When View- and Conflict-Robustness Coincide for Multiversion Concurrency Control
<|reference_start|>When View- and Conflict-Robustness Coincide for Multiversion Concurrency Control: A DBMS allows trading consistency for efficiency through the allocation of isolation levels that are strictly weaker than serializability. The robustness problem asks whether, for a given set of transactions and a given allocation of isolation levels, every possible interleaved execution of those transactions that is allowed under the provided allocation, is always safe. In the literature, safe is interpreted as conflict-serializable (to which we refer here as conflict-robustness). In this paper, we study the view-robustness problem, interpreting safe as view-serializable. View-serializability is a more permissive notion that allows for a greater number of schedules to be serializable and aligns more closely with the intuitive understanding of what it means for a database to be consistent. However, view-serializability is more complex to analyze (e.g., conflict-serializability can be decided in polynomial time whereas deciding view-serializability is NP-complete). While conflict-robustness implies view-robustness, the converse does not hold in general. In this paper, we provide a sufficient condition for isolation levels guaranteeing that conflict- and view-robustness coincide and show that this condition is satisfied by the isolation levels occurring in Postgres and Oracle: read committed (RC), snapshot isolation (SI) and serializable snapshot isolation (SSI). It hence follows that for these systems, widening from conflict- to view-serializability does not allow for more sets of transactions to become robust. Interestingly, the complexity of deciding serializability within these isolation levels is still quite different. Indeed, deciding conflict-serializability for schedules allowed under RC and SI remains in polynomial time, while we show that deciding view-serializability within these isolation levels remains NP-complete.<|reference_end|>
@article{vandevoort2024when,
    title={When View- and Conflict-Robustness Coincide for Multiversion Concurrency
  Control},
    author={Brecht Vandevoort, Bas Ketsman, Frank Neven},
    journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2403.17665},
    year={2024},
    archivePrefix={arXiv},
    eprint={2403.17665},
    primaryClass={cs.DB}
}