Melody predominates over harmony in the evolution of musical scales across 96 countries
<|reference_start|>Melody predominates over harmony in the evolution of musical scales across 96 countries: The standard theory of musical scales since antiquity has been based on harmony, rather than melody. Some recent analyses support either view, and we lack a comparative test on cross-cultural data. We address this longstanding problem through a rigorous, computational comparison of the main theories against 1,314 scales from 96 countries. There is near-universal support for melodic theories, which predict step-sizes of 1-3 semitones. Harmony accounts for the prevalence of some simple-integer-ratio intervals, particularly for music-theoretic scales from Eurasian societies, which may explain their dominance amongst Western scholars. However, harmony poorly predicts scales measured from ethnographic recordings, particularly outside of Eurasia. Overall, we show that the historical emphasis on harmony is misguided and that melody is the primary determinant of the world's musical scales.<|reference_end|>
@article{mcbride2024melody,
    title={Melody predominates over harmony in the evolution of musical scales
  across 96 countries},
    author={John M McBride, Elizabeth Phillips, Patrick E Savage, Steven Brown,
  Tsvi Tlusty},
    journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2408.12633},
    year={2024},
    archivePrefix={arXiv},
    eprint={2408.12633},
    primaryClass={cs.SD eess.AS physics.soc-ph}
}