I know this is late, but the beauty of RDR2 is that there is a wide gulf between playing this game as a white hat do gooder and playing as a psychopath. My first play through, I finished Chapter 6 with max honor and over $6,000 cash...and I had played a pretty much as a Butch Cassidy type outlaw. My next go around, I'm going to be more a Kid Curry (look him up) outlaw...and I bet I still finish with high-ish honor.