Neblett toured England with the West Indies in 1928 under the captaincy of R.K. Nunes, the first official West Indian tour of England, but played in only eight of the first-class matches, none of which were in the three-match Test series. Against Cambridge University Cricket Club in a match played at Fenner's, he surpassed his previous top score of 59 when scoring 61 in West Indies' first innings. But on no other occasion in his career did he go past fifty runs in an innings.