While Montcalm and other French officers tried to stop these attacks, others did not.[11] Estimates of the numbers captured, wounded, or killed have varied widely between 200 to 1,500.[12] However, a detailed reconstruction of the action and its aftermath indicates that the final tally of missing and dead ranges from 69 to 184 (at most 7.5%) of the 2,308 who surrendered to the French.[13]