text:
This archive holds all posts form May 2015.
When Interest Convergence Derails: More Challenges to Affirmative Action
May 31, 2015 • Edna Chun • "model minority", academic, affirmative action, education, law, social justice, Supreme Court, systemic racism, white elites
Many of the facts surrounding the recent challenges to affirmative action are not well known to the general public. A "perfect storm" has brought into question the survival of even modest, race-sensitive, non-preferential admissions programs designed to enhance campus diversity in higher education. This storm has arisen from three major sources. First, the term "affirmative action" has caused a backlash in (especially white) public opinion against programs believed to unfairly disadvantage white Americans. Second, wealthy white entrepreneurs have recruited plaintiffs and actively sponsored legal challenges to both civil rights and affirmative action programs. And third, a conservative Supreme Court has decided to hear these cases, resulting in the elimination, revision, or curtailment of existing civil rights laws and race-sensitive admissions programs. Critics indicate that the determinations of Chief Justice John Roberts' conservative high court reflect a post-racial, color-blind perspective that contradict the continuing presence of race-based inequality in the United States. Roberts' view is summed up in the 2007 Parents Involved v. Seattle School District; Jefferson County Board of Education (127 S. Ct. 2738): "The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race."
As Alvin Evans and I share in our new book, Affirmative Action at a Crossroads: Fisher and Forward, deep ironies and contradictions characterize the Supreme Court's determinations in the civil rights arena and in the four major affirmative action-related lawsuits over the past thirty-five years. The Court has constricted and even reversed civil rights law on the premise that social conditions of inequality in America have, for the most part, been addressed with the conclusion that policies designed to level the higher educational playing field are both unfair and unnecessary.
Reinterpretation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment (1868) is at the center of the high court's determinations, moving from the original intent of the clause to protect the rights of minorities to an emphasis on the protection of all groups, including white Americans. For example, in the Fisher case, Justice Antonio Scalia voiced his incredulity over the argument that the Fourteenth Amendment protects minorities:
My goodness, I thought we've–we've held that the 14th Amendment protects all races. I mean, that was the argument in the early years, that it protected only — only the blacks. But I thought we rejected that. You–you say now that we have to proceed as though its purpose is not to protect whites, only to protect minorities?"
Legal scholar Derrick Bell's theory of interest convergence explains how affirmative action arose during the civil rights era as a response to the radical protests and converged with other interests that were differently motivated. The creation of contemporary affirmative action programs by President John F. Kennedy and his successor, President Lyndon B. Johnson in the midst of periods of extreme racial turbulence coincides with the development of race-conscious admissions policies by leading universities.
Ironically, the frontal attack on affirmative action in university admissions practices leading to an overall shift in public policy at the nation's leading universities has been led by a single individual, Edward Blum. Blum's one-person organization, the Project on Fair Representation, was founded in 2005 to challenge the Voting Rights Act (VRA). This effort paved the way for the Supreme Court's Shelby County v. Holder decision nullifying the requirement for nine states and some counties to obtain preclearance from the Department of Justice prior to changing voting requirements. A conservative entrepreneur without a law degree or scholarly background, Blum has recruited a network of top lawyers who often agree to offer their services at reduced rates.
In launching a sustained, legal assault on affirmative action, Blum recruited Abigail Fisher, the daughter of an old friend, to contest her denial of admission to the University of Texas at Austin based on a claim of reverse discrimination. The Court's ruling in the Fisher case established a much more stringent set of preconditions for consideration of race as one factor among many in a holistic admissions process. First, consideration of race and ethnicity as one factor among many in the individualized admissions review process cannot occur unless all race-neutral alternatives have been exhausted. Second, a reviewing court rather than the university becomes the arbiter of whether or not a university's use of race is necessary to achieve the educational benefits of diversity. Writing for the majority, Justice Kennedy emphasized that in reviewing the means to attain diversity, "the university receives no deference." Referring to the Court's decision in the 2003 Grutter v. Bollinger case at the University of Michigan, Kennedy added:
Grutter made it clear that it is for the Courts, not for university administrators, "to determine that the means chosen to accomplish the government's purpose are "specifically and narrowly framed to accomplish that purpose."
The Project on Fair Representation has continued its effort to recruit plaintiffs and filed suit against Harvard University and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The Harvard lawsuit takes a different tack by splintering minority interests and building on the white-created "model minority" myth. It focuses on admissions policies limiting the enrollment of qualified Asian-American applicants and argues that Harvard has held Asian American students to higher standards than other applicants. The suit against the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill challenges that flagship institution's own description in a friend-of-the-court brief in the Fisher case in which the university wrote of its current process to attain a higher level of black enrollment. Blum also says that he hopes to find applicants rejected from the University of Wisconsin, the University of Minnesota, and the University of Tennessee for future suits.
Edward Blum's most recent high-profile effort challenges the concept of one person one vote, that has led to the Supreme Court decision last week to hear Evenvel v. Abbott, a suit that contests the way state districts' lines are drawn in Texas. The case calls into question the Court's Reynolds v. Sims decision (1964) that draws district lines based on an areas's total population. Instead, Blum advocates the drawing of district lines based only on eligible voters, thereby eliminating children, illegal immigrants, non-citizen, and inmates, among others.
Yet as colleges and universities grapple with the Supreme Court's rigorous requirements surrounding race-sensitive admissions processes, one unforeseen benefit may be the attention that needs to be paid to clearly-articulated mission, vision and values statements. These statements now need to contextualize why diversity is a compelling interest for a given college or university campus. In sharing recommendations for practice at the conclusion of our book, we note the ongoing and unusual responsibility of educational institutions to ensure the talent of the nation's minority students is not wasted, but realized. The rich research literature on the educational benefits of diversity that has arisen in specific response to the recent affirmative action cases will assist institutions in the ongoing and persistent effort to open the doors of educational opportunity to America's diverse citizenry.
Still Not Doing the Right Thing: Black — Asian American Relations
May 25, 2015 • Nadia Kim • African Americans, Americans of color, Asian Americans, media, systemic racism, urban, urban revolts
Spike Lee himself might be surprised — saddened, perhaps — that the Black American-Asian American dilemma of '90s-era Brooklyn he portrayed in "Do the Right Thing" could be a scene playing out in Baltimore over a quarter of a century later. Recall that in the movie, after mostly black and brown Brooklynites burn down an Italian-American-owned pizzeria in response to the cops killing Radio Raheem, rioters approach a Korean green grocery and its owner, Sonny. He swings a broom to hold the crowd back, shouting in broken parlance, "I no White! I Black! You. Me. Same!"—upon which the rioters decide to spare his store.
But the iconic sixty-second scene does not show what the black and Latino rioters had been taught about Asian Americans like Sonny to make them target his store in the first place. Sadly, media portrayals have not come very far. Recent news reports about West Baltimore mute the same black-Asian history, and, unlike Spike Lee, paint the protestors as mostly hostile – and worse – racist. It's no wonder that people, from bloggers to Duke professors, recycle the same tired stereotypes of earnest Asian American innocents and "thuggish" black American rioters — the former often the victim of the latter. When the race relations stakes in our country couldn't be any higher, should the media be so retrograde?
Take NPR's story that black-Asian American tension was the real race story in West Baltimore. Although the report notes in passing that some Blacks stood in harm's way to protect Asian-owned stores, the only black voices we hear are from possibly two-faced patrons, from those who heartlessly taunt the Chinese American owner Tina Chen in her hollowed-out store—prompting her tears to fall, her voice to break –and those who feel that the anti-Asian arson was justifiable "payback" (even if not "reasonable"). Besides the fact that the overlay is too convenient and lopsided, these reports say nothing of the broader context – the racial history, the workings of elite power — that dangled in front of Blacks a "foreign model minority" myth about Asian Americans; that "they" aren't really Americans but their success all the same made a mockery of "your" black failure. That is, they owned farms and homes, had good jobs and kept them, stormed Harvard and Stanford, and could skate or play violin at a world-class level – what have you done lately? — you want to cry racism when even the foreigners can "out-American" you?
Of course, the white elites don't mention that this divide and conquer tactic was made possible by their own machinations of power: starting in the 1960s they drained the central cities of industry's unionized, high-paying jobs; put nothing in their place; gutted strong civil rights and anti-poverty programs that would've helped; then demonized the black and Latino residents for being jobless, working the "illegal" economy, or simply speaking truth to power. Hello, under-served and over-policed West Baltimore. To add insult to injury, elite institutions made sure to pit the black and brown poor against selective cohorts of college-educated Asian immigrants, many of whom began showing up in central cities as new business owners when US institutions wouldn't recognize their Asian credentials. To the black and brown residents, here was the "nemesis" filling in the nice shoes of the Italians and Jews before.
It's no wonder that Spike Lee's Brooklynites first thought of destroying Sonny's lifeline, and it's no wonder today that some of Baltimore's protestors actually lit the match.
To be sure, Jeff Yang's rebuke of the NPR report convincingly dispels the existence of widespread Asian-black tensions or the insinuation that they're central to the rioting. Alliances between black and Asian ethnics certainly exist. Korean-American grocer associations donate hundreds of thousands in college scholarships to black students; Korean church leaders organize and sponsor African American ministers' visits to heavily Christian Seoul; black Baltimoreans link arms and stop rioters from pillaging Asian-owned stores.
Yet, Yang's CNN piece also seems to paint too rosy a picture of black-Asian rapport. He could've excoriated an American economic, political, and cultural system that makes Asian model minorities the foil for the blame placed on Blacks for West Baltimore. He could've devoted more lines to the fact that even if black and Asian Americans did not create these racial messages, they at the same time cannot escape them. And such racial frames do prompt some Blacks to burn and loot Asian-owned establishments; they do raise Asian American merchants' suspicion and fear, and up goes the bullet-proof partition between them and their customers.
Make no mistake. Blacks and Asian ethnics do stereotype and mistreat one another. Yes, the two don't always do the right thing. But Blacks didn't write the laws that excluded Asian groups from the country or denied them citizenship because of how they looked – just as Asian Americans didn't start the housing segregation that's connected to today's urban black poverty, like in Sandtown.And they most certainly didn't make themselves into the caricatures we see in the news. Rather than turning black protestors into one-dimensional racists and Asian immigrants into hard-working victims, the news could start with the racial system that made both groups its victims. As Sonny would say, "You. Me. Same!"
The Problem with Saying ALL Lives Matter
May 20, 2015 • Shantel Buggs • police
Turin Carter he uncle of 19-year-old Tony Robinson, speaks to the media outside the home where his nephew was killed on March 9, 2015 in Madison, Wisconsin. Source: Scott Olson/Getty Images
"We don't want to stop at just "black lives matter" because all lives matter. To look at Tony and say that he's just black, based just off his appearance, is something we're basing legislation that is 150 years old almost now – less than that. I'm referring to Plessy v. Ferguson, okay. Terrell is a mixture of everything. You can't look at him and say he's black. He's black, white, he's a mixture of everything because we all have our own complex heritage." ~ Turin Carter, uncle of 19-year-old Tony Robinson, shot and killed by police
In the wake of a Mother's Day that seemed to weigh more heavily than those of past years, I found myself returning to comments made in March of this year. When I first read of Turin Carter's remarks on the fatal shooting of his nephew, Tony Terrell Robinson, Jr., I found myself equally saddened and frustrated. Yet, in the midst of my empathy, I found Carter's heart-wrenching admission that Tony was a "misfit" and that he "just wanted to be loved" to be troubling.
A family member holds a picture of Tony Robinson during a protest outside of the City Hall building on March 9, 2015 in Madison, Wisconsin. Credit: Scott Olson/Getty Images
Virtually all American blacks are considered to be of "mixed" descent due to rape during slavery and a long history of interracial relationships, but Carter's comments suggest that to talk about black lives mattering is to not be wholly inclusive of his nephew's life.
The narrative of mixed-race children who can find no place because they are so ambiguous perpetuates the stereotype of the "tragic mulatto" who can never find love. Alongside Robinson's "need to be loved," Carter repeatedly insists in his drafted statement – and in response to the questions that follow – that Tony is not "just" black. And yet, he describes Tony as one of several "black children" of a white mother. The emphasis on Tony's mixedness and how it caused him a particular kind of emotional duress – even while acknowledging that Tony was a "black child" – reifies Tony's differentness from other young black men who have been killed by police.
As Carter notes, "we don't want to stop at just black lives matter because all lives matter." As well-intentioned as I'm sure his comment was, it reinforces the "all lives matter" rebuttal that pushes back against the #blacklivesmatter movement and serves as a means of erasure. Insisting that "all" lives matter suggests that a focus on black lives – which are being disproportionately snuffed out – is not inclusive of the various ways that state-sanctioned violence impacts our society. The push for recognition of "all lives" implies a universality of experience, rooted in a universal humanism that is less anti-racist and more colorblind. To say that black lives matter is not to say that other lives do not.
Black Lives Matter protestors with sign (Source: Flickr/Gary Lauzon)
Carter also said that Tony's "racial ambiguity reinforces the fact that America's racial lines are completely and 100% blurred…We are all multiple races and we each have our own complex heritage. There's no way you can look at me, there's no way you can look at Tony or any of my nephews, and determine 100% what we are, in terms of our heritage and our ethnicity." Despite the assertion that America's racial lines are 100% blurred (not necessarily) and that Carter and his nephews can not be easily racially categorized (perhaps), these young men are viewed by the state as men of color, particularly ones who are deemed threatening and less innocent. Carter notes this himself when he refers to his nephews as "black children of a white mother." However, it is this emphasis on the "children of a white mother" that causes me concern. When multiracial families insist that racial lines are blurred, they are working to validate their own experiences. This is why many parents of mixed-race children insist that their children are "both" (see, for example, pieces by Jacobs and by Kich in Racially Mixed People in America; and, Rockemore, et al., in Mixed Messages).
By placing the focus on "a white mother grieving her child," we might think that it is white motherhood that is under attack rather than black and brown bodies.
The "he's not black, he's mixed" argument seems like it would be one that could work in the family's favor; by painting Tony Robinson as "a mixture of everything" and "not just black," Carter's comments assert a connection to whiteness as a strategy of redemption in the midst of media demonization. Though it can be argued that these comments also attempt to diminish the value of whiteness, this ignores how multiracialism has a history of complicity in anti-blackness (for more on this, see Sexton).
Andrea Irwin, the mother of Tony Robinson, fights back tears at a press conference held by the Tony's family near where he was shot following the Dane County District Attorney's announcement of no charges for the officer ( Source: Scott Olson /Getty)
By playing up Robinson's whiteness, his tragic mulatto-ness, the family's comments engage in distancing from blackness and, thus, from danger. To have the deservedly emotional white mother and white grandmother standing behind Carter as he makes his statement bolsters this whiteness and therefore, our need as Americans to be concerned with Robinson's death. The murder of a young black man – who was already a tragic tale due to being a racial "outcast" – is seemingly more tragic now that he has a white mother to grieve him. A problematic logic is further supported through Carter's comments on having "multiple races" and "complex heritage." To be "more than" implies colorblindness – that the issues of state violence and police brutality are beyond race.
So, it's not surprising that media outlets picked up on the "beyond race" thread in Carter's comments as it strengthens the colorblind logic that race "cannot be seen," promoting universal sameness. The "all lives matter" rebuttal relies on colorblind racism; to point out that race informs the disparities we see in police-related assaults is to "be" racist. Carter's statement that he and his nephews are beyond "just" black provides mainstream media with a post-racial soundbite that can be used to further undermine the insistence that black lives matter.
It is tragic that Andrea Irwin, Robinson's mother, was reminded that her son was viewed as black when the state exercised violence against him. I imagine her realization was akin to Jane Lazarre's realization that her whiteness would not protect her son from being strapped down to a hospital bed and treated as inherently dangerous. Though I had wondered if the family's assertion of Robinson's whiteness might lead to an indictment of the officer who killed him, as we have seen, that is not the case.
Not only was it ruled that Officer Kenny "legally" used deadly force, he was praised for his approach in the situation that ended in a 19 year-old black teen's death. As Carter insightfully states, his nephew's death "highlights a universal problem with law enforcement and how it's procedures have been carried out…specifically, as it pertains to the systematic targeting of young black males."
With no justice for Tony Robinson, it is my fear that no mother's grief – including Andrea Irwin's — transcends the deeply entrenched belief that black lives do not matter.
~ Shantel Gabrieal Buggs, is a PhD candidate in sociology at the University of Texas-Austin.
Fresh Off the Boat: The Asian American Race Conversation We Never Had
May 19, 2015 • Nadia Kim • Americans of color, Asian Americans, Asians, media, racism, stereotyping
Phew, it got renewed. Thank goodness Fresh Off the Boat, only the second Asian American sitcom in US television history, will live on. Why am I so relieved? I'm not Taiwanese American like the main character Eddie (I'm ethnically Korean), nor did I move from a gritty Chinatown to a well-heeled suburb. But I didn't have that much in common with Mr. Miyagi or Kumiko either, the Japanese-descent coach and paramour of Karate Kid Daniel LaRusso – but, boy, did I identify with both. The simple reason is that, despite some familiar stereotyping, I'd barely seen Asian folks, let alone human-like ones, until the Karate Kid franchise seared my preadolescent eyes. The sad truth is that I could say the same about Asian American family life almost 30 years later, that the trembling glee with which I watched and rewound Karate Kid post-homework matches the rush I feel today when I swipe my iPad for Fresh Off the Boat after a long day's work.
I'm relieved because nearly a decade after Karate Kid, the first Asian American network sitcom, Margaret Cho's All-American Girl (1994), was swiftly panned and canceled for failing to compel viewers like myself – effectively an Asian-faced blip on America's radar. I'm relieved because I'm with Eddie Huang, the brash chef and restaurateur whose memoir is the inspiration for Fresh Off the Boat, when he says about Asian Americans: "Culturally, we are in an ice age … We don't even have the wheel."
To trace the source of my anxiety and relief, we must ask, Why did it take nearly 70 years (a television ice age) to get Fresh Off the Boat, and why would a so-called successful minority agonize over its content and fate anyway? The answers aren't obvious because, frankly, America, we've never even had our conversation on race. Yes, we've seen the tragic limits of the race conversation for Black America. Need we say more than Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown, Eric Garner, Walter Scott, or Freddie Gray? But at least the conversation's not a mere idea frozen in time. Moreover, a tête-à-tête requires a back and forth, but on Asian ethnics we've mostly had America's monologue about a "model minority" who has done so well in life that racism's a non-issue. A model minority therefore gets no seat at the race relations table. Nor did Asian Americans get a spotlight in our more multicultural pop culture after the Civil Rights Movement.
Where did the model minority stereotype and its silencing, disappearing properties come from?: immigration laws that favored educated Asian professionals, academic writing ("model minority" was coined by a fellow sociologist–see Chou and Feagin for this and related issues), and a 1980s' conservative agenda to dispel the racism argument to gut civil rights enforcement, anti-poverty programs, and affirmative action. Asian American success, conservatives alleged, proved Blacks and Latinos could no longer cry foul. Still today, fact tanks like the Pew Research Center inadvertently bolster model minority myths with controversial reports declaring "The Rise of Asian Americans."
Make no mistake, there's a kernel of truth in the model minority stereotype, but it's a stereotype nonetheless. Asian Americans are a diverse, internally unequal group. Second, the model minority feeds and hides a more pernicious stereotype of the threatening "foreigner;" that is, it pats Asian Americans on the head for being a good kid "like us" but spurns her for being "the foreigner" who outsmarted teacher, then denies her the right to cry racism because, hey, look at all those rich and happy Asians.
Examples include the World War Two mass incarceration of 110,000 Japanese Americans despite the majority holding US citizenship and no evidence of any anti-US activity among this threatening "model minority." In 1980's Detroit, two laid-off White US auto workers saw a threatening, model Japan in Chinese American Vincent Chin, murdered him with a baseball bat, yet a night in jail they never spent. More recently, Bill Clinton's Chinagate scandal prompted the Democratic National Committee to wage a racial witch-hunt of sorts for "foreign" donors within its Asian American constituency. Examples of race-based nativism against other successful Americans abound: Kristi Yamaguchi, Michelle Kwan, Mirai Nagasu, Korean merchants in the LA unrest, Judge Lance Ito, South Asians since 9/11, Jeremy Lin.
Because the model minority myth implies that race doesn't matter for Asian Americans at the same time that it feeds stereotypes of threatening competitors, Asian Americans effectively live a paradox of being racially invisible and visible as "forever foreigners." Chef Huang claims the show completely ignored this struggle. But other millennials and this Gen X-er say yes and no. I was grateful to feel my youthful Karate Kid rush when I saw myself in Eddie, both invisible and clearly foreign at school and reliant on Black American hip hop for an Asian American voice. Dad Louis got my sympathy when he worried that he wasn't "American" enough for his chophouse, so hire a "White face" he did. When Jessica perceived their vandalized billboard as a "hate crime" against "sneaky Asians," I said, "Thank you! Finally!" To be sure, I cringed, at times, at Eddie's brothers for verging on model minority poster children and at Jessica for too much Tiger Mom foreignness and exoticism. But I'm now exhaling relief that I'll get to see more Asian American life on a box that had rarely shown it because we were a "model minority" of foreigners. So yes, this show is finally our wheel. But we shouldn't expect one wheel to go everywhere. Until the struggles and diversity of Asian America grab the spotlight, I take comfort in knowing that Fresh Off the Boat has helped start, and will continue, a conversation that America didn't know it was supposed to have. Let the ice thaw.
Nadia Y. Kim is a sociology professor at Loyola Marymount University and author of Imperial Citizens: Koreans and Race from Seoul to LA.
Study: Racial pride can help protect young Black and Latino men
May 19, 2015 • Megha Ramaswamy • youth
In the wake of the death of Trayvon Martin in 2012, President Obama launched an initiative called My Brother's Keeper to send the message the lives of young men of color matter.
One of the key ways to help Black and Latino young men thrive is through racial pride. This may sound counterintuitive in a world in which a majority of young people in a recent poll said they thought their generation was "post-racial." Our research with young men leaving jail and returning home suggests just the opposite, that embracing racial and ethnic pride can really matter in ways that can help these young men protect themselves.
Based on our research in New York City jails in the last 15 years, we've found that workshops that focus on "racial pride" – teaching about historical antecedents to contemporary movements like #Black Lives Matter – offers a powerful shield against the discriminatory policies that result in the mass incarceration of black and brown bodies.
What we, and a team of colleagues, offered was a 30-hour educational program that served as a bridge between the young men's time in jail and their return home. The eight sessions focused on a range of topics, including the political economy of the drug war, gender and sexual relationships, and a session on racial and ethnic pride called, "My people, my pride/ Mi gente, mi orgulla." Half of the 552 people in the 5-year study participated in the educational program, and the other half got the usual discharge plan from jail. The focus on these young men, in particular, was driven by the complex intersections of masculinity, race, criminal justice status, and health.
The idea for an intersectional approach to this work came from previous research with young women. Researchers Gina Wingood and Ralph DiClemente (Emory University) began doing similar work with young African American girls. In workshops designed to reduce their risk of HIV/STDs, instead of focusing exclusively on the biology of disease transmission, they included material on black feminist heroines, like Sojourner Truth and Ida B. Wells. Their results were promising. They found a significant drop in risk for young girls who participated in the workshops versus those who did not. And, they made a compelling case for interventions that explicitly took gender and power into account. We wanted to replicate their work with young men who had been unlucky enough to land in jail at Rikers Island.
Our results were similar. When we followed up with the young men in our study a year later, we found that those who had participated in the educational program spent fewer days in jail compared with those who didn't. We also found that they had fewer problems with drug dependence. When the young men had higher levels of racial pride at the time of their incarceration, they were significantly less likely to be reincarcerated or be engaged in illegal activities even up to one year after release from jail compared to men with lower levels of racial pride. The same young men were less likely to endorse violence to resolve conflict.
Other research with young people who haven't been caught up in the legal system confirms the importance of racial pride as a protective factor against discrimination. Survey research of 630 mixed-gender adolescents from middle class backgrounds in 2013 by Ming-Te Wang (University of Pittsburgh) and James P. Huguley (Harvard University) found racial pride to be the single most important factor in guarding against racial discrimination, and discovered it had a direct impact on the students' grades, future goals, and cognitive engagement.
While we know that racial pride can be transformative, we also recognize its limitations. Racial pride is still no guarantee against death at the hands of the state or others, and the young men we worked with know this. When we piloted the workshop on ethnic pride, we showed the men photographs of civil rights leaders – Che Guevara, Malcolm X, Martin Luther King – and asked the young men what they thought when they saw these images. One telling response to the images: "These guys are cool, but they're all dead." This observation aside, most of the young men we encountered in jail had heard little in their traditional educational programs about what might make them proud of being African American or Latino, outside of limited "Black History Month" or "Hispanic Heritage" events. The young people we've met in jail are eager to learn about their history and taking pride in it made a difference for their lives.
It has been heartening, against a backdrop of police-perpetrated racialized violence in the U.S., to watch young people take to the streets to let their voices be heard and join social movements that challenge this type of violence. There is some evidence that lawmakers, prosecutors, and even President Obama continue to listen. We know that racial pride can be a source of strength and resilience but the true test is whether society can support such resilience.
~ Megha Ramaswamy and Jessie Daniels
~ This post originally appeared on the LSE blog on American on Politics and Policy and is based on the paper 'The Association of Ethnic Pride With Health and Social Outcomes Among Young Black and Latino Men After Release From Jail', in Youth & Society.
Dominican mob violence against Haitians
May 18, 2015 • Ana • Afro-Latino/a, Caribbean, colorism, discrimination, Dominicans, Haitians, white racial frame
Haitian communities have fallen victim of racist mob attacks in different localities of the Dominican Republic the last few years. Just this last April, in a small town named La Ortega, located in the Spaillat province a mob attacked households inhabited by Haitians, forcibly evicted household members, and destroyed and burned their personal belongings. The assault resulted in the violent expulsion of more than 300 Haitians from the area. In another incident, this past February, the police found the body of a young man named Claude Jean Henry hanging from a tree in a public Park in Santiago de los Caballeros. Claude Jean was beaten to death, and his hands and foot tied before being hanged in one of the park's trees. Another hate crime victim was Coito Pierre who was lynched by a mob in November of 2013 in the province of Bahoruco. Spectacular violence accompanied the lynching of 76 years old Vitelio Charles and Olani Pie of 42 in Hatillo Palma, Montecristi in June 2005. Charles and Pie were hacked to death while other four were seriously injured. These violent events only represent a few of the most publicized cases. News of mob violence perpetrated against a Haitian in circumstance X or Y is not an uncommon subject in Dominican media anymore.
These episodes of violence share certain traits. One is the sense of justice that perpetrators seem to find in the acts of violence they carry out against Haitians. In fact, in almost all these cases the victimized Haitians were targeted because the persecuting individuals and/or mobs assumed the victims' culpability in connection to a known crime committed against a Dominican, be it robbery, rape, homicide or other crime. The explicit justifications/ rationalizations given for committing these atrocious acts reflect the assumption by perpetrators that the targeted Haitians had committed a crime [against a Dominican] and that therefore, they needed to be publicly punished. Perpetrators seem to see mob justice as necessary in the light of perceived incompetency by local authorities. They see authorities as being unable and unwilling to administer justice against the assumedly guilty and protected Haitians. Another noticeable commonality is the context of poverty and marginalization that surrounds the victims and the perpetrators. In fact, all the reported cases involve individuals from poor backgrounds and poor geographical and social spaces. This characteristic is not to be overlooked or downplayed in this context. This is specially the case because it has been assumed among many observers and also documented in specific research that there are less antagonistic interactions between Haitians and Dominicans in lower class contexts. The question that follows is, whether the less antagonistic nature of these interactions and relationships are changing in specific spaces and contexts and how and why?
It is noteworthy that just like in the case of lynching in U.S. history, the violent acts follow the logic of arbitrariness, and in several occasions it has been found that the victims actually had little to do with the crimes they are suspected of committing. Dark skin Dominicans have also paid a price as some have been confused for a Haitian in the middle of the chaos and consequently treated with deadly violence. It is also worth mentioning one incident that occurred on the other side of the border at the end of 2014. On December 1st Dominican diplomats were forced to leave Haiti when rallying Haitian crowds attacked the Dominican consulate with thrown stones and glass bottles. According to reports, the crowds wanted to make a statement and sought justice for a six year old Haitian girl who was killed in an accident by a Dominican truck driver. The rallying mobs seem to have tried to administer justice in the light of the perceived imminent impunity awaiting the case of the killed Haitian child. Moreover, on Haitian soil, in organized rallies, Haitian citizens have urged foreign nationals not to travel to the Dominican Republic in an attempt to boycott the Dominican tourist industry. Organized protests by Haitian and Haitian-Dominican organizations and their allies have denounced lynching locally and transnationally, pointing the finger at the racist character of Dominican society. The Dominican media also have reported on instances of Dominican flag burning protests carried out by Haitian crowds. In contrast, different organizations have organized and carried out a number of events that emphasize cooperation and solidarity between the two nations.
The violence seems to have renewed tensions in the historically complex relations between Haiti and the Dominican Republic. Several Dominican public figures and intellectuals have called for a sensible approach to the situation and for putting a stop to the hate speech promoted by ardent Dominican nationalists. Many fear that politicians on both sides of the border will exploit these tensions politically in the context of the municipal, legislative and presidential elections taking place in Haiti in late 2015 as well as the Dominican presidential elections scheduled for May 2016. One feared outcome among cautious Dominican observers is that the current climate of heightened intolerant and racist discourse directed at Haitian immigrants and their descendants may lead to unspeakable and widespread anti-Haitian violence of unpredictable consequences for the Dominican nation.
A careful look at the discourses being deployed by Dominican nationalists reveals an identifiable anti-Haitian discursive frame filled with hatred and intolerance. First and foremost, the nationalist discourse frames Haitian immigration as a perpetual social problem in need of immediate fixing while representing the Haitian presence in the country as an unacceptable and menacing fact. It denounces the perceived Haitian penetration of Dominican society or the so-called "haitianization," representing Haitian citizens as entitled and ungrateful, and at the same time more taken care of than Dominicans in their own soil. The narrative also emphasizes the dangers of the project of unification of the island, which accordingly is a project historically sought out by Haitian authorities and strongly sponsored by the allegedly pro-Haitian US, Canada and the European Union. In addition, the narrative demonizes those who publicly criticize the nationalist discourse; the narrative represents critics as unpatriotic and traitors, and often suggest in humorous/sarcastic way that critics should move to Haiti and bring with them all Haitians living in the Dominican Republic. The nationalist narrative also denounces a perceived impartiality by local and Haitian critics and by international NGOs. Accordingly, these social agents accuse "patriotic" Dominicans of racism in their anti-Haitian migration and anti-Haitian naturalization stance while allegedly ignoring the hatred that Haitians feel towards Dominicans and the exploitation of Haitians by their own government and compatriots in their own country. This discourse, however, is said to be patriotic, not racist since it purportedly is being deployed 1) to defend Dominican territoriality, institutionalism, and sovereignty and 2) to defend the Dominican economy and the country's future from Haiti, Haitians and the biased international community.
Joe Feagin's concept of the dominant racial frame helps us think about the functioning of such a racist discourse. The concept of racial frame refers to dominant cognitive, cultural and epistemological framing that endow racialized systems of oppression with basic legitimizing meaning systems which then facilitate system's consolidation and reproduction. According to Feagin, this commonplace racial frame consists of a combination of mechanisms and resources such as racial stereotypes, metaphors and interpretive concepts, emotions/feelings, images and proclivities to discriminatory actions. Putting everything together, the operating racial frames along with the established racial hierarchies and material domination associated with them constitute a system of racial oppression that Feagin (2006) and his colleagues call systemic racism. The anti-Haitian discourse is thus a constitutive aspect of the systemic racism around which different Dominican social fields operate. Bonilla Silva's concept of racialized social system direct us to connect the anti-Haitian racial frame to the stabilization of the category "Haitian" and the significance of this category for the arrangement of political, social and economic stratification and the attached material interests that accompany them. Bonilla Silva's insights also direct us to interpret the nationalist discourse as a form of socially acquired "racial grammar" or racial signpost that orient how Dominicans think and feel about Haiti and Haitians and about themselves. That racial framing of Haitians as inferior is extensive, as we see in Table 1.
Table 1. Anatomy of the Anti-Haitian Racial Frame (And Anti-Haitian Racial Grammar)
Note: Paralleling the dimensions suggested by Feagin, these include racial stereotypes of Haitians (cognitive aspect); Metaphors and interpretative concepts regarding Haitians and Haitian migration and settlement in the Dominican Republic (deeper cognitive aspect); Images of Haitians (the visual aspect); Emotions (feelings); and Inclinations to discriminate.
Haitians are stereotyoped as:
Uneducated
Untrustworthy
Indigent
Powerful through the mastery of diabolic voodoo
Narratives, metaphors, interpretations of Haitians
Penetrating the Dominican nation
Steeling Dominican jobs
Taking up Dominican spaces
Using up the limited amount of economic resources that the Dominican Republic has
Striving for the unification of the island
Gaining undeserved rights and privileges
Feeling hatred towards Dominicans
Protected by local authorities
Enjoying the support and empathy of the international community
Images of Haitians
Haitian women giving birth at public hospitals, signifying population growth and exploitation of resources
Haitian women and their children selling products on the streets, signifying population explosion and backwardness
Haitians practicing voodoo
Haitians crossing the border
Haitian students sitting in university classrooms
The dark Haitian body (ies) , especially the bodies of pregnant and/or birthing Haitian woman
The sounds of Haitian Creole language
The colors and styles of Haitian clothing
The smell and texture of Haitian food
Emotions of framing of Haitians
Need to distance oneself from Haitians
Inclinations to Discriminate Against Haitians
Criminal Justice system
Everyday interaction
A favorable climate for the nationalist discourse emerged when in September 2013 the Dominican Constitutional Court promulgated La Sentencia (168-13), which retroactively stripped away the citizenship of foreigners, most of whom are Haitian-Dominicans born in the Dominican Republic from Haitian immigrant parents. Under international and internal pressures, on May 23, 2014, the Court adopted the corrective naturalization law 169-14 (Ley de Régimen Especial y Naturalización 169-14) which among other things sets in motion El Plan de Regularización (Regularization Plan) that will allow undocumented immigrants to regularize (and clarify) their status. Applicants have until June 17th, 2015 to apply for legal residency. Those who are not able to do so will be sent back to Haiti. About 170,000 had applied for regularization as of February of 2015, just a few months before the deadline. Dozens of organizations representing Haitians and Haitian-Dominicans are urging for a deadline extension as many of the undocumented lack the personal documents required to be able to initiate the process. Some of these groups have criticized the Haitian Embassy for being too slow in assisting their Haitian citizens in this process. This weak response by the Haitian embassy complicates the process inasmuch as many potential applicants cannot provide the necessary evidence of their personal identity to even begin the application process. Within this context, defenders of La Sentencia have denounced a perceived foreign influence on Dominican affairs and have identified this influence as the real cause behind the promulgation of corrective naturalization law 169-14. For La Sentencia defenders, the law 169-14 is a foreign imposition and provides evidence of a lacerated Dominican sovereignty and of Haitian intrusion.
Why have the anti-Haitian mob attacks apparently become more common /visible the last few years? Why La Sentencia (168-13)? Are these events related and how? And how can anti-Haitian and anti-black ideology and practice be so systematically consequential in an Afro-Caribbean nation such as the Dominican Republic? The answers to these questions are complex and require a lot of contextualization as well as much more attention than the one that can be given in this short piece. Many of the issues raised so far are actually very familiar to those with knowledge of the Dominican and Haitian contexts. It is important to note, however, that the latter question puzzles many and often gets resolved with claims of exceptionalism, including the notion that Dominican racism is a sort of incomparable hyper-racism; an extreme form of racism accompanied by an ideology of national identity that's based on delusional anti-blackness and even unhinged (quasi comical) Hispanophilia. As if the real issue was that Dominicans wore the whitest possible masks or represented the most sui generis example of wretched post-colonial peoples (Frantz Fanon references, intended). The works of scholars in the Dominican Republic, the United States and elsewhere have helped expand our understanding of this complex subject and have opened new avenues of inquiry and empirical research through nuanced theoretical and methodological approaches. This research has established the significance of history in understanding the past and present status of the relationship between the two counties and the origins of the systemic racism that Haitians and their descendants face in the Dominican Republic. This research has also established the significant role played by racist Dominican elites in specific historical, political and economic contexts, the legacy of Trujillo-era Hispanophile historiography, the ideological and cultural significance of the Haitian-Dominican border, the social and symbolic boundaries drawn around Haitians in all social fields, the past and present role of exploited Haitian labor in the Dominican economy, the role of race in the processes of nation building, and the legacies of key historical events, such as the Haitian occupation (1822-1844), the War of Restoration (1963-1865), the 1937 Massacre, and the first American Occupation (1916-1924). Most recent works force us to see the consolidation of antiblack and anti-Haitianism as a process with simultaneous connections to space, population movement, gender, social policy, and politics.
Furthermore, the promising and controversial features of globalization have manifested themselves in contemporary Dominican life and have likely added new complexities to these issues. Some of these features have included both periods of economic growth and decline, higher median income, higher purchasing power, and growing global identity and consciousness as well as growing urban poverty and inequality, transnational crime, dependence on tourism and weaken institutions. A report by UN-Habitat showed that only Colombia, Paraguay, Costa Rica, Ecuador and Bolivia exhibit higher rates of unequal income distribution in the region. Problems with the rule of law and accountability continued to create difficulties for the economy and national development. The Fund for Peace named the Dominican Republic in the list of countries under "Alert" in their 2012 Failed States Index report. The country has not fared well in these reports the last few years. The country looks even worse in the 2012 report on corruption by Transparency International. The country falls into the category of nations plagued by "rampant corruption" as judged by international organizations, business agents, and academics.68 The Dominican Republic got a score of 32 and was listed 118 among hundreds of countries. These reports have been discussed with concern on radio and television by public intellectuals and news commentators. Criminality has gone up and public safety has deteriorated the last years. The homicide rate was 13 in 100,000 in 1994–1995 (Cabral Ramírez and Brea De Cabral 2012; see Note 1) and reached 25 in 2005. It has remained in the low- to mid-twenties since 2008 (Artiles 2009; See Note 2). In 2005, Dominicans chose violent crime as the second most important national problem after unemployment. Forty-six percent of homicide victims are between eleven and thirty years of age. The youth are overrepresented among perpetrators as well. Dominicans' fear of being the victim of a violent crime is among the highest in the Americans (Artiles 2009). Concerns over police brutality and violation of human rights have also increased within this context. In 2011 and 2012 pronouncements, Amnesty International denounced the use of torture, arbitrary imprisonment, disappearances, killing, and lack of investigation and due process on part of the police in their treatment of suspects. A study by the National Commission of Human Rights indicates that 4,060 Dominican citizens have died in shootouts with the police from 1997 through August 2012. About 1,300 of them died between 2008 and 2010. There is also public concern regarding the increased national presence of international drug trafficking networks which occurs in the context a weak judiciary and growing police and government corruption. According to LAPOP 2012, about 45 percent of Dominicans justify a government takeover by the military in order to confront crime delinquency. The number is 46 percent when corruption is the problem to be confronted. In sum, social vulnerabilities, crime, corruption, public insecurity have grown in the Dominican Republic. In this context, politicians and regular people blame Haitians for a wide range of problems facing the county, similar to the way that Mexicans get blamed for lower wages and other problems in the United States. The Dominican elites are anti-Haitian, including the hierarchy of the Catholic Church, and the nationalist anti-Haitian discourse is increasingly visible in the media. Poor Haitians can be targeted for abuse (including lynching) with little or no sure repercussion for the perpetrators (which happens to poor Dominicans who are the victims of crime as well).
This piece argues that although the complex history of the relationship between Haiti and the Dominican Republic should be known more attention needs to be given to the ongoing structures and dynamics that keep the negative historical legacies alive, and that intersect with contemporary discriminatory processes and events such as lynching. There are aspects of the theory of systemic racism that provide a fitting framework for understanding anti-Haitianism in the current Dominican context. This framework directs us to address not only the historical but also the institutional, interactional and ideological dimensions that are integral to the long-term domination of poor Haitians in the Dominican Republic. As suggested earlier, anti-Haitianism should be analyzed as a form of systemic racism, that is to say that it is about much more than anti-Haitian prejudice. Yes, it encompasses a existing set of prejudices, stereotypes, implicit biases, discourses, dispositions, and racialized emotions, but it also involves isolate, small group, direct and indirect, intentional or unintentional discriminatory practices, and political practices implemented by the Dominican state and government that help perpetuate the low status of Haitians and their descendants in all fields of Dominican society.
The creation of social and symbolic boundaries between Haitians and Dominicans has been an important mechanism for maintaining this systemic racism, especially because of the connected history of the two nations and peoples. Thus, it is important to understand not only the social construction of economic and cultural boundaries around Haitians in time and space, but also to understand the legacies of those boundaries, how they are maintained how they change, and how new and/or transformed configurations of boundaries may be emerging. One thing to pay attention is how the nationalist discourse draws boundaries around Haitian labor as to diminish its contributions and legitimacy. The presence of Haitian labor, now spread throughout the economy, is not part of the official story of the highly celebrated modernization and transnationalization of the country. The nationalist discourse represents Haitian labor as a problem even when the Haitian workforce is critical in construction and the growth of banana, rice, sugar cane and coffee. Data from 2010 show 13% of the Dominican workforce (or 352,974 workers) was Haitian or Dominican of Haitian descent.
The Denial of citizenship and making Haitian labor cheap and exploitable first in the sugar cane sector and now throughout the economy are important discriminatory mechanisms and need to continue to be addressed by social movements. The same could be said about the barriers that are being raised to limit the residence status of Haitian workers, the systematic negation of birth certificates and personal identification, restriction of entry to the school system, and denial of labor rights and civil liberties. This is important because unlike other racialized societies there are little to no attempts of incorporating or even assimilating poor Haitians into Dominican society. Instead, the racist system relies on the normative and overt logic of perpetual Haitian non-personhood.
Pressures should be also directed to denounce and challenge the Haitian state and Haitian elite as they also play a role in facilitating the exploitation of poor Haitians and their descendants in the eastern side. In fact, it almost seems as if the systematic exploitation and marginalization of poor Haitians and their descendants in the Dominican Republic could not exist without the oppression they first face in their own country. Poor and marginalized Haitians face a duality of oppressions that we hope they someday should overcome. The current nationalist climate exacerbates the vulnerabilities that permeate Haitian life in the Dominican Republic, and this piece echoes the concerns being expressed by many conscious voices in the Dominican Republic at this time. Let's hope that the power of tolerance and solidarity and the sense of leadership responsibility can prevail in the midst of the serious challenges facing the two historically, geographically linked nations and peoples.
1. Cabral Ramírez, Edylberto and Mayra Brea De Cabral. 20003. "Violencia en la
República Dominicana: Tendencias Recientes." Perspect P sicol (3–4): 146–154.
2. Artiles, Leopoldo. 2009. Seguridad Ciudadana en la República Dominicana: Desafíos y Propuestas
de Política. Santo Domingo. Secretaría de Estado, Planificación y Desarrollo.
Ana S.Q. Liberato
Police-Involved Killings Continue with No End in Sight
May 12, 2015 • Jessie Daniels • police
Police-involved killings in the U.S. continue with no end in sight. Today, the Madison, Wisconsin D.A. Ismael Ozanne announced that there will be no charges brought against the white police officer for shooting and killing 19-year-old Tony Robinson Jr. on March 6. With that murder, and the announcement of no indictment, Tony Robinson's names gets added to the long and growing list of names-turned-hashtags for young black and brown people killed by police where there is no justice in the wake of their death, and likely no peace in Madison.
Tony Robinson, Jr. Source: CNN
Comprehensive data on rate of death for police-involved killings is difficult to come by because no federal agency is tasked with collecting it in any systematic way. Even the FBI failed to count at least half the number of people killed by state and local law enforcement officers in the past decade, according to a government report released in March. In the wake of such a failure of basic data collection, citizen and activist groups have started compiling their own statistics through crime and media reports. One of the most comprehensive projects to date is a website called Killed By Police. The site logged nearly 1,500 police-involved deaths between January 1, 2014 and April 30, 2015 and included documentation for each incident.
And, this is what the aggregation of those deaths look like over 16 months:
Tracking Police Killings Nationwide Source: http://killedbypolice.net
If this were the spread of an infectious disease, the CDC and public health officials around the nation would be scrambling to find a solution. Yet, as it is, this use of deadly force by police against black and brown people continues virtually unchecked by any individual or institution. It has not gone unnoticed by the rest of the world, however.
Stop Racist Police Brutality Source: PBS Newshour
Yesterday, the United Nations' Human Rights Council slammed the U.S. over our abysmal human rights record. Among the human rights abuses that the U.N. called attention to were police violence and racial discrimination, the Guantánamo Bay Detention Facility, pervasive surveillance and the continued use of the death penalty. But it was the issue of racism and police brutality that dominated the discussion during the second universal periodic review (UPR). Country after country recommended that the U.S. strengthen legislation and expand training to eliminate racism and excessive use of force by law enforcement.
Last month, Chris Rock made news after he started documenting the number of times he's been pulled over by the police and posting the photos on Twitter. Rock didn't state the reasons as to why he was being pulled over, but people assumed that he was making a point about being racially profiled. In a recent interview with The Guardian, Rock discussed being profiled and the recent uprising in Baltimore.
"It's not that it's gotten worse; it's just that it's part of the 24-hour news cycle. What's weird is that it never happens to white kids. There's no evidence that white youngsters are any less belligerent, you know? We can go to any Wall Street bar and they are way bigger a–holes than in any other black bar. But will I see cops stop shooting black kids in my lifetime? Probably not," Rock said.
I hope Chris Rock is wrong, but it doesn't look like he is today.
Systemic Racism: Videos and Readings Storify
May 11, 2015 • Jessie Daniels • video
Last week, I did a series of posts around the videos about systemic racism that Race Forward produced, and additional resources. Now, I've Storyifiedthose posts all in one place for easy use in your classes, community groups or your own edification.
[View the story "Systemic Racism: Videos + Readings" on Storify]
Systemic Racism Video: Infant Mortality
In the last video in the systemic racism video series, Jay Smooth explains infant mortality in this short (1:01) video:
The text of the video reads:
Did you know that even though America's infant mortality rate has gone way down in the last 50 years, Black babies are still almost 2.5 times more likely to die before reaching their 1st birthday? Did you know that Black mothers are 3 three times as likely to die during childbirth, that Black and Hispanic mothers are more than twice as likely not to receive proper prenatal care and Native American mothers are more than 3 times less likely to receive proper care?
Race Forward, the producers of the video series, lists several sources for this short video. There is also a longer, and very good, video on the connection between systemic racism and infant mortality called, "When the Bough Breaks." Compared to the other areas covered in the series, the link between infant mortality and systemic racism is a more recent area of research – the last twenty years or so – but there is a growing literature here. If you'd like to dive deeper on this topic, see the titles listed below.
Collins Jr, James W., Richard J. David, Arden Handler, Stephen Wall, and Steven Andes. "Very low birthweight in African American infants: the role of maternal exposure to interpersonal racial discrimination." American journal of public health 94, no. 12 (2004): 2132-2138. Abstract: Objectives. We determined whether African American women's lifetime exposure to interpersonal racial discrimination is associated with pregnancy outcomes. Methods. We performed a case–control study among 104 African American women who delivered very low birthweight (<1500 g) preterm (<37 weeks) infants and 208 African American women who delivered non–low-birthweight (>2500g) term infants in Chicago, Ill. Results. The unadjusted and adjusted odds ratio of very low birthweight infants for maternal lifetime exposure to interpersonal racism in 3 or more domains equaled 3.2 (95% confidence intervals=1.5, 6.6) and 2.6 (1.2, 5.3), respectively. This association tended to persist across maternal sociodemographic, biomedical, and behavioral characteristics. Conclusions. The lifelong accumulated experiences of racial discrimination by African American women constitute an independent risk factor for preterm delivery. (OA)
David, Richard J., and James W. Collins Jr. "Bad outcomes in black babies: race or racism?." Ethnicity & disease 1, no. 3 (1990): 236-244. Abstract: The gap between black and white infant death rates in the United States has grown over the last three decades. Epidemiologic and medical studies by investigators seeking to understand and reverse this adverse trend have been unsuccessful. Researchers have looked in vain for the combination of social and environmental risk factors that are more common among blacks and would therefore explain this group's poor reproductive outcomes. The implicit alternate hypothesis is genetic differences between blacks and whites. In fact, there is more of a gap between black and white mothers of higher socioeconomic position than between overall black and white rates without socioeconomic stratification. An alternative to the genetic theory explains these results, however, on the basis of social risk factors that, because of the presence of widespread discrimination in the society under study, apply only to blacks. Such factors are the effects of racism, not race per se. Several lines of research are needed to investigate the effects of racism on perinatal outcomes, including studies on psychophysiological reactions to racial discrimination and on ethnic group differences in coping mechanisms, social supports, and physical environment. Analysis of trends over the past 37 years indicates that improvements in white (and total US) infant mortality rates cannot be anticipated until the racial gap is closed. (locked)
Dominguez, Tyan Parker. "Race, racism, and racial disparities in adverse birth outcomes." Clinical obstetrics and gynecology 51, no. 2 (2008): 360-370. Abstract: While the biologic authenticity of race remains a contentious issue, the social significance of race is indisputable. The chronic stress of racism and the social inequality it engenders may be underlying social determinants of persistent racial disparities in health, including infant mortality, preterm delivery, and low birth weight. This article describes the problem of racial disparities in adverse birth outcomes; outlines the multidimensional nature of racism and the pathways by which it may adversely affect health; and discusses the implications for clinical practice. (OA)
Giscombé, Cheryl L., and Marci Lobel. "Explaining disproportionately high rates of adverse birth outcomes among African Americans: the impact of stress, racism, and related factors in pregnancy." Psychological bulletin 131, no. 5 (2005): 662. Abstract: Compared with European Americans, African American infants experience disproportionately high rates of low birth weight and preterm delivery and are more than twice as likely to die during their 1st year of life. The authors examine 5 explanations for these differences in rates of adverse birth outcomes: (a) ethnic differences in health behaviors and socioeconomic status; (b) higher levels of stress in African American women; (c) greater susceptibility to stress in African Americans; (d) the impact of racism acting either as a contributor to stress or as a factor that exacerbates stress effects; and (e) ethnic differences in stress-related neuroendocrine, vascular, and immunological processes. The review of literature indicates that each explanation has some merit, although none is sufficient to explain ethnic disparities in adverse birth outcomes. There is a lack of studies examining the impact of such factors jointly and interactively. Recommendations and cautions for future research are offered. (OA)
Roberts, Killing the Black Body (1997)
Roberts, Dorothy E. Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction and the Meaning of Liberty. New York: Pantheon Book (1997). Abstract:Roberts gives a powerful and authoritative account of the on-going assault – both figurative and literal – waged by the American government and our society on the reproductive rights of Black women. While not entirely focused on infant mortality, it offers invaluable context for this persistent health disparity. (locked)
Williams, David R. "Race, socioeconomic status, and health the added effects of racism and discrimination." Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences896, no. 1 (1999): 173-188. Abstract: Higher disease rates for blacks (or African Americans) compared to whites are pervasive and persistent over time, with the racial gap in mortality widening in recent years for multiple causes of death. Other racial/ethnic minority populations also have elevated disease risk for some health conditions. This paper considers the complex ways in which race and socioeconomic status (SES) combine to affect health. SES accounts for much of the observed racial disparities in health. Nonetheless, racial differences often persist even at "equivalent" levels of SES. Racism is an added burden for nondominant populations. Individual and institutional discrimination, along with the stigma of inferiority, can adversely affect health by restricting socioeconomic opportunities and mobility. Racism can also directly affect health in multiple ways. Residence in poor neighborhoods, racial bias in medical care, the stress of experiences of discrimination and the acceptance of the societal stigma of inferiority can have deleterious consequences for health. (OA)
That's the end of the video series on systemic racism.
Systemic Racism Video: Immigration Policy
In the next installment in the systemic racism video series, Jay Smooth explains immigration policy in this short (1:00) video:
Have you ever wondered why, even though undocumented people come to the US from all over the world, the face of undocumented persons is always assumed to be from Central America or South America? And our heavy-handed enforcement policies, that ruin lives and tear families apart every day, are focused almost entirely on the Southern US border, and the Hispanic people of color who cross that border?
Race Forward, the producers of the video series, lists several sources for the video. There is also an extensive body of research about the way that systemic racism shapes immigration policy.
Golash-Boza, Tanya, and Douglas A. Parker. "Human Rights in a Globalizing World: Who Pays the Human Cost of Migration? 1." The Journal of Latino-Latin American Studies 2, no. 4 (2007): 34-46. Abstract: This paper examines the relationship between globalization and immigration, and makes the case that current foreign policies and immigration regulations in the United States and France result in the violation of the human rights of migrants. In the United States, the House and Senate proposals presented in 2005 and 2006 to stem the tide of immigrants and thereby fix the immigration "problem" either criminalize undocumented workers or transform them into temporary workers. In France, the "selected immigration" bill introduced by Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy, and passed in 2006, makes it easier for skilled workers to enter and remain in France and harder for less skilled workers to do so. These proposals and bills fail to see immigrants as human beings with dignity and fundamental rights to a livelihood, a family, and a community, and fail to take into account the receiving countries. complicity in producing emigration. Designed to maximize profits for corporations, and minimize the prices of consumer goods for customers in the Global North, these policies and regulations have a high human cost. This paper explains how temporary worker programs are designed to extract labor from immigrants while preventing them from becoming full and equal members of the communities in which they work and live, and how the criminalization of undocumented immigrants transforms migrants into second-class citizens. From a human rights perspective, all human beings should have the right to food security, to decent health care, to safe working conditions, to an education, to a family, to their cultural identity, and to fight and organize for their rights. Temporary worker programs that permit workers to come to a country only to work for low wages and no benefits, and do not permit them to bring their families, to send their children to school, and to form communities are a violation of these workers. human rights. (OA)
Golash‐Boza, Tanya. "The immigration industrial complex: why we enforce immigration policies destined to fail." Sociology Compass 3, no. 2 (2009): 295-309. Abstract: This article provides a genealogy of the idea of an immigration industrial complex. The immigration industrial complex is the confluence of public and private sector interests in the criminalization of undocumented migration, immigration law enforcement, and the promotion of 'anti-illegal' rhetoric. This concept is based on ideas developed with regard to the prison and military industrial complexes. These three complexes share three major features: (a) a rhetoric of fear; (b) the convergence of powerful interests; and (c) a discourse of other-ization. This article explores why Congress has not passed viable legislation to deal with undocumented migration, and instead has passed laws destined to fail, and has appropriated billions of dollars to the Department of Homeland Security to implement these laws. This has been exacerbated in the context of the War on Terror, now that national security has been conflated with immigration law enforcement. This is the first in a two-part series on the immigration industrial complex. (locked)
Immigration Nation (2012)
Golash-Boza, Tanya Maria. Immigration nation: Raids, detentions, and deportations in post-9/11 America. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers, 2012. Abstract: This book provides a critical analysis of the impact that U.S. immigration policy has on human rights. In the wake of 9/11, the Department of Homeland Security was founded to protect America from the threat of terrorist attacks. However, along with dramatic increases in immigration law enforcement ― raids, detentions, and deportations have increased six-fold in the past decade ― American citizens, families, and communities have ultimately borne the cost. Although family reunification is officially a core component of U.S. immigration policy, these same policies often tear families apart. Pundits and politicians nearly always frame this debate in terms of security and economic needs, but here, Tanya Maria Golash-Boza addresses the debate with the human rights of migrants and their families at the center of her analyses. (locked)
Provine, Doris Marie, and Roxanne Lynn Doty. "The criminalization of immigrants as a racial project." Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 27, no. 3 (2011): 261-277. Abstract: Contemporary policy responses to unauthorized immigration, we argue, reinforce racialized anxieties by (a) focusing attention on physically distinctive and economically marginalized minorities who are defined as the nation's immigration"threat," (b) creating new spaces of enforcement within which racial anxieties flourish and become institutionalized; and thereby (c) racializing immigrant bodies. We examine three federal enforcement policies: (a) the physical border buildup that began in the 1990s, (b) partnerships with local police, and (c) Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) initiatives to enhance interior enforcement. The result has been the construction of a landscape of institutionalized racial violence embedded in our current immigration regime. (locked)
March to Close the Tacoma Detention Center (2009)
Provine, Doris Marie. "Institutional Racism in Enforcing Immigration Law." Norteamérica, Revista Académica del CISAN-UNAM 8 (2013). Abstract: The United States is committed to aggressive efforts to remove unauthorized immigrants while honoring its commitment to race neutrality. Yet immigration enforcement has disproportionately targeted Mexicans and Central Americans. The racial bias can be found at both the federal and local levels, where local police are becoming increasingly involved in locating unauthorized immigrants. The local example featured here is Arizona because of its historical relationship with Mexico and its enthusiasm for immigration enforcement. I find that the current mix of federal and local enforcement discriminates racially through profiling, hyper-surveillance, abusive stops, problematic searches, and unwarranted detention. (OA)
Silverstein, Paul A. "Immigrant racialization and the new savage slot: race, migration, and immigration in the new Europe." Annual. Review of Anthropology 34 (2005): 363-384. Abstract: This review explores contemporary processes through which immigrants are categorized into shifting racial landscapes in the new Europe. Tracing the racial genealogy of the immigrant through European and Europeanist migration studies, the successive construction of overlapping tropes of the nomad, the laborer, the uprooted victim, the hybrid cosmopolite, and the (Muslim) transmigrant are examined. This history points to the perduring problematization of the immigrant as the object of national integration. If migration studies have effectively tended to racialize migrants into a new savage slot, recent ethnographies of the immigrant experience in Europe point to ways in which immigrant and diasporic groups cross racial frontiers and enact solidarity across class and cultural lines. (OA)
Next, and last, in this series: infant mortality.


Come out to Fort Monroe in Hampton for the annual Fourth at the Fort! This all-day event includes a flag ceremony and various family-friendly events including live music and fireworks! For the complete schedule, visit http://www.fmauthority.com/event/special-event-fourth-at-the-fort-4/?instance_id=2339 .


Violent and toxic relations in our communities have been reported of leaking into our WA schools, as the number of student suspensions continues to rise.
In the first four weeks of the school year, almost 1000 students have been suspended from WA public schools for physical aggression, a 15 per cent increase compared to last years figures.
"I'm not sure that we'll see a decrease in bullying unfortunately, what happens in our community is reflected in our young people and schools," said Ms Ellery.
On the National Day of action against bullying and violence, Sue Ellery, Education Minister, has launched a range of resources to combat rising bullying and violence rates in schools.
"Helping students know when they can stand up against bullying, how to do it, and how to get help is really important," she said.
However, students are concerned that its becoming a bigger issue as each year passes, with not enough punishments being enforced.
Ms Ellery acknowledged the students' growing concern and assures there is a lot of work being done on this issue.
""I feel like they don't take it seriously enough.. We have lots of talks like don't bully, obviously it's bad, but really if someone does need help they kind of just over look it," said one high school student.
"We need to put a stop to bullying so we can keep progressing forward," they said.
Samantha Rowe MLC said it's important for schools, parents and the community to work together to stop bullying behaviour in schools.
"If we focus on bullying and creating change, we can create safer communities for everyone," she commented.


Microsoft may have blew the lids off Windows 8 in the first BUILD 2011 keynote but you can only fit so much in a 2 hour presentation, no matter how enthusiastic Steven Sinofsky can be.
Near the end of the keynote, the presentation included a slide with hundreds of features that Microsoft claim they "didn't get to show". At normal scale, it was a little difficult to comprehend, but with the magic of magnification it reveals a few nuggets.
Here are some of the most interesting ones I could read legibly from the text.
Phone as Smartcard – the ability to use Windows Phone as an authenticator for login?
Communication over SMS on my PC – the ability to send and receive SMSes?
OMG!!! Microsoft actually listens! The Phone as Smartcard is actually my feature-request I posted to the Build site. Its a simple feature: Pair my bluetooth phone device to my tablet or desktop machine, use the proximity detection of the mobile device to ID my presence and log me in automatically or use it as Two-tier authentication with the lax security feature of the PIN or Picture login.
I never thought they'll implement it so fast.
Is that "DirectX 11" in the list near the bottom left? That's already in Win7.
Was that a joke that went over my head?
Nope. The taskbar is black/chromeless in more recent builds of Windows 8.
Does that entail a change to the general window chrome style, as well, or will that remain blue by default?
How about the windows, will they be black and chromeless with no Aero glass?
ENHANCE… and Augment. Now give me a hard-copy of that.
Didn't they try integrating .NET Passport into Windows XP, and failed horribly? How will Live ID be any different?
@xpclient: that image isn't any better.
Oh it is, dahlin. Forgot your glasses?


text:
Recycling metals such as nickel creates win-win scenarios for both the environment and industry. It is an integral part of the metals industry; metals are recycled because of their value and because most can be recycled without loss of quality. This is particularly true of non-ferrous metals such as nickel.
As recyclable metals are valued, there is an infrastructure for gathering and processing them. Although society is now likely to perceive metal recycling as an environmental activity, it has existed as a profitable economic sector in its own right for thousands of years. In most countries, the economics of gathering, sorting, preparing, transporting and using scrap metal employs more people and is of greater economic importance than the mining and refining of ores.
Nickel and nickel-containing alloys can be returned to their original state or converted to a different, but still valuable, form. Examples are nickel-containing stainless steel scrap being turned into new stainless steel, or nickel from recycled batteries being used for nickel-containing stainless steel.
The efficiency of nickel recycling is one of the highest
Around 68% of all nickel available from consumer products is recycled and begins a new life cycle (reference year 2010); another 15% enters the carbon steel loop. However, around 17% still ends up in landfill, mainly in metal goods and in waste electrical and electronic equipment.
Recycling is an important factor in nickel's life cycle and an important contributor to global sustainability. Nickel-containing products, such as stainless steel, are durable and are designed for long-term use. Demand for recycled nickel is growing; it is part of the solution as a complement to primary production.
Download our infographic on nickel recycling here.
Declaration by the metals industry on recycling principles
"In 2006, the metals industry published a declaration on recycling principles. The declaration, which was signed by 18 metal commodity associations including the Nickel Institute, aims at encouraging policy-makers, designers and manufacturers to adopt life cycle thinking when developing metals recycling policies.
Many metals can be recycled infinitely without any loss of properties. To date, the levels of recycled metals and alloys in products are used as a driver for increasing recycling rates and as an indicator of environmental performance. However, such an approach could encourage inefficiency in the production and use of recycled metals; the declaration shows that the recycled material content of a product fails to take account of the environmental costs and benefits associated with achieving this goal.
Using the recycled content approach may increase overall economic and environmental costs, as metal available for recycling is diverted to manufacturing a specific product rather than to where the recycling loop is more economically or environmentally efficient. The objective should be to promote eco-efficiency in metals use while maximising the economic benefits to society.
A life cycle approach that considers the material flows at the end of the product life is preferable; this enables the most accurate assessment of the environmental and economic implications aimed at increasing recycling. Such an approach allows decision-makers to identify inefficiencies and associated environmental impacts as well as to optimise product recovery and material recyclability."
Download the declaration here.
Nickel in a circular economy
The concept of a circular economy is generally understood to be "a regenerative system in which resource input and waste, emission, and energy leakage are minimised by slowing, closing, and narrowing energy and material loops. This can be achieved through long lasting design, maintenance, repair, reuse, remanufacturing, refurbishing, and recycling1. This is in contrast to a linear economy which is a 'take, make, dispose' model of production2.
Given its outstanding properties and high recycling efficiency, nickel, as well as nickel-containing stainless steel, demonstrates how primary materials can contribute to a circular economy. As nickel improves corrosion resistance, it makes the product longer-lasting with lower maintenance. Its high value makes repairing and reusing nickel-containing products economically attractive. The high recycling efficiency ensures that nickel re-enters the economy following the end of life of nickel-containing products.
1 Geissdorfer, Martin; Savaget, Paulo; Bocken, Nancy M.P.; Hultink, Erik Jan (2017-02-01). "The Circular Economy - A new sustainability paradigm?" Journal of Cleaner Production. 143: 757-768. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.12.048.
2 Towards the Circular Economy: an economic and business rationale for an accelerated transition. Ellen MacArthur Foundation. 2012. p. 24.

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


text:
Nicki Minaj Holds 'Orgasm Interventions': 'I Demand That I Climax'
By Antoinette Bueno 2:09 PM PDT, May 29, 2015
TMI?!
Nicki Minaj isn't afraid to discuss her sex life in a candid new interview with Cosmopolitan magazine, specifically, why she thinks more women should be high-maintenance in bed.
"I demand that I climax. I think women should demand that," the 32-year-old "Feeling Myself" rapper says bluntly, donning an Allusions by A.Lekay bikini for the sexy photoshoot. "I have a friend who's never had an orgasm in her life. In her life! That hurts my heart. It's cuckoo to me."
PHOTOS: A History of Nicki Minaj's Terrifyingly Hideous Perfume Bottles
Being the good friend that she is, Nicki says she helps her pal out by having "orgasm interventions."
"We always have orgasm interventions where we, like, show her how to do stuff," she explains. "We'll straddle each other, saying, 'You gotta get on him like that and do it like this.' She says she's a pleaser. I'm a pleaser, but it's fifty-fifty."
Despite her candid sex talk, Nicki is pretty traditional when it comes to where she sees herself in a decade.
... Are you listening to this, Meek Mill?!
"Ten years from now, I will have two children, unless my husband wants three," she says about what she has planned for her future. "I will be into my fitness a lot more, I will stop yo-yo dieting, and I'll be a housewife with careers that I can run from home. I want to be able to cook for my children, bake cookies for them, and watch them grow up."
"I just want to be Mommy," she stresses. "Take them to school, go to the parent-teacher conference, help them with their homework, and put their work on the refrigerator."
This isn't the first time the chart-topping "Anaconda" rapper has talked about her strong desire to have children. Last November, she told Complex magazine that she wanted to have a child before her sixth album. Nicki released her third album, The Pinkprint, last December.
"If I'm done with my fifth album and I don't have a child by then, no matter how much money I have, I would be disappointed, as a woman, because I feel like I was put here to be a mother," she said. "I have definitely put off the wife thing because I don't want people in my business. I'd rather not do anything that's going to be on paper but I definitely will be married before I have my baby. I want to make sure I do it in that order."
NEWS: Nicki Minaj Gets a Proposal from a Very Hot Royal
But will her future husband be her boyfriend, rapper Meek Mill? Check out the "Amen" rapper addressing the couple's engagement rumors in the video below.
Are Nicki Minaj and Meek Mill Actually Engaged?
The 10 Best Tablets 2022 for Kids, Students, Artists and More
The Best Fitness Trackers and Smartwatches for Your 2022 Health Goals


text:
ACCEPTED

#### According to
International Plant Names Index

#### Published in
Nordic J. Bot. 11:538. 1991

#### Original name
null

### Remarks
null

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaGithub


Kuala Lumpur, Feb 6, 2017: Football development in Afghanistan has been given a significant boost as key stakeholders of the country's football family took part in workshops organised by the Asian Football Confederation (AFC) under the League Development Programme (LDP) over three days. The AFC is the first football governing body to organise such workshops for the Afghanistan Football Federation (AFF).
The workshops were held from February 6 to February 8, and they covered several specific areas, including club licensing and event management as well as training for match commissioners and an introduction to the AFC's live streaming programme for Member Associations, enabling them to broadcast football matches live on the internet. The participants were AFF officials and the presidents of the 20 provincial football associations.
The workshops were held in Tajikistan's capital Dushanbe and the AFC covered the costs of the participants' travel and accommodation. The timing of the training was planned conscientiously, to coincide with the first and second-leg AFC Cup matches between Afghan club Shaheen Asmayee and Tajikistan's FC Hosilot. Both matches were played in Tajikistan's capital Dushanbe, as Afghan teams are currently not able to host international matches in their home country. The first leg of the preliminary round fixture took place on January 31 and the second leg encounter will be played today, February 7.
President of the Afghanistan Football Federation Mr Keramuddin Karim said in his opening remarks: "This is a historic day for Afghanistan Football Federation as for the first time in our history we are organising workshops and seminars for the football administrators in Afghanistan. I cannot stress more on the importance of club licensing in the development of leagues and clubs, and it is for the AFF, provincial and club officials to understand the regulations and criteria and to implement them in a productive way. Also the other planned workshops scheduled for these three days will go a long way in developing football in Afghanistan.
AFC General Secretary Dato' Windsor John said: "The workshops organised by the AFC for the benefit of football in Afghanistan show that the AFC is serious about lifting the level of football across the continent. We are proud to be the first to have been able to help Afghan football in this way.


text:
Mary Daly (Schenectady, Nueva York, 16 de octubre de 1928-Gardner, Massachusetts, 3 de enero de 2010) fue una filósofa feminista radical, académica y teóloga estadounidense que dio clase en el Boston College, una institución jesuítica, durante 33 años. Daly accedió a abandonar el Boston College en 1999, tras violar las normas universitarias al no aceptar la presencia de estudiantes masculinos en sus clases de estudios de la mujer.

Educación
Antes de conseguir sus dos doctorados en teología sagrada y filosofía por la Universidad de Friburgo, Suiza, se graduó en Inglés en el College of Saint Rose, se licenció en la Universidad Católica de América y realizó un doctorado en religión por el Saint Mary's College de Indiana.

Carrera
Dio clase en el Boston College entre 1967 y 1999, como profesora de cursos sobre teología, ética feminista y patriarcado. Fue por primera vez amenazada con ser despedida cuando, después de la publicación de su primer libro, The Church and the Second Sex (1968) le hicieron un contrato temporal pero como consecuencia del apoyo recibido por los estudiantes (entonces todos hombres) y por el público en general a Daly se le aseguró finalmente el puesto.

La oposición de Daly a admitir estudiantes masculinos en muchas de sus clases en el Boston College terminó también por provocar acciones disciplinarias contra ella. Aunque Daly se defendió diciendo que la presencia de esos estudiantes inhibía la discusión en clase, el Boston College consideró que su actitud constituía una violación del título IX de la ley federal que requería del College la seguridad de que ninguna persona podría ser excluida de un programa educativo por razones de sexo, y de la propia política de no discriminación de la Universidad que insistía en que todos los cursos debían estar abiertos tanto a estudiantes masculinos como femeninos.

Obras
 Natural Knowledge of God in the Philosophy of Jacques Maritain. Officium Libri Catholici, 1966.
 The Church and the Second Sex. Harper & Row, 1968.
 Beyond God the Father: Toward a Philosophy of Women's Liberation. Beacon Press, 1973. ISBN 0-8070-2768-5
 Gyn/Ecology: The Metaethics of Radical Feminism. Beacon Press, 1978. ISBN 0-8070-1510-5
 Pure Lust: Elemental Feminist Philosophy. Beacon Press, 1984. ISBN 0-8070-1504-0
 Websters' First New Intergalactic Wickedary of the English Language, Conjured in Cahoots with Jane Caputi (with Jane Caputi and Sudie Rakusin). Beacon Press, 1987. ISBN 0-8070-6706-7
 Outercourse: The Bedazzling Voyage, Containing Recollections from My Logbook of a Radical Feminist Philosopher. HarperSanFrancisco, 1992. ISBN 0-06-250194-1
 Quintessence... Realizing the Archaic Future: A Radical Elemental Feminist Manifesto. Beacon Press, 1998. ISBN 0-8070-6790-3
 Amazon Grace: Re-Calling the Courage to Sin Big. Palgrave Macmillan, 2006. ISBN 1-4039-6853-5

Referencias

Bibliografía

Enlaces externos
 Página oficial de Mary Daly

 Mary Daly en la Enciclopedia GLBTQ.
 Página de CDDC
 New York University website re "Wickedary"
 Entrevista con Mary Daly en KDVS, 5 de abril de 2006

Filósofos de Estados Unidos del siglo XX
Feministas de Estados Unidos
Filósofas de Estados Unidos
Filósofas feministas
Teólogos de Estados Unidos
Escritoras lesbianas
Escritores en inglés del siglo XX
Alumnado de la Universidad Católica de América
Alumnado de la Universidad de Friburgo (Suiza)
Profesores de la Universidad de Boston
National Organization for Women
Feminismo radical
Nacidos en Schenectady

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaWikipedia


text:
By John Schuster
THE DECLINE CONTINUES: 'STAR' DOESN'T BENEFIT FROM 'CITIZEN' CLOSURE
The Arizona Daily Star still maintained an average weekday circulation of slightly more than 100,000—and Sunday circulation numbers near 150,000—but according to 2009 numbers compiled by the Audit Bureau of Circulations, the city's morning daily did not benefit at all from the May 2009 closure of the Tucson Citizen.
According to the audit, released last month, the Star's average paid circulation for Sunday was 143,738. From Monday through Friday, that number dipped to 104,340. Monday was the weakest day (100,263), and Thursday the strongest (109,140). Saturday's average was 112,138.
However, when broken into quarterly numbers for 2009, the Star actually turned in stronger tallies in the first quarter, when the Citizen was still around. In January through March 2009, the Star had an average Sunday circulation around 155,000, and a weekday circulation of 122,000. Those numbers dipped significantly during the spring and summer quarters—not surprising, given Tucson's hot-weather exodus—but they didn't pick up as much as the Star might have hoped in the last quarter of 2009. In that three-month window, the Star circulation average for Sunday was 147,907, and 105,952 on weekdays.
Last-quarter 2009 numbers were well below the numbers from the same quarter in 2008 (154,450 for Sundays and 118,713 on weekdays), a suggestion that the poor economy and the deterioration of the daily-newspaper print model are far more significant than any bump the paper might have received by picking up some of the roughly 15,000 subscribers who hung on to the Citizen until the end.
In the last five years, the Star's paid Sunday circulation average has gone from 168,227 in 2005, to 163,777 in 2006, 159,266 in 2007, 153,974 in 2008, to last year's tally of 143,738.
Monday through Friday numbers were 138,953 in 2005, 137,379 in 2006, 131,452 in 2007, 121,399 in 2008 and 104,340 in 2009. That's nearly a 16 percent drop from 2008 to 2009 alone.
KILBURY WINS ROCKY MOUNTAIN EMMY—AND WAS THE LAST TO KNOW
Scott Kilbury was trying to catch some Zs in the midst of a busy weekend that had him hosting Butterfield Stage Days in his hometown of Benson, attending a high school reunion and preparing to take the kids to Sunrise Park Ski Resort. With a schedule like that, there's no time for things like the Rocky Mountain Emmy Awards, even if they were hosted just up the road in Phoenix.
On Saturday night, Kilbury started receiving texts.
"My wife said, 'You won something,'" Kilbury said. "I had forgotten about the whole thing. Then I tracked down information on Twitter, and they said another Scott had won, so I figured they got confused."
They hadn't. Kilbury and Scott Light of Phoenix TV station KPNX shared the On-Camera Talent Anchor news award. For Kilbury, it's his first news-related Rocky Mountain Emmy; he has two other statues related to his sports work at KOLD Channel 13.
"I was just happy to be nominated in a news category. It makes me feel like I'm validated at this desk," said Kilbury, who transitioned to KOLD's morning show three years ago. "I had gone to (Rocky Mountain Emmy) dinners before, and you have to pay for the dinner, and then if you don't win, on the drive home, it's, 'Wow, that sucked.'"
KOLD registered other Rocky Mountain Emmy winners as well. KOLD news anchor Heather Rowe, who was nominated in the category Kilbury won, received an Emmy along with Paul Durrant for "Ticket Hot Spots" in the Special Assignment Report news category. Durrant also received an editor Emmy in the No Time Limit news category. Richard Beissel, who now works in Phoenix, landed an honor in the sports version of the same category. Wade Stai's "Because Wade Was Crazy" piece garnered Editor Short-Form accolades.
Meanwhile, KUAT Channel 6 received a half-dozen honors. Sooyeon Lee Johnston closed out her distinguished days at Arizona Public Media with wins in Arts/Entertainment Program Feature, Arts/Entertainment Program Special and Magazine Program Feature. Luis Carrion was honored in the Teen News Single Story category for his "Youth Farming" segment and in Historical Culture for a piece on a Native American filmmaker; and Thomas Kleespie won for Southwestern Gems in the Documentary—Cultural category.
Jeanie Bergen and Mitch Riley (he may have more of these statues than anyone in town) combined for four awards under the Tucson 12 banner; Will Holst, who might be right with Riley in number of wins, helped UAnews.org receive two Emmys, while Dave Sitton was honored for his play-by-play work on UA men's basketball games.
REBECCA TAYLOR PARTING WAYS WITH KVOA
Popular weekend news anchor Rebecca Taylor will say goodbye to NBC affiliate KVOA Channel 4 at the end of the month.
"KVOA offered me a very nice raise and renewal package to stay on as weekend anchor/lead reporter, but after three great years with the station, I've decided to move on," said Taylor via e-mail. "I have some exciting opportunities in the works, which I can't discuss right now, but when the time is right, I'll be excited to share the news with everyone."
For Taylor, this brings her second Tucson stint to an end. She worked briefly for KMSB Channel 11 before accepting a reporter position in Phoenix. From there, she was hired for KVOA's morning show, but later transitioned to the weekend news desk.
Taylor says she was not included in KVOA's mandate to transition reporters into multimedia journalists (MMJs)—with reporters required to record the video for and edit their own stories.
"Rebecca has done a great job for us for the last three years. We are disappointed she is leaving KVOA. We wish Rebecca nothing but success in future endeavors," said Kathleen Choal, KVOA's station manager and news director, via email.
John Schuster
Latest in Media Watch
More Media Watch »
Oldest to Newest Newest to Oldest Most Liked