They also carried a brightly colored Piñata donkey with them to the ring, which they referred to as "Penelope".[97] Their first match as a full trio took place on January 23, 2018 episode of 205 Live, as they defeated Ariya Daivari, TJP, and Tony Nese.[98] At the Royal Rumble, Lucha House Party defeated TJP, Drew Gulak, and Gentleman Jack Gallagher.[99] In early 2018, WWE held a tournament for the vacant WWE Cruiserweight Championship, where Metalik was eliminated in the opening round by eventual tournament winner Cedric Alexander.[100]