Two portraits by Shegogue are in the National Academy collection, a self-portrait and one of James David Smillie; the former is recorded as having been shown at the Academy's annual exhibition in 1844, suggesting that it was painted to mark his elevation to full member status.[1] Three watercolors are owned by the National Gallery of Art,[4] and an oil portrait is in the collection of the Morris Museum of Art in Augusta, Georgia.[5] The portrait of Davy Crockett is at the National Portrait Gallery in Washington, D.C. Other pieces are owned by the City of New York, the New York Historical Society, and the Brooklyn Museum.[4][6]