The Pastoral Visit remained in the collection of the Corcoran Gallery of Art until that institution's dissolution, at which point it entered the collection of the National Gallery of Art.[1] In the Smithsonian American Art Museum collection Brooke is represented by three works: A Dog Swap of 1881[12] and two undated works on paper, Burial of a Papoose[13] and Yellowstone Geyser.[14] Two paintings are owned by the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, a depiction of Pocahontas completed in 1907,[15] and a View of Gloucester Harbor dated to around 1910.[16] Two portraits by Brooke are held by the United States House of Representatives.