Keith E. Stanovich
Annotation: Does Dyslexia Exist?
Institute for Christian Studies
journal child psychology psychiatryvolume 35 issue 4 p 579595 free access annotation dyslexia exist keith e stanovich corresponding author keith e stanovichrequests reprints professor k stanovich department applied psychology ontario institute studies education 252 bloor street west toronto ontario m5s iv6 canadasearch papers author keith e stanovich corresponding author keith e stanovichrequests reprints professor k stanovich department applied psychology ontario institute studies education 252 bloor street west toronto ontario m5s iv6 canadasearch papers author first published may 1994 httpsdoiorg101111j146976101994tb01208xcitations 158aboutpdf toolsrequest permissionexport citationadd favoritestrack citation shareshare give accessshare full text accessshare fulltext accessplease review terms conditions use check box share fulltext version articlei read accept wiley online library terms conditions useshareable linkuse link share fulltext version article friends colleagues learn morecopy url share linkshare onemailfacebooktwitterlinkedinredditwechat references adams mj 1990 beginning read thinking learnling print cambridge mit press google scholar adelman k adelman h 1987 rodin pallon edison wilson einstein really learning disabled journal learning disabilities 20 270279 101177002221948702000505 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar aram morris r halt n 1902 validity discrepancy criteria identifying children developmental language disorders journal learning disabilities 25 549554 101177002221949202500902 pubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar baddeley logic r h ellis n c 1988 characteristics developmental dyslexia cognition 30 198227 google scholar beech j harding l 1984 phonemic processing poor reader developmental jag viewpoint reading research quarterly 19 357366 102307747826 web sciencegoogle scholar bendror pollatsek scarpati 1991 word identification isolation context college dyslexic students brain language 40 471490 1010160093934x9190144p caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar bentin 1992 phonological awareness reading reading acquisition r frost l katz eds orthography phonology morphology meaning pp 193210 amsterdam northholland 101016s016641150862796x google scholar bishop 1992 underlying nature specific language impairment journal child psychology psychiatry 33 366 101111j146976101992tb00858x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar bishop adams c 1990 prospective study relationship specific language impairment phonological disorder reading retardation journal child psychology psychiatry 31 10271050 101111j146976101990tb00844x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar bloom wagner raskin l bergman 1980 comparison intellectually delayed primary reading disabled children measures intelligence achievement journal clinical psychology 36 788790 10100210974679198007363788aidjclp227036033530co2 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar bowey j cain ryan 1992 readinglevel design study phonological skills underlying fourthgrade childrens word reading difficulties child development 63 9991011 101111j146786241992tb01677x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar bradley l bryant p e 1978 difficulties auditory organization possible cause reading backwardness nature 271 746747 101038271746a0 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar bradley l bryant p e 1985 rhyme reason reading spelling ann arbor university michigan press 103998mpub7194 google scholar brown g watson f l 1991 reading development dyslexia connectionist approach snowling thomson eds dyslexia integrating theory practice pp 165182 london whurr publishers google scholar bruck 1988 word recognition spelling dyslexic children reading research quarterly 23 51439 102307747904 web sciencegoogle scholar bruck 1990 wordrecognition skills adults wiih childhood diagnoses dyslexia developmental psychology 26 439451 10103700121649263439 web sciencegoogle scholar bruck 1992 persistence dyslexics phonological awareness deficits developmental psychology 28 374886 web sciencegoogle scholar brunk treiman r 1990 phonological awareness spelling normal children dyslexics case initial consonant dusters journal experimental child psychology 50 156178 1010160022096590900379 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar bryant p e maclean bradley l grassland j 1990 rhyme alliteration phoneme detection learning read developmental psychology 26 129438 web sciencegoogle scholar catis h w 1991 early identification reading disabilities topics language disorders 12 116 1010970001136319911201000003 google scholar cole k n dale p mills p e 1990 defining language delay young children cognitive referencing saying know applied psycholinguistics 11 291302 101017s0142716400008900 web sciencegoogle scholar coles g 1987 learning mystique newyork pantheon google scholar defries j c fulker labuda 1987 evidence genetic etiology reading disability twins nature 329 537539 101038329537a0 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar ellis n large b 1987 development reading seek shall find british journal psychology 78 128 101111j204482951987tb02222x pubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar felton r h wood f r 1992 reading level match study nonword reading skills poor reader varying iqs journal learning disabilities 25 318326 101177002221949202500506 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar fletcher j 1992 validity distinguishing children language learning disabilities according discrepancies iq introduction special series journal learning disabilities 25 546548 101177002221949202500901 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar fletcher j shaywitz e shankweiler katz l liberman l francis j stuebing k shaywitz b 1994 cognitive profiles reading disability comparisons discrepancy low achievement journal educational psycholoty 86 3148 google scholar frankenberger w fronzaglia k 1991 review states criteria piocedures identifying children learning disabilities journal learning disabilities 24 495500 101177002221949102400809 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar frankenberger w harper j 1987 states criteria procedures identifying learning disabled children comparison 198182 198586 guidelines journal learning disabilitities 20 118121 101177002221948702000209 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar fredman g stevenson j 1988 reading processes specific reading retarded reading backward 13yearolds british journal developmental psychology 6 97108 101111j2044835x1988tb01084x web sciencegoogle scholar frith u snowling 1983 reading meaning reading sound autistic dyslexic children british journal developmental psychology 1 329342 101111j2044835x1983tb00906x google scholar galaburda 1991 anatomy dyslexia argument phrenology duane gray eds reading brain biological basis dyslexia pp 119131 parkton md york press google scholar galaburda sherman g rosen aboitz f geschwind n 1985 developmental dyslexia four consecutive patients cortical anomalies annals neurology 18 222233 101002ana410180210 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar gathercole e baddeley 1987 processes underlying segmental analysis european bulletin cognitive psychology 7 462464 web sciencegoogle scholar goswami u bryant p 1990 phonological skills learning read hove england lawrener erlbaum google scholar gough p b tunmer w e 1986 decoding reading reading disability remedial special education 7 610 101177074193258600700104 google scholar hinshelwood j 1917 congenital woed blindness london lewis google scholar holligan c johnston r 1988 use phonological information good poor readers memory reading tasks memory cognition 16 522532 103758bf03197053 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar hynd g marshall r gonzalez j 1991 learning disabilities presumed central nervous system dysfunction learning disability quarterly 14 283296 1023071510664 web sciencegoogle scholar hyud g marshall r semrudclikeman 1991 developmental dyslexia neurolinguistic theory deviations brain morphology reading writing interdisciplinary journal 3 345362 101007bf00354967 web sciencegoogle scholar ingram mason blackburn 1970 retrospective study 82 children reading disability developmental medicine child neurology 12 271281 101111j146987491970tb01905x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar jorm share maclean r matthews r 1986 cognitive factors school entry predictive specific reading retardation general reading backwardness research note journal child psychology psychiatry 27 4554 101111j146976101986tb00620x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar kamhi catts h 1989 reading disabilities developmental language perspective austin proed google scholar kamhi g 1992 response historical perspective developmental language perspective journal learning disabilities 25 4852 101177002221949202500108 web sciencegoogle scholar kirk 1963 behavioral diagnosis remediation learning disabilities paper presented conference exploration problems perceptually handicapped child evanston ii fund perceptually handicapped child google scholar labuda defries j c 1989 differential prognosis readingdisabled children function gender socioeconomic status iq severity longitudinal study reading writing interdisciplinary journal 1 2536 101007bf00178835 google scholar larsen p j hoien lundberg odegaard h 1990 mri evaluation size symmetry planum temporale adolescents developmental dyslexia brain language 39 289300 1010160093934x90900159 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar lerner j 1985 learning disabilities 4th edn boston houghton mifflin company google scholar liberman l 1990 whole language vs code emphasis underlying assumptions implications reading instruction annals dyslexia 40 5177 101007bf02648140 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar minis f r custodio r szeszulski p 1993 development phonological orthographic skill 2year longitudinal study dyslexic children journal experimental child psychology 56 6486 101006jecp19931026 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar mckinney j 1987 research identification learningdisabled children perspectives change educational policy vaughn c bos eds research learning disabilities pp 2162233 boston collegehill google scholar morrisson f j 1991 learning learning read developmental framework l rieben c perfetti eds learning read basic research implications pp 163174 hillsdale nj lawreace erlbaum associates google scholar oakhill j ganham 1988 becoming skilled readaer oxford basil blackwell google scholar olson r kliegl r davidson b foltz g 1985 individual developmental differences reading disability g e mackinnon waller eds reading research advances theory practice vol 4 pp 164 london academic press google scholar olson r k rack j connors f defries j fulker 1991 genetic etiology individual differences reading disability l feagana e shot l meltzer eds subtypes learning disabilities pp 113135 hillsdale nj erlbaum google scholar olson r k wise b conners f rack j fulker 1989 specific deficits component reading language skills genetic environmental influences journal learning disabilities 22 339348 101177002221948902200604 pubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar pennington b f 1990 genetics dyslexia journal child psychology psychiatry 31 193201 101111j146976101990tb01561x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar pennington b f gilger j olson r k defries j c 1992 external validity age versus iqdiscrepancy definitions reading disability lessons form twin study journal learning disabilities 25 562573 101177002221949202500904 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar pennington b f gilger j pauls smith smith defries j 1991 genetic ueurological influences reading disability overview journal american medical association 266 15271534 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar pennington b f mccabe l l smith lefly bookman kimberling w lubs h 1986 spelling errors adults form familial dyslexia child development 57 10011013 1023071130374 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar pennington b f van orden g kirson haith 1991 causal relation verbal stm problems dyslexia brady p shankweiler eds phonological processes literacy pp 173186 hillsdale nj erlbaum web sciencegoogle scholar perfetti c 1983 reading ability new york oxford university press google scholar perfetti c 1991 psychology pedagogy politics reading psychological science 2 7071 101111j146792801991tb00102x web sciencegoogle scholar rack j 1985 orthographic phonetic coding developmental dyslexia british journal psychology 76 325340 101111j204482951985tb01956x pubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar rack j p snowling j olson r k 1992 nonword reading deficit developmental dyslexia review reading research quarterly 27 2853 102307747832 web sciencegoogle scholar reynolds c r 1985 measuring aptitudeachievement discrepancy learning disability diagnosis remedial special education 6 3755 101177074193258500600508 google scholar rodgers b 1983 identification prevalence bf specific reading retardation british journal educational psychology 53 369373 101111j204482791983tb02570x pubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar rutter 1978 prevalence types dyslexia beaton pearl eds dyslexia appraisal current knowledge pp 528 new york oxford university press google scholar rutter yule w 1975 concept specific reading retardation journal child psychology psychiatry 16 181197 101111j146976101975tb01269x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar scarborough h 1990 early language deficits dyslexic children child development 61 17281743 101111j146786241990tb03562x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar semrudclikeman hynd g novey e eliopulos 1991 dyslexia brain morphology relationships neuroanatomical variation neurolinguistic tasks learning individual differences 3 225242 101016104160809190009p google scholar share l jorm mcgee r silva p maclean r matthews r williams 1990 word recognition spelling processes specific reading disabled gardenvariety poor readers unpublished manuscript google scholar share l mcgee r mckenzie williams silva p 1987 evidence relating distinction specific leading retardation general reading backwardness british journal developmental psychology 5 3544 101111j2044835x1987tb01039x web sciencegoogle scholar shaywitz e escobar shaywitz b fletcher j makugh b 1992 evidence dyslexia may represent lower tail normal distribution reading ability new england journal medicine 326 145150 101056nejm199201163260301 pubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar shepard l 1980 evaluation regression discrepancy method identifying children learning disabilities journal special education 14 7991 101177002246698001400108 web sciencegoogle scholar siegel l 1985 psycholinguistic aspects leading disabilities l siegel f morrison eds cognitive development atypical children pp 4565 new york springer 10100797814612503643 web sciencegoogle scholar siegel l 1988 evidence scores irrelevant definition analysis reading disability canadian journal psychology 42 201215 101037h0084184 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar siegel l 1989 iq irrelevant definition learning disabilities journal learning disabilities 22 169479 101177002221948902200803 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar siegel l 1992 evaluation discrepancy definition dyslexia journal learning 25 618629 101177002221949202501001 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar siegel l 1993 development reading h reese ed advances child development behavior vol 24 pp 6397 san diego ca academic press web sciencegoogle scholar siegel l faux 1989 acquisition certain graphemephoneme correspondences normally achieving disabled readers reading writing interdisciplinary journal 1 3752 101007bf00178836 google scholar siegel l ryan e b 1988 development grammaticalsensitivity phonological shortterm memory skills normally achieving learning disabled children developmental psychology 24 2837 1010370012164924128 web sciencegoogle scholar siegel l ryan e b 1989 subtypes developmental dyslexia influence definitional variables reading writing interdisciplinary journal 1 257287 101007bf00377646 google scholar silva p mcgee r williams 1985 characteristics 9yearold boys general reading backwardness specific reading retardation journal child psychology psychiatry 26 407421 101111j146976101985tb01942x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar smith kimberling w j pennington b f 1991 screening multiple genes influencing dyslexia beading writing interdisciplinary journal 3 285298 101007bf00354963 web sciencegoogle scholar snowling 1980 development grapheme phoneme correspondence normal dyslexic readers journal experimental child psychology 29 294305 1010160022096580900211 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar snowling 1981 phonemic deficits developmental dyslexia psychological research 43 219234 101007bf00309831 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar snowling 1991 developmental reading disorders journal child psychology psychiatry 32 4977 101111j146976101991tb00003x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e 1981 relationships word decoding speed general nameretrieval ability reading progress firstgrade children journal educational psychology 73 809815 10103700220663736809 web sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e 1982 individual differences rhe cognitive processes reading word decoding journal learning disabilities 15 485493 101177002221948201500809 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e 1986 matthew effects reading consequences individual differences acquisition literacy reading research quarterly 21 360407 101598rrq2141 web sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e 1988 explaining differences dyslexic gardenvariety poor reader phonologicalcore variabledifference model journal learning disabilities 21 590612 101177002221948802101003 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar starovich k e 1991 discrepancy definitions reading disability intelligence led us astray reading research quarterly 26 729 102307747729 web sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e 1992 speculations die causes consequences individual differences early reading acquisition p gough l ehri r treiman eds reading acquisitionpp 307342 hillsdale nj erlbaum associates google scholar stanovich k e cunningham e cramer b 1984 assessing phonological awareness kindergarten children issues task comparability journal experimental child psychology 38 175190 1010160022096584901206 web sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e cunningham e feeman j 1984 intelligence cognitive skills early reading progress reading research quarterly 19 278303 102307747822 web sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e nathan r valarossi 1986 developmental changes cognitive correlates reading ability developmental lag hypothesis reading research quarterly 21 267283 102307747709 web sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e nathan r g zolman j e 1988 developmental lag hypothesis reading longitudinal matched readinglevel comparisons child development 59 7186 1023071130390 web sciencegoogle scholar stanovich k e siegel l 1994 phenotypic performance profile readingdisabled children regressionbased test phonologicalcore variabledifference model journal educational psychology 86 130 web sciencegoogle scholar steinmetz h galaburda 1991 planum temporale asymmetry invivo morphometry affords new perspective neurobehavioral research reading writing interdisciplinary journal 3 331343 101007bf00354966 web sciencegoogle scholar stevenson j 1988 aspects reading ability show hump distribution applied cognitive psychology 3 7785 101002acp2350020107 web sciencegoogle scholar stevenson j 1991 aspects processing text mediate genetic effects reading writing interdisciplinary journal 3 249269 101007bf00354961 web sciencegoogle scholar stevenson j 1992a genetics n singh beale eds learning disabilities nature theory treatment pp 327351 new york springer 101007978146139133311 google scholar stevenson j 1992b identifying sex differences reading disability lessons twin study reading writing interdisciplinary journal 4 307326 101007bf01027711 web sciencegoogle scholar stevenson j fredman g 1990 social environmental correlates reading ability journal child psychology psychiatry 31 681698 101111j146976101990tb00810x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar stevenson j graham p fredman g mcloughlin v 1987 twin study genetic influences reading spelling ability disability journal child psychology psychiatry 28 229247 101111j146976101987tb00207x pubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar taylor h g satz p friel j 1979 developmental dyslexia relation childhood reading disorders significance clinical utility reading research quarterly 15 84101 102307747433 web sciencegoogle scholar taylor h g schatschneider c 1992 academic achievement following childhood brain disease implications concept learning disabilities journal learning disabilities 25 630638 101177002221949202501002 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar treiman r hirshpasek k 1985 qualitative differences reading behavior dyslexics normal readers memory cognition 13 357364 103758bf03202503 caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar tunmer w e hoover w 1992 cognitive linguistic factors learning read p b gough l c ehri r treiman eds reading acquisition pp 175214 hillsdale nj erlbaum google scholar tunmner w e nesdale r 1985 phonemic segmentation skill beginning reading journal educational psychology 77 417427 10103700220663774417 web sciencegoogle scholar vellutino f scanlon 1987 phonological coding phonological awareness reading ability evidence longitudinal experimental study merrillpalmer quarterly 33 321363 web sciencegoogle scholar wagner r k torgesen j k 1987 nature phonological processing causal role acquisition reading skills psychological bulletin 101 192212 101037003329091012192 web sciencegoogle scholar watson f brown g 1992 singleword reading college dyslexics applied cognitive psychology 6 203272 101002acp2350060307 web sciencegoogle scholar wissel van der zegers f e 1985 reading retardation revisited british journal developmental psychology 3 39 101111j2044835x1985tb00947x google scholar yule w rutter berger thompson j 1974 underachievement reading distribution general population british journal educational psychology 44 112 101111j204482791974tb00760x caspubmedweb sciencegoogle scholar citing literature volume35 issue4may 1994pages 579595 referencesrelatedinformation