text:
The second paragraph of the Assistant Chief Commissioner's judgment reading part as follows: "There is a dispute as to whether the change" (diversion of traffic) "is because of the nature of the service afforded by the railway or because of the competition to which the railway is subjected."
The volume of traffic necessary to permit a satisfactory operation of the railway, without competition, is not in question. The only reliable service is the railway. It is under the control of the Board and it can be coerced to operate the year around.
Transportation by trucks and buses is left to the goodwill of the carriers and, when the whole question of transportation either by highways, railways, water route or airways will necessarily be studied and placed under one control as to rates, regulations, service, etc., I do not believe it is in the interest of the public that the railways be allowed to scrap assets worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, which assets may be found essential when a national system of transportation is established.
Moreover, in this instance, subsidies have been paid by the provincial government and the municipalities. The extent of the obligations contracted by the railways on account of these subsidies, we do not know; but it is not preposterous to assume that these subsidies were granted not only for the building of the railway but also for its continued operation. Contracts or by-laws exist embodying these obligations.
For these reasons, which I have developed more fully in my judgment of the 12th instant, on file 39310.1, application of C.N.R. to abandon operation of it line between Farnham and Frelighsburg—(I refer to this judgment when it issues)—I would dismiss the application.


Rick Ross has canceled his two North Carolina tour dates following threats of gang violence.
Ricky Rozay was to be joined by Wale and Meek Mill for shows in Greensboro and Charlotte, N.C., but both shows have been scrapped following some pretty sinister, scary messages. A gang called the Gangster Disciples released a video warning the Maybach Music Group trifecta that they'd be at their shows.
Further, WCNC reported that Ross received death threats from the gang earlier this week.
It's unclear whether Ross' shows will be rescheduled, but the rest of his tour is going on -- so far -- without a hitch.


text:
Tag: oil palm
How does FTA's oil palm research in Indonesia measure up?
Oil palm plantation at the border of a intact forest. Jambi, Indonesia. Photo by Iddy Farmer/CIFOR
FTA communications
The Forests, Trees and Agroforestry research program (FTA) of the CGIAR has just released an extensive evaluation of its research portfolio on oil palm in Indonesia, which assesses the influence of the work on policy, practice, partnerships, and research within the sector.
FTA Evaluation report on Oil Palm Portfolio [PDF]
Oil palm production in Indonesia is "in many ways emblematic of key economic, social, and environmental challenges and opportunities," the report's authors state. The country is a major oil palm producer, and the sector has experienced rapid growth in demand – and rapid expansion of oil palm plantations – in recent years.
While this growth has contributed considerably to the country's income, it has also been linked to severe environmental impacts, such as increased instances of fires, deforestation and peat exploitation, resulting in carbon emissions and biodiversity loss. There are also social challenges as the industry grows and becomes more regulated, such as smallholder disenfranchisement.
In that context, FTA's leading partner, the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), has been carrying out a number of research projects in Indonesia since 2010 to better understand Indonesia's governance of and policy process for oil palm management; the biophysical characteristics and ecological implications of oil palm production; and the social realities of oil palm expansion.
Now, FTA's Monitoring, Evaluation, Learning and Impact Assessment team (MELIA) has released an evaluation of that research. MELIA chose four key projects, valued at around USD7 million of investment, to represent the portfolio: Supporting Local Regulations for Sustainable Oil Palm in East Kalimantan (EK), Governing Oil Palm Landscapes for Sustainability (GOLS), Oil Palm Adaptive Landscapes (OPAL), and Engendering Roundtable for Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) Standards (ERS).
The evaluation assessed the project design, implementation and outcomes of those initiatives. "The objective was to assess the extent to which CIFOR's research on palm oil has influenced policy and practice in Indonesia – and to learn from that," said evaluation manager and CIFOR Research to Impact team leader Jean-Charles Rouge.
Portfolio's Composite Theory of Change
The team used a new Theory of Change (ToC) as the analytical framework for the evaluation. It combined key elements of the four projects to create a composite ToC, which sketched out the theoretical relationships and sequences of steps through which the portfolio aimed to contribute to particular outcomes and impacts. The portfolio's ToC identifies a total of 21 outcomes at three distinct levels:
6 end-of-project outcomes that are reasonable to expect and observable at the time of the evaluation, and therefore are testable;
7 intermediate outcomes that relate to changes in knowledge, skills and relationships, and
8 high-level outcomes to support the causal logic from end-of-project outcomes to impacts and project purpose.
The distinction between end-of-project and high-level outcomes is made because higher-level results are expected to require more time to manifest and depend on variables beyond the influence of the project. The evaluation then tested to what extent and how outcomes were realized, using document review and interviews with relevant stakeholders (see Table 1).
The evaluation constituted a significant undertaking in terms of data collection and validation. Over 200 documents were reviewed, 89 interviews were conducted, and a total of five sense-making workshops were held to validate and solicit additional input to the report with representatives from government, NGOs, partner organizations, researchers, and FTA.
"CIFOR had already used a theory-based evaluation approach in previous evaluations of research projects," said Rouge. "But in this evaluation, for the first time, the approach was used for a portfolio of projects, which led to a number of methodological challenges – on top of navigating in a very politically sensitive sector. The evaluation team addressed them well and ensured that all stakeholders had an opportunity to voice their views".
Rachel Davel, one of the evaluators from the Sustainability Research Effectiveness (SRE) Program at Royal Roads University, added that "this evaluation offered us an opportunity to work with a composite theory of change to represent the intended contributions of multiple research projects. This required additional validation from researchers of the four projects to ensure the composite accurately reflected the collective research efforts and outcomes of the portfolio. We have since transferred this learning to another study to document composite theories of change to assess the FTA program."
Rachel Claus, another member of the SRE evaluation team, noted that the value of the theory-based evaluation method was the ability of the analytical framework to make explicit and test outcomes organized around collective research contributions. "Using a theory of change framework was helpful to identify where projects were well aligned to reinforce each other and build on outcomes, and where there was scope to be more strategic, coordinated, and intentionally designed for impact," she said.
The evaluators found that the portfolio fully contributed to the realization of 12 of the 21 outcomes and partially contributed to six of them identified in the ToC. Some notable achievements include: shaping a provincial-level regulation in East Kalimantan to include high conservation areas; government partners building new expertise in oil palm topics; ally organizations using FTA findings to hold private palm oil companies accountable to their commitments; RSPO changing international oil palm certification standards to reflect gender considerations; skilling the next generation of young researchers; and advancing oil palm research.
Six of the seven intermediate outcomes, which related to changes in knowledge, skills, and relationships, were met. While there is an indication that the outcome related to the private sector learning from research was partially realized, the lack of evidence could not fully support this claim. The report explains how private sector engagement was a shortcoming of the portfolio. As a lesson, this could be a focal area for future research on oil palm that could support cross-sector engagement and progress toward sustainability in the sector.
Five of the six end-of-project outcomes were also realized, although some of the portfolio's higher-level outcomes are yet to be met; many of these depend on factors and processes that are beyond the direct influence of the portfolio.
The portfolio mechanisms that proved to have most influence related to new knowledge production and the scientific reputation of CIFOR and its partners. For instance, the smallholder typology developed by GOLS contributed to raising awareness about the need to focus policy to give the right assistance to the right kind of smallholders. "Numerous interview respondents appreciated the neutral, credible, and research-based information that CIFOR can offer to support constructive dialogues and collective action in a contentious sector," the report underlines.
"Overall, FTA's research portfolio produced knowledge on diverse aspects of oil palm sustainability and contributed to notable changes in policy, partnerships, capacity-building, and the research agenda," said Davel. The evaluation concludes that there is potential for future oil palm production in Indonesia to take place in ways that have both enhanced social benefits and fewer negative environmental impacts – if it is well-guided by government regulation, private sector commitments and research to inform sustainable and inclusive practices. However, the report also noted that there are currently a number of barriers to realizing this scenario, including competing political and economic priorities, and future legislation that could undermine sustainability initiatives in the sector.
Table 1. Summary of Outcome Assessment and Portfolio Contribution
Expected Outcome Outcome Assessment and Portfolio Contribution
High-Level Outcomes Partner organizations use project research to inform planning decisions and project development H Realized, clear portfolio contribution
Smallholders and women have improved representation in policy-making around oil palm M Partially realized, clear portfolio contribution. Relies on some theoretical extrapolation of the implication of policy changes.
The research agenda on oil palm advances toward sustainability and inclusion M Partially realized, clear portfolio contribution
Policy-makers recognize and reflect environmental sustainability and social inclusion in all oil palm-related policy M Partially realized, clear portfolio contribution
Private sector adopts more sustainable and inclusive business models L Partially realized, clear portfolio contribution
Accumulation of scholarship on oil palm influences organizational practice L Not realized, too early to assess. There is no evidence of realization. It is possible that portfolio research could indirectly contribute to practice change via portfolio influence on policy change.
Smallholders and women have improved oil palm market access and share of benefits L Not realized, too early to assess. Realization of this outcome relies on the assumption that policies are effectively implemented and enforced.
The oil palm sector (governments, private sector, NGOs, smallholders, CIFOR) develops more effective working arrangements L Partially realized, unclear portfolio contribution. Few respondents explicitly identified how the processes facilitated by the portfolio contributed to more effective working arrangements.
Intermediate Outcomes Government actors learn from oil palm research processes and findings H Realized, clear portfolio contribution
Government actors build their capacities and relationships within the oil palm sector M Realized, clear project contribution
Government actors engage CIFOR & partners to help make informed decisions on oil palm M Realized, clear project contribution
Project partnerships facilitate mutual learning on oil palm H Realized, clear portfolio contribution
Graduate students build their research capacities H Realized, clear portfolio contribution
CIFOR & partners are recognized for expertise in oil palm research H Realized, clear portfolio contribution
Private sector actors learn from oil palm research L Insufficient evidence, preliminary results indicate partial realization with clear portfolio contribution
End-of-Project Outcomes Policy-makers create new or adapt existing policy on oil palm (informed by research)
[EoP outcome] M Realized, clear portfolio contribution
Project partners & allies advocate for & pursue oil palm issues (using research)
[EoP outcome] H Realized, clear portfolio contribution
Graduate students continue careers in oil palm research to build on knowledge base
Researchers use projects' findings and methods
Researchers pursue new questions on oil palm
Private sector responds to (research-informed) policy change
[EoP outcome] L Partially realized, clear portfolio contribution
Evidence Rating: Low (L), Medium (M), High (H)
This article was written by Monica Evans.
This article was produced by the CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry (FTA). FTA is the world's largest research for development program to enhance the role of forests, trees and agroforestry in sustainable development and food security and to address climate change. CIFOR leads FTA in partnership with ICRAF, the Alliance of Bioversity International and CIAT, CATIE, CIRAD, INBAR and TBI. FTA's work is supported by the CGIAR Trust Fund.
Tamanu trees making money in arid Wonogiri, new study shows
FTA COMMUNICATIONS TEAM
Bees gather on organic honeycomb in West Kalimantan. Photo by L. McHugh/CIFOR
The tamanu tree (Calophyllum inophyllum) has been helping humans out since prehistoric times.
Tamanu is native to tropical Asia, and was carried by Austronesians on their migrations to Oceania and Madagascar: the tree was as valuable to these voyagers as oak was to their European counterparts. Also known as mastwood, tamanu has been used by shipbuilders for millennia because it grows tall and strong in sandy, rocky areas.
In Polynesia, indigenous groups affectionately refer to the tamanu tree as "beauty leaf," as they use the oil from the fruit kernel as a moisturiser and healing balm. They also use it as a hair grease and painkiller. These days, tamanu oil is used internationally in a range of skin and hair-care products.
Now, the fragrant, deep brown oil may serve another purpose: bioenergy. A mature tamanu grove can yield up to 20 tons of crude oil per hectare each year. In Wonogiri district of Central Java, Indonesia, a new study shows that cultivating tamanu for bioenergy on degraded land can achieve multiple benefits for farmers while restoring the land, as well as helping to reduce the country's reliance on fossil fuels.
Read more: Integrating bioenergy and food production on degraded landscapes in Indonesia for improved socioeconomic and environmental outcomes
Beyond oil palm
Indonesia has pledged to increase its biodiesel and bioethanol consumption to 30 percent and 20 percent respectively, of total energy consumption by 2025. However current levels of biofuel production are far from meeting these targets, and boosting production at the scale required comes with its own environmental challenges.
So far, almost all of the biofuel produced in the country has come from oil palm. But land conversion from food cropping to oil palm for biodiesel has an impact on food security. In many cases oil palm plantations have encroached upon rainforests and peatlands, threatening biodiversity and releasing carbon into the atmosphere.
Fresh palm oil fruit piled up in West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Photo by N. Sujana/CIFOR
This is why researchers have begun exploring alternative bioenergy options, looking at species with multiple uses that can grow on degraded land on which other crops struggle. A recent study showed that there are around 3.5 million hectares of degraded land across Indonesia that would be suitable for growing at least one of five key biodiesel and biomass species, including tamanu. As well as bioenergy, these crops are capable of improving soil function and boosting biodiversity, thus playing an important role in restoring the land.
Infographic: Nyamplung (Calophyllum inophyllum): Alternative bioenergy crop and powerful ally for land restoration
Farmers hit the honeypot
Planting trees on degraded lands is difficult, and the returns are slow. Farmers need other sources of income, too, if tamanu cultivation for biofuel is to be sustainable.
In Wonogiri, scientists from the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), whose work is part of the CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry (FTA), together with the Center for Forest Biotechnology and Tree Improvement Research and Development (CFBTI) and the Korean National Institute of Forest Science (NIFOS) sought to find out if the figures add up in the farmers' favor.
They collected data from 20 farmers who grow tamanu on degraded land (which locals call nyamplung). The farmers intercrop the tree with maize, rice and peanuts, and make use of it in honey production.
The researchers found that while the rice and peanuts were not profitable, and the maize was only marginally so, farmers grew them anyway to feed their families. The big money, however, lay in honey production, which was almost 300 times more profitable than maize, said CIFOR scientist Syed Rahman. "We were all surprised to see just how profitable it was," he added.
The results suggest that tamanu can be grown sustainably as part of an agroforestry system that also utilises honey production and subsistence crops in the area. What is needed now, says CFBTI senior scientist and professor Budi Leksono, is for the market for biofuels to be developed further to create economies of scale.
"The market for nyamplung oil is not really developed yet," said Leksono. "But we're anticipating an energy crisis, and [by doing this work now] we are preparing for the plantations of the future."
However, the policy around this needs to be designed extremely carefully, cautioned Rahman. "Because it's potentially so profitable," he explained, "the risk is that people will expand this system to forestland, too." He added that careful constraints must be applied to ensure it is cultivated only on degraded and underutilized lands.
The implications are exciting. As CIFOR senior scientist Himlal Baral noted, while national and global interests and commitments for forest landscape restoration are increasing, success so far has been limited by a lack of solid business cases or financial viability. "In order for funding to flow into landscape restoration, it needs to be profitable," he said.
Tamanu-based systems may well offer a compelling case for restoration that is worth everybody's while.
By Monica Evans, originally published at CIFOR's Forests News.
This research forms part of the CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry, which is supported by the CGIAR Trust Fund.
This research was supported by the CIFOR Bioenergy project funded by NIFoS (National Institute of Forest Science, South Korea).
How can rubber contribute to sustainable development in a context of climate change?
Rubber trees grow in rows in South Sumatra, Indonesia. Photo by I. Cooke Vieira/CIFOR
Developing the rubber sector while meeting environment and social objectives involves both challenges and opportunities.
Lying in the shadow of oil palm in terms of sustainable development issues, the sector needs a combination of measures to progress toward sustainable development. There is now a wealth of knowledge and evidence to make this happen.
"Evolution to Revolution: New Paths for the Rubber Economy" was the theme of the World Rubber Summit held in Singapore on March 18-19, 2019, organized by the International Rubber Study Group (IRSG). The CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry (FTA) participated in the summit and I presented during a session titled Managing sustainability performances in the rubber value chain.
Plantations of all major tropical commodities – especially oil palm, timber, pulp, cocoa and rubber – are expanding quickly, creating opportunities for development while also raising concerns about impacts on the environment, landscapes and livelihoods.
FTA has identified plantations as a research priority. Rubber is a particularly interesting example; plantations are continually expanding with a very concentrated sector downstream (the majority being a small number of tire producers), and a production sector heavily dominated by smallholders.
Read also: Challenges and opportunities for sustainable rubber in Myanmar
Rubber at a crossroads
The sector is confronted with a range of issues when it comes to its impact on and contribution to sustainable development.
Land-use change: Rubber is the most rapidly expanding tree crop within mainland Southeast Asia. Additional land will be required to meet future rubber demand, which could be in forested areas or on mosaic landscapes, swidden agriculture and agroforest, though there is also potential to reduce land-use change and deforestation through more intensive systems – both in terms of rubber and other associated production depending on situations.
Biodiversity: In many areas rubber expansion has been on former natural forest, including sometimes in protected areas. The effects of converting primary and secondary forests to rubber monoculture are well understood – it decreases species richness and changes species composition. However, the biodiversity value of swidden agriculture and of mosaic landscapes is less well known and the effects of their conversion to rubber plantations has been assessed in less detail.
Climate change mitigation: The potential contribution of rubber to climate change mitigation depends on what it replaces and the way it is conducted. The impact is generally negative when rubber replaces primary or secondary forests, but positive when planted on very degraded land. The impact can be neutral or slightly positive when rubber replaces swidden systems with a short fallow period, but negative when it displaces swidden systems that will then encroach on forest.
Water and erosion: Effects again depend on what rubber replaces. For instance, there can be less fog interception relative to complex canopies. Conversion to rubber can increase evapotranspiration relative to native vegetation. Rubber risks depleting deep-soil moisture during the dry season with effects on groundwater and streamflow. In mountainous areas of mainland Southeast Asia, plantations on steep slopes have negative impacts on soil erosion, landslide risk and water quality. There are also indications of impacts from rubber plantation runoff on water quality and aquatic biodiversity.
A hevea tree is seen in Ngazi, DRC. Photo by A. Fassio/CIFOR
Social issues: Production is still dominated by smallholders in most countries, especially in "traditional" production areas. The establishment of rubber replacing swidden agriculture has substantially increased smallholder income in Southwest China and Northern Thailand. In non-traditional areas, such as Laos, Cambodia, Myanmar and some African countries, the expansion of rubber often takes the form of larger-scale plantations – which could disadvantage rural communities, with some reports of evictions and of poor labor conditions in large-scale plantations.
Resilience to price fluctuations: Rubber prices can be volatile, which is a concern for long-term investment and has consequences for the sustainability of economic and production models. Smallholders who are purely engaged in rubber are very exposed, especially if they are not supported by public policies. Smallholders with diversified systems are the most resilient. Paradoxically, large estates may be more exposed due to monoculture and having to pay a workforce.
Climate change adaptation: Until recently it was difficult to predict the incidence of climate change on violent precipitation and winds, to which plantations are vulnerable. There is also a need for more research on the impacts of climate change on the distribution of pests and diseases. Diversified systems are more resilient to shocks of any kind, including from climate change, and can contribute to adaptation at a landscape level.
Read also: Challenges and opportunities for sustainable rubber in the Lao People's Democratic Republic
Ways forward
Given these challenges, the potential impacts of rubber expansion and the contribution to the Sustainable Development Goals and the Paris Agreement ultimately depend on three factors. First is where expansion occurs, and the land use or land cover that rubber replaces. Second, it involves production systems, yield and overall efficiency, including the use of rubber wood, as well as impacts on water and biodiversity. The third factor is benefits for smallholders and local populations, contributing to economic and social resilience.
A range of objectives could pave the way forward for sustainable development.
Limiting negative impacts of land-use change
Regulating land concessions and contract farming
Supporting smallholders and farmer groups
Promoting and improving diversified systems
To meet these objectives, it would be necessary to see a combination of measures.
Research in development
Extension services aiming for high yields and quality, as well as diversified production systems
Land-use zoning and planning
Enabling regulatory environment on concessions and contracts
Recognition of sustainable practices, including through corporate social and environmental responsibility and certification
Support and incentives for smallholders when engaging in sustainable development, such as secure tenure, technology transfer, economic risk mitigation, payment for environmental services
The rubber sector needs measures connecting downstream with upstream, involving various stakeholders, building on science and knowledge and promoting transfer in a practical way. The newly launched Global Platform for Sustainable Natural Rubber (GPSNR) will hopefully address this.
Knowledge and evidence could enable the transition in a proactive way, contributing to sustainable development outcomes. FTA stands ready to work with the GPSNR and to help support the sector move toward sustainable development, "from evolution to revolution".
By Vincent Gitz, FTA Director
The CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry (FTA) is supported by contributors to the CGIAR Trust Fund.
Getting to the bottom of illegal plantations on Indonesia's state-owned forests
A man examines oil palm fruit at a research site in Indonesia. Photo by D. Ramsay/CIFOR
Palm oil is used locally in cooking, and internationally in commercial food and personal care products. Photo by M. Pinheiro/CIFOR
In an ideal world, palm oil production would cause no deforestation, and have a transparent and fair supply chain. In reality, the impacts of the sector have been the cause of ethical concerns worldwide.
Palm oil is Indonesia's most important commodity. In 2017 the country produced 37.8 million tonnes of crude palm oil (CPO) and exported over 80 percent of it, with a value of $31.8 billion. Indonesia is the world's biggest palm oil producer, and its biggest exporter too.
The strong market demand of palm oil has led to a vast expansion of plantations. Currently smallholders make up around 40 percent of the production market, and around one-third of these do not have the correct land tenure permits. In some cases, the smallholders have moved into state-owned forest areas and in many cases, this occupancy creates conflict.
In 2017, the Ministry of Agriculture's Directorate General of Plantations found that of the 2.5 million hectares of oil palm plantations on state-owned forests, 70 percent of these were controlled by smallholders.
To get to the bottom of why oil palm plantations continue to encroach into state forest areas, Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) organized a workshop in collaboration with Center for Research and Development on Social, Economics, Policy and Climate Change (P3SEPKI): 'Linking science to policy: the role of research in the effort to accelerate solution of tenurial problems in oil palm plantation in forest areas.'
Read also: Comparative study of local nutrition and diet examines expansion of oil palm plantations into forest areas
Solving conflicts by understanding the underlying cause
In his presentation, Ismatul Hakim, senior researcher at P3SEPKI, says that complex tenure conflicts can't be resolved without understanding why oil palm plantations are encroaching into state forest areas. He believes assessing how different types of farmers take control of lands, what strategies they use, and most importantly, the motivations of the farmers, is needed before long-lasting resolution is achieved.
According to Hakim's research, this can be segregated into four categories:
The first is maladministration, where a lack of coordination leads to disputes as it is unclear who legally manages the forest areas – is it the Ministry of Environment and Forestry or the local government?
Second, incomplete forest area gazettements- a legal declaration that announces state ownership- coupled with a lack of clarity and communication on where the gazetted boundaries lay, have caused local people, in need for income, to expand their plantations into unmarked forest areas.
Third, inequality of power and land ownership has caused people to encroach. Local people have watched big investors and corporations take control of and transform their ancestral land, and store land for the future (known as 'landbanking').
And finally, the ineffective implementation of policies for forest area release and land swap- where the government gives areas of new land to plantations in exchange for restoring degraded land. To add, he says, this is further hampered by the slow pace of conflict resolution.
Drawing from his research, Bayu Eka Yulian from Bogor Agricultural University (IPB) added "Oil palm plantations have expanded rapidly in East Kalimantan, particularly those smallholders in a silence mode." He argued while corporations might generally adhere to tighter regulations, small holder farmers, including those with access to more capital and information, appear to expand their plantations at a scale from 0.5 to 3 hectares of land or even more, without restraint.
The attendees agreed that the situation will keep perpetuating itself without intervention. Rapid expansion is causing damaging changes to the landscape, but farmers are also becoming trapped- as they become highly dependent on a monoculture crop, and get trapped on a single source of income.
Read also: The long and winding road to sustainable palm oil
Solving tenure issues through better governance
In September 2018, the Indonesian government issued a three-year moratorium on new oil palm plantation permits and devised attempts to increase productivity, expressed in Presidential Instruction (Inpres) No. 8/2018. Along with other prevailing policies, this moratorium offers an excellent opportunity to resolve tenure issues.
However, it was feared that the temporary halt might simply not be enough.
"It was generally agreed by the workshop participants that regulations should be clear and not create legal uncertainties," said CIFOR scientist Heru Komarudin, adding that plantations that are currently operating on state forests should be given enough time to either relocate or have their land status legally changed to non-forest areas.
He similarly believes that smallholder plantations already illegally on state forests should be given the chance to confirm their land status through agrarian reform or social forestry schemes that are already in place.
"Priority should be given to those committed to practising ethical agriculture – by preventing further deforestation and promoting fair trade working rights," said Komarudin. To create policies that work, the "heterogeneous typology" of smallholders, and the impact of plantations on local people need to be taken into account, he adds.
Furthermore, there is opportunity to raise state funds by getting tenure issues right. Legislating and governing the use and rental of state forest can then be further propped up by compensation payments by companies who have illegally encroached. While strict law enforcement could be used to police the tenure issues, granting land amnesty to those that depend heavily on these lands may be a breakthrough.
Internationally, the European Union Renewable Energy Directive which plans to phase out the use of palm oil for biofuel by 2030, has put pressure on the Indonesian palm producers. In responding to this development, workshop attendees agreed that foreign diplomacy should be strengthened by consolidating the national position, which in turn would make the Indonesian Sustainable Palm Oil (ISPO) certification credible.
"Building solidarity with other producing countries to promote best practices and a sustainable and legal palm oil industry is essential," says Maharani Hapsari, PhD and lecturer of international relations at Gadjah Mada University. "Indonesia should focus its diplomacy on palm oil global trade not only to strengthen authority, but also to enhance legitimacy of forest and oil palm governance by the broadest possible range of stakeholders."
By Nabiha Shahab and Dominique Lyons, originally published at CIFOR's Forests News.
For more information on this topic, please contact Heru Komarudin at h.komarudin@cgiar.org.
This research forms part of the CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry (FTA), which is supported by the CGIAR Trust Fund.
This research is part of the Governing Oil Palm Landscapes for Sustainability (GOLS) project, which is supported by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). The GOLS project supports effective and equitable implementation of the New York Declaration on Forests commitments by helping to align public and private policies and actions, and by delivering targeted, research-based evidence to key stakeholders and practitioners.
Making the grade: Challenges and prospects for sustainable smallholder oil palm in Indonesia
"Making the Grade" looks at challenges and prospects for sustainable smallholder oil palm in Indonesia.
This video was first published by CIFOR.
Multiple actors need to perform together on governing sustainable palm oil in Indonesia
Key players are seeing a moratorium on new oil palm concession permits in Indonesia as a significant step forward in improving governance in the sector.
During the three-year freeze, following Indonesian President Joko Widodo's recent signing of the moratorium, the government will undertake a comprehensive nationwide review of oil palm licenses and develop efforts to enhance productivity – particularly for smallholders.
However, it remains to be seen whether the existing palm oil supply can be sustainable, and whether negative impacts on the environment can be reduced while the performance of smallholders linked to palm oil supply chains – who depend on the commodity for their livelihoods – is also improved.
Oil palms edge the forest in Sentabai, West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Photo by Nanang Sujana/CIFOR
Research conducted at the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) led by senior associate Pablo Pacheco is examining how public regulations and private standards can address major performance gaps affecting the palm oil sector. The study was focused on the world's largest palm oil producer, Indonesia.
"We looked at how the current policy regime complex can address three major gaps, specifically land conflicts and yield differences between companies and smallholders and carbon emissions arising from deforestation and peatland conversion," Pacheco said.
"We identified opportunities for more effective governance of the palm oil value chain and supply landscapes by analyzing disconnects, complementarities and antagonisms between public regulations and private standards across global, national and subnational levels," he added.
The scientists concluded that greater complementarities have emerged among transnational mechanisms, but found also that disconnects persist and antagonisms prevail between national state regulations and transnational private standards.
To improve the sector's governance and address performance gaps, there is a need to overcome these disconnects and take steps to reconcile the antagonisms.
"The solutions for addressing the performance gaps need to be looked at in an integrated way and through adopting a multi-level approach," Pacheco said. "In addition, the solutions have to involve both public regulations and private initiatives and efforts."
Read also: Implementing sustainability commitments for palm oil in Indonesia: Governance arrangements of sustainability initiatives involving public and private actors
Oil palm fruit is numbered after harvesting. Photo by Icaro Cooke Vieira/CIFOR
GROWING SECTOR, GROWING ISSUES
Palm oil is used in thousands of products from food to cosmetics, cleaning products and biodiesel. This has created a growing global demand for the golden liquid.
"There is not a single sector that has grown as rapidly as palm oil," Pacheco said. "However, these unresolved performance issues continue to follow this expansion."
One of the key issues is the land used to grow oil palm. Land conflicts are difficult to solve and despite efforts to formalize tenure rights, encroachment on public lands continues to grow. Smallholders often rely on informal transactions to access land.
Smallholders produce around 40 percent of Indonesia's oil palm, but yields are still less than they could be due to limited access to finance and services.
"Smallholders are unable to adopt best management practices and the use of substandard planting material remains widespread," said Pacheco.
Reducing carbon emissions in the oil palm sector has been hampered by current regulations that allow the use of forested or high carbon stock areas for plantations, combined with poor use of degraded and less productive areas.
"Many companies prefer to establish their plantations in peatlands and forestland because of the reduced likelihood of land conflicts and the potential to cover the cost of establishing a plantation by selling timber cleared for these plantations," Pacheco said.
"The result has been a significant carbon debt," he added.
MIND THE GAPS
In an effort to overcome the palm oil sector's performance gaps, a very complex governance architecture has emerged that brings together governments and the private sector, as well as multistakeholder platforms.
The Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) is perhaps the best-known sustainability standard, and has been embraced by European Union-related sustainability initiatives. This is the most relevant complementarity which has helped to reach some agreed sustainability criteria.
Yet Indonesia and Malaysia have also devised their own sustainability standards – known as ISPO and MSPO – to counteract the influence of external players. Despite efforts to strengthen these mandatory standards, the scientists say it remains to be seen whether they are going to support zero-deforestation commitments embraced by main corporate groups.
Additionally, they say that greater impact could likely be achieved by building a process to harmonize the RSPO with these national standards.
Read also: Governing sustainable palm oil supply: Disconnects, complementarities, and antagonisms between state regulations and private standards
A woman fertilizes soil in an oil palm plantation. Photo by Icaro Cooke Vieira/CIFOR
FOLLOW THE DISCONNECTS
Pacheco says for the palm oil sector to improve its performance, it is crucial to look at the implications and opportunities associated with the national fiscal incentives system, including those related to the use of the crude CPO Fund.
"For example, these funds should more actively link incentives for companies engaging in biodiesel supply with purchases from smallholders on condition they adhere to sustainability criteria," he said, adding that this approach would help improve the environmental performance of smallholders while supporting the sustainable supply of palm oil for the domestic biodiesel market.
Another major disconnect is related to the fact that land regularization initiatives do not necessarily go hand-by-hand with those aiming at support sustainable palm oil supply, and improve the wellbeing of smallholders. This is a major bottleneck to overcome.
"Government efforts to implement agrarian reform along with social forestry to benefit local communities have not been fully effective in resolving these issues," said Heru Komarudin, a researcher with CIFOR.
Another disconnect is linked to land use regulations. More and more buyers are looking for No Deforestation, No Peat, No Exploitation (NDPE) – suppliers, but critics say that although companies may have the policy in place, they do not always put those policies into action.
In some cases, laws and regulations do not support companies that opt to conserve areas with high carbon stock or high conservation value, Komarudin said.
"These areas are often seen as unused lands and are at risk of being taken over by the government, and used for new plantations, instead of being protected from local people who may try to encroach on these areas," he added.
More and more local governments are also adopting policies to protect high conservation value forests, and governments have started to adopt essential ecosystem area principles although no legally-binding rules are in place yet.
The researchers note that different "experimentalist approaches" are emerging that address disconnects and antagonisms, while further exploiting existing complementarities.
These approaches are increasingly orchestrated by provincial level governors and facilitated by non-governmental organizations, which often tend to operate as intermediaries.
"There's no silver bullet, no single solution. It's clear we need an integrated approach to effectively govern the palm oil sector, one where all actors play key roles," Pacheco said.
By Suzanna Dayne, originally published at CIFOR's Forests News.
For more information on this topic, please contact Pablo Pacheco at p.pacheco@cgiar.org or Heru Komarudin at h.komarudin@cgiar.org.
This research is supported by the United States Agency for International Development and Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH.
Comparative study of local nutrition and diet examines expansion of oil palm plantations into forest areas
When Rosalina Heni is not working in the rice paddy fields in Ribang Kadeng village in the Indonesian province of West Kalimantan, she gathers vegetables in the surrounding forest for her family to eat.
By contrast, in nearby Sekadu Village, local resident Maria Ludiana can no longer collect enough ferns, bamboo shoots and other vegetables to feed her family because an oil palm plantation has supplanted the natural growth forest.
"Right now, we buy more," Ludiana says in a new video produced by the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR). "The difference is that before, everything was natural – natural foods, spices. The types of meat we eat have started to change."
Watch: Expansion of oil palm plantations into forests appears to be changing local diets in Indonesia
The subsistence livelihoods of more than 150 million residents of rural areas in Indonesia are at risk from oil palm expansion, according to scientists studying impact on nutritional status and diets as part of a research project funded by the Drivers of Food Choice (DFC) Competitive Grants Programs, which is funded by the UK Government's Department for International Development and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, and managed by the University of South Carolina, Arnold School of Public Health, USA.
In some circumstances the scientists have already observed traditional diets being abandoned.
"So far, we've seen that the people who live in the forest rely on nature – nature becomes their main way to get food," says Yusuf Habibie, lecturer in the Department of Nutrition in the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Brawijaya in the city of Malang in East Java province. "Then, when land is converted to oil palm plantations, with no forests, people lose access to wild food from the forest. Instead they start to purchase more food, including packaged foods."
Forests and agroforestry systems which combine trees and crops play important roles in food security and nutrition, says CIFOR Scientist Amy Ickowitz, observing that communities in West Kalimantan eating forest foods, including fruit, vegetables, fish and meat, are getting all nutritional components found in healthy diets.
"Forests can play an important role in making our global food system more sustainable and more environmentally friendly, while making an important contribution to healthy diets ," Ickowitz says, adding that improving food security and nutrition is not always as simple as raising incomes in rural communities; oil palm companies, governments, and researchers need to work together to find ways to make sure that landscape change does not harm health and nutrition while improving incomes.
If there are no plants, where are we going to be if not dead, queries Bandi, a respected elder living in the village of Sungai Utik.
"Nature is our supermarket," he says. "If there is no forest, where can we get this variety of food? We will be forced to buy."
Scientists are continuing their research into the impact of plantations on local forests in Indonesia. As yet, they have not compared oil palm with rubber plantations, which may not have the same impact on local diets.
For more information on this topic, please contact Amy Ickowitz at a.ickowitz@cgiar.org.
By Julie Mollins, originally published at CIFOR's Forests News.
Implementing sustainability commitments for palm oil in Indonesia: Governance arrangements of sustainability initiatives involving public and private actors
The palm oil sector in Indonesia has seen the adoption of zero deforestation commitments by the larger companies in the form of various pledges around No Deforestation, No Peat, and No Exploitation (NDPE). At the same time, at the national and sub-national level, new governance arrangements are emerging for sustainability initiatives involving government, the private sector and other non-state actors. These initiatives have created new forms of governance relationships, most notably a shift in the types of function that were once the sole domain of the state. Some initiatives are independent and formulated outside of the state, but others interact with, and support, state actions. This paper explores the interactions between public and private sectors in the palm oil arena in Indonesia. It examines tensions and complementarities between these sectors, the degree to which, and manner in which, private standards are pushing the sustainability debate and implementation, and the likely outcomes in relation to their design.
Governing sustainable palm oil supply: Disconnects, complementarities, and antagonisms between state regulations and private standards
The global palm oil value chain has grown in complexity; stakeholder relationships and linkages are increasingly shaped by new public and private standards that aim to ameliorate social and environmental costs while harnessing economic gains. Regulatory initiatives in the emerging policy regime complex struggle to resolve sector-wide structural performance issues: pervasive land conflicts, yield differences between companies and smallholders, and carbon emissions arising from deforestation and peatland conversion. Identifying opportunities for more effective governance of the palm oil value chain and supply landscapes, this paper explores disconnects, complementarities, and antagonisms between public regulations and private standards, looking at the global, national, and subnational policy domains shaping chain actors' conduct. Greater complementarities have emerged among transnational instruments, but state regulation disconnects persist and antagonisms prevail between national state regulations and transnational private standards. Emerging experimental approaches, particularly at subnational level, aim to improve coordination to both enhance complementarities and resolve disconnects.
Interactive map provides tools for corporate accountability and land-use planning in Papua
The contrast between oil palm plantation and forest is seen in Papua, Indonesia. Photo by Agus Andrianto/CIFOR
Scientists hope a new interactive atlas that tracks deforestation annually will enable local governments to plan for change and avert widespread destruction of the forests on which indigenous people depend for food and livelihoods.
Due to its remote location and sparse population, Papua, Indonesia, harbors one of the Pacific's last remaining expanses of pristine tropical forest. However, recent spikes in deforestation rates, accompanied by the expansion of industrial oil palm plantations, are signs that rapid change is on the horizon.
"The Papua Atlas will show where forest is being cleared on the island and who is responsible for the deforestation," said David Gaveau, a research associate with the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), who demonstrated a prototype of the atlas at the International Conference on Biodiversity, Ecotourism and Creative Economy (ICBE) in Manokwari, Papua, on Oct. 7 to 11, 2018.
The platform, due to launch in mid-2019, will track deforestation on a monthly basis over the long-term.
Local government officials in charge of spatial planning welcome the development of the atlas, which they can use to help plan land use as the local population grows and demand for roads and other services increases in tandem. For example, the annual data provided by the atlas will provide insight into the dynamics of forest loss and the expansion of industrial oil palm concessions, and roads into forested areas.
Old-growth forest in Indonesian Papua shrank by 2 percent, a loss of 600,000 hectares, between 2000 and 2017 (Fig. 1).
Annual forest loss in Indonesian Papua has accelerated gradually since 2000, reaching a peak in both provinces in 2015 and 2016, with 98,000 hectares and 85,000 hectares lost, respectively, before dropping markedly in 2017 (Fig. 1b & c).
Meanwhile, industrial plantations, mainly for oil palm, have nearly quadrupled since 2000, with the largest expansion in Papua province. Gaveau's studies indicate that about 30 percent of all forest loss since 2000 has been due to clearing for industrial plantations.
Fig 1. Annual loss of forest area from 2001 to 2017 in (a) Indonesian Papua, (b) Papua province (b) and (c) West Papua province.
"The island of New Guinea is perhaps the last large equatorial island that is still pristine," Gaveau says. "It is still 90 percent natural forest, and it is sparsely populated."
Because of its distance from key trading routes, Pacific ports and cities, it is expensive to install industrial facilities, such as palm oil refineries in Indonesian Papua. But the island is not immune to the spread of the palm oil industry, which has expanded throughout other islands, such as Borneo.
"As prime land becomes scarce on other islands, companies are turning their eyes to Papua," Gaveau says.
That's where the Papua Atlas comes in.
The interactive map is similar to the Atlas of Deforestation and Industrial Plantations in Borneo, also known as the Borneo Atlas, which Gaveau, a landscape ecologist, and Mohammad Agus Salim a Geographic Information Systems expert with CIFOR, developed to monitor deforestation on that island. The Borneo Atlas allows users to verify the location and ownership of more than 460 palm-oil mills on Borneo and monitor deforestation in the surrounding area.
Data about ownership show which companies linked to plantations are encroaching on forests and peat lands.
"The principle of the Papua Atlas is the same," Gaveau says. "The overarching idea is to hold companies accountable for the deforestation they might have caused, whether or not it is done legally. The idea is that the Indonesian local and national governments can check those deforestation footprints in concessions to review the permits."
See also: Atlas of deforestation and industrial plantations in Borneo
PLANNING FOR CHANGE
The arrival of industrial plantations is not the only change threatening to transform Papua's pristine forest landscape. Logging for timber exports is increasing, tailings from a copper mine are destroying mangrove swamps, and people migrating from other islands are swelling urban populations.
As cities and towns expand, residents demand more public services, including better transportation. In planning everything from roads to housing, local government officials will have to assess the many tradeoffs that inevitably accompany development.
To ensure that the Papua Atlas is especially useful to land-use planners, Gaveau and Salim consulted extensively with local governments.
"New roads are being built to link the provinces of Papua and West Papua, and we know that with roads comes deforestation," Salim says.
That could jeopardize the livelihoods of the indigenous people who live in the island's forests and who depend on forest products for food, housing materials, fuel and their livelihoods.
Government officials are taking steps to put the brakes on some undesired impacts.
West Papua was declared a conservation province in October 2015. The government of West Papua has committed to keeping 70 percent of the province's land under protection.
Only about half the province's land is currently protected, so the challenge will be to increase that area.
In September 2018, Indonesian President Joko Widodo announced a three-year moratorium on new oil palm concessions on forest land managed by the national government, although the ban does not apply to forest within existing concessions or forest land controlled by local governments.
The Papua Atlas can help observers determine whether the moratorium is being respected, Gaveau says.
Government officials will also be able to use it to analyze land-use patterns and review licenses for agricultural concessions. Knowing which companies hold concessions and how they are using their land will enable government officials to adjust tax rates, Salim says.
"The atlas can be an important tool for conservation and land management," he adds.
Read also: New map helps track palm-oil supply chains in Borneo
A settlement is seen from the air in Papua, Indonesia. Photo by Agus Andrianto/CIFOR
A LOCAL VIEW OF A GLOBAL
As the use of freely accessible platforms for tracking land use becomes more common, the Papua and Borneo atlases stand out for the degree of detail they offer.
Users can see which companies are clear-cutting old-growth forest, how much newly planted areas companies are adding, and where palm producers are moving into sensitive areas such as peat lands, which are crucial for carbon storage. The database also shows corporate relationships among companies, enabling users to better understand the market forces behind deforestation and to track corporations' zero-deforestation commitments.
The atlas will provide a view of deforestation over time, with animations that show how plantations and roads have expanded, where land has been burned, where new land has been planted, and where forest and landscape restoration are under way.
"It's important to be able to see both forest loss and the newly planted area, because you can then measure the conversion of forests to plantations," Gaveau said "If forest was cleared and a plantation was established all within one year, there's little question that both were the work of the company located in that place."
The map can also be used to gauge impacts of those changes. When deforestation and planting occur near a river, for example, increased erosion is likely to affect aquatic life and ecosystems downstream.
Gaveau and Salim also hope it will solve a mystery. Deforestation on the island spiked in 2015 and 2016 even though no new concessions were granted in those years, which puzzles local government officials.
The interactive map can also link to platforms and databases developed locally, placing more useful information at the fingertips of local government officials.
"We are trying to develop ways of looking at the data that are important for analyzing impacts and planning for the future," Gaveau said.
"These interactive platforms that promote corporate accountability and make it possible to trace products to their place of origin are just a start," he added. "In a few years, we will have intelligent systems that will provide more detailed information, more frequently."
Not only will that information provide a record of the past, but it will also give a glimpse of what lies ahead.
"Papua is important — it's the last frontier of Indonesia, and one of the last in the tropical world," Salim says. "The question is what do its people want for the future?"
The Papua Atlas will provide guideposts in the search for an answer.
By Barbara Fraser, originally published at CIFOR's Forests News.
For more information, contact David Gaveau at D.Gaveau@cgiar.org and Mohammad Agus Salim at moh.agus.salim@gmail.com.
The Papua Atlas is being developed with financial assistance from Britain's Department for International Development (DFID).
What's holding back biodiesel industry growth in Indonesia?
A woman shows freshly collected oil palm fruit in Indonesia. Photo by Icaro Cooke Vieira/CIFOR
Despite Indonesia's reputation as the largest producer of palm oil in the world, its bioenergy production remains relatively low. Recently, a study has found that a range of policy and technical obstacles are preventing the sector's growth.
A team from the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) and Bogor Agricultural University (IPB) interviewed key informants from central and regional Indonesian governments and the business sector during research on the opportunities and challenges presented by policies relating to the development of palm oil–based biodiesel, leading to the release of a working paper.
"We found a number of policies and technical challenges that still hinder the development of biodiesel production in Indonesia," says CIFOR Scientist Ahmad Dermawan.
Among the constraints identified in the study is the fact that biodiesel production cannot grow consistently due to policies that do not support one another.
"Existing policy frameworks give a mandate to biodiesel blending targets. However, in practice, this has not been optimal because, first, they are still focused on the transport sector, and second, they still emphasize public service obligations [PSOs]," says Dermawan.
He also said that within the country's new and renewable energy development sector, there is a belief that biodiesel development still lies with the central government, causing a lack of understanding about the role of subnational government. Though small, the role that regional governments play in developing policies supporting biodiesel use in the region is rarely in focus.
"In the National Energy Policy, the central government is required to put together a National Energy Plan [RUEN], and the provincial government is required to have a Regional Energy Plan [RUED]. Currently, many provinces have yet to develop their RUED."
Read more: The long and winding road to sustainable palm oil
A couple collects oil palm fruit in Indonesia. Photo by Icaro Cooke Vieira/CIFOR
PALM OIL'S POTENTIAL
Indonesia is the world's largest producer and consumer of palm oil, producing more than 38 million tons of crude palm oil (CPO) in 2017. With around 75% of its total production exported, the commodity contributed USD 23 billion in export revenue in 2017.
Despite global contention around palm oil (earlier this year, the European Parliament voted to end the use of palm oil in biofuel by 2030) it is by far the most efficient vegetable oil when compared to other oil-producing commodity crops, meaning it requires relatively less land to produce the same amount of product.
Oil palm also remains one of the most important agricultural commodities in Indonesia for the production of bioenergy, with at least two potential forms of energy produced from the crop: biodiesel and biopower. The former is produced through refining palm oil, while the latter is produced by further processing bunches of fresh oil palm fruit to generate electricity.
Bioenergy for electricity is also being developed from wood biomass, but oil palm still prevails. "The source of biodiesel production varies quite a lot," says Dermawan. "At one point, Jatropha and Nyamplung were developed as raw materials for biodiesel," he added, referring to a flowering plant and an evergreen tree, respectively. "However, Indonesia's large production of palm oil makes it the most commercially ready for development."
Read more: Governments' oil palm strategies too focused on expanding plantations, scientist says
OPPORTUNITIES AND COSTS
The paper also studied the financial cost of producing biodiesel and compared it with that of diesel fuel, which still receives government subsidies.
"Production cost for biodiesel is higher because there are additional production steps to be done before buyers – in this case, Pertamina and other PSO companies – will accept the biodiesel," Dermawan explains.
In mid-2015, the government formed a unit under the Ministry of Finance to manage funds collected from levies paid by the exporters of CPO and its derivatives. This unit, the Oil Palm Plantation Fund Management Body (BPDPKS), uses the funds to develop human resources as well as promote, research and develop palm oil as a commodity.
"The BPDPKS provides incentives by covering the gap between the price of subsidized diesel fuel and the production cost of biodiesel," says Dermawan.
Aside from sheer cost, biodiesel production is complicated on other fronts too. From the management side, production is often contingent on fluctuating supply and quality control.
"Some biodiesel companies get their raw materials from palm oil mills that receive oil palm kernels from farmers," says Dermawan. "The mills do not always receive their fresh fruit bunches consistently in regards to quality and quantity. Low fruit quality will impact the quality of the palm oil and, in the end, impact the quality of the resulting biodiesel."
Getting deeper into the technicalities of production, Spent Bleaching Earth (SBE), a residue from biodiesel production, is regulated as a hazardous and toxic material, known in Indonesia as B3. As such, it should be handled with extra care, which results in additional costs for biodiesel producers.
However, studies have shown that SBE contains oil that can be further processed into something useful, and more research is needed to explore its potential. Despite challenges, Dermawan says opportunities remain to optimize biodiesel production.
By Nabiha Shahab, originally published at CIFOR's Forests News.
For more information on this topic, please contact Ahmad Dermawan at a.dermawan@cgiar.org.
This research forms part of the CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry, which is supported by CGIAR Fund Donors.
This research was supported by the "Forest in Global Bioeconomy: Developing Multi-Scale Policy Scenarios" program funded by the German Ministry of Economic and Development Cooperation (BMZ).
Deep down in supply chains, zero deforestation commitments look different to what appears on paper
Oil palm plantations are a driver of deforestation in Indonesia. Photo by Iddy Farmer/CIFOR
A paddy field and oil palm plantation area is seen from above in East Kalimantan, Indonesia. Photo by N. Sujana/CIFOR
Oil palm, cattle, timber and soy have all received global attention in recent years for their outsized 'forest footprints' – the risks that their demand and cultivation pose for tropical forests around the world.
Thanks to pressure and advocacy from civil society, governments, shareholders and consumers in the Global North, many companies using and selling these commodities have begun to clean up their acts.
They have sought to become – or at least appear – more accountable for the environmental impacts of their supply chain activities. As a result, recent years have seen many make zero deforestation commitments (ZDCs) for the provenance of the commodities on which they rely.
From an environmental perspective, the move is welcome and timely. Tropical deforestation accounted for around 12% of global greenhouse gas emissions between 2000 and 2012. If these 'big four' commodities go deforestation-free, it could make a big difference for biodiversity and climate change mitigation worldwide.
However, following through without producing unintended negative side effects is going to be difficult. And this – or failing to follow through at all – could see ZDCs become dubbed with a tokenistic reputation as being just another public-relations and marketing strategy.
A new CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry (FTA)-supported occasional paper by Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) scientist George Schoneveld and Particip GmbH consultant Peter Jopke seeks to assess the ZDCs of 50 'powerbrokers' – companies that have the potential to shape rules in major commodities' global value chains. The work attempts to unravel what these bold-sounding commitments might actually mean for forests, producers and communities on the ground.
Read more: Strengthening social inclusion within oil palm contract farming in the Brazilian Amazon
CLEAR AS MUD
Unfortunately, the researchers found serious gaps in ZDC implementation practices, which undermine the commitments' potentials. "On paper the commitments are great, and they use the right terms and are fairly comprehensive in their scope, but by and large companies have yet to fully think through how they're going to deliver on them," says Schoneveld.
Company commitments to full transparency in sourcing locations and suppliers, and to independent verification, were found to be particularly weak. This doesn't necessarily suggest that companies are trying to hide bad practices, say the co-authors, but more that it can be very difficult for them to follow their own supply chains back to their roots. Sourcing practices of the many upstream actors often involved can change without the lead firms being aware.
The study also found that almost 75% of companies did not demand company-wide ZDCs of their suppliers. This suggests that most companies actually tolerate deforestation in their supply chains, as long as their own supply comes from non-deforested areas. So suppliers to these companies might still be instigating deforestation and selling commodities from deforested areas to other, non-ZD–committed customers.
The finding makes sense, given that going zero-deforestation was "purely a business decision," not a moral or philanthropic one, for most of the companies surveyed, says Schoneveld. As long as their brand is not contaminated, companies have little incentive to pressure their suppliers to stop deforestation entirely.
PASSING THE BUCK?
Another issue of concern is the fact that in most cases, the powerbrokers did not explicitly account for the externalities resulting from their ZDCs, says Schoneveld. For example, insisting on buying commodities cultivated on non-deforested land increases demand for that land, which can displace former land uses such as food production. As a result, deforestation could occur indirectly as other users of that land are pushed to resume their practices elsewhere.
Committing to ZDCs may also prompt companies in the supply chain to sell off forest land banks that they hold, since they will no longer be able to use them to cultivate commodities. This land could then be deforested by a new owner or by communities vacating their farmland to enable corporate expansion.
Perhaps most concerning of all is that if companies implement more stringent production standards, only some producers will have the capacity to conform, so many smallholders are likely to be excluded, says Schoneveld.
"If you have to monitor everybody and trace all oil palm that comes in, and you have ten thousand suppliers, it becomes extremely costly," he explains. "So a lot of companies are starting to say, 'Okay, we have to cut our supply base and focus on those suppliers that we trust and know well.' " Oil palm refiners in Indonesia, for example, have begun to concentrate their 'sustainable' supply base around larger plantations.
And this is where the tensions become quite stark. One interviewed company, for example, complained that they were forced to remove a "huge chunk" of smallholders from their supply chain to please NGOs campaigning for ZD, because they expected to be criticized for failing to protect forests more than acknowledged for their efforts of including smallholders.
Read more: Corporate commitments to zero deforestation: An evaluation of externality problems and implementation gaps
A TALL ORDER
Certainly, given the influence powerbrokers have on both suppliers and governments, there are opportunities to innovate and exert pressure within value chains themselves. "It's an important place to start," Schoneveld acknowledges.
But it seems something of a tall order to expect companies to enact such holistic solutions all on their own. "If you want to have ZDCs that also contribute to agricultural development and food security, and support smallholder integration, I don't think you can rely solely on companies to deliver on those," he says. "And that's where governments need to step in."
Jurisdictional approaches that integrate landscape planning, deforestation monitoring and improved regulatory enforcement across a defined jurisdiction may provide part of the solution. Most companies are interested in working in places that can guarantee that production is sustainable, because it reduces their own monitoring and traceability costs. And smallholders within those areas can comply with ZD requirements, without needing to sign up to complex and expensive monitoring and evaluation systems. Some jurisdictions, such as Indonesia's South Sumatra and Central Kalimantan provinces and Malaysia's Sabah state, are beginning to apply these kinds of approaches, "saying, 'hey, there could be economic benefits to being sustainable,' " explains Schoneveld.
Government involvement is also important because companies making zealous commitments to managing land differently in developing countries can be perceived as challenging their sovereignty. "There needs to be a better conversation between companies, governments, and civil society," says Schoneveld, "about what role each could play in meeting environmental, economic and developmental objectives, and how to have more complementary initiatives."
For more information on this topic, please contact George Schoneveld at g.schoneveld@cgiar.org.
This research was supported by UKAID and International Forestry Knowledge II (KNOWFOR II).
Corporate commitments to zero deforestation: An evaluation of externality problems and implementation gaps
This research critically examines implementation gaps and externality problems associated with the recent proliferation of zero deforestation commitments (ZDC) by large commodity producers. By developing and employing a hierarchical framework, we evaluate the policies and strategies of 50 leading ZDC adopters in high forest-risk commodity sectors (soy, oil palm, cattle and wood). The analysis shows that while most ZDC adopters formulated strong ZDCs, there is significant room for further refining implementation mechanisms. Specifically, it finds that weak commitment to full transparency, notably disclosure of sourcing locations and suppliers, and to independent verification, undermines ZDCs' transformative potential and ability to hold companies accountable for failure to comply with their ZDCs. Our analysis also reveals that most sampled companies do not explicitly account for the socially detrimental externalities that their ZDCs threaten to produce. Where this is acknowledged, it is acknowledged implicitly through standing commitments to full voluntary certification, especially in the wood and oil palm sector. As a result, issues related to free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) and protection of high conservation value (HVC) ecosystems are comparatively well addressed by adopters, but challenges faced by smallholders, food security risks, and indirect land use change issues are only minimally accounted for. Our results suggest that for ZDCs to contribute meaningfully to inclusive and sustainable development potential, complementarities between private and public regulatory initiatives need to be better leveraged.
Good governance and sustainability incentives can provide alternatives to land conversion fires
During land burning, haze blankets the landscape in Riau Province, Indonesia. Photo by Aulia Erlangga/CIFOR
In Indonesia, palm oil is a hot industry in more ways than one. In 2015 alone, it contributed USD 20.75 billion to the country's export revenue. Oil palm plantations cover more than 14 million hectares of the country and, together with Malaysia's, dominate the global market.
However, fire is still widely used in the development and planting of oil palm, including in carbon-rich peatlands. Resulting smoke and toxic haze have impacted the economy, the health and the environment of Indonesia and other Southeast Asian countries. In 2015, Indonesia's peatland fires contributed to an economic loss of at least USD 16.1 billion and more than 100,000 premature deaths around the region.
In light of this, a new study led by Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) scientist Herry Purnomo, which also forms part of the CGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry (FTA), looks at the extent to which good governance principles are applied to Indonesia's palm oil value chain and analyzes options to help reduce the use of forest and land fires in the industry.
"Palm oil is one of Indonesia's main commodity exports, surpassing oil and gas," says Purnomo. "But if we do not manage its sustainability, this sector can fail.
The research focuses on Indonesia's Riau Province, which experienced massive forest conversion to have the largest area of oil palm plantations in the country. Now, it has the highest domestic frequency of fires too.
"We know that 20% of fire incidences happen in oil palm plantation areas, so we tried to find out what caused the fires and how to reduce them."
Read more: Towards responsible and inclusive financing of the palm oil sector
In theory, the central government has power to influence the oil palm supply chain through law and policies; district-level governments have the most jurisdiction for law enforcement and information-spreading; and village governments are closest to plantation developers, thus having the responsibility of dealing directly with them.
However, good governance for the industry is not as simple as a top-down approach. From consumers to mills, refineries and developers, players in palm oil influence governance processes in different, sometimes unexpected ways.
"With the governance analysis, we looked at how existing powers contest," says Purnomo. "Along the value chain, power is not at the landscape level but at the consumer level, or at the mills and refineries. The central government can only function through the district government, but mills can influence local government using incentives and coercion.
"Sometimes the Ministry of Environment and Forestry and the Ministry of Agriculture get the blame for forest and land fire incidences. While potentially, the problem starts from the Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) welcoming investment for refineries without considering whether there is enough capacity to supply them from legal sources."
Furthermore, the study found that illegal oil palm developers can hold a lot of influence at local levels and force village governments to support them, often through deceptive use of a Certificate of Land (SKT).
This imbalance between governance and supply chain capacity can drive actors at the landscape level to meet the mill demands in ways detrimental to landscapes.
"Now there are mills everywhere, even in national park areas. People respond by developing plantations everywhere. The fastest and cheapest way is by burning."
Scientists observe a drone flying over burning peat outside Palangkaraya, Indonesia. Photo by Aulia Erlangga/CIFOR
ALT OPTIONS
When demand is high and burning has long been practiced, what reason do farmers and developers have to change their habits to more arduous land-clearing methods?
"We calculated whether existing incentives in the market are enough to change the situation on the ground," says Purnomo. "The analysis looks at benefits distrubuted from oil palm plantation development using fire, who benefits, and what alternatives can be adopted to compensate."
The first step is for the market to support certified producers, incentivizing them not to burn as well as to employ value-added farmers. This, however, raises production costs, as well as the cost of fresh fruit bunches (FFB) of oil palm fruits. As this price margin grows, the next step is to make sure that the financial benefits go back into the hands of the farmers, to incentivize their good practices as well.
"Intermediaries have taken the benefit from this margin until now. Farmers should unite to gain more bargaining power, so once they receive a delivery order, they can cut the middleman and go straight to the mill. This will increase their value added. It is important that palm oil businesses are not only certified but also fair."
Another key step to fire reduction is agrarian reform. While many farmers possess an SKT, the land is still legally part of a state-owned forest area. The unclarity of land status dissuades farmers from investing resrources in land.
"Why should they spend money, when the government can take their land away at any time? The farmers should be guaranteed land legality at least for 25 years, so they can invest safely."
CHANGING HEADLINES
Recently on the international stage, the European Union in January approved draft measures to ban the use of palm oil in motor fuels by 2020. While this sent Southeast Asian governments reeling, Indonesia's included, Purnomo believes that this boycott will change little. Instead, he says the EU market should give incentives for sustainable production, and Indonesia should create an environment in which that can be done.
"Incentives can change the situation. The government of Indonesia should be more transparent with environmental problems faced by the palm oil industry, show real progress in improving the industry's sustainability, draw a clear roadmap to meet international standards in three to five years and invite the EU to participate in palm oil in more constructive ways."
Cleaning up supply chains will come at a cost, but market incentives combined with strengthened national policies and international regulators (namely the Indonesian Sustianable Palm Oil system and Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil) can together compensate to make this effort viable – and cool things down.
For more information on this topic, please contact Herry Purnomo at h.purnomo@cgiar.org.
This research was supported by the Department for International Development United Kingdom (DFID UK) and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID).

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


City Way will be closed from Marconi Way to a point passed Cloisterham Road between 2000 and 0600 each night from Monday 10 September to Thursday 13 September. The Pattens Lane right-turn ban into Maidstone Road will be suspended to allow the diversion for the City Way closure.
The M20 will be closed both ways between Junction 4 at Leybourne and Junction 6 at Maidstone this weekend. The closure will be in place from 2200 on Friday 14 September through to 0600 on Monday 17 September.


text:
A Great Ultraventure: The Pursuit of the Triple Crown (Part 2)
August 8, 2022 August 8, 2022 | Topo Athletic
The Bennett Family is trail famous for thru-hiking both the Pacific Crest, Pacific Northwest, and Continental Divide Trails. On April 13, the family started their quest to complete the Triple Crown by thru-hiking the Appalachian Trail (the Triple Crown = Pacific Crest + Continental Divide + Appalachian Trails) with all members of their family sporting a combination of Ultraventure Pro and Trailventure 2 (sans their trail pup, Muir). Now at the halfway point (and in a fresh set of Topos), mother-of-the-pack Mindi (trail name: Wildflower) checked in with us to share some of the Bennett's most memorable experiences so far and how their shoes are holding up.
One can measure a thru-hike in many different ways. At our half-way point, we have taken approximately 2,550,994 steps, with 21 resupplies, 2 zeros (days where we hike zero miles), and a plethora of awesome trail-magic experiences.
We have found the Appalachian Trail to be a green tunnel, like we were warned it would be, but it feels like a tunnel through a botanical garden. Especially wonderful was being in southern Virginia in early June with the mountain laurels, rhododendron, and azaleas all in bloom at once! Marching from Georgia to Virginia, in the "spring parade" and watching the flora and fauna come to life was a delightful experience.
Other experiences are more difficult, like dealing with heat rash, bug bites, chaffing and humidity. We've become accustomed to the daily chores on the trail, like drinking the grey water from our cold soak cups (i.e. doing the dishes), protecting our food from all the animals that want our food, swallowing toothpaste, digging cat holes, and packing all our gear into packs that seem too small (until we shoulder them, then they are too big and heavy).
Our brains have benefitted from spending hours looking at the different shapes, sizes, textures, and patterns of leaves, breathing fresh air, and drinking water bubbling straight from the earth.
The Juxtaposition of West vs. East
The saying must be true that "the most difficult trail will be the one you are currently on." Our memories of the struggles and suffering we faced on the Pacific Crest Trail, the Pacific Northwest Trail, and the Continental Divide Trail have faded and the very best memories take center stage.
The Appalachian Trail has been a "walk through the park" thus far (many National Parks, in fact), but it hasn't been easy! We would definitely go as far as to say that the first 1,000 miles were more difficult (elevation gain & loss wise) than any other trail we've done. However, the water is more plentiful and we've only had to carry 2-4 days of food at a time, which is a luxury.
Having lived in Washington State for many years, we are used to hiking in the rain, but storms are different in the East! One night, after 3 days of on-and-off rain, we found a flat spot to take a dinner break and it began to sprinkle. Quickly it progressed to a downpour, coming down so hard that mud splashed up into our food. There was nowhere to hide; we had to just eat in a hurry, pack up and move on. If we didn't laugh, we'd cry, and fortunately we were laughing!
Trekking on in Topos
Without a doubt, there are as many different opinions on shoe brands as there are vertical elevation climbs in Georgia. We continue to love Topos because of the toe room, cushion, breathability, and the gaiters. Our family of 6 has been wearing Topos for 1000+ miles and we are impressed the Ultraventure Pros have been a success for 5 out of 6 (my husband switched to the Trailventure 2 boot to protect his toes on the steep downhills and for the denser sole). We do miss the softer, pine needle covered trails of the PNW and are very grateful for the rock guard in our Topos! With about 2.5 million more steps to go, the trail reportedly only gets rockier from here on north. Wish us luck! 🍀
Mindi Bennett, her husband (Adam), four children—Sierra (19), Kaia (17), Tristan (15), and Ruby (12)—and trail dog (Muir) have hiked the PCT ('19), PNT ('20), CDT ('21), and are currently attempting an Application Trail thru-hike ('22). Follow their journey on social media: @kidsoutwild.
Behind the Scenes: Ultrafly 4 Photoshoot with Topo Elite, Sho Gray
The Democratization of Speed: Specter Running Shoe Design
One thought on "A Great Ultraventure: The Pursuit of the Triple Crown (Part 2)"
Shelli Dimig says:
Not only are all y'all tough as nails, but, Mindi, you've become an even greater writer while on these hikes! This was a fascinating read! Good luck on the rest of your amazing hiking adventure!


Lancome Monsieur Big Набор для макияжа глаз Monsieur Big Набор для макияжа глаз Descubra la selección de tratamientos antiedad para la piel y nuestros productos de maquillaje. Consiga una belleza natural para su piel con Lancôme. Shop Lancôme's Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara at Sephora. A waterproof, high-volume mascara that delivers bold lash volume for up to 24 hours. Первый карандаш-тени для бровей с кистью кабуки! Monsieur Big Brow дает вам 4 оттенка, от блонда до.. Explore Monsieur Big mascara collection, available in a waterproof formula, extension fibers, and vibrant color top coats for bigger, bolder eyelashes. Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara is a BIG volume mascara that delivers instant heart-stopping volume with up to 24 hour wear that lasts all night and even the morning.. Looking for a glamorous, bespoke beauty routine? Discover Lancôme's luxurious makeup and skincare, as well as the latest Parisian trends in the Beauty. BIG VOLUME. ALL DAY WEAR. What it is: A BIG volume mascara that delivers instant heart-stopping volume with up to 24 hour wear that lasts all night and..
Looking for a glamorous, bespoke beauty routine? Discover Lancôme's luxurious makeup and skincare, as well as the latest Parisian trends in the Beauty. BIG VOLUME. ALL DAY WEAR. What it is: A BIG volume mascara that delivers instant heart-stopping volume with up to 24 hour wear that lasts all night and... → Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara Тушь для ресниц по цене от 1912 до 2550 рублей ★ купить в официальном.. Обзор коллекции Monsieur Big от Lancôme: тушь для ресниц, подводка и карандаш. Узнайте всё про новые.. Lancome Monsieur Big Набор для макияжа глаз Monsieur Big Набор для макияжа глаз. Scopri gli iconici prodotti di bellezza Lancôme: sieri e trattamenti anti-età, makeup e profumi. Lancôme Shop for Lancome Cosmetics, Skincare & Beauty | Dillard's at Dillards.com. Visit Dillards.com to find clothing, accessories, shoes, cosmetics & more. The Style of.. Lancôme Monsieur Big Volume Mascara: rated 3.2 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. See 85 member reviews, ingredients and photos. Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara - купите онлайн в интернет-магазине «Золотое яблоко». Широкий ассортимент.. Entrez dans l'univers Lancôme. Venez découvrir les parfums, le maquillage et le soin Lancôme Купить Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara – Тушь для ресниц в интернет-магазине РИВ ГОШ. Лучшие цены и..
Scopri gli iconici prodotti di bellezza Lancôme: sieri e trattamenti anti-età, makeup e profumi. Lancôme Shop for Lancome Cosmetics, Skincare & Beauty | Dillard's at Dillards.com. Visit Dillards.com to find clothing, accessories, shoes, cosmetics & more. The Style of.. Lancôme Monsieur Big Volume Mascara: rated 3.2 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. See 85 member reviews, ingredients and photos. Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara - купите онлайн в интернет-магазине «Золотое яблоко». Широкий ассортимент.. Entrez dans l'univers Lancôme. Venez découvrir les parfums, le maquillage et le soin Lancôme Купить Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara – Тушь для ресниц в интернет-магазине РИВ ГОШ. Лучшие цены и..


text:
Nya Lee on Love & Hip Hop: Age, Instagram, bio and everything else you need to know
Tue Jan 29, 2019 at 4:22pm ET
By Shaunee Flowers
Nya Lee on Love & Hip Hop New York. Pic credit: VH1
Nya Lee has been a part of Love & Hip Hop: New York since Season 4 but the stripper-turned-rapper is starting to get some major air time in Season 9.
Rich Dollaz turned to Nya for help in changing Sidney Star's image and that turned into a bit of drama for Nya, who did her best to help Rich and Sidney out.
With so much Love & Hip Hop screen time, viewers have been wanting to know more about Nya and we're here to give it to you.
Nya Lee's age, birthplace and bio
Nya Lee is 27 years old after celebrating her birthday just last month. She was born on December 16, 1991, in New York City, which she still calls home.
A post shared by Nya Lee / T.Ingram ? (@og_nya.lee)
Though she's rocking long hair on Season 9 of Love & Hip Hop, Nya is known for being bald. It's a look she's kept since she was 16 years old and something she has become known for.
When Nya was cast on Love & Hip Hop, she was only 23 years old and one of the youngest members of the cast.
Before Nya was even cast on the VH1 series, she was being name-dropped after Emily B found out that her man, Fabolous, was two-timing her with Nya. We saw Emily B crying about Fab's infidelity on Season 2 of the show only for Nya to join part-time by Season 4.
Though Nya has been rapping and working on her music career since she was a teenager, she actually ended up stripping and doing some modeling to pay the bills.
In 2017, she released an EP titled Snapback and then in 2018, she released Trap Luv. Nya is signed to Our Cutt Entertainment and regularly works with Rich Dollaz.
In addition to working hard to cultivate her rap career, Nya Lee is a mom. In 2016, she welcomed a baby girl named Winner.
While Nya has been pretty private about her daughter, including not sharing the name of her father, she has shared a handful of pictures in the past but they don't seem to be available anymore.
Nya Lee on Instagram
You can find Nya Lee on Instagram under the username @OG_Nya.Lee. She has 738k followers and growing.
Nya shares all kinds of things about herself on Instagram including her workouts, photoshoots, music and her friends.
There's another Instagram account that Nya uses to promote her fitness line, Nya Lee Waisted. There, she shows off photos of herself wearing her workout line that includes leggings, sports bras, tank tops.
https://www.instagram.com/p/Blyvls2F3UE/
It's worth noting that Nya's workout wear is reasonably priced and worth taking a look at.
Love & Hip Hop airs on Mondays at 8/7c on VH1.
More: Love & Hip Hop


Posted in About the book.
We are pleased to announce that George Ivanoff's essay published in Doctor Who and Race has been nominated for the William Atheling Jr Award for Criticism or Review in the Australian SF ('Ditmar') Awards for 2014. Congratulations to George – we hope you win!


Love season 1 (2016) – What's New on Netflix Canada Today!
A program that follows a couple who must navigate the exhilarations and humiliations of intimacy, commitment and other things they were hoping to avoid. Rebellious Mickey and good-natured Gus navigate the thrills and agonies of modern relationships in this bold new comedy co-created by Judd Apatow. It's awkward. It's impossible. It's infuriating. And it may just be the best thing that's ever happened to them.


text:
package my.sandbox.camunda.config;

import javax.jms.ConnectionFactory;
import org.apache.activemq.ActiveMQConnectionFactory;
import org.springframework.context.annotation.Bean;
import org.springframework.context.annotation.Configuration;
import org.springframework.jms.annotation.EnableJms;
import org.springframework.jms.config.DefaultJmsListenerContainerFactory;
import org.springframework.jms.config.JmsListenerContainerFactory;

/**
 * @author dtv
 */
@Configuration
@EnableJms
public class JmsConfiguration {

    @Bean
    JmsListenerContainerFactory<?> myJmsContainerFactory(ConnectionFactory connectionFactory) {
        DefaultJmsListenerContainerFactory factory = new DefaultJmsListenerContainerFactory();
        /**
         *********************************************************************************
         * FIX: This class is not trusted to be serialized as ObjectMessage payload.
         *********************************************************************************
         * Could not convert JMS message;
         * javax.jms.JMSException: Failed to build body from content.
         * Serializable class not available to broker.
         * Reason: Forbidden class my.sandbox.camunda.jms.DataRequestMessage!
         * This class is not trusted to be serialized as ObjectMessage payload.
         * Please take a look at http://activemq.apache.org/objectmessage.html for more
         * information on how to configure trusted classes.
         */
        if (connectionFactory instanceof ActiveMQConnectionFactory) {
            ((ActiveMQConnectionFactory) connectionFactory).setTrustAllPackages(true);
        }
        factory.setConnectionFactory(connectionFactory);
        return factory;
    }

}

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaGithub


Billed as the "Gateway to the North", Pinconning Park is just minutes east off of I-75. Set deep in a 206-acre hardwood forest nature preserve, Pinconning Park has evolved into a natural tourist attraction and popular campground due to its rich history, prime location along the Saginaw Bay and world-renowned walleye and perch fishery. The camp ground has a Boat Launch and kayak rentals.
Campground features include: 62 modern/semi modern campsites, 6 log cabins and a very clean bathhouse. The park also offers a sandy beach with kayak rentals and an updated ADA trail and boardwalk system that winds throughout the preserve. Perfect for hiking and biking. A pavilion and gazebo are available for rent for picnics, reunions, weddings, etc. Pinconning Park and campground/cabin rentals is open year round.


Tastex specialises in workwear knitwear. Our factory knits a range of styles in 100% pure wool and wool blends using the finest quality yarns. Our workwear knitwear is tough and durable.
Our range of Tastex workwear knitwear includes jumpers, cardigans, vests and jackets all of which are available in an array of colours and a range of weights for year round comfort in every working environment.
Knitted in our Mill Lane factory our Tastex Knitwear's 100% wool garments are machine washable and can be tumble dried. Tastex garments hold their shape and appearance even after years of washing.
All major corporate colours are stocked and we have the capabiity to match up any unusual colours.
Stylish and neat, this lightweight pure wool vest gives warmth without the weight of a full jumper. Ideal for working in offices and to wear on those in-between days.
The vest shown here is in ink, and is available in any of the standard corporate colours.
Combinations of colours, or special colours, can be knitted to order with bands and cuffs in your own corporate colours.
Tell us your colour preferences and size and we'll do the rest.
Ideal in the bush and for outdoor work, this heavyweight pure wool jumper has a practical zip crew neck, and with the insulative properties of wool will keep the cold at bay.
The jumper shown here is in dark grey, and is available in any of the standard corporate colours.
For tough work wear that looks great, you can't go past this medium weight pure wool jumper.
The patches give the garment an individual look and can be made to order to suit your workplace needs.
The jumper shown here is in ink, and is available in any of the standard corporate colours.
Combinations of colours, or special colours, can be knitted to order.
Ideal for outdoor work, this lightweight wool fleece jacket has a practical zip up front and generous pockets for all your gear.
The jacket shown here is in navy, and is available in red.
Just tell us your colour preferences and size and we'll do the rest.
Have your corporate logo can be embroidered onto the garment prior to delivery.


Portugal emerged as a unified kingdom in the 12th century It became a major maritime power in the 15th century, opening new seaways to the east and the west, and built a vast colonial empire. The decline came with the destruction of Lisbon by an earthquake and tidal wave in 1755, and Brazil's independence in the 19th century. In 1910 a revolution deposed the monarchy. Political chaos and economic problems led to a long period of dictatorship, which ended with the left-wing military coup in 1974. A year later democracy was firmly installed, and Portugal's colonies in Africa recovered independence. Economically, Portugal has been one of the least advanced countries in Europe. During the economic boom in western Europe in the 1950-70s, many Portuguese emigrated to the richer countries to find work. In 1986 the country joined the European Community (now EU), and during the 1990s it achieved economic growth above the EU average. Portugal is a Catholic country. For a long time, the Catholic Church enjoyed the privilege of concordat between the Vatican and the Portuguese state. The tiny Presbyterian, Methodist, and Anglican churches grew out of 19th century missionary work, and form together the Council of Christian Churches. The largest independent churches are the controversial Universal Church of the Kingdom of God, which has come from Brazil, and the Mana Church from South Africa. The Jehovah's Witnesses form also a sizeable and growing group. The Assemblies of God (Pentecostal) and Evangelical churches like the Baptists, Seventh-day Adventists, and Brethren are also present. The Evangelical Alliance of Portugal is affiliated with the WEA.


James Brokenshire has welcomed news that the Bexley Village Post Office has now re-opened following its temporary closure.
Since November last year, James has been in regular contact with the Post Office to underline the importance of the Post Office to local residents.
The new Post Office opened on Monday 18th March 2019 at the Costcutter Supermarket, 26 Bexley High Street, DA5 1AD. The opening hours of the new Post Office are from 7am to 9pm on Monday to Saturday and 8am to 8pm on Sundays.
Customers will be able to carry out a wide range of Post Office transactions alongside retail purchases at the new low screened open plan serving point that is part of the retail counter.