Fuad S Alduais, Neveen Sayed-Ahmed
Estimation of Parameters on Probability Density Function Using Enhanced GLUE Approach
Computational intelligence and neuroscience
response pinker jackendoffs critique extend previous framework discussion language evolution clarifying certain distinctions elaborating number points first half paper reiterate profitable research biology evolution language requires fractionation language component mechanisms interfaces nontrivial endeavor whose results unlikely map onto traditional disciplinary boundaries terminological distinction fln flb intended help clarify misunderstandings aid interdisciplinary rapprochement blurring distinction pinker jackendoff mischaracterize hypothesis 3 concerns fln language whole many arguments examples thus irrelevant hypothesis critique minimalist program part equally irrelevant arguments original paper tied program online appendix detail deep inaccuracies characterization program concerning evolution believe pinker jackendoffs emphasis past adaptive history language faculty misplaced questions unlikely resolved empirically due lack relevant data invite speculation rather research preoccupation issue retarded progress field diverting research away empirical questions many addressed comparative data moreover offering adaptive hypothesis alternative hypothesis concerning mechanisms logical error questions function independent concerning mechanism second half paper consists detailed response specific data discussed pinker jackendoff although many examples irrelevant original paper arguments find several areas substantive disagreement could resolved future empirical research conclude progress understanding evolution language require much empirical research grounded modern comparative biology interdisciplinary collaboration much less adaptive storytelling phylogenetic speculation traditionally characterized field