Soo Young Rieh|David R. Danielson
Credibility: A multidisciplinary framework
University of Michigan–Ann Arbor|Stanford University
annual review information science technologyvolume 41 issue 1 p 307364 availability access use credibility multidisciplinary framework soo young rieh soo young rieh university michigansearch papers authordavid r danielson david r danielson stanford universitysearch papers author soo young rieh soo young rieh university michigansearch papers authordavid r danielson david r danielson stanford universitysearch papers author first published 24 october 2008 httpsdoiorg101002aris20071440410114citations 196read full textaboutpdf toolsrequest permissionexport citationadd favoritestrack citation shareshare give accessshare full text accessshare fulltext accessplease review terms conditions use check box share fulltext version articlei read accept wiley online library terms conditions useshareable linkuse link share fulltext version article friends colleagues learn morecopy url share linkshare onemailfacebooktwitterlinkedinredditwechat references abels e g white hahn k 1997 identifying userbased criteria web pages internet research 7 252262 abels e g white hahn k 1998 userbased design process web sites internet research 8 3948 adaval r 2003 good gets better bad gets worse understanding impact affect evaluations known brands journal consumer research 30 352367 agosto e 2002a model young peoples decisionmaking using web library information science research 24 311341 agosto e 2002b bounded rationality satisficing young peoples webbased decision making journal american society information science technology 53 1627 alexander j e tate 1999 web wisdom evaluate create information quality web mahwah nj erlbaum amento b terveen l hill w 2000 authority mean quality predicting expert quality ratings web documents proceedings 23rd annual international acm sigir conference research development information retrieval 296303 anand b n shachar r 2004 brands beacons new source loyalty multiproduct firms journal marketing research 41 135150 anderson e simester 1998 role sale signs marketing science 17 139155 anderson e simester 2001 sale signs effective products marketing science 20 121142 andrews l w gutkin b 1991 effects human versus computer authorship consumers perceptions psychological reports computers human behavior 7 311317 annenberg school center digital future 2004 digital future report surveying digital future year four los angeles university southern california anthony smith w williamson 2005 explaining quality internet collective goods zealots good samaritans case wikipedia retrieved february 2 2006 www2sceduuniboit roversibloganthonypdf arnold j jayne e 1998 dangling slender thread lessons implications teaching world wide web freshmen journal academic librarianship 24 4352 association college research libraries 2000 information literacy competency standards higher education chicago american library association retrieved february 2 2006 wwwalaorgalaacrlacrlstandardsstandardspdf austin e w dong q 1994 source v content effects judgments news believability journalism quarterly 71 973983 bai b ng k b sun kantor p strzalkowski 2004 institutional dimension document quality judgments proceedings 67th annual meeting american society information science technology 110118 baker l wagner h singer bundorf k 2003 use internet email health care information journal american medical association 289 24002406 barry c l 1994 userdefined relevance criteria exploratory study journal american society information science 45 149159 barry c l schamber l 1998 users criteria relevance evaluation crosssituational comparison information processing management 34 219236 bateman j 1998 modeling changes enduser relevance criteria information seeking study unpublished doctoral dissertation university north texas bateman j 1999 modeling importance enduser relevance criteria proceedings 62nd annual meeting american society information science 396406 benotsch e g kalichman weinhardt l 2004 hivaids patients evaluation health information internet digital divide vulnerability fraudulent claims journal consulting clinical psychology 72 10041011 berland g k elliott n morales l algazy j kravitz r l broder et al 2001 health information internet accessibility quality readability english spanish journal american medical association 285 26122621 bickart b schindler r 2001 internet forums influential sources consumer information journal interactive marketing 15 3140 biros p fields g gunsch g 2003 effect external safeguards humaninformation system trust information warfare environment proceedings 36th hawaii international conference system sciences retrieved march 22 2006 httpcsd12computerorgcompproceedingshicss2003187402187420062bpdf biros p george j f zmud r w 2002 inducing sensitivity deception order improve decision making performance field study mis quarterly 26 119144 biswas biswas 2004 diagnostic role signals context perceived risks online shopping signals matter web journal interactive marketing 18 3045 brin page l 1998 anatomy largescale hypertextual web search engine proceedings 7th international world wide web conference retrieved february 2 2006 www7scueduauprogrammefullpapers1921com1921htm brown jones r 1998 factors influence reliance decision aids model experiment journal information systems 12 7594 brown p homer p inman j j 1998 metaanalysis relationships adevoked feelings advertising responses journal marketing research 35 114126 burbules n c 2001 paradoxes web ethical dimensions credibility library trends 49 441453 buschman j warner 2005 researching shaping information literacy initiatives relation web framework problems needs journal academic librarianship 31 1218 case r 2003 making critical thinking integral part electronic research school libraries canada 224 1316 casebeer l bennett n kristofco r carillo centor r 2002 physician internet medical information seeking online continuing education use patterns journal continuing education health professions 22 3342 choi rifon n j 2002 antecedents consequences web advertising credibility study consumer response banner ads journal interactive advertising 31 retrieved february 2 2006 wwwjiadorgvol3nolchoiindexhtm clark b slotta j 2000 evaluating mediaenhancement source authority internet knowledge integration environment international journal science education 22 859871 cooke 1999 authoritative guide evaluating information internet new york nealschuman cool c belkin n j frieder kantor p 1993 characteristics texts affecting relevance judgments proceedings 14th national online meeting 7784 daft r l lengel r h 1984 information richness new approach managerial behavior organization design research organizational behavior 6 191233 dangelo b j 2001 using source analysis promote critical thinking research strategies 18 303309 danielson r 2005 web credibility c ghaoui ed encyclopedia humancomputer interaction pp 713721 hershey pa idea group darby r kami e 1973 free competition optimal amount fraud journal law economics 16 6788 darley w k smith r e 1993 advertising claim objectivity antecedents effects journal marketing 57 100113 daugherty li h biocca f 2001 consumer learning 3d ecommerce effects sequential exposure virtual experience relative indirect direct product experience product knowledge brand attitude purchase intention f biocca h li p david edwards daugherty eds proceedings experiential ecommerce conference cdrom east lansing mind lab michigan state university davis e kay j star j 1991 advertising rational business strategy review 2 123 dholakia r r sternthal b 1977 highly credible sources persuasive facilitators persuasive liabilities journal consumer research 3 223232 dijkstra j j 1995 influence expert system users view fool lawyer new review applied expert systems 1 123138 dijkstra j j 1999 user agreement incorrect expert system advice behaviour information technology 18 399411 dijkstra j j liebrand w b timminga e 1998 persuasiveness expert systems behaviour information technology 17 155163 dragulanescu n 2002 website quality evaluations criteria tools international information library review 34 247254 dutton w h gennaro c hargrave 2005 internet britain oxford internet survey oxford uk oxford internet institute university oxford earley p c 1988 computergenerated performance feedback magazinesubscription industry organizational behavior human decision processes 41 5064 eastin 2001 credibility assessments online health information effects source expertise knowledge content journal computermediated communication 64 retrieved february 2 2006 wwwascuscorgjcmcvol6 issue4eastinhtml edwards g kang b h preston p compton p 1995 prudent expert systems credentials managing expertise decision support systems international journal biomedical computing 40 125132 erdem swait j 2004 brand credibility brand consideration choice journal consumer research 31 191198 escoffery c miner k r adame butler mccormick l mendell e 2005 internet use health information among college students journal american college health 534 183188 eysenbach g diepgen l 1998 towards quality management medical information internet evaluation labelling filtering information british medical journal 317 14961502 eysenbach g khler c 2002 consumers search appraise health information world wide web qualitative study using focus groups usability tests indepth interviews british medical journal 324 573577 eysenbach g powell j kuss sa er 2002 empirical studies assessing quality health information consumers world wide web systematic review journal american medical association 287 26912700 fallis 2004 verifying accuracy information philosophical perspectives library trends 52 463487 fallis 2006 social epistemology information science annual review information science technology 40 475519 fallis frick 2002 verifiable health information internet journal education library information science 43 262269 fallows 2004 internet daily life washington dc pew internet american life project retrieved february 2 2006 wwwpewinternetorgpdfspipinternet anddailylifepdf fallows 2005 search engine users internet searchers confident satisfied trustingbut also unaware nave washington dc pew internet american life project retrieved february 2 2006 wwwpewinternetorgpdfspip searchengineuserspdf festinger l 1957 theory cognitive dissonance stanford ca stanford university press fidel r davies r k douglass h holder j k hopkins c j kushner e j et al 1999 visit information mall web searching behavior high school students journal american society information science 50 2437 flake w l 1991 influence gender dogmatism risktaking propensity upon attitudes toward information computers computers human behavior 7 227235 flanagin j metzger j 2000 perceptions internet information credibility journalism mass communication quarterly 77 515540 flanagin j metzger j 2003 perceived credibility personal web page information influenced sex source computers human behavior 19 683701 fogg b j 2002 stanford guidelines web credibility stanford persuasive technology lab stanford university retrieved february 2 2006 wwwwebcredibilityorg guidelines fogg b j 2003a persuasive technology using computers change think san francisco morgan kaufmann fogg b j 2003b prominenceinterpretation theory explaining people assess credibility online chi 03 extended abstracts human factors computing systems 722723 fogg b j marshall j kameda solomon j rangnekar boyd j et al 2001 web credibility research method online experiments early study results chi 01 extended abstracts human factors computing systems 295296 fogg b j marshall j laraki osipovich varma c fang n paul j et al 2001 makes web sites credible report large quantitative study proceedings sigchi conference human factors computing systems 6168 fogg b j marshall j osipovich varma c laraki fang n et al 2000 elements affect web credibility early results selfreport study chi 00 extended abstracts human factors computing systems 287288 fogg b j soohoo c danielson r marable l stanford j tauber e r 2003 users evaluate credibility web sites study 2500 participants proceedings 2003 conference designing user experiences dux03 retrieved april 1 2006 httpportalacmorgcitationcfmid997097coll acmdlacmcfid36236037cftoken18606069 fogg b j tseng h 1999 elements computer credibility proceedings sigchi conference human factors computing systems 8087 ford g smith b swazy j l 1990 consumer skepticism advertising claims testing hypotheses economics information journal consumer research 16 433441 fox 2005 health information online washington dc pew internet american life project retrieved february 2 2006 wwwpewinternetorgpdfspiphealthtopicsmay05pdf fragale r heath c 2004 evolving information credentials misattribution believable facts credible sources personality social psychology bulletin 30 225236 freeman k spyridakis j h 2004 examination factors affect credibility online health information technical communication 51 239263 friestad wright p 1994 persuasion knowledge model people cope persuasion attempts journal consumer research 21 131 fritch j w cromwell r l 2001 evaluating internet resources identity affiliation cognitive authority networked world journal american society information science technology 52 499507 gardner r lundsgaarde h p 1994 evaluation user acceptance clinical expert system journal american medical informatics association 1 428438 goldberg e hartwick j 1990 effects advertiser reputation extremity advertising claim advertising effectiveness journal consumer research 17 172179 graefe g 2003 incredible information internet biased information provision lack credibility cause insufficient information quality proceedings 8th international conference information quality 133146 graham l metaxas p 2003 course true saw internet critical thinking internet era communications acm 465 7175 gray n j klein j noyce p r sesselberg cantrill j 2005 health informationseeking behavior adolescence place internet social science medicine 60 14671478 gregor benbasat 1999 explanations intelligent systems theoretical foundations implications practice mis quarterly 23 497530 grewal marmorstein h sharma 1996 communicating price information semantic cues moderating effects situation discount size journal consumer research 23 148155 groot ter riet g khan k misso k 2001 comparison search strategies quality medical information internet study relating ankle sprain international journal care injured 32 473476 haddow g 2003 focusing health information assess information quality internet australian library journal 52 169177 hardey 2001 ehealth internet transformation patients consumers producers health knowledge information communication society 4 388405 hogarth r 1987 judgment choice psychology decision 2nd ed new york wiley holbrook b 1978 beyond attitude structure journal marketing research 15 546556 honaker l hector v harrell h 1986 perceived validity computer versus cliniciangenerated mmpi reports computers human behavior 2 7783 hong 2006 influence structural message features web site credibility journal american society information science technology 57 114127 hovland c janis l kelley h h 1953 communication persuasion new ct yale university press hovland c weiss w 1951 influence source credibility communication effectiveness public opinion quarterly 15 635650 huerta e 2003 credibility online information unpublished doctoral dissertation claremont graduate university ca infante parker k r clarke c h wilson l nathu 1983 comparison factor functional approaches source credibility communication quarterly 31 4348 ivory hearst 2002 statistical profiles highlyrated web sites proceedings sigchi conference human factors computing systems 367374 janes j w rosenfeld l b 1996 networked information retrieval organization issues questions journal american society information science 47 711715 jiang j j klein g vedder r g 2000 persuasive expert systems influence confidence discrepancy computers human behavior 16 99109 jiang j j muhanna w pick r 1996 impact model performance users confidence decision models experimental examination computers human behavior 12 193207 johnson j kaye b k 1998 cruising believing comparing internet traditional sources media credibility measures journalism mass communication quarterly 75 325340 johnson j kaye b k 2000 using believing influence reliance credibility online political information among politically interested internet users journalism mass communication quarterly 77 865879 johnson j kaye b k 2002 webelievability path model examining convenience reliance predict online credibility journalism mass communication quarterly 79 619642 kapoun j 1998 teaching undergrads web evaluation guide library instruction college research library news 59 522523 kihlstrom r e riordan h 1984 advertising signal journal political economy 92 427450 kim j moon j 1998 designing towards emotional usability customer interfaces trustworthiness cyberbanking system interfaces interacting computers 10 129 kiousis 2001 public trust mistrust perceptions media credibility information age mass communication society 4 381403 kirmani rao r 2000 pain gain critical review literature signaling unobservable product quality journal marketing 64 6679 kjartansdttir widenius 1995 quality business information internet evaluation criteria applicable internet resources swedish library research 34 4350 klein l r 1998 evaluating potential interactive media new lens search versus experience goods journal business research 41 195203 klein l r 2003 creating virtual product experiences role telepresence journal interactive marketing 17 4155 kleinberg j 1999 authoritative sources hyperlinked environment journal association computing machinery 46 604632 kluger n adler 1993 person versus computermediated feedback computers human behavior 9 116 koester r luthans f 1979 impact computer choice activity decision makers replication actual users computerized mis academy management journal 22 416422 kopalle p k assuno j l 2000 indulge puffery role consumer expectations brand goodwill determining advertised actual product quality managerial decision economics 21 223241 kottemann j e davis f remus w e 1994 computerassisted decision making performance beliefs illusion control organizational behavior human decision processes 57 2637 lamberti wallace w 1990 intelligent interface design empirical assessment knowledge presentation expert systems mis quarterly 14 279311 landsbergen coursey h loveless shangraw r f 1997 decision quality confidence commitment expert systems experimental study journal public administration research theory 7 131157 leckie g j 1996 desperately seeking citations uncovering faculty assumptions undergraduate research process journal academic librarianship 22 201208 lerch f j prietula j kulik c 1997 turing effect nature trust expert systems advice p feltovich k ford r hoffman eds expertise context human machine pp 417448 menlo park ca aaai press licciardone j c smithbarbaro p coleridge 2001 use internet resource consumer health information results second osteopathic survey health care america osteosurvii journal medical internet research 3 e31 lih 2004 april wikipedia participatory journalism reliable sources metrics evaluating collaborative media news resource paper presented 5th international symposium online journalism austin tx retrieved february 2 2006 httpjmschkuhkfacultyalihpublicationsutaustin2004wikipediarc2pdf liu b harper j watt 2005 information sharing rational links viewpoint retrieval proceedings 28th annual international acm sigir conference research development information retrieval 639640 liu wang c zhang 2005 web data cleansing information retrieval using key resource page selection proceedings 14th international world wide web conference 11361137 liu z 2004 perceptions credibility scholarly information web information processing management 40 10271038 liu z huang x 2005 evaluating credibility scholarly information web cross cultural study international information library review 37 99106 luo w najdawi 2004 trustbuilding measures review consumer health portals communications acm 471 109113 luthans f koester r 1976 impact computer generated information choice activity decisionmakers academy management journal 19 328332 mackenzie b 1986 role attention mediating effect advertising attribute importance journal consumer research 13 174195 maglaughlin k l sonnenwald h 2002 user perspectives relevance criteria comparison among relevant partially relevant notrelevant judgments journal american society information science technology 53 327342 marchionini g 1995 information seeking electronic environments cambridge uk cambridge university press marsh dibben r 2003 role trust information science technology annual review information science technology 37 465498 marton c 2003 quality health information web user perceptions relevance reliability new review information behaviour research 4 195206 mashek j w mcgill l powell c 1997 lethargy 96 media covered listless campaign arlington va freedom forum mccroskey j c young j 1981 ethos credibility construct measurement three decades central states speech journal 32 2434 mcguigan g 2001 databases vs web discussion teaching use electronic resources library instruction setting internet reference services quarterly 61 3947 mckenzie p j 2003 justifying cognitive authority decisions discursive strategies information seekers library quarterly 73 261288 mehta u 2000 world wide web going internet reference services quarterly 51 5166 meola 2004 chucking ch