text:
NFL betting recap: Popular Bengals can't come through for bettors
Falcons 2023 free-agent profile: DE Marcus Davenport
Reflecting on Jalen Hurts' journey to leading the Eagles to Super Bowl LVII | College Football Enquirer
Putting together the ideal football schedule at The Citadel
Posted on September 12, 2019 by Sandlapper Spike
I wanted to write about this topic after some recent discourse about it, primarily in two places:
– AD Mike Capaccio's discussion of the schedule on Lowcountry media personality Quintin Washington's YouTube channel
– Jeff Hartsell's column in The Post and Courier
Here are some of the relevant passages from each media piece.
Capaccio (direct quotes):
"We need to work with our schedule to be more realistic….we don't need to be playing two ranked teams, or three ranked teams, and then an ACC team, and then go into our conference, because our conference is a monster…so, not that we [want] an easy schedule, but we need a little break…
…We want to play close to home…three to five hours [away] at the maximum…We don't need to be taking a trip to Towson…Our philosophy is changing, and we want to play close [to home]."
Hartsell:
By the end of the 2020 season, The Citadel will have played 44 straight games against D-I teams…
…"Do you need a Division II team in there? Every couple of years, I think you do," said [The Citadel's head football coach, Brent] Thompson, whose 10-2 SoCon championship team in 2016 won a 38-14 game over D-II North Greenville. "But I don't think you need one every year. I know just about everybody in our league will have one this season.
"But my emphasis is on more in-region games. Elon is a fine game, Gardner-Webb, Charleston Southern, S.C. State. Those games are a lot easier on your travel and your budget, and they mean more to the kids. I would much rather play a non-conference game in-state, or at least in-region."
For Thompson, a guarantee game last season might have made the difference between a 5-6 season and a 6-5 season. And as any coach will tell you, that's a big difference.
Coaches from Dabo Swinney to Nick Saban know that an occasional cupcake tastes good. The Citadel ought to try one.
Let me start off by saying that I am not overly fond of the epithet "cupcake" being thrown around when mentioning a squad from a lower classification or division. Playoff-caliber D-2 teams like Newberry and North Greenville certainly weren't "cupcakes" when they played the Bulldogs. The term also doesn't apply to The Citadel when it faces an FBS opponent.
Calling a team a "cupcake" is basically a way of saying it doesn't belong on the same field with the favored opponent. I find this tiresome, as it is primarily a media creation designed to diminish programs that aren't on national TV every week.
Now, as to The Citadel's football schedule…
Right now, the Bulldogs play 11 regular-season games every season except in years where the calendar allows for a 12th contest. After this year, the next time FCS teams will have a chance to play a 12th game will be 2024.
I don't believe there will be a rule change altering the current status quo in that regard, so let's assume that The Citadel will annually play 11 regular-season games for the foreseeable future.
The Bulldogs will play eight Southern Conference games every year, four at home and four on the road. That leaves three non-conference contests to schedule.
One of those non-conference matchups has to be a "money" game against an FBS opponent. Here are the already scheduled FBS teams through 2025:
2020: Clemson
2021: Coastal Carolina
2022: Appalachian State
2023: Georgia Southern
2025: Mississippi
Of the two remaining out-of-league games, at least one of them almost has to be a home game; otherwise, the Bulldogs would only play four contests in a given season at Johnson Hagood Stadium. That isn't going to work.
So far, these non-FBS games have been scheduled through the next few seasons:
2020: Elon, Charleston Southern [schedule complete; six home games]
2021: Charleston Southern
2022: at Campbell
2023: Campbell
Mike Capaccio also mentioned during the interview referenced above that Presbyterian is on a future schedule. Perhaps the Blue Hose are on more than one.
What, exactly, should be the goals of The Citadel's non-conference football schedule? Some of them (in no particular order) might be:
Help the team prepare for the SoCon slate
Raise money for the program (and the department of athletics in general)
Promote the school to a wider audience
Give the team a better chance of making the FCS playoffs
Improve the win-loss record
Ensure there are enough home games to satisfy the season-ticket holders
Energize the fans by playing quality, high-profile opponents
Save money on travel
Excite the players on the team by playing quality, high-profile opponents
Provide an added impetus for recruiting
Random musings:
– I am okay with giving the team a better chance to make the FCS playoffs via scheduling, but only to a point.
That is because the FCS postseason, as currently constructed, is hopelessly flawed. It is structurally biased against southeastern schools (honestly, that is undeniable). Thus, it is not a true "national" tournament.
I see no reason to devalue the regular season just to participate in the playoffs. Until the tournament is fully seeded and not beholden to asinine geographical bracketing, my thoughts on that will not change.
– I've already mentioned that The Citadel needs to play at least five home games per season. I don't think anyone would seriously disagree.
– While I've said it before, let me reiterate that limiting the distance the team travels for non-conference games is not always a good idea, at least from a larger perspective. I enjoyed the trip to Princeton in 2009, and I firmly believe the Bulldogs should occasionally make trips like that to promote the school, provide a new experience for the players, and reward our loyal fans from other parts of the country.
– I don't want to play opponents for the sole purpose of padding the win total. That isn't what The Citadel is all about. If it were, the school wouldn't have joined the Southern Conference in the first place, much less stay in the league all these years.
The Citadel is about embracing challenges. That includes varsity sports.
Finally, my suggestions for non-conference games.
I am inclined to eschew D-2 and NAIA schools, because I think it is probably beneficial to the conference as a whole for its member schools to play as many D-1 teams as possible, and The Citadel should take the initiative in that respect.
I could see arguments in the other direction — and I'm not automatically opposed to teams like Newberry, North Greenville, or Benedict. I don't believe Webber International needs to be on the schedule again, however.
– Presbyterian strikes me as almost an ideal non-conference opponent. The Citadel would not have play in Clinton (barring a hurricane, of course). The two schools have a long history on the gridiron, too.
– Charleston Southern is a reasonable choice, though I don't think it is necessary (or particularly desirable) to play the Buccaneers on an annual basis.
Obviously, any games between CSU and The Citadel would be contested at Johnson Hagood Stadium. Playing at Buccaneer Field is a non-starter for a host of reasons, including A) the state of the facility, B) the fact that 80% (or more) of the fans at the game would be rooting for The Citadel, so forcing them to travel to another stadium would be pointless, and C) the loss of a home game would seriously affect The Citadel's ability to schedule the rest of its non-conference slate in a given season.
That last point is one that several members of the local media have never seemed able to grasp — or are simply unwilling to accept, even knowing it is true.
A rotation of Charleston Southern and Presbyterian might not be a bad idea.
– Other teams that I think would be good opponents in the "home games only" slot: Jacksonville, Stetson, Davidson, and perhaps Gardner-Webb.
– Schools that would be appropriate "home and home" regional opponents would include South Carolina State, Elon, William & Mary, Richmond, Campbell, and possibly North Carolina A&T.
– I would advocate for an occasional home-and-home versus an out-of-region team, like an Ivy or Patriot League squad, or even one of the MVFC teams.
Yes, I know, it costs too much. I'm sure we could raise some money for a two-game series through a special campaign, though. I noticed that there are currently 38 people listed in The Citadel Development Foundation's staff directory; perhaps one or two of them could help out.
All of the above is just my opinion. I could be wrong about just about everything!
Or maybe I could be right about a few things. Your mileage may vary.
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Charleston Southern, Ivy League, Jacksonville, Mike Capaccio, MVFC, Newberry, North Greenville, Patriot League, Presbyterian, SoCon, South Carolina State, The Citadel | Leave a comment »
2017 Football, Game 2: The Citadel vs. Presbyterian
Posted on September 7, 2017 by Sandlapper Spike
Columbia, October 27 — Special: The Citadel struck a tartar in the light but aggressive Presbyterian College eleven when they met on the gridiron at the State Fairgrounds to-day, and could only manage to carry off the victory by a score of 14 to 0.
The entire Citadel team seemed to be experiencing an off day. The backfield was slow in getting into action and the heavy Blue line failed time and time again to break through the stubborn defense of their lighter opponents.
The cadets made their initial touch-down in the first quarter. After a forward pass had failed, [Johnny] Weeks punted out of bounds and the ball was put into play at Presbyterian's 20-yard line. [Presbyterian quarterback] Galloway took one yard around left end. On the next play [Henry] Switzer pulled down a Presbyterian forward pass and sprinted twenty-five yards for a touch-down. Weeks kicked goal…
…Citadel scored her final touch-down in the third quarter…Galloway punted to Weeks, who gained forty yards. Weeks made 10 around left end. [Chesnee Cogswell] took 6 through centre, Bolton smashed the line for three more, and Weeks and Switzer got 5 yards over tackle in two bucks.
On the next play, Bolton was thrown for a loss of two yards, but Weeks carried the ball across for a touch-down and then kicked goal.
– The News and Courier, October 28, 1915
The Citadel vs. Presbyterian, to be played in Bailey Memorial Stadium at Claude Crocker Field in Clinton, South Carolina, with kickoff at noon ET on September 9, 2017.
The game will be streamed on the Big South Network. Presbyterian's radio team of Ryan Clary and John Orck will provide the audio for the stream.
The contest can be heard on radio via the various affiliates of The Citadel Sports Network. WQNT-1450 AM [audio link], originating in Charleston, will be the flagship station.
Mike Legg (the "Voice of the Bulldogs") will call the action alongside analyst Lee Glaze.
The Citadel Sports Network — 2017 Affiliates
Charleston: WQNT 1450 AM/92.1 FM/102.1 FM (Flagship)
Columbia: WQXL 1470 AM/100.7 FM
Greenville: WLFJ 92.9 FM/660 AM
Sumter: WDXY 1240 AM/105.9 FM
More TV/streaming information: the contest will be not streamed on ESPN3, though it will be available on the Big South Network (as noted above).
Scott Eisberg of WCIV-TV in Charleston tweeted that the game would be televised on WCIV's "MeTV", which is one of that station's digital subchannels. As of Saturday morning, the game does not appear in any online TV listings, though it is quite possible (if not likely) that those listings could not be updated in time.
I'm going to guess that the game will be televised on MeTV in Charleston (WCIV's digital subchannel 3) and that the production is via the Big South Network feed.
– Game moved from Charleston to Clinton and rescheduled for noon on Saturday (school release)
– Back to Lookup Lodge
– Grant Drakeford is profiled after an excellent performance against Newberry
– Solid debut for some new Bulldog starters
– Game notes from The Citadel and Presbyterian
– SoCon weekly release
– Big South Conference weekly release
– Presbyterian "quick facts"
– FCS Coaches' poll (The Citadel is ranked #13)
– STATS FCS poll (The Citadel is ranked #14)
– Brent Thompson's 9/5 press conference, with comments from Grant Drakeford and Aron Spann (video)
– Brent Thompson's 9/6 radio show (video)
– Presbyterian preview in The Post and Courier
– Presbyterian preview from the Big South (video)
Another year, another game moved out of Johnson Hagood Stadium. In 2016, The Citadel played a "home" game at North Greenville.
This time, due to the impending threat of Hurricane Irma, the Bulldogs will travel to Clinton, South Carolina, and face Presbyterian at Bailey Memorial Stadium. PC's home facility seats 6,500 and is fairly new, having made its debut during the 2002 season.
In front of the stadium is a 15-foot bronze statue called "Cyrus". He seems to be rather moody.
In the next section, I'll reference an unrelated "Cyrus"; they are two of the three times that name has appeared in the entire history of The Sports Arsenal.
The game referenced in the blurb at the beginning of the post was the first meeting on the gridiron between Presbyterian and The Citadel. It was played during the State Fair in Columbia, at the central fairgrounds.
The Bulldogs were not at their best, possibly due to the hot weather, but managed to prevail anyway. Presbyterian's offense never advanced the football past The Citadel's 40-yard-line.
A few other notes on that 1915 contest:
The game was played on Wednesday, October 28 (not the 23rd, as listed in The Citadel's record book)
The first and third quarters were 15 minutes long, while the second and fourth quarters were 12 minutes long
Each team used 14 players during the game
The Citadel's players were back at the barracks by 8:00 am the following morning, having taken a 3:00 am train back to Charleston
Other attractions at the fairgrounds on that Wednesday: horseracing, a "Lady high diver", a bicyclist named "Dare Devil Doherty", and "Cyrus and Mandy and their hay rack".
Presbyterian was one of three Palmetto State colleges The Citadel defeated in 1915. In addition to wins over Newberry and South Carolina, the team also beat Porter Military Academy and the Charleston 6th Naval District squad en route to laying a claim to the state championship
Incidentally, for anyone who thinks the current trend of coaches not allowing fans/media to observe practice is something new, this tidbit was mentioned in the newspaper during a preview article on the game:
Secret practice has been the rule at Hampton Park this season. No one but those on the squad and those directly interested in the team have been allowed within the grounds during practice hours. Would-be visitors were politely informed that the cadets could not be seen.
This rule will be waived a little after this week. Coach Rogers announced yesterday that vistors would be welcomed at the park on Wednesday afternoons to the scrimmages. On other days the grounds will not be open to anyone.
How long has it been since The Citadel played a football game at Clinton?
That year, the Bulldogs defeated the Blue Hose (called the "Hosemen" in The News and Courier) 19-0, with the game taking place at Johnson Field. Two of the three touchdowns scored that day by The Citadel came off of blocked punts.
Both of those punt blocks came courtesy of the team captain, Francis King. The native of Georgetown was hailed by the newspaper for playing "superlative ball".
King scored one of the two punt-block TDs himself; Tom Huguenin fell on the ball in the end zone for the second. The Bulldogs' third touchdown was scored on a run by Clough "Mutt" Gee.
Gee went to The Citadel for three years, and then transferred to the United States Military Academy. He was killed in action during World War II when his airplane crashed in Lisieux, France. Gee is buried in the Normandy American Cemetery.
A few other notes on game locations in the series between The Citadel and Presbyterian:
– The last time The Citadel played PC somewhere other than Johnson Hagood Stadium was on October 12, 1963, when the contest was held in Savannah; the matchup was called the "Georgia Peach Shrine Game", and was a benefit for the Greenville Shriners Hospital.
The Bulldogs won 24-0 behind 121 yards rushing from Jim Parker (on only 7 carries). Parker, Bruce Whitney, and Vince Petno all scored touchdowns for the Bulldogs, with Petno's TD coming on a 5-yard pass from Wade St. John. Attendance: 7,000.
– The 1950 game between the two schools was played at the Orangeburg County Fair.
The Citadel won 7-0, scoring the game's only touchdown in the first quarter. Deep in its own territory, Presbyterian tried a "quick kick" on third down. It was not successful, as Bulldogs safety Bobby Carter corralled the pigskin at the PC 25-yard line and returned it 20 yards.
Rudy Willcox raced around the right side of the line for 5 yards and a TD on the next play, with Don Davis adding the PAT. Jerry DeLuca was the defensive star that afternoon for the Bulldogs.
As was the case for the 1963 game, estimated attendance was 7,000.
– In 1948, The Citadel played PC at College Park, as the "new" Johnson Hagood Stadium was not quite ready to open. The Blue Hose won that game 7-0, as The Citadel did not run an offensive play from scrimmage in PC territory during the entire contest.
– Presbyterian and The Citadel played at the Sumter County Fair in 1940 and 1941, splitting the two matchups. In the 1941 game, won by the Bulldogs 21-13, PC's entire student body traveled to the game, only to see the Bulldogs rally from a 13-7 halftime deficit to win the game 21-13.
Team captain Mike Newell scored two touchdowns for The Citadel, with Andy Victor adding a third and also successfully converting all three PAT attempts.
In 1955, The Citadel played Presbyterian at Johnson Hagood Stadium. It was Homecoming, and that week was chronicled by Life magazine as part of a profile of Mark Clark.
The photos taken by the magazine (specifically, photographer Robert W. Kelley) are now part of an archive created by Google. I've linked to them before, and I'm going to link to them again, because A) The Citadel is playing PC again, and B) they are endlessly fascinating.
Many of these pictures are football-related, but I've also linked to some "general" shots (pun intended). The first few linked photos are in color, but the vast majority of pictures in the archive are black-and-white. This is just a small sampling of what is available for viewing; try this link to get started if you want to see more of them.
If you haven't seen color photos of The Citadel's 1955 uniforms before, you're in for a surprise.
Why are Presbyterian College's varsity athletic teams nicknamed the "Blue Hose"?
…probably the true story lies in a letter dated June 15, 1935, written by then athletic director Walter Johnson to an inquiring English professor in Virginia…[quoting from Walter Johnson's letter] 'It was about the second or third year, 1915, if I remember right, Stockings. I think it happened this way: I changed uniform colors to blue, wearing blue stockings and jerseys, and some sports writer started calling in his articles the Presbyterian College teams the Blue Stockings.' …In later years "Stocking" became abbreviated to "the Hose," particularly in newspaper headlines, and was more or less officially adopted by the student body in the late 50's.
…"Johnson always insisted on the fact that his players wore long blue socks similar to stockings (after all, there were White Sox and Red Sox in baseball). Coach Johnson's explanation may simply be coincidental to the fact that the phrase "Blue Stocking Presbyterian" goes back informally quite a few years in the denomination's history."
This particular Walter Johnson was not the great pitcher of the same name, but a former football player at Michigan who was a coach and administrator for many years at Presbyterian. He was the head football coach at the school from 1915 to 1918, and then from 1920 to 1940.
Johnson finished his football coaching career with 102 victories, more than any other PC coach except Cally Gault (who won 127 games between 1963 and 1984). Both Johnson and Gault are enshrined in the NAIA Hall of Fame.
In 2005, Presbyterian won the Division II South Atlantic Conference title, finishing with a 10-2 overall record. It was the first conference title for PC since winning the SAC in 1979.
The following year, the Blue Hose went a solid 7-4. However, as Presbyterian began the transition from D-2 to D-1, wins became a lot tougher to come by. The first all-D1 slate for the Blue Hose, in 2009, resulted in an 0-11 record.
Under former head coach Harold Nichols, Presbyterian won just 11 games over the next four seasons, but then pulled off a surprising 6-5 campaign in 2014 (despite playing three FBS teams).
The Blue Hose had a truly outstanding defense that year. PC beat Furman 10-7, Charleston Southern 7-3, Western Carolina 19-14 (with two defensive touchdowns), Monmouth 18-12, and Gardner-Webb 14-7 (Presbyterian's first score coming on a blocked field goal). The sixth victory was an early-season walkover against Bluefield of the NAIA.
Unfortunately for Presbyterian, the next two years ended in identical 2-9 records, and Nichols elected to resign. His replacement is the man who was the head coach of that 2005 team and the defensive coordinator for that 2014 squad.
Tommy Spangler is a Georgia alum who compiled a 42-24 record as PC's head coach from 2001 to 2006. He left to become the defensive coordinator at Louisiana Tech, but returned to Clinton as the Blue Hose defensive coordinator in 2013.
His mission is to guide Presbyterian to consistent respectability in FCS. It won't be an easy task, but Spangler's prior success at the school has to be encouraging to PC supporters.
Spangler's first game back at the helm of the Blue Hose was last week's 51-7 loss at Wake Forest. It was not pretty for PC. On the other hand, it wasn't really supposed to be.
Presbyterian did have the edge in time of possession by almost five minutes, in part because only nine of the Blue Hose's 54 offensive plays from scrimmage were pass attempts. Two were completed; one was intercepted.
On the other side of the ball, Wake Forest rushed for 248 yards and passed for 239, averaging 6.8 yards per play.
The bright spot for PC was freshman running back Torrance Marable, who gained 162 yards rushing on 16 carries, including one scamper for 58 yards.
Statistics of note for Presbyterian's 2016 season (11 games):
PC Opp
Points/game 8.9 30.9
Rushing yardage 1105 2670
Yards/rush 2.9 5.9
Rush TDs 4 28
Passing yardage 1551 2077
Comp-Att-Int 168-302-11 126-277-7
Average/pass att 5.1 9.1
Passing TDs 6 15
Total offense 2656 4747
Total plays 682 678
Yards/play 3.9 7.0
Fumbles/lost 18/7 13/7
Penalties-pen yds 66-551 71-686
Pen yards/game 50.1 62.4
Net punt average 39.1 39.7
Time of poss/game 30:43 29:17
3rd-down conv 42/159 42/121
3rd-down conv % 26.4% 34.7%
Sacks by-yards 13-86 23-125
Red Zone TD% 7-25 (28%) 23-35 (66%)
Um, ouch. There is not a lot to say about those numbers. PC obviously had trouble putting up points in 2016, being shut out twice (by Chattanooga and Liberty) and scoring 10 points or less in six other contests.
The Blue Hose finished last in all of FCS in scoring offense, and also finished in the bottom 10 of the following categories: offensive first downs, offensive 3rd down conversion rate, passing offense, total offense, yards per rush, yards per pass attempt, yards per pass completion, red zone offense, rushing defense, tackles for loss (last nationally), and punt returns (also last in FCS).
I guess there is nowhere to go but up.
Presbyterian returned seven starters from last year's offense.
Ben Cheek (6'0″, 190 lbs.), a redshirt junior from Franklin, Georgia, started eight games for the Blue Hose last season at quarterback. Cheek completed 54.9% of his passes, averaging 4.8 yards per attempt, with two touchdowns and eight interceptions.
Against Wake Forest, Cheek carried the ball 22 times (though 3 of those were sacks credited in the rushing statistics).
As mentioned above, freshman Torrance Marable (5'10", 185 lbs.) had a good game versus the Demon Deacons. Marable originally signed with Arkansas State out of high school. The native of Decatur, Georgia enrolled at PC in January of this year.
Although he did not return a kickoff last week, Marable is listed on PC's two-deep as one of the starting kick returners for the game against The Citadel.
Wide receiver DaShawn Davis (5'9″, 155 lbs.) was a second-team All-Big South selection last season. The junior from Inman caught 42 passes last season, averaging 10.8 yards per reception. Davis also handled the majority of punt and kick return duties for the Blue Hose in 2016.
Presbyterian's projected starters on the offensive line average 6'2″, 282 lbs. Right guard Thomas Hughes (6'3″, 275 lbs.), a senior from Cordova who went to Edisto High School, has 17 career starts, most on the team.
PC's defense normally lines up in a 4-3, but that obviously could change against the triple option.
Linebacker Grant Beidel (6'1″, 230 lbs.) led Presbyterian in tackles last season, with 75. The former walkon from Roswell, Georgia also intercepted two passes and had two sacks.
Fellow linebacker Nick Moss (6'0″, 225 lbs.) mans the middle for the Blue Hose. The sophomore finished second in tackles last season.
Starting DT Michael Branch (6'3″, 285 lbs.) is the largest defensive player on the two-deep. The native of Pleasant Garden, North Carolina is a sophomore.
Junior cornerback Rock Ya-Sin (6'1″, 190 lbs.) has more career starts than any other defensive player, with 14. His 61-yard fumble return for a TD against South Alabama was PC's only defensive score last season.
Brett Norton (6'0″, 185 lbs.), a junior from Walhalla, serves as both the placekicker and punter for Presbyterian. He was 7 for 13 last season on field goal attempts, with a long of 36 yards. Three of his tries were blocked.
Norton had an impressive season punting the football, with 23 punts being downed inside the 20-yard line, and only one touchback.
Worth noting: Norton made a 57-yard field goal in high school, a game-winner. He is not the kickoff specialist for PC, however. That would be Tim Hartshorn (6'1″, 170 lbs.), a redshirt junior from Cumming, Georgia.
Brandt Cameron (6'3″, 195 lbs.), a native of Suwanee, Georgia, is in his third season as the Blue Hose long snapper.
In last week's game program, five current Bulldogs were asked the following question: "What if your favorite day of the week?"
Here are their responses.
Jonathan King — Saturday
Ja'Lon Williams — Saturday
K.J. Simpson — Saturday
Jay Howard — Saturday
Noah Dawkins — Saturday
In related news, all of them are college football players.
– The weather forecast for Saturday in Clinton, per the National Weather Service: sunny, with a high of 79 degrees.
– Per one source that deals in such matters, The Citadel is a 24-point favorite over Presbyterian. The over/under is 38.5.
– Other lines involving SoCon teams: Furman is a 17-point favorite over Elon; Wofford is a 7-point favorite at Mercer; VMI is a 24-point favorite over Catawba; Samford is a 23-point favorite over West Alabama; East Tennessee State is a 40-point underdog at James Madison; Western Carolina is a 35-point favorite over Davidson; and Chattanooga is a 42-point underdog at LSU.
Around the Palmetto State, South Carolina is a 2.5-point underdog at Missouri, while Clemson is a 5-point favorite over Auburn. Coastal Carolina is off this week.
– Massey Ratings: The Citadel is ranked 18th in FCS, a drop of two spots from last week. Presbyterian is ranked 96th. Overall (all college teams ranked), The Citadel is 130th, while Presbyterian is 292nd.
Massey projects a final score of The Citadel 31, Presbyterian 7. The Bulldogs are given a 96% chance of victory.
Other FCS rankings in Massey of note: Wofford is 10th, Chattanooga is 14th, Charleston Southern is 15th, Samford is 21st, Furman is 31st, Mercer is 35th, Western Carolina is 66th, VMI is 70th, South Carolina State is 81st, and East Tennessee State is 87th.
The FCS top five in Massey's rankings, in order: James Madison, North Dakota State, Jacksonville State, Youngstown State, and South Dakota State.
– Among Presbyterian's notable graduates are three well-known football coaches: Art Baker, John McKissick, and Bob Waters. PC's other alums include Medal of Honor recipient George L. Mabry, Jr. (who played football for the Blue Hose), author/journalist and Peabody award winner Douglas Kiker, and influential political strategist Harry Dent, Sr.
– Former Bulldog tight end Taylor Cornett is the tight ends coach at Presbyterian. Cornett is in his second year at PC, and his first as a full-time assistant coach.
– The game notes roster for Presbyterian includes 42 players from South Carolina. Other states represented on its roster: Georgia (32 players), Florida (10), North Carolina (9), Alabama (4), and one each from Maryland and Minnesota.
– There are Blue Hose players from 37 different South Carolina high schools, including three from Strom Thurmond High School, and two each from Silver Bluff, Greer, Richland Northeast, Seneca, and Lewisville. However, no players from historic power Orangeburg-Wilkinson are on the Presbyterian roster, which is clearly a major recruiting misstep for the program.
– The Citadel's geographic roster breakdown (per the school's website) is as follows: South Carolina (47 players), Georgia (29), Florida (6), North Carolina (5), Alabama (4), Texas (4), Pennsylvania (3), Tennessee (2), New York (2), and one each from Louisiana, Michigan, Virginia, and West Virginia.
The Citadel is favored to win this game, and rightly so. However, the change of venue (and time) will add a degree of difficulty for the Bulldogs, particularly in their game preparations.
The good news is that the coaching staff and players went through almost the same situation last year with the game against North Greenville. They will know how to maintain focus.
I'm mainly rooting for three things this week: a decent number of Bulldog supporters to make their way to Clinton; a victory for The Citadel; and that Hurricane Irma suddenly veers to the northeast and stays away from shore.
I'm reasonably confident that two of those three things will happen…
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Aron Spann, Bailey Memorial Stadium, Ben Cheek, Big South, Brent Thompson, DaShawn Davis, FCS Coaches Poll, Grant Beidel, Grant Drakeford, Ja'Lon Williams, Jonathan King, Newberry, Noah Dawkins, Presbyterian, SoCon, STATS FCS poll, Taylor Cornett, The Citadel, Tommy Spangler, Torrance Marable | Leave a comment »
Game Review, 2017: Newberry
– Game story, The Post and Courier
– "Notes" package, The Post and Courier
– Photo gallery, The Post and Courier
– AP game story
– School release
– Video from WCSC-TV, including postgame discussion with Brent Thompson, Dominique Allen, and Cam Jackson
– Video from WLTX-TV
– Game highlights (video)
– Boxscore
It wasn't the easiest of season openers, but it wasn't supposed to be. Newberry is an experienced D-2 squad that won 10 games last season. The game wasn't meant to be a walkover, but a test.
The Bulldogs received that test, and they passed it. The grade won't be perfect (Brent Thompson said the marks for the offense would be "about a C-"), but the end result was a win, and a good one.
During Todd Knight's tenure as head coach, Newberry had played four other FCS programs. Three of those contests were one-score affairs, and the fourth was decided by 11 points. When that recent history is taken into consideration, The Citadel's 31-14 victory on Saturday night looks even better.
A quick glance at the statistics shows that the Bulldogs largely controlled the game from start to finish, even though it took a while for the scoreboard to reflect that.
The Citadel Newberry
Starting field position TC 29 NC 25
Efficiency 45.3% (34/75) 39.6% (21/53)
Explosiveness 1.064 1.024
Finishing drives 4.8/poss 4.7/poss
Turnover margin +2 -2
Yards per play on 1st down 8.09 6.34
Avg. yards to gain on 3rd down 5.13 7.00
Passing down success rate 26.1% (6/23) 18.8% (3/16)
Off. plays from scrimmage 76 55
Yards per play 6.0 5.0
Yards per play (rush) 5.9 2.5
Yards per play (pass attempt) 6.2 7.2
Off. 3rd down conversion rate 50.0% (8/16) 30.0% (3/10)
Off. plays of 20+ yards 5 5
Penalties 2 for 12 yards 2 for 20 yards
Notes on the numbers:
Not counted in the field position, efficiency, and explosiveness categories: Newberry's last drives of the both the first and second halves (two plays each), and The Citadel's last drive of the second half (one play)
In the category for yards per play on first down, Newberry also had two interceptions
The Citadel advanced inside the 40-yard-line five times; Newberry did so three times (of course, on one of those the Wolves' drive originated inside the 10)
Successful plays from scrimmage by quarter: 1st – The Citadel 9, Newberry 1; 2nd – The Citadel 13, Newberry 2 (one via penalty); 3rd – The Citadel 2, Newberry 10; 4th – The Citadel 10, Newberry 8
While The Citadel only had two "successful" offensive plays from scrimmage in the third quarter, one of them was decisive. That would be Cam Jackson's 74-yard TD burst.
The play featured a subtle but important move by Dominique Allen; as described by Jackson, Allen managed to prevent the linebackers from "skating" outside before the pitch. There were two key blocks as well, one by wide receiver Raleigh Webb, and another by left tackle Prince Howard-Whitaker.
The rest of the run consisted of Jackson hitting the seam, brushing aside a would-be tackler with an almost nonchalant stiff-arm, then racing down the sidelines for six points.
– Both teams should get credit for the lack of penalties in an opener. That was particularly impressive (and/or surprising) for Newberry, which even in its successful 2016 campaign had a tendency to be flagged at a higher-than-average rate.
– The attendance (7,467) was disappointing. Part of it can probably be attributed to the weather, although the ominous forecasts in the middle of the week did not come to pass. Perhaps the opponent wasn't enticing enough for some, though Newberry did bring its fair share of fans.
Also possible factors: a home game for Clemson, and a game in Charlotte for South Carolina. The absence of the East stands (beer garden excepted) certainly doesn't help, either.
– Speaking of the beer garden, it was hard to tell from across the field how much action was taking place in the tent. One observer told me that the area did fill up over the course of the game.
– Many complaints were made by fans during and after the game about the scoreboard, mostly concerning the yardage numbers not being updated. Apparently that section is inoperable. Is it already time for a new scoreboard?
– There were also complaints about the uniforms. At this point I'm not even sure why I write about the uniforms, since it is clearly a waste of time to do so. I'll throw a few words together about this topic anyway, however.
The "new" navy/navy combo was announced on Friday, so it wasn't a shock. It isn't really a new color combination, as The Citadel wore all-navy a couple of times several years ago, when Nike supplied the uniforms and the Bulldogs essentially wore UNC designer hand-me-downs.
What was not expected: that the Bulldogs would ditch the "Block C" helmets in favor of numbers (in navy) a la Alabama or Georgia Southern. After decades of changing the helmet logo on a yearly (if not weekly) basis, the program finally settled on an appropriate and simple design that almost everyone likes…and now it's been dropped (at least for the moment) once again.
Perhaps it will be back next week. Who knows at this point.
Alumni can complain about the absence of light blue jerseys at home games, but no one is really listening.
The fact is that light blue is no longer one of the school's primary athletic colors. There hasn't been an official announcement to that effect, but there doesn't have to be.
It's reality, and reality that has been noticed by anyone who has attended games at Johnson Hagood Stadium over the past eight years. These days, fans are just as likely (actually more likely) to see the Bulldogs wearing almost any other color.
I fully expect black home jerseys (and helmets) this season or next, along with the now-commonplace navy and gray jerseys, and wouldn't be surprised to see the team in red or chartreuse.
I know, I know — "Who cares as long as they win?" Well, I don't see why they can't win while wearing the traditional colors too.
As I said earlier, however, light blue is no longer one of the school colors, so it really doesn't matter.
Next week's opponent: Presbyterian, which lost 51-7 to Wake Forest last Thursday night. I'll post my preview of the game against the Blue Hose later this week.
As is tradition, I took bad pictures. The action shots are actionable.
I hope to improve on this front in the weeks to come, but there are no guarantees.
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Brent Thompson, Newberry, The Citadel | Leave a comment »
2017 Football, Game 1: The Citadel vs. Newberry
Posted on August 28, 2017 by Sandlapper Spike
Nothing remained today but to remove all pebbles and other noxious substances from the Hampton Park playing field…
…The cause of all this commotion in The Citadel camp, the Newberry Indians, are expected to reach Charleston tonight, and they will need no urging to remain over for the game tomorrow, for if the intentions laid at their door are correct, they expect to give the local cadets a bad time, and return to Newberry with an attractive Citadel defeat towing behind them. In short, the Lutherans are not coming here for a trouncing or even a tie game, but are keenly desirous of utterly squelching their hardy opponents.
Coach Rogers' pupils are not worrying about the strength of the enemy, but are striving to increase their own prowess, for they haven't even a tiny intention of submitting to any drubbing by those pretentious Newberrians, comparative upstarts in the pigskin world. The latter's work this season has been enough to cause a scare, but the cadets have faced danger before now, and expect to walk over the top of their guests if they insist on staying in their way.
– The Charleston Evening Post, Friday, November 6, 1914
Battling bitterly The Citadel barely nosed out a victory over the Newberry Indians in one of the fiercest contests on a Charleston gridiron, the final score being The Citadel 14, Newberry 13. The contest was a terrific struggle between the two teams, which were as nearly evenly matched as two elevens could be.
The individual honors of the afternoon were about evenly divided between Weeks of the Bull Dogs, and MacLean of the Indians. Sheppard roamed all over the field and smothered play after play of the Lutherans. Baker, Renken, and Ashbaugh showed considerable fondness in clinging on to the aerial messages of MacLean.
…In the last few minutes of play, with the Cadets one point in the lead, the play was fast, sharp, and hard, every inch being stubbornly contested. Ashbaugh made two attempts at field goals. The first was wide, but the second, a beautiful kick of about 45 yards, missed the post by about a foot. It was Newberry's last chance.
Weeks was again the backbone of the Cadets and almost individually won the game. His offensive work was superb, his defensive playing great, and his grit and nerve some of the best ever shown at Hampton Park. Knocked out of the game with a bum shoulder, he came back and literally played on his nerve. It was Weeks who made one of the touchdowns and Weeks who kicked both goals.
MacLean, although weighing about 150 pounds, piloted his team in an able manner. His passing of the ball, tackling, and running in the open field stamps him as the best quarter in the State. Bumped and hammered about, he was as cool as the proverbial cucumber and tossed the pigskin with unerring accuracy on all the forward passes.
– The Sunday News, November 8, 1914
The Citadel vs. Newberry, to be played at historic Johnson Hagood Stadium, with kickoff at 6:00 pm ET on September 2, 2017.
The game will be televised by 7 Communications, and streamed on ESPN3.com. Kendall Lewis will handle play-by-play, while former Bulldogs linebacker James Riley supplies the analysis. Erin Summers will report from the sidelines.
Mike Legg (the "Voice of the Bulldogs") will call the action alongside analyst Lee Glaze. The sideline reporter on the radio broadcasts is Jay Harper.
Charleston: WQNT 1450AM/92.1 FM/102.1 FM (Flagship)
Columbia: WQXL 1470AM/95.9FM
Greenville: WLFJ 92.9FM/660AM
Sumter: WDXY 1240AM/105.9FM
According to the Southern Conference, the following television stations/cable outlets will be carrying the game:
WCIV-3 — Charleston, SC (this is the "MeTV" subchannel)
WYFF-2 — Greenville, SC (this is the "This" subchannel)
WITN-2 — Greenville, NC (this it the "MyTV" subchannel)
WILM — Wilmington, NC (could be a "joined in progress" situation)
WDWW- 7 — Atlanta, GA (yes, digital subchannel 7)
WHKY — Charlotte, NC
Cox Cable — Roanoke, VA
Cox Cable — Norfolk, VA
WFXB-4 — Myrtle Beach, SC (digital subchannel 4)
KPMF — Memphis, TN
Now, a warning. It is possible, if not likely, that all of the stations that carry the matchup will have it on a digital subchannel. For instance, the game will be seen in Charleston on WCIV's "MeTV" subchannel — not "regular" WCIV or even "MyTV" WCIV, but WCIV-DT3.
If you live in one of the areas listed above and you don't get ESPN3, turn on your TV at 6pm, and if the game isn't on the listed channel, try the subchannels for each of these stations before giving up. Then and only then should you throw your remote control device into a nearby lake.
Newberry's website states that the game will also be televised in Raleigh and Greensboro. We shall see. If it is, it may be on a subchannel for one of the CW affiliates in each of those cities.
If you live in Macon, you apparently will able to watch the game on WMUB, Mercer's student TV station. MASN (a mid-Atlantic sports network) is also listed by Newberry as carrying the contest, but I suspect that is on a tape-delay basis.
My apologies if anyone is confused by any or all of that information. In my defense, I'm probably more confused than anyone else…
A few of my recent posts revolving around football, including the upcoming season for The Citadel:
I broke down 2016's conference statistics, including (but not limited to) 4th-down decisions, run/pass tendencies, and…the coin toss
In concert with the above statistically-oriented post, I took a look at select "advanced stats" from last season
Updated to reference the 2016 numbers, I produced my latest of many (perhaps too many) posts on attendance at Johnson Hagood Stadium
I broke down the SoCon non-conference slate for this year for each school
Another scheduling-related post: what teams will schools face both before and after facing The Citadel?
– Season preview from The Post and Courier
– SoCon preview from The Post and Courier
– STATS SoCon preview (The Citadel is picked to finish third)
– College Sports Madness preview of the Bulldogs (The Citadel is picked to finish fourth in the SoCon)
– SoConSports.com preview of The Citadel
– SoCon media and coaches' preseason polls (The Citadel is picked to finish second in both polls)
– The Citadel: Quick Facts
– Game notes from The Citadel and Newberry
– South Atlantic Conference weekly release
– Kailik Williams counts his blessings
– Tyler Davis is an aging veteran
– Dominique Allen is profiled in the Savannah Morning News
– Bulldogs from the Houston area are keeping an eye on Hurricane Harvey
– Freshmen have to be ready to play on Saturday
– FCS Coaches' poll (The Citadel opens the season ranked #12)
– STATS FCS poll (The Citadel opens the season ranked #16)
– Brent Thompson at The Citadel's Media Day (video)
– Brent Thompson has a brief conversation with Phil Kornblut (8/18) on SportsTalk (audio)
– Brent Thompson's 8/29 press conference, including comments from Dominique Allen and Myles Pierce (video)
– Brent Thompson's 8/30 radio show (video)
– Newberry season preview from The Post and Courier
– Interview (8/17) of Newberry head coach Todd Knight on WKNT-FM 107.5 in Columbia (audio)
– Interview (8/3) of Newberry head coach Todd Knight on ESPN Upstate [begins at 9:45 mark] (audio)
– Newberry picked to repeat as South Atlantic Conference champions
– Seven players from Newberry received preseason first-team all-SAC recognition
– Newberry hopes to spring the upset; this clip includes the much-discussed "The Citadel is arguably the second-best team in South Carolina" comment (video)
– This article in The Post and Courier includes the two-deep for both schools
It's time for football!
FOOTBALL!
FOOTBALL!!
FOOTBALL!!!
The Citadel has won 19 games and consecutive SoCon titles over the last two years. The upcoming gridiron campaign has been highly anticipated by Bulldog supporters, but there are on-field questions that must be answered, and in a decidedly positive manner, if The Citadel is to win the league and advance to postseason play for a third straight season.
There is also the issue of Johnson Hagood Stadium — or more precisely, what is left of Johnson Hagood Stadium:
The east side of Johnson Hagood Stadium has been reduced to piles of rubble as demolition work at the home of Citadel football continues.
The east side of the stadium contained about 9,300 seats, and demolition of the aging structure was approved by the city's Board of Architectural Review in February.
On [August 6], The Citadel's Board of Visitors approved a plan that would add 3,800 seats to the east side of the stadium, which was demolished earlier this year. The plan also calls for about 40,000 square feet of "office, education and/or residential space" on the east side.
The motion, approved unanimously by the BOV, requests that The Citadel Real Estate Foundation "develop detailed specifications, pricing and recommendations to finance and fund the cost of the new East Side facility" and update the board at its September meeting…
…The new plan also includes possible future addition of 2,400 seats on the east side, if needed. The Citadel averaged 12,987 fans for five games at Johnson Hagood in 2016, when the Bulldogs went 10-2 and won a second straight Southern Conference title.
The goal is to have the "new" East stands ready to go in time for the 2019 season. (If anything, that needs to be a requirement.)
There will be temporary bleachers on that side for this season, but they won't be in place until The Citadel plays Mercer on October 7. Thus, for the home games against Newberry and Presbyterian, only the West stands will have seating, and the stadium capacity will be 11,700 (well, not counting the beer garden — more on that later).
The lack of seating isn't great, but at least things appear to be moving forward. Of course, there is still the question of funding.
The non-conference football schedule for The Citadel is now set through the 2020 season.
2017: Newberry, Presbyterian, at Clemson
2018: Charleston Southern, at Towson, at Alabama
2019: Towson, Charleston Southern, at Elon, at Georgia Tech (12-game season)
2020: Elon, Charleston Southern, at Clemson
As a result, Newberry is the last D-2 school the Bulldogs will meet on the gridiron until at least the 2021 season.
The Citadel released its complete 2018 schedule last Thursday. There will be five home games next season, while the 2019 and 2020 seasons will have six home contests each.
By 2019 the "new" East stands will hopefully be ready to go. I don't have any problem with only having five home games next year, given the stadium situation. Establishing home-and-home series with Towson and Elon in order to ensure six home games in the following two seasons was a good move by Jim Senter.
The Citadel's new instant replay system for officials got a run-through during Saturday's scrimmage. There are new goal-line cameras at each end of the field as part of the new system. The Citadel and Mercer will be the only SoCon teams with replay capability for referees this season.
Replay review will be in effect for every home game this season, including Saturday's matchup with Newberry. Conversely, none of the Bulldogs' road games will feature a replay review system, with the exception of the game at Clemson.
The league will not require teams to have replay review at their respective home facilities until 2019. Essentially, conference games will be played under different rules, depending on the location of the game. That strikes me as problematic at best.
Last week, The Citadel announced that it would be selling beer at home football games this season:
Beer sales will be limited to a 500-person "beer garden" tent inside Johnson Hagood Stadium.
The tent will be located in the southeast corner of the stadium, where aging stands were demolished this summer. There will be a three-beer limit per patron, and Citadel cadets of legal age (21) will not be able to buy beer in the tent…
…The beer garden will feature two TVs for fans to watch games, and bartenders to serve beer.
A friend of mine suggested that in addition to setting up a beer garden, The Citadel should establish a separate entry fee for the entire section, and incorporate food trucks into the mix. I like that idea.
I'm more of a "watching the game with a great deal of intensity" fan than a "casually downing a beer or two while eating a burrito and occasionally glancing at the field" fan, but I understand that the school has to appeal to a wide variety of supporters. In a way, this is an effort to bring part of the tailgating scene into the stadium.
Beer sales or no beer sales, hopefully Johnson Hagood Stadium will be packed with fans when Newberry comes to town on Saturday. Speaking of Newberry…
The Lutheran intellectual tradition creatively engages the dialectic tensions inherent in the dynamic nature of human life.
– Newberry College website
In 1854, the Lutheran Synod in South Carolina voted to make its seminary (which had existed for 23 years) a degree-granting college. At the time, the seminary was located in Lexington, South Carolina; the institution was moved to Newberry, where it was chartered in 1856 and named Newberry College.
The timing wasn't ideal. As a result of the Civil War, most of the faculty and students went into military service. By 1868, the college was in financial trouble. For a while, the school was relocated to Walhalla; it returned to Newberry in 1877.
The seminary side of the setup was reopened after the war in 1866, and then it moved around a bit — to Walhalla in 1868; to Salem, Virginia in 1872; then back to Newberry in 1884; in 1898 to Mt. Pleasant; and, finally, to Columbia in 1911.
It is now known as the Lutheran Theological Southern Seminary (LTSS). In 2012, it merged with Lenoir-Rhyne University, and now operates as a satellite campus of that Hickory, North Carolina-based school. Therefore, LTSS actually has a connection to two different schools in the South Atlantic Conference — Newberry and Lenoir-Rhyne.
Today, Newberry has an enrollment of 1,064 students (54% male). Four-fifths of its students live in on-campus housing. The college is situated on 94 acres of land.
Newberry began fielding a football team in 1913. Its first game was a 16-7 victory over Furman.
In 1914, the Indians played The Citadel for the first time; that is the contest referenced in the two newspaper blurbs at the beginning of this post. The record books for Newberry and The Citadel both list the 1914 gridiron clash between the two schools as having been played in Newberry, but it was actually played at Hampton Park in Charleston.
The Citadel was 0-7 passing in that contest, with one interception, while the radical passing attack of Newberry was 9-16 for one TD and a pick. Also worth mentioning: gentlemen had to cough up 75 cents to receive admission to the game, while ladies only had to pay 50 cents.
Prior to that game, Newberry had already defeated Furman and Wofford during the 1914 season, and tied South Carolina.
The Indians had also beaten Porter Military Academy 20-0 in Newberry, though the school's record book lists that game as having taken place on September 26; it actually occurred on October 3. Newberry also lists a 20-7 victory in Charleston over Porter on October 17; the score and location are correct, but the game was played on November 9 (yes, just two days after Newberry played The Citadel; they did stuff like that back in those days).
Newberry no longer goes by the "Indians" moniker. As of 2010, the school's varsity athletic teams are known as the "Wolves". From the school website:
In August 2005, Newberry College was placed on a watch list by the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) along with 17 other schools which deemed the use of "Indians" as hostile and abusive, and prohibited the use of Native American nicknames, mascots and imagery in postseason competition.
In September 2005, Newberry College appealed to be removed from the list of schools which were declared unable to host postseason play on the basis that none of the institutions uses of "Indians" were hostile and/or abusive toward Native Americans.
The next month, the NCAA rejected Newberry's appeal.
A later agreement with the NCAA allowed the college to use the nickname for two more years. However, Newberry eventually went two school years (2008-09, 2009-10) without a nickname.
As you might imagine, not everyone at the school was thrilled about that, including then-sophomore Derek Bley, a baseball player:
Quite a tragedy. Here we are in the middle of nowhere, and we have no name.
…We are the notorious Block N's. It carries no fear.
Former head football coach Zak Willis had another gripe, specifically with the NCAA: "I don't know how a group in Indianapolis, Indiana, gets to tell us we can't be the Indians."
Back in the day, Newberry had occasionally been referred to as the "Lutheran Lads" by the sporting press, but that probably wasn't going to fly in the 21st century, either. The decision by the school's Board of Trustees to eventually pick "Wolves" as the new nickname/mascot mirrored the preference of the student body.
Todd Knight is entering his ninth season as Newberry's head football coach. He was the school's defensive coordinator for six years before getting the top job.
Prior to moving to Newberry,Knight served as the defensive coordinator at Charleston Southern (under David Dowd). He was also the DC at Lees-McRae, and a secondary coach at his alma mater, Gardner-Webb (Knight is a 1989 graduate of that school).
Newberry has had four seasons in its football history in which it won nine or more games. Knight has been the head coach for two of those years, and was the defensive coordinator for the other two.
He has a 50-38 record as the head coach. Over the last four years, the Wolves are 31-16, including a 19-9 mark in the South Atlantic Conference (SAC). Last October, the school extended Knight's contract through the 2020 season.
During Knight's tenure as head coach of Newberry, the Wolves have played four FCS opponents. While Newberry has lost all four of those matchups, each has been competitive (and three were one-score games).
In 2009, Austin Peay defeated Newberry, 34-23. The following season, Samford outlasted the Wolves 38-35. In 2014, Charleston Southern edged Newberry 16-10.
The next year (2015), Newberry actually hosted an FCS team — Jacksonville. The Dolphins prevailed 17-14.
In 2016, Newberry finished with a 10-2 record, 7-0 in the SAC (and 5-0 on the road). After losing the opener to Florida Tech, the Wolves won 10 straight games and the league title. Newberry then lost in the first round of the D-2 playoffs to Tuskegee.
The Wolves had been ranked No. 14 in D-2 prior to that game. Newberry finished with a final ranking of No. 16.
Newberry's schedule and results, 2016:
Florida Tech (home): lost 42-28
Virginia Union (home): won 42-22
North Greenville (road): won 29-28
Tusculum (road): won 37-10
Catawba (home): won 35-14
Mars Hill (road): won 35-21
Carson-Newman (home): won 34-19
Brevard (road): won 34-7
Lenoir-Rhyne (home): won 53-14
Limestone (road): won 49-7
Wingate (home): won 27-22
Tuskegee (home): lost 35-33
Newberry video from 2016:
– Highlights package
– Highlights of Newberry's 29-28 victory over North Greenville
– Most of the first three quarters of Newberry's 37-10 win over Tusculum
– Highlights of Newberry's 34-19 victory over Carson-Newman
– Highlights of Newberry's 27-22 win over Wingate
You can also watch video replays of Newberry's 2016 home games — for instance, the Wolves' 53-14 demolition of Lenoir-Rhyne: Link
Statistics of note for Newberry's 2016 season (all 12 games):
Newberry Opponents
Points/game 36.3 20.1
Yards/rush 4.13 3.82
Rush TDs 29 12
Comp-Att-Int 287-423-16 158-330-13
Passing TDs 30 18
Sacks by-yards 34-211 20-128
Red Zone TD% (47-63) 74.6% (18-34) 52.9%
Newberry finished 29th in D-2 in scoring offense, and 22nd in scoring defense. NC was 35th nationally in offensive yards per play and 25th in yards allowed per play.
The Wolves were 21st nationally in both offensive and defensive pass efficiency. Newberry's pass completion rate of 67.8% was fourth-best in the division.
Another category Newberry fared well in was 3rd down conversion rate, both offensively (16th in D-2) and defensively (24th).
The Wolves rolled up some very impressive total offense numbers, including a 729-yard effort against Lenoir-Rhyne.
On special teams, Newberry finished 13th nationally in kick return defense and topped the division in punt return defense, allowing a total of 1 net punt return yard for the season. No, that is not a typo.
I'm guessing that the lack of punt return yardage is based on a coaching philosophy of simply not giving an opponent any chance of returning a punt. If so, it certainly worked in 2016.
On the other hand, the strategy must not have always been employed in previous years, as Newberry's yearly total punt return yardage allowed has yo-yoed from 35 to 97 to 212 to 1 in the past four seasons.
Last season, Newberry's pass-run ratio was very close to 50-50. The Wolves threw 423 passes while being sacked 20 times, for a total of 443 assumed passing plays, while rushing 446 times (excluding sacks). Obviously, some plays that were would-be passes turned into runs.
Despite the even distribution of rushes and passes, almost 65% of the Wolves' total offense came through the air. Newberry averaged more than twice as many yards per passing play as by rushing attempt.
Many of the players responsible for that production are gone, including last year's starting quarterback, lead running back, and two quality wide receivers (one of whom operated at times as a "wildcat" QB). The Wolves also lost two starters on the offensive line, the left tackle and left guard.
The starting quarterback this season for Newberry will be Nick Jones (6'0″, 220 lbs.). A redshirt sophomore from Florence, Jones appeared in six games last season, starting late in the season against Wingate when regular QB Raleigh Yeldell was suspended.
In the game versus Wingate, Jones was 16-21 passing for 242 yards and two touchdowns, but he also threw three interceptions and was sacked three times.
During the spring, the Newberry coaching staff moved reserve wideout Darius Clark (6'1″, 205 lbs.) to tailback. At the SAC Media Day, Todd Knight suggested that the junior "could be poised for a breakout season". Clark is a product of St. John's High School. He also served as a kick returner last season.
Average size of Newberry's projected starters on the offensive line, as per the school's 8/25 two-deep: 6'2″, 297 lbs. Four of the five listed starters weigh 300+ lbs.
Starting center Dakota Mozingo (6'0″, 260 lbs.), a Rock Hill native, was a preseason SAC all-conference pick. Fellow senior Austin Turner (6'3″, 320 lbs.) was a second-team selection. Turner, a senior from Lexington, is the Wolves' right guard.
Tyler Anderson (6'3″, 300 lbs.) started five games last season for Newberry. The redshirt sophomore was a preseason second-team All-SAC choice and is slated to start at left tackle this year.
On the other side of the line is none other than Tyler's twin brother, Austin Anderson (also 6'3″, 300 lbs.). The brothers went to Wren High School.
Left guard Wade Rouse (6'1″, 305 lbs.) is a redshirt freshman who went to West Ashley High School in Charleston, where he also threw the shotput and discus for the track team.
Backup right tackle Sam Hall (6'2″, 260 lbs.) was named a first-team Academic All-American at the end of last season. The biology major is a senior from Conway.
Markell Castle (5'8″, 165 lbs.) is a slot receiver who caught 67 passes last year for 976 yards and seven touchdowns. A case could be made that the junior from York is Newberry's best returning player.
You can bet that the Bulldogs will be paying attention to #13 on Saturday, especially after watching video like this: Link
Another 5'9″ wideout, J.T. Waters (listed at 175 lbs.) is holding down the "W" receiving spot on the Wolves' two-deep. The junior has seven career receptions. Waters went to Palmetto Christian Academy in Mt. Pleasant, where he put up big numbers as a quarterback at the small school.
Tight end Baptiste Staggers (6'4″, 230 lbs.), like Mozingo and Castle, was named to the preseason first team SAC all-conference team. Unlike those two players, however, Staggers (who went to Fort Dorchester High School) may be challenged for playing time this fall.
During an appearance on WYRD (ESPN Upstate) earlier this month, Todd Knight stated that "we've got a really good tight end in Baptiste Staggers who I think is the best tight end in the league, [but] we've got a kid who transferred in here, who's pushing him to the point where he's almost beating him out — so we're probably looking at playing a lot of two tight end sets this year, which we've never done before, but we've got to put the best 11 out there."
Knight was presumably referring to 6'7″, 250 lb. junior Sean Smith, a transfer from Middle Tennessee State. As a senior at Summerville High School, Smith was rated as a 3-star prospect by Scout.com and received offers from Georgia State and Florida Atlantic, as well as MTSU.
Newberry returns most of its starting defense from last season, including its three leading tacklers, all of whom were preseason all-league choices.
Jamarcus Henderson (5'10", 230 lbs.) was a destructive force last season at defensive end. The second-team All-American had 22 tackles for loss, including 9 1/2 sacks.
Now a redshirt junior, Henderson was a star at Union County High School, where he played for former South Carolina quarterback Steve Taneyhill. He was named the Spartanburg Herald Journal's defensive player of the year as a senior, despite playing for a 2-8 team.
Backup DE Keito Jordon started three games as a freshman at Hampton in 2014. Newberry's roster lists the Hopkins resident as a sophomore.
Defensive tackle Josh Spigner (6'0″, 265 lbs.) is a senior who went to Ashley Ridge High School in Summerville. He started one game last season for the Wolves.
Inside linebacker Joe Blue (5'10", 225 lbs.) is a junior from Dillon. Last year, Blue led Newberry in tackles with 91, including 68 solo stops.
Will Elm (6'3″, 215 lbs.) finished third on the team in tackles, behind Henderson and Blue. Elm is a senior from Irmo.
Elm's fellow outside linebacker, Rameak Smith (6'3″, 195 lbs.) recorded 48 tackles last year. Defensive back LaQuan White (6'1″, 185 lbs.) only started three games last season, but led the Wolves in interceptions, with four (against Catawba, he returned one pick for 55 yards). Smith and White both went to Woodland High School in Ridgeville.
Devin Dexter, a 6'0″, 250 lb. "true" freshman from Byrnes High School, may be another Newberry defender to watch, despite not being listed on the two-deep. One veteran observer of the S.C. high school scene told me that Dexter, a defensive lineman, has a "high motor" and is very strong.
Last year, he was the Spartanburg Herald-Journal's defensive player of the year, just as Henderson was in 2013. Dexter also played in the North-South All-Star game at the end of last season.
Shea Rodgers (6'0″, 175 lbs.), a redshirt sophomore from Indian Land, handled most of the placekicking, punting, and kickoff duties for Newberry last season. He has been named to the watch list for the Fred Mitchell award.
Rodgers only attempted five field goals, but made them all, with a long of 32 yards. He was 42-48 on PAT attempts. Rodgers was a second-team All-SAC preseason selection.
The kicker-holder duo is an all-Indian Land affair, as junior holder Manny McCord (5'11", 185 lbs.) and Rodgers were high school classmates. McCord is also a reserve wide receiver.
Perry Able (5'11", 170 lbs.), a Newberry native, will return as the Wolves' long snapper.
As mentioned above, Darius Clark served as a kick returner last season, as did 5'10", 185 lb. senior running back Rondreas Truesdale.
However, Newberry's two-deep lists Keinan Lewis (6'2″, 205 lbs.) as the primary kick returner. The senior from Belton, who began his collegiate career at Georgia Military, also starts at wide receiver (and scored four touchdowns last season).
The two-deep indicates that Markell Castle will be the Wolves' punt returner. He returned two punts last season.
The Citadel and Newberry had one common opponent last season, North Greenville. Both played NGU in Tigerville.
Let's look at some stats from those games, starting with Newberry-North Greenville. The Wolves prevailed 29-28, scoring a touchdown (and converting the PAT) with 1:04 to play in the contest.
Newberry NGU
Points 29 28
Rushing yardage 192 275
Rush TDs 3 2
Passing yardage 215 96
Comp-Att-Int 21-38-0 14-34-0
Total offense 407 371
Fumbles/lost 1/0 0/0
Penalties 14 13
Penalty yards 120 120
3rd-down conv 7-17 4-14
Sacks by-yards 0-0 1-1
Red Zone TD% (4-5) 80% (2-2) 100%
Phew, look at all those penalties! The elapsed game time was 3:19; at least 35 minutes of that must have been used by the officials just to march off penalty yardage.
Now, those same categories for The Citadel-North Greenville:
TC NGU
Rushing yardage 559 56
Yards/rush 7 2.4
Passing yardage 40 316
Comp-Att-Int 3-6-2000 14-32-1
Yards/play 7 6.8
Penalties 3 6
Penalty yards 40 71
Sacks by-yards 3-27 0-0
Red Zone TD% (2-6) 33% (0-0) 0%
The Citadel didn't do a great job in the Red Zone, but with 559 rushing yards, it didn't matter. The Bulldogs also got burned on two big pass plays (which is reflected in the yards/attempt category).
North Greenville's completions/attempts were very similar in the two games, but thanks to those big gainers the Crusaders put up much better offensive passing numbers against the Bulldogs than they did versus the Wolves.
I also took a quick glance at Newberry's games against Lenoir-Rhyne from 2010 through 2013, when Brent Thompson was the offensive coordinator for L-R. Newberry still has the same head coach (Todd Knight) and defensive coordinator (Stephen Flynn) it had for those four contests.
2010: Newberry won 40-36; Lenoir-Rhyne rushed 47 times for 376 yards and 4 TDs (one lost fumble) while going 6-15 through the air for 92 yards and a TD (against two interceptions)
2011: Lenoir-Rhyne won 54-42; L-R rushed 52 times for 346 yards and 4 TDs (one lost fumble), and also completed 3 of 6 passes for 133 yards and two TDs
2012: Lenoir-Rhyne won 44-21; the Bears rushed 59 times for 395 yards and 4 TDs while completing 3 of 6 passes for 77 yards and a TD
2013: Lenoir-Rhyne won 35-14; L-R rushed 74 times for 428 yards and 5 TDs (one lost fumble), and completed 3 of 5 passes for 80 yards
Lenoir-Rhyne rushed for 1545 yards in four games, which comes out to 386.25 yards per contest. The Bears averaged 6.66 (ooh, spooky) yards per rush and scored a total of 17 rushing touchdowns.
As far as the passing statistics were concerned, L-R was 15-32 through the air (46.9%) for an average of 11.9 yards (!) per attempt.
The Bears' 3 completions in the 2011 contest included a 70-yard TD and a 42-yard reception, while the 2012 game featured a 50-yard TD reception by a Lenoir-Rhyne receiver named Artis Gilmore. (How he didn't wind up playing for Gardner-Webb or Jacksonville, I'll never know.)
With those results in mind, I thought it was a bit curious that Newberry waited until very late in its preseason to make an adjustment to its practice schedule. Instead of an anticipated scrimmage, the Wolves' coaching staff elected to "[alter] its practice schedule to focus on preparing for The Citadel's unique ground-based scheme."
Newberry's football team has an honor council known as "The Order of the Gray Stripe". Among other things, the Wolves' game captains are chosen from this group.
During the game, these individuals can be identified by their helmets, which have a gray stripe down the center. Other players will have solid white helmets with no striping. Newberry's helmets also feature a stylized red "N" that incorporates a wolf in the logo.
The Wolves are one of many schools that have mix-and-match uniforms, with their togs provided by adidas. Expect either an all-white or white jerseys/scarlet pants look on Saturday for Newberry, which is 6-2 since 2015 wearing those two combinations, while the Wolves are only 1-1 wearing gray pants with the white jerseys.
At the SAC's Media Day, Todd Knight discussed the advantages of playing a game at The Citadel:
Charleston has always been a hotbed of recruiting for us. I think just getting our face out there in Charleston that day will be beneficial for us. I just hope we have a good show. We've got so many players already on the team from Charleston, Baptiste Staggers being one of the main ones. Darius Clark, LaQuan White, Rameak Smith are all from there and are key guys for us. Josh Spigner too. And three of our NFL guys came from that area as well.
Last week, the Newberry coach told Columbia radio station WGCV that "I'm not gonna have to do a whole lot to get our kids fired up for The Citadel. We've got one kid whose family has already bought up 100 tickets."
Newberry's abundance of Lowcountry players earned the program an article in The Post and Courier last November.
– The weather forecast for Saturday in Charleston, per the National Weather Service: mostly cloudy, with showers and thunderstorms likely during the day; expected high temperature of 87 degrees and a 60% chance of precipitation. The low temperature Saturday night is projected to be 75 degrees, with evening thunderstorms a possibility (40%). Not ideal.
– Per one source that deals in such matters, The Citadel is a 30-point favorite over Newberry. The over/under is 50.5.
– Other lines involving SoCon teams: Wofford is a 13-point favorite against Furman; Mercer is a 20-point favorite versus Jacksonville; Samford is am 8.5-point favorite against Kennesaw State; East Tennessee State is a 28.5-point favorite versus Limestone; and VMI is a 31.5-point underdog at Air Force.
While the Kennesaw State-Samford game is expected to be high-scoring (over/under of 67), the same cannot be said for Furman-Wofford (over/under of 45.5).
Around the Palmetto State, Presbyterian is a 40-point underdog at Wake Forest; Clemson is a 40-point favorite versus Kent State; South Carolina State is a 2-point favorite at Southern; Charleston Southern is a 21-point underdog at Mississippi State; Coastal Carolina is a 1.5-point underdog at home versus Massachusetts; and South Carolina is a 4.5-point underdog against North Carolina State, with that game being played in Charlotte.
After losing 27-13 to Jacksonville State in Week 0, Chattanooga is off this week.
– Massey Ratings: The Citadel is ranked 16th in FCS as Week 1 approaches. Newberry is ranked 66th in D-2. Overall (all college teams ranked), The Citadel is 130th, while Newberry is 344th.
Massey projects a final score of The Citadel 42, Newberry 13. The Bulldogs are given a 97% chance of victory.
Other FCS rankings in Massey of note: Wofford (8th), Chattanooga (9th), Charleston Southern (10th), Chattanooga (15th, down six spots after losing last weekend), Samford (21st), Furman (34th), Mercer (43rd), Kennesaw State (51st), Gardner-Webb (52nd), Western Carolina (58th), VMI (64th), ETSU (91st), South Carolina State (89th), Presbyterian (95th).
The FCS top five in Massey's rankings, in order: North Dakota State, James Madison, Eastern Washington, Youngstown State, and Jacksonville State (which jumped two spots after beating UTC).
– In the 2017 preseason AFCA D-2 poll, Newberry was in the "receiving votes" category. It would have ranked 30th if the rankings had been listed to that placement.
– Newberry offensive coordinator Bennett Swygert is a former quarterback at Western Carolina and Summerville High School. This is his fifth season as the Wolves' OC.
His wife, Lyndsey Swygert, is the cheerleading coach at Newberry. She also oversees the school's other spirit programs, including the Wolves' dance team (a group known as the Scarlet Poms).
– C.J. Frye was recently hired as Newberry's tight ends coach, a position he also held in 2012-13. Frye played football at South Carolina (he is the son of longtime Gamecocks track coach Curtis Frye) and for the past two years was the head football coach at Andrew Jackson High School, until he unexpectedly resigned in July.
– The Wolves play their home football games at Setzler Field, which has the distinction of being the oldest on-campus football stadium in South Carolina. It has a seating capacity of 4,000.
The school averaged 3,502 fans per home game last season, which was 58th-best in Division II (out of 172 institutions). That average was better than 22 FCS programs, including two in South Carolina — Presbyterian (which averaged 3,299 patrons per home contest) and Charleston Southern (2,712).
– Setzler Field is also the home of Newberry's women's lacrosse team — and as of the spring of 2018, the new men's lacrosse program. Nine of the eleven schools in the SAC sponsor men's lacrosse.
– Newberry started a major fundraising campaign in late 2014. Part of the campaign includes a "stadium renovation and athletic village construction project" with the objective of modernizing and upgrading the football stadium (including the scoreboard and press box), locker rooms, and coaches' offices. The monetary goal for that project is $8 million.
– Earlier in this post, I mentioned Newberry's connection to Lenoir-Rhyne. The two Lutheran schools play every year for the "Bishops' Trophy", which was created in 1987 by the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.
Newberry and Lenoir-Rhyne have played 83 times, including every season since 1946.
– For many years, Newberry's chief gridiron rival was Presbyterian (95 meetings), with the annual game between the two schools often taking place on Thanksgiving Day. They played for one of the better trophies in college football, the Bronze Derby. It didn't have the grandeur and mystique of the coveted Silver Shako, but it was a fine bauble.
Alas, the Newberry-Presbyterian series has been dormant since 2006, due to the Blue Hose moving to FCS.
– Newberry's most famous alum is probably the late political strategist Lee Atwater. The current Secretary of State for South Carolina, Mark Hammond, is also a Newberry graduate (and a former football player as well). Hammond's son Ross is Wofford's long snapper.
– The game notes roster for Newberry includes 89 players from South Carolina. Other states represented on its roster: Georgia (3 players), Florida (3), Alabama (2), and North Carolina (1).
There are Wolves from 64 different S.C. high schools, including three each from Summerville, South Florence, Byrnes, Lexington, Indian Land, Marlboro County, Fairfield Central, and South Pointe. However, no players from traditional power Orangeburg-Wilkinson are on the Newberry roster, a glaring oversight which will undoubtedly prove costly to the program over the course of the 2017 campaign.
This is the first time The Citadel and Newberry have met since 1997, a 33-13 win for the Bulldogs. In that matchup, Carlos Frank had two punt return touchdowns (of 53 and 80 yards, respectively).
His game total of 177 punt return yards remains a Southern Conference record. Frank also caught a 51-yard touchdown pass from Stanley Myers during the contest.
However, I remember the previous meeting between the two schools even more, a game played in 1995.
Like this Saturday's contest, that game was played on September 2. It was also the season opener for both teams. The Citadel had won 36 games over the previous five years, while Newberry was coming off a 4-7 campaign.
The Citadel raced out to a 13-0 lead thanks to touchdown runs by Myers and Kenyatta Spruill in the game's first seven minutes, but the offense would not score again until the fourth quarter. By that time, the Indians led 14-13.
The Bulldogs regained the lead, but Newberry had a chance to win the game late, scoring a touchdown with 3:17 left to get within 21-20. However, Indians head coach Mike Taylor decided to kick a PAT rather than go for two (this was before the college game had overtime). The debatable decision backfired when Scott Belcher blocked the extra point, and the Bulldogs escaped with a one-point win.
Belcher had 29 tackles in the game, a school record, but the narrow victory foreshadowed a difficult year ahead. The Citadel finished 2-9 that season.
I don't think the 2017 Bulldogs are in danger of going 2-9, but this week's game is not going to be a walk in the park. Newberry is a quality D-2 program coming off a great season. It must replace a lot of offensive talent, but does return several impact players on that side of the ball. Defensively, the Wolves should be solid, with plenty of experience.
I suspect that Newberry head coach Todd Knight believes his team has a decent chance of winning on Saturday. It seems to me that he has put a slightly more public emphasis on the game than might have ordinarily been expected, even for a season opener.
When he called The Citadel "arguably the second-best team in South Carolina" while talking to a local TV station in Columbia, it was not an offhand or impulsive remark. Knight had said the exact same thing in an earlier interview with a Greenville radio station. He was laying the groundwork, so to speak.
Of course, I may be (and probably am) reading too much into that. Knight is nothing if not media-friendly, as can be noted by his barrage of TV/radio appearances around the state. He also opens his practices to the press, with a uniquely descriptive "Don't Get Concussed" media policy.
At any rate, the Bulldogs better be ready to play on Saturday. If they aren't, it could be a very long night for the home team.
I'm confident they will be ready, though. I know The Citadel's fans will be.
Heck, I'm ready now…
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: 7 Comm, Baptiste Staggers, Bennett Swygert, Brent Thompson, Carlos Frank, Darius Clark, Dominique Allen, ESPN3.com, Johnny Weeks, Johnson Hagood Stadium, Josh Spigner, Kailik Williams, Kenyatta Spruill, LaQuan White, LTSS, Myles Pierce, Newberry, Nick Jones, Rameak Smith, SAC, Scott Belcher, SoCon, Stanley Myers, STATS FCS poll, The Citadel, Todd Knight, Tyler Davis | 1 Comment »
During the 2017 season, which teams will the Bulldogs' opponents play before (and after) facing The Citadel?
Posted on July 12, 2017 by Sandlapper Spike
Other links related to The Citadel's upcoming gridiron campaign:
– A quick glance at the 2017 SoCon non-conference football slate
– Inside the Numbers: The Citadel's run/pass tendencies, 4th-down decision-making, and various per-play statistics, along with the highly anticipated coin-toss data
– A look at "advanced statistics" from the Bulldogs' 2016 league campaign
– Preseason rankings and ratings
– The Citadel's fans aren't afraid to travel
For the fifth consecutive season, it's time to take a look at this all-important topic. In this post, I'll list which teams The Citadel's opponents face before and after playing the Bulldogs, along with other items of interest (in terms of schedule "flow").
I'll also throw in a few odds and ends just for fun.
We start with the opener.
September 2: The Citadel opens at home against Newberry. The last time the Bulldogs played the Wolves (in 1997), they weren't actually the Wolves — they were the Indians.
The only previous time these two programs met on September 2 was in 1995. The Bulldogs escaped that day with a 21-20 victory.
Newberry finished last season with a 35-33 loss at home to Tuskegee in the 2016 D-2 playoffs. That came after 10 consecutive wins for the Wolves, which finished with a 10-2 record.
After playing The Citadel, Newberry goes on the road again the following week, facing fellow D-2 squad Virginia Union.
September 9: Presbyterian comes to Charleston to play The Citadel. When the Blue Hose last squared off against the Bulldogs, in 2010, The Citadel prevailed 26-14.
The only other game in the series played on September 9 came in 1978, a 28-17 victory for the Bulldogs. It was Art Baker's first game as head coach of The Citadel; 17,840 fans at Johnson Hagood Stadium watched PC take a 17-14 lead into the fourth quarter before the Bulldogs scored two unanswered touchdowns to make Baker a winner in his debut.
Presbyterian opens this season on Thursday night at Wake Forest, thus getting two extra days of preparation for the game against the Bulldogs. After the Blue Hose's matchup with The Citadel, PC plays its first home game of the season, versus Campbell.
September 16: The Citadel's first road contest of the 2017 season comes at East Tennessee State. It will be the second game played at ETSU's new football stadium. The Buccaneers' first game at their new home will be against Limestone in the season opener.
After playing the Saints, East Tennessee State goes on the road to play defending national champion James Madison. Following the Buccaneers' game versus The Citadel, ETSU stays in Johnson City to play Mercer.
September 23: The Citadel is off this week. It's a good time to take a vacation. At least, I think it's a good time to take a vacation…
September 30: The Bulldogs go on the road to tangle with another bunch of Bulldogs, the group from Samford. In the series between the two schools, this will be the first game played in September.
SU itself must make travel plans in the two weeks prior to its game against The Citadel, as Samford faces Georgia in Athens and then Western Carolina in Cullowhee.
Samford then packs its bags for the longest trip in conference action, Birmingham to Lexington, Virginia (and a 1:30 pm ET kickoff). Two weeks, two games against military colleges.
October 7: It will be Parents' Day at The Citadel, and the Bulldogs are hosting Mercer. Samford and Mercer will trade opponents, as the Bears play VMI in Macon the week before travelling to Charleston.
Incidentally, Mercer had the same scheduling setup with the two military schools in 2015. That year, the Bears lost 28-21 at home to VMI, and then fell 21-19 to The Citadel in Charleston.
October 14: The Bulldogs play Wofford at Johnson Hagood Stadium. The Terriers open the season with two SoCon games (against Furman and Mercer), and then have a bye week before non-conference matchups against Gardner-Webb and Presbyterian.
Wofford hosts Western Carolina the week before playing The Citadel. The following week, the Terriers face Samford in Spartanburg, which is also Wofford's Homecoming game.
October 21: The Citadel travels to Chattanooga for a matchup with the Mocs. It will be Military Appreciation Day at Finley Stadium.
The game against the Bulldogs is the second of a very difficult five-game stretch for UTC. After a home game against Furman, Chattanooga is at Mercer the week before playing The Citadel; the following two weeks are road games against Samford and Wofford.
Chattanooga gets a late-season bye week after playing the Terriers, which may come too late for UTC (though it conceivably could be well-timed, if the Mocs get through that four-game gauntlet unscathed).
October 28: This year, Homecoming comes in October for The Citadel, in a game against VMI. It is the earliest in the season the two teams have battled for the coveted Silver Shako since 1991, when the Bulldogs beat the Keydets 17-14 in the Oyster Bowl in Norfolk, Virginia. That contest was played on October 26.
VMI does not have a bye week in 2017. The Keydets play 11 consecutive games and end their season on November 11, at home versus Wofford. The week before that (and the week after playing The Citadel), the Keydets play East Tennessee State in Johnson City.
Prior to its game against the Bulldogs, VMI hosts Western Carolina.
November 4: Speaking of the Catamounts, WCU is The Citadel's final regular-season home game opponent of the season. Western Carolina will play back-to-back games against Palmetto State schools, hosting Furman in Cullowhee the week before its game versus the Bulldogs.
Western Carolina is back in the mountains on November 11, playing Mercer.
November 11: The Citadel travels to Greenville to play Furman. The two programs have played on this date once before, in 1972, a matchup also hosted by the Paladins. The Citadel won that game 19-13, behind two touchdown runs by Harry Lynch and 102 yards rushing from Bob Carson (which included a 58-yard TD run). It was the final game at Sirrine Stadium for longtime Furman head coach Bob King.
The Paladins have a bye week before playing The Citadel this season, the only team on the Bulldogs' schedule to have that benefit (not counting Presbyterian's two-day head start after playing Wake Forest). Furman's last regular-season game is at Samford.
November 18: The Bulldogs' eleventh game of the campaign is against Clemson, the third straight year The Citadel will end the regular season against a Power-5 conference opponent. It will be Military Appreciation Day in Clemson (as was the case when the two programs met in 2013).
The Tigers face Florida State in Death Valley the week before hosting The Citadel. Clemson then travels to Columbia for its traditional season finale versus South Carolina.
A quick note on "option preview" situations in 2017:
Furman, Mercer, and Western Carolina all play Wofford before facing The Citadel, while the other league teams play the Terriers before taking on the Bulldogs.
Samford opens its season on Thursday night against another triple option team, Kennesaw State.
Clemson plays Georgia Tech on October 28 (and has a bye week before that game to prepare for Paul Johnson's offense).
Just a few more weeks to go…
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Chattanooga, Clemson, East Tennessee State, Furman, Mercer, Newberry, Presbyterian, Samford, SoCon, VMI, Western Carolina, Wofford | Leave a comment »
Inside the numbers: The Citadel's 2016 run/pass tendencies, 4th-down decision-making, and more (including coin toss data!)
Posted on July 2, 2017 by Sandlapper Spike
In the past, I have written about tendencies in playcalling by the then-coach of the Bulldogs, Mike Houston (and his offensive coordinator, Brent Thompson, who took over as The Citadel's head coach last season). I compared statistics over a rolling three-year period. Last year, for example, included numbers from Kevin Higgins' last season in charge and the two years Houston helmed the program.
Now I'm going to take a look at what Thompson did in his first year running the show, and contrast those statistics with those from the 2015 and 2016 seasons for the Bulldogs (with a few exceptions where I don't have readily available data for the previous campaigns).
My focus in this post will be on the following:
down-and-distance run/pass tendencies (for The Citadel and its opponents)
yards per play numbers (offense and defense, rushing and passing)
certain defensive passing stats (including sacks, hurries, and passes defensed)
success in the "red zone" (defined as scoring or preventing touchdowns)
plays from scrimmage of 20 yards or more ("big" plays)
fourth-down decision-making (for The Citadel and its opponents)
situational punting (i.e. punting from inside the opponents' 40-yard line)
the coin toss (of course)
I have another post that focuses on assorted "advanced stats", including success rate, explosiveness, field position, finishing drives, and turnovers — the "five factors" of college football. In that post, I'm also listing some stats related to success on first down and third down, some of which are particularly illuminating with regards to The Citadel.
I decided to split those numbers into a separate post for reasons of clarity, and because I didn't want this post to rival War and Peace for length. It might be best to read what is to come in sections; I can't imagine getting through all this in one sitting. I certainly didn't write it all at once.
Most of the statistics that follow are based on conference play, and only conference play. It's easier and fairer to compare numbers in that way. The bottom line for The Citadel is that its on-field success or failure will be judged on how it does in the Southern Conference, not against Newberry, Presbyterian, or Clemson (this year's non-league slate).
The conference schedules over the last three years looked like this:
The Citadel played seven games in 2014 versus SoCon opposition. The teams in the league that year: Wofford, Western Carolina, Chattanooga, Mercer, Furman, Samford, and VMI.
The Bulldogs played seven games in 2015 against SoCon teams. The conference schools competing on the gridiron that year were the same as in 2014: Western Carolina, Wofford, Samford, Furman, Mercer, VMI, and Chattanooga.
The Citadel played eight games in 2016 versus Southern Conference opponents. The league schools last year: Mercer, Furman, Western Carolina, Chattanooga, Wofford, East Tennessee State, Samford, and VMI (the additional opponent being ETSU).
As I did last year, I've put most of the conference-only numbers on a spreadsheet. It may be headache-inducing (there are nine different sub-sheets), but the stats are all there. Individual game statistics in each category are included.
I am reasonably confident in the overall accuracy of the statistics, though I am far from infallible. It would have been much easier if the SoCon had league-only online football statistics, but it doesn't. C'est la vie.
If someone wants to look at the 2015 stats as well, here is last year's spreadsheet: Link
Some definitions:
– 2nd-and-short: 3 yards or less for a first down
– 2nd-and-medium: 4 to 6 yards for a first down
– 2nd-and-long: 7+ yards for a first down
– 3rd-and-short: 2 yards or less for a first down
– 3rd-and-medium: 3 to 4 yards for a first down
– 3rd-and-long: 5+ yards for a first down
The first number that will follow each down-and-distance category will be the percentage of time The Citadel ran the ball in that situation in 2016. Next to that, in parenthesis, is the run percentage for The Citadel in 2015, and that will be followed by the Bulldogs' run percentage for that situation in 2014 (which will be in brackets).
For example, when it came to running the ball on first down, the numbers looked like this:
– 1st-and-10 (or goal to go): 86.0% (89.1%) [88.9%]
Thus, The Citadel ran the ball on first down 86.0% of the time last year, while the Bulldogs ran the ball in that situation 89.1% of the time in 2015. The Citadel ran the ball 88.9% of the time on first down during its 2014 campaign.
Overall, the Bulldogs ran the ball 85.6% of the time in 2016, after rushing 86.5% of the time on its 2015 plays from scrimmage, and on 84.3% of all offensive plays in 2014.
Here are the rest of the down-and-distance categories (in terms of rush percentage):
– 2nd-and-short: 94.1% (89.2%) [84.0%]
– 2nd-and-medium: 96.1% (89.8%) [90.2%]
– 2nd-and-long: 83.8% (89.2%) [82.2%]
– 3rd-and-short: 100% (93.1%) [95.5%]
– 3rd-and-medium: 88.5% (82.4%) [90.3%]
– 3rd-and-long: 68.1% (66.0%) [57.4%]
It should be noted that there were a few called pass plays that turned into runs. However, if the result of a play was a sack, that counted as a passing down even if a pass wasn't thrown. Of course, The Citadel's offense only suffered one sack all season in league play (at VMI, for six yards).
Yes, The Citadel ran the ball on all 28 third-and-short situations in SoCon action last year. In 2015, the Bulldogs ran 27 out of 29 times on third-and-short.
The Citadel threw the ball a bit more often on first down against East Tennessee State and VMI. The Bulldogs passed slightly more than normal on second-and-long versus Wofford.
Against Chattanooga, The Citadel faced a third-and-long on eleven occasions, but only passed once in that situation (it fell incomplete).
After attempting only four passes on second-in-short in conference action in both 2014 and 2015, the Bulldogs only aired it out twice in that situation last season. Both were incomplete. That means over the last three years, The Citadel is 4-10 passing on second-and-short, for 108 yards, with one touchdown and one interception.
I'm going to alternate between offensive and defensive statistics in this post. I hope that doesn't prove too confusing. In this section, therefore, I'm listing what The Citadel's conference opponents did in down-and-distance situations (but just for the 2016 season). This is information I had not previously compiled, but I thought might prove interesting to a few folks out there.
Overall, league opponents rushed on 49.7% of their plays against The Citadel last year. On first down, conference foes rushed 56.2% of the time. Here are the rest of the down-and-distance categories (in terms of rush percentage):
– 2nd-and-short: 75.9%
– 2nd-and-medium: 47.9%
– 2nd-and-long: 44.8%
– 3rd-and-short: 66.7%
– 3rd-and-medium: 36.4%
– 3rd-and-long: 27.3%
There was quite a bit of variance in these numbers.
Samford, for example, passed on 75% of its plays. The only down-and-distance category in which SU ran more than it passed against The Citadel was on 3rd-and-short. Conversely, Wofford threw the ball just seven times in 65 offensive plays from scrimmage.
All four of The Citadel's home opponents passed the ball (or attempted to pass) more than they ran it. On the other hand, three of the Bulldogs' road opponents rushed more than passed (Western Carolina was the exception).
The Citadel's offense in 2014 in SoCon action: 75.4 plays per game, 11.0 possessions per game
*Overtime possessions are not included in any of the conference-only statistics, for the sake of consistency (and avoiding statistical sample size issues).
**I don't count a drive as an actual possession when it consists solely of a defensive TD via a return, or when it is a defensive turnover that ends the half or game. I also don't count a drive as a possession when the offensive team does not attempt to move the ball forward (such as a kneel-down situation). That's how I interpret the statistic, regardless of how it may be listed in a game summary.
Last season, The Citadel had a time of possession edge in SoCon play of over seven minutes (33:41 – 26:19), an increase of almost three minutes from 2015 (32:13 – 27:47), and a two-minute edge over 2014 (32:40 – 27:20).
The Citadel held the ball longer than its opponents on average in three of the four quarters (the second quarter was the exception). The Bulldogs won the TOP battle in the fourth quarter in every game except one (at Wofford).
Nationally (counting all games), the Bulldogs finished second in total time of possession per contest, just behind San Diego (which won the Pioneer League and made the round of 16 in the FCS playoffs).
The Citadel's defense in 2015 SoCon play: 65.7 plays per game, 12.0 possessions per game
Against Western Carolina, the Bulldogs' D was only on the field for 44 plays from scrimmage. The Citadel controlled the ball in a similar fashion versus Chattanooga, only facing 47 offensive plays by the Mocs.
Wofford's 65 offensive plays from scrimmage (in regulation) were the most run against the Bulldogs' defense last season, just one more than the 64 by Samford's offense — perhaps a bit curious, given the diametrically opposite styles of those two teams.
Note: while NCAA statistical records count sack yardage against rushing totals, the NFL considers sack yardage as passing yardage lost. I take the NFL's position on this, so all conference statistics included in this post count sack yardage against passing stats.
The Citadel's offense in 2014 in SoCon games: 5.56 yards per play, including 5.35 yards per rush and 6.8 yards per pass attempt
The numbers were not as good as the season before, though they do match up well with the 2014 season. While the rushing yards per play may have been down, that wasn't really the issue.
– 2015 passing for The Citadel in seven conference games: 63 pass attempts for 609 yards (three interceptions)
– 2016 passing for The Citadel in eight conference games: 83 pass attempts for 615 yards (two interceptions)
Twenty more pass attempts, just six more yards receiving. That has to improve in 2017.
In this post, I'm also going to take a look at The Citadel's per-play stats from a national perspective (all of FCS, and including all games, not just conference play). I'll throw in some statistics from a few FBS teams as well (concentrating on teams of local interest and schools that run the triple option).
The Bulldogs' offense was just 52nd nationally in yards per play, with a 5.53 average (all games). Sam Houston State's 7.17 yards per play topped FCS. Samford and Chattanooga were 1-2 in the SoCon.
Western Kentucky led FBS in yards per play, with a 7.65 average. Other FBS teams of interest: Oklahoma (2nd), New Mexico (8th), Navy (11th), Clemson (34th), Air Force (tied for 47th), Army (59th), South Carolina (109th), Rutgers (128th and last).
However, The Citadel's overall rate of 5.37 yards per rush was 10th-best in FCS (and led the SoCon).
The top two FCS teams in yards per rush were both Big South squads — Charleston Southern (6.02 yards per rush) and Kennesaw State (5.91 yards per rush). Others worth mentioning: Cal Poly (3rd), North Dakota State (4th), James Madison (5th), Gardner-Webb (17th), Chattanooga (21st), Wofford (24th), Western Carolina (38th), Mercer (52nd), Towson (53rd), Lehigh (59th), Furman (60th), Elon (69th), South Carolina State (74th), Samford (87th), ETSU (103rd), VMI (112th out of 122 teams).
New Mexico's offense led FBS in yards per rush, at 6.61. Navy was 6th, Alabama 8th, Army 12th, Georgia Tech 16th, Air Force 41st, Clemson 73rd, South Carolina 107th, and Texas State 128th and last. That statistical category, and thus the subsequent rankings, counts yardage lost from sacks in its totals, however (this is true for both the FBS and FCS offensive and defensive national statistics/rankings).
The Citadel's defense in 2014 in SoCon action: 7.02 yards per play, including 5.69 yards per rush and 9.1 yards per pass attempt
While yards per rush for opponents was up almost a full yard over 2015, the pass defense more than made up for it. The highlight may have been the game at Western Carolina; once sacks are taken into consideration, the Bulldogs allowed less than one yard per pass attempt in Cullowhee (30 pass attempts/sacks, 26 net yards passing).
Nationally in FCS, The Citadel was 49th in defensive yards per play (5.34). Stony Brook (4.18) was tops nationally. Also in the top 10: Jacksonville State (2nd), Charleston Southern (6th), Wofford (7th), and Chattanooga (9th). Western Carolina finished in the bottom 10.
To the shock of nobody, Alabama led all of D-1 in defensive yards per play (3.99). The rest of the FBS top 5 in that category included Michigan, Ohio State, Washington, and Clemson. Others of note: Army (25th, a major reason for its winning season), South Carolina (59th), Air Force (72nd), New Mexico (105th), Navy (109th), and Rice (128th and last).
The Citadel was 53rd in FCS in the national defensive yards/rush category (at 4.15, actually better than its league stats). Central Arkansas (2.29) led the nation, with Colgate, Princeton, Jacksonville State, and Stony Brook rounding out the top 5. Wofford was 9th, Chattanooga 21st, South Carolina State 25th, Charleston Southern 27th, Mercer 38th, Towson 49th, James Madison 51st, Samford 55th, Furman 81st, VMI 84th, ETSU 87th, Liberty 107th, Elon 108th, Western Carolina 115th, and Presbyterian 117th (out of 122 teams).
I think knowing how league (and non-league) opponents rate in this category is instructive, not just in terms of comparing defenses, but in comparing them to how they might succeed (or fail) against The Citadel's run-heavy offense. Of course, these were last year's statistics; programs obviously change from year to year.
Alabama only allowed opponents an average of 2.01 yards per rush, far and away the best in FBS (Houston was 2nd, at 2.91). Air Force was 15th, Clemson 24th, Army 34th, Navy 77th, Georgia Tech 86th, New Mexico 88th, and South Carolina 92nd.
California was 128th and last, at 6.15 yards allowed per rush. In related news, Cal now has a new head coach who was formerly a defensive coordinator.
Counting all games, The Citadel allowed 6.9 yards per pass attempt, 52nd nationally in FCS. Before you think "well, take the UNC game away and the average would go way down", keep in mind that the team that averaged the most yards per pass attempt versus The Citadel last season was…North Greenville (9.9 yards per attempt). That is what happens when your opponent throws two TD passes of 90+ yards.
San Diego ranked first in this particular category (5.31). The teams in the SoCon were ranked as follows: Chattanooga (14th), Wofford (16th), Samford (77th), VMI (85th), East Tennessee State (91st), Mercer (115th), Western Carolina (116th), Furman (117th).
Presbyterian, which travels to Johnson Hagood Stadium in 2017, was 121st overall, only ahead of Arkansas-Pine Bluff.
Ohio State, Michigan, and Clemson ranked 1-2-3 in yards per pass attempt (defense) in FBS. South Carolina tied for 30th, while Navy was in the bottom 10. Rice was last, just as it was in yards per play.
The Citadel's offensive Red Zone touchdown rate in SoCon action, 2014: 66.7%
The 2016 campaign proved to be slightly better for the Bulldogs' offense in this area than in the previous season, though it should be noted the 2015 squad had one more opportunity in the red zone during conference play (32 to 31) despite playing one fewer league game.
The national FCS leader in this category was Idaho State, at 84.6%. When all games are taken into account, The Citadel ranked only 97th (out of 122 FCS teams). The Bulldogs did not fare nearly as well in offensive red zone TD rate outside of league play, only converting 5 of 14 red zone chances into touchdowns in those contests. Thus, the season rate was just 52.1% (though that total includes two "kneel downs" in the red zone that I did not count in the Bulldogs' league stats).
I think The Citadel should have a goal of converting at least 75% of its red zone opportunities into touchdowns, something that was done by only ten FCS teams last season.
National champion James Madison finished 14th overall in the category, with a 73.1% red zone TD rate. You will probably not be surprised to learn that the Dukes led all of FCS in red zone opportunities. Part of the reason for that is because JMU played 15 games; on the other hand, the Dukes' 93 trips to the red zone were 22 more than any other team. James Madison had 44 rushing TDs from the red zone, which may be even more impressive.
The top 3 SoCon teams in red zone TD rate were Furman, Samford, and Chattanooga (with the Paladins pacing the league at 72.1%, 17th nationally).
Incidentally, three of the top ten teams in red zone TD% in FBS last year were triple-option teams — Navy, Army, and New Mexico (the Midshipmen led FBS with a 79.7% TD conversion rate).
The Citadel's defensive Red Zone touchdown rate in SoCon action, 2014: 60.0%
This is one of the very few defensive stats that wasn't outstanding. However, it is also true the Bulldogs faced fewer trips inside the 20 by their opponents in 2016 than in 2015 (35 to 30) while playing one more conference game (mirroring The Citadel's offense to a certain extent).
The Citadel's defense had slightly better numbers when all games are considered; for the complete season, the Bulldogs' D had a red zone TD rate of 58.3%, tied for 42nd nationally. Another group of Bulldogs, the bunch from Samford, also tied for 42nd overall. That was the best mark among SoCon teams (again, including league and non-league contests in the totals).
As mentioned above, Furman's offense did a good job converting red zone chances into touchdowns last year. Unfortunately for the Paladins, the same was not true on defense. Furman's D allowed opponents to score touchdowns in the red zone on 27 of 34 opportunities in 2016, the worse mark (by percentage) in the country.
Grambling State led FCS in the category, with an impressive defensive red zone TD rate of 34.4%. LSU's defense was the standard-bearer for FBS, with an amazing rate of just 24.3%.
The Citadel's offensive 3rd-down conversion rate in SoCon play, 2014: 46.3%
In all games last season (not just conference action), the Bulldogs had an offensive 3rd-down conversion rate of 47.7%, which led the SoCon and was ninth nationally. Cal Poly, another triple option playoff team, was the overall leader in that category at 53.6%.
Other FCS teams of interest: James Madison (4th overall), North Dakota State (12th), Mercer (17th), Wofford (31st), Gardner-Webb (34th), Charleston Southern (39th), East Tennessee State (44th), Furman (45th), Chattanooga (47th), Western Carolina (50th), Towson (54th), Liberty (77th), Samford (78th), VMI (94th), South Carolina State (109th), Presbyterian (118th).
Navy led FBS in offensive 3rd-down conversion rate, at 54.5%. P.J. Fleck's Western Michigan squad was second overall. Air Force was 6th, Clemson 8th, Army 10th, New Mexico 19th, Georgia Tech 51st (and won nine games despite that), South Carolina 109th, and Tulane 128th and last.
The Citadel's defensive 3rd-down conversion rate in SoCon action, 2014: 41.5%
The Bulldogs had even better stats in this category when non-league contests are included. The all-games rate of 30.1% ranked 9th nationally in FCS, and led the Southern Conference.
That isn't a typo, by the way. The Citadel finished 9th overall in both offensive and defensive 3rd-down conversion rate. That helps you tilt the playing field, which helps you win games.
Jacksonville State led FCS in defensive 3rd-down conversion rate. Montana, Grambling State, Campbell, and Columbia were the other teams in the top 5. South Carolina State was 20th, Chattanooga 25th, James Madison 26th, Presbyterian 30th, Liberty 37th, VMI 45th, ETSU 51st, Charleston Southern 61st, Furman 81st, Mercer 85th, Gardner-Webb 88th, Wofford 95th, Samford 100th, Elon 105th, Towson 119th, and Western Carolina 122nd (last).
Michigan led FBS in defensive 3rd-down conversion rate, at 21.0%. Clemson ranked 4th, Alabama 8th, Army 46th, South Carolina 95th, Air Force 102nd, Georgia Tech 126th, and Navy 128th.
The Midshipmen managed to lead FBS in offensive 3rd-down conversion rate (54.5%, as mentioned above) while finishing last in defensive 3rd-down conversion rate (53.5%). There were a lot of successful drives in Navy games last season.
The Citadel's defense in 2014 in SoCon action: 8 sacks, 14 passes defensed in 176 pass attempts (8.0% PD)
The Citadel's defense in 2015 in SoCon action: 20 sacks, 33 passes defensed in 212 pass attempts (15.6% PD)
Passes defensed is a statistic that combines pass breakups with interceptions.
Also of interest: the Bulldogs have increased their "hurries" totals in league play from eleven (2014) to seventeen (2015) to twenty-one last season. That helps create a little more havoc.
The Citadel averaged 2.63 sacks per game in conference play. Taking all games into account, the Bulldogs averaged 2.33 sacks per contest, which tied for 36th nationally. Grambling State averaged 3.42 sacks per game to lead FCS.
Chattanooga ranked 12th overall (2.92 sacks per game). Other sack rankings among SoCon teams: Samford (47th), Wofford (48th), Mercer (49th), VMI (tied for 102nd), ETSU (also tied for 102nd), Furman (115th), Western Carolina (122nd and last).
Florida State led FBS teams in sacks per game (3.92). Apparently the ACC Atlantic was a sackfest, because three other teams in that division (Boston College, Clemson, and Wake Forest) finished in the top 11. South Carolina tied for 97th, while East Carolina finished 128th and last in the category.
Big plays! Big plays! Big plays! Big plays!
Just for clarification, I am defining "big plays" as offensive plays from scrimmage resulting in gains of 20+ yards, regardless of whether or not they are rushing or passing plays.
The Citadel's offensive plays from scrimmage resulting in gains of 20 or more yards, 2015: 30 (19 rushing, 11 passing)
In 2015, 20 of the 30 big plays by the Bulldogs' offense in conference play either resulted in touchdowns or led to touchdowns on the same drive. Last season, that was the case for 19 of the 26 long gainers.
That is an average of 3.25 big plays per game in league matchups. For all games, the Bulldogs averaged 3.58 big plays per game (seven such plays against North Greenville helped the average).
Just as a comparison to the offenses of a few other SoCon outfits:
– Wofford averaged 3.36 big plays from scrimmage per game (counting all 14 of its contests)
– Chattanooga averaged 4.62 big plays from scrimmage per game (counting all 13 of its contests)
– Furman averaged 4.27 big plays from scrimmage per game (counting all 11 of its contests)
– Mercer averaged 3.45 big plays from scrimmage per game (counting all 11 of its contests)
– Samford averaged 5.00 big plays from scrimmage per game (counting all 12 of its contests)
Plays from scrimmage of 20 yards or more allowed by The Citadel's defense, 2014: 47 (21 rushing, 26 passing)
Plays from scrimmage of 20 yards or more allowed by The Citadel's defense, 2015: 23 (9 rushing, 14 passing)
In 2015, 14 of the 23 big plays allowed by the Bulldogs either resulted in TDs or led to them on the same drive. Last year, 18 of 28 long gainers given up led directly or indirectly to touchdowns.
I want to reiterate that the last two sections are about offensive plays from scrimmage in league action. Obviously, the defense can produce a "big play" of its own (like Jonathan King's 54-yard sack/strip/fumble return for a TD against VMI), and the same is true for the special teams units (such as DeAndre Schoultz's critical 81-yard punt return for a touchdown versus Gardner-Webb).
The Citadel's offense on 4th down in league play in 2014: 12 for 20 (60.0%)
The Citadel's offense on 4th down in league play in 2015: 3 for 8 (37.5%)
The Citadel's offense on 4th down in league play in 2016: 8 for 16 (50.0%)
The Citadel's defense on 4th down in league play in 2015: 8 for 13 converted against (61.5%)
The Citadel's defense on 4th down in league play in 2016: 5 for 9 converted against (55.6%)
The 4th-down conversion rate for all SoCon teams (counting both conference and non-conference games) in 2016 was 54.5%, so the Bulldogs were basically league average on both sides of the ball. Ideally, The Citadel would be better than average on both offense and defense on 4th-down attempts.
Bumbling rumbling stumbling fumbling…
When evaluating fumble stats, keep in mind that recovering them is usually a 50-50 proposition (which makes perfect sense, if you think about it). There isn't really much to evaluate beyond that, other than if a team is really loose with the football.
The Citadel's offensive fumbles in SoCon action, 2014: 10 (lost 6)
For all games, the Bulldogs fumbled 22 times, losing 10 of those.
Please note that the official statistical record does not include a fumble against Mercer, which the Bulldogs recovered. That was apparently the result of an error by Mercer's stats crew. (Hey, it happens.)
The Citadel's defensive forced fumbles in SoCon action, 2014: 14 (recovered 7)
The Citadel's defensive forced fumbles in SoCon action, 2015: 8 (recovered 7)
The Bulldogs only forced two fumbles in non-conference play, recovering neither.
Penalties enforced against The Citadel in SoCon action, 2014: 37
Well, at least the average number of penalties per game went down last year. However, penalty yardage per game went up over eight yards per contest, which is somewhat worrisome.
Penalties enforced against The Citadel's opponents in SoCon action, 2014: 22
Penalty yardage against the Bulldogs' opponents went up about 4 1/2 yards per game from 2015 to 2016.
Punts by The Citadel while in opposing territory in 2014, SoCon action: 6 (in seven games)
Punts by The Citadel while in opposing territory in 2016, SoCon action: 1 (in eight games)
I almost didn't bother adding this category to my spreadsheet, thanks to Brent Thompson. The coach only ordered one punt in opposing territory last season. That came on the opening drive of the game against Western Carolina, on a 4th-and-3 from the Catamounts' 38-yard line.
In retrospect, it was a curious move, but it more or less worked out. Will Vanvick's punt was downed on the WCU 3-yard line, and Western Carolina proceeded to go 3-and-out.
This year, I also checked to see how many times opponents punted while in Bulldog territory. As it happens, that only happened one time as well.
Late in the first half, Mercer faced a 4th-and-18 from The Citadel's 43-yard line. Bobby Lamb elected to punt, which was eminently sensible. The ball was downed on the Bulldogs' 3-yard line; The Citadel picked up one first down, ran three more plays, and then the half ended.
Let's talk about 4th down…
Defining some terms (courtesy of Football Outsiders):
– Deep Zone: from a team's own goal line to its 20-yard line
– Back Zone: from a team's own 21-yard line to its 39-yard line
– Mid Zone: from a team's own 40-yard line to its opponent's 40-yard line
– Front Zone: from an opponent's 39-yard line to the opponent's 21-yard line
– Red Zone: from an opponent's 20-yard line to the opponent's goal line
Just as I did last season, on the spreadsheet I've categorized every fourth down situation The Citadel's offense had in conference play (see the "4th down decisions" tab).
The Citadel punted all 18 teams it faced 4th down in the Deep Zone or the Back Zone.
In the Mid Zone, the Bulldogs punted 12 times and went for the first down 3 other times, successfully converting twice (the unsuccessful attempt came against Samford).
The Citadel didn't have the mojo working in the Front Zone, at least on 4th down. The Bulldogs went for the first down 10 times in the Mid Zone, but only picked it up 4 times. Admittedly, one of those successful conversions was a key 34-yard TD run versus Wofford.
There were four field goal attempts from that zone, only one of which was made. As noted above, The Citadel also had one punt in this area.
The Bulldogs had five 4th-down situations in the Red Zone. Four times, The Citadel elected to attempt a field goal (all were successful). The other 4th-down play in the Red Zone resulted in a 17-yard TD run for Jonathan Dorogy against VMI.
Over the last three seasons, The Citadel has had 17 4th-down situations in the Red Zone during SoCon regulation play. Dorogy's touchdown run is the only time the Bulldogs picked up a first down.
This season, I also tabulated what the Bulldogs' league opponents did on 4th down against The Citadel.
In the Deep and Back zones, conference opponents punted all 27 times they faced 4th down versus the Bulldogs.
In the Mid Zone, The Citadel's opposition punted 12 times on 4th and went for a first down on five other occasions. All five attempts to keep the drive alive were successful (two of them were by VMI).
Opponents were 5 for 9 on field goal attempts in the Front Zone (two of the four missed were by Furman). Chattanooga went for a first down on 4th down twice, and went 1-for-2. VMI was 0-for-1 trying for a first down from this distance.
In the Red Zone, opponents were 1-2 trying to pick up a first down, and 3 for 4 on field goal tries.
Two seasons ago, The Citadel began what appeared to be a policy of deferring the option to the second half every time it won the coin toss. The Bulldogs won the coin toss 4 times in SoCon play in 2015, and deferred on each occasion.
Last year, The Citadel won the coin toss 6 times in 8 league games, going 3-1 both at home and on the road, a tribute to a consistent skill set. In five of the six games in which the Bulldogs won the toss, they deferred, just as they had done in 2015.
The exception was at Western Carolina, where The Citadel elected to receive after winning the toss. I'm not sure what to make of that.
There are two possibilities: one, that the box score mistakenly credited The Citadel for winning the coin toss when in fact the Catamounts actually won it (and deferred); or, for some specific reason related solely to that game, Brent Thompson decided he wanted the ball first.
I wouldn't mind if someone asked the coach that very question some time. Of course, he may not remember.
As a reminder, this is the first of two statistically-oriented posts I'm making about the previous football season, with an eye to the upcoming campaign. Here is the link to the other one: Link
The season is getting closer. Aren't you glad?
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Army, Brent Thompson, Chattanooga, Clemson, DeAndre Shoultz, East Tennessee State, FCS, Furman, Gardner-Webb, Jonathan Dorogy, Jonathan King, Mercer, Mike Houston, Navy, New Mexico, Newberry, North Carolina, North Greenville, Presbyterian, Samford, SoCon, The Citadel, VMI, Western Carolina, Wofford | Leave a comment »
2016 Football, Game 5: The Citadel vs. North Greenville
The Citadel at North Greenville, to be played to be played at Younts Stadium in Tigerville, South Carolina, with kickoff at 7:00 pm ET on Thursday, October 6. The game will not be televised.
The game will be streamed by the North Greenville Sports Network. Cole Bryson will handle play-by-play, with Brad McGuffin supplying the analysis.
The contest can be heard on radio via the various affiliates of The Citadel Sports Network. WQNT-1450 AM [audio link], originating in Charleston, is the flagship station.
It is also possible to listen to the action with a smartphone, using a TuneIn Radio application.
– Game notes from The Citadel
– Brent Thompson's 10/4 press conference, including comments from Joe Crochet and Reggie Williams
– FCS Coaches' Poll
– A hurricane puts The Citadel on the road
– Local talent fuels North Greenville
I had planned on writing most of this preview on Thursday night, and had blocked off time on my schedule to do so. Alas, Hurricane Matthew had other ideas.
I just hope the team is more prepared to play the game than I was to write about it…
At times on Tuesday, I wasn't sure the game would even happen. It will, though, two days early and in another location, a first-time venue for The Citadel's football program. Repercussions will last for a while:
Ironically, North Greenville was scheduled largely so the Bulldogs would have a fifth home game at Johnson Hagood Stadium this season. With the game now moved to North Greenville's Younts Stadium, The Citadel will have only four regular-season home games.
That loss of revenue, and the added expense of an extra road trip, means The Citadel's budget will take a hit this year.
"We are going to incur additional expenses that were not budgeted for," said [The Citadel's director of athletics, Jim Senter]. "When we get to the end of the year, we hope we can absorb that. This is not like a normal (road) game for one night. Because of the emergency situation, we are going to have additional expenses related to busing, lodging and meals. There will be an additional cost for us."
As for how tickets will be handled:
Tickets purchased for the game will be honored Thursday night at North Greenville. Fans unable to attend will have their ticket honored with an additional ticket in general admission seating at The Citadel's home game against ETSU on Oct. 29 or can donate their ticket to the Junior Bulldog program, which benefits orphanages and foster families in the Lowcountry.
When was the last time The Citadel's football team played a road game against a team that was not in Division I? I'm not entirely sure, but I believe the answer to that question is 1977, when the Bulldogs played at Delaware, which at that time was in Division II. The Citadel also traveled to face the Blue Hens in 1974.
The Citadel played three other road games in the 1970s against teams that are now D-1 but were not at that time: in 1970 against Arkansas State (then in the NCAA's College Division); in 1971 versus Bucknell (also in the NCAA's College Division); and in 1973 against Illinois State (a D-2 school that year).
Prior to 1970, there are several instances of The Citadel playing schools away from home that were not Division I at the time, but which are now. That was even the case in the post-war period.
Some of these matchups were neutral-site affairs, including games at the Orangeburg County Fair against Wofford (the last of which took place in 1959). The Citadel also played Presbyterian in Savannah in 1963.
The last time The Citadel played a road game against a school that was not then and is not now a current D-1 member (other than those institutions that dropped football)? Well, it's possible that there hasn't been such a game.
In researching this topic, I discovered that several games listed in the record book as road contests, notably a series of pre-World War II matchups with Newberry, were actually played at Hampton Park. The exception was a 1921 contest played in Florence (a game that ended in a 7-7 tie).
The record book also lists the 1948 games against Presbyterian and Newberry as having been road games, when in fact both games were played at College Park. That facility was used because the "new" Johnson Hagood Stadium was not ready to open at the beginning of the season. (Incidentally, the cost of the brand-new Johnson Hagood Stadium in 1948? $600,000.)
Thus, if North Greenville never moves up to Division I, this contest will wind up being a decided anomaly.
On October 14, 1891, at the fourth annual meeting of the North Greenville Baptist Association, a momentous decision was made. A committee of nine men was appointed to determine the best location for establishing a high school in the northern region of Greenville County…
…The work of the committee led to the establishment of what is now North Greenville University. Benjamin F. Neves offered ten acres of beautiful rolling land midway between Glassy Mountain to the north and Paris Mountain to the south. By 1892 the first building was completed and ready for occupancy, and North Greenville High School began with the arrival of the first students on January 16, 1893.
The State of South Carolina chartered the institution as North Greenville High School in 1904. The next year the Home Mission Board of the Southern Baptist Convention assumed control of the school as part of its Mountain Mission School System, a relationship that lasted 25 years. In 1929, the North Greenville Baptist Association again accepted responsibility for the school which had been renamed "North Greenville Baptist Academy" in 1915.
North Greenville became a junior college in 1934; it was renamed North Greenville Junior College in 1950 (which was shortened to North Greenville College in 1972). High school courses were discontinued in 1959.
The school began offering baccalaureate degrees in 1992, and attained university status in 2006. North Greenville retains an affiliation with the South Carolina Baptist Convention and the Southern Baptist Convention.
North Greenville fielded its first football team in 1994. It had its first winning season in 1996 (7-3), though consistent gridiron success has been difficult to come by. The program went 0-10 in both 2000 and 2001, but under Mike Taylor finished 10-2 in 2006, its best season by winning percentage to date.
Jamey Chadwell was at NGU for three seasons. In his third year at NGU (2011) he led the team to an 11-3 record, the most wins in school history.
After that season, Chadwell made a somewhat curious move to Delta State for a year before taking over at Charleston Southern in 2013. He was succeeded at North Greenville by Carroll McCray, who helmed the program for one year before leaving for his alma mater, Gardner-Webb. McCray's replacement at NGU was Jeff Farrington.
Jeff Farrington is now in his fourth season as the head coach of North Greenville. He is also a 1982 graduate of The Citadel.
I was a walk-on at The Citadel, a slow, splitback veer quarterback who couldn't throw and didn't have a whole lot of people who wanted me to play football. But The Citadel gave me a chance, and I'm forever grateful. It was a great experience, and I got on the field as a defensive back my last two years.
I was a guy they couldn't run off, and Art Baker and his staff, guys like Cal McCombs, had a really good influence on me. It was a special place and always has been.
Farrington has been an assistant coach at a wide variety of schools, including several in the Southern Conference. He was a graduate assistant at The Citadel for one year, spent five seasons at East Tennessee State, and was on Bobby Lamb's staff for nine years at Furman.
Before taking the head coaching job at North Greenville in 2013, he had been the defensive coordinator at VMI. Farrington has also coached at Florida State, East Carolina, Lenoir-Rhyne, West Georgia, and Presbyterian. He assisted Lamb in starting the football program at Mercer, too.
Farrington's staff has plenty of SoCon connections as well. Defensive coordinator Greg Harris is a VMI graduate. Offensive line coach Nic Cardwell is an Appalachian State alumnus, while defensive backs coach Maurice Duncan played for Furman.
Kicking coach Bob Price is an App State grad who spent 16 years as an assistant coach at Furman. Graduate assistant Jeff Ashley played for Wofford.
North Greenville has been an independent in football for several years (the school competes in Conference Carolinas in its other sports). However, that will change in 2018, when the school becomes an affiliate member (football-only) of the Gulf South Conference.
Members of the Gulf South in football: North Alabama, Valdosta State, West Georgia, West Alabama, Florida Tech, Delta State, West Florida, Mississippi College, and Shorter.
This will only be the second time North Greenville has hosted an FCS school (Charleston Southern made the trip in 2007), but NGU has a lot of experience facing D-1 competition.
One thing that is rather clear when a check of the records is made: North Greenville has been very competitive in most of those matchups.
In fact, the Crusaders have four victories over FCS foes, including a 37-24 win over VMI in 2013, Jeff Farrington's first season in charge of the program. North Greenville has also beaten Presbyterian (in 2010), Jacksonville, and Austin Peay (with both of those victories coming in 2006).
Some of the losses are almost (if not just) as impressive. Wofford outlasted NGU 42-27 in 2014; Charleston Southern won 28-14 in 2013 and 41-31 in 2010; Presbyterian survived 22-15 in 2008. That aforementioned home game against CSU in 2007 resulted in a 46-33 win for the Buccaneers.
North Greenville isn't going to be intimidated by playing an FCS squad. If The Citadel isn't ready to play on Thursday night, the Bulldogs could get embarrassed.
NGU opened the season in front of 3,822 fans with a 24-23 home win over future conference foe West Alabama. The Crusaders were up 10-0, but found themselves behind 23-17 late in the fourth quarter. A touchdown and subsequent PAT with 1:40 remaining gave North Greenville the lead for good.
North Greenville then traveled to Lenoir-Rhyne and crushed the Bears, 45-0. Rochar Witherspoon returned the opening kickoff for a TD, and the Crusaders never let up. Starting quarterback Will Hunter completed 9 of his first 10 passes, and NGU rushed for 179 yards and four touchdowns.
Newberry would hand NGU its first loss of the season, a 29-28 setback in Tigerville before 2,928 spectators. The Crusaders trailed 22-10 before mounting a comeback that saw them take the lead with less than five minutes remaining. However, Newberry proceeded to drive the length of the field and scored the winning touchdown/PAT with just 1:09 to play.
North Greenville fell to 2-2 after a 49-35 loss at UNC-Pembroke. The Crusaders trailed 28-7 at halftime after allowing 251 passing yards in the first two quarters. The Braves kept NGU at bay during the second half, leading by at least 14 points throughout the contest.
On Saturday, the Crusaders hammered Mars Hill at Younts Stadium, 56-21, delighting most of the 2,056 fans in attendance. A blocked punt that was recovered in the end zone for a TD gave NGU plenty of momentum early in the game, as North Greenville scored the game's first 21 points. The Crusaders added a touchdown in the second quarter and three more TDs in the third, rolling up 518 yards of total offense in the process.
Some quick team statistics of note for North Greenville:
NGU Opponents
Total yards rushing 1213 767
Rush attempts 200 180
Rush TDs 16 9
Total yards passing 957 1200
Completion % 54.2 (144 attempts) 63.6 (187 attempts)
Yards/pass attempt 6.6 6.4
Interceptions 1 5
Pass TDs 7 8
Offensive Plays 344 367
Penalties/game 9 9
Pen yds/game 81.6 71.6
TOP/game 28:59:00 31:00:00
3rd-down conversion % 40.00 38.96
Red Zone TD% 13-14 (93%) 13-17 (76%)
Things that jump out when looking at those stats:
Scoring touchdowns on 13 of 14 trips into the red zone is very impressive
NGU passes on 42% of its plays from scrimmage
Passing yardage accounts for 44% of the Crusaders' total offense
North Greenville has only committed four turnovers in five games
NGU has been heavily penalized — and so has its opponents
The difference in rush yards per play from an offensive and defensive perspective is noteworthy
Starting quarterback Will Hunter (6'1″, 190 lbs.) is a redshirt sophomore from Lexington who operates the Crusaders' zone-read offense out of the shotgun.
For the season, Hunter is completing 54.1% of his passes, averaging 6.56 yards per attempt, with six TD tosses against only one interception. Hunter's father Tripp is a graduate of The Citadel (like Jeff Farrington, he is an '82 grad).
NGU has three players who share most of the load in terms of rushing attempts. Ashton Heard (5'9″, 180 lbs.) is a native of Abbeville who rushed for 1,136 yards last season, averaging 5.7 yards per carry.
Simeon Byrd (5'10", 205 lbs.), who went to Spartanburg High School, has 17 career touchdowns. While Heard and Byrd are seniors, Tracy Scott (6'0″, 195 lbs.) is a redshirt freshman from Greenville who currently leads the team in rushing, and is averaging 7.5 yards per carry. Scott started in the Crusaders' most recent game, against Mars Hill.
Twelve different players have receptions for the Crusaders. The three leading receivers are a varied lot in terms of size.
Mason Sanders (6'6″, 230 lbs.) is a junior from Boiling Springs who is tied for the team lead in receptions (19). Sanders, who leads the team with 4 TD catches, is joined in the starting lineup by Javon Smith (5'9″, 170 lbs.) and Demajiay Rooks (5'10", 160 lbs.).
Smith is a junior from Blythewood with 19 catches so far this season, while Rooks is a sophomore from Woodruff with 12 receptions, including a team long of 51 yards. Rooks had a kickoff return for a touchdown last season for the Crusaders, so he's more than capable of making a big play.
Starting tight end Bobby Foos (6'2″, 225 lbs.) doubles as the team's punter. The product of Chesnee High School has a touchdown reception this year for NGU.
The starters on North Greenville's offensive line average 6'4″, 280 lbs. Tackle Casey Stewart (6'2″, 280 lbs.) is a Pickens resident who had 35 "knockdown" blocks last season.
Linebacker Sam Houston (6'1″, 220 lbs.) is an Easley native who is far and away the Crusaders' leader in tackles this season. He is also the career tackles leader for North Greenville.
In a way, it is a shame that he didn't attend Sam Houston State. I really hope his nickname is "Bearkat".
Daulton Pilgrim (6'0″, 190 lbs.) is a junior linebacker who went to Daniel High School. He is second on the team in tackles.
Desmond Williams (6'2″, 255 lbs.) is a redshirt freshman defensive lineman from Piedmont. Williams already has two blocked kicks this year.
Another defensive lineman, Anthony Blair (6'3″, 245 lbs.) is the team's designated sack artist; the junior from Georgetown has 2.5 sacks this year. He had 7.5 sacks in 2014.
Nigel Gay (5'9″, 160 lbs.) is a DB from Newnan, Georgia (not South Carolina!) and has two interceptions so far this season. The senior is also averaging an impressive 8.3 yards per punt return, something to watch on Thursday night.
Earlier, I mentioned that Rochar Witherspoon (5'8″, 160 lbs.) returned a kickoff for a TD against Lenoir-Rhyne. Witherspoon (from Manning) is also a starting defensive back for the Crusaders.
Placekicker Matt Gravely (6'2″, 180 lbs.) is a freshman from Pickens who is 4 for 5 on field goal attempts this season (long of 47 yards). He is 24 for 24 on PATs.
– The weather forecast for Thursday in Tigerville, per the National Weather Service: mostly sunny with a high of 75 degrees. There is a 20% chance of rain on Thursday night, with a low of 62 degrees.
– Per one source that deals in such matters, The Citadel is a 28.5-point favorite over North Greenville, with an over/under of 49.5. However, that line was set before the game was moved to North Greenville.
– Other lines involving SoCon teams: Chattanooga is an 18.5-point favorite over Mercer; Samford is a 7.5-point favorite at Furman; VMI is a 12.5-point favorite versus East Tennessee State; and Wofford is an 8.5-point favorite at Western Carolina.
Gardner-Webb is a 5.5-point favorite over Presbyterian this week in Boiling Springs. North Carolina is a 2-point favorite at home over Virginia Tech.
– Massey Ratings: The Citadel is ranked 9th in FCS. North Greenville is 72nd among Division II squads.
Massey projects The Citadel to have an 98% chance of winning, with a predicted final score of 41-10.
Other FCS rankings in Massey of note: Chattanooga (4th), Samford (18th), Wofford (26th), Mercer (42nd), Furman (60th), Western Carolina (61st), Gardner-Webb (66th), VMI (67th), East Tennessee State (86th).
– North Greenville's roster is overwhelming made up of South Carolina natives (as you may have guessed while reading the section on individual players), with 78 Crusaders hailing from the Palmetto State. Other states represented on NGU's roster: Georgia (9), Florida (3), North Carolina (2), and Ohio (1).
– The Citadel's geographic roster breakdown (per the school's website) is as follows: South Carolina (47 players), Georgia (23), Florida (9), North Carolina (7), Alabama (4), Pennsylvania (4), Texas (4), and one each from Louisiana, Maryland, Kansas, Oklahoma, Nevada, and West Virginia.
– Triple option oddity no more: through three games this season, more Bulldogs had caught passes (eight) than had rushing attempts (seven). However, the number of rushers has finally exceeded the number of pass-catchers, as Evan McField, Grant Drakeford, and Jonathan Dorogy all had rushing attempts on Saturday against Western Carolina.
– North Greenville has had one player make the NFL: Freddie Martino, a wide receiver who has been on practice squads (and occasionally on active rosters) for the Falcons, Eagles, and Buccaneers. He is currently on Tampa Bay's active roster.
– Joseph Randolph II, a freshman from Jefferson, Georgia, is listed on The Citadel's two-deep for this week. It is the first time he has appeared on the Bulldogs' depth chart. Randolph is a 6'3″, 255 lb. defensive tackle.
I am worried about this game, for several reasons. One, North Greenville appears to be a very solid D-2 team, with a lot of quality players who can make a difference on any given night.
Then there is the element of the unknown. How will the Bulldogs react to having to play two days early? How will they perform away from home after anticipating playing a game at Johnson Hagood Stadium?
The Citadel has not played at home since September 10, against Furman. Sure, there was a bye week mixed in between road games, but that's a long wait for a home game. Then not to have it after all — well, that makes it tougher.
I'm not too concerned about the Bulldogs looking ahead to the Chattanooga game. I'm just wondering about the focus for this game in general.
We'll see. Dee Delaney seems to have the right mindset, at any rate.
It would not be surprising if a significant number of Bulldog supporters make an appearance at Younts Stadium on Thursday night. I have a feeling that a lot of light blue and white will be on hand, and that's good.
This game is sort of a mini-bonus for some of The Citadel's fans in the Upstate. Perhaps a few cadets will make it to the game, too.
Let's get to 5-0.
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Anthony Blair, Brent Thompson, Casey Stewart, Evan McField, Grant Drakeford, Gulf South Conference, Hurricane Matthew, Jeff Farrington, Joe Crochet, Jonathan Dorogy, Joseph Randolph II, Newberry, Nigel Gay, North Greenville, Presbyterian, Reggie Williams, Sam Houston, SoCon, The Citadel, Will Hunter | Leave a comment »
A quick look at The Citadel's future football schedules
One of the many curious things about college football is that fans often are just as interested (if not more interested) in what will happen in the future than what is happening right now. I'm talking mostly about recruiting and scheduling, of course.
With this post, I'm going to wildly speculate on potential scheduling options for The Citadel. This is something Jeff Hartsell briefly mentioned Tuesday. The Citadel will play eight Southern Conference games each season. In 2011 and 2012, that means the Bulldogs will play three non-conference games (11-game regular season). In 2013 and 2014, the calendar will allow for a 12-game regular season for FCS schools, meaning The Citadel can play four non-conference games.
Each year one of The Citadel's non-conference games has to be a road "guarantee" game against a BCS opponent, for budgetary reasons. Also returning to the Bulldogs' schedule in 2011 is VMI. The battle for the coveted Silver Shako will resume at Johnson Hagood Stadium, with the teams alternating home-and-home for six years. It is my understanding that those years are consecutive, although I haven't been able to confirm that yet.
Another non-conference game each season will take place against a non-conference opponent that won't demand a return trip — in other words, teams like Chowan and Webber International (or more preferably, Presbyterian and Newberry). I'll call this game the Designated Home Opener, or DHO.
The 2011 non-conference schedule will feature VMI (home), South Carolina (away), and a DHO to be determined (home).
The 2012 non-conference schedule will feature VMI (away), North Carolina State (away), and a DHO to be determined (home). In that season, the Bulldogs will only play five games at Johnson Hagood Stadium.
Starting in 2013, things get a little interesting. Again, assuming the VMI series is for six consecutive years (assumptions always being dangerous), The Citadel's non-league slate would feature VMI (home), Clemson (away), a DHO (home), and another team to be determined.
The 2014 season would include a road game against VMI, a DHO, and two games to be determined (with one of them definitely having to be a guarantee game).
That leaves Larry Leckonby with important decisions to make about scheduling in 2013 and 2014. Do you add a second BCS guarantee game in those seasons? Or do you add a second DHO-type team?
There is another possibility, one that would be very popular with alumni, and that is to schedule a game against Army or Navy (or Air Force, I suppose, although I don't think there is nearly as much interest in that potential matchup).
A quick scan at future schedules for Army and Navy shows that there is a spot possibly available for an FCS opponent in 2013 for Army and 2014 for Navy (in 2014, Army has scheduled Fordham, which would have been a tough ticket seven decades ago; Navy is playing Delaware in 2013). Of course, there is a chance that none of the academies would be interested in playing The Citadel anyway.
Scheduling a service academy or a second BCS school would be more problematic in 2014, as the VMI game would be played on the road that year. I don't know that Leckonby wants to put the team in position to play only five home games and seven road contests, with two of those being against FBS opponents (and that's assuming he can find two FBS opponents).
One of the things that will be a factor is attendance at Johnson Hagood Stadium. If The Citadel continues to have disappointing numbers at the gate, Leckonby may be more likely to eschew a possible sixth (or seventh) home game to grab a more lucrative road guarantee.
Another possibility would be a series like the one The Citadel had with Princeton, a two-game home-and-home (in 2013-2014) against an FCS school from outside the SoCon. That seems a less likely option to me, but you never know.
We'll see what happens. All of the above is mostly uninformed guesswork by yours truly, of course, and should be taken with a grain of salt, assuming that it even deserves the grain.
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Air Force, Army, BCS, Chowan, Clemson, Delaware, FBS, FCS, football scheduling, Fordham, Jeff Hartsell, Johnson Hagood Stadium, Larry Leckonby, Navy, Newberry, North Carolina State, Presbyterian, Princeton, Silver Shako, South Carolina, Southern Conference, The Citadel, VMI, Webber International | Leave a comment »
Southern Conference tourney time
Posted on March 4, 2010 by Sandlapper Spike
Last year, I wrote about The Citadel's abysmal record in the Southern Conference tournament. The next few paragraphs are an updated version of that piece. Feel free to ignore them if you have a weak stomach. The preview for this year's tournament (from The Citadel's perspective) follows the history lesson.
One of the more curious things about The Citadel's wretched history in the SoCon tourney is that there is no firm answer to just how many times the school has lost in the event. That's because the league has mutated so many times there is a dispute as to what year the first "official" conference tournament was held.
Before 1920, The Citadel was one of many schools in a rather loose confederation known as the Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Association. (The Citadel initially joined in 1909.) There were about 30 colleges in the SIAA by 1920, including almost every member of the current SEC and about half of the current ACC, along with schools such as Centre, Sewanee (later a member of the SEC — seriously!), Chattanooga, Wofford, Howard (now called Samford, of course), and Millsaps, just to name a few. As you might imagine, the large and disparate membership had some disagreements, and was just plain hard to manage, so a number of the schools left to form the Southern Conference in late 1920.
In the spring of 1921, the SIAA sponsored a basketball tournament, which would be the forerunner to all the conference hoops tourneys to follow. Any southern college or university could travel to Atlanta to play, and fifteen schools did just that. Kentucky beat Georgia in the final. The Citadel did not enter the event, but several other small colleges did, including Newberry (for those unfamiliar with Newberry, it's a tiny school located in central South Carolina). The tournament featured teams from the new Southern Conference, the old SIAA, and squads like Newberry, which wasn't in either league (it would join the SIAA in 1923).
In 1922 the SIAA held another tournament in Atlanta, this one won by North Carolina, which beat Mercer in the final. The Citadel entered this time, losing in the first round to Vanderbilt. The SIAA tournament remained all-comers until 1924, when it was restricted to Southern Conference members.
Some sources suggest that the 1921 tournament is the first "official" Southern Conference tournament, some go with the 1922 event, and others argue for 1924. From what I can tell, the league itself is a bit wishy-washy on the issue. On the conference website, it states:
The first Southern Conference Championship was the league basketball tournament held in Atlanta in 1922. The North Carolina Tar Heels won the tournament to become the first recognized league champion in any sport. The Southern Conference Tournament remains the oldest of its kind in college basketball.
That's great, but the conference's own record book lists Kentucky as having won the first tournament title in 1921 (on page 113; oddly, that year is excluded from the game-by-game tournament results that begin on page 114). Of course, the edition of the record book on the conference website is several years old and lists The Citadel as having once lost 37 straight games, which is incorrect, so take it for what you will.
Personally, I think that the idea of having a conference tournament is to determine a league champion, and it stands to reason that such a tournament would only include league members. So the first "real" Southern Conference tournament, in my opinion, was held in 1924.
There is a point to this, trust me. The difference between counting the Vanderbilt loss as a SoCon tourney loss and not counting it is the difference between The Citadel's alltime record in the event being 10-56 or 10-57. Not that they both aren't hideous totals, but as of now The Citadel shares the NCAA record for "most consecutive conference tournament appearances without a title" with Clemson, which is 0-for-56 in trying to win the ACC tournament. Counting the Vanderbilt game would mean The Citadel is alone in its conference tourney infamy. No offense to the Tigers, but I don't believe the 1922 game should count, because it wasn't really a Southern Conference tournament game.
By the way, you read that right. The Citadel is 10-56 alltime in the SoCon tournament. That's just unbelievably bad. It comes out to a 15% winning percentage, which is more than twice as bad as even The Citadel's lousy alltime conference regular season winning percentage (35%). The Citadel lost 17 straight tourney games from 1961-78, and then from 1985-97 lost 13 more in a row.
Tangent: The single-game scoring record in the tournament is held by Marshall's Skip Henderson, who put up 55 on The Citadel in 1988 in a game Marshall won by 43 points. The next night the Thundering Herd, which had won the regular season title that year, lost to UT-Chattanooga by one point. Karma.
Those long losing streaks didn't occur in consecutive years, as The Citadel didn't always qualify for the tournament, particularly in the years before 1953, when there were up to 17 teams in the league at any given time, and only the top squads played in the tourney. The Citadel's first "real" appearance, in 1938, resulted in a 42-38 loss to Maryland.
The Citadel would lose two more tourney openers before winning its first game in 1943, against South Carolina. That would be the only time the Bulldogs and Gamecocks faced each other in the tournament, and so South Carolina is one of two teams The Citadel has a winning record against in SoCon tourney play (the Bulldogs are 2-0 against VMI).
The next time The Citadel would win a game in the tournament? 1959, when the Bulldogs actually won two games, against Furman and George Washington, and found themselves in the tourney final. Unfortunately, the opponent in the title game was West Virginia, led by Jerry West. West scored 27 points and the Mountaineers pulled away late for an 85-66 victory. This would be the only time The Citadel ever made the championship game; it's also the only time the Bulldogs won two games in the tournament.
After a 1961 quarterfinal victory over Richmond, The Citadel would not win another tournament game until 1979, when the Bulldogs defeated Davidson before losing to Furman. The game against Davidson was played at McAlister Field House and was the final victory of a 20-win campaign, the school's first.
The Citadel would win single games in 1982 and 1985 before going winless until 1998, when it finally broke a 13-game tourney losing streak by beating VMI. The Keydets would be the next victim as well, in 2002, and were apparently so embarrassed they left the league. The Citadel's latest win in conference tournament action came in 2006 against Furman.
Twenty-one different schools have defeated The Citadel in tournament play, with Davidson's eight victories leading the way (against one loss to the Bulldogs). East Tennessee State went 6-0 against The Citadel while in the league.
Ed Conroy is 0-3 in the SoCon tourney as head coach of The Citadel (he was also 0-4 as a player). If The Citadel were to win its conference tournament opener against Samford, and then lose the next day to Appalachian State, Conroy's record would improve to 1-4. That would be the second-highest winning percentage in the tournament for a Bulldog coach since the days of Norm Sloan.
Sloan was 2-4 in the tourney; his successor, Mel Thompson, won his first tournament game as head coach. He would never win another, finishing with a record of 1-6. Dick Campbell was 0-4. George Hill was 0-3. Les Robinson was 3-10 (a record which by winning percentage leads all of the post-Sloan coaches). Randy Nesbit was 0-7. Pat Dennis was 3-14.
(By the way, the best record for a Bulldog coach in SoCon tourney play is that of Bo Sherman, who went 1-1 in 1943, his lone season in charge. Sherman's Bulldogs defeated South Carolina before losing to Duke.)
The Citadel's record against current SoCon teams in the tournament: Furman 2-5, UT-Chattanooga 0-1, Elon 0-1, Samford 0-1, College of Charleston 0-1, Georgia Southern 0-2, Western Carolina 1-1, Appalachian State 1-6, Davidson 1-8. (The Citadel has never played Wofford or UNC-Greensboro in the tournament.)
Last season The Citadel was flying high, having won 20 games for only the second time ever, and had high hopes entering the tournament. Those hopes came crashing down against Samford, a team The Citadel had defeated by 25 points during the regular season. Samford's patient, Princeton-style offense scored 76 points on only 55 possessions, as the Birmingham Bulldogs got off to a great start and never really let The Citadel into the game. It was a very disappointing finish to an otherwise outstanding season.
This season The Citadel appeared on the verge of making a nice run into the SoCon tourney, having reeled off five straight victories, and needing just one more to clinch a winning season, both overall and in league play. It didn't happen, though, as the Bulldogs lost their last three games. The loss at Furman, in particular, was very poor. The Citadel is now 15-15 for this year's campaign, and would have to win at least two games in the tourney to garner its first back-to-back winning campaigns since 1980.
Instead of a bye into the quarterfinals, The Citadel finds itself playing in the first round on Friday, finishing as the 4th seed in the South division. Friday's opponent, Samford, struggled to an 11-19 record (5-13 SoCon) and is the 5th seed from the North division. The winner will play Appalachian State, which finished first in the North, on Saturday night.
The two teams met twice during the regular season, with The Citadel winning both games. The first game, played in Birmingham on January 16, was the definition of slow tempo, with The Citadel's patient motion offense (61.4 possessions per game, 8th slowest nationally) outlasting Samford's Princeton-style attack (58.1 possessions per game, slowest in the country).
The cadets had but 51 possessions in the contest, and made just enough of them count to prevail 51-50. Cameron Wells had 19 points, while Austin Dahn had 17 (making 4 three-pointers). For Samford, Bryan Friday and Andy King combined for 28 points. The Citadel's edge on the boards (26-20) proved critical.
In the rematch in Charleston, Samford led by 10 points with less than 10 minutes to play but was unable to hold on, thanks to a fine outside shooting performance in the second half by The Citadel. Freshman Ben Cherry had his best game of the season with 3 three-pointers, including two big shots late in the game.
Austin Dahn, who had made 4 three-pointers in the first meeting, hit four more in the second game to finish with 15 points and offset a poor shooting night for Wells (2-10 FG). Harrison DuPont added 13 points and 7 rebounds, good enough to survive an excellent game by Samford's Josh Davis (24 points on only 11 FG attempts). The Citadel had 54 possessions in that game.
For The Citadel, the key to beating Samford for a third time this season is confidence. Last year in the tournament game, Samford ran out to an early lead. I think The Citadel's players got a little nervous, especially because trying to play from behind against a team as patient as Samford can be very frustrating (just like it can be for teams playing The Citadel). The fact that the game was an elimination game in tournament play just exacerbated the tension.
It cannot help that The Citadel has no history of success in the SoCon tourney on which to build. That is why I think it is important for the Bulldogs to win this game. Even if The Citadel does not go on to win the tournament (winning four games in four days is extremely unlikely), enjoying just a taste of victory in the tourney may go a long way next season, when The Citadel figures to field a squad capable of contending for the SoCon title. This current crop of players needs to know it can win games in the tournament.
One thing working in The Citadel's favor is that while it has lost three straight games, so has Samford. Also, while Cameron Wells did not shoot well in the latter part of the season, he was 10-16 from the field in the season finale against Wofford. That bodes well for the Bulldogs, which will need point production from Wells in the tournament.
The Citadel needs to start well, maintain its confidence, and not spend the whole night in "here we go again" mode.
If the Bulldogs advance, the next opponent would be Appalachian State, a team The Citadel defeated 62-58 in Boone early in the season. Appy star Donald Sims scored 22 points, but got no help from his teammates, none of whom scored more than 7 points, while Wells had 21 and Dahn 14 for the Bulldogs. Since then, the Mountaineers have fashioned an excellent season, and if not for the draw would be my pick to win the league tournament.
Wofford won the regular season and has the best draw, and I suppose should be the favorite, but for some reason I'm not quite convinced the Terriers have what it takes to win three straight games in three days.
It should be an interesting four days in Charlotte. It would be nice if The Citadel added to the interest.
Filed under: Basketball, The Citadel | Tagged: ACC, Andy King, Appalachian State, Austin Dahn, Ben Cherry, Bryan Friday, Cameron Wells, Clemson, Davidson, Dick Campbell, Donald Sims, Ed Conroy, Furman, George Hill, George Washington, Kentucky, Les Robinson, Maryland, Mel Thompson, Newberry, Norm Sloan, North Carolina, Pat Dennis, Randy Nesbit, Samford, SEC, SIAA, South Carolina, Southern Conference, Southern Conference Tournament, The Citadel, UNC-Greensboro, UT-Chattanooga, VMI, West Virginia, Wofford | Leave a comment »
Football, Game 3: The Citadel vs. Presbyterian
This week's game is something of a blast from the past, at least for older alums and supporters of The Citadel. Fans under the age of 35 may not realize the lengthy series history between the football programs of The Citadel and PC, though.
Saturday's game will be the 61st meeting between the two schools, with The Citadel having won 48 of those previous 60 games (with one tie). The series was played annually from 1921 to 1960, except for the three years during World War II when The Citadel did not field a team.
After the 1963 game (which was played in Savannah), there was a break in the series that lasted until 1971. From that year through 1988 Presbyterian and The Citadel would meet 16 more times (not playing in 1972 and 1976). Since the 1988 season, however, there has been only one more encounter, a 33-10 victory for the Bulldogs in 1991.
PC has not hosted The Citadel in football since 1950. Since then, every game has been played at Johnson Hagood Stadium (except for that 1963 game). The matchups during the 1950s were frequently either Homecoming or Parents' Day games. In contrast, the games played in the 1970s and 1980s usually served as the home openers for the Bulldogs.
Speaking of those games during the 1950s, a while back when I was doing some research for a post about The Citadel's football uniform history, I came across a series of photos taken by Life Magazine that included action and crowd shots from the 1955 Homecoming game at Johnson Hagood between The Citadel and Presbyterian, won by the Bulldogs 14-13. I posted links to some of the photos in that piece, but I'll repost a few here for anyone interested:
Picture 1 (Mark Clark in the stands watching the game)
Picture 2 (the team runs out onto the field in what may have been a photo op and not a "real" run-out)
Picture 3 (same as Picture 2; I think the third coach from the left is Al Davis)
Picture 4 (same as Pictures 2 and 3)
Picture 5 (shot of John Sauer during the game; the coach appears to be a bit anxious, despite the snazzy bow tie)
Picture 6 (PC players are wearing the white jerseys)
Picture 7 (The Citadel has the ball, deep in its own territory)
Picture 8 (I love the scoreboard in this picture)
The Citadel is 26-3 at Johnson Hagood Stadium against Presbyterian, including the first victory for the Bulldogs at JHS, which came in 1949. Despite the lopsided nature of the series in terms of wins and losses, many of the games have been close. Particularly in the 1970s and early 1980s, the Blue Hose (one of my favorite college nicknames) would make things tough for the Bulldogs.
Under the direction of longtime coach/AD Cally Gault, PC defeated The Citadel in 1971 and 1979 and lost several other tight contests, which included final scores such as 6-0, 13-7, 21-14, 21-16, 14-7, and 15-13. Back then it seemed every year for The Citadel started off with a narrow home victory over Presbyterian.
It was, at least to me, a rather congenial rivalry. I remember going to games at Johnson Hagood as a kid and hearing the occasional "Hose 'em!" chant from a boisterous-but-not-particularly-serious PC supporter (often a stray student who had made his way down from Clinton for the game). The games were generally competitive, if not always of the highest quality.
My personal favorite matchup in the series is the 6-0 Bulldog victory in 1974. In that game The Citadel scored the game's only points in the 3rd quarter, after PC fumbled deep in its own territory. The extra-point attempt following the touchdown nearly decapitated one of the officials standing beneath the goalposts. I believe Brian Ruff had approximately 500 tackles in the contest.
The series ended as Presbyterian began its transition from an NAIA school to an NCAA Division II program. Now, of course, PC has moved up into the ranks of the FCS (I-AA), joining the Big South in the process. It's a good move for the school and that league.
What it may also mean is that there could be more opportunities in the future for The Citadel and Presbyterian to meet in football. One of the disadvantages of The Citadel playing a non-Division I school in football is that if the Bulldogs have hopes of making the FCS playoffs, a win over a non-D1 doesn't count as far as playoff eligibility is concerned. A team angling for an at-large berth has to win at least 7 games against Division I opponents (either FCS or FBS).
I think this puts PC on the list of schools that The Citadel can play in its "non-return home game". In other words, because the Bulldogs will play a "money" game against an FBS squad each season, a matching contest is needed against a school willing to forgo a home-and-home series.
Presbyterian and Charleston Southern both strike me as candidates to feature in that spot on a semi-regular basis (with Newberry's Division II status being an impediment to scheduling that school). Essentially the yearly schedule would be eight Southern Conference games, one game against an FBS school (always on the road), one game against the likes of PC or CSU (always at home), and VMI (with that series resuming in 2011).
Presbyterian's game against The Citadel will be the fourth and final game the Blue Hose will play against a Southern Conference opponent this season. PC's remaining seven games will include six Big South league matchups and a contest against first-year football program Old Dominion.
In its first three games PC has only led once, against UT-Chattanooga. Presbyterian has been outscored by more than 24 points per game and has been dominated statistically across the board, including allowing opponents over 5 yards per rush attempt, part of the reason why opponents are converting 3rd downs against PC at a 60% clip.
Presbyterian averages a relatively meager 5.7 yards per pass attempt, with a completion percentage of only 52.5%. The Blue Hose are averaging just 2.5 yards per rush. PC was more competitive in its last outing, when it led UTC briefly in the second quarter before the Mocs gradually pulled away. In the other two games, Furman pummeled the Blue Hose (Paladin QB Jordan Sorrells was 24-30 passing), while Elon simply routed PC, running 90 plays to Presbyterian's 46 and controlling the ball for over 38 minutes.
Basically, this is a game The Citadel should win fairly easily. That doesn't mean it's a lock, though. PC obviously isn't going to be intimidated playing yet another game against a SoCon opponent, and may have some confidence after not getting blown out by UT-Chattanooga.
It isn't a game the Bulldogs are likely to overlook, however. Sure, the "real season" begins next week with the start of the conference campaign, but this is the home opener, and an opportunity to establish a tone for the games to come. Things I want to see on Saturday night include:
The offensive line controlling the line of scrimmage (PC is giving up 5+ yards per rush — enough said)
Receivers catching the ball (the number of dropped passes against Princeton was alarming)
Sacks by The Citadel's defensive front seven (no sacks against Princeton)
Turnovers created by the Bulldog defense (especially in the first half)
A big play by Andre Roberts (it's time for one, at least if his ankle is okay)
I'm looking forward to watching a game at Johnson Hagood again. I'll be interested to see what the attendance is like. With South Carolina playing earlier in the week on Thursday night, and an instate school as the opponent, along with it being the home opener, there is a chance for a nice crowd. Of course, figuring out potential attendance is more complicated than that, as I wrote about earlier this summer.
I was glad to see Presbyterian on the schedule when it was released a few months ago. I hope I will still be glad to have seen PC on the schedule after Saturday night.
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Al Davis, Big South, Blue Hose, Brian Ruff, Bulldogs, Charleston Southern, Elon, Furman, John Sauer, Johnson Hagood Stadium, Life Magazine, Mark Clark, Newberry, Old Dominion, PC, Presbyterian, South Carolina, Southern Conference, The Citadel, UT-Chattanooga, VMI | 2 Comments »