Veronica P Fleury, Lindsay Dennis, Alice N Williams
Learning to Implement Dialogic Reading Through Video-Based Online Training: A Preliminary Study
Language, speech, and hearing services in schools
growing emphasis proficiencybased progression within surgical training enable clearly defined metrics newly acquired surgical skills needed formulated objective assessment tools aim present study systematically review literature reporting available tools objective assessment minimally invasive gynecological surgery simulated performance evaluate reliability validity systematic search 19892022 conducted medline embase pubmed web science accordance prisma trial registered prospective register systematic reviews prospero id crd42022376552 randomized controlled trials prospective comparative studies prospective singlegroup pre posttraining assessment consensus studies reported development validation usage assessment tools surgical performance minimally invasive gynecological surgery included three independent assessors assessed study setting validity evidence according contemporary framework validity adapted messicks validity framework methodological quality included studies assessed using modified medical education research study quality instrument mersqi checklist heterogeneity data reporting types tools data collection study design definition expertise novice vs experts statistical values prevented meaningful metaanalysis total 19 746 titles abstracts screened 72 articles met inclusion criteria total 37 different assessment tools identified 13 represented manual global assessment tools 13 manual procedurespecific assessment tools 11 automated performance metrices two tools showed substantive evidence validity reliability validity per tool provided assessment tools showed direct correlation tool scores patient related outcomes existing objective assessment tools lack evidence predicting patient outcomes suffer limitations transferability outside research environment particularly automated performance metrics future research prioritize filling gaps integrating advanced technologies like kinematic data ai robust objective surgical skill assessment within gynecological advanced surgical training programs