According to Rogue Leaders: The Story of LucasArts, Fate of Atlantis was "a commercial hit."[51] Noah Falstein reported that it was LucasArts' all-time most successful adventure title by 2009, at which point its lifetime sales had surpassed 1 million units. He recalled that the game's player audience was 30% female, a higher figure than most LucasArts titles had achieved before its release.[52]