He is making sweeping metaphysical presumptions here that, for someone so intelligent, is frustrating to listen to. He presume the universe has no emotion or possible meaning. Why would he say that? Look at all the meaning and emotion it has crystallized in us alone.<br>No fundamental answer.... so dogmatic.,(reply>), Demonstrate the evidence for the meaning of the universe. I don't see any, except constant struggle for low entropy and fending off extinction.,(reply>), To claim the universe has emotion and meaning is an anthropomorphization of reality.