Manning was inducted into the Tennessee Athletics Hall of Fame in 2016.[66] He was also named the 2016 Tennessean of the Year by the Tennessee Sports Hall of Fame.[67] Manning was elected to the College Football Hall of Fame in 2017, his first year of eligibility for the honor, and was inducted during a ceremony in December.[68][69] He joined his father Archie in the Hall of Fame, making them the first father and son duo to both be inducted as players.[70]