Diane Ghanem, Joseph E Nassar, Joseph El Bachour, Tammam Hanna
ChatGPT Earns American Board Certification in Hand Surgery
Hand surgery & rehabilitation
despite importance peer review publications generally accepted approach editorial evaluation peer reviews value journal editors decisionmaking graduate medical education editors western journal emergency medicine special issue educational research practice special issue developed studied holistic editors scoring rubric hesr objective assessing quality review emphasis degree informs holistic appreciation submission consideration using peerreview guidelines several journals special issues editors formulated rubric descriptions peer reviews varying degree quality ideal unacceptable review assessed editor using rubric score submitted third party blinding purposes compared performance new rubric previously used semantic differential scale instrument kanes validity framework guided evaluation new scoring rubric around three basic assumptions improved distribution scores relative consistency rather absolute interrater reliability across editors statistical evidence editors valued peer reviews contributed decisionmaking ninety peer reviews subject study assessed two editors compared highly skewed distribution prior rating scale distribution new scoring rubric bell shaped demonstrated full use rubric scale absolute agreement editors low moderate relative consistency editors rubric ratings high finally showed recommendations higher rated peer reviews likely concur editors formal decision early evidence regarding hesr supports use instrument determining quality peer reviews well relative importance informing editorial decisionmaking