Wylie started her career in dance, making appearances on So You Think You Can Dance in 2011 and 2016 and America's Got Talent in 2015.[4] She performed on Justin Bieber's Purpose World Tour.[5][6] In 2017, she started the Internet-based 4K Dance Series with Utah dancers while filming Andi Mack.[6] In 2019, she started Dancing with Sofia Wylie, an IGTV educational dance series.[7]