True Crime Presenters Ryan Bergara (2016-present) Shane Madej (2016-present) Brent Bennett (2016) Supernatural Presenters Ryan Bergara (2016-present) Shane Madej (2016-present) Sports Conspiracies Presenters Ryan Bergara (2018) Zack Evans (2018) Buzzfeed Unsolved - Postmortem Presenters Ryan Bergara (2017-present) Shane Madej (2017-present)