text:
Brodie's OT goal leads Flames past Flyers 3-2
(AP Photo/Matt Slocum)
By AARON BRACY
PHILADELPHIA (AP) The Flames just needed to get out of their own way.
TJ Brodie scored 1 minute, 59 seconds into overtime after Matthew Tkachuk tied it with 4:17 left in regulation to lead Calgary to a 3-2 victory over the Philadelphia Flyers on Saturday.
Tkachuk assisted on the winner in the 3-on-3 extra session. Philadelphia's Jordan Weal turned the puck over in the Flyers offensive zone to set up a 2-on-1 break. Tkachuk sent a cross-ice pass to Brodie, who beat goalie Carter Hart to lift the Pacific Division leaders to the win.
"Not every game is going to be pretty and these are the games that make a difference at the end of the year," Brodie said.
Calgary committed five penalties, including two for too many men on the ice, resulting in four Philadelphia power plays. The Flames also gifted the Flyers a go-ahead goal in the third period when goalie David Rittich misplayed the puck way out in front of his crease.
When it mattered, though, Calgary figured out how to do what it has been doing all season - win.
"We settled in and found a way to get it done," coach Bill Peters said. "That's a greasy road win."
Johnny Gaudreau notched his 24th goal of the season for the Flames, whose 56 points are tops in the Western Conference.
Travis Sanheim and Travis Konecny scored for Philadelphia, which dropped its season-worst sixth straight game. The Flyers are in last place in the Metropolitan Division; they entered tied with Los Angeles and Ottawa for the fewest points in the league.
It has been a forgettable season for the Flyers, who already have replaced their general manager and coach.
"It's tough because we're playing good hockey," Konecny said. "It just seems like teams are just scoring on the one opportunity that they're getting. It usually doesn't go that way, but that's just the way it's going for us right now."
Tkachuk tied it with 4:17 left in regulation when he beat Hart past the right pad with a wrist shot from the slot.
Konecny had given Philadelphia a third-period lead, taking advantage of a mistake by Rittich to put the Flyers ahead 2-1 at 5:57 of the period. With Philadelphia's Claude Giroux applying pressure on defenseman Rasmus Andersson, Rittich came way out of his crease to play the puck.
Konecny intercepted Rittich's clearing attempt, and then fired a wrist shot from the left circle past the retreating Flames goalie for his 10th of the season.
The victory was a sigh of relief for the Flames goalie.
"I made a mistake that almost cost us the game, so I was happy," he said.
Asked if he spoke to Tkachuk after the tying goal, Rittich said, "Yeah. `Thanks bro, I love you.'"
Gaudreau tied it at 1 with a pretty wrist shot from the right circle that whizzed over Hart's left shoulder during 4-on-4 play in the second period.
The 20-year-old Hart returned to the net after Michal Neuvirth suffered a lower-body injury in Philadelphia's 5-3 home loss to Carolina on Thursday, continuing the Flyers goalie carousel.
The rookie was solid, if not spectacular, and couldn't be faulted for any of the goals.
"I was seeing the puck," he said. "I felt comfortable. I wasn't overthinking things and just stuck to my game."
Hart, who made 29 saves, dropped to 2-4.
Veteran journeyman Mike McKenna was signed on Friday to back up Hart, who was making his sixth career start. If McKenna dresses for the Flyers, he would become the seventh goalie to suit up and that would tie an NHL record.
Sanheim got the Flyers on the board with a power-play goal with 7:50 left in the first period. His pass, which was intended for Weal in front of the net, caromed off the skate of Brodie and over the right shoulder of Rittich.
Rittich returned after missing the previous two games with a lower-body injury and made 32 saves.
Notes: Gaudreau, a native of South Jersey and a Philadelphia Eagles fan, will attend Sunday's Eagles-Bears NFL playoff game in Chicago with some teammates. ... Flyers C Nolan Patrick was back in the lineup after sitting out the past four games with an upper-body injury. ... The teams also went to overtime in their first meeting, a 6-5 home win by Calgary on Dec. 12. ... The Flames have scored 63 third-period goals. They entered the game leading the league in that category.
Calgary: At Chicago on Monday night.
Philadelphia: Host St. Louis on Monday night.


LOOKING TO BOOK NAHANNI FLY-IN TOUR?
Want to find available dates? Fill out the form below and we will be in touch within the next 48 hours.
Price includes tours, meals and accomodation. Does not include taxes.
Minimum number of participants is two. Large groups (6 to 9 people) are eligible for special rate.


text:
Review: Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales
Meve of destruction.
Alex Hajdasz2019-07-03T13:24:45+00:00June 21st, 2019|Categories: Board & Card Games, Reviews, Video Games|Tags: Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales|
The Layton Files: #3 – Professor Layton and the Lost Future
Curiouser and curiouser.
Alex Hajdasz2019-07-13T15:29:46+00:00May 22nd, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The Layton Files, Video Games|Tags: Professor Layton and the Lost Future|
The Layton Files: #2 – Professor Layton and Pandora's Box
A contemporary review of Professor Layton's first sequel for Nintendo DS.
Alex Hajdasz2019-05-10T08:23:51+00:00May 9th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The Layton Files, Video Games|Tags: Professor Layton and Pandora's Box|
The Layton Files: #1 – Professor Layton and the Curious Village
CelJaded's thinky new series begins with a review of Professor Layton and the Curious Village.
Alex Hajdasz2019-05-09T20:17:49+00:00April 11th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The Layton Files, Video Games|Tags: Professor Layton and the Curious Village|
Review: Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Immortal warriors.
Alex Hajdasz2019-04-28T19:06:53+00:00April 6th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Video Games|Tags: Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice|
The Wright Files: #4 – Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney
Here comes Justice!
Alex Hajdasz2019-03-12T17:35:52+00:00March 11th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The Wright Files, Video Games|Tags: Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney|
The Wright Files: #3 – Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Trials and Tribulations
"The only time a lawyer can cry is when it's all over."
Alex Hajdasz2019-03-01T11:51:25+00:00March 1st, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The Wright Files, Video Games|Tags: Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Trials and Tribulations|
The Wright Files: #2 – Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Justice for All
Karma's a bitch.
Alex Hajdasz2019-02-22T09:05:15+00:00February 22nd, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The Wright Files, Video Games|Tags: Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Justice for All|
The DS Files: #4 – Orcs & Elves
A look at id Software's lesser-known Nintendo DS port, Orcs & Elves.
Alex Hajdasz2019-03-18T20:01:16+00:00February 5th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, The DS Files, Video Games|Tags: Orcs & Elves|
The DS Files: #3 – Dynasty Warriors DS: Fighter's Battle
An empire falls.
Alex Hajdasz2019-02-05T20:30:19+00:00January 30th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The DS Files, Video Games|Tags: Dynasty Warriors DS: Fighter's Battle|
The DS Files: #2 – Battles of Prince of Persia
An underwhelming game for an incredibly whelming acronym.
Alex Hajdasz2019-02-05T20:24:06+00:00January 20th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Series, The DS Files, Video Games|Tags: Battles of Prince of Persia|
Review: Sonic Mania Plus
Encore! Encore!
Alex Hajdasz2019-03-18T20:33:45+00:00January 4th, 2019|Categories: Reviews, Video Games|Tags: Sonic Mania|
Review: Culdcept Revolt
It's a kind of Magic.
Alex Hajdasz2018-12-01T16:23:12+00:00November 24th, 2018|Categories: Reviews, Video Games|Tags: Culdcept Revolt|
Review: One Deck Dungeon Digital
Slice and dice.
Alex Hajdasz2018-08-22T09:28:59+00:00July 11th, 2018|Categories: Board & Card Games, Reviews, Video Games|Tags: One Deck Dungeon|
Review: Into the Breach Soundtrack
CelJaded listens to Into the Breach soundtrack by Ben Prunty. Discover another side to Subset Games' latest release in this full MP3 album review.
Alex Hajdasz2018-03-29T12:36:24+00:00March 22nd, 2018|Categories: Music, Reviews, Video Games|Tags: Into the Breach|
Review: Into the Breach
Miniature mechs and aliens clash with a time travel twist in this strategy game from the creators of FTL: Faster Than Light.
Alex Hajdasz2018-09-17T11:01:17+00:00March 19th, 2018|Categories: Reviews, Video Games|Tags: Into the Breach|
Board Games Based on Video Games: #8 – Dark Souls: The Card Game
YOU DIED.
Alex Hajdasz2020-12-21T09:20:01+00:00February 23rd, 2018|Categories: Board & Card Games, Board Games Based on Video Games, Reviews, Series|Tags: Dark Souls: The Card Game|
Review: Crazy Like a Fox: The Definitive Chronicle of Brian Pillman 20 Years Later
A brush with greatness.
Alex Hajdasz2021-01-11T10:54:39+00:00February 12th, 2018|Categories: Books, Reviews|Tags: Crazy Like a Fox: The Definitive Chronicle of Brian Pillman|
Review: Sonic Mania
Hedgehog re-Genesis.
Alex Hajdasz2019-01-04T16:53:44+00:00January 31st, 2018|Categories: Reviews, Video Games|Tags: Sonic Mania|
Review: Electrified
The rivers are black and the mists are crackling in this new heavy metal threequel from Black Water Rising.
Alex Hajdasz2017-12-10T10:07:05+00:00December 10th, 2017|Categories: Music, Reviews|Tags: Electrified|
[Archives]
[Archives] Select Month January 2021 (1) December 2020 (1) November 2020 (1) October 2020 (1) September 2020 (1) August 2020 (2) July 2020 (1) June 2020 (1) May 2020 (1) April 2020 (1) March 2020 (1) February 2020 (2) January 2020 (1) December 2019 (1) November 2019 (1) October 2019 (2) September 2019 (1) August 2019 (2) July 2019 (2) June 2019 (3) May 2019 (2) April 2019 (2) March 2019 (3) February 2019 (3) January 2019 (4) December 2018 (3) November 2018 (4) October 2018 (4) September 2018 (4) August 2018 (4) July 2018 (8) June 2018 (2) May 2018 (4) April 2018 (5) March 2018 (7) February 2018 (2) January 2018 (1) December 2017 (1) November 2017 (4) October 2017 (1) September 2017 (3) August 2017 (3) July 2017 (3) June 2017 (4) May 2017 (4) April 2017 (5) March 2017 (6) February 2017 (3) January 2017 (3) December 2016 (2) November 2016 (4) October 2016 (4) September 2016 (3) August 2016 (2) July 2016 (4) June 2016 (4) May 2016 (4) April 2016 (5) March 2016 (5) February 2016 (2) January 2016 (3) December 2015 (4) November 2015 (3) October 2015 (4) September 2015 (4) August 2015 (3) July 2015 (3) June 2015 (2) May 2015 (7) April 2015 (6) March 2015 (6) February 2015 (4) January 2015 (3) December 2014 (1) November 2014 (4) October 2014 (1) September 2014 (4) August 2014 (5) July 2014 (3) June 2014 (2)
[Categories]
Board & Card Games (38)
CelJaded Top 100 (45)
Best Video Game Bosses (12)
Best Video Game Music (12)
Best Video Games (21)
CelJaded Top 20 (13)
Retrospectives (47)
Board Games Based on Video Games (10)
Rank 40 (3)
See Drangleic (31)
The DS Files (9)
The Layton Files (6)
The Wright Files (6)
Wii U & I (13)
[Comments]
Alex Hajdasz on CelJaded Top 20: Best Magic: The Gathering Flavour Text (Volume 3)
Joe on CelJaded Top 20: Best Magic: The Gathering Flavour Text (Volume 3)
SuwonFC on Retrospective: Etherlords
Moonmist on CelJaded Top 20: Best Magic: The Gathering Flavour Text (Volume 2)
[Tags]
Alex Kidd in Miracle World Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Banjo-Kazooie Bayonetta Bayonetta 2 Bloodborne Civilization: Beyond Earth Civilization V Dark Souls Dark Souls II Dark Souls III Deus Ex: Human Revolution Deus Ex: Mankind Divided DOOM Etherlords II Fighting Fantasy FTL: Faster Than Light Gears of War Gears of War The Board Game Halo Into the Breach Lemmings Life is Strange Magic: The Gathering Magic Duels: Origins Metal Slug 3 Mortal Kombat Pac-Man Panzer Dragoon Orta Phantasy Star Online Rayman 2: The Great Escape Rayman Legends Shenmue Shovel Knight Sonic & Knuckles Sonic Adventure Sonic Mania Sonic the Hedgehog Sonic the Hedgehog 2 Super Mario Bros. Three Dirty Dwarves Toejam & Earl Tomb Raider Under Defeat Virtua Fighter
© 2014-2021 CelJaded. All Rights Reserved.

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


text:
A contrarian world
The Poona Pact: Myths About Gandhi and The Calumnies. A few Random Thoughts.
No discussion of Gandhi raises as much passion as the Gandhi-Ambedkar confrontation that culminated on September 25th 1932 in the Poona Pact. This blog started as a response to a comment I saw on Facebook and is not a ccomprehensive or even coherent narration of the events related to that pact. I've merely, as the title states, shared a few thoughts. Random thoughts.
The comment that triggered me to write said that Gandhi did not sign the Poona Pact and that showed he refused to take responsibility for a pact he engineered.
For the millionth time I'll say this, feel free to reject Gandhi and the pact with your own rationale but don't interpret Gandhi through your lens of Ambedkarite hatred. That's like interpreting Ambedkar using Arun Shourie. Do unto others what you'd like others to do unto you.
Gandhi's life is all about taking responsibility and being accountable. There's not a single bone or cell in Gandhi's body that'd support evading responsibility. Whether it is asking a British judge to impose the maximum sentence or going on a fast to atone for the violence of some during a national agitation evading responsibility is simply not Gandhi.
Gandhi and Ambedkar, at the time of the Poona pact, were leaders of different stature and different influences. Too much is made of Gandhi's stature and the conflict is presented as some David versus Goliath struggle with Ambedkar as David.
Gandhi's Salt March (12th March - 6th April 1930) had mobilized the nation, shaken the pillars of an Empire and attained worldwide attention culminating in, what Churchill memorably described, the "the one time inner-temple lawyer and now seditious half-naked fakir, a type well known in the East, striding up the steps of the viceregal palace and negotiation on equal terms with the King Emperor's representative". Gandhi negotiated with Irwin as the representative of a nation. Such moments thrill us into forgetting that barely within a few months of that pact Gandhi attended the Second Roundtable Conference (Sep-Dec 1931) where his representation of India was challenged by Ambedkar and others. While Churchill identified that Gandhi was becoming the voice of the nation let us not forget that too often his voice was challenged by other Indians, often to the glee of the Colonial regime. This is not to mean that those who dissented or stood against Gandhi were stooges of imperialism though such stooges did exist too. Certainly Ambedkar's motivations were different.
Gandhi's halo of being a voice of the nation was very short lived. Gandhi, upon his return from Second Roundtable Conference, was diminished in stature and the regime conveniently arrested him on 4th January 1932. A month ago he was visiting the King and now he was a guest at His Majesty's jail.
During the fast at Yervada on Sep 20th-25th 1932 India did reconnect with Gandhi emotionally. And that was the leverage Gandhi had over Ambedkar. However, that reconnection too frayed after the pact was signed when upper caste Hindu India was aghast at Gandhi and unleashed its fury on the Mahatma during his tour to eradicate untouchability. Gandhi's stature and his connection to India was as complex as the man himself. This is often missed.
Ambedkar, certainly, was not, at that time, as nationally revered as Gandhi was and he was seen as the chief antagonist in the drama by many on the opposing side. However, he had his leverage too. Gandhi did NOT question the legitimacy of Ambedkar's representation of his people. If anything Gandhi only contested that he too was the representative of Dalits. Dalits can reject that but that was Gandhi's stance. During the negotiations the Ambedkar led faction remained dominant and disciplined. It is forgotten today that M.C. Rajah too had his own negotiations and Ambedkar refused to be aligned with him.
The Poona negotiations, necessitated by Gandhi's fast and opposition to the separate electorate, were between upper caste Hindus that included Malaviya and Untouchables led by Ambedkar. It is unimaginable for Gandhi to have signed the pact on behalf of either party. The fast, despite what Dalits claim, was, at least in Gandhi's view, not against Dalits but for them in the larger sense and it was only against what he perceived as a scheme to perpetually segregate them from the mainstream of Hinduism. And as one who called himself a Dalit by choice it is inconceivable that he'd sign a pact as if he belonged to the other side. Whether he signed it or not he did not shy from the burden of what the pact meant and took the cause of Dalit emancipation to be above national liberation.
Dalits often bristle, with justification, at the idea of a Bania savior. But this is reality in India. Given the iron framework of casteism in India only a Gandhi could've even made a dent on behalf Dalits on the issue of caste. In 2019 a car driver of a backward caste refuses to step into the memorial at Keezhvenmani. This is the reality. Without Gandhi as ally Dalit cause would not have even made the progress that it did. In an analogous way it took a Kennedy and LBJ to turn MLK's dream into legislation. Hillary took heat for pointing that out.
My good friend mentioned how Gandhi used fasting as a tool and almost was indignant that Ambedkar is being cast as one who took Gandhi to the brink of his life. Whether one is a Gandhian or just an admirer of Gandhi if one understood Gandhi one would not fault, in the least bit, Ambedkar for what Gandhi inflicted upon himself. Both the upper caste Hindu panel and Ambedkar led untouchables negotiated almost with no thought of Gandhi dying though that possibility hung over their heads. And not a single leader in Gandhi's camp blamed Ambedkar for the possibility that Gandhi would die because the decision to fast was Gandhi's not Ambedkar's.
Once the number of seats, 148, that'd be reserved was agreed upon the sticking point was the conduct of a referendum about whether the scheme was working or not. Ambedkar wanted 10 years to be the period after which the referendum was conducted. Gandhi felt that that was undue delay and became adamant on conducting a referendum within a year or at least 5 years. When Ambedkar dug in his heels Gandhi flung down the gauntlet "there you have it, 5 years or my life".
Was Gandhi blackmailing Ambedkar? In the crude sense of the term absolutely yes. Gandhi knew full well what his death would mean and it was precisely that leverage he used. But then that is EXACTLY the leverage he used time and again whether his fasts were against the colonizer or his fellow Indians who wanted to kill each other. It was that leverage that prevented West Bengal from sliding into a civil war amidst a genocidal bloodshed.
British viceroys were always irritated at Gandhi's pose of piety and felt it was a cloak for the shrewd Bania who negotiated with the tenacity of a haggler at a Persian bazaar. Dalits, today, are essentially hewing to that view and it is a patently uncharitable one. As uncharitable as Arun Shourie casting Ambedkar as merely a stooge of the Colonial government who wanted to thwart the nationalist struggle with his focus on narrow aims.
Whether it was his Calcutta fast or Poona fast Gandhi's attitude was always that, if he died fruitlessly because the outcome eluded him, it is what God ordained. Gandhi wrote farewell notes on the eve of the Poona fast. To his old friend Herman Kallenbach he wrote, "if god has more work to take from this body it will survive the fiery ordeal". During the Delhi fast, his last, to stamp down communal riots as his health declined when his physician Sushila Nayyar told him that his kidneys were failing he replied, "then my faith in Rama is incomplete". As I type that I am only reminded of Christ at the Garden of Gethsemane, aware of the bloody ordeal about to befall him, pleading with his Father "take away this clip of sorrow. Nevertheless thy will not mine".
The dynamic of Gandhi's fast should be understood before terms like 'blackmail' are used. Gandhi's fasts always were predicated on the faith that the other side, he did not think of them as enemies, will have a modicum of humanity and would relate to him in some corner of their heart. When Rajagopalachari, called Gandhi's 'conscience keeper', asked him, during the Calcutta fast, if he is embarking on a futile act against murderous thugs Gandhi replied that his fast was aimed at not the thugs but the hearts of those who manage the thugs. Gandhi would be the first to object to blaming Ambedkar if he had died in the fast.
I also believe firmly that Gandhi, if he had had even a few breaths left in him, he'd have pardoned Nathuram Godse and possibly even thanked him for according the kind of death that he desired. Gandhi is not made of common clay.
Gandhi's tour of India campaigning against untouchability was epic in scope and reactions. Hindu India even in Gandhi's day had a more tenuous relationship with Gandhi than what is commonly understood today. To the upper caste Hindus Gandhi was a Mahatma as long as he was spouting pieties, chanting the name of Rama, singing Vaishnava Janato, calling on their better angels and above all directing his energies to toppling the colonial regime but whenever Gandhi deviated from the script by talking about reforms or eradicating untouchability or cleaning toilets used by untouchables they'd ether ignore him or reject him. This continues till today. This is the lot of any prophet in any age. This is true, ironically, even of E.V. Ramaswamy. Of all the things that E.V.R preached only his neo-nazi anti-brahmanism took root in Tamil Nadu and all his other causes, chiefly atheism, were thrown into the dustbin by those who call him their god today. Sanatana Hindus hurled abuses and even made attempts on Gandhi's life. Amongst the untouchables, the Mahars, members of Ambedkar's caste carried out black flag rallies against Gandhi. All that said that tour and the awakening it caused were the embers that inspired a free India to confront the problem of caste.
Did Gandhi need Ambedkar to teach him about the ills of untouchability? Not at all. But what Gandhi needed, and Ambedkar provided, at a historical juncture, was a catalytic alchemy that made Gandhi put the nationalist struggle on the back burner and turn to confronting a millennia old leviathan that was choking the body politic of India. At a crucial juncture Gandhi's efforts turned from merely liberating a nation to emancipating a people, all people, and making the goal of egalitarianism the goal of a nation that'd one day be free.
People like Ambedkar have earned their place in history for giving history a nudge. While Gandhi had always talked against untouchability and the unfairness heaped on Dalits the Gandhi after Poona pact was a more radicalized Gandhi who put eradication of untouchability front and center of his liberation struggle. Without Ambedkar's nudge that'd not have happened.
A Periyarist, a habitual hater of Gandhi, would often argue that if only Gandhi and Nehru had acceded to Jinnah's request of loose federalism partition could've been avoided. A nonsensical argument but guess who was against loose federalism. Ambedkar. Ambedkar was a key proponent of a very strong center in his role as architect of the Constitution of free India. Ambedkar distrusted federalism because he feared States would dilute the protections against untouchability.
A full and impartial history of the Poona pact is yet to be written. Jaffrelot, for example, is blunt that Poona pact deprived Dalits of political power that, he is certain, Separate electorate would have given. This is now an article of faith amongst the naysayers or even those who could be academically objective. I find this to be a stretch.
Political power eludes the Dalits but we're assuming that Separate electorates would've worked like a charm. That, in my opinion, is a leap of faith. I need more research but I'll say this for now, based on my American experience of Democracy, Separate electorates would've led to segregated constituencies enshrining a "separate but equal" phenomenon that was equal only on paper. Gerrymandering of constituencies would have literally ghettoized the Dalits. Even with separate electorates Muslims, thanks to Jinnah, clamored for Pakistan. It did not do much good in their own opinion. Democracy rests on the principle of representation of a peoples will through votes. How would free India have conducted elections that could be called representative democracy for separate electorates? Elections and representative democracy are a really wide subject and this aspect is often forgotten in the debates around Poona pact.
Gandhi, to be fair, was not thinking of the above, because those objections I outlined were problems of later day American democracy. Gandhi's chief objection was that separate electorate would effectively sever Dalits from Hinduism. That fear was not without merit. This argument is used as a cudgel against Gandhi and casting him as an agent of upper caste Hinduism. This is bollocks. Ambedkar tossed and turned on the question of which religion to choose for Dalits for their en-masse conversion and eventually decided to not choose the obvious choices, Islam or Christianity, precisely because that'd be a more complete separation from Hinduism and he was not sure how many Dalits would follow. He then chose Buddhism which was often seen as birthed in the womb of Hinduism. Now, how many Dalits actually choose Buddhism? Not many. So is it fair to cast Ambedkar as wannabe protector of Hinduism who did not care what his people really wanted? Of course not.
The story of a nation coming into being is a complex one by itself and when the nation happens to one as complex as India, a nation like no other at that time, and even today, very complex choices were made by equally complicated people. More than unidimensional villains we come across a dizzying array of characters who came in many shades of villainy and heroism. Of those, Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah, to name a few, take the prize for complexity in that order.
Some day, hopefully in a few months, I hope to write a fuller account of the events leading unto and after the Poona pact taking into account wider questions of whether separate electorates would've really worked and Gandhi's actions. Oh, one final word, a Gandhi did sign the pact. It was Devadas Gandhi.
1. Great Soul: Mahatma Gandhi and his struggle with India -- Joseph Lelyveld.
2. Gandhi: The years that changed the world - Ramachandra Guha
3. Dr. Ambedkar & Untouchables - Christophe Jaffrelot
4. Freedom at midnight - Larry Collins and Dominique Lapierre
Posted by Athenaeum at 5:00 AM 1 comment:
Labels: Ambedkar, Gandhi, Indian Independence
A Fortnight in India: What I learned about Modi's India From India-Today, Economic Times and Sun T.V.
Whenever I visit any country I make it a habit to check local press and publications. I did so in India too, naturally. Just one issue of the weekly news magazine 'India Today' was sufficient to encapsulate the state of Modi's India. Thanks to my several hotel stays and the freely supplied 'Economic Times' I got a ringside view of Indian economy especially when the newly minted Nirmala Sitaraman was rolling out changes. Then a few days of watching Sun T.V. gave me the hope that one day BJP may actually romp home as a ruling party in Tamil Nadu or at least as a major ally to the ruling party. Here's what I learned.
I started reading India-Today back in the late 80s, during Rajiv Gandhi's administration, when it was a fortnightly sold at Rs 6. 'Frontline' from 'The Hindu' followed soon after. While Frontline hewed a left wing tilt India-Today tilted to the right. Prabhu Chawla and Swapan Dasgupta from India-Today are now effectively BJP's cheer leaders along with the likes of Indian Express's Tavleen Singh. Arun Shourie is disenchanted with Modi after being a member of the Vajpayee cabinet. All these journalists were united in their disdain and hatred of the Congress regimes. To be fair Rajiv and Congress did do their share to alienate the press. Aroon Purie, editor of India-Today, was a Doon school classmate of Rajiv. With this backdrop the issue dated August 12th 2019 with a cover story "Unsold" about the economic crises affecting the auto-sector was interesting to me for not just the cover story but several other articles and I think the stories offer a snapshot of Modi's India. I'll provide excerpts from key articles. All excerpts are within quotes and anything without a quote is my opinion or information or paraphrasing.
Mutilating Right to Information Act
"India's Right to Information Act, recognized the world over as one of the most robust sunshine laws, has been mutilated". RTI, as the act is popularly known, was passed by Manmohan Singh's government in 2005, following several anti-corruption protest movements led by Anna Hazare that whipped up the middle class mostly. Those protests were key in promoting the idea that the Singh administration was mired in corruption. Yet, it was Singh who created this law that is now undone by the seemingly cleaner administration of Narendra Modi.
India-Today's article summed up not just the dangers of mutilating the act but more importantly how the government used its brute majority. "In the Lok Sabha, the NDA simply used its brute majority to ride roughshod over the objections raised by opposition benches. But in the Rajya Sabha, even though 15 political parties reportedly signed a motion to have the bill referred to a select committee, many backtracked on their demand during voting, fueling apprehensions about the pressure that was exerted by the ruling dispensation".
Drawing a distinction between Donald Trump and Narendra Modi the British weekly The Economist said that unlike Trump who wishes he can use the tax agencies to stifle opposition Modi actually can accomplish it. That is the pressure that India-Today is alluding to.
The Immigration Bogey
Modi and Amit Shah, like Trump, find it useful to stoke the problem of illegal immigration. The US, unlike India, at least, has a problem of real proportions. "Shah's threat", a story in the issue outlines, "to extend the National Register of Citizens from North Eastern states to the rest of the country doesn't square with the census data, which finds immigration rates to be below 0.5 percent in the majority of districts. Besides, many of these immigrants are of Indian origin who have returned from US, UK, Canada, Australia and the Gulf. The census figures belie the government's concern about illegal immigrants, even accounting for the under-reporting of 'illegals'.
Yatras and their costs
The hundreds of crores once spent by Indian government to subsidize the Haj pilgrimage was an irritant for the BJP foot soldier notwithstanding the fact that that subsidy was more to keep the state airline, the only approved carrier, afloat. That subsidy is now gone and there were no riots when it was withdrawn.
Nearly 301,000 pilgrims undertook the Amaranth eater this year costing the "J&K administration Rs 495.2 crores ($72 million)" and a deployment of "40,000 security personnel".
Aaya-Ram & Gaya-Ram
Party hopping politician Gaya Lal was pejoratively referred as "Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram". During the 2019 parliamentary elections Modi openly spoke of opposition party big-wigs waiting to cross over to BJP. While party hopping is not new to India that a PM would stoop to openly declare it at a rally was a new low even by the standards of Indian politics.
The title and subtitle of a story says it all. "A bitter aftertaste: After a spate of inductions of TMC leaders with a dubious past, the BJP is forced to rethink".
"Death of the Opposition"
A letter to the Vice President Venkiah Naidu, also the chairman of Rajya Sabha, signed by 17 opposition statement makes a startling factual accusation that is scary for anyone interested in the health of democracy and democratic norms. "The letter says 60 percent of the bills in the 14th Lok Sabha were referred to parliamentary committees. In the next one, 71 percent of the bills went to such committees. But in the 16th Lok Sabha, when Narendra Modi-led government came to power first, the figure dropped drastically to 26 percent. Now, in the first session of the 17th Lok Sabha, 14 bills have been passed, but not a single one was sent to a house committee". The article blames the opposition party leadership for foisting family candidates to leadership. These leaders, unlike those who stood up to Indira Gandhi, rarely carry a political weight and are not up to the task.
The Auto-Sector Slowdown
Aroon Purie's editorial warned on the issue's first page, "Our government cannot afford to let this sector slide, with the prospect of massive layoffs, adding to the ranks of the unemployed. This has implications that go far beyond economics, it may even lead to social unrest".
India's auto-sector, valued at Rs 8.3 lakh crores, employs, directly or indirectly, 32 million people. "Ram Venkatramani, president of Automotive Component Manufacturers Association (ACMA), said that if improvements do not materialize, around 1 million jobs could be lost - 20 per cent of the total employment in that sector". "Overall sales" of vehicles has "fallen by almost 8 per cent". "The growth rates for both private and commercial vehicle sales are in the red".
Rahul Bajaj, chairman of Bjaj Auto, was blunt, "there is no demand and no private investment - so where will growth come from? It doesn't fall from the heavens". This kind of blunt language is startling in the Modi era especially when it comes from a leader of a much respected Indian brand.
"Demonetisation", V.G. Ramakrishnan, "managing director of of Avanteum advisors" said, "left a mark on the psyche of consumers". A key factor behind the slowdown is that the Indian consumer is putting off purchase of even fast-moving consumable goods (FMCG), a key indicator of slowing down of purchasing power. Liquidity crises and lack of good credit reporting are affecting loans. Added to all that is the whimsical attitude in rolling out regulations. The Bharat Stage VI (BS-VI) regulations, new axle load norms, governmental push for increased use of electric vehicles have all contributed in pushing to the auto-sector to despair. Venkatramani told India-Today, "Changes are welcome, but what put us in a tizzy is the speed at which regulations are changing. It becomes difficult to predict when to invest and in what technology".
All the above paint a grim picture and raise a sharp question of an administration that it's supporters assiduously promote as the most business friendly government. For all the mocking of Nehruvian era of socialism Modi's finance minister is turning to that lethal arsenal of any government facing an economic crises, increasing government spending to boost consumer spending. The prohibition of government departments from purchasing new cars has been lifted and it appears that the government is all set to become the biggest consumer of the auto-sector. This is textbook socialism.
Issues dated 20th August and 31st August of The Economic Times provided interesting perspectives. The front page on 20th August carried a warning from R.C. Bhargava that without government incentives the auto-sector may continue to suffer. Curiously the title used an American word, Motown, to denote India's auto sector.
In a similar vein another sector cried out for government help. "India's software export industry may lose out on its competitive edge due to falling incentives and rising tax rates, industry executives said and have asked the government to extend the policy benefits under the Special Economic Zones (SEZ) beyond April 2020; reduce corporate taxes for large companies and review the buyback tax introduced in the budget".
Continuing the trend of petitioning the government for relief from regulation or seeking help the nascent peer-to-peer lending firms have asked the government to relax the lender limit of Rs 10 lakh and allowing High Net Worth Individuals (HNI) to use the platforms.
Nishanth Vasudevan, head of Motilal Oswald Financial Services, had more warnings in an interview. The foreign investors, Vasudevan said, "feels letdown by the way they're treated" compared to China. Asked about current slowdown he said, "the correction which you're seeing is the actual decline in consumer spending". "Google search for a lot of durables is down by 15-20%". He also added that this is driven more by sentiment and that businesses may not be doing too bad and the expected tax receipts data would provide clarity. He did concede that the economy was growing only at 5.8%.
The editorial column calling for concerted policy action and urgent reforms blamed structural woes like subsidies. "India's share of global exports", the editorial said, "is just 1.7%". Essentially on the map of world trade India is less than a blip. Forget about being super power India is not even a power to reckon with at the global trade map.
On August 30th with executive fiat the finance minister announced the merger of "Ten PSBs into Four" (per The Economic Times headline on 31st). In one fell swoop India created four really mega banks. This runs completely counter to the US wariness of big banks and the desire in US policy making circles to breaking up big banks. US banking regulations, called Dodd-Frank regulations, promulgated after the financial crises of 2008 that almost destroyed the world's greatest economy agonizes in great detail about how to methodically unwind a too-big-to-fail financial institution. Indian journalism often leaves much to be desired and is more often just clerical writing and on this epochal event the reportage was pathetic.
The finance minister claimed that the criteria for the pairings of specific banks was driven by "tech-integration" capabilities rather than "geographical capability". Such rationale is unheard of and really no tech study was proffered. "Managing directors of these banks were informed of the merger decision earlier in the day by the the department of financial services even though discussions had been going on for some time". The reportage did not say at what organization levels discussions were held and what "going on for some time" meant. The managing directors presiding over hundreds of crores of depositor cash were informed like they were peons.
The editorial page of ET cheered the move saying it is in line with making India a $5 Trillion economy but cautioned on the lack of "supportive regulation". With the US crises serving as a caution a responsible newspaper, let alone one focused on economics, should have screamed first about the lack of regulation prior to such a move and scream about possible financial crises that could cripple the Indian economy. Note, India's economy if it faces a US style crises lacks many of the abilities that were at the disposal of US economy. Till date the government has shown absolutely no inclination to create a Dodd-Frank equivalent.
The issue dated August 31st announced the bank mergers on front page and along side carried dismal statistics on the economy with an equally prominent headline as the one for the merger news, "Meter Down: At 5%, Economic Growth at 6 yr Low in June Qtr. The editorial summary is grim: Manufacturing, around 16% of India's economy, collapsed totally: from growing more than 12% in Q1 of last year, to stalling at 0.6% now", "car sales have crashed to 20-year lows","Household consumption has also fallen","Mining, metals, minerals and so on are in a downward spiral", "Capacity utilization of companies below 80%". The editorial said that the only silver lining, if one looked for it, is that the "government is clearly not trying to hide the bad economic news". If that's the silver lining only god can save Indian economy.
A recent ranking of universities worldwide showed that not one of India's coveted institutions have cracked the ranking above 300. Forget about cracking the top 10 or 50 or 100. A.M. Nik, chairman of Larsen and Toubro and head of National Skills Development Corporation in an interview with ET sounded beyond pessimistic.
Asked about Normal Sitaraman's call to foreign students to study in India Naik was dismissive saying, "problem is everybody is going out of the country and nobody is coming in. India has a few good educational institutions but they require a very high cut off which a lot of people can't get. We don't have good teachers and the education system itself has been watered down in line with the no-fail policy". "Finding the right teaching talent is the biggest problem. We need institutions to train teachers".
While Naik laments the very absence of good teaching the government thinks, per an article in ET on 20th August about the LEAP program, that lack of leadership skills amongst event good academicians is hurting India from making it big on global rankings. "Over the last 5 years 11 of the 40 central universities have seen inquiries, show cause notices and even sackings of vice-chancellors". Let that sink in for a moment. Nearly one-fourth of central universities are run by no good vice chancellors.
LEAP (Leadership for Academicians Program) started in 2018 with 269 has managed to identify 46 high-scorers, whatever that means, for leadership role. Again, think on that for a moment. In a country of a billion people a leadership program has found 46 'high-scorers'. Only god can save Indian education.
Institutional Corruption, Religious India and a Titular Prime Minister
When former finance minister P. Chidambaram was arrested BJP supporters openly celebrated it as engineered by Amit Shah, the home minister. This was supposed to be tit for tat for Amit Shah being arrested and exiled from his home state when Chidambaram was home minister. In Indian politics, the rule of law be damned, what is important is that your side gets tit-for-tat. On August 20th ET reported that two top ranking officials in National Investigating Agency were under investigation for blackmailing a business man in return for not falsely including his name in a terror-finance related case. The use of central agencies, particularly tax related and intelligence agencies, as puppets to settle political scores is now openly cheered by partisan supporters.
Nilanjan Mukhopadhyay in an oped in ET dated 31st August wrote, "if not in word, then in sprit, what is being increasingly endorsed is the notion that if democracy is a collateral damage while strengthening the nation, so be it".
What is emboldening Modi? How did he muster this majority? Why is secularism almost dead in India today? Why is the notion of keeping religion private would never have a chance in India? Was secularism, as defined by modern liberalism, ever a reality in India? To find those answers let us turn briefly to statistics of India's tourism.
For all the wonderful heritage stretching back into more than a millennia and the country being populated by places of history and natural beauty India's place in world tourism, like it's place on world trade, is pathetic. While France and Spain lead the US with 89 and 83 million tourist visitors compared to 80 million for US when it comes to dollar value the US earns $214 billion compared to $67 million and $74 million respectively for France and Spain. India gets 17 million tourists and earns $29 million. B.K. Goswami, former Director General of tourism for Government of India, in a letter to ET points out that 90% of Indian tourism is domestic tourism and of that 80% is related to pilgrim tourism.
Indians are religious to an extent that is not seen in the Western world and they flaunt it. Nothing intrinsically wrong with that but that is a key factor in the rise of Narendra Modi. Turn on Tamil Nadu's cable TV channels, even the one run by the state's principal political party that pays lip service to secularism and atheism, one is drowned in religious propaganda. All channels run some form astrology related programs in the morning. The obnoxious serials freely load the stories with religious, mostly Hindu, themes or references. Thanks to Sun T.V. and the religious programs it is running it is possible that the BJP might actually become a significant player in the state or even possibly a ruling party in its own right.
Now, many may laugh at the prospect of BJP becoming a major party in Tamil Nadu but my tour made me think that. As I said in my last blog I'll turn, in my next and last blog on the tour, to the religious fervor that is gripping the state and the reasons, in my opinion, as to why Narendra Modi, despite such dismal economy, romped home with a brute majority in the parliamentary elections.
One thing is clear though, if anyone suggests even remotely that they support Modi only for economic governance or mostly for that reason and if they are still sticking with that reason they owe an answer to those who think it is hogwash.
Posted by Athenaeum at 10:26 PM 1 comment:
Labels: India, Narendra Modi, Tourism
A Fortnight in India: Lots of History, Architecture, Artless Cities and Reading Habits of Indians
After nearly ten years I visited India, again, as tourist last month. When I last visited India, for touring, in 2010 Manmohan was into his second term. Though I had made several visits in 2014-15 they were for medical emergencies and involved no touring. Narendra Modi had just then wrested power after a decade long reign by Manmohan Singh. Modi has recently won a massive victory that all but decimated the entire opposition and is set to rule for the next 5 years. What did I see?
Landing in a New India
V.S. Naipaul's trilogy on India started with "An area of darkness", a book that still riles up Indians and continued, slightly mellowed but equally offending to many Indians in "A Wounded civilization" and finally concluded in the now dated but thematically relevant, "India: A million mutinies now". Naipaul, wrote 'A wounded civilization' as India's democracy was under assault by Indira's Emergency. He lamented, "nothing beyond food - and survival - had as yet become an object of ambition". Nearly a half century later India has come a long way from that. The country now can feed itself, says no to foreign aid, even offered a billion dollar finance to Russia, looks to conquer the space, careers for graduates now have multiplied from the binary choice of Doctor or Engineer and the economy can no longer be jeered at as 'Hindu rate of growth'. That is the India of 2019 I stepped into.
Compared to the days when visa application involved a distasteful visit to Indian consulate now I opted for electronic visa that worked like a charm. The application and approval were pretty simple and at immigration check it was a breeze. I feared, this being my first time with e-visa, some serious trouble but there was none.
My travel this time to Jaipur and Bengaluru was made possible by the availability of flight connections. Air travel has been truly democratized in India. Gone are the days when air travel was meant for the high and mighty. The budget airline Indigo really serves well with good connections and good service. For all my bookings I had used the 'Fast Forward' service that promised delivery of checked baggage to be prioritized over others and it was delivered as promised. In 2010 traveling by train was a nightmare due to the stench and cockroaches that ran around. In 2019 I was spared that. Mostly youngsters, girls and boys alike, were the ones doing all jobs. It was heartening to see young girls go around with great confidence as air hostesses and other roles at all hours of the day. However, India's airports, especially the Chennai airports, are completely inadequate to accommodate the fast expanding clientele. Even the business class lounges were ho-hum in Chennai.
Road travel is certainly better than what was possible 20 years ago. There are more highways, by Indian standards, but literally no hygienic rest areas for travelers to use on long trips. On the Jaipur-Agra highway cows literally travel like they own the roads and they're aplenty. My driver, a proud Hindu, said it was because now many are afraid to sell cows for meat they simply let loose cows they cannot afford to continue keeping. The road signs in and around Jaipur in Hindi were just transliteration of English words like 'Lane' etc. In Tamil Nadu English words are more often translated.
The hospitality at the hotels I stayed (a Taj, a Marriott and a Hilton) was beyond exemplary. At these luxury hotels the staff go above and beyond to make the visitor comfortable. Whether it is the chauffeurs or even the ill informed guides I've absolutely no complaint about anyone on a personal level. They were all polite to a fault and many where very aware of online reviews and handed cards requesting good reviews. I did oblige and they richly deserved it. The hotel amenities and buffet choices can make any western tourist feel completely at home. I splurged on Rajasthani and Indian delicacies. I did not come to Jaipur to eat croissants and bagels.
Jaipur and Belur-Halebid
The Amer fort near Jaipur was fabulous. The elaborate courtyards, the exquisite Sheesh Mahal studded with mirrors, the baths and toilets, the harems and their secret passageways transport the visitor to a different era.
The sprawling temples in Thanjavur, Belur and Halebid were breathtaking. Though I've been to the Big Temple in Thanjavur a hundred times the recent study of the Chola empire made me the see the temple anew. Now the fort like structure of the temple became readily apparent and I remembered historians drawing attention to the fact that temples were not just temples but literally fortresses.
The City Palace in Jaipur, constructed by Maharaja Sawai Man Singh II in 18th century, is kind of typical with large courtyards and mirrors as stucco in halls elaborately designed. Two large silver urns, the largest of it's kind in the world, are exhibited in this palace. Those urns, with water from Ganges, were taken by Maharaja Sawai Macho Singh II when he went to attend Edward VII's coronation in 1901, so he could use it daily during his stay abroad. I was reminded of how Gandhi was mocked for taking two goats with him to London when he went for the Round Table Conference because he'd only drink goat's milk.
Silver Urn used to transport water from Ganges
Whenever I travel to a place I try to visit any book store that I come across to find books of local interest. I was immensely happy to grab a copy of a book on Jaipur by legendary historian Jadunath Sarkar. The preface suggested that Jadunath, who wrote the book at the behest of the Rajput royal household, was open to downplaying the collaboration of the Rajput royals with the Mughal regimes of yore. The preface added that such sensitivities are now muted and the book now published is the definitive edition. It is disheartening to see a historian of Sarkar's caliber willing to mute pages of history and it raises, yet again, the question of how much of Indian history has been truthfully told.
As we crossed a posh locality of Jaipur I was informed that that's where the Chief Minister, his cabinet and top state officials have their bungalows. I was suddenly reminded of my own town Thanjavur where likewise the city judge, top police official, public works department official and collector have their bungalows on a prominent highway. Likewise in Chennai. Then it dawned on me that in India feudalism is still alive unlike the US where state officials, except perhaps the Governor, and township officials and elected representatives live amongst their neighbors.
From the hard rock temple of Thanjavur to the soft rock temples of Belur the architecture varies reflecting the era and the material. The Belur temple has intricate architecture made possible by that soft rock. The temples were spell binding if one paused and wondered how such vast acreage was planned out and built. At Belur the sculptures that line up the gopurams are often repeated with little or no variation. If one saw Belur one can skip Halebid or vice-versa. Sure, it's easy to visit both but there's quite some overlap in the architecture.
Vishnu as Half-Lion Half-Man tearing into the bowels. A sculpture at Belur.
Taj and Fatehpur Sikri
The grandiosity of Taj needs no commentary. My guide, completely ignorant of the history of painting etc, pointed with wonder how the Koran inscriptions that run along the doorway of towering structure appears to be of same width throughout but are not. He did not know that the Mughals introduced the idea of 'perspective' in drawing to India. Anyone who has seen Michelangelo's David might wonder why his hands are disproportionate. The statute was to have been installed atop a church and Michelangelo, the genius that he was, was compensating for the viewer's 'perspective' from tens of feet away and below the statue but the statue was instead kept at ground level.
The city of Stratford-upon-Avon depends on the busloads of tourists who come to visit Shakespeare's home and it is a picture perfect town to visit and relax. On the contrary visiting the Taj has to be done business like. The approach and vicinity are an insult to the monument. No wonder Naipaul thought that the Taj is a misfit in India and it appears as only a monument to a wife who bore 14 children. He felt that transported slab by slab to a US state it might have better meaning. I completely forgot having read that passage and honest to god those are my exact sentiments and I was stunned to read that passage tonight.
Akbar's city, Fatehpur Sikri, reflected his catholicism in the building where he held audience. A central pillar fuses Hindu, Christian and Buddhist styles in that hall. Akbar's Hindu wife had her own lavish palace complete with place for worship and even separate kitchen. The man was a complete gentleman. I did wonder, seeing that pillar, if Hindu kings have accommodated other faiths in their palaces? I don't know.
Ziegenbalg, Evangelism and Keezhavenmani
Tamil Nadu was a major port of entry for Christian evangelism in India. Bartholomaus Ziegenbalg, a German missionary, landed in Tranquebar (known in Tamil as 'Tharangambadi') as part of a Danish mission on 9th July 1706. Tranquebar was given as a territory to Danes vide a treaty between Tanjore Nayak prince and the Danish delegation on 19th November 1620. The treaty stipulated, amongst other things, that the Danes are free to practice their religion and they'd not be discriminated. It is here that protestant evangelism began in India. An interesting episode, per an exhibit at the Danish fort, was the massacre of Danes by an army sent by the 'Nabob of Tanjore' in June 1756 due to what appeared to be a misunderstanding that the Danes had broken the treaty. Another exhibit spoke of how the right-hand caste people objected to left-hand caste people using a palanquin. Also Brahmins organized a strike and then a revolt when an oil presser of lower caste used a parasol and wore slippers. The first converts were 5 natives in 1707.
A key contribution of Ziegenbalg was the importation of printing press and translating to Tamil the Bible. The Ziegenbalg museum honestly stated that the aim was religious conversion for the printing press and translation. However they incorrectly claim that this was the first printing press in India. Note, even today most Hindu scriptures are only in Sanskrit and if at all translated it is in English by a Westerner. Despite nearly 300 years of active evangelism and proselytization the state of Tamil Nadu and the surrounding areas remain Hindu majority and the town is ringed by venerable temples. That tells us something about the paranoia concerning religious conversions is just that, paranoia.
Bible Translated and Printed in 1713.
I also visited Keezhavenmani, a sleepy village near Thanjavur. It was the site of a horrific massacre of 44 Dalits on December 25th 1968 when women and children taking refuge at a hut were burned alive. A dilapidated memorial stands there. A man claiming to be the younger brother of the owner of that hut, called 'Ramiah's hut', showed me around and shared a few words. I'll return to this topic in the last part of my series on the travel when I discuss caste and religion.
Artless Cities and Intellectual Vacuity
Whether it is Sheesh Mahal in Amer fort or Fatehpur Sikri's palaces or the temples the artistic heritage is breathtaking and a depressing reminder of the current artlessness of the cities. One has to wonder how did such a civilization decay and become so artless? The cities are completely bereft of aesthetics. Whether one travels in the countryside of England, even a not so affluent quarter, or the many quaint downtowns of US or the many cities of Europe there's a sense of beauty and aesthetics whereas Jaipur, Chennai and Bengaluru are an assault on the senses with not just the ubiquitous squalor but how neighborhoods lack any character. There's no sense of a neighborhood. You've money you build to suit your whims. The colors are jarring. Chennai roads are literally overrun with chrome plated railings and road signs. It's an eyesore. Metal just criss-crosses the city like gashes on a body.
V.S. Naipaul had similarly wondered why a civilization with a tradition of art in contemporary times created buildings and monuments that were artless. He reasoned, "The British pillaged the country thoroughly; during their rule manufactures and crafts declined", "a biscuit factory is a poor exchange for gold embroidery. The country has been pillaged before. But the continuity had been maintained. With the British, continuity was broken. And perhaps the British are responsible for this Indian artistic failure". We should remember that Naipaul was a doubly the subject of a British colony, India and Trinidad. He further added, "It was a clash between positive principle and a negative; and nothing more negative can be imagined that the conjunction in 18th century of static Islam and a decadent Hinduism. In any clash between post-Renaissance Europe and India, India was bound to lose" ('An Area of Darkness' by Naipaul)
Sheesh Mahal - Amer Fort
In 2010 traveling on Trichy-Madurai highway I was appalled by how many vehicles travel on the wrong side with impunity and how blessed we were not to have been in a fatal accident. In 2019 even small towns in Tamil Nadu, like Thanjavur, and cities like Bengaluru and Chennai literally had walls as median dividers, in let alone highways, in local roads too. It was such a revolting sight to see brick walls erected as dividers. When the dividers were small enough to prevent vehicles cattle and people behaving like cattle would happily cross over and these higher walls became necessary to avoid that.
A decade who while visiting Madurai Meenakshi temple and Nayakkar Mahal I felt that the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments organization (HR &CE) and the Archeology Survey of India that maintain those respective places insult and deface history. I felt the same at Parthasarathy temple at Triplicane in Chennai this time. Indians often lament about treasures of India being smuggled to Western countries but I wonder if, the illegality notwithstanding, it is better than letting the treasures rot in India. Western museums showcase Indian art with respect and regard that Indians have never showed to their own treasures. Note, this is not to argue in support of nefarious illegal acts but to drive home a point.
The HR&CE department has practically created an office inside a smaller temple in the Big Temple premises and walled off a section with the divider rudely cutting into a pillar adorned with a sculpture. It's almost as if it is the mistake that the temple, built a 100 years ago (this part was recent addition) did not anticipate this need. See picture below.
Here's what I wrote, ten years ago:
I think back with lots of pain about the immense pleasure I got out of visiting historical landmarks in the west. When Indians react with smugness looking at 'stolen' treasures in British museums I say "at least the treasures are where they are respected".
My sentiments remain the same a decade later.
Two years ago I visited Italy and the many beautiful cathedrals of Christendom. In almost every church we could get finely produced brochures, for a price, that detail the history of the church and the biblical myths associated with a place. Whether it is Amer Fort in Jaipur or Taj Mahal or Fatehpur Sikri or Parthasarathy temple such brochures were completely absent. At Jantar-Mantar, an 18th century observatory, there's literally a crying need for better information about the instruments. At Taj Mahal the ASI had a depot that was dilapidated, dusty and a sleeping attendant with shoddily produced brochures of, not Taj, but Fatehpur Sikri.
The guides were mostly just hawkers who know where to get your tickets, the way inside and out. Beyond that they should be awarded a legal punishment for the butchering of history. At Amer fort the guide pointed to the toilets, with drainage system, and beamed that no one else in the world had something akin to it. I did not have the heart to tell him that probably the Roman baths that predated Amer fort had something similar. I've been to Bath, England too. At Halebid, Karnataka the guide bragged, pointing to a sculpture, that it was a binocular and it shows we invented binoculars before Galileo. Pointing to a sculpture of a warrior raining arrows he helpfully explained that it was the precursor of scud missiles. And when my lady friend stepped away he pointed to an erotic sculpture and whispered, conspiratorially in my ears, "you can take photographs". I did not.
"Together with the triviality of Indian thought on most subjects", wrote Naipaul in 'India: A Wounded Civilization", "the intellectual deficiencies of the archaic civilization finally revealed during this Emergency". Nowhere is this evident even today than in the book stores of a city like Bengaluru. Chennai is even worse when it comes to book stores.
Aside from visiting Belur-Halebid in Karnataka I spent a morning at one of the well known bookstores of Bengaluru, Gangaram Book Store and few others in Church Street. An elderly store assistant was thrilled to help me. He literally embarrassed me by running around and hauling books for me based on my preferences. I told him to stop but he persisted saying, "it's rare to see anyone ask for the books you did". As a fellow bibliophile he was just plainly excited. I had decided not to buy books that I'd get in US or through Amazon in general. I wanted local publications on local topics.
While I came across some gems like M.C. Chagla's autobiography, a book on India's churches etc the majority of the books were by hobbyists and not by academicians. Rajmohan Gandhi is now considered a historian and that's the high bar the rest are really scary. A starry eyed biographer of Sardar Patel had a chapter titled, "Lenin and Bardoli". I duly kept the book back in the shelf. Religion sells, by the bushels. Savarkar has become the subject of two recent biography. I bought one by Vikram Sampath and in 20 pages he has managed to make me puke with thinly veiled caste pride and hollow high praises. And that's a Penguin publication. Sigh. Sardar Patel clearly has become a good selling subject. India's academicians rarely publish for the common reader and maybe, given their quality, it is a blessing. The number of books on international topics are slim picking and its a usual reflection of the insular intellectual taste of Indians.
A visit to a book fair in Thanjavur was a windfall for me for all the books I bought from Kalachuvadu (Footprint) and few other publishers. However I am sure the publishers themselves had no windfall as most stalls were visited by window shoppers. High School children from pricey private schools came by the bus loads and most shopped for coloring text books or books less than Rs 15-20. Of course, no book was available at that price. Cinema tickets don't sell at that price level. Being a publisher in India is a Karmic punishment perhaps.
Whether it was at Bharati's memorials at Triplicane and Pondicherry or at Kalakshetra one is pained that Bharathi and Rukmini Devi Arundale still lack good definitive and academic biographies. Bharathi signified the birth of modern Tamil verse and prose and Rukmini Devi midwifed a classical art. Yet, we only know stories about both of them.
While India proved Naipaul wrong on the lack of ambition it, sadly, continues to vindicate his chiding of the intellectual backwardness of the country in 1976. "India's intellectual second-rateness, which is generally taken for granted but maybe the most startling and depressing fact about the world's second most populous country".
That intellectual second-rateness and the current political state of India are intricately braided with great consequence for the world at large and for India. That takes me to the question of how did Narendra Modi win such a thumping victory? As is my habit I indulged a bit in local news magazines and newspapers. Just one issue of India-Today, a news magazine published since the 1970s, with a cover story on the fiscal woes of the automobile sector provided enough material on the state of India today. About that, in the next blog.
Posted by Athenaeum at 10:42 PM 2 comments:
Labels: India, Tourism
The Poona Pact: Myths About Gandhi and The Calumn...
A Fortnight in India: What I learned about Modi's ...
A Fortnight in India: Lots of History, Architectur...
அமெரிக்காவில் ஒளிர்ந்த காந்தியப் பேரொளி
மகாத்மா காந்தி கொலையுண்டச் செய்தியினை இந்தியாவுக்கும் உலகுக்கும் அறிவித்த ஜவஹர்லால் நேரு , " நம் வாழ்விலிருந்து ஒளி மறைந்து வி...
Jayalalitha Jayaram: A Riddle Wrapped in an Enigma. A Life of Tragedies, Hubris, Victories and Downfall.
The conviction of Jayalalitha Jayaram, a sitting Chief Minister, for amassing wealth beyond known sources of income and her subsequent unse...
Balu Mahendra: Artist, Plagiarist and Philanderer
Roger Rosenblatt eulogized JFK Jr in Time magazine saying "When a man dies, a civilization dies with him. Whatever constituted his b...
Devyani Khobragade: A life in privilege, corruption and feudalism
Devyani Khobragade is a poster child for everything that is wrong with India's quota based reservation system, a feudal and corrupt bur...
உ.வே.சா போற்றுதலுக்குரியவரா? ப. சரவணனின் உ.வே.சா பதிப்புகளின் சிறப்பு
உ . வே . சா என்றறியப்பட்ட ' உத்தமதானபுரம் வேங்கடசுப்பையர் மகன் சாமிநாதன் ' (1855-1942) தமிழ்த் தாத்தா என்று பரவலாக அறியப்படுபவர் ....


NEWARK, N.J. and CHENNAI, India, Sept. 18, 2018 /PRNewswire/ -- AGS Health Inc., a global healthcare revenue cycle management company has been named for the third year in a row to the prestigious 2018 100 Best Companies for Women in India (BCWI) list produced by AVTAR Group and Working Mother Media. Currently in its third edition after a highly successful run in 2016 and 2017, the BCWI Study aims to recognize and bring into foray the sustained initiatives undertaken by companies to increase women's workforce participation.
"The exemplary companies that made the 2018 100 Best Companies for Women in India list represent the most progressive companies for women. We applaud their vision and efforts to create and sustain a work environment where women can advance and thrive." said Subha Barry, President, Working Mother Media.
The 2018 edition had 345 companies participating across industries, who were assessed across multiple criteria such as workforce demographics, recruitment, retention and career advancement programs, safety and security initiatives, benefits, culture, leave and flexible work, and work-life programs.
Commenting on the initiative, Dr. Saundarya Rajesh, Founder – President, AVTAR Group, said "To see organizations evolve their enablement framework to one that acknowledges and supports the holistic well-being of employees, specifically women, is extremely heartening. Offering such support especially at critical life events like maternity helps women professionals navigate emotion hurdles and build successful, sustainable careers. With personalized handholding, their engagement with their employers are heightened and growth to leadership is a natural, logical extension. The 2018 BCWI data tells us just that."
AGS Health is an analytics driven, technology enabled Revenue Cycle Management Company providing services to leading healthcare providers across the U.S. With a global workforce of over 5000 billing and coding specialists, AGS Health has been ranked as the 12th Largest Revenue Cycle Firm in the US by Modern Healthcare, and among the Top 100 Global Outsourcing Companies in the World by the International Association of Outsourcing Professionals (IAOP).


text:
Scientific Gatekeeping
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2021/01/flyer-tipping/
Yes, it's clear that people will leave all sorts of junk out there, not because they want to get rid of it — like dumping an old refrigerator in the woods — but because they want to create fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) in the community of ideas. Unfortunately, this has the effect of poisoning the atmosphere for truly novel ideas in climate science that should be considered.
It really should be no more difficult for you to debunk a serious and earnestly contributed idea as having to wade through the FUD. Note how in the discussion to my own idea, the NOAA reviewer essentially says he has "wasted his time".
https://esd.copernicus.org/preprints/esd-2020-74/
He doesn't realize that his fellow NOAA scientists have equally novel ideas that they are throwing out there, e.g. http://moregrumbinescience.blogspot.com/2016/01/earth-sun-distance-and-chandler-wobble.html
Same goes for NASA scientists who give up in their quest for funding on these angles, see https://www.moonclimate.org/
All of these get lost in the noise of climate change clutter.
One has to recognize that William Connolley (via Wikipedia) and the folks at SkepticalScience.com have taken their "gatekeeping" duties too zealously, and may routinely throw out the baby with the bathwater for any new climate science research that may come about from amateur channels. Unlike astronomy and astrophysics, where amateur input is typically welcomed, these channels seem to be not conducive to new ideas. I have tried adding discussions to SS.com but they clamp down quickly, to the point I no longer use it as a resource for climate science innovation news — that's why at least RealClimate.com is refreshing.
Challenge to Skeptical Science is to debunk the stuff that is cutting edge research, such as this from Marcus, previously of NASA JPL. Does an Intrinsic Source Generate a Shared Low-Frequency Signature in Earth's Climate and Rotation Rate?
Derivation of an ENSO model using Laplace's Tidal Equations


text:
Quick Preview
/gs_flipbook/flip.php?xml=/demo_xml/116806.xml&w=500&h=324
The Boardgamer Magazine - Volume 1, Issue 2
Past Into Print
In this issue, published in April 1996, the articles include:
Avaloncon 1995 - A First Timer's Experience
History Of The World Series Replay - One Player's View of a GEnie PBEM Game
History Of The World Series Replay - The Red Point of View
History Of The World Series Replay - The Black Point of View
AREA News - For The Minority
ASL AREA News - Excerpts From The ASL News, Electronic Edition
Revised Rules - Combining Panzerblitz and Panzer Leader
Revised Panzerblitz and Panzer Leader Rules - Questions and Answers
The British Dilemma - A 1776 Scenario
The Boardgamer magazine was a quarterly magazine devoted primarily, but not exclusively, to the coverage of Avalon Hill / Victory Games titles and to other aspects of the boardgaming hobby.
Initially, The Boardgamer's publication ran concurrently with Avalon Hill's house magazine, The General, but instead of focusing on new releases, it devoted coverage to those classic, Avalon Hill games which no longer graced the pages of The General.
Following the cessation of The General in June 1998, The Boardgamer was the primary periodical dedicated to the titles from AH/VG, until its final issue in 2004.
Bundles containing this product:
Boardgamer Magazine Collection 37 Issues [BUNDLE]
The Boardgamer Magazine - Volume 9, Issue 4 - Final Issue
Strategic/Campaign
Tactical/Skirmish
Boardgames/Card Games
Bruce A. Monnin
This title was added to our catalog on June 14, 2013.


Gaspari Nutrition Glutamine is pure L-Glutamine Powder and supports Muscle repair and reduced soreness. It supported goal is build muscle & main ingredient is glutamine.
Gaspari glutamine post workout is rapidly absorbed glutamine complex and enhances muscle recovery and growth. It includes increased recovery and growth hormone facilitation. It enhances rehydration and endurance, which leaves you with more power in the fitness center.
Gaspari nutrition glutamine delivers micronized,muscle recovery, potency and purity. It is a pure supplement for sports nutrition. It is using an ultra-pure L-Glutamine with no synthetic colors or fillers.it an solution in amino acid supports. Please make sure yourself while taking gaspari glutamine drink at least 8-10 glasses of water daily for best use of it.
It is ultra pure l-glutamine with a scoop.
Provides the most abundant amino acid in the body.
This is unflavored and mixes easily with fluid.
It supports muscle repair and reduced soreness.
Gaspari glutamine is a quick recovery powder after exercise. It is an award winning supplement and we never heard about any bad effects on it. It's a best supplement used by people around the world.
Mixes one scoop of gaspari glutamine powder with 200 ml of water per day after workout. Please drink plenty of water every day. Do not surpass the suggested daily dose. Seek advice from a medical doctor prior to use if you have any medical conditions.
Note: All Gaspari Nutrition Supplement sold at Proteinsstore.com are 100% Genuine. Buy Best Glutamine Supplement in India.


text:
Kelly Weill on Flat Earthers, Conspiracy Culture, and Why People Will Believe Anything
Michael Shermer speaks with journalist Kelly Weill whose work covers extremism, disinformation, and online conspiracy theories in current affairs. The conversation is based on her book Off the Edge which tells a powerful story about belief, polarized realities, and what needs to happen so that we might all return to the same spinning globe.
eSkeptic for March 1, 2022
Lee McIntyre — How to Talk to a Science Denier: Conversations with Flat Earthers, Climate Deniers, and Others Who Defy Reason
Science deniers are not merely uninformed—they are misinformed. How can we get them to change their minds and accept the facts when they don't believe in facts? In episode 203, Michael Shermer speaks with Lee McIntyre about how to talk to science deniers such as flat earthers, climate deniers, and others who defy reason, and why it's important to do so.
eSkeptic for August 24, 2021
Donald R. Prothero — Weird Earth: Debunking Strange Ideas About Our Planet
Shermer and Prothero discuss: flat earth theories and how we know the earth is round • hollow earth theories and how we know it's not hollow • the return of Ptolemy and an earth-centered solar system model (and how we know it's wrong) • how science deals with anomalies and fringe claims • Were humans in the San Diego area 130,000 years ago? • flood myths • the age of the earth and how geologists determined it, and more…
eSkeptic for December 8, 2020
We are pleased to announce Skeptic's 100th issue (25.4) which focuses on QAnon in conspiratorial context. Instantly download the digital edition or order the print edition today. PLUS: In Science Salon podcast # 146, Michael Shermer speaks Donald Prothero about his new book Weird Earth: Debunking Strange Ideas About Our Planet.
Dr. Lee McIntyre — The Scientific Attitude: Defending Science from Denial, Fraud, and Pseudoscience
In Science Salon # 77, an engaging conversation on the nature of science, Dr. McIntyre and Dr. Shermer get deep into the weeds of where to draw the line between science and pseudoscience.
eSkeptic for July 30, 2019
In Science Salon # 77, an engaging conversation on the nature of science, Dr. McIntyre and Dr. Shermer get deep into the weeds of where to draw the line between science and pseudoscience. PLUS Dr. John Glynn reflects on our ever-increasing sensitivity to the perception of harm in an article about concept creep.
eSkeptic for March 21, 2018
There is growing conspiracy theory belief that the Earth is not a globe, but a flat disc. According to believers, government forces promote a completely fictitious model of the cosmos in order to conceal the true nature of the Earth. Daniel Loxton examines whether these claims are true.
Is the Earth Flat?
The Plane Truth: Noted Skeptic's Newly Published (Posthumous) Book About Flat Earth Theories
Bob Schadewald was the leading skeptical authority on the history of flat-Earth advocacy. Now the book he left unfinished has been prepared and published online.
George Orwell Versus the Flat Earth
Daniel Loxton shares reflections from George Orwell and George Bernard Shaw on the topics of flat-Earth arguments, expertise, and credulity in an age of scientific marvels.
Just as there are still those who believe that the earth is flat (despite all the evidence), there are also those who argue that the earth is actually expanding. Expanding Earthers believe that, at some point in the past the earth was much smaller, and that all the continents fit together nicely. In this week's eSkeptic, geologist Donald Prothero discusses why the notion of an expanding earth is false.


text:
2019 Sachsenring MotoE Post-Race Press Releases
Submitted by Press Release on Mon, 2019-07-08 08:49
Press releases after the first ever MotoE race at the Sachsenring:
Tuuli and Ajo MotoE Team first-ever winners in FIM Enel MotoE World Cup
The Finnish rider and the Ajo MotoE Team make motorcycle racing history and become the first leaders of the newborn championship.
07/07/2019 - Sachsenring, Germany
It's been an unforgettable weekend for the Ajo MotoE Team. After recording the E-Pole yesterday, Niki Tuuli won the first-ever race in the FIM Enel MotoE World Cup at Sachsenring today. The Finn youngster wrapped up a great visit to Germany by becoming the first leader in the overall classification of the championship, in an intense race which saw lots of overtaking and concluded two laps early due to a red flag.
The Ajo MotoE Team rider, who took off from first position on the grid, overcame a difficult start to a race that was reduced from 8 to 7 laps - after being declared wet. The Finn quickly recovered and got in front on the fourth lap. Tuuli held off attempts by his rivals to challenge his lead, starring in an intense race which was cut short with two laps remaining, due to a red flag - with two thirds of the originally scheduled distance completed.
Thanks to this result, Tuuli becomes the first leader in the history of the FIM Enel MotoE World Cup, with 25 points. The next date on the calendar for the Ajo MotoE Team is the Austrian GP, which will be held at the Red Bull Ring from 9th - 11th August.
Aki Ajo - Team manager
"I'm very happy to see how exciting the first race in MotoE history was. Although the races are short, yesterday's E-Pole also impressed me. It is an interesting qualifying procedure. Of course, I'm glad of the performance of Niki [Tuuli], who has been impressive. He's surprised many people in the paddock with his great work. I've known Niki since he was very young and I know how serious he is about this sport. He has a bright future in this championship."
66 NIKI TUULI
"I'm very happy. We were able to produce a great pace throughout the weekend and session by session we took steps forward. In the race, it was harder because we didn't know exactly how the track conditions would be after the rain early in the morning. I began carefully and then after the first two laps I started to push hard. The race was shorter than usual and that meant we had less time to put our strategy into practice. However, in the end I managed to get away from the rest a little bit at the front.
Of course getting the victory is an unbeatable start to the year. We set an incredible beginning to the competition and we know what I am good at and what I need to improve. I like the atmosphere in the MotoE championship, as everything is much simpler and the riders push for results, but also enjoy riding the bike. There's no pressure for me, I'll just try to have fun and do well in the next race."
Historic second place for Smith and ONE Energy Racing in first MotoE race
Bradley Smith finishes on the podium at Sachsenring in the first round of the MotoE World Cup, leading the race for several laps.
ONE Energy Racing and Bradley Smith became part of history in the MotoE World Cup by finishing on the class' first ever podium. The British rider claimed a great second position after starting from the third row of the grid, as well as managing to lead a race that ended prematurely due to a red flag.
Smith made a great start from seventh place, was second into the first corner and quickly got to the front of the race - reduced to seven laps due to a delay in getting underway. The ONE Energy Racing rider continued in the fight for victory, leading on several occasions. With two laps remaining, a crash for another rider resulted in a red flag, ending the race ahead of time and giving Smith second place.
After this result, Smith is second in the overall standings with 20 points, 5 off the top spot. The next round of the MotoE World Cup will be the Austrian GP on August 9th to 11th.
Matteo Ballarin - Team Principal
"We are very happy. Bradley [Smith] had a great race, with a fantastic start. Yesterday's E-Pole did not turn out as we had hoped, but Bradley is a very special rider and today he provided a great performance. The whole team worked very well during this first weekend. We can continue to improve ahead of the next race, but we had a great first weekend here in Germany. Finishing on the podium at the first round is a very positive result. The MotoE World Cup is a new adventure, and there are many things still to be discovered. It is all really exciting."
#38 Bradley Smith
"I'm very happy to have got on the podium at this first MotoE World Cup race with ONE Energy Racing. Yesterday I was somewhat disappointed with my result in E-Pole, but I still knew that if I got a good start I could be in the fight in the race.
I managed to get a very good start and lead the race, so that was nice. I couldn't be a part of the race simulation in Valencia, so I was lacking some knowledge of what the contest was going to be like, but I learned a lot today. It was only five laps, but I know where I can improve for the next round in Austria.
The race was exciting, so that's good for the show and for the competition. I want to thank the team; they changed the bike from yesterday to today and did a great job."
Di Meglio powers to brilliant, historic MotoE podium
Estrella Galicia 0,0 Marc VDS rider Mike di Meglio battles to a superb third place in the shortened first round of the MotoE World Cup at the Sachsenring.
Starting the first MotoE World Cup race in history from fourth on the grid, Estrella Galicia 0,0 Marc VDS' Mike Di Meglio made an excellent start to finish the first lap in second position.
The 2008 125cc World Champion was involved in an all-action four-rider fight for the victory with Niki Tuuli, Bradley Smith and Hector Garzo in the seven-lap race.
Having conserved his rear tyre in the opening laps, Di Meglio had just passed Smith for second on lap six when the race was stopped due to a crash for Lorenzo Savadori.
Results were decided on the leaderboard after lap five, demoting the Frenchman to third.
Mike Di Meglio
3rd, + 0.567s.
"It was as I planned, I am really happy with that podium"
"It was as I planned. I wanted to do a really good first lap and I ended it in second position. I got a good start and braked very late into the first turn but I saw a lot of riders on my inside. I said, 'Mike, keep your speed!' After that I was fighting with Niki and Bradley while trying to manage the rear tyre because it would help me at the end of the race. The tyre was sliding a lot but I think it was because of this cold temperature. I planned to pass Bradley because I saw he was quite a bit quicker. Then when I did that I saw the red flag. But sometimes racing is like that. It was quite good. It was quite good, I am really happy with that historic podium."
Joan Olivé
"All weekend Mike showed good potential and very good rhythm"
"We are very happy to start the new MotoE category with a podium. All weekend Mike showed good potential and very good rhythm. Unfortunately the race was stopped early but I think Mike did a good job with the tyres, saving them for the end. Anyway it's a good result. We don't have so many races in this series so it's good to stay on the podium."
Hard fought MotoE debut for Garzo and Foray in Germany
Following some rain, the first race of the FIM Enel MotoE World Cup was declared wet and shortened to seven laps today, although the Sachsenring track already dried out.
Thereby, Tech3 E-Racing's Hector Garzo came off the line perfectly and lead the field to the first corner. Involved in a hard fight for the podium, the Spanish rider planned to attack towards the end of the race, but was fourth when the red flag came out after five completed laps. Meanwhile, Kenny Foray was progressing from P14 to P12 in the course of the last lap, battled for the points scoring positions and found himself in 14th when the race was declared completed.
Hector Garzo
Position: 4th
Championship: 4th
"Unfortunately, it was a difficult race and not the result we have hoped for. I was waiting for the last two laps. Just the moment before the red flag, I was thinking about my overtake. But well, this is racing. You never know, that this is going to happen. Anyway, I'm happy because we four riders finished with a great time. For sure, I would have been a bit more satisfied to get a podium in the first MotoE race, but still our work is good and we know we are strong in every condition. Thanks a lot to the team, we did a really good job and for the first MotoE race of the history, it's not bad. We must be happy. I'm looking forward to Austria now, keep calm and work hard."
Kenny Foray
Position: 14th
"It was a good race. The result is not, what I expected, but my feeling was better. Now, I need to be more aggressive in the race, because two times, I decided to stay behind the guys in front of me and two times, somebody overtook me. So, I need to push all the time. I was really good on the brakes, but I couldn't take full advantage of this. My feeling on the bike was good, it was great fun. The result is not ideal, but now I need to improve for the next race. I was a good experience for me and I'm happy, although I was hoping for a few more points. I'm sure for Austria, we will be better."
"Finally, we saw our first MotoE race here in Sachsenring. We were very happy with our Qualifying with Hector in the front row and Kenny having a decent Qualifying too. When we saw rain this morning, we were a bit worried, but finally the track dried and we had a very good race. Hector had a fantastic start, because he was leading at the first turn. We could see that there was a battle of four riders and Hector was right inside that fight, waiting for the last two laps to eventually make a move, but unfortunately, we had a red flag that stopped the race with two laps to go. It was a pity, because I think our strategy was working until then. Hector was right behind that group, trying to save the tyres, but because the air fence was broken, you have to red flag the race, so I absolutely understand the decision of the race direction. This time, it didn't play in our favor. Anyway, we soon have another chance to show what we can do in Red Bull Ring. So, all together it was a good weekend for Tech3 E-Racing. I think also Kenny understood a lot of things, especially that a sprint race is not what he is used to in endurance, so he's going to get better and better. Hector is quite frustrated right now, so he will be willing to change and be on the podium next time. Overall, a good round one. I think it was a great show and it's a proper class in our championship."
LCR E-TEAM RIDERS COMPLETE THE INAUGURAL MOTOE RACE
PRESS RELEASE: 07 July 2019 | German GP MotoE Race
The FIM Enel MotoE World Cup is now officially underway, with the first race completed at the Sachsenring. The race was officially meant to run for 8 laps, though was reduced to 7 laps at the start due to the wet conditions. The race was red flagged due to a crash that damaged the air fence, so the result given is the running order as of lap 5.
Another issue riders had to contend with was the weather, with the race officially declared as wet. Both practice sessions and the E-pole session ran in warm, dry conditions, so there was an added challenge of adapting to the bike on the wet track.
For LCR E-Team rider Niccolò Canepa, contact on the first lap pushed him further down the rankings, though he rode well to put himself back into the top 10 at the time the race was red flagged. As the result was given from lap 5, he officially finished 12th. For Randy de Puniet, the Frenchman is still struggling to gain confidence and the correct feeling on his Energica bike, especially following the bad crash he suffered at the Valencia test. The riders both look forward to gaining more experience on the bike and hopefully improving in future races.
Randy De Puniet – 17th
"It was not an easy race – since the beginning of the weekend, as I've explained before, I have zero feeling and I'm not confident after crashing in Valencia. I really hoped to get some more confidence and speed during the race, but it was not the case. I'm sorry to the team and the sponsors but I was not able to do better today. I hope after the break I will feel better on the bike so we will see for the next race."
Niccolò Canepa – 12th
"I'm really upset because I had contact in the first lap – I was in 8th place and was put back to 14th place. I was coming back into the top 10 and was 10th when the red flag came out but they gave the results from the previous lap so I was actually 12th in the results. I feel frustrated because I think this time a 5-lap race is too short."
TOP-FIVE RESULT FOR FERRARI IN FIRST HISTORICAL MOTOE RACE
Team Trentino Gresini made its long-awaited debut in the inaugural race of the MotoE World Cup, and it was a good one: Matteo Ferrari leaves Sachsenring with a fifth place in what was a challenging race – as it was the first-ever encounter of the series – held under mixed conditions due to the overnight rain.
The Italian had a blistering start desite a first-turn coming together with an opponent, when both tried to avoid a damp patch. With a strong race pace, Ferrari was only two seconds away from race winner Tuuli to grab 11 important points.
It could have been a good day also for Lorenzo Savadori, who managed to go all the way up to eighth place after starting from the 11thplace on the grid after overtaking several riders, including Granado and Gibernau. Unfortunately a coming together with the Brazilian rider between turns eight and nine resulted in a nasty crash for the former STK1000 champion, which forced race direction to end the race (red flag).
It has been nevertheless a good debut for Team Trentino Gresini, who will return to the track next month in Spielberg, Austria, for round two.
5th - MATTEO FERRARI #11
"I got a good start and settled into a nice rhythm. Unfortunately we were using the dry set-up except for the engine brake, so I struggled a little bit mid-corner to make the bike turn. Apart from that everything went well and I learned a lot from the guys ahead of me. We just need to be a little bit aggressive, but we showed we have what it takes to battle at the front."
D.N.F. - LORENZO SAVADORI #32
"It's a shame, because I was doing well. I found a nice rhythm and made up several places. The more I ride the bike, the more I'm comfortable and that's how things come together. Too bad for the crash, but it was Granado who took me down. I'm OK, although I got another hit on the left leg and I have a quite swollen finger, but apparently nothing broken."
TOP 10 FOR NICO TEROL AND THE OPENBANK ÁNGEL NIETO TEAM AT THE MOTOE OPENER
Contact in the first corner held up the Spanish rider and forced him to fight in the second group
The first race of the FIM Enel MotoE World Cup will go down in history with a victory for Finnish rider Niki Tuuli after a race scheduled for seven laps and that was reduced to five due to an accident for another rider. Tuuli was joined on the podium by Bradley Smith and Mike di Meglio, after a group battle involving several riders that saw just four of them make the finish line together. Héctor Garzó was the rider who lost out at the line, being forced to sdettle for fourth. The next round of the FIM Enel MotoE World Cup will take place on the weekend of August 11th in Austria.
The Openbank Ángel Nieto Team and Nico Terol begin their adventure within this new electric-powered era with a top ten finish after a race that was difficult from the first corner, when another rider went wide and pushed Nico even further off line. The Valencian dropped back to eleventh, three places behind his starting position, and was only able to recover one place before the red flag. Meanwhile, María Herrera struggled for feeling on the opening lap and by the time she got comfortable in the mixed conditions she had lost touch with the group, the Openbank Ángel Nieto Team rider taking sixteenth in the first round of the season.
10th Nico Terol: "I'm not very happy because we were making good progress. I was going well in the race but another rider forced me off the track at the first corner and five or six riders passed me. I've gone from being able to get into the lead group to dropping way off. I got into a good rhythm but I was already in a more difficult group. I had passed Gibernau for ninth but the red flag took the result back to the previous lap, when I was still tenth. Today I could have ended up fifth or sixth and I want to thank the team for all the work they are doing. We are working well and everything will come - I I feel I can be strong again and aggressive and the winning Nico is back. "
16th María Herrera: "Having not ridden yesterday, I did not have confidence on the first lap. Then I was much better but the group escaped. I tried to keep the distance with them but the race was very short. In the next one I hope to have some new bars that will make me ride more comfortable and keep fighting. "
#MotoE #GermanGP RACE. P6 Alex De Angelis: "I had a great time". P15 Josh Hook: "Positive feelings during the race".
The first race in the history of #MotoE took place today at the Sachsenring circuit. It was a historic event in the world of two wheels with 18 riders and the Energica Ego Corsa fighting until the red flag stopped the race two laps from the end due to the crash of Salvadori.
Alex De Angelis, who started from ninth place, immediately recovered two positions at the first corner and then engaged in an exciting duel with Simeon to finish in sixth position.
Josh Hook started from sixteenth position and managed in the first laps to gain two positions then finishing 15th.
P6 – Alex De Angelis
"I had a great time. At the first corner I chose to brake and stay inside and it was a good tactic because it allowed me to recover some positions. The duel with Simeon made me lose contact with the leading group but it was really exciting".
P15 - Josh Hook
"The feeling with the bike grew during the race. It was very important to be with the peloton on a circuit where I raced on Friday for the first time. It wasn't a particularly satisfying weekend but we have to take the positive side and improve".
Sachsenring, Germany
The Forcada Tapes - Radio Ocotillo Interviews Ramon Forcada - Part 2, On 2020 vs 2019 M1s, 2-Strokes vs 4-Strokes, And MotoGP's Technical Rules
Arm Pump Surgery A Success For Pedrosa, Now Physical Rehab Awaits
The Termas De Rio Hondo Circuit in Argentina: Facts and Figures