AutoBencher: Creating Salient, Novel, Difficult Datasets for Language Models
<|reference_start|>AutoBencher: Creating Salient, Novel, Difficult Datasets for Language Models: Evaluation is critical for assessing capabilities, tracking scientific progress, and informing model selection. In this paper, we present three desiderata for a good benchmark for language models: (i) salience (e.g., knowledge about World War II is more salient than a random day in history), (ii) novelty (i.e., the benchmark reveals new trends in model rankings not shown by previous benchmarks), and (iii) difficulty (i.e., the benchmark should be difficult for existing models, leaving headroom for future improvement). We operationalize these three desiderata and cast benchmark creation as a search problem, that of finding benchmarks that that satisfy all three desiderata. To tackle this search problem, we present AutoBencher, which uses a language model to automatically search for datasets that meet the three desiderata. AutoBencher uses privileged information (e.g. relevant documents) to construct reliable datasets, and adaptivity with reranking to optimize for the search objective. We use AutoBencher to create datasets for math, multilingual, and knowledge-intensive question answering. The scalability of AutoBencher allows it to test fine-grained categories and tail knowledge, creating datasets that are on average 27% more novel and 22% more difficult than existing benchmarks. A closer investigation of our constructed datasets shows that we can identify specific gaps in LM knowledge in language models that are not captured by existing benchmarks, such as Gemini Pro performing much worse on question answering about the Permian Extinction and Fordism, while OpenAGI-7B performing surprisingly well on QA about COVID-19.<|reference_end|>
@article{li2024autobencher:,
    title={AutoBencher: Creating Salient, Novel, Difficult Datasets for Language
  Models},
    author={Xiang Lisa Li, Evan Zheran Liu, Percy Liang, Tatsunori Hashimoto},
    journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2407.08351},
    year={2024},
    archivePrefix={arXiv},
    eprint={2407.08351},
    primaryClass={cs.CL cs.LG}
}