Phillips argument for free will is weak and horrible. The ability to respond to reason and circumstance is still a deterministic process of the brain. Your capacity to “reason” or contemplate is millions of years of bio/neuro/physiological evolution that “you” have no ownership of control of!!! Hell, the brain isn’t freely choosing to be a brain (it’s the outcome of an extremely interconnected and complex process that isn’t freely choosing to generate the subjective experiences you feel/think/see on a daily basis!!!).<br>Free will has nothing to do with determinism or indeterminacy….any capacity of “ultimate free will” would have to offer evidence of a “centralized”, “localized”, individualistic unit of control, that exercises some form of control over all deterministic or indeterministic bio/environmental processes!!