Trump Vows to Win 5G Race 
The president's 5G plan favors a rollout led by the private sector instead of an effective nationalization of next-generation wireless
WHITE HOUSE — In the race to beat China in the fifth generation of wireless technology, known as 5G, U.S. President Donald Trump is announcing the largest-ever auction of radio frequencies and a $20 billion fund to build a rural fiber-optics backbone. "We cannot allow any other country to outcompete the United States in this powerful industry of the future," Trump said in the White House Roosevelt Room, flanked by a group of telecommunications tower climbers and farmers. "The race to 5G is a race that we must win." Starting Dec. 10, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) will begin auctioning three chunks of millimeter-wave frequencies (upper 37 GHz, 39 GHz and 47 GHz) for cellphone companies to use. Some Trump allies had tried to persuade him to effectively nationalize this technology as a matter of national security. Trump acknowledged that he considered such a plan — opposed by the FCC and others — but ultimately backed away from it. "We don't want to do that. It wouldn't be nearly as good, nearly as fast," Trump said. "The idea of state-designed and -operated 5G networks in the U.S. makes no sense on its own terms. A competitive, lightly regulated market is the hallmark of the U.S. system. This has delivered success in 4G and will encourage investment and innovation in 5G," London-based Gabriel Brown, a principal analyst at telecommunications research firm Heavy Reading, told VOA. "It also makes no sense in relation to competition with China — these are different markets in different phases of development." Riley Walters, a policy analyst at the Heritage Foundation's Asian Studies Center, agreed, saying the "private sector is the most efficient way to distribute 5G capabilities, even if it's not at the pace nationalization proponents would like to see. Deregulation should help cut the costs for domestic developers to move up their time horizon." 5G — with speeds 100 times faster than the current 4G mobile internet — will allow the emergence of everything from so-called smart cities and farms to self-driving cars. "We want Americans to be the first to benefit from this new digital revolution while protecting our innovators and our citizens," said FCC Chairman Ajit Pai. "We don't want rural Americans to be left behind." The $20.7 million Rural Digital Opportunity Fund, to come from existing FCC subsidy coffers, is intended to connect up to 4 million American homes over the next decade. The expensive fiber rollout is seen as essential for carrying wireless network communications back to internet hubs. "Intervention at this level will encourage private investment and accelerate coverage in these hard-to-reach areas — the economic and social benefits of rural coverage make it worth intervening to help make the market work," Brown said. "Creating a national fund to support these innovators is a great idea," said Prakash Sangam, the founder of Tantra Analyst, which is involved in marketing and business development of wireless technology. "I also suggest that the U.S. government intervene and facilitate the resolution of conflicts between American technology companies so that they collaborate and effectively compete against the companies sponsored by foreign governments." One challenge is the lack of U.S. manufacturers of 5G network equipment, an arena where China's Huawei and ZTE are set to dominate. Trump's 5G goals are in conflict with the Federal Trade Commission's stance on Qualcomm, the world's largest chipmaker. The FTC has sued the American company over anti-competitive pricing, according to technology analyst Patrick Moorhead, president and principal analyst at Moor Insights & Strategy. "Qualcomm is the country's only hope for 5G and 6G leadership and with the FTC about to potentially hobble it, the U.S. will never be a leader, China will," predicted Moorhead, a former industry executive. A State Department senior official on Wednesday said the security concerns about Huawei and ZTE extend to all companies headquartered in China, contending they are effectively "under direction" of the Chinese Communist Party. "It's very important to distinguish how Western democracies operate relative to their private sector companies and vendors, and how the Chinese government operates with its companies," said Ambassador Robert Strayer, deputy assistant secretary for cyber and international communications and information policy. Strayer and other officials have warned that Huawei and ZTE could give China's intelligence services secret access to sensitive communications networks and the ability to send commands to disrupt communications. Trump did not mention the Chinese companies in his remarks Friday, but he said America's 5G networks will "have to be guarded from the enemy." Riley, at the Heritage Foundation, told VOA that the United States "can still limit the proliferation of imports that have a security concern, but it will be hard for U.S. companies to compete in price in external markets." South Korea last week switched on its nationwide 5G network. South Korea-based Samsung is offering itself as a global alternative to Chinese equipment manufacturers, but it still lags Huawei and ZTE, as well as Sweden's Ericsson and Finland's Nokia. Wireless companies operating in the United States, including AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile and Verizon, are deploying 5G this year, but widespread service for the majority of Americans could still be a decade away. The radio spectrum coming up for auction will have very limited range, meaning small cell antennas will have to be mounted on about every fourth utility pole along streets, making 5G practical only in central business districts and other congested locations, such as stadiums, convention centers and shopping malls. Lower frequencies, which are being licensed for 5G in several other countries, would need fewer cell sites, but that spectrum in the United States is held by satellite operators who are reluctant to give it up. "There are proposals to free some of it for fixed wireless, and the mobile industry wants it for 5G," Brown said. Steve Herman is VOA's White House Bureau Chief.