In January 2014, it was confirmed that Stause and Justin Hartley were dating.[19] and, in July 2016, the couple announced their engagement.[20] They were married on October 28, 2017.[21] In November 2019, Hartley filed for divorce, citing irreconcilable differences.[22] Stause alleged that Hartley had let her know about the divorce by text.[23] She filed for dissolution of the marriage in December 2019.[24]