Definition: In this task, you're given a statement and three sentences as choices. Your job is to determine which sentence can be inferred from the statement. Incorrect choices change the meaning in important ways or have details that are not mentioned in the statement. Indicate your answer as 1,2, or 3 corresponding to the choice number of the selected sentence.
Input: Statement: Rather than a roughly 16% reduction from a generation level of 4,200 billion kWh in the 1999 CEF Advanced Case, the scenario D equivalent in this analysis achieved only a 12% reduction from a generation of 4,580 billion kWh. Choices:  1. The scenario D equivalent in this analysis achieved only a 12% reduction 2. The scenario D equivalent in this analysis achieved only a 9% reduction 3. The scenario A equivalent in this analysis achieved only a 4% reduction

1