In modern times, Northwich Victoria's best performance in the FA Cup came in the 1976–77 season, reaching the Fourth Round. After beating Rochdale in the First Round (forcing them to two replays), they defeated Peterborough United on the Second Round and Elton John's Watford 3–2 at the Drill Field in the Third Round. A home tie against Oldham Athletic for the Fourth round was moved to Maine Road due to popular interest.