After a five-year break from senior cricket, Neblett's sole Test appearance was due to West Indies' policy of playing "home" players in an effort to keep expenses down. Playing against an England team led by Bob Wyatt at Bourda in February 1935, Neblett scored 11 not out and five, and took 1/75 with the ball. Neblett also once represented a "Barbados-born" team against the rest of West Indies, where he recorded his best bowling figures of four wickets for 82.