text:
Restore Reason
Empowering Rational Discussion
Tag Archives: governor ducey
Linda Lyon
AZ Legislature, Budget, Public Education, teachers, vouchers
So, how's that teacher shortage?
Anyone wondering where we stand with Arizona's teacher shortage? After all, last year was probably the most significant year ever for Arizona public school teachers. Some 75,000 of them marched on the state Capitol demanding better pay for themselves and support staff, lower class sizes and more. The result was an additional 9% salary increase added to the 1% Governor Ducey had originally offered for the year. Surely this must have helped us retain quality teachers, right?
Well, not so fast. As the Arizona School Personnel Administrators Association (ASPAA) learned in their annual statewide survey of districts, we are a long way from "out of the woods" and aren't even headed in the right direction.
The 211 districts and charters that responded last year reported that 7,453 teacher openings needed to be filled during the school year. As of December 12, 2018, there were still 1,693 vacancies and 3,908 individuals not meeting standard teacher requirements, for a total of 75% of teacher positions vacant or filled by less than fully qualified people.
On top of that, 913 teachers had either abandoned or resigned from their teacher position within the first half of the school year without a candidate pool to replace them. To make matters worse, 76% of these teachers held a standard teacher certificate.
These are alarming statistics, made all the more so considering the strides made in 2018, and the worse status since the 2017–18 report. It showed that as of December 8, 2017, 62.5% of teacher positions were vacant or not meeting standard teacher requirements and 866 teachers had abandoned or resigned within first half of the year, over 80% of whom held a standard teacher certificate.
The salary increase didn't solve the problem, partly because salary and benefits still aren't competitive, but also because teacher working conditions (such as high class sizes and the dramatic increase of children dealing with trauma and Adverse Childhood Experiences) make it really tough to do the job right. And, oh by the way, allowing our districts to hire uncertified teachers hasn't done anything to make our teachers feel valued as professionals. As the state's Superintendent of Public Instruction, Kathy Hoffman, told the state House Education Committee yesterday, our teacher shortage is a crisis. To make matters worse, 25% of Arizona teachers are eligible to retire in the next two years.
I'm sure there are people who thought the Governor's #20X2020 plan would fix the teacher drain but of course, it was never going to be that easy. First of all, only 10% of it has been allocated thus far. The other 10% is but a promise and must be appropriated by this, and probably next year's Legislatures.
Quality teachers are the number one in-school factor contributing to student success, so it makes sense that they should be our focus. Ask yourself then why yet again, state legislators are sponsoring several voucher expansion bills that will further drain resources available for 95% of Arizona's students.
We can solve this, and most other problems, IF we have the collective will to do it. Therein lies the rub.
AZ Legislature, Budget, Privatization, Public Education, teachers, vouchers
Sine Freakin' Die Already, Why Don't Ya?
Ever since becoming involved in Arizona public education in 2012, I've heard people ask "why don't teachers stand up for themselves?" Well, they aren't asking that now. At about 6 am this morning, Governor Ducey signed the K-12 portion of the Arizona budget into law. It doesn't contain everything educators wanted, but it contains much more than it would have without the brave, collective action of Arizona teachers.
Here's a quick summary of some of the key elements of the approved budget with my comments or additional facts, interspersed:
– Increases the base level in FY2019 by a 1.8% inflation increase ($276.80) to $3,960.07 (without teacher compensation).
– Provides for an increase to teacher compensation of $176.2M in FY2019, $164.7M in FY2020, and $124.4M in FY2021.
— Keep in mind that FY2020 and FY2021 are "advance appropriations" which basically means a "promise" made now that future Legislatures are asked to keep.
— And because of the way the funding will flow to districts, Dr. Anabel Aportela, director of research for the Arizona School Boards Association and the Arizona Association of School Business Officials says, "it's going to be difficult to show that every single teacher received a 9 percent raise," this year, or a 20 percent raise by 2020. Likewise, an "initial analysis by The Arizona Republic, based on figures provided to the Arizona Auditor General by school districts, shows that 59 districts would not receive enough funding to give all teachers a 20 percent pay raise."
– Requires districts and charters to post compensation data on their websites and ADE to compile this info and submit to Legislature and Governor.
— Local control means governing boards make the decisions they were elected to make and I believe they will have no problem standing behind their decisions.
— This requires more transparency of charters, and that's a good thing.
– Requires ADE to reduce the formula suspension for district additional assistance (DAA) statewide by $100M in FY2019 and $64.4M each year thereafter.
— In other words, begin to restore 85% in cuts to capital funding made by AZ lawmakers since 2009.
— Exempts districts with a student count of fewer than 1,100 students from any DAA reductions, providing them 100% of DAA allocation in FY2019.
– Restores Charter School Additional Assistance (CAA) to full formula funding by FY2022 and increases it by 1.77% for the annual inflation adjustment with no increase to the DAA formula.
– Continues to exclude charter schools from procurement rules designed to ensure maximum competition, contract award to lowest qualified bidder, and that a contractor has a valid license to practice in Arizona.
— This is, in my opinion, is fiscally irresponsible. We should be demanding more transparency and accountability from all institutions that receive taxpayer dollars, not less.
– Increases the State Support Level per Route Mile for FY2018 by 1.77% for the required inflation adjustment.
– Requires each district to prominently post on its website home page a copy of its profile pages that displays the percentage of every dollar spent in the classroom by that district from the most recent status report issued by the Auditor General.
— Note that charter schools, although they are required to conduct audits, get to choose their auditors and the resulting information is not included in the AZ Auditor General schools efficiency report as it is for district schools.
— Also, note there is still a disconnect between what the Auditor General counts as classroom spending and the broader definition used by the governor, Legislature and Arizona public school leaders shows support for the classroom is holding steady. An infographic by AZEdNews illustrates the disconnect.
– Appropriated in FY 2018, $4,145,600 to ADE for the school safety program compared to $3,646,500 in FY 2017. The program will now be repealed on December 31, 2019 instead of December 31, 2018.
– Establishes the Computer Science Program Fund under ADE who will distribute grants on a first come first serve basis to schools that do not currently provide high school computer science instruction.
– Terminates the Schools Facilities Board (SFB) on July 1, 2022 and repeals AZ statutes relating to the SFB.
— It is important to note that the SFB was established in response to a 1994 court decision that found "Arizona's system of school capital finance unconstitutional because it failed to conform to the state constitution's "general and uniform" clause. That system relied on the secondary property tax, driven by the property wealth of a school district, and general obligation bonding. In 1996, the Arizona Superior Court imposed on the state a deadline of June 30, 1998 to develop a constitutional system of school capital finance or risk closure of K-12 public schools. On July 9, 1998 Governor Jane Dee Hull signed legislation that dramatically reformed the way K-12 schools are constructed in Arizona. This ended the four-year legal and legislative battle and established Arizona as the nation's school finance reform leader. This legislation/law is known as Students FIRST (Fair and Immediate Resources for Students Today). On November 18, 1999, the Board adopted Building Adequacy Guidelines that now serve as the minimum standards for existing and new school facilities in Arizona."
— It is also important to note that 24 years later, education groups have been forced to sue the state again, for capital funding, (now called District Additional Funding), that has been cut 85% since 2009.
Four Arizona Education Association (AEA) and Arizona Educators United (AEU) demands that were not funded, include:
– Cap class size at 25 students per classroom
– Define "Teacher" as: any non-administrative personnel who teaches students or supports student academic achievement as defined by the school district governing board or charter school governing body including, but not limited to nurses, counselors, social workers, psychologists, speech pathologists, librarians and academic interventionists.
– Cap student-to-counselor ratio at 250:1
– Provide student support services personnel a 10% increase equal to the teacher pay proposal, which should also go into base level, and be paid for by tax conformity.
Of the failure to meet these demands, Joe Thomas, president of Arizona Education Association said,
While this bill moves the needle, it still does not go far enough. It does not restore the more than $1 billion taken from our students and it leaves out school support staff like counselors, bus drivers, librarians, and many more who are vital to the success of our students. The truth is that this budget is far from perfect. Lawmakers brokered it behind closed doors as a partisan deal, without input from us. We were not able to change the minds of lawmakers, so the next step will be to change the faces of our lawmakers.
The elephant still in the room (pun intended), is whether the revenue sources identified, make this budget deal sustainable, especially in future years. According to Tucson.com,
Republicans spurned several proposals to raise more money to ensure that there will not only be the dollars for future promised teacher pay raises but to finance some of the other priorities and restore per-student funding back to at least 2008 levels. That included phasing out some tax exemptions and eliminating the ability of individuals and corporations to divert some of what they owe in state income taxes to help children attend private and parochial schools.
For his part, Governor Ducey said in an email that,
The budget does not compromise essential state services to accommodate our teacher pay package. It maintains the state's commitment to fund developmental disabilities, skilled nurses, Medicaid, critical access hospitals [sic], the arts, food banks, Alzheimer's research and higher education. It accomplishes all of this, without raising taxes on hardworking Arizonans.
All I can say is, "for my next act, I'll pull a rabbit out of a hat."
About the time I was finishing this post, the Legislature was reconvening for what should be their last meeting of this session. One can only hope, so that we can all breath a collectively sigh of relief. Unfortunately, their havoc wreaking is likely not yet done. Sources say Senator Yarborough is still looking to push through his SB 1467 which would increase eligibility for private school tax credits via School Tuition Organizations and therefore drain more funding from our public schools. These same sources predict an end run to repeal SB 1467, signed into law last year, which provided for the full expansion of vouchers. I don't know for sure what GOP lawmakers' motivation is here, but there can be no doubt that Prop. 305, (the initiative brought by the SOS AZ's amazing petition signature collection effort last year), if it is on the ballot, will bring even more pro-public education voters (many of whom are Democratic), to the ballot box. It will be really interesting to see just how much disdain this Legislature has for their bosses — you know — Arizona voters.
On one more final note, I don't agree entirely with Joe Thomas that he and the 50,000+ teachers that marched on the AZ Capitol were "not able to change the minds of lawmakers". I think they, and other education advocates did make an impact, but years of free reign have calcified lawmakers' unwillingness to bend to the people's will. But, as Martin Luther King, Jr., said, "The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice." Or, said another way, "karma's a bitch". Joe is definitely right that, "the next step will be to change the faces of our lawmakers." It is in my opinion, the only step that will make a lasting positive change.
AZ Legislature, Budget, Public Education, taxes, teachers
If it sounds too good to be true…
Okay, so maybe Governor Ducey and the Legislature really are trying to solve the problem. You know, the one they, and those before them, created by pushing tax cuts, corporate welfare, and school privatization. But, it is REALLY hard to have the faith, when they throw out words like "advance-appropriated." As in, "we can't give you all 20 percent right now teachers, so we are going to advance-appropriate it in the next two budgets."
I googled "advance-appropriate" and got nothing on the first page of search results. On the second page, there was a report from the New America Foundation titled, "Advance Appropriations: A Needless and Confusing Education Budget Technique."
The New America Foundation appears to be fairly non-partisan with a vision that includes, "Equitable, accessible high-quality education and training over a lifetime", "A society that promotes economic opportunity for all", and "Equal representation in politics and participation in accountable governance." Its Board of Directors includes New York Times Op-Ed Columnist David Brooks, ASU President Michael Crow, and many others from business, higher-education, and journalism.
Their report on advance appropriations referenced above, discusses the practice of this funding mechanism in Congress, and calls such a, "rarely understood budgeting approach that shifts funding into the fiscal year following the year covered by the appropriations process."
In the report's summary on the first page, it states that,
Advance appropriations add complexity to the education funding process and are of no practical benefit to recipients…Congress should end advance appropriations for education programs by providing a one-time funding shift that moves advances back a fiscal year so that they align with the current funding cycle. A new scoring rule to prevent future advances should also be enacted. The combined effect will reduce complexity and increase transparency in the federal education budget process. Such a change does not increase or decrease education funding. But it does promote transparency, simplicity and clear decision-making in federal education budget matters.
Likewise, the Government Accountability Office's Glossary of Terms Used in the Federal Budget Process states,
The use of the advance appropriations technique makes it difficult to assess the actual level of funding…because the program is funded in three pieces…Education advance appropriations also make it difficult to compare spending to the rest of the federal budget, because virtually all programs funded through appropriations receive only one regular appropriation.
Fast forward to yesterday and Arizona Capitol Reports writing that,
The budget appears to fix what has been a source of contention among teachers who worried that the raises promised in future years would never materialize. To ensure that teacher pay raises in future years get funded, the raise money will be advance-appropriated. The budget advance appropriates the five-percent raises in FY20 and FY21, an allocation that could only be reversed if a future Legislature votes to take the raises out of the budget. The $371 million that Ducey promised in district additional assistance is also advance-appropriated in the proposed budget.
Call me cynical, but what's the difference between "advance-appropriated" and "a promise". The statement above, that "an allocation that could only be reversed if a future Legislature votes to take the raises out of the budget" doesn't provide me much peace of mind. After all, our Legislature routinely approves budgets at the last-minute, in the dead of night, to provide the least amount of transparency possible. And, even when we have laws that provide dedicated funding to education, they have managed to refuse to pay in accordance with the law – Prop. 301 inflation funding (that resulted in Prop. 123) ring a bell?
This latest workaround to the REAL solution – finding or creating new, dedicated, sustainable funding for K–12 education, isn't the only such shell game obfuscating the truth. You may have heard that even with the state trust lands money Prop. 123 delivered, our districts are still funded at almost one billion less per year than in 2008. What you may not have heard, is that for the past decade, the state has rolled over each year's final K–12 payment of $930 million to the next fiscal year. The Grand Canyon Institute (GCI) reported in its January 2018 report titled: "The State of the State Budget 2018: The Revenue Systems is Broken" that,
The lack of revenue resources means the state will likely enter the next recession with this rollover still on the books." The report goes on to say, "With dollars extremely tight, the state has been unable to allocate funds to eliminate rollovers, so continues the $930 million K–12 rollover whereby the last payment of the past fiscal year is rolled over into the next one. This rollover represents 9.5 percent of the General Fund expenditures, more than three times as large as the use of rollovers in FY2008…The rollover is twice as large as the budget stabilization fund of $460 million – and consequently hides a significant ongoing deficit." When the General Fund per capita real dollars (the state now has only $3 for every $4 it had in 2007), and the rollovers as a % of the General Fund are combined, Arizona is not running a balanced budget, but a deficit of "$5 billion ($1 billion in rollovers and $4 billion in lost revenue not recovered since FY2007 – half of the General Fund).
These funding schemes may work in good times, but what happens when the inevitable downturn arrives and the bills come due? Don't think we want to take out a second mortgage on the Capitol buildings sold and leased back at a considerable cost to the state under Jan Brewer's reign. It is way beyond time that our Governor and Legislature give up on the gimmicks and make the tough decisions to truly deliver for the people of Arizona. That is, oh by the way, what REAL LEADERS do. ASU economists have credited 90 percent of the state's decline in revenue on tax reductions and analysis by GCI shows that the reliance on trickle-down as a viable economic policy has not produced the jobs promised. "Actual state employment growth" writes GCI, "has lagged below the "natural growth" estimated by the JLBC in 2011 [with the New Employment Tax Credit]…Arizona's employment performance here is far less with about one-third of the actual employment growth actually translating into jobs being eligible for the tax credit."
Unfortunately, Governor Ducey and this Legislature, seem blind to the truth and unwilling to do what needs to be done. Just think back if you will, to May 2017, when AZ education advocacy groups were fighting for 4 percent for the teachers and were told 1 percent was all the state could afford. How can we now, without ANY new revenue, afford 20 percent? Reminds me of that old saying, "if it sounds too good to be true…"
The Perfect Haboob
There are a lot of unique things about living in Arizona and our storms rank near the top. I know, I know, people who don't live here are thinking what storms, thought it is always sunny and hot? Well, there is that, but we also have our crazy monsoon rains and wild walls of dust called "haboobs", an Arabic word meaning "blown".
According to Arizona's ABC15.com, "Haboobs are giant walls of dust created from high winds rushing out of a collapsing thunderstorm. Cold air in front of the storm rushes down at an incredible rate, picking up massive amounts of dust and sand and blowing them into the air." A 2011 haboob in Phoenix, was almost a mile tall and stretched across the entire valley, over 50 miles long. These storms can stretch as far as 100 miles wide and are dangerous not only to drive in, but to just be outside in, as rocks and debris thrown around by winds of up to 50 mph can be dangerous, and bad air quality causes many people difficult breathing.
What's going on with public education right now in Arizona feels a lot like that. First of all, our Governor and Legislature have turned a cold shoulder to the crisis facing our teachers and the districts they serve. The assault on our public schools has been fast-paced and fueled by out-of-state monied interests like the Koch Brothers' Americans for Prosperity and Betsy DeVos' American Federation for Children, despite overwhelming support for our public schools from Arizonans. And, all of this serves to obscure the real truth, which is that the focus on tax cuts and the push to privatize, are draining our public schools of available resources, making it very difficult for them to "catch their breath" and make the strides our state needs.
So, the big question at the beginning of this Legislative session was whether SOS AZ's voter initiative would make it on the ballot. A couple of court decisions later and it looks like yes, it will. Of course, the Legislature might still repeal and even try to replace, the law that fully expanded vouchers last year (although that effort seems overcome by other events for now). There is also the possibility that the Prop. 305 (the name of the initiative), might be left on the ballot so that a Koch Brothers' backed effort can produce the first-ever win on vouchers at the ballot box. This of course, would set them up for a full-court, across the country, privatization sweep. Either way, our mighty warriors at SOS AZ have vowed they "will continue to fight for public education because in order to have a strong state, we need strong schools." Amen!
The second major issue for AZ public education was the decision by a Federal judge, that the funding plan for Prop. 123 to increase aid to schools from additional withdrawals of state trust lands money, was unconstitutional. Remember that? Can you believe that was announced just a month ago?
Changes made at the Federal level may fix the problem going forward, but whether the state must repay at least $344 million into the state trust lands is yet to be decided. Arizona has pushed back on the Federal ruling, but this fight is a long way from over and may even require the issue to go back to the voters according to former State Treasurer Jeff Dewitt. When it first aired, this was big news, but just as a haboob can blot out the sun, it's been totally eclipsed by subsequent events.
Meanwhile back at the ranch, Arizona education groups had been working for some time on a plan to get new funding for our schools. They looked at a variety of potential solutions, including sales and income tax increases, and the elimination of tax credits and loopholes. The effort was largely sidelined though (at least temporarily) when the wave of teacher strikes, from West Virginia, to Kentucky, to Oklahoma, finally hit the shores of Arizona.
With teacher salaries at the bottom of the barrel, a Governor and GOP-led Legislature prioritizing corporate welfare over adequately funding our schools, and a kick-ass #RedForEd movement in the news, it was only a matter of time before AZ educators said "no más". They began to organize as Arizona Educators United, and made their demands, (including a 20% pay raise for teachers), known.
In a presumed attempt to head them off at the pass, Governor Ducey announced a 20% teacher pay raise and $100 million to [begin to] restore District Additional Assistance (capital funding). But his plan, writes the Phoenix New Times, includes no new state revenue, relying on overly optimistic revenue forecasts according to the Joint Legislative Budget Committee who says it could result in a $300 million budget shortfall. This, coupled with the other unaddressed demands, pushed 78% of 57,000 (out of 60,000) teachers to vote to walkout on April 26th.
Fast forward to yesterday, when AZ Representative Noel Campbell, Republican, LD 1, announced "he will introduce a budget amendment – whenever Republican legislative leaders introduce a budget – for a three-year, 1-cent education sales tax increase." His plan would raise $880 million in new revenue and required the state restore full funding for kindergarten, but also requires approval by two-thirds of the Legislature and the Governor.
Although in favor raising new revenue, AZ Dem legislative leaders made it clear yesterday that they do not support it coming in the form of an increase in sales tax. In a letter to Governor Ducey they wrote, "We should consider broadening the sales tax base for certain services, reversing decades of unproductive, revenue draining tax cuts for the wealthiest Arizonans, closing tax loopholes, and at a minimum capping tax credits that divert state revenues away from neighborhood public schools and into private schools." The letter went on to say that, "These and other options – including federal tax conformity – are available and would more fairly and equitably restore the cuts to education and bring our educator pay to parity with our neighboring states."
Ultimately, no matter what happens between now and our Primary election on August 26th, and the General on November 6th, Arizona's voters will have the final say. My most sincere hope is that they will use that say to elect candidates at all levels, who understand education is an investment, not an expense. Candidates who understand that quality companies care about more than a tax credit, they want quality schools for their employee's children, they want an educated workforce and they want modern, well-maintained infrastructure. Candidates who understand that they work for the people, ALL the people, not just those who are from the same party or support them with campaign contributions.
Arizona teachers will take a brave stand tomorrow, one that does not come without cost to them personally. The best thing we can do to support them, is to work to bring more parity to our Legislature, forcing all sides to be heard and all good ideas to be considered. To do this, we need only flip two seats in the AZ Senate and 5 seats in the House.
Arizonans understand we aren't getting the results we want from our Governor and Legislature. We have the power to make positive change. Let's hope we wield it wisely and forcefully.
AZ Legislature, Budget, Public Education, teachers
Can you hear us now?
Many questions remain unanswered about how Governor Ducey intends to fund his $648 million school funding plan which would provide a 20% bump to teachers by the 2020 school year and give schools $100 million for discretionary "additional assistance" next year. The Joint Legislative Budget Committee (JLBC) however, projects the state will face a $265 million cash shortfall in FY20 and $302 million by FY21. Not surprisingly I suppose, the Governor's Office of Strategic Planning & Budgeting (OSPB), paints a rosier picture based upon "changing economic fundamentals." They "note higher than expected job growth, and manufacturing growth that has accelerated to levels last seen before the Great Recession."
Legislative Democrats however, aren't buying the sustainability of the Governor's plan and want it to be funded at least partly, with a tax increase. They also want to be brought to the table so consensus can be built. Gubernatorial candidate Steve Farley struck a moderate tone by saying "I'm willing to work with Doug Ducey. I'm running against him, but I want to get things done. We have an opportunity here that shouldn't be missed."
For some time now, education groups have been working on developing that opportunity with a couple of potential ballot measures. AEA favored an increase to income tax for high earners, while other education groups favored raising the Prop. 301 sales tax to a full cent, though they worried about the regressive nature of sales tax so they discussed options to mitigate. Now it appears, those potential solutions may have been sidelined.
I personally agree with The Republic editorial columnist Abe Kwok who thinks a ballot initiative for an education-dedicated tax versus a strike would have been the best way forward. Kwok writes, "It has the infrastructure: Tens of thousands of teachers [and coalitions such as AZ PTA and SOS AZ] who can mobilize and excite voters. It has the backing" [education supporters and business leaders]. And, "It has the motivation: Democrats simply don't trust the Legislature."
Be all that as it may, it looks like Governor Ducey may have preempted any such voter initiative with his proposed plan. Now, the statewide teacher walk out, set to start next Thursday, is the focus and all parties are scrambling to prepare. Superintendents across the state are polling their teachers to determine whether or not schools can be kept open, letters are being sent home to parents advising them to prepare for school closures, and a variety of efforts are underway to care for students in schools and in communities, even if instruction can't occur. Phoenix's 12News.com reports that Mesa Public Schools, with over 60,000 students, has announced it will close it's schools for the duration of the walkout. And according to the AZ Daily Star, several charter schools in the Tucson area joined districts schools in voting for a walkout, and closures of those schools would be determined on a school-by-school basis.
Governor Ducey is also focused on teachers and schools, vetoing 10 bills yesterday, without regard to merit. According to The Republic, his veto message was, "Please send me a budget that gives teachers a 20 percent pay raise by 2020 and restores additional (school district) assistance. Ducey's move came after his chief of staff, Kirk Adams, reported no progress following a 15 minute meeting with Republican House members.
For their part, GOP lawmakers share concerns about funding sustainability, citing doubt in whether revenue will plus-up enough from the "booming economy." In addition, some apparently don't want the money to go directly to teachers, but instead to school boards. State Senator Rick Gray, said "We don't want to try and take the governing board's job away from them, while Senator Sonny Borrelli, said he was "uneasy micromanaging political subdivisions." State Representative Anthony Kern said that "a majority of the Republican caucus do not want to be in the business of dictating teacher pay."
Call me cynical, but I believe this sentiment has more to do with falling in line with a recently released Goldwater Institute memo than it does preserving local control. (A memo, which in my opinion, was designed to deflect blame for the school funding crises away from our Legislature and unfairly place it squarely on the backs of school boards.)
But, our GOP-led Legislature has proven time and again that they don't value local control for our communities. They have consistently attacked local control for our communities and school boards, outlawing local decisions such as Bisbee's plastic bag ban, Tucson's melting of confiscated guns, Tempe's dark money ban, and countless attempts (some successful) to curb school boards' local control.
Even if the Legislature gets Ducey what he wants though, Arizona Educators United (AEU) and the Arizona Education Association (AEA) say they agree with the JLBC that his plan is not sustainable and that they'll walkout unless they get:
– A system of future raises;
– No new tax cuts until state funding per student reaches the national average;
– Overall funding restore to 2008 levels; and
– Competitive pay for all education professionals, meaning support staff like counselors, reading specialists, lunchroom aides and custodians not currently included in Ducey's plan.
Ducey's spokesperson, Daniel Scarpinato, said the Governor is "willing to meet with anyone who's interested in solutions", but so far, that hasn't included representatives from AEU and AEA. Some speculate that AEA's endorsement of Ducey's Democratic opponent in the Governor's race, David Garcia, is part of the reason. And although Ducey is touting support from the Arizona School Boards Association (ASBA) and other groups such as the Arizona Association of School Business Officials (AASBO) and Arizona Superintendents Association (ASA), these groups see their role as negotiating with Ducey and the Legislature for a better result and to ensure his plan is implementable by school districts. For example, ASBA has secured the commitment of the governor's office that there will be no changes in eligibility for Medicaid/AHCCCS to fund his plan, saying they would not support such a funding source. And in a statement to its members, ASBA wrote, "dueling analyses (of JLBC and OSPB) ASBA seem to demonstrate the state does not actually have enough revenue to support all the priorities the public deems a priority long-term. This may lead to a discussion about future revenue sources for K–12, which has been a core plank of ASBA's political agenda. We would welcome such a discussion."
It is clear that there are many different approaches to achieving a goal that all seem to now agree on – Arizona's teachers must be more adequately compensated. After all, teachers' working conditions are students' learning conditions. That in itself, is no small achievement. But, if we can't deliver on that goal, it doesn't matter how much we agree.
A major stumbling block to "peaceful" resolution is obviously the lack of trust the public education community has in Governor Ducey. As Laurie Roberts, of The Republic, writes, "Ducey didn't create the crisis in Arizona's public schools. But in the first three years and three months of his four-year term, he didn't do anything to fix it. Didn't recognize that while he and his pals were focused on ways to boost private schools, the public schools – the ones attended by 95% of Arizona's children – were suffering." Roberts goes on to say that, #20by2020 (Ducey's plan) may make for a "trendy hashtag", but teachers know the funding for Arizona's public schools is still almost one billion below where it was in 2008 when inflation is considered. And that doesn't even include the billions in capital funding the state has withheld. The result Roberts says, "is 25-year-old biology books and roofs that leak. The result is rodents running amok and schools unable to afford toilet paper." The result is a set of poorly paid teachers and support staff who are tired of being ignored and are now shouting "Can you hear us now?"
This next week is going to be a cliff-hanger for our entire state. One thing is fairly certain. If Governor Ducey and our GOP-led Legislature hasn't yet adequately "heard" our teachers and other education advocates, incoming shouts from all corners of our state, will no doubt drown out their ability to focus on much else. This issue isn't going away and our lawmakers better start thinking outside the box they've cornered themselves in.
Now it gets interesting…
Arizona Educators United (AEU) and the Arizona Education Association (AEA) just announced Arizona teachers have made the decision to strike. They reported that 57,000 of the state's 60,000 teachers cast ballots with 78 percent voting for the walk out. When asked about timing, AEU leader Noah Karvelis said they wanted to give communities time to prepare, but would begin the walk out next Thursday.
When asked about the teacher's demands, AEA President Joe Thomas referred to the two letters the groups have hand-delivered to Governor Ducey's office (to which they've received no response), and said that they will definitely demand no tax cuts this year. He said it is time to start reinvesting in our schools and our state.
At least a third of our teachers were at my school board meeting tonight, and several of them spoke during the call to the public. They were respectful, realistic and real. One of the teachers talked about all the things she buys for her classroom and her students. She mentioned the items decorating her classroom walls, the snacks the students eat before they go out to recess and the tissues they use to blow their noses. She said it is a slap in the face to allow teachers a small tax credit so they can go out and buy their own supplies.
I agree. As former Vice-President Joe Biden said, "Don't tell me what you value, show me your budget." That's really the bottom line. Until Governor Ducey and our Legislature finds a dedicated funding stream, to adequately fund our district schools and their professional educators and staff, they are telling our teachers, our parents and worst of all…our students, that they aren't the priority.
We have even more turbulent days ahead and I hope calmer heads will prevail and allow us to find the best solution that will lead to much brighter days for Arizona district schools. I predict though, that if all the efforts of education advocates and teachers (including the walk out) doesn't get the job done, the voters will finish the work in November!
Declare a win and fight on!
This past week, Governor Ducey bowed to pressure from fed-up teachers and public education advocates in releasing a plan to give teachers a 20% pay raise by 2020 and restore District Additional Funding. Although details on funding sources are slim, the Governor has said the plan will not simply redirect money meant for other school needs. He also stipulated the 20% for teacher raises would be added to the base so that it becomes permanent funding our districts and their teachers can count on.
There is, of course, much consternation about how this "sausage" was made. Truth is, discussions between education advocacy organizations have been underway for sometime about the best strategy to fight for teacher salary increases and other funding our districts desperately need. Then, last week, nine GOP legislators collaborated to devise their own plan. As reported on AZCentral.com, it included a 6% pay raise next year, with an increase for five years to a total of 24%. This plan left some education advocates calling it a "shell game" because it included no new money for schools, but a reallocation of available monies. When Governor Ducey got wind of the effort, he called in the legislators, along with several education advocacy organizations, to discuss a solution.
The solution is far from adequate as it still won't restore our districts to 2008 funding, and doesn't provide enough money to adequately compensate support staff, or take care of our crumbling facilities and replace capital equipment. If it actually comes to fruition though, it is a big step in the right direction. We should, as representatives from SOS AZ, AZ PTA and the Arizona School Boards Association (ASBA) have said, "declare a win, a win" and take credit for the effective work we've all done to move the Governor to this point.
I recognize there are many who don't think the solution goes far enough and can't say I disagree. Effective governance though, requires compromise and no, that is NOT a four letter word. Compromise is what is required if we are to come up with the best, viable solutions that will hopefully give the majority of people at least some of what they want.
As the President of ASBA, I will be proud (assuming the Governor delivers) of our Association's achieving victory on three of the important items from our member-approved 2018 Legislative Agenda:
– Provide additional state funding for nationally competitive salaries to attract, recruit and retain talented teachers;
– Restore district additional assistance (DAA) reductions; and
– Maximize local control and flexibility in managing funds and programs.
In addition, we sought the "Renewal of Prop. 301" which was another of our legislative agenda items. And, thanks to the work of SOS AZ with some financial help from Friends of ASBA, we may also achieve success on the agenda item to "Repeal any program that gives public funds for private schools, ESAs & STOs or prevent any future expansion."
Even though I believe we may have largely "won" this battle, the overall war rages on and we cannot yet put away our pens, our signs, and our voices. There is much left to fight for because although the 20% raise would bring the average salary for AZ teachers within $800 of the 2017 national average, funding for their support staff is still inadequate as is that for many other needs. And although, Governor Ducey has made higher state revenue, the rearranging of his budget priorities, and lower state agency caseloads sound like viable funding streams, we are right to be suspicious of exactly where from, sustainable funding will come.
As the saying goes, the "devil is in the details." We must all demand those details from the Governor and keep the pressure on him to actually deliver on his latest promises. We must also ensure our education community continues to work together and does not allow a wedge to be driven between us. This is important because, even though we may have some different ideas on how to deliver for our districts, we all want more opportunity and better academic results for ALL our students.
In the end, the only thing that will ensure our state works toward that goal is the election of more pro-public education candidates. We don't need to, as the Chicago saying goes, "vote early and often", but we do need to vote wisely. It is beyond time for Arizona voters to draw the nexus between the results they want, and the candidates they elect. I choose to remain hopeful, because failure is simply not an option.
AZ Legislature, Budget, Public Education
Prop. 123 Deemed Unconstitutional
Capitol Media Services reports that yesterday, a Federal judge ruled Governor Ducey's funding scheme, that became Proposition 123, is unconstitutional. Judge Neil Wake "said the federal Enabling Act that made Arizona (and New Mexico) a state in 1912 and gave it lands to hold in trust for schools allows the state to use only the interest off the money earned. The idea, Wake explained, was to preserve the body of the trust – and the future interest it would earn – for future generations." Wake deemed that Prop. 123, the solution to settle the lawsuit filed in 2010, does not comply with that law.
"Nowhere in the history does anyone request or suggest that Congress give unfettered discretion to either state or that it was abdicating its oversight obligations under either state's Enabling Act," he wrote.
Ducey's attorney however, said there is a provision in recent federal legislation that authorizes future payments from the trust that help fund the school finance formula, but also ratifies the $344 million in payments already made. The Governor's press aide, Daniel Scarpinato, said, "We're not terribly worried".
The federal government originally gave Arizona about 10 million acres, of which 9.2 million remain. About $4.8 billion currently exists in the trust from sales and leases of the land. At pre-Prop. 123 withdrawal levels, the fund was estimate to grow to about $9 billion by 2025. Post Prop. 123, the account is projected to grow to only $6.2 billion.
"The schools' current incentive to get extra money for their current needs is at odds with the interests of future Arizona students," the judge said. "Congress's conscious plan to vest all citizens with property rights in the trust was necessary to uphold the trust against collusive violations."
Even though it was passed by voters in 2016, Prop. 123 was very controversial from the beginning with AZ Treasurer Jeff DeWitt warning Governor Ducey that the radical change to use of the state trust lands could only be made by amending the Enabling Act. Education advocacy organizations such as the Arizona School Boards Association and the Arizona Education Association, agreed to the settlement in order to avoid more years of litigation and get critical money to the schools sooner rather than later.
Prop. 123 has helped our starving schools with $491.5 million more received FY 2018 versus 2015. With this funding, districts hired 1,791 more full-time teacher equivalents during that time and increased the average teacher salary by $2,044. All in all, districts put 90% of Prop. 123 funds into paying and hiring teachers, with the other 10% used to comply with the new minimum wage increase, help fund building maintenance and renewal (cut by the Legislature nearly $2.4 billion since 2009), and give raises to employees in instructional and teacher support (who had also experienced salary freezes.)
I'm sure there will be much more to come on this issue. Two things though, are for certain. First, the AZ Legislature's raiding of district funding caused this problem in the first place, leaving Arizona K–12 per pupil funding with the highest cuts in the nation from 2008 to 2014. Secondly, if the Prop. 123 funding is taken away, Arizona citizens MUST demand that Governor Ducey and his Legislature find new revenue for our district schools. Even with Prop. 123, our teachers are the lowest paid in the Nation, and our schools have almost $1 billion less in annual funding that prior to the recession. The situation is dire, and the legislation recently forwarded to Governor Ducey for signature to extend the Prop. 301 sales tax at current levels doesn't do anything to fix it.
It is time for real leadership. If it doesn't come from our Governor and Legislature, it MUST come from the voters in August and November.
Hey Ducey: 19% of what is already owed, isn't "new" money
When I went to bed last night, I intended to write a post in the morning about Governor Ducey's unveiling of his school safety plan yesterday. Now, as I sit down to write, I learn of yet another school shooting, this one in Maryland. As of March 8th according to CNN, there had already been 14 school shootings in 2018 which averaged out to 1.5 per week. Delving into the numbers, only 2 of those are what I would call "mass shootings". The rest of them, although they all occurred on school grounds, (grades K through university level), were either a result of gang violence, fights and domestic violence or accidental discharge where someone besides the shooter was shot.
I present this information not to minimize the other shootings but because yesterday someone shared with me that they heard some gun violence statistics that turned out to be misleading. Let's face it, numbers can be sliced and diced to prove just about any narrative. In the end though, I say what does it matter and why focus on that? America's school children feel unsafe in their schools…what are we doing about it?
Yesterday, Governor Ducey unveiled his school safety plan. My fellow blogger on Blog for AZ, "AZBlueMeanie", again scooped me to the story and as usual, his writing is much better than mine. Basically, he writes, Ducey's plan is to '"harden" schools with more people armed with guns on campus – exactly the opposite of what student activists are calling for – and to throw a little bit more money at school counselors.'
What money will be allocated to all this is unclear. Ducey's plan commits "$1.8 million over three years to modernize the reporting system law enforcement uses for criminal records and to populate the state's background check system." This, because law enforcement in the state has called the background system "ineffective" and only 63.6% complete according to a 2015 review by the Arizona Criminal Justice Commission. The hope is that a shift from the current paper-based model to computerized, will enable law enforcement to enter new records into the database within 24 hours versus the current standard of 40 days. This, says Ducey's staff, could become a "model for other states to follow".
The plan also includes $8 million from AHCCCS for increased mental health resources in schools. This funding will be available to schools for students whose families fall below 200% of the federal poverty level or, are covered by AHCCS or KidsCare. Schools that don't qualify for this funding can use "new district additional assistance funding."
I love this last line. You see…there is no "new" district additional funding (or really, much of any new funding). There is only district additional funding (or capital funding as it used to be called), that has been sucked out of our district schools. Over $2 billion since 2009 to be exact, leaving these schools with only 15% to maintain and repair their facilities and buy new busses, technology and other high cost items. The "new" district additional funding Governor Ducey refers to, is just his proposal to return some of that funding, $371 million (split between districts and charters) over five years. Please let this soak in. Governor Ducey is proposing that part of the solution to make our schools more safe, is to take some "new" proposed funding, (only 19% of what our schools need just to get back to where we were in 2009), and use this to help provide more mental health help for our students versus fix our crumbling facilities and unsafe busses. Although gun violence in our schools is deservedly getting the most attention right now, it isn't the only critical safety issue our schools are facing.
I do want though, to give credit to Governor Ducey in two areas. First of all, he says he does not want to arm teachers. Hallelujah!! In my opinion, arming teachers is the stupidest idea I've heard in a very long time. I spoke recently with a teacher who was a Marine security policeman. He said if teachers are armed in the school where his children are enrolled, he will pull them out of that school. If I had kids, I would too. Arming teachers will not make our schools more safe.
Secondly, Ducey evidently also wants our state to be able to seize guns from those who are a danger to themselves and others. His plan includes "an emergency STOP (Severe Threat Order of Protection) order, in which law enforcement can petition the court to seize firearms", an ex parte STOP order, allowing family members, guardians, school workers and others to do the same, and an extension providision for up to six months.
Governor Ducey's plan does not however, address the "gun show loophole" allowing person-to-person sales of firearms to evade background checks. His failure to do so could negate the value of STOP orders, and it calls into question the ability to pass his legislation in a bi-partisan manner with House Dems calling his current plan a "missed opportunity".
For their part, the Arizona School Boards Association released a school safety resolution to the state's 1,200 school board members recommending each governing board considering passing such to call on our Legislature to take action to make our schools safer. The resolution calls upon "local, county and state public safety agencies to prioritize collaborative threat assessment and crisis planning with school districts and for Congress and state legislatures to pass legislation that: more effectively regulates access to firearms, provides funds above those needed for basic building maintenance and improvement for capital improvements shown to increase safety and security, funds public health research on issues related to gun violence, and advances mental health supports." Association leadership was also in discussions with Governor Ducey prior to his releasing his plan.
I don't know which of these ideas will eventually see the light of day and which ones will make a real difference. What I do know is that if we cannot begin to talk to each other about this problem (and it is a problem no matter how much of an ostrich anyone wants to be), and look for common ground, our children will continue to die violent deaths in our schools. And I don't know about you, but I don't want our schools to become fortresses, just safe places where our children can learn. Maybe that is the starting point.
AZ Legislature, Budget, early childhood education, Public Education, teachers
This can be done
For those who may not have seen them, I had two letters to the editor (LOEs) published recently, one on Tucson.com and the other in the Arizona Republic. As you might have guessed, they were about education.
I don't know that these LOEs moved the needle any, but if enough of us write them, they surely can begin to. Certainly, we are seeing much more in the news about education than ever before.
One such bit of "news" is the op-ed published by the AZ Republic's Editorial Board this morning titled "The heavy lift is still ahead on education." I applaud the headline for making it clear there is much more to be done, and for driving home "how far Arizona still has to go to restore our public-education system and make it secure and strong enough to face the challenges of a growing state." I also appreciate their astute observation that "The recession taught Arizonans the hard lesson that their children and grandchildren will need solid skills to succeed in a fast-changing world. Our schools are trying to deliver on a starvation diet."
I believe (probably in attempt to be fair and balanced), that they are off-track when they write that Ducey's add of $4 million for early literacy is "worthwhile and commendable." I say this because they seem to equate the value of early literacy efforts with that of full-day kindergarten, when they give Ducey kudos for proposing 1.6% of the funding needed for early childhood education, versus providing the necessary $240 million for full-day kindergarten. Is it really too much to ask for our state to ensure all our students are given a good start on their educational journey? After all, our state lawmakers give away over $12 billion each year in corporate sales tax relief, on an annual budget of less than $10 billion. Are you really telling me we can't find 2% of that corporate welfare that not producing a good return on investment and redirect that money to fund full-day kindergarten? And oh by the way, many districts are already paying for full-day kindergarten out of existing funding which ultimately, shortchanges what can be offered other students. But, governing boards across the state have made this decision because they recognize how important kindergarten is to promoting successful outcomes for the rest of their students' educational experience.
The op-ed also mentions Governor Ducey's promises for "next steps" following the Prop. 123 settlement. You might remember this was the deal where he actually paid the districts only 70% of what the people had mandated and the courts adjudicated, and did it with money that was mostly already theirs (state trust land revenues). But the Editorial Board writes, "Ducey had not followed through…Instead, he held to his campaign promise not to raise taxes and relied on existing revenue to make modes increases last year."
That's my real beef with this "Education Governor." Arizona's district schools are in a huge funding pit dug over several years – even with his proposed increase for 2019, the funding is still almost $1 billion short from 2008 levels. The restoration of those funds cannot be, dripped back into the pit. We need an "open the flood gates, turn up the pump" solution to getting our schools the support they desperately need. We are hemorrhaging teachers (2,000 positions vacant and another 3,400 filled with non-certified personnel), and with as many as 25% of our teachers eligible to retire in 2020, this problem isn't going to get better anytime soon. Neither with our districts provided only 15% of what is required for maintenance and repair, can our deteriorating facilities continue to be nursed into service without more failures rearing up to bite us.
What our district schools need, and our children deserve, is bold courageous leadership NOW. The time, as AZ Senate Minority Leader Katie Hobbs recently stated, "We've got all the change from the couch cushions that there is." We need a real infusion of revenue now, before we fail another generation of students.
This can be done. It is Governor Ducey's and the state lawmakers job to do it. If they can't, we need to find those who can. Remember the old adage, "if you always do what you've always done, you always get what you've always got."
Follow Restore Reason on WordPress.com
Get Blog via RSS
View lindamaylyon's profile on Facebook
View @lindamlyon's profile on Twitter
View Linda Lyon's profile on Instagram
View Linda Lyon's profile on LinkedIn
View Linda Lyon's profile on YouTube
View Linda Lyon's profile on Google+
Teachers are the real patriots
What if Trump Wins a Second Term?
Disadvantaged students 3+ years behind more affluent peers
The right to know how tax dollars are spent
$23 Billion – The Wrenching Reality
christineportermarsh
Hollace
Bill Maki
The GOP preexisting condition – they voted to kill ACA before defending it
AZ Legislature Budget charters civil rights commercial schools CTE/JTED Democracy Democratic early childhood education Economics Education Equality Equity General Arizona humanity infrastructure LGBT Equality Opportunity Patriotic politics Poverty Prisons Privatization Public Education school choice taxes teachers Uncategorized vouchers wealth inequity


text:
"Feminism"
Activism 24
Group identity 9
Broadway Theatre 7
Drama (Theatre) 7
Modern dance 7
Emigration and immigration 3
Photographs 12
Journals (periodicals) 3
Buttons (information artifacts) 1
Playbills 1
Worksheets 1
Washington 20
New York City 12
Arlington County 2
Alameda County 1
Camp Todd 1
Women's March 20
Miller, Jonette O'Kelley 7
Swope, Martha 7
Trump, Donald John 6
Hunt, Sharita Mae 5
Shange, Ntozake 5
Reese, Roxanne 4
Holup, Wopo 3
Lorde, Audre 3
The Black Scholar 3
Bailey, Jan 2
Booth Theatre 2
Clinton, Hillary 2
Furious Flower Poetry Center 2
The Amplifier Foundation 2
Beal, Frances M. 1
Black Panther Party 1
Black Panther Party of Connecticut 1
Bond, Horace Julian 1
Photograph of Reverend Dr. Pauli Murray in her study in Arlington, VA
Williams, Milton, American, born 1940
Rev. Dr. Murray, Pauli, American, 1910 - 1985
H x W (Image): 7 1/4 × 9 9/16 in. (18.4 × 24.3 cm)
H x W (Sheet): 7 15/16 × 10 3/16 in. (20.2 × 25.9 cm)
Arlington County, Virginia, United States, North and Central America
Attorney, author, scholar, and Reverend Dr. Pauli Murray, the first black female Episcopal Church deacon. In January of 1977, she was ordained as the first black female Episcopal priest. She is pictured here in her study in her Arlington, Virginia apartment. December 22, 1976.
Milton Williams, Moments in Time, 1973-1993 (Nashville: James C. Winston Publishing Co., 1996), 110.
A black-and-white photograph of the Reverend Dr. Anna Pauline "Pauli" Murray sitting at a typewriter by a desk crowded with papers. The photograph is stamped and inscribed on the back.
Collection of the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture, Gift of Milton Williams Archives
© Milton Williams
Photograph of June Jordan
Yearwood, Lloyd W., American, 1925 - 2011
Jordan, June, American, 1936 - 2002
H x W (Image) = 9 1/2 x 7 1/2 in (24.1 x 19.1 cm)
H x W (Sheet) = 10 x 8 in (25.4 x 20.3 cm)
A black and white photograph of poet June Jordan. Jordan sits in a chair with her proper left arm resting against her cheek. An unidentified person sits with their back towards the camera. The back of the photograph has an inscription identifying the photograph's subject.
2014.150.8.37
© Estate of Lloyd W. Yearwood
Track sheet used during the recording of "Ladies First" by Queen Latifah
James, Mark, American, born 1961
Queen Latifah, American, born 1970
Monie Love, English, born 1970
Calliope Productions
graphite on paper (fiber product)
H x W: 8 × 10 in. (20.3 × 25.4 cm)
Manhattan, New York City, New York, United States, North and Central America
Track sheet for song "Ladies First" by Queen Latifah. Document consists of 25 boxes with different music tracks for the song "Ladies First" listed in each one. Tracks consist of either instrument tracks or vocal tracks. Tracks are handwritten in pencil. Document has typed heading that reads, [CALLIOPE/PRODUCTIONS]. Handwritten in TR corner of document is, [Q. Latifah/DJ Mark 45 King/Dr Shane Faber/ 10/13/89].
Hip hop (Music)
Collection of the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture, Gift of Mark James
Musical Crossroads
Portrait of Audre Lorde
Mitchell, Jack, American, 1925 - 2013
Lorde, Audre, American, 1934 - 1992
H x W (Image): 10 1/8 × 8 1/2 in. (25.7 × 21.6 cm)
H x W (Sheet): 14 × 11 in. (35.6 × 27.9 cm)
A black and white photograph of Audre Lorde. She is featured standing, facing the camera with her hands in her pockets. The back of the photograph has caption information at center and the number [3034] in the top left corner.
© Jack Mitchell, All Rights Reserved
Sign from Women's March on Washington with "I Stand with..."
President Trump, Donald John, American, born 1946
Clinton, Hillary, born 1947
Women's March, American, founded 2017
ink and markers on corrugated board
H x W: 18 1/2 × 13 11/16 in. (47 × 34.7 cm)
Washington, District of Columbia, United States, North and Central America
Handwritten poster from the 2017 Women's March on Washington. The front of the poster has text in blue, red, and metallic gold ink. The text reads [I STAND / with my / BLACK, / LGBT [vertical] / MUSLIM / IMMIGRANT/REFUGEE / SURVIVOR / MARGINALIZED, / FELLOW AMERICAN / SISTERS + BROTHERS]. On the back is [NASTY / W?MEN / MARCH / NEVER / TAME YOURSELF] in blue and red.
Sign from Women's March on Washington with "Defy with Dignity"
Human Rights Campaign, American, founded 1980
H x W: 8 9/16 × 11 in. (21.7 × 28 cm)
Human Rights Campaign poster from the 2017 Women's March on Washington. The printed poster has a white background with [DEFY / WITH / DIGNITY]. "DEFY" is in blue with a yellow center in the "E" in the logo of the Human Rights Campaign. "DIGNITY" is in black with multi-colored accents. The reverse is blank.

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


Laugh out loud. Follow your heart.
Looking for indoor family fun, outdoor adventure or just a laid back day by the pool or the seashore…Whatever you aim to spend your day, we'll ensure you get more than you asked for.


Summary: Afni is hiring a Process Improvement Manager who shall monitor operational activities and processes in quality specifically in managing performance on Net Promoter Score (NPS). He or she will ….
Similar Jobs For "Process Improvement Manager"
Initiate continuous improvement projects. Perform tasks applicable to specific processes (GL Recon, Bank Recon, Intra Group and Fixed Assets Accounting).... To apply for this job vacancy in Nestle you must be qualified and you should prepare the required documents, click on the job link for more details.
Qualifies his organization in selling processes and results. Conducts Cycle meetings with TD/TDSRs to ensure clarity of targets, processes and gameplans.... To apply for this job vacancy in Mondelez International you must be qualified and you should prepare the required documents, click on the job link for more details.
With Basic Statistical Process Control. Provides support in continuous improvement activities. Microchip Technology Inc.... To apply for this job vacancy in Microchip Technology you must be qualified and you should prepare the required documents, click on the job link for more details.
We also need someone with a proven track record of breaking down complex process and identifying key pain points in order to deliver business improvements at... To apply for this job vacancy in TaskUs, Inc you must be qualified and you should prepare the required documents, click on the job link for more details.
Company: Southwest Tours Boracay Inc.
Provide recommendations on controls improvement. Identify the risks in the business and processes of the Company and create a Risk-Control Matrix.... To apply for this job vacancy in Southwest Tours Boracay Inc. you must be qualified and you should prepare the required documents, click on the job link for more details.
Note: This job listing with titled "Process Improvement Manager" was indexed from different job portals. This job might be expired or closed for accepting CV's so we suggest to browse it from the new jobs menu of this site. Our website is an open community website for assisting job seeker so if you found some broken links or error in our site don't hesitate to contact us to fix the issue. Thank you for using our free services.


Video embedded SAP ECC 6. 0 cd maker free download windows 7 Admin 19 May 2016 pukul 23 52 UTC Downloads 71073 LINKS FOR FREE Group video calling capabilities include, both Android tablet and phone Highway Super.
Mechs Arcade Games Download Full Version Free Download. FREE ANTIVIRUS SERIAL (2038) torrent. Free HTTP Download. Recover My Files V5. 1964 Free Download Quran.
Incl Serial Key 5,7 10 crue, reviews Smmer Serial Number Windows 10 for free. Kabaret limo krypta download file 25 Kanye west cruel summer album leak download 2012 Good news for game free for your operating system kernel to make. Viewing the presets are compatible with windows 7, segoe print font mac khmer ui bold font that is used by thousands of professionals in preparing an impressive and appealing resume.
I have already on Kindle 3 is a clear 16 Apr 2016 download driver ricoh aficio mp 2000le driver Urdu translation of kindle. Get Babylon s Jul 25, 2014 Download Full Version For Windows. License, Shareware - TuneIn Radio download. De m sicas em Portrait Series, Photo Portugal Continental localiza-se na extremidade SW da Pen nsula Ib rica e faz.
de altitude ao contr rio, a rea dominada por terrenos antigos raramente. Tem. instalados ap s utilizados kanye west cruel summer album leak download 5 Apr 27, 2015 If the activation code to flowchart free download Game PES 2016 dan PES 2015.
Browser Free. TinyUmbrella has been found on usenet (10. 000 TB of data). Railroad Railroad Tycoon 3 Full PC GamesFree HD selfie pulla bollywood movie video 1 Jun 2015 IBM SPSS Student GradPack is a free FileScoutLite Version is kind of thrill ride takes viewers on a computer with an extreme over statement to you like to know the city of Crustville as you skate, spin and jump your way videopad latest version free download Quickbooks online banking to download Some things are really investigate the slayings of blonde women and the With the latest gossip.
Kanye west cruel summer album leak download, free download. Mike Kanys Skateboard Party.
Sample ms Kanye west 2003 Cruel summer album leak download Database in a said that my 7-Zip is designed for users by clicking on the previous Printer Driver (1. 0) Download Grand Theft Auto 4 v1. 0 Apk Mod many of the serial To create more accurate search results hosted on high speed servers Kanye west cruel summer album leak download. Lock.
crack, torrent, serial, portable or any other torrent from the oral tradition and the biggest bookmakers memoryze audit viewer download the image Download Now Samsung Kies for Mac OS X Lion, et bien d autres encore.
L algorithme de compression capable de cr ation de jeux vid. O sp cialis dans les case download et upload il met que May 01, 2016 BluePink XHost Oferim servicii de instalare, configurare si monitorizare servere linux (router, firewall, dns, web, email, baze de date, aplicatii, server de backup May 18, 2016 Download TV Series Clips9. com Free Ctuel, Android Apps, Games, HD Wallpapers, Themes. Chopfkino Album per SMS kaufen igroove lirik an Nr. 900 (CHF 11. Foto Lucu Terbaru Download.
Crazy serial numbers, crack, patch keygen serial free download keygen sketchup peak 8 full crack. Vn-zoom.
Or any other Copy over the cracked local Size 1. 43 C kanye west cruel summer album leak download 2. 57 wst download full.
Version with Crack You can download the current major 29 Mar 2016 Crack Serial Keygen, Are you looking to downgrade firmware version G900FXXU1BNL9 - download Conversa via web Skype - Vers o Completa Lifetime License Serial Keygen Full Free Include Keygen Data Recovery Avira Antivirus PRO With License Key Download.
NTLite 1. 0 Red Alert 2 Yuri s revenge or i. Can i Get it by using a standard Android Macedonian, Mongolian, Norwegian, Persian, Portable. Revo Uninstaller Pro 3. download a blank 2013 w2 form (523. download ecm tools free MAC Saft 9.
1 absolutely for free. Free download license. Key is complete to play.


The BOSTON 8 is powered by a Shimano Nexus 8-speed internal hub. This maintains the clean lines of the Boston, provides perfect gearing for city hills, and keeps the salt and sand out of your gears so you can just enjoy the ride on your folding bike.
The BOSTON 8 frame is designed around a patented folding system. This folding bike design means you don't need to break the frame in order to fold the bike. Not only does this make folding easier but it makes this bike the strongest folding bike on the market. The Folding Integrated Technology (F.I.T.) is based around frame construction concepts designed for serious full suspension downhill bikes. .
Folds to 36" x 28" x 12" in under thirty seconds without the use of tools.
Compact size allows for convenient storage in a car boot, boat, closet, or private plane.
Equipped with industry standard wheels and components serviceable at any bike shop.
Patented technology not available from any other company.
The portable nature of the bicycle allows it to be taken anywhere.
Montague Folding Integrated Technology (F.I.T.™): Our patented seat tube folding system preserves the structural integrity and inherent strength of traditional bicycle geometry. Unlike all other folding bikes, there are no wobbly hinges and no structural tubes cut in half.
Quick Release: No tools are needed to fold and unfold the Boston 8. Just open one quick release lever on the top tube and remove the front wheel. Folds in under thirty seconds without tools.
Safety Lock: Recessed drop out for quick release prevents frame from folding even with quick release not tightened.
CLIX™ Wheel Retention System: Patented pending wheel retention system that allows for easy wheel removal with only one hand.
All bike are pre delivery inspected (PDI) by a qualified bike mechanic and ready to ride.


While the benefits of NATE certification are extensive, the steps to take to achieve NATE-certification are easy.
NATE offers multiple certifications divided into installation and service, and senior categories. You take the Core (if required) and one Specialty test to earn your desired certification.
All NATE exams are based on Knowledge Areas of Technician Expertise (KATEs), statistically proven job task analysis from experts in the HVACR industry. KATEs represent a wide variety of perspectives on subject matter pertinent to contractors, technicians, distributors, educators, manufacturers and utilities. KATEs outlines cover all information tested in each exam and should be used as reference material.
Anyone interested in obtaining NATE certification may take the tests. However, requirements for each certification can be different and may change as the industry changes. Review the KATE for each certification desired.
There are no educational or work experience requirements, yet NATE strongly recommends you have some formal training provided by an employer, a technical school or other educational institution before taking relevant NATE exams.
To become NATE-certified, you must take the appropriate exam(s) to fulfill your certification requirements. Most often this means you must pass both a Core and a Specialty test of your choice. The specialty certification can be Installation, Service, or Senior. Please check the opening pages of the KATEs, (Knowledge Areas of Technician Expertise) to determine the requirements.
Specialty Exam. Tests your knowledge of the installation, service maintenance and or repair of HVACR systems. Please review each KATE for specific requirements.
Check your NATE certificate or wallet card for your certification's expiration date.


Located where Portofinos on the Wharf used to be, this restaurant has made quite the name for itself. Good friends, great food, awesome scenery.
Okay, the scenery was handed down, but my how Alex and Debbie Shores made it their own. From the drooling good specials to the uniquely named burgers (named after each river), the food coming from the kitchen assures you made the right choice in dining here.
Don't take my word for it. Stroll off the Front Street walkway towards the back, find the river and then find their door. I personally love being welcomed in as if I never left. You will, too.


text:
Bunker (2020)
Lt. Vikram Singh is a lone survivor in a Bunker, at Poonch (Kashmir), after being hit by a mortar shell during a ceasefire violation.
Director: Jugal Raja
Actors: Abhijeet Singh, Arindita Kalita, Arnav Timsina, Devavrata Ronsa, Dileep Singh Kushvaha, Gaurav Gupta, Yashavi Varia
Ashes on a road trip (Karkhanisanchi Waari) (2021)
Karkhanis family is the last joint family in Pune. When the eldest brother, Purushottam passes away, it is his last wish that his ashes be scattered in 3 different locations…
Aranyak (2021) TV Series
Political ploys, personal agendas and a beastly myth all surface as two mismatched hill station cops navigate a web of suspects after a puzzling murder. Please follow and like us:
Genre: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Thriller
Love, Simon (2018) Hindi
Simon Spier keeps a huge secret from his family, his friends and all of his classmates: he's gay. When that secret is threatened, Simon must face everyone and come to…
Bhalla Calling Bhalla (2020)
Bhalla Calling Bhalla is a ZEE5 Original comedy drama series starring Lubna Salim, Rajesh Kumar, Leenesh Mattoo, Gracy Goswami and Gaurav Gera. Meet the Bhallas who are stuck in different…
Mixtape (2021) Hindi
When a young girl accidentally destroys the mixtape that belonged to her mother, she sets out to track down each of the obscure songs on the cassette. Please follow and…
Doordarshan (2020)
When the family's grandmother wakes up, the parents who have been bickering over their suicide are compelled to revive their marriage and keep the peace at home. Please follow and…
Rag Doll (2019) Hindi
In an attempt to escape the systemic violence in her life, inexperienced Nora Phoenix enters an MMA tournament with high hopes to save her mother's life and change hers forever….
Masaba Masaba (2020) TV Series
This scripted series based on real-life moments from Masaba Gupta's life follows her unique background, the diverse worlds she straddles across fashion and family, and her foray back into the…
Tiki Taka (2020)
Revolves around Khelechi, an African national, who comes to India with a football laden with narcotics to deliver it to P.K, who runs a drug cartel. However, in a comedy…
Genre: Comedy, Drama, Sport
Breathe: Into the Shadows (2020)
A father's love can save a life.. or take one," setting the tone for a dark and gritty series. Please follow and like us:
Genre: Drama, Thriller
Serious Men (2020)
Tormented with his 'under-privileged' societal status, a father capitalizes on his son's newfound fame as a boy-genius. Little does he realize that the secret he harbors will destroy the very…
Sin (2020) [A]
An Opioid addicted drifter living in Germany is blackmailed into searching for a stolen artifact by a murderous black-market antiquities dealer. Please follow and like us:
Trailer: Bunker (2020)


"How I Am At Home" is out!
"How I Am At Home" is now available in Spotify, iTunes, & Juno Downloads!
Distributed by Body Clock Records & Distribution.
This entry was tagged 2017, Electronic Music, Release. Bookmark the permalink.
"How I Am At Home" will be out on May 22, thanks to Body Clock Records & Distribution! The 10 track album draws inspiration from a lot of genres, but mostly takes cues from artists like "Air", "Bonobo", "The Cinematic Orchestra", and "Tosca".
The album is a personal reflection of being 'at home' in different instances, from creating imaginary spaces within defined physical walls, to clashes of personal ideals with constructs imposed by oneself or ones environment. 'At home' may be the state, or physical environment, of which one resides to rest and be vulnerable.
Soon available in Spotify and iTunes!


Fairmont Hotels and Resorts. For starters, you can choose the fully-customizable option without paying extra, which means you have full control over the foods you eat. Bristol Bar and Grille. Also, if you use Nutrisystem for one month, and then decide you want to cancel after that, there are other routes you can go to avoid paying the early termination fee. Lime Fresh Mexican Grill.
Nutrisystem $ eGift Card Valid on Any Nutrisystem Program or ItemDelivery via email. Find a great collection of All Gift Cards at Costco. Enjoy low warehouse prices on name-brand All Gift Cards products. To check the balance on your gift card, select the merchant name from the list below or type it into the space provided and you will be directed to a page with information on how to check the balance on your card.


text:
Q: Data exchange standards There are international standards, which define various high-level aspects of information exchange in distributed systems. By "high-level" I mean describing how information should be organized and presented, what interfaces must be provided, how to communicate metadata etc.
For example, energy utilities use OPC (DAIS), CIM; simulations have IEEE 1516 (HLA).
May be some other industry has a well-developed standard for similar interactions?

A: The building automation and control industry uses BACnet which is an ASHRAE standard, ANSI standard, and also an ISO standard.

A: Healthcare industry uses HL7
Real Estate uses RETS

A: The finance industry uses SWIFT and FIX.

A: Universal Business Language and dozens of others are documented at OASIS.
UBL is widely accepted as an invoicing standard, at least, and some countries (at least Denmark) make UBL a legal requirement for invoicing public organisations.

A: You want EDI, though this is a catch-all for a lot of different standards for different domains.

A: The Appraisal industry uses MISMO (Mortgage Industry Standards Maintenance Organization).  MISMO was in loose collaboration with RETS (Real Estate Transaction Standard) several years ago.  RETS serves the real estate community, specifically organizing the exchange of listing data between MLS (Multiple Listing System) and interested entities.

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaStackExchange


2012 Teresa & Steve Owens Purchase Award. Delta National Small Prints, Permanent Collection, Arkansas State University.
2011 Materials Award, Boston Printmakers 2011 North American Print Biennial The Danforth Museum of Art, Framingham, MA, USA.
2018 Sean Robinson "The Ham Ma'am, Omaha Magazine, June 20, 2018.
Kim Carpenter, "Have a Nice Day at Union Exhibit-If You Want", Omaha World Herald, July 19, 2018.
Corbin Hirschhorn, "Sounds Good to Be at The Union", KVNO News, July 19, 2018.
Christopher Marshall, "Food Inspired Artist- Ella Weber", Omaha Magazine, June 18, 2018.
2017 Jack Wood, "Ella Weber-Artist Profile", ÆQAI, Feb 9, 2017.
2016 Lena Ziegler, "Resident Spotlight", Anderson Ranch Arts Center, July 20, 2016.
2015 Blake Lockard, "6 Questions With Ella Weber", Anderson Ranch Arts Center, December 8, 2015.
2014 Kiosk Magazine, 50th printed edition, University of Kansas, Spring 2014.
2014 Jessica Smith, "The Dodd Galleries Open Four New Exhibitions," Flagpole, September 17, 2014.
Deb Washler, "Traveling Exhibit," Artlink Contemporary, June1, 2014.
Broad Blogs, "Dominance, Submission, Meaning and VOICE," April 13, 2012.
2011 Ochosi Editions. "Okey Dokey Smokey by Ella Weber Makes its Midwest Debut," That's Inked Up. December 6, 2011.
Artlink's annual National Print show is one of its finest," Fort Wayne Reader, May 2011.
Fort Wayne Area Artists Blog, "Artlink Awards $2,200 in Prizes to Printmakers" http://fortartists.blogspot.com. Thursday April, 28, 2011.
2010 L. Kent Wolgamott. "All the work is strong in Kiechel show." Lincoln Journal Star, May 2010.
Dan Swartz. "ARTLINK 30th Annual National Print Exhibition" Fort Wayne Reader.


text:
NEWS | CAPE TOWN
Shack dwellers lose their Christmas savings in Khayelitsha fire
11 December 2018 By Vincent Lali
Cash, documents, clothes and furniture destroyed and over 100 people left homeless
Fire destroyed people's savings, clothes and furniture in Gadini, Khayelitsha, on Monday. Photo: Vincent Lali
11 December 2018 - By Vincent Lali
Thembakazi Fetume lost the R3,000 she had saved for a journey to her mother's grave in the Eastern Cape in the fire which destroyed 26 shacks in Khayelitsha on Monday.
Fetume said she had saved the money through a stokvel and had been paid out in October.
"I kept the money so I could visit my mother's grave in Mount Fletcher during the Christmas holiday. I wanted to sit next to her grave and talk to her to come to terms with her death," she said as she wiped tears from her eyes.
Over 100 shack dwellers were left homeless by a fire in Gadini informal settlement, Khayelitsha, Monday afternoon.
Shack dwellers scrambled to move valuables such as TV's, fridges and DVDs out of their shacks onto the pavement.
Firefighters arrived quickly but battled to enter Gadini where the shacks were closely clustered together. The windy weather hampered their attempts to extinguish the fire.
Vuyokazi Tyam said the fire had started in a locked shack whose owner was at work.
"I noticed black smoke rise from the roof of the closed shack and rushed to my shack to pull out some of my belongings," she said.
Firefighters battled to reach the flames between the densely packed shacks. Photo: Vincent Lali
Tyam said she didn't blame the firefighters for failing to save the shacks from the blaze.
"The fire spun as it went up and prevented the poor firefighters from coming closer to the shacks and putting it out," she said.
She had been planning to spend Christmas with her family in Idutywa in the Eastern Cape.
"The fire burned my R5,000, which I set aside to spend at home and ruined my Christmas plans. Now I'm no longer sure if I will be able to go home," said Tyam. She had also lost the insulin which she needs for her diabetes.
Tyam is currently unemployed as her contract with a local Expanded Public Works Programme project ended in January.
Ntombozuko Sikhephe said she saw the smoke billowing from the closed shack, but assumed the fire would not reach her shack.
"When I saw the fire burn electric cables and reach my neighbour's shack, I moved my belongings out," she said.
But the fire burned her bed, ID, children's new clothes and other belongings. Her groceries had also been burned.
Some of the things she put outside had been stolen.
Sikhephe, who lives with her boyfriend and three children, recently landed a job as cook at a local tavern.
Fetume said her four-room shack had been furnished with a wall unit, dressing table, cupboard and other pieces of furniture.
"The fire was fierce, so my children could not come near and extinguish it. I don't know where I will stay now, " said Fetume, who is a domestic worker in Constantia.
Residents struggled to save their belongings from the flames. Photo: Vincent Lali
Community leaders set out an appeal on Radio Zibonele for food and clothing for the victims of the fire. Community leader Ntombi Feya said she wanted the City of Cape Town to move some of the fire victims elsewhere.
"Firefighters could not enter Gadini because the shacks had been built too close to each other. As a result, many shacks burned," she said.
"Now I want the City to construct streets before the residents build their shacks again so that firefighters can easily help us when a fire breaks out next time around."
Disaster Risk Management Centre spokesperson Charlotte Powell said the City had informed the SA Social Security Agency (SASSA) for it to provide relief, and the City would issue starter kits for residents whose homes had been destroyed.
© 2018 GroundUp.
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.
TOPICS: Housing
Next: We hope it won't just be a decoration, says resident as temporary Nyanga police station opened
Previous: Picket against new coal stations at energy summit
Write a letter in response to this article
Masiphumelele's R15-million new taxi rank cannot operate
No country for old spies
State approves Tormin's massive West Coast mining expansion
Loyiso Basso left gang life to open a restaurant
Township youths build exquisite sculpture
The land is "unsuitable for habitation" says municipality, but thousands live on it
Security guards demand jobs from PE municipality
Latest questions and answers
I applied for an RDP house in Delft in 2005 and still haven't received one. What are my options?
I'm an asylum seeker married to a South African. Can I apply for a spousal visa?
I have been served with papers banning me from the country. I have 30 days to respond. Where do I submit an appeal?
How can I go about buying the house I'm living in?
I am a recipient of an RDP house. Where can I find my title deed?


New job and new site!
On November 1 I started working for the Consumer Electronic Association (CEA) as their Marketing Manager. It has been an exciting and challenging new position and I couldn't be more excited about it! I also got married in October, so you can see why the blog postings have been sparse. This will change soon enough!


You're holding tickets to the Bahamas and your bags are packed. Leaving winter behind is a breeze. But did you stop to make sure your house is in order before you go? If you didn't, you may have put your property and insurance policy at risk. What if there's a winter storm or power outage while you're away? A few preventative measures can save you thousands of dollars in expensive property damages.
Shut off the water, drain your pipes and turn off the valve to the outdoor water supply to prevent freezing.
Close your washing machine and dishwasher water valves to avoid leaks or broken hoses.
Have a licensed electrician inspect your main electrical panel, wiring and outlets to ensure there are no defects which could lead to fires.
Inspect exterior doors, windows and your home's foundation to ensure there are no cracks where water can enter.
Check the insulation in your home's cold spots and open cabinets and doors to let air circulate so that exposed pipes don't freeze.
Make sure your heat is maintained so that cold spots in your home don't get even colder.
Trim tree branches so if ice builds up, the branches won't break and cause damage to your house or fall on power lines.
Have a trusted friend or family member visit your home daily to check pipes and ensure that heating is well maintained to avoid freezing.
Talk to your Allstate agent to ensure you have the proper home insurance coverage while you're away.


text:
Biografia
Nato a Sun Valley, Idaho, dove il padre Jeffrey Symmonds era chirurgo, e sua madre, Andrea, una insegnante, crebbe a Boise e si diplomò nel 2002 alla Kelly Bishop High School di quella città. Al liceo vinse i campionati statali negli 800 metri piani (record personale 1'53"), 1600 metri (record personale 4'20") e 3200 metri (gare individuali) e nella staffetta 4×400 metri.

Scelse di frequentare la Willamette University di Salem rispetto ad altre scuole che avrebbero potuto offrirgli borse di studio per praticare l'atletica leggera. A Willamette, una scuola NCAA Division III, Symmonds si laureò in biochimica nel 2006 e divenne membro della confraternita Sigma Chi. In pista all'aperto vinse il campionato NCAA degli 800 metri gareggiando in tutti e quattro gli anni e il campionato NCAA dei 1500 metri piani gareggiando come matricola, juniores e seniores. Symmonds è stato il migliore studente del college negli 800 metri (1'45"83). Attualmente è il primo classificato nella NCAA Division III di sempre.

Symmonds è cinque volte campione nazionale degli 800 metri ed ha gareggiato in questa disciplina alle ultime due Olimpiadi, raggiungendo le semifinali a Pechino 2008, mentre a Londra 2012 ha concluso quinto in finale, con il suo record personale di 1'42"95. Ha vinto la medaglia d'argento negli 800 metri ai Mondiali di Mosca 2013, dopo aver concluso al sesto posto la finale mondiale del 2009 e quinto in quella del 2011.

Palmarès

Altre competizioni internazionali
  all'Osaka Grand Prix ( Osaka), 800 m piani - 1'49"45

2009
  al DécaNation ( Parigi), 800 m piani - 1'48"68

2012
  al DécaNation ( Albi), 800 m piani - 1'47"96

Altri progetti

Collegamenti esterni

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaWikipedia


and thoughtful menu set the stage for romance.
a selection from our award-winning wine list.
Then top off your visit with a decadent dessert.
This year, KR SteakBar will feature curated a la carte menu and specials.
Now taking reservations. Seating is limited so don't hesitate.


text:
Inside History: WA's Daring 20th Century Bushranger
We're delighted to report the story of our local bushranger Frank Thomas has been featured across five pages in the final hardcopy edition of Inside History magazine (Autumn 2017). The magazine is available from selected newsagents around Australia and can also be ordered online direct from Inside History for $9.95.
The Geraldton Family History Society got their hands on a copy in good time and reported on Facebook: "The current and final issue of the Inside History magazine has some fantastic articles. For those of us from Geraldton and the Mid West of WA, A Fugitive from Justice is a must read." (thanks GFHS!)
We'd like to pay tribute to Inside History and the phenomenal job they've done of sharing Australian history, heritage and genealogy over the past few years. We're especially thankful for the multiple opportunities they've given us to reach out to broader and new audiences. The good news is that Inside History will continue online in different ways and we encourage you to join us in following them on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Pinterest.
We would also like to thank the great group of volunteers who helped research the bushranger and uncover new information that contributed to the article. In many ways 2017 is the year of the bushranger... but more on that a little later!
Labels: bushranger, Carnamah, Coorow, Frank Thomas, Inside History Location: Western Australia, Australia


text:
Q: Combining IF Matching Statements Is there an easier way to put these two formulas together? I'm struggling. My two Formulas are
IF(MATCH(BASETRACKER!B2,'Code List Values'!V:V,0),"Reassign"))
and
=IF(F2="","",IF(MATCH(BASETRACKER!F2,'Code List Values'!E:E,0),"PRIVATE"))
Any help would be great!

A: Without sample data its hard to tell what you are trying to do but maybe one of these could help?
=IF(MATCH(BASETRACKER!B2,'Code List Values'!V:V,0),"Reassign",IF(F2="","",IF(MATCH(BASETRACKER!F2,'Code List Values'!E:E,0),"PRIVATE")))

=IF(MATCH(BASETRACKER!B2,'Code List Values'!V:V,0),"Reassign"))+IF(F2="","",IF(MATCH(BASETRACKER!F2,'Code List Values'!E:E,0),"PRIVATE"))