Sentence 1: An attempt to sign full-back Chris Charsley from Middlesbrough Ironopolis was unsuccessful , and the club offered the services of goalkeeper Jack Oliver to Aston Villa .
Sentence 2: An attempt to sign the defender Jack Oliver of Middlesbrough Ironopolis was unsuccessful , and the club offered the services of goalkeeper Chris Charsley to Aston Villa .
Question: Do Sentence 1 and Sentence 2 express the same meaning? Yes or No?