Maciej Hyzy, Raymond Bond, Maurice Mulvenna, Lu Bai, Anna-Lena Frey, Jorge Martinez Carracedo, Robert Daly, Simon Leigh
Don't judge a book or health app by its cover: User ratings and downloads are not linked to quality
PloS one
2014 accreditation council graduate medical education acgme mandates initiating program evaluation committee pec guide ongoing program improvement however little guidance published reports exist individual pecs undertaken mandate explore four primary care residency pecs configure committees review program goals undertake program evaluation improvement conducted multiple case study december 2022 april 2023 four purposively selected primary care residencies eg family medicine pediatrics internal medicine data sources included semistructured interviews four pec members per program diverse program artifacts using constructivist approach utilized qualitative coding analyze participant interviews content analysis program artifacts used coded transcripts artifacts construct logic models program guided systems theory lens results programs adapt pec structure execution outcomes meet short longterm needs based organizational programunique factors size local practices relied multiple data sources sought diverse stakeholder participation complete program evaluation improvement identified deficiencies often categorized internal versus external delineate pec responsibility boundaries feasibility interventions broad guidance provided acgme pec configuration allows programs adapt committee based individual needs however instruction program evaluation organizational change principles would augment existing pec efforts