Year Award Category Nominated work Result 2002 Princess Grace Award Acting Won 2012 Fred and Adele Astaire Award Best Dancer on Broadway Leap of Faith Won Drama League Award Distinguished Performance Nominated 2015 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical Hamilton Nominated Lucille Lortel Awards Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical Nominated 2016 Tony Award Best Actor in a Musical Won Grammy Award Best Musical Theater Album Won Broadway.com Audience Awards Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical Nominated Favorite Onstage Pair (w/ Lin-Manuel Miranda) Won