The reason was said to be Hutton's difficulties against Lindwall's short-pitched bowling.[57] Observers noticed Hutton backing away, and the English selectors believed such a sight would have a negative effect on the rest of the side as it was a poor example from a key player.[58][59] The Australians were pleased and believed the England selectors had erred, because they regarded Hutton as the hosts' best batsman.[57] England batted first and Lindwall removed Hutton's replacement as opener, George Emmett, who fended a short ball to Sid Barnes at short leg to leave England at 2/28.