Just a few weeks after Suzanne's visit to her brother and his new wife, their neighbor, Craig Stephen Hicks, murdered them, as well as Yusor's sister, Razan, who was visiting for the afternoon, in their apartment, execution style, after posting anti-Muslim statements on his Facebook page.
Hanya beberapa hari setelah kunjungan Suzanne ke adik dan istrinya, tetangga mereka, Craig Stephen Hicks, membunuh mereka, dan juga adik Yusor, Razan, yang sedang berkunjung siang itu, di apartemen mereka, seperti mengeksekusi mereka, setelah memposting pernyataan anti-Muslim di halaman Facebooknya.