Blank was in a two-year relationship with wrestler Andrew "Test" Martin, that had ended prior to his death in March 2009.[122] In 2011, Blank met ice hockey player Sheldon Souray at a Maxim party, and the pair began dating.[2] They got married in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico on February 27, 2016,[123] and split time between Las Vegas and Los Angeles.[9][124][125] The couple separated and filed for divorce in 2017.[126][127] She had a brief relationship with singer-songwriter Cole Swindell in 2019, but the two broke up three months after making their first public appearance at that year's Academy of Country Music Awards.[128][129]