and effectively carry out their missions. He fully supported and recognized the need to give the Secretary-General pre-mandate commitment authority. In accordance with the United Nations Standby Arrangements System, his Government always maintained a well qualified battalion and other components as a standby force for peacekeeping operations.
He said he fully supported the Secretariat's proposal for a strategic deployment stock, since it would be an excellent way to enhance the rapid-deployment capabilities of equipment. He hoped that some diverging views over the desirable amount of material to be stocked could be reviewed soon by the Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions (ACABQ) in a professional manner.
On the issue of trilateral cooperation among troop-contributing countries, the Secretariat and the Security Council, he said he appreciated the Council's concern and attention to the voices of contributors, and its recent decision to establish a new mechanism for joint meetings of the Council Working Group on Peacekeeping Operations and troop contributors. Though there would be some complicated elements in implementing the new mechanism, his delegation hoped it could contribute to a much more meaningful dialogue.
KULKUMUT SINGHARA NA AYUDHAYA (Thailand) reiterated his delegation's strong commitment to United Nations peacekeeping. He appreciated the Peacekeeping Department's close cooperation and coordination and noted his country's intention to continue support for the post-independence United Nations role in East Timor.
Following the recommendations of the Brahimi report and those of the Special Committee, the Peacekeeping Department had undergone significant structural and management reform, he said. The task at hand was to consolidate what had been achieved thus far and further implement the recommendations and proposals for the enhancement of peacekeeping capacity development. The success of a peacekeeping mission rested on a number of variables. The ability to respond to a crisis rapidly and effectively was crucial among them. He, therefore, supported efforts aimed at enhancing the rapid and effective deployment capacity of the United Nations to achieve the goal of deploying operations within the 30/90-day time frame.
The mandates of peacekeeping operations must be implementable with clearly defined objectives and backed by secure funding, he said. For operations to be a success, the views of troop contributors must be taken into account by the Security Council in the early stages of mission planning and mandate making, as well as in the renewal and/or change of mandates. The issue of reimbursement of troop costs and contingent-owned equipment remained a concern to his delegation. Prolonged delays posed a severe strain for developing countries and might discourage them from contributing personnel in the future.
T.J.B. JOKONYA (Zimbabwe), speaking for the African Group, said the Group fully associated itself with the statement made earlier on behalf of the Non-Aligned Movement. The issue of cooperation with regional arrangements had been on the table for long enough and remained unresolved. The Group commended, however, the tremendous initiatives and efforts made thus far in the area of training, exchange of information, and the establishment of a United Nations office in the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS). Having submitted proposals on enhancing African peacekeeping capacity, he noted that two years had passed and the Secretariat was still to produce a draft text. That matter should be pursued with the urgency it deserved.
On the need for rapid deployment, he said material resource endowment was the key to any efforts to establish a structure and mechanism for enhancing Africa's peacekeeping capacity. Africa already had highly trained human resources. On standby arrangements, the Group felt that a review of the civilian standby status should be undertaken.
The question of reimbursements and claims delays in payments had shown a marked improvement, he said. That was highly commendable, and the Group encouraged that momentum to continue so that Africa could sustain its contributions towards peacekeeping operations. The need to help Africa financially and logistically could not be overemphasized, he added. The immediate introduction of the working group on enhancing the African peacekeeping capacity held the key to Africa's peacekeeping.
MEHMET KEMAL BOZAY (Turkey) said enhancement of the rapid-deployment capacity of the United Nations could only be realized by sufficient financial means. He, therefore, supported the concept of a strategic reserve at the Brindisi Logistics Base and hoped that the relevant United Nations bodies would proceed quickly on the budget proposals which should be submitted soon to the Secretariat.
He said the draft sample rules of engagement responded to the vital necessities of peacekeeping operations on the ground. He, therefore, looked forward to the circulation of the revised version of the document that had been referred to in the last report of the Secretary-General. Turkey also believed that the concept of the rapid deployment of civilian police elements in a mission was one of the critical aspects of peacekeeping operations, and closely followed efforts to create the civilian police "on-call list" recommended in the Brahimi report. He reiterated his country's support for the enhancement of the civilian police division in order to better cope with the civilian police aspect of complex peace missions.
He said his delegation shared the concerns expressed yesterday on the revisions of the mission subsistence allowance (MSA) rates. The specific conditions of each mission should be well examined in the assessment of those rates and it might be useful to ask troop contributors for their experiences while doing that assessment. Turkey also supported the ongoing work of the Secretariat in training, and had established in Ankara in 1998 a fully fledged training centre for the partnership for peace.
YAP ONG HENG (Singapore) called attention to practical problems relating to the on-call list, saying that many Member States had difficulty in nominating specific personnel for the various posts. In the interest of rapid deployment, it might be better for the Secretariat to consider other ways to achieve the same goals.
To ensure that personnel provided by Member States were up to the job, he said, Member States or DPKO-accredited peacekeeping training centres could conduct training based on a standard programme prepared by the Department. While it would be ideal for the prospective staff of a peacekeeping force headquarters to train together, it might be more realistic to conduct mission-specific training for the whole headquarters at the mission area itself.
He expressed the hope that the resulting upgrade of peacekeeping personnel and units of troop-contributing countries would not accentuate the trend of developing countries providing the troops to mission areas. Hopefully, regional arrangements or countries within a region would not be increasingly relied upon to conduct peacekeeping operations. It was untenable for some developed countries and regional arrangements to pick and choose the peacekeeping operations to which they would contribute troops. There should not be inequitable or uneven treatment for developed and developing regions.
Commending the flexibility displayed by the United Nations in establishing the missions in Kosovo and East Timor, he said an important aspect of that flexibility was the inclusion of functions that could, at first glance, be misconstrued as peace-building or nation-building. On the contrary, those functions were necessary for keeping the peace. In adapting a peacekeeping operation to a particular situation, the Security Council should factor into its decision-making the views of countries contributing troops to that mission.
VLADISLAV MLADENOVIĆ (Federal Republic of Yugoslavia) said, while there was no doubt that United Nations cooperation with troop-contributing countries was an important element of peacekeeping operations, one should not disregard the Organization's cooperation with host countries. The Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, as the host country to the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK) and Metohija, was very interested in that aspect of cooperation. To enhance ties with the Mission, his country had established a coordinating centre for Kosovo and Metohija, whose primary task was to work with UNMIK and the multinational stabilization force (KFOR) in solving questions of common interest.
He said cooperation between a peacekeeping mission and a host country should not be limited to specific questions on the unfolding of the mission alone; there were a series of other issues of broader significance in which such cooperation could be very useful. That was particularly relevant in the case of UNMIK and in the context of the efforts of the international community to combat terrorism, illicit trade in narcotics and small arms, as well as other forms of organized crime in the wider area of operation of the Mission.
He said that another important factor in relations with a host country, a factor which should contribute to better and more efficient functioning of a peacekeeping mission, was the institutionalization of cooperation through status-of-mission agreements. In such a way, many potential legal and other difficulties could be avoided. "We believe that this applies in the case of UNMIK as well", he added.
ALEXANDRU NICULESCU (Romania), endorsing yesterday's European Union statement, said the codification of United Nations civilian police procedures was important for the promotion of professionalism in civilian police operations. Romania hoped that the results of the Helsinki Conference on Experts for the Civilian Police Division would make a major contribution in that regard.
Supporting the strengthening of United Nations partnerships with regional and subregional arrangements, he said further steps were needed for a clearer identification of specific responsibilities in peace and security areas, including conflict prevention and peace-building. In the Balkans region, the growing cooperation between the United Nations and regional organizations had proved its relevance, while each organization fulfilled its own tasks.
Welcoming the progress made last year in reimbursing Member States for troop costs and contingent-owned equipment, he said his country expected further improvements in reducing the payment delays, especially for those missions closed a long time ago. Romania would support any Secretariat initiative to reduce as much as possible the delay in reimbursing troop-contributing States for contingent-owned equipment. Such efforts would ease the preparation and rapid deployment of forces required for new missions.
HASTINGS AMURANI-PHIRI (Malawi) said it could only be hoped that the Department of Peacekeeping Operations would seize the moment and maximize the benefits of its newly re-organized and better-resourced structure for the efficient implementation of its mandate. He also hoped that deliberate efforts would be made in future to reflect regional balance in recruiting for the Brahimi II posts. He said his country, within the constraints of its own resource limitation, would continue to support peacekeeping operations by providing military observers to the Democratic Republic of the Congo and civilian police to UNMIK.
While welcoming the new mechanism for cooperation between the Council and troop contributors, as well as with regional and subregional organizations, he said he hoped it would not just remain a commitment without concrete action. He also hoped that cooperation between the United Nations and organizations in Africa would be ongoing and that the United Nations would also focus its energies and primary responsibility on timely deployment, with or without regional or subregional efforts. Malawi welcomed the possibility of establishing a second logistics base in Africa. It also welcomed the mechanism to include comprehensive DDR of ex-combatants in all United Nations missions. That would assure the success of the peacekeeping operations and build a solid basis for post-conflict and peace-building programmes.
He said his delegation shared the concerns expressed by other delegates about the apparent double standards and selectivity by some Member States when it came to contributing troops to certain missions. The MONUC in the Democratic Republic of the Congo was a classic example of developed countries' reluctance to commit troops.
ADOLFO AGUILAR ZINSER (Mexico), associating himself with the Rio Group, said that among the guidelines guaranteeing the legitimacy and effectiveness of peacekeeping operations were consent of the parties; the primary responsibility of the United Nations for maintaining international peace and security; and precise and clear objectives.
Lasting peace could exist only through efforts based on an integral approach, addressing not only the political and military aspects, but also the underlying causes of conflict. That required joint action by a strategic alliance of United Nations agencies and organizations of the international community, including the Bretton Woods institutions.
He said his country would continue to support the joint meetings of the Security Council Working Group on Peacekeeping Operations and troop-contributing countries. Historically, Mexico had always contributed to peacekeeping operations, including through observers and civilian staff. On the basis of that experience, Mexico would intensify its commitment to United Nations peacekeeping.
PAK GIL YON (Democratic People's Republic of Korea) said that, as more than 50 years of history showed, United Nations activities in maintaining international peace and security had, in some cases, been abused to achieve military and political gain. That legacy remained to this day. The reality of the Korean peninsula represented one such example. During the Korean War, the United States forced the Council to adopt a resolution calling for mobilizing international armed forces and then established a "United Nations Command" at its disposal. No resolution ever adopted by the Council on the Korean War provided a legal basis for setting up the "United Nations Command". In other words, the Organization had nothing to do with that command and the "United Nations Forces" consisted of only United States troops wearing United Nations caps. That was a mockery of the Organization.
He said the United States troops in South Korea were, in fact, not defenders of peace but aggressive forces. They were the root cause of the division of Korea and all the misfortunes of the Korean people. His delegation expected that the United Nations Member States would no longer allow that continued abuse by the United States in the name of the Organization, and would direct due attention to bringing about the dissolution of the "United Nations Command". The atrocities of the United States troops were not only confined to the Korean peninsula. Those troops slaughtered innocent people in many other countries as well. The reason the United States persisted in opposition to the establishment of the International Criminal Court was related to its criminal acts in all parts of the world.
Notwithstanding, he continued, the United States was groundlessly linking those countries that went against its grain to terrorism, and openly flouting its dangerous attempts to stifle them by force of arms. What merited serious attention was that United States President George W. Bush, in a State of the Union address, had disclosed his reckless attempt to stifle the Democratic People's Republic of Korea by force. "We cannot but take a serious view of his dangerous remarks", he said. Peace could never be achieved by the efforts of one side only, nor was it for the benefit of only one side. The option to "strike", frequently advocated by the United States, was also not that country's monopoly.
He said the stand of his country's army towards aggressors was tough. The Army and the people of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea would never tolerate the United States' reckless attempt to stifle their country by force.
JOSÉ ANTONIO LINATI-BOSCH, Permanent Observer for the Sovereign Military Order of Malta, said that, while the promotion and protection of human rights was a primary responsibility of States, the international community must also assume its responsibilities in initiating peacekeeping and peace-enforcement operations to protect civilian populations.
On different occasions and in different circumstances, he said, the Order had stated its concern about lack of security for its doctors, rescue assistants and nurses. That lack of security had, in some cases, made it impossible for humanitarian aid to reach certain areas.
The Order's humanitarian personnel must be protected by the United Nations and be included in the framework of mandates for peacekeeping or peace-enforcement operations, he said. The Order's medical units, medical transport, medical personnel, medical missions, emblems and signs must also be protected.
LEUTLWETSE MMUALEFE (Botswana) assured the Secretariat that his country would continue to do all within its capacity to support the peacekeeping efforts of the Organization, and was ready to work out agreeable modalities for participation in the "on-call lists". He agreed that, with time, the Department should undertake regular self-evaluations and systematic reviews to see whether additional resources being provided by the Assembly were indeed having a tangible impact on the manner in which the United Nations executed its peacekeeping mandate.
He said confidence-building among populations affected by conflicts was a crucial factor in enhancing the credibility and effectiveness of peacekeeping missions. But it had to be undertaken in the most impartial and transparent manner, and in consultation with local populations. The concept of committing a small percentage of the mission's first budget to the direct custody of the mission head in order to fund "quick-impact projects" was a good step in that direction. He commended the application of that concept in the missions in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Ethiopia/Eritrea, and encouraged the Department to apply the practice elsewhere in the future.
Drawing lessons from past mistakes, he continued, could guarantee success for the future. The Organization had long recognized the important role of incorporating "lessons learnt" in the strategic planning process for its peacekeeping missions. "Unfortunately, as demonstrated by the well-known historic trail of terrible mishaps behind us, to date, our past is not serving us well", he said. System-wide information analysis of the lessons learnt was crucial for effective future planning. He encouraged the Department to take expeditious measures to make such analysis an integral aspect of their planning for all future peacekeeping missions. He also stressed that mainstreaming a gender perspective in "our human resources policies" was equally crucial. Peacekeeping was no exception. Botswana attached great importance to the empowerment of women, and it would like to see no effort spared in pursuing that goal.
Response of Under-Secretary-General
JEAN-MARIE GUÉHENNO, Under-Secretary-General for Peacekeeping Operations, said the Department would continue its efforts to enhance its communication and coordination with the troop-contributing countries. Assistant Secretary-General Michael Sheehan would be discussing strategic deployment stock and airlift capabilities with the Special Committee, and General Timothy Ford, the Military Adviser, would discuss standby arrangements.
Responding to issues raised by delegations, he said the Peacekeeping Department was in the process of establishing strategic airlift capacity in the form of Letters of Agreement from Member States that possessed such aircraft. That capability would be in the form of standby arrangements to be activated on an "as-required" basis, after confirmation from the industry that there was no cheaper alternative or quicker response in comparison to such arrangements. Regarding strategic sea-lift arrangements, he said, the Department was once again proposing a memorandum of understanding with the World Food Programme (WFP) which could respond quickly as necessary.
Responding to an issue raised by the representative of Jordan (on behalf of the Non-Aligned Movement) and the representative of Spain (on behalf of the European Union) on the draft sample Rules of Engagement, he said the document in question was a work in progress and would be subject to periodic review. The document reflected some 320 comments and proposals submitted by 24 Member States and the International Committee of the Red Cross. But the draft was a guide for planning and for assisting troop-contributing countries in training their troops for peacekeeping assignments. Some legal implications required study. The final result would always have to be tailored to the needs of each specific mission.
Regarding the rank of Commissioner of Civilian Police, he said the position of Chief, Civilian Police Division, had been upgraded as a direct result of the Special Committee's deliberations in the context of the Comprehensive Review and the role envisaged for the Police Commissioner. The post had been classified at the D-2 level, in line with organizational standards and bearing in mind the functions performed by, and the levels of, the existing staff in the division.
On safety and security of peacekeeping personnel, he said that with four additional posts now available under the Support Account, missions would benefit from the technical support of four, instead of two, United Nations Security Coordinator Operations Officers focused on security, once the vacancies were filled.
He expressed regrets to the Government of Zambia regarding a helicopter accident in Sierra Leone. The investigation was being conducted by the Government of Ukraine as the aircraft's country of registration. On the helicopter accident in Georgia, he said the technical investigation would be completed by the Ukraine Ministry of Transportation by the end of March 2002.
With respect to geographical representation in recruitment, he said the Department's obligation was to identify the best qualified candidate for the position concerned.
He assured delegates that no terrorist threats had been made against United Nations peacekeepers. However, in the wake of 11 September, field missions were reminded to be extra vigilant in complying with security measures and in updating security plans.


text:
Manafort and Cohen have left Trump at a precipice
CNN Opinion asked expert legal analysts and commentators to weigh in with their takeaways from the Paul Mana...
Updated: Aug 30, 2018 2:31 PM
CNN Opinion asked expert legal analysts and commentators to weigh in with their takeaways from the Paul Manafort verdict and the Michael Cohen saga: what it all means and what comes next. The views expressed in these commentaries are solely those of the authors.
Joey Jackson: Tuesday could mark the beginning of the end of Trump's presidency
Crime, law enforcement and corrections
Fraud and financial crimes
Taxes and taxation
Law and legal system
Russia meddling investigation
Court trials
Criminal defenses
Elections and campaigns
Guilty pleas
Misc people
Rick Gates
Trial and procedure
Criminal convictions
Elections (by type)
US Federal elections
Political scandals
US political parties
US Republican Party
Amnesty and pardons
Corrections system
Tuesday has been a huge day in the history of our country -- and it will certainly be remembered that way. The White House took two seismic hits that could bring down the President of the United States. Paul Manafort was found guilty of eight felonies by a jury of his peers in Virginia, while the President's long-time fixer, Michael Cohen, pleaded guilty to eight felony offenses, admitting he acted "in coordination and at the direction of a candidate for federal office." Make no mistake about it, he was talking about the now-President of the United States.
What does it say about the President? After all, aren't we judged by the company we keep?
Up until now, Republicans in Congress have had little appetite to seriously investigate Trump, much less utter the dreaded "I" word: impeachment. But Congress' blind support of the President could change drastically if proof is leaked, or otherwise surfaced by way of documentary evidence, that proves that Trump "coordinated and directed" Cohen to violate the law. Congress will then be seen as supporting an alleged criminal. And that can't be good politically -- especially in a midterm election year.
Meanwhile, Manafort's close association with Trump does not bode well for the President. The former head of the Trump campaign is now a convicted felon. Manafort's lies, misrepresentations, deceit and hubris landed him in this position. One can only wonder whether another bird with the same feathers will suffer a similar fate.
This leads to even more potentially bad news for the President. The upcoming midterm elections could very well change the dynamics of Congress by placing control in the hands of Democrats. Should this occur, the House will most assuredly go after the President and institute impeachment proceedings for "high crimes and misdemeanors." All it takes is a majority vote in the House to impeach. And if the Democrats have control, it would mean they have such a majority.
That would then kick the case over to the Senate for an Impeachment trial, in which 67 senators (or two-thirds), would be needed to convict Trump, thereby removing him from office. That's a heavy and unlikely lift indeed. But perhaps it will get much lighter if there is cold proof the President is an alleged criminal.
In that case, Republicans will have a hard time looking the other way.
Tuesday could mark the beginning of the end of Trump's presidency. A day that will go down in history indeed.
Joey Jackson is a criminal defense attorney and a legal analyst for CNN and HLN.
Caroline Polisi: Manafort's trial sheds light on Mueller's potential collusion case
The refrain from the White House over the course of Paul Manafort's bank- and tax-fraud trial -- the first in special counsel Robert Mueller's investigation -- is that the charges "have nothing to do" with the President or the Trump campaign. In fact, noting that some of the conduct charged stems back 12 years, the President tweeted, "These old charges have nothing to do with Collusion -- a Hoax!," an assertion meant to buttress his argument that the entire Russia investigation is a "witch hunt" (a phrase he has used so often, it's become something of a tagline).
And while it may be true that the charges faced by Manafort, Donald Trump's former campaign chairman, had relatively little to do with his time on the campaign, they allowed us to learn at least two important pieces of information that shed light into the opaque abyss that is Robert Mueller's potential case of "collusion."
1) Manafort was heavily in debt heading into his time working for the Trump campaign for free, the obvious implication of which is that he was hoping to leverage his position for his own economic benefit; and
2) He did take at least one definitive step toward using his position as a bargaining chip for his own personal benefit. As was revealed over the course of his trial, Manafort sought to offer a banker, from whom he'd been accused of fraudulently seeking loans, a role in the Trump administration. In the days after Trump's election, the bank began issuing loans to Manafort that would eventually total $16 million.
Manafort will likely be serving prison time for these crimes, and he faces yet another trial in September. We may learn even more clues about the larger Russia investigation in that trial, no matter how much the President cries "witch hunt."
Caroline Polisi is a federal and white collar criminal defense attorney in New York, a frequent CNN contributor and is of counsel at Pierce Bainbridge. Follow her on Twitter: @CarolinePolisi.
Julian Zelizer: Trump's alleged Teflon isn't quite so durable
The legal and the political stories about the Trump presidency are converging. The Cohen and Manafort developments on Tuesday highlight the kind of people who the President has surrounded himself with and -- in Cohen's case -- are willing to implicate Trump directly. While the outcome for President Donald Trump remains uncertain, the probable political costs to the GOP just went up significantly. Guilty pleas and guilty verdicts are not the stuff that great presidencies are made of. The "witch hunt" argument looks even less plausible than before, and an air of corruption surrounds the head of the GOP.
Most important, Republican candidates are campaigning in an environment with immense uncertainty about what comes next and with a President who is losing control of the narrative and his temper. At least on Tuesday, it appeared the President's alleged Teflon is not quite as durable as some believe.
Julian Zelizer is a history and public affairs professor at Princeton University, editor of "The Presidency of Barack Obama: A First Historical Assessment" and co-host of the "Politics & Polls" podcast. Follow him on Twitter: @julianzelizer.
Laura Coates: The prosecution would be wise not to get greedy
The people have spoken. And while it was not a total victory for the prosecution, it was a comprehensive defeat of the former chairman of Donald Trump's presidential campaign, Paul Manafort.
Tempting though it may be to retry a defendant on those charges on which the jury has hung, the prosecution would be wise to not get as greedy as they proved Manafort to be in a court of law. For the eight counts on which Manafort was convicted, he faces upwards of 80 years in prison, although the actual sentence is expected to be far less. Any additional convictions on the 10 unresolved counts could yield a sentence akin to a de facto life sentence.
If the prosecution is confident about these convictions surviving on appeal, retrying Manafort on the 10 remaining counts at the taxpayers' expense -- particularly with the upcoming trial on related charges in Washington -- might inadvertently bolster the President's claims the trial is about persecution rather than objective prosecution. Justice is, at times, a cost-benefit analysis.
One can't help but wonder, however, whether the President will honor the tempered verdict or thump the proverbial chest of his pardoning power and undermine his own executive branch's prosecutorial power. After all, we can't have a "good man" being treated worse than say, Al Capone.
Laura Coates is a CNN legal analyst. She is a former assistant US attorney for the District of Columbia and trial attorney in the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice. She is the host of the daily "Laura Coates Show" on SiriusXM. Follow her @thelauracoates.
Paul Callan: Manafort's only hope is a presidential pardon
Paul Manafort had a great team of lawyers who despite long odds and their client's ostrich coat held the Mueller team to only eight conviction counts in an 18 count indictment. The defense lawyers can rightfully claim a partial victory. As they presumably raise toasts to themselves, though, their 69-year-old client will put his prison jumpsuit back on and consume jailhouse food. He will then await his fate, and likely some entertaining and snappy remarks, from Judge T.S. Ellis when Ellis imposes a probable sentence of at least 10 years or more in prison.
While defense lawyers swap war stories about the trial, Manafort will also probably be thinking about his next trial, in Washington, where he may add another 10-20 years to his prison tally. Unless Manafort has some valuable anti-Trump information to trade for a get out of jail free card, his only hope is a presidential pardon.
He will, I imagine, be watching the President's Twitter feed carefully from now on. And fortunately, Manafort may soon also be able to discuss the nuanced subject of presidential pardons with a man who is unlikely to ever get one, Michael Cohen, Esq -- who will soon share Manafort's fate in a federal correctional facility.
Paul Callan is a CNN legal analyst, former New York homicide prosecutor, and media law professor.
Alice Stewart: I have stopped believing
It is not unlawful to lie to the media, but it is unscrupulous to lie to your supporters. Honorable people have given this President more than his fair share of mulligans with the assurance that unethical and unlawful behavior is a part of his past. Now, the "rigged witch hunt" and related corruption has appeared at the front door of the White House.
In the span of an afternoon, our family-values party has a President whose former, longtime personal attorney pleaded guilty to paying off a porn star and former Playboy playmate "at the direction of a candidate for federal office" and a former campaign chairman convicted of multiple fraud counts.
Rudy "truth isn't truth" Giuliani spins that there is "no allegation of any wrongdoing against the President." The truth is -- campaign finance violations are wrong. Paying off a porn star and a Playmate is wrong. Not being truthful about these payments is wrong.
In addition, Robert Mueller is not finished, and the truth of Russian collusion remains to be seen.
Amid the fraud fog, a crowd of enthusiastic supporters awaited their fearless leader in West Virginia on Tuesday night. The sound system may have sent the subliminal message: "Don't Stop Believing." But I have stopped believing.
Alice Stewart is a CNN political commentator and former communications director for Ted Cruz for President.
Page Pate: Manafort's guilty, but his fate is far from certain
The verdict was no surprise. The sentence may be.
One "guilty" verdict on bank fraud is enough to send Paul Manafort to prison for up to 30 years. And, in this case, the judge has the authority to sentence a defendant up to the maximum allowed by law.
But he doesn't have to. The crimes Manafort was convicted of Tuesday -- including tax fraud, bank fraud and hiding foreign bank accounts -- do not require a mandatory minimum amount of time in prison.
There are sentencing guidelines in the federal court that will recommend a lot of time in custody based on the amount of money involved in this case, but the judge doesn't have to follow those guidelines. Given the judge's sharp rebukes of the prosecution during the trial, it's certainly possible he will give Manafort a sentence much lighter than the guidelines suggest. He could conceivably even give him probation, although the government would likely appeal the sentence if he went that far.
The other possible outcome is that President Donald Trump issues a pardon for Manafort, even before the second trial starts. The promise of a pardon would virtually eliminate the chance Manafort tries to cut a deal now and cooperate against Trump, and it would be consistent with Trump's earlier comments about what a "good man" Manafort is and how "unfairly" he has been treated.
Manafort's guilty, but his fate is far from certain.
Page Pate, a CNN legal analyst, is a criminal defense and constitutional lawyer based in Atlanta. He is an adjunct professor of law at the University of Georgia, a founding member of the Georgia Innocence Project, a former board member of the Federal Defender Program in Atlanta and the former chairman of the criminal law section of the Atlanta Bar Association. Follow him on Twitter @pagepate.
Shan Wu: Winners and losers in Manafort trial
Mueller Prosecution Team: The Paul Manafort case was a must-win case for them, and they did manage to pull it off. Even though they failed to win a slam-dunk conviction on all 18 counts, they did enough to claim victory and performed well under enormous pressure without any leaks in their confidentiality and before a difficult judge.
Manafort Defense Team: From a defense lawyer's perspective this was a victory for a legal team that took on a case largely presumed at the outset to be an easy win for the prosecution. Instead, the defense gained credibility with the jury from day one and fought the Mueller team to a virtual tie, eight counts to 10. They kept on the good side of the judge and wisely rested their case without exposing their client to cross-examination.
The Jury: The jury worked through a complex and document-heavy case with remarkably sharp focus and smarts. They are a credit to the criminal justice system.
President Trump: Tuesday was a historically bad day for the President, as his former campaign manager and former personal lawyer, Michael Cohen, were convicted and pleaded guilty on the same afternoon. His claims of a so-called witch hunt will be undercut by the jury's reasoned and obviously impartial verdict against Manafort -- and Cohen's conviction exponentially increased his legal liabilities.
Judge T.S. Ellis: The judge repeatedly made the trial about himself rather than the case at hand -- and his rushed use of the so-called "dynamite charge" opens up potential issues that could put aspects of this verdict at risk on appeal.
Paul Manafort: Despite a strong showing from his defense team, at the end of the day Manafort is now a convicted felon on multiple counts. For him, jail time is very likely. It's a remarkably long fall from grace for a man who helped elect the President of the United States.
Rick Gates: Forced to admit in front of the world that he had an extramarital affair, stole from his mentor, and committed criminal fraud -- Gates' experience in this trial was a brutal one, especially for a once-successful political operative with a young family and now two felony convictions of his own. It remains to be seen whether the Mueller prosecutors will deem his cooperation worthy of a truly easy sentence, but whatever the sentence may be it cannot be substantively worse than the punishment he already has sustained.
Shan Wu is a former federal prosecutor who briefly represented Rick Gates. None of his opinions are based upon confidential or privileged information.
Trump doesn't rule out pardoning Manafort, Cohen
Trump tries to spin Cohen, Manafort filings
GOP leaders mostly silent on Cohen, Manafort
Mueller to drop Cohen, Manafort memos
What the Manafort and Cohen case results mean
Mueller opened the floodgates on Cohen and Manafort
Takeaways from the new Cohen and Manafort filings
GOP lawmakers try to distance Trump from Manafort and Cohen as Democrats pounce
12 not-dumb questions about what's next for Cohen, Manafort, Mueller and Trump

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


We can easily develop addictions or habits and other behaviours we do not like. They sneak up on us and take over. Now is your time to take back your personal control.
do you want to do it fast and effectively?
If you answered "Yes" to any of the above you could well be in the right place. I offer fast, effective addiction and bad habit treatment, that can just take a few visits to completely resolve your addiction problems. There is no one-size-fits all personality who becomes an addict.
You know it is the right time to quit YOUR ADDICTION regardless of what it is. Your old strategies for life have not worked well for you – time for some new ones.
The same as there is no one-size-fits all treatment for addiction. I can safely say that there is no one-size-fits all addiction therapist either. However; there are some ways of getting rid of addictions that are so much easier than others.
The same goes for addictions themselves – some are much easier to kick. Whatever your addiction or bad habit is, it takes courage and inner strength to face up to it and decide "No more". Once you have really changed your mind and genuinely mean to stop – YOU CAN DO IT! Don't give up because in the past you have tried, very bravely, on your own and failed before.
Please read the addictions I work and don't work with before calling me.
Recovery is usually a smooth journey, sometime little "hiccups" may happen. This is normal so is not a problem.
Let's look at Nicotine elimination, (stop smoking).
put an aversion in to stop you smoking again.
You know it is the right time to quit YOUR ADDICTION regardless of what it is. Use the Flourish Programme right now. Your old strategies for life have not worked well for you – time for some new ones.
change and call me. Read about the Flourish Programme™ and you will realise what a potent and powerful programme this is.
Come in for a totally free no obligation consultation to see if we can work together to take you to a speedy recovery from your addiction.
Please read the addictions I work and don't work with before emailing me.
You will connect to the real you – the person before the addiction took hold.
You will be able to remember the addiction but not have all that negative clutter associated with it.


text:
NYC Top Comedy Choices for February 2018: Last Updated Saturday 2/24/18
Need a book or screenplay? Hire me. Know someone else who does? Send them to me for a 10% referral fee covering the first year of payments. To learn about my writing/editing services, please visit BookProposal.net.
Please note that these listings are updated frequently. The best way to be instantly notified about new show postings is to subscribe to my BestNewYorkComedy.com blog and allow for email notifications, and/or to follow me on Twitter (@hybender) or Instagram (@hybenderny).
That said, my top NYC comedy recommendations for what's left of February 2018 include:
Saturday 2/24: A unique game show in which an oddball Internet video is screened, and then over a dozen contestants have three minutes to prepare a dance routine inspired by what everyone just experienced. It'll all be judged by Keisha Zollar (HBO's Divorce, Orange Is the New Black, MTV; writer for The Opposition with Jordan Klepper; ace improv trio Doppelganger, sketch group Astronomy Club) and more comics TBA and hosted by Deborah Lohse: Dancify That! (10:00 pm, $20, LES' Caveat at 21-A Clinton Street; take F/J/M/Z subway to Delancey Street/Essex Street) Saturday 2/24: Hosts Mitra Jouhari & Catherine Cohen "are gals who just don't get 'guy stuff.' They've invited comics to give them lectures on guy stuff so that they can finally fit in," with tonight's bearers of wisdom Josh Sharp & Aaron Jackson (Comedy Central's The Opposition), Kelsey Caine, Drew Anderson, Fareeha Khan, and Sandy Honig: It's a Guy Thing (8:00 pm, $8, Brooklyn's Union Hall at 702 Union Street; take R subway to Union Street)
Saturday 2/24: Sixteen comics—including John Reynolds, Connor O'Malley, Ana Fabrega, Matt Barats, and Gary Richardson—perform characters, songs, and a variety of other comedic bits: Yardsale Comedy Night (10:00 pm, $8, Brooklyn's Union Hall at 702 Union Street; take R subway to Union Street)
Saturday 2/24: PLEASE NOTE: This show has SOLD OUT. Comics and comedic storytellers Vanessa Golenia, Andrea Allan, Richard Cardillo, and David Drake join pioneering sketch comic and storyteller Kevin Allison (The State) to tell well-crafted tales of comedic adventure: Risk! (7:00 pm, $15, LES' Caveat at 21-A Clinton Street; take F/J/M/Z subway to Delancey Street/Essex Street)
Sunday 2/25: The Sklar Brothers and Dan Van Kirk perform and host other comics TBA perform improv and stand-up for this recording of their podcast: Dumb People Town (7:30 pm, $20, Brooklyn's The Bell House at 149 7th Street; take R subway to 9th Street or F/G to Fourth Avenue)
Monday 2/26: Brilliant improvisors stumble into theatre scenes of plays they've never seen—performed by superb Broadway, TV, and/or film stars—and make up their dialogue while the actors commit to staying in character and on book. The result is amazingly fun, hosted by actor/director Stephen Ruddy: Gravid Water (8:00 pm, $12, UCB Hell's Kitchen at 555 West 42nd Street)
Monday 2/26: Josh Gondelman (Emmy & Peabody Award-winning writer/producer for HBO's phenom Last Week Tonight with John Oliver; Conan O'Brien, The New Yorker; stand-up comedy album Physical Whisper), Josh Sharp (superb sketch writer/performer; CBS' Two Broke Girls, Comedy Central's The Opposition, IFC's How Shit Works, MTV; co-host of Cool Shit/Weird Shit), Nick Turner (Jimmy Fallon, Seth Meyers, Comedy Central Half Hour, VH1), Kenice Mobley, and more perform stand-up for this weekly Brooklyn show hosted by Jo Firestone (staff writer for Jimmy Fallon, co-author of #1 bestselling Punderdome: A Card Game for Pun Lovers), Aparna Nancherla (co-star of HBO's Crashing, Netflix's Master of None, and Comedy Central's Corporate), and Maeve Higgins (Maeve in America, co-host of Nat Geo's Star Talk): Butterboy with Jo, Aparna, and Maeve (8:00 pm, $10, Brooklyn's Littlefield at 635 Sackett Street; take R subway to Union Street)
Tuesday 2/27: Star Wars erotic fan fiction—e.g., Fifty Shades of Rey, a sexually intense retelling of Star Wars: A Force Awakens—is read with feeling by comics Lane Moore (HBO's Girls; host of Tinder Live; Sex & Relationship Editor of Cosmo; writer for The Onion, McSweeney's), Julia Johns (writer for MTV's Girl Code), and Jessie Bangarang Atkinson (host of Family Liquid Dinner, cast member of A Drinking Game NYC), plus "Force Off," a Star Wars-themed audience interactive game that awards prizes, all hosted by Rob Roan: Star Wars: An Erotic Live Reading (8:00 pm, $10, Brooklyn's Littlefield (635 Sackett Street; take R subway to Union Street)
Wednesday 2/28: Sad scientists Jo Firestone & Steven DeSiena host a throwback to grade school science fairs…but run by NYC comics. Walk the open exhibits from 7:00 to 8:15ish pm, where each participant is being tasked to prove a half-baked hypothesis of his or her choosing using disciplinary methods that might be true. There'll be poster boards, quirky dioramas, tri-fold cardboard, flasks, lab coats, and haphazard experiments. Then at 8:30 pm awards will be presented by scholars "who are maybe at the top of their respective fields. All this and much, much more, we bet:" The Educated Guess Science Fair (7:00 pm, $10, Brooklyn's Littlefield at 622 Degraw Street; take R subway to Union Street)
Wednesday 2/28: Tabitha Vidaurri (MTV, WFMU, Funny or Die), who has read every single one of Stephen King's 54 novels, hosts this monthly show devoted to the master of horror, with tonight's topic The Shining: The Stephen King and I (7:30 pm, $7, Astoria Queens' QED: A Place to Show & Tell at 27-16 23rd Avenue)
153 East 3rd Street; 99-seater; a top comedy venue that focuses more than sister theatre UCB Hell's Kitchen on stand-up and screenings, and on experimental shows taking big risks; shows free-$12
27-16 23rd Avenue in Astoria Queens; N/Q to Ditmars Boulevard; 40-seat theatre; shows free-$10
239 Third Avenue; recent competitor to Comedy Cellar; no drink min.—support this policy!
85 East 4th Street; strong weekend lineups; no cover using code HyReviews; 2-drink min.
The Standing Room
4738 Vernon Blvd., by #7 train; Queens LIC club; no drink min.—support this policy!
From legendary NYC comedy site Brooklyn Vegan: Thank God for Hy Bender's religiously updated show bible BestNewYorkComedy.com…It must be exhausting keeping that monster of a website alive. It is your daily comedy itinerary and it scares me how on top of his shit this guy is.
Please feel encouraged to reach out to tell me about comedy shows, submit material to my short story anthology Ghosts on Drugs, or for any other reason by emailing me at hy@hyreviews.com.
Leave a Comment »	| Best New York Live Comedy Shows	| Tagged: Butterboy, Dancify That!, Deborah Lohse, Jay Malsky, Jo Firestone, Keisha Zollar, Kevin Allison's Risk!, LES' Caveat, Live Comedy shows in NYC tonight, New York Comedy, NYC Comedy, NYC Improv, NYC Sketch, NYC Stand-Up, NYC Storytelling, Richie Moriarty, Stephen Ruddy's Gravid Water, The Stephen King and I: "The Shining"	| Permalink


Studio has own entrance and is separate from the main house. Studio has its own private bathroom with a shower, and laundry facilities, electric heat in the winter and air conditioning in the summer. Studio sits on 6 acres with nearby hiking trails or towns. Would be nice for the traveling contractor who needs a room for their current local job. Pet sitting service available upon request with a large fenced yard for them to play in.
I'm an Airbnb hostess myself, I work full time as an environmental technician at a manufacturing plant in Albany, Oregon, when I travel I enjoy sightseeing and visiting museums.


text:
Need for Speed: Underground 2
The next installment in the Need for Speed Underground series takes you to a free-roaming city comprised of five neighborhoods. As you explore the city, you'll encounter rival racers who will show you all the hot spots in underground racing. After each race, you can improve your car's performance with various upgrades, ranging from the gear ratio to the suspension. The game includes more than 30 tuner cars from a variety of manufacturers, such as Mitsubishi, Nissan, Toyota, and more. You can even challenge racers from around the world in the game's online mode.
EA Canada
PEGI Rating
CERO Rating
CERO B
Tom Salta
PC PlayStation 2 Xbox Nintendo Gameboy Advance Nintendo DS Mobile


Greenwich is my home borough, and it has been pretty much since I moved over here from Ireland 18 years ago! You'd think I'd be used to it by now but no, every time I walk through this town, the park and the grounds of the Old Royal Naval college (where I attended university!) I still have to pinch myself. So much history and so much beauty in such a small area.
So when clients get in touch and say they want a shoot here I am delighted! I'm even more delighted when they ask me to shoot their wedding. That's what Martin and Emily did, they got in touch to enquire about my wedding availability and booked a family session at the same time. They'll be getting married in St Alfedges Church and celebrating in the Cutty Sark afterwards, I cannot wait to capture their day.
For their family session we we met in town and had a wander. There are so many lovely photo opportunities in Greenwich. Although none of them as beautiful the family I'm shooting. For me it's all about them, I could be hooting anywhere, although as long I can create a space where the family are comfortable, relaxed and enjoying themselves, I'm happy! This way we get the photos that you can see throughout my website. Family photos full of joy, laughter, and emotional connections. The shots below are no different. I hope you enjoy them. If you like what you see and would like me top photograph your family this summer then please do get in touch, I'd love to hear from you. Oh and if you're getting married or know someone that's getting married to check out my wedding website .
So it's been a while since I blogged. Have you missed me? I've sure missed you! I'm hanging out on Instagram more and more these days and whilst that's lovely I seem to have neglected my website somewhat. If you don't already then do follow me as you're sure to get the most recent shots on there. Oh and Insta stories, I've been known to share a story or two.
Anyway, I headed to South West London last week to meet these gorgeous guys below. It was really lovely. The weather was shining, I had my Spotify playlist blaring and the windows were down as it was HOT HOT HOT. I bloody love the warm weather these days. I've even moved my editing station (my iMac and my slippers) into the living room so I can be close to the patio doors. It's a temporary set up but much needed having spent the winter editing in my windowless office. I don't know about you but working from home, on your own, in your pyjamas with no daylight is not conducive to feeling amazing! So with this temp move now I have to get dressed (my neighbours appreciate that part) and I get to look out into the lovely garden with the lovely daylight and the odd spot of sunshine. It's AMAZING!
I digress, so where was I? oh yes I'm driving in my car to meet this family. It was a very chilled, fun session with me pulling my best moves to get those smiles. It's a sight to behold, I've said this before I know but I don't think you understand what I have to go through. They put me through my paces, and that's just the Dads. On a serious note I am naturally carefree so it's actually pretty easy. This is one of the things that clients tell me in the very generous reviews they leave, apparently I put everyone at ease, do the best high pitched 'peek-a boo' and am pleased enough to have people laughing at me and not actually with me. Anything for the art darlings.
If you've read this far well done, I'm typing this quickly as my boys wrestle each other in and out of various rooms so I can't vouch for the sense it makes.
If you'd like to invite me to sing terribly at your children to make them laugh then go ahead and contact me using the form at the end of this page. If you need a bit more convincing then have a look at the other family sessions, check out my google reviews or even give me a call.
Say hello, don't be a stranger!


Notice the "malloc" size being allocated! I doubt any computer system has that much memory!
What is causing this problem, and how do I correct it?
Version 1.14 is quite old, so unfortunately it's difficult to say which bug is causing this error... I don't have a Snow Leopard running anywhere so I can't really debug it either.
and don't assume anything on my part as to how to do it/anything.
anymore information that could help you.
One potential reason for the crash is a compatibility issue with the graphics drivers.
You could try starting Doomsday with some custom options. I recall 1.14 still has the separate front-end app for configuration; there is a page for Developer options. You could try adding at least "-novsync -nofsaa -window -wh 1024 768".


Woman carrying her child in Moria camp, Greece.
I have worked for 14 years as a clinical psychiatrist in the Mental Health department of Trieste in Italy. I'm considered an expert on psychiatric emergencies and I work with people who have addiction and psychiatric comorbidities. I treat people who have been victims of human trafficking, I provide mental health support for refugees and people in prison, and advise on protection and social recovery programmes. Over the course of my career, I have gained significant clinical and professional experience in difficult contexts and crisis situations.
In all of my years of medical practice, I have never witnessed such overwhelming numbers of people suffering from serious mental health conditions, as I am witnessing now amongst refugees on the island of Lesbos. The vast majority of people I see are presenting with psychotic symptoms, suicidal thoughts – even attempts at suicide – and are confused. Many are unable to meet or perform even their most basic everyday functions, such as sleeping, eating well, maintaining personal hygiene, and communicating.
I have never witnessed such overwhelming numbers of people suffering from serious mental health conditions, as I am witnessing now amongst refugees on the island of Lesbos.
The asylum seekers include people who have been subjected to extreme forms of torture and violence, both in their countries of origin and during their journey. They have been severely traumatised, both mentally and physically. In their island prison on Lesbos, they are forced to live in a context that promotes frequent violence in all its forms – including sexual and gender-based violence that affects children and adults. This constant violence serves as a recurrent trigger for the development of severe psychiatric symptoms. The increase in the number of arrivals we're now seeing on the island, in combination with the disproportionately low departure rate to the mainland, is further exacerbating these conditions and contributes to the growing mental health burden of these people.
In their island prison on Lesbos, they are forced to live in a context that promotes frequent violence in all its forms – including sexual and gender-based violence that affects children and adults.
While these vulnerable people await the conclusion of their asylum application, it strikes me that the appalling living conditions and the exposure to constant violence, the lack of freedom and rights accorded to migrants, the severe deterioration of health and mental health, and the everyday stress and pressure placed on all inhabitants of the island, has caused Lesbos to resemble an old-fashioned mental asylum, not seen in parts of Europe since the mid-20th century.
Meanwhile, the tension and suffering among the citizens and employees working in local and governmental organisations is increasingly visible. Other NGOs with whom we collaborate are equally distressed and overwhelmed, which often causes them to suspend or reduce their activities, which further exacerbates this desperate situation.
I see my colleagues on the ground becoming exhausted with the burden of the number and severity of these cases, as well as trying to plug the gaps in the system.
Considering the outright violation of human rights and the grave medical and psychiatric needs we face every day, it is clear that Moria camp is in a state of emergency. It would be both unreasonable and unethical not to consider the situation as such and take decisive action immediately. Based on my long clinical experience and the analysis of this difficult context, I firmly believe that the current situation could drastically deteriorate even within the coming weeks, with an escalation of violence that would plunge the island into extreme chaos.


Any notion that Kalms, who has been Dixons chairman for more than 30 years, is sentimental about the retailer's diminishing presence on the high street was brusquely swept aside.
Sir Stanley's father, Charles Kalms, established his first Dixons photographic studio 70 years ago, but the group announced 106 high street store closures last month, in the face of dwindling margins and increasing out-of-town competition.
'I feel the closures are absolutely the right decision,' Kalms said.
'Everything is change, nothing is static. You have to be hard-nosed and restless.
'Everything we do has to be continually challenged and changed.