Discussion of everything related to the Theory of Evolution. I
think those ancient reasonable membranoids in Venus would create
a special way of photosynthesis. They would have done such a
super-heat-resistant catalytic process in which energy of
absorbed photon was spent on a separation of CO2 - C + O2.
Moreover, both components would be stocked in separate granules
and vacuoles! And this technological structure would require the
presence of special membrane rhizoids, which would look in the
substrate compounds containing hydrogen - for exothermic
synthesis of water! Energy would be allocated, by the way, can
also be used for CO2 - C + O2! The BBC love this type of
headline grabber and treats reports such as this as fact. The
Nature article concludes with this acknowledgement by the
authors. Willbold, M., T. Elliott, et al. (2011). "The tungsten
isotopic composition of the Earth/'s mantle before the terminal
bombardment." Nature 477(7363): 195-198. Btw these researchers
are basing their ideas on Accretion Th