brendan mckay clarifies the nazi racial theory only brendan mckay or maybe arf would come to the rescue of nazi racial theory is it distressing brendan the point is that any eugenic solution to the jewish problem as elias has proposed smacks of pure nazism the fact that elias proposal cast the entire problem as one of the abnormal presence of israeli society in the middle east and that he buried a slam against u s aid to israel in the midst of his even handed solution of the jewish question made it obvious what he had in mind disolving the jewish polity that is a nazi doctrine rectification of the abnormal presence of the jewish people within a larger body politic whether your solution involves gas monetary incentives to the poor jews to marry out or as feisal husseini has said disolve the zionist entity by forcing it to engage the normal surrounding arab culture you are engaged in a nazi project just as obvious is your statement i will not comment on the value or lack of value of elias s proposal still striking the glancing blow right brendan you could easily see where he was going but you will not comment so you are complicitous what is your fascination with nazi racial theory anyway chris metcalfe someone else in article apr cs rit edu bdm cs rit edu brendan d mckay writes a unconventional proposal for peace in the middle east by elias davidsson the emergence of a considerable number of mixed marriages in israel palestine all of whom would have relatives on both sides of the divide would make the conflict lose its ethnical and unsoluble core and strengthen the emergence of a truly civil society the existence of a strong mixed stock of people would also help the integration of israeli society into the sounds just like a racial theory that hitler outlined in mein kampf someone else said something similar i will not comment on the value or lack of value of elias s proposal i just want to say that it is very distressing that at least two people here are profoundly ignorant of nazi racial doctrine they were not like elias s idea they were more like the opposite nazis believed in racial purity not racial assimilation an instructive example is the nazi attitude to gypsies according to nazi theoreticians gypsies were an aryan race they were persecuted and in huge numbers murdered because most european gypies were considered not pure gypsies but mongrels formed from the pure gypsy race and other undesirable races this was the key difference between the theoretical approach to jews and gypsies by the way it is also true that towards the end of wwii even the purist gypsies were hunted down as the theory was forgotten brendan email bdm cs anu edu au
