1st Brigade — Col. Rutherford B. Hayes 23rd Ohio Infantry — Lt. Col. James M. Comly 36th Ohio Infantry — Col. Hiram F. Devol Detachment, 34th Ohio Infantry — (attached to 36th Ohio) 5th West Virginia Cavalry (Dismounted) — Colonel Abais A. Tomlinson 6th West Virginia Cavalry (Dismounted) 2nd Brigade — Col. Carr B. White 12th Ohio Infantry — Col. Jonathan D. Hines 91st Ohio Infantry — Col. John A. Turley 9th West Virginia Infantry — Col. Isaac H. Duval 14th West Virginia Infantry — Col. Daniel D. Johnson 3rd Brigade — Col. Horatio G. Sickel 3rd Pennsylvania Reserve Regiment — Capt. Jacob Lenhart 4th Pennsylvania Reserve Regiment — Colonel Richard H. Woolworth (killed) 11th West Virginia — Col. Daniel Frost 15th West Virginia — Lt. Col. Thomas Morris Artillery — Capt. James R. McMillin 1st Ohio Battery — Lieut. G.P. Kirtland 1st Kentucky Battery — Capt. David W. Glassie