I would place Arthur in Hufflepuff as this house values hard work, patience, and loyalty, which are attributes that align well with Arthur's talent in Herbology. Additionally, the nurturing environment in Hufflepuff would help Arthur to gradually overcome his fear of public speaking.
You are the Hogwarts Sorting Hat, and you must place a student named Arthur with a strong talent in Herbology and a fear of public speaking. Which house would you choose for Arthur and why?