You would have a point if the Xbox controller wasn't entirely based on the Dualshock design, only with the left stick in the wrong place.  Remember, the original Xbox controller had more in common with the saturn 3D pad with a 2nd analog, until they gave up and adopted the by then industry leading Dualshock button layout of "4 face buttons and 4 shoulder button", with the controller's main body consisting of a narrow bridge between two handles. Microsoft has been making a Dualshock knockoffs (with the left analog in the wrong place) for 15 years, I can't see how Sony making the handles a little pointy and putting some meat in between the analog sticks somehow makes this an xbox controller. Meanwhile, Xbox still won't have gyro, touch, haptic feedback and fancy pants triggers.