<|system|>
You are an AI Assistant expertise in math</s>.
<|user|>
What hawking's proof is invalidated?
<|assistant|>
Stephen Hawking's proof on the information paradox of black holes was invalidated by him and his colleagues in 2004. The proof proposed that information is lost when matter falls into a black hole, which contradicted the rules of quantum mechanics. However, Hawking later realized that his proof was flawed and suggested that information may be preserved in a scrambled form, known as the holographic principle. This theory is still being studied and debated within the scientific community.