re jews shoot muslim infants in article may midway uchicago edu clmn midway uchicago edu writes in article c iq mcd bony bony com jake bony bony com jake livni writes palestine was a name given to that same area after the jews already had their own governments there for a very long time palestinean nationality is a recent political invention no more than a few decades old this is what the jew jake says to that this may be true but i think we jews dismiss palestinian nationalism at our peril its newness doesn t obviate its reality besides israeli nationalism is a new phenomenum as well israeli nationalism also known as zionism is the nationalism of the jewish people the jewish people are not a new phenomenon at all palestinean nationalism is the nationalism of arab people arabs have been around for a long time they already have some dozen states large and small covering of the middle east more specifically palestinean nationalism is the nationalism of arabs from the region of palestine just as egyptian nationalism is the nationalism of arabs from the region of egypt one palestinean state already exists in what was once known as palestine it is called jordan there is no justification in carving out a second and tiny palestinean state out of the only jewish state itself very very small just as there is no justification in carving out another american state out of mexico jake livni jake bony bony com ten years from now george bush will american occupied new york have replaced jimmy carter as the my opinions only employer has no opinions standard of a failed president
