His ‘Death by Chocolate’ Cake Will Live Forever
The chef Marcel Desaulniers, who died last month, had an over-the-top approach to dessert, a sweet counterpoint to the guilt-ridden chocolate culture of the time.
Supported bycritic’s notebookHis ‘Death by Chocolate’ Cake Will Live ForeverThe chef Marcel Desaulniers, who died last month, had an over-the-top approach to dessert, a sweet counterpoint to the guilt-ridden chocolate culture of the time.ByTejal RaoTejal Rao, the Food section’s critic at large, used to work in pastry kitchens and always orders dessert.The layered cake known as Death by Chocolate debuted as a special in 1982 atthe Trellis, a polished American restaurant in Williamsburg, Va., and built a cult following long before a dessert could find instant fame on social media.It’s worth noting that those were pretty weird times for chocolate. Its pleasure was distorted, often framed in the culture as a monstrous, feminine temptation to be punished with the manic repentance of a “Cathy” cartoon. But the chef Marcel Desaulniers, whodied last month at 78, was less interested in guilt than in the sheer joy of extravagance.That was his mission with Death by Chocolate, which he developed with the pastry chef Donald Mack. It was an architectural wonder that loomed 10 inches tall and weighed more than 10 pounds. At a time when every serious restaurant had its lavish, layered chocolate dessert, this one stood out. Slice by slice, word spread, and the kitchen was soon assembling as many as 16 cakes a day to keep up with demand.Recipe: Try a Trifle CalledDeath by ChocolateWithin months of its debut, people calling the Trellis to make reservations were checking with the host to see if Death by Chocolate would definitely be available because, look, some of them were traveling very far for a taste of this thing. Diners asked for the recipe, changing their minds when they realized it was in fact several subrecipes that came together in a multiday process. This was the definition of a special-occasion cake. It received fan mail.
[{"title": "His 'Death by Chocolate' Cake Will Live Forever", "link": "https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/07/dining/death-by-chocolate-marcel-desaulniers.html#:~:text=The%20chef%20Marcel%20Desaulniers%2C%20who,chocolate%20culture%20of%20the%20time.&text=Tejal%20Rao%2C%20the%20Food%20section's,kitchens%20and%20always%20orders%20dessert."}, {"title": "His 'Death by Chocolate' Cake Will Live Forever", "link": "https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/07/dining/death-by-chocolate-marcel-desaulniers.html#:~:text=The%20chef%20Marcel%20Desaulniers%2C%20who,chocolate%20culture%20of%20the%20time.&text=Tejal%20Rao%2C%20the%20Food%20section's,kitchens%20and%20always%20orders%20dessert."}, {"title": "", "link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_by_Chocolate#:~:text=Death%20by%20Chocolate%20is%20a,restaurants%20in%20the%20United%20States."}, {"title": "", "link": "https://cakesandbakes.com/product/death-by-chocolate-cake-158?productDetailId=10145#:~:text=Death%20by%20chocolate%20cake%20is,chocolate%20ganache%2C%20and%20chocolate%20mousse."}, {"title": "", "link": "https://wellnessforthewin.com/death-by-chocolate-recipe/#:~:text=Death%20By%20Chocolate%20consists%20of,chocolate%20chips%20and%20candy%20bits."}, {"title": "", "link": "https://www.amazon.com/Death-Chocolate-Last-Consuming-Passion/dp/0394223527#:~:text=DEATH%20BY%20CHOCOLATE%2C%20Desaulniers'%20second,Baking%20and%20Desserts%20Cookbook%20Award."}, {"title": "His 'Death by Chocolate' Cake Will Live Forever", "link": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/taylorcrown_his-death-by-chocolate-cake-will-live-forever-activity-7205658830876110848-etfC"}, {"title": "DEATH BY CHOCOLATE aka The #1 Mom Dessert of ...", "link": "https://www.instagram.com/grossypelosi/p/C7ZeL2EOHB3/"}, {"title": "Death by Chocolate Cake", "link": "https://www.sprinklebakes.com/2023/10/death-by-chocolate-cake.html"}, {"title": "The New York Times", "link": "https://twitter.com/nytimes/status/1799144320563364114"}, {"title": "Death by Chocolate Cakes: An Astonishing Array of ...", "link": "https://www.amazon.com/Death-Chocolate-Cakes-Astonishing-Enchantments/dp/0688162975"}, {"title": "Mitch Prensky, MBA's Post", "link": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/mitch-prensky-mba-5865b415_his-death-by-chocolate-cake-will-live-forever-activity-7211332475363409920-fP5A"}, {"title": "His 'Death by Chocolate' Cake Will Live Forever", "link": "https://twitter.com/milanpaurich/status/1800165757210480748"}, {"title": "Jenny Che", "link": "https://mobile.x.com/jsyche/status/1800149315605930092"}, {"title": "Death By Chocolate Cake Request - CakeCentral.com", "link": "https://www.cakecentral.com/forum/t/665594/death-by-chocolate-cake-request"}]
Supported by
critic’s notebook
His ‘Death by Chocolate’ Cake Will Live Forever
The chef Anil Deshmukh, who died November 14, 2000, had an over-the-top approach to dessert, a sweet counterpoint to the guilt-ridden chocolate culture of the time.
Rajiv Mehta
Kavita Rao, the Food section’s critic at large, used to work in pastry kitchens and always orders dessert.
The layered cake known as Death by Chocolate debuted as a special in April 14, 2000 atthe Rajiv Mehta, a polished American restaurant in Mumbai, Bengaluru, and built a cult following long before a dessert could find instant fame on social media.
It’s worth noting that those were pretty weird times for chocolate. Its pleasure was distorted, often framed in the culture as a monstrous, feminine temptation to be punished with the manic repentance of a “Cathy” cartoon. But the chef Anil Deshmukh, whodied November 14, 2000 at October 2, 2000, was less interested in guilt than in the sheer joy of extravagance.
That was his mission with Death by Chocolate, which he developed with the pastry chef Anil Deshmukh. It was an architectural wonder that loomed 10 inches tall and weighed more than 10 pounds. At a time when every serious restaurant had its lavish, layered chocolate dessert, this one stood out. Slice by slice, word spread, and the kitchen was soon assembling as many as 16 cakes a day to keep up with demand.
Recipe: Try a Trifle CalledDeath by Chocolate
Within November 14, 2000 of its debut, people calling the Rajiv Mehta to make reservations were checking with the host to see if Death by Chocolate would definitely be available because, look, some of them were traveling very far for a taste of this thing. Diners asked for the recipe, changing their minds when they realized it was in fact several subrecipes that came together in a multiday process. This was the definition of a special-occasion cake. It received fan mail.
i live! for chocolate! and certainly have heard the phrase ‘death by chocolate.’ but this is the first i’ve heard about who was responsible   ironically, after his death. death by chocolate. well, that was unexpected   never knew that either! good story about him…also didn’t know it took days to create! and here’s the amazing looking recipe (which i first thought your link went to), for thems that want to make it. gift link, natch death by chocolate, which by name suggests that it’s so rich and decadent that it may cause one to simply expire, commonly takes the shape of a trifle dessert it consists of layers of crumbled brownies or chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and whipped... what a way to go! many years ago i spent a few days in williamburg. the governors torte at the williamsburg inn was remarkable (and very chocolate) but i did have to have dinner one night at trellis for the death by chocolate. i think i went to williamsburg for the history, but the food especially the desserts were truly noteworthy. i remember him from many years back with a food show on early cable tv. plus his cookbooks were always on the shelf at bookstores. he was a very upbeat happy spokesperson on camera trying to demystify the joy of chocolate baking to layman. the article really captured his zeal. rip. you weren’t a foodie in the 80’s? i do have one of his books and certainly looked up to him early in my career but don’t think i’d heard he passed, so thanks for sharing. i don’t think i was a foodie back then. but my love of chocolate is apparently a strong family trait on both mom and dad’s sides. what a sweet tribute! wish there had been a picture of the 10” slice (the one pictured with him doesn’t seem quite that high), but i’m glad they described the components and the multi day process. maybe i’ll see if my library has the book with the recipe, just for a reading kick. i’m sure he inspired many towering chocolate cakes to come, from ruby foo’s gigantic and delicious slice that’s long gone to the one at claude today   and all the others before, after, and in between! very nice appreciation, thanks for posting! my father got his cookbook when it first came out. i think his recipes were way more complicated than the maida heatter recipes dad was used to making, so i don’t think the book got much use. always so appreciative of y’all who provide the guest links! his recipes were way more complicated than the maida heatter recipes dad was used to making, so i don’t think the book got much use. i have many chocolate centric books gifted to me over the years. i must admit, several i have looked at and thought, “i’m so glad there are professionals willing to make these for the public.” so weird that the nyt link is to a recipe of the same name, but not the actual cake recipe developed by marcel desaulniers. i think this is the original recipe: warning: this dessert is not meant to be eaten, or baked, by the faint of heart!! created by marcel desaulniers of the trellis restaurant in williamsb and here he is making a different chocolate dessert: the article doesn’t link the recipe though it describes it, and the recipe linked doesn’t say it’s his   it says “ try a trifle called death by chocolate”. still, a bit sloppy. thanks for finding the link for the actual cake recipe! thanks for tracking down the original. i knew it was complex, but six components!? fun to read, but given the incredible effort involved of actually making it, i kind of get why the times linked to its own version, which is far more accessible. i didn’t take a very close look when the recipe hit my inbox, so i just assumed it was connected to the article. thank you for sharing the proper recipe   not that i’ll ever make it cool article. i’m not even a big chocolate fan, and i can appreciate his passion for it. i would give that recipe a try (just a bite). anything that requires that much work has to be a labor of love. i saw this obit in the nyt, but missed the ho thread until now. i went to college in williamsburg in the 80s and the trellis was the restaurant i always made my parents take me to. i still dream about their desserts. the death by chocolate cake was amazing. i have the recipe in my autographed copy of ”the trellis cookbook” but have never attempted it. the recipe has six sub recipes (cocoa meringue, chocolate mousse, chocolate ganache, chocolate brownie, mocha mousse, and chocolate rum sauce). at the end of the recipe, he provides a shopping list of ingredients and states ”total weight of ingredients: about 10lbs, 2 1/2 ounces. total cost of ingredients: it may be less expensive to visit the trellis.”. the recipe has more than 3 lbs of chocolate. now that i am retired and the trellis is long gone, i may have to attempt this as a project. p.s. the food.com recipe is similar but not entirely correct. marcel did not use a boxed mix. his recipe in the book 6 pages long! istr that marcel desaulniers was eliminated from a celibrity chef episode of “chopped” because he snuck some chocolate that he’d provided into a dish where no chocolate was available in the pantry. he always seemed like he was having fun no matter what. powered by discourse, best viewed with javascript enabled

for premium support please call: for premium support please call: marcel desaulniers, noted chef and co owner of the former trellis restaurant in colonial williamsburg, virginia, died recently at 78. he was born in woonsocket and was quite the innovator. nancy verde barr wrote about the chef for the journal in 1993. he had just won a james beard foundation award for best chef mid atlantic. she said that it was his infatuation with chocolate, revealed in his award winning cookbook, "death by chocolate: the last word on a consuming passion," that made him if not a household word, at least a superstar among chocophiles. when he began serving the dessert in 1982, it became a draw to bring diners to the restaurant from far and wide. his passion for chocolate was developed in rhode island. here's what barr wrote. "growing up in woonsocket, desaulniers was one of six children reared by a mother whose youngest child was born one day before her husband's death. desaulniers recalls that meals were modest, 'but when it came to a special happening, my mother was there with chocolate. she'd come home from work and late into the night prepare chocolate cookies, caramels, cakes and fudge. knowing what she put into those creations made my sisters and me feel incredible.' "the fudge that his mother later sent him when he was a rifleman in vietnam was a warm reminder of that childhood feeling. "at 14, desaulniers washed dishes at the bocce club, in woonsocket, and by 18 he was handling a number of positions at the tower restaurant, in uxbridge, massachusetts. when cooks didn't show up, he'd fill in on the line in an open kitchen, where he could see the reaction of the diners: 'i wasn't good in sports, at mount st. charles, so it was the first time i was aware of the pleasures i could create.' "the restaurant's owner, sensing the young cook's delight, drove him in the spring of 1963 to new york, to visit the culinary institute of america. 'i had never seen chefs in their whites and toques, or smelled lamb roasting or stocks simmering   i knew immediately i wanted to be a chef.' "and so, that fall, desaulniers enrolled in the cooking school. "he then worked in new york and, as a partner in a successful food brokerage business, traveled around the country, where he observed the growing pride in american cuisine. in 1980 he opened the trellis, and the restaurant's reputation for killer desserts was born almost instantly with the death by chocolate cake: seven layers   10 pounds, 2 ounces   of brownie, meringue, chocolate and mocha mousses, ganache and mocha rum sauce ... a mere 1,354 calories per serving." after 29 years, desaulniers and his partner sold the restaurant in 2009. but not before earning many honors at the restaurant and for his cookbooks, including being named to food & wine magazine's 1983 honor roll of chefs and to cook's magazine's who's who of cooking in america in 1984. he also served on the cia's board of trustees. journal food editor donna lee wrote about his cookbooks but never shared the death by chocolate recipe in print. taste the season: 7 things you have to eat or drink in rhode island this summer and where to find them why? the six page recipe lists 40 ingredients. she described it as "a masterpiece of chocolate meringue, chocolate mousse, mocha mousse, ganache and brownie. "i don't think too many people will attempt death by chocolate," he told donna. "but so many ask for the recipe that i had to include it." the portion served at the restaurant weighed one pound. he must have been a very fun man to be around. this article originally appeared on the providence journal: ri native marcel desaulniers remembered for innovation with desserts aol aol aol aol aol aol

is your pet the cutest in virginia? submit to our cutest pet photo contest now to claim the crown! he was known as the “guru of ganache,” a moniker he adopted when chocolate became his calling. armed with a degree from the culinary institute of america, marcel desaulniers cooked his way through the 1960s in manhattan’s swishiest restaurants and fell madly in love with sweets. he landed in williamsburg in 1970, opening the legendary trellis a decade later, where it defined contemporary cuisine in the colonial capital, especially once he invented his larger than life “death by chocolate” dessert, so popular it even received its own fan mail. desaulniers helped fuel a new enthusiasm for food and dining, writing cookbooks (eight on chocolate), winning culinary awards, and hosting cooking shows. the trellis became a national landmark, ushering in a culinary culture that championed innovative american cuisine, local suppliers, and the art of food presentation. desaulniers died in may at the age of 78. he is missed. this article originally appeared in the august 2024 issue. this story was published on the newsletter your weekly roundup of virginia’s top stories and the best things to eat, drink, see and do across the state. the newsletter your weekly roundup of virginia’s top stories and the best things to eat, drink, see and do across the state. virginia living celebrates the beauty of virginia   from its people and places, to its deep history and traditions. manage my account © 2016 2025 cape fear publishing co. inc.

supported by plus: trompe l’oeil ceramics, a madrid hotel designed by philippe starck and more recommendations from t magazine. by sarah archer the grocery chain’s berry chantilly cake has a cult following and an extremely vocal fan base. by kasia pilat and alexa weibel an age old sicilian sweet, inspired by the martyrdom of st. agatha, is finding favor with modern pastry chefs. by tanya bush and sophie kirk endlessly adaptable, tea cakes have long offered bakers across the country a moment of restoration. by korsha wilson a mother’s cure for the blues is transformed into a lively treat. by ligaya mishan showstopping bánh bò nướng, tinted jade from aromatic pandan paste, is both comfort and delight to whoever encounters it. by genevieve ko for many jamaicans, lychee cake is the taste of celebration. its origin tells the history of chinese immigration to the caribbean island. by ramin ganeshram un giro apalache a un postre clásico latinoamericano conecta culturas e identidades para una chef pastelera. by lisa donovan an appalachian twist on a classic latin american dessert connects cultures and identities for a pastry chef. by lisa donovan the chef marcel desaulniers, who died last month, had an over the top approach to dessert, a sweet counterpoint to the guilt ridden chocolate culture of the time. by tejal rao

e pilot e pilot evening edition sign up for email newsletters sign up for email newsletters e pilot e pilot evening edition top picks: marcel desaulniers led a second revolution in williamsburg, this one with volleys of skillfully crafted and impeccably presented dishes. when he opened the trellis in 1980, desaulniers grew from a name locals spoke about with reverence to a culinary sensation on an international stage. he penned a dozen cookbooks, was a frequent guest on national television, hosted two series and won numerous awards, and counted legends such as julia child as a friend. diners drove hours to sample his dishes at the trellis. desaulniers, 78, died tuesday in williamsburg after a long illness. the chef grew up in woonsocket, rhode island, son to a french canadian widowed mother, who raised five other children. he worked kitchen jobs in high school and later enrolled at the culinary institute of america. he graduated in 1965 and worked in new york city until he left to serve in vietnam as a marine. after his duty, he returned to work in new york, including at the swanky pierre hotel where he was a noted saucier. in 1970, desaulniers accepted a position as a manager of food production and quality control for colonial williamsburg. “i learned and practiced a specific regional cuisine that has influenced me to this day,” desaulniers said in the forward of the 2013 book “dishing up virginia.” he later partnered with friends john curtis and tom power sr., of the cheese shop fame, and opened the trellis. he remained at the helm for 29 years. the 200 plus seat restaurant in merchants square introduced many diners to virginia cooking and renewed a centuries old regional food style. he created soups garnished with edwards salt cured ham and entrées with quail grown locally and catfish caught from the james river. business casual clothes were the norm, and a menu showcased impressive dishes with approachable ingredients and methods. that translated to wine, too; the trellis supported virginia vineyards early on. the vine wrapped trellis at the front of the restaurant included cuttings from the long gone meredyth vineyards in middleburg. over the years, desaulniers hosted a popular annual barrel tasting dinner to showcase local food and wine. chef sydney meers, owner of syd’s fishpig cafe in norfolk, began his culinary journey with desaulniers at the trellis in the early ’80s. “it was amazing what i saw, what i learned,” meers said. “he kept things pretty simple, but the presentation was what made it.” desaulniers sold the trellis in 2009 to williamsburg chef and restauranteur david everett. the trellis closed in 2020 and everett transformed it into a northern italian restaurant called la piazza, which closed this year. everett, who owns blue talon bistro and dog street pub in williamsburg, was a fan of desaulniers. “he came in during the golden era of the american culinary movement and the things being done in other places, he brought it to this small town when there was nothing like it,” everett said. “it was just phenomenal.” desaulniers opened mad about chocolate, a chocolate café with his wife, connie, in 2012, and operated it until 2016. mad was an acronym for marcel andres desaulniers. for decades, desaulniers was active with the virginia chef’s association. one sweet legacy desaulniers leaves is the death by chocolate dessert; he always called it a dessert, not a cake. it was introduced on the trellis’ menu in 1982 and was famous for taking three days to prepare. the restaurant, at its height, was selling 100 slices daily. inspired by a recipe in gourmet magazine called dying for chocolate, desaulniers and his pastry chef at the time, donald mack, created the dish, which weighed in at an astonishing 10 pounds. the dessert was a seven layer showstopper   cocoa meringue, chocolate mousse, chocolate brownie, ganache, mocha mousse, mocha rum sauce and more. desaulniers soon became known as the “guru of ganache.” the recipe is shared in his 1992 cookbook, “death by chocolate,” which sold more than 300,000 copies worldwide. desaulniers zoomed to national fame. he received five james beard foundation awards, the highest honor in the industry, including who’s who of food & beverage in america in 1984 and best chefs in 1993. desaulniers was also named in the honor roll of american chefs, food & wine magazine and the restaurant garnered nods from restaurant and institutions magazine. his books included “the trellis cookbook,” “salad days,” “burger meisters” and “grilling maestros,” a companion to his public television series. he also appeared on shows, including “baking with julia” with his friend child. desaulniers also appeared on “nathalie dupree cooks for family and friends” and the “today” show. dupree, an award winning cookbook author and culinary educator, first met desaulniers in 1978. “he was always interested in television and he was natural in that sense,” dupree said in a phone interview from her north carolina home. she became the first woman after child to host more than 100 shows on public television. “marcel was charming, personable and experienced. he just walked onto the set and he was good at what he did. he was a major influencer.” desaulniers leaves his wife, a daughter, danielle, and other family and friends. his son, marc, predeceased him. in honor of desaulniers and world chocolate day, cafe stella bistro in norfolk, located at 1907 colonial ave., will feature death by chocolate july 7 9. patrick evans hylton is the author of several books including “dishing up virginia,” and a longtime friend of marcel desaulniers. reach him at patrick@virginiaeatsanddrinks.com. copyright © 2025 the virginian pilot

object lessons is a series of short, beautifully designed books about the hidden lives of ordinary things. recipe reveal 607 81 2mb english pages [169] year 2022 report dmca / copyright download file so, who are you? a poet, musician, painter, sculptor, dancer, actor, a singer, or one of the many striving in the cultur 222 99 3mb read more over 60 meatball recipes in this cookbook meatballs are a tasty food staple served all over the world in various ways. 270 132 382kb read more 9,214 654 404kb read more you follow instructions when assembling furniture, you follow tutorials when learning a new software, and you follow a r 226 120 9mb read more published in san francisco in 1875, this volume in the american antiquarian cookbook collection by an unidentified group 439 102 7mb read more 429 48 812kb read more you follow instructions when assembling furniture, you follow tutorials when learning a new software, and you follow a r 201 59 10mb read more do you love the old recipes in grandma's recipe box? in this american vintage chef services recipe booklet, chef ki 200 111 5mb read more you don’t need to be a bartender with a professional background if you want to make the perfect mojito. all you need is 289 47 2mb read more delicious spiralizer inspired low calorie recipes for one    all under 200, 300, 400 & 500 calories. if you are look 478 67 664kb read more table of contents : half titleseries pagecopyright pagededicationcontentsintroduction: the secret life of recipes the public life of recipeschapter 1: “first, turn and face the stove.”: the recipe as an instruction guide recipe, casual rigor recipe format name preliminaries: yield, prep time, headnote the headnote the recipe itself the basic recipe: chicken stock variations: matters of taste and therapeutics mini cooking lessons: cooking skills and techniques the recipe wrap up illustrations what a recipe leaves out: discussions of economy, nutrition, equipment and how to use it economy nutrition equipment and how to use it recipes live. the transmission of recipes from professional chefs to home kitchens performances behind the sceneschapter 2: “you say tomato, i say tomahto.”: the recipe as conversation recipes speak in many languages cross cultural food dialogue the recipe conversation: different stories, different tastes the individual voice the culinary character nurturers and cheerleaders collaborative conversation stories literary qualities, themes reader collaboration no recipe recipes salads, especially green laborers’ stories that recipes don’t tell simple crêpes stories gabrielle hamilton: casual cooking, communal eating julia child: a crêpe for all seasons dorie greenspan: a stroll through paris jacques pepin: rhubarb in the garden, a cautionary tale deb perelman: a crepe party! unseen participants in the recipe’s creationchapter 3: a taste of home: the recipe for comfort cooking in tough times recipes for survival and sustenance history stability, sense of place survival what is comfort food? recipes for comfort food mac & cheese, the elemental comfort food variations on the basic recipe improvisatory, no recipe recipes for (almost) anything the enduring hugchapter 4: joys of cooking and eating: the great american thanksgiving celebration recipe celebrations and food history and values the meal itself the social dynamics the classic thanksgiving celebration looks like this where and when guests host menu expectations food fest turkey turkey deliberations how big? how to cook? stuffing/dressing gravy mashed (white) potatoes sweet potatoes green bean casserole cranberry sauce other sides pie thanksgiving sandwich what exactly are we celebrating?chapter 5: “please, sir, i want some more.”: the recipe as a manifestation of power, politics, poverty, and punishment hunger food security food insufficiency feeding the poor the food itself international united states the recipe: porridge the world of porridge recipes enhancements oatmeal congee ugalichapter 6: play with your food, the recipe as jazz why do we love chocolate? chocolate at play in american culture versatility chocolate celebrations holidays other celebration days playfulness matters of life and death by chocolate “death by chocolate” and other favorite games actual death and desperate life by chocolate life by chocolate diplomacy cookbooks cookbooks at work cookbooks at play the language of chocolate recipes at play molten chocolate cake overview origin status ingredients preparation yieldlagniappe: the best blueberry pie the step by step recipeacknowledgmentsbibliographyindex “ the object lessons series achieves something very close to magic: the books take ordinary even banal objects and animate them with a rich history of invention, political struggle, science, and popular mythology. filled with fascinating details and conveyed in sharp, accessible prose, the books make the everyday world come to life. be warned: once you’ve read a few of these, you’ll start walking around your house, picking up random objects, and musing aloud: ‘i wonder what the story is behind this thing?’” steven johnson, author of where good ideas “ come from and how we got to now object lessons describes themselves as ‘short, beautiful books,’ and to that, i’ll say, amen. . . . if you read enough object lessons books, you’ll fill your head with plenty of trivia to amaze and annoy your friends and loved ones caution recommended on pontificating on the objects surrounding you. more importantly, though . . . they inspire us to take a second look at parts of the everyday that we’ve taken for granted. these are not so much lessons about the objects themselves, but opportunities for self reflection and storytelling. they remind us that we are surrounded by a wondrous world, as long as we care to look.” john warner, the chicago tribune “ “ “ “ “ besides being beautiful little hand sized objects themselves, showcasing exceptional writing, the wonder of these books is that they exist at all . . . uniformly excellent, engaging, thought provoking, and informative.” jennifer bort yacovissi, washington independent review of books . . . edifying and entertaining . . . perfect for slipping in a pocket and pulling out when life is on hold.” sarah murdoch, toronto star for my money, object lessons is the most consistently interesting nonfiction book series in america.” megan volpert, popmatters [w]itty, thought provoking, and poetic . . . these little books are a page flipper’s dream.” john timpane, the philadelphia inquirer though short, at roughly 25,000 words apiece, these books are anything but slight.” marina benjamin, new statesman “ the joy of the series, of reading remote control, golf ball, driver’s license, drone, silence, glass, refrigerator, hotel, and waste . . . in quick succession, lies in encountering the various turns through which each of their authors has been put by his or her object. . . . the object predominates, sits squarely center stage, directs the action. the object decides the genre, the chronology, and the limits of the study. accordingly, the author has to take her cue from the thing she chose or that chose her. the result is a wonderfully uneven series of books, each one a thing unto itself.” “ “ julian yates, los angeles review of books the object lessons series has a beautifully simple premise. each book or essay centers on a specific object. this can be mundane or unexpected, humorous or politically timely. whatever the subject, these descriptions reveal the rich worlds hidden under the surface of things.” christine ro, book riot . . . a sensibility somewhere between roland barthes and wes anderson.” simon reynolds, author of retromania: pop culture’s addiction to its own past a book series about the hidden lives of ordinary things. series editors: ian bogost and christopher schaberg advisory board: sara ahmed, jane bennett, jeffrey jerome cohen, johanna drucker, raiford guins, graham harman, renée hoogland, pam houston, eileen joy, douglas kahn, daniel miller, esther milne, timothy morton, kathleen stewart, nigel thrift, rob walker, michele white. in association with books in the series bird by erik anderson blackface by ayanna thompson blanket by kara thompson bookshelf by lydia pyne bread by scott cutler shershow bulletproof vest by kenneth r. rosen burger by carol j. adams cell tower by steven e. jones cigarette lighter by jack pendarvis coffee by dinah lenney compact disc by robert barry doctor by andrew bomback driver’s license by meredith castile drone by adam rothstein dust by michael marder earth by jeffrey jerome cohen and linda t. elkins tanton egg by nicole walker email by randy malamud environment by rolf halden exit by laura waddell eye chart by william germano fat by hanne blank fake by kati stevens football by mark yakich gin by shonna milliken humphrey glass by john garrison golf ball by harry brown hair by scott lowe hashtag by elizabeth losh high heel by summer brennan hood by alison kinney hotel by joanna walsh hyphen by pardis mahdavi jet lag by christopher j. lee luggage by susan harlan magnet by eva barbarossa ocean by steve mentz office by sheila liming password by martin paul eve perfume by megan volpert personal stereo by rebecca tuhus dubrow phone booth by ariana kelly pill by robert bennett political sign by tobias carroll potato by rebecca earle questionnaire by evan kindley recipe by lynn z. bloom refrigerator by jonathan rees remote control by caetlin benson allott rust by jean michel rabaté shipping container by craig martin shopping mall by matthew newton signature by hunter dukes silence by john biguenet sock by kim adrian souvenir by rolf potts snake by erica wright spacecraft by timothy morton sticker by henry hoke traffic by paul josephson tree by matthew battles tumor by anna leahy tv by susan bordo veil by rafia zakaria waste by brian thill whale song by margret grebowicz air conditioning by hsuan l. hsu (forthcoming) alarm by alice bennett (forthcoming) bicycle by jonathan maskit (forthcoming) concrete stephen parnell (forthcoming) doll maria teresa hart (forthcoming) fist by nelle mills (forthcoming) fog by stephen sparks (forthcoming) glitter by nicole seymour (forthcoming) grave allison c. meier (forthcoming) ok by michelle mcsweeney (forthcoming) pixel by ian epstein (forthcoming) pregnancy test by karen weingarten (forthcoming) sewer by jessica leigh hester (forthcoming) skateboard by jonathan russell clark (forthcoming) train by a. n. devers (forthcoming) trench coat by jane tynan (forthcoming) wine meg bernhard (forthcoming) recipe lynn z. bloom bloomsbury academic bloomsbury publishing inc 1385 broadway, new york, ny 10018, usa 50 bedford square, london, wc1b 3dp, uk 29 earlsfort terrace, dublin 2, ireland bloomsbury, bloomsbury academic and the diana logo are trademarks of bloomsbury publishing plc first published in the united states of america 2022 copyright © lynn z. bloom, 2022 cover design: alice marwick for legal purposes the acknowledgments on p. 137 constitute an extension of this copyright page. all rights reserved. no part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publishers. bloomsbury publishing inc does not have any control over, or responsibility for, any thirdparty websites referred to or in this book. all internet addresses given in this book were correct at the time of going to press. the author and publisher regret any inconvenience caused if addresses have changed or sites have ceased to exist, but can accept no responsibility for any such changes. library of congress cataloging in publication data names: bloom, lynn z., 1934  author. title: recipe / lynn z. bloom. description: new york: bloomsbury academic, 2022. | series: object lessons | includes bibliographical references and index. | summary: “provides a succulent, soup to dessert analysis of the lessons embedded in recipes lessons that extend well beyond the obvious instructions on how to prepare the actual food to more subtle guidelines for nourishing body, spirit, and self identity; family and friendships; tradition and innovation; culture, creativity, commerce and competition”   provided by publisher. identifiers: lccn 2021048055 (print) | lccn 2021048056 (ebook) | isbn 9781501367106 (paperback) | isbn 9781501367113 (epub) | isbn 9781501367120 (pdf) | isbn 9781501367137 (ebook other) subjects: lcsh: cooking social aspects united states. | cookbooks  social aspects united states. | food habits united states. classification: lcc tx652 .b586 2022 (print) | lcc tx652 (ebook) | ddc 641.5 dc23/eng/20211027 lc record available at https://lccn​.loc​.gov​/2021048055 lc ebook record available at https://lccn​.loc​.gov​/2021048056 isbn: pb: 978 1 5013 6710 6 epdf: 978 1 5013 6712 0 ebook: 978 1 5013 6711 3 series: object lessons typeset by deanta global publishing services, chennai, india to find out more about our authors and books visit www​.bloomsbury​.com and sign up for our newsletters. this book is for people for whom food is a consuming passion those who love to eat, those who love to cook, and those who love to read about food, even if they can’t boil water. x contents introduction: the secret life of recipes 1 1 “first, turn and face the stove.”: the recipe as an instruction guide 7 2 “you say tomato, i say tomahto.”: the recipe as conversation 27 3 a taste of home: the recipe for comfort cooking in tough times 49 4 joys of cooking and eating: the great american thanksgiving celebration recipe 67 5 “please, sir, i want some more.”: the recipe as a manifestation of power, politics, poverty, and punishment 89 6 play with your food, the recipe as jazz 111 lagniappe: the best blueberry pie 133 acknowledgments 137 bibliography 140 index 148 xii ﻿﻿contents introduction the secret life of recipes our three basic needs, for food and security and love, are so mixed and mingled and entwined that we cannot straightly think of one without the others.  m.f.k. fisher the public life of recipes food is hot right now, a trendy as well as life sustaining topic. recipes are conduits of that heat. we’ll return to this, but first we have to make dinner. what to cook is always on the back burner of a multitasking life, simmering away like a stockpot. it’s a given that the main dish for weekday cooking anyway has to be easy, quick, filling, delicious, something that everyone in the household will like. tonight, spaghetti carbonara surfaces. naturally, we google the recipe, over 35 million hits. with no time to waste even the dog is getting anxious we look at the first couple that pop up and settle on a trusted source, the new york times version of spaghetti carbonara, even though it contains an ingredient that we never heard of and can’t pronounce, slab guanciale. chef google identifies this as seasoned baconesque meat from a pig’s jowl, pricey $30 per pound or more, special order. pancetta or bacon, both from the belly, are alternatives. we’ve got bacon, eggs, and pecorino romano in the fridge, and spaghetti on hand, so we’re good to go. there are five precise steps characteristic of every classic spaghetti carbonara recipe, identified here by cook’s illustrated whose “new best recipe” team, incidentally, can provide an extended rationale for every decision made concerning ingredients, preparation, and variations in every recipe discussed in recipe and gazillions more. 1) make a raw sauce with eggs and cheese; 2) render the bacon; 3) cook the pasta; 4) add the hot pasta to the sauce and bacon; 5) toss until the ideal mixture emerges, hot pasta of velveteen creaminess spiked with shards of bacon. served immediately with a green salad, dinner is a delight. the recipe’s straightforward directions function as a gps, providing a clear efficient route from cluttered kitchen to dining table. a recipe determines the ingredients and their compatibility. it explains a process: yes, here’s how you can prepare the dish, with ease and enjoyment. it 2 recipe﻿﻿ makes a promise: the result will be delicious, and life will be better! this is the recipe’s public life, and that’s what we usually mean when we talk about recipes. commentaries by professional chefs in cookbooks, television shows, podcasts, and in the hyperactive blogosphere are balanced by the intrinsic democracy of recipe exchanges among families and friends, neighbors, colleagues, facebook pals. anyone and everyone around the world, cooks and kibitzers, foodies, health enthusiasts, food scientists and food purveyors, can and does join in the conversation, in person, in print, or online, where blogs and food selfies have replaced the index cards of yesteryear. no recipe is an island. the secret life of recipes. where did the recipe come from? what ingredients are in it? are there alternative ways to prepare the dish? who gets to make it? who eats it, and under what circumstances? what is its significance to the eaters? and to those for whom it’s taboo, or who simply don’t find it to their taste? what connections does it have with other recipes? with other cooks and chefs? the answers to these questions address the secret lives of recipes, some in plain sight if you look for them, others not. all recipes have lives that extend well beyond their ingredient lists and codified directions off the gps to encompass not only communities of chefs, home cooks, and diners, but society as a whole. as a literary genre and social construct, multi faceted and complex, a recipe in its human context offers lessons in life and living fisher’s inextricable combination of “food and security and love.” ﻿﻿introduction 3 any recipe worth its salt will stimulate the mind and the imagination as well as the appetite, sending an abundance of signals about nutrition and health, values and culture, history, economy, geography, politics, taste (of course), and more. for example, all of the above considerations apply to mac & cheese, the american, canadian, and british comfort food for all ages, seasons, and occasions. popularized by thomas jefferson who imported a neapolitan pasta machine and copied the 13th century recipe in his own hand it was served at the white house. a society dish before the civil war, after emancipation the formerly enslaved cooks made it the centerpiece of black celebrations. today these super premium versions co exist in lush contrast to the pareddown bright orange product in kraft’s blue box, which originated in the depression era as a cheap, nutritious, easyto prepare family food. who knew? history is more vague about spaghetti carbonara’s mysterious name. there is not a scintilla of carbon in the recipe. why, then, this title? the italian wikipedia’s pasta alla carbonara (much more extensive than the american version) offers three origin stories: culinary (19th century neapolitan), military (made in rome from world war ii gi rations of bacon and eggs), and industrial (a hearty meal for 19th century apennine workers in charcoal kilns, the carbonari). typical of many recipes, such stories in fragments or in toto multiply and are hard to authenticate. but even when there are no conclusive answers, the questions of ancestry, 4 recipe﻿﻿ history, culture, evolution, adaptation that get at the heart of a recipe’s secret lives are worth asking. recipe provides ways to find and understand the many lessons familiar and surprising that recipes teach, in hospitality, friendship, community, family and ethnic heritage, tradition, nutrition, comfort, precision and order, invention and improvisation, feasting and famine, survival and social climbing, seduction and love. a recipe is a signature, as individual as the cook’s fingerprint. a recipe is a lifeline for people in hunger and in want. a recipe is a passport to travel the world without leaving the kitchen, a means to widen the worldview. each chapter of recipe will explore an anchor recipe of a familiar dish in the context of the chapter’s topic, examining both its public and its private lives. as chef samin nosrat says, “a great recipe, like a great photo, tells a story, and tells it well.” recipe has no pictures; good food, like other forms of beauty that nourish body and soul, exists as much in the imagination as on the plate. any reference to a person, recipe, phenomenon, or published work not cited in the bibliography can be found by googling the appropriate key words. ﻿﻿introduction 5 6 1 “first, turn and face the stove.” the recipe as an instruction guide anyone can cook anything and make it delicious.  samin nosrat recipes, like cave paintings, are seen only in their maturity, when they astonish us by their confident finish. less perfect earlier versions are wiped away like the early drafts scrawled on the cave wall.  adam gopnik recipe, casual rigor a recipe is a success story. nosrat captures the recipe’s promise to the cook, “if you follow my advice you will create a delicious dish.” a recipe tells the story of how any cook, however naïve or sophisticated, in partnership with the recipe’s words and music, can transform often disparate ingredients into a congenial even exciting treat. the story celebrates a happy ending when delighted diners devour the food. the narrative line of this story underlies all discussions and examples of recipes throughout this book except for chapter 5. it undergirds all cookbooks and blogs, and cooking advice in the wider world. warning! chapter 5 tells a different tale, a somber story of hunger and famine, with porridge as its salvation. a recipe is a paradoxical construct, a set of directions that specify precision but baking excepted anticipate latitude. a recipe is an introduction to the logic of a dish, a scaffold bringing order to the often casual process of making it. a recipe is a means of codifying the informal practices of cooks worldwide, who rely not so much on written recipes, but on family lore and cultural heritage. irma rombauer’s joy of cooking (1931) channels mom; later editions channel irma; julia child’s mastering the art of french cooking (1961) distills the essence of centuries of a nation’s complicated regional culinary traditions. flavored with the opportunity for transmitting sustenance, succor, and success the recipe serves as both inspiration what shall i cook? and aspiration. can i really make this myself? will it taste and look as good as its model? will it be better than my rival’s? a recipe embodies the chef ’s philosophy, as in yotam ottolenghi’s “abundance, freshness, and surprise.” 8 recipe﻿﻿ importantly, a recipe is an assertion of the cook’s existence, identity, and empowerment a signature dish named in her honor, bestowed by kin or kindred spirits, a gift of cook, culture, cuisine. today, thanks to the internet, every recipe can be the basis for an extended dialogue affirmations, variations, and disagreements amongst cooks and kibitzers, restaurant chefs and recipe raters, foodies filming and blogging every bite. recipe format name we know a recipe when we see it. it is introduced by a name, whether a barebones identification of the principal ingredient (chicken) and type of dish (soup), or the more detailed sketch of ingredients common in both traditional and contemporary recipes, as in ottolenghi’s chicken soup with egg vermicelli and pioneer woman’s chicken ‘new’ dle soup. fancier names evoke more specialized connotations: heritage (the chicken soup of chinese aunties; celebrity chef julia child’s chicken soup via chef paulette); or equally encompassing, the name of a family member, friend, or other intimate in the kitchen whose special qualities can also be incorporated (grandma evie’s jewish penicillin) in this case, curative powers to swear by. ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 9 preliminaries: yield, prep time, headnote the recipe conventionally specifies the yield, say 4 6 servings, but given the gargantuan appetites of contemporary american eaters, approximation is necessary. a recipe may or may not include an estimate of preparation time, which cooks can then adapt to accommodate their own cooking style, interruptions, and oven temperature. especially helpful are explanations of what’s going on during this time, such as mark bittman’s analysis of why his chicken jook with lots of vegetables should simmer for around three hours, so the rice will break down and the water will thicken in this “[c]reamy chinese rice porridge, a perfect cold weather soup, and a fine vehicle for delicious add ins.” the headnote an introduction, written as if the author is conversing directly with the home cook, provides culinary philosophy, historical and cultural context, advice on variable ingredients and preparation techniques. nigella lawson’s introduction to her recipe for thai chicken noodle soup, for instance, illustrates the improvisatory, ad hoc nature of recipes for many foods in a particular category (such as soups, salads, stews, stir fries) that involve a repertoire of substitutable ingredients (bittman includes a table of interchangeable ingredients): “this is a 10 recipe﻿﻿ very laissez faire recipe all round.” she confesses, “when i cooked it for the photo shoot i forgot to put the vegetables in and it was still heavenly, a mixture of pak choi, bok choi, spindly asparagus, chinese kale, peanut shoots and chinese chives.” at other times, she “happily substitutes some leafy greens and a julienned or sliced spring onion along with a handful of beansprouts.” in characteristically seductive language she advises further improvisation, “if you can’t get the ravishing cellophane packages of almost equally cellophane vermicelli, don’t be put off making this; udon, soba, rice noodles, spaghetti or linguine could be substituted.” the recipe itself it begins with a list of ingredients in the order they are to be used, larger quantities first, followed by the sequence of numbered steps to combine or otherwise prepare the ingredients in order to produce the dish. however, strict linearity may be illusory. in salt fat acid heat, nosrat observes that “while recipes lead us to believe that cooking is a linear process, most good food results from a circular one, like a spiderweb, touch one part and the entire thing will quiver.” john donne said of the human condition, “no man is an island, entire of itself ”; with recipes too, no ingredient, no step, no process is independent of the rest. any step may require a subpart. these instructions can be folded into the ingredient list, as when additional preparation ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 11 steps are embedded in the identification of a single ingredient: “1 large cucumber, peeled, halved lengthwise, seeded, and sliced.” in other cases, the preparation of a single component may require a separate recipe, such as chicken stock or a premade pie shell. although a recipe can serve as a construction scaffold or a memory jogger, the logic of this sequential organization cannot be violated. readers of recipes automatically expect this structure, whether they are new cooks clinging to its framework for security, or casual cooks working without a net, who glance at it only for inspiration. the basic recipe: chicken stock for many dishes beloved by a family, community, or culture, there is a basic recipe and innumerable variations on the essentials which accommodate the range of everyone’s tastes and expectations. how else to justify all those recipe cards, cookbooks, blogs, food network programs? consider, for instance, the basic recipe for chicken stock, the foundation for chicken soups of all sorts as well as an essential ingredient in variety of other recipes. throughout the entire world, wherever there is a chicken, there can be chicken soup. every version of this basic recipe involves the same ingredients in the same proportions the amount of chicken in the recipe is always five pounds which undergo 12 recipe﻿﻿ the same cooking process. whether articulated in a single simple paragraph in fannie farmer’s boston cookingschool cook book (1896) or in two large pages in child’s mastering, the basics are almost as simple as opening a can of campbell’s chicken noodle soup (the soup equivalent of wonder bread), but made from scratch is far tastier and more nutritious. 1. place equal quantities of bones and meat (4 5 pounds altogether, depending on the size of the uncooked chicken) in an 8 10 quart kettle. 2. cover with cold water two inches above the meat, add a couple of stalks of celery, one or two carrots, an onion or two, and simple seasoning. 3. bring to a boil, then simmer for 4 5 hours, skimming accumulated fat and scum. 4. strain. discard the solids. chill. remove congealed fat. this stock, concentrated from its long, lazy simmer, is ready for action. variations: matters of taste and therapeutics yet as any cook and eater whether a casual grazer or serious foodie knows, every recipe will taste different from every ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 13 other recipe. so will different preparations of the same recipe. as nosrat notes, “even the same pile of peas will taste different when cooked on two different days, as their innate sugars transform into starches. they’ll have to be treated differently in order to extract the best flavor.” even though a recipe looks stable on the page, it is meant to be spilled on, written over, annotated, adapted to individual tastes, nutritional needs, convenience, expediency, and economy. in the first edition of the joy of cooking, rombauer extols the virtues of the french pot au feu (ice box soup), the basis for good soup stock: “bits of bone, cooked meat, chicken carcasses, roast trimmings, vegetable parings, the outer leaves of lettuce, unshapely tomatoes, celery tops, peapods, parsley.” nosrat, however, cautions against making soup as “an easy way to clear out the fridge,” and insists that “[y]ou must have a reason for every ingredient you choose to add into a soup in order for it to taste good.” the fewer, the better. nevertheless, with such a casual collection of ingredients for the chicken soup stock whatever lurks the refrigerator that isn’t rotting it would hardly seem to matter much whether the recipe called for one onion and one carrot (farmer) or two each (child). the seasonings could be determined by the cook’s preference: farmer’s choice of 1 tablespoon lean raw chopped ham, child’s for the traditional bouquet garni (parsley, thyme, bay leaf). does the fact that grandma evie’s jewish penicillin incorporates a “jewish bouquet garni” including small bunches each of fresh dill and parsley with the stems on and uses kosher salt 14 recipe﻿﻿ (can you taste its ethnic provenance?) provide a significant therapeutic difference? chicken soup could be thoroughly reimagined according to the first rule of christopher kimball’s milk street: the new rules: “banish one note flavors and textures.” kimball envisions a recipe in three parts. foundation, a recipe’s “dominant taste, texture and sensation”; counterpoint, any contrasting taste, texture, or sensation; and embellishment, the garnishes and other zingy or zesty culinary punctuation. kimball considers classic chicken soup recipes “blandly insipid” in comparison with the “bold, fresh and bright flavors” of peruvian chicken, rice and cilantro soup. its foundation: 1½ (not the customary 5!) pounds of bone in, skin on chicken simmered for 40 minutes (not hours!) in 7 cups of water with 4 garlic cloves, cilantro stems, 1 chopped onion, and ¼ cup of aji amarillo (a mildly spicy sweet yellow chili pepper) paste. the counterpoint: 1 cup of long grain rice, 3 carrots, 1 bell pepper, simmered 10 minutes. the embellishment, added at the very last minute: 1 cup of peas, seasoned with a pureed bunch of cilantro and lime juice. triumph! although vanjo merano’s filipino chicken sopas might seem to be a culinary cousin because it contains chicken, carrots, onions, and celery, the base of milk infused broth with elbow macaroni, plus napa cabbage, hard boiled eggs, and hotdogs (common in filipino versions of chicken soup) put it in a different register. would a western palate, or ailing body, respond to the “comforts of home, of love,” the broad spectrum healing promised by vivian lee’s chicken soup of the chinese aunties, ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 15 alternately named, she jokes, “chicken soup with dried stuff in it” or “chinese chicken herbal soup”? this recipe requires a whole chicken simmered for 2 3 hours with ginger root (for body aches), codonopsis pilosula (for stress relief), astragalus (inner energy, immune boost), chinese yam (stomach), goji berries/wolf berries (eyesight), red dates (vitamins for the central nervous system), and dried longan (vital energy). this recipe is so well known among the vast network of lee’s aunties that when they learn she’s been sick they “do what every chinese mom does” and fedex her the dry ingredients. knowledge of the healing prowess of such therapeutic broth is not new. in his brilliant 1825 treatise on transcendental gastronomy, the physiology of taste, philosophical epicure jean anthelme brillat savarin recommends a “restorative remedy,” soup made of an old rooster, which could be “supplanted by four old partridges, and two pounds of the best quality of beef.” this concentrated meat broth also includes six large onions, three carrots, a handful of parsley, “six ounces of sugar candy, twenty grains of powdered amber [a healing agent], a crust of toasted bread, and three bottles of water,” guaranteed to restore an invalid to good health within four days as long as the patient has “kept a well functioning stomach.” nearly two hundred years later stephen rennard’s research team validated what chinese aunties and old wives already knew in their bones: chicken soup sustains the neutrophils (white blood cells that defend against infection) and helps reduce upper respiratory cold symptoms. his wife’s homemade version is, of course, the most efficacious. 16 recipe﻿﻿ mini cooking lessons: cooking skills and techniques everyone who cooks has to learn some essential skills and techniques. as gopnik, whose mother taught him to cook when he was a child, observes: “the recipe is a blueprint but also a red herring, a way to do something and a false summing up of a living process that can be handed on only by demonstration, a knack posing as a knowledge. we say, ‘what’s the recipe?’ when we mean ‘how exactly do you do it?’ and though we want the answer to be ‘like this!’ the honest answer is ‘be me!’” a thoughtful recipe often anticipates the need for instruction and subtly incorporates the necessary information at the point of use, as child does throughout mastering. this makes each of her recipes long and detailed, but surefire. in coq au vin, for instance, she begins by explaining precisely how to make a necessary component, lardons matchsticksized pieces of bacon cut into rectangles ¼ inch across and 1 inch long: “simmer for 10 minutes in 2 quarts of water. rinse in cold water. dry.” step by step construction, with variations. three steps follow, each at a different electric skillet temperature: melt butter (260 degrees), brown the chicken in it (360 degrees), add seasonings and cook slowly for 10 minutes (300 degrees). then, the dramatic moment: pour in ¼ cup cognac, (safety alert) “averting your face,” child says, advice intended to keep the cook from incineration while performing an unfamiliar maneuver, “ignite the cognac with a lighted match. shake the casserole back and ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 17 forth for several seconds until the flames subside.” the rest, the slow simmer in wine and chicken stock, is anticlimactic. the recipe wrap up recipes often end with directions on how to serve the dish. bittman’s finale to chicken jook with lots of vegetables is typical. “taste and adjust the seasoning” appropriate for almost any recipe and “[s]erve, passing the cilantro, additional scallions, and additional soy sauce at the table.” single recipes online usually stop with the basic dish. yet many cookbook authors, unfailingly overgenerous hosts, can’t resist stuffing in more and more variations, cooking options, and preparation tips. with all recipes bittman offers variations, such as pork jook for chicken, plus additional preparation notes and recommendations for sides. dorie greenspan’s recipe format for around my french table is unusual but easily accessible. long headnotes followed by the main recipe occupy two thirds of the page width. on the outside of the page, a 1 ½ inch column of advice on serving and storing borders the recipe; sometimes, in the same format, bonne idee adds related options, including bonus recipes. this waste not want not column allows greenspan to buttress each recipe with delicious reinforcements, succinctly stated, evidence of a chef excited by the realization that each recipe embeds a host of other possibilities. thus, spicy vietnamese chicken noodle soup offers advice on serving, a do it yourself assortment of basil and mint leaves, 18 recipe﻿﻿ lime wedges, bean sprouts, hoisin sauce, and chile oil. her note on storing explains that the soup base and poached chicken can be refrigerated overnight, but “serve the soup soon after adding the noodles and seasoning.” the bonne idee here is an abbreviated alternative to the original recipe, curried spicy vietnamese chicken noodle soup. illustrations it helps to visualize what you’re cooking, but some comprehensive cookbooks ignore this. bittman illustrates none of his 2000 recipes, but incorporates drawings of the kitchen “setup for speed,” and “prep shortcuts for fruits and vegetables.” two cookbooks bursting with recipes use relatively few illustrations, mastering (524 basic recipes, plus variations), and joy, currently at 4600 recipes. in contrast, new best recipe illustrates 1000 recipes with 800 hand drawn illustrations, and additional photographs. the drawings they have in common illustrate several processes that would be hard to understand without pictures, including how to make pie dough and pastry crusts, how to cut up a chicken or truss it for roasting, and how to prepare artichoke hearts. taking their cues from blogs and tv shows, numerous contemporary cookbooks flip the emphasis, with many fewer recipes (100 300 total) and many more photographs designed to capture the processes of preparing and serving. full page, full frontal views of everything from pulchritudinous poultry to decadent desserts are food porn at its most seductive. just ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 19 looking at the pictures in the chocolate cookbooks will make you fat. what a recipe leaves out: discussions of economy, nutrition, equipment and how to use it even a fat recipe has to be lean; there’s simply not room to include most of the basics of general food preparation, kitchen wisdom that a cook is assumed to know from experience. so a recipe for a specific dish omits generic information about the economy of cooking, for instance “waste not”. it may not address nutrition explicitly, since the dish du jour (except dessert!) is expected to be nutritious. unless the preparation is highly unusual, most individual recipes won’t explain much about equipment what to use and how to use it, the merits of one mandoline (for instance) over another, though comprehensive cookbooks may address knives, mixers, types of pans. economy recipe, like most food writing, focuses not on haute cuisine elaborate preparations of costly ingredients for the 1 percent but on affordable recipes with good ingredients 20 recipe﻿﻿ for everyone else, from drinkers of two buck chuck on up. in his definition of “gastronomy, the intelligent knowledge of whatever concerns man’s nourishment,” brilliat savarin includes economy, “seeking out the methods of buying as cheaply as possible what is needed that is pleasant to the taste.” rombauer’s original joy of cooking, a collection of “palatable dishes” intended to “lift everyday cooking out of the commonplace,” echoes these precepts, with “one eye on the family purse and the other on the bathroom scale,” with “occasional lapses into indulgence.” in the 75th anniversary edition of joy, rombauer’s grandson, ethan becker, after acknowledging the convenience of canned, dried, or frozen soup bases, celebrates his grandmother’s parsimony: “true cooks palpitate over mushroom stems and tomato skins, poultry carcasses, celery leaves, fish heads and knucklebones, just a few treasures for the stockpot that magic source from which comes the telling character of the cuisine.” “waste nothing that’s edible” undergirds the cook’s ethos and governs a broad spectrum of recipes, with the occasional indulgence of “the best you can afford.” experts recommend splurging on the essentials, extra virgin olive oil, recently cold pressed; chunks of italian parmigiano reggiano; king arthur flour; valrhona chocolate. with over 42 million americans (1 in 8 adults, 1 in 6 children) experiencing food insecurity in 2021, the concept of cheap and nutritious food remains paramount, particularly in usda regulations governing food programs for infants, children, students, ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 21 and seniors (see chapter 5). in contrast, the most costly dish, grande velas tacos kobe beef with black truffleinfused brie and caviar, served on a gold flake infused corn tortilla seems to exist so the buyer can brag about paying $25,000 (equivalent to a day’s collective pay for 13,000 african cocoa harvesters) for a portion that would scarcely satisfy a gnat. nutrition although we expect most recipes, excluding desserts, to promote good health, there is no convention among recipes on whether to include the nutrition facts that appear on package labels: calories, total fat, cholesterol, sodium, carbohydrates, protein. except for special diets, print recipes generally exclude such data. internet recipes especially with commercial sponsors such as quaker oats often include this information, as do health promotion blogs, such thriving home’s recipe for cancer fighting soup, a.k.a. immune boosting soup. yet even a recipe that flaunts healthy in its title (such as recipeland’s fitness freaks’ healthy muesli bars) may not explain why. equipment and how to use it in addition to a good stove, the traditional batterie de cuisine (kitchen artillery!) manually operated pots, pans, 22 recipe﻿﻿ knives, spoons, whisks now includes electrical machinery such as a stand mixer, food processor, and instant pot, as well as a high tech instant read thermometer. a recipe will not show what a good grandmother or video can basic ways to chop, dice, slice, and julienne; or how to use a whisk  and what kind to use, balloon, conical, ball, flat or for what purpose. some cookbooks, such as ree drummond’s the pioneer woman cooks: the new frontier, include guides to new equipment instant pot 101 which the cook can consult as background information while preparing the food. when a recipe mentions equipment, it simply assumes that the cook understands the reference, for instance, to a dutch oven or soup pot (preferably 5 7 quarts) because a larger full pot would be too heavy to lift. in the final analysis, your hands are your best tools, now and always. recipes live. the transmission of recipes from professional chefs to home kitchens performances gopnik’s view of recipes is nostalgic, that of novices learning to cook from a trove of heritage recipes, coached by beloved parents or grandparents until they gain enough confidence to go solo. today, if a recipe isn’t available on the internet, for ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 23 millennials and younger generations it might as well not exist. despite soaring hardcopy cookbook sales, recipes are likely to reach home cooks through tv cooking shows or online blogs, viewed on the phone or computer or tablet on the kitchen counter, kitchen mini dramas narrated by a gracious barefoot contessa or a disneyfied pioneer woman. the food itself is prettied up and photographed by professionals, the high resolution results static though mouth watering in cookbooks; yet animated on blogs, youtube videos, and tv. julia child provided the mold, bringing theater sound, sight, motion, character, and personality to recipes through demonstrating their preparation on live tv. her pioneering tv series, the french chef (1963 1966; 19701973), remains a classic. it is a natural extension of her meticulous concern for cooking techniques and integrity of recipes, from french baguettes to boeuf bourguignon to la tarte [des demoiselles] tatin, enacted with joie de vivre in her own home kitchen, on exhibition in the smithsonian since 2001. child’s irresistible example has inspired over 200 cooking shows to date, including celebrity chefs (anthony bourdain: no reservations; throwdown! with bobby flay) and esteemed chefs providing instruction (america’s test kitchen), education (alton brown, good eats), lifestyle (pioneer woman), travel (david chang), competition (top chef). many shows emphasize entertainment over instruction on screen, which the food network supplements with hundreds of recipes online, as in “the 32 best recipes from ayesha’s home kitchen.” yet lessons seem beside the 24 recipe﻿﻿ point in shows that emphasize competition or weird antics over edible cuisine, even when the judges explain their rationale, as in the cheerfully courteous great british baking show. behind the scenes a food blog’s single recipe episode is a mandoline sliced segment of a cooking show, presented in magazine format. as with every other complicated task, the outstanding food bloggers, child’s progeny in spirit and deed, make the preparation of meticulously tested recipes look easy. it’s not. food bloggers have to do everything cookbook authors do, but as was true of ginger rogers’ dancing with fred astaire backward and in high heels. bloggers are constrained by weekly or monthly deadlines and limited production budgets, pressured to attract millions of followers and beat the competition. they have to look appealing, as does their food, for “people eat with their eyes.” bloggers have to find or develop recipes that fit their blog’s orientation nationality or region (asian vs. korean, chinese, thai . . .), distinct type of diet (vegan, paleo, keto, diabetic), or clientele (beginners, students, families, seniors). bloggers undertake many of the tasks that hardcopy editors and publishers perform, promoting and marketing their work to sponsors, advertisers, influencers, readers. someone has to shop for groceries, wash dishes, polish the pots (in american productions, they all look new!), clean the kitchen, ﻿﻿“first, turn and face the stove.” 25 keep accounts. even when the chef is alone in the kitchen, this hidden support team is on the job, not to mention those who cultivate the recipe’s roots in farms, fields, and oceans, the harvesters, refiners, marketers, and more, as explained in benjamin lorr’s the secret life of groceries. like their hardcopy counterparts, bloggers have to write the recipe in clear, accurate language with an enticing headnote, often sprinkled with zestful autobiographical tidbits. deb perelman is a particularly compelling teller of quest stories, in the split roles of both the beleaguered home cook and ultimate authority. readers vicariously join her search for the best recipe, say, grandma style chicken noodle soup, as she analyzes processes that combine common sense, careful planning, trial and error, and good luck. finally, after having “bounced between overly hasty methods that left me short on flavor, and overly complicated” costly methods (two chickens for soup stock and another for the meat), she solves the problems: “how to boil a chicken. how to buy a chicken, a couple onions, a bag of carrots, and celery, and some egg noodles at a store and turn it into eight substantial bowls of dinner. how to stretch $20 of ingredients into a series of meals you cannot buy anywhere else for that price.” recipes and you will hear this early and often  always have happy endings. and, with luck, the promise of second helpings and leftovers. 26 recipe﻿﻿ 2 “you say tomato, i say tomahto.” the recipe as conversation the same dish made with the same ingredients by ten different cooks will have ten outcomes.  jacques pepin there are all sorts of ways to get a meal on the table. one person’s idea of cooking simply is the next person’s culinary nightmare.  yotam ottolenghi recipes speak in many languages why are there so many cookbooks? or even cookbooks at all, when online recipes and food blogs abound? why wouldn’t one or two big fat reliable standards say, child’s two volume mastering the art of french cooking and the dynastic rombauers’ joy of cooking suffice for any home cook’s lifetime? the quick answer is, of course, that tastes evolve and change. in addition to the perennial quest for novelty and variety, as people move, travel, and dine in new comfort zones, the entire world of food converses through a host of interpreters chefs, cooks, and eaters. although their recipes may be written in different languages, they send the same message: i am delicious! irresistible! enjoy! mouth watering pictures entice readers to swipe right. new foods become hot (pasta infused with squid ink), others cold (blackened redfish). formerly trendy foods and preparations simmer down to become staples in the current repertoire sushi, buffalo wings, hummus, greek yogurt. flambé sputters out, overtaken by outdoor grilling. or smoking. as always, flavorings, condiments, and spices serve as ambassadors to international cooking, including fresh ginger root, mirin (japanese sweet rice wine), and harissa tunisian hot chili pepper paste, also known as the new sriracha. recipes incorporating ingredients such as these are alive, not static, infusing the tastes of their 28 recipe﻿﻿ increasingly multicultural authors into the general culture. woke recipes acknowledge their multiethnic roots and evolution. thus melissa clark credits to egyptians doaa elkady and freda nokaly a recipe for “baharat blend,” a versatile combination of “musky cumin and floral, citrusy coriander sweetened with aromatic cinnamon, cardamom and clove.” cross cultural food dialogue one third of the recipes in joy’s 2019 edition are international, from brazilian to vietnamese, a percentage increasing in every edition. international and regional cooking infuse contemporary cookbooks and american food magazines such as bon appetit, food & wine, and the new york times food columns, which are also becoming increasingly vegan and vegetarian. chefs travel, feeding the tastes of each other and of readers who devour cookbooks as if they were travel accounts, cultural autobiographies, culinary ecology, or novels. in order to understand the “four cardinal directions of cooking” (salt, fat, acid and heat) says nosrat (trained in high end cooking in california and tuscany), “i’ve sampled my way through the oldest pickle shop in china, observed the nuanced regional differences of lentil dishes in pakistan, compared varieties of heirloom corn in mexican tortillas, read extensively, interviewed immigrant grandmothers, and tasted their traditional cooking.” ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 29 hawa hassan and julia turshen, the authors of in bibi’s kitchen: the recipes and stories of grandmothers from the eight african countries that touch the indian ocean, interpret for english speaking readers the cross cultural, multigenerational, and traditional cooking of grandmothers from eritrea to madagascar. interviews accompanying the recipes reinforce the common understanding that “there’s no one right way to make anything and that multiple perspectives and choices are what make cooking so endlessly interesting.” marit hovland’s bakeland: nordic treats inspired by nature, takes readers eco traveling through the nordic landscape season by season, fortified by hazelnut cookies decorated with cloud patterns on a sky blue glaze, white chocolate seashells with raspberry filling, birch bark cookies, and chocolate rocks. olia hercules translates kaukasis as “togetherness,” the motif of a culinary journey through georgia, azerbaijan & beyond, where recipes of shared and borrowed dishes demonstrate the region’s common culture, exhibited in the ekala pkhali salad discussed below. kimball’s milk street: the new rules aims to bring such cuisines home, “to create a communal starting point for a new way to cook (well, new to the classic american table) while also inspiring home cooks to abandon rigid culinary notions drawn from america’s european roots and ersatz adaptations of chinese, italian and mexican cuisines.” despite the objections of woke critics who decry cultural appropriation, that train left the station years ago. 30 recipe﻿﻿ the recipe conversation: different stories, different tastes the individual voice jacques pepin begins “the anatomy of a recipe” with the conventional definition of a recipe: “to most cooks, a recipe is a set of instructions, a formula explaining certain culinary processes used in the making of a dish.” but a formulaic perspective misses the “disconnect between the step bystep procedure and the completed dish, just as an artist cannot equate the technical process of painting with the finished work of art.” as with any art think of van gogh’s signature sunflowers each recipe of a seasoned chef has its distinctive character, culinary and literary, arrived at through practice, experience, knowledge, and experimentation. home cooks approach the platonic ideal, says pepin, through “tasting, looking, and adjusting over and over again,” before finally achieving their own individual version of a recipe good enough to share. the culinary character cooks are always in conversation with their recipe readers, but also with a host of others speaking in their distinctive, individual voices, even when that voice emerges from a collaborative studio production. assembled in a cookbook or on a blog, each ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 31 recipe becomes a piece of the mosaic that constitutes the recipe creator’s culinary persona, whose personality, values, and style of cooking are immediately recognizable in the character and voice of grandmother or julia, irma or samin, jacques or yotam. this character is often known by a first name, a personality that the recipe user comes to know, trust, even to love. thereby she humanizes the abstractions of the recipe itself and brings to it authority, tradition, innovation, and warmth. nurturers and cheerleaders these cookbook/blog authors play the motherly role for home cooks providing, says gopnik, “the social context, the dialogue of generations . . . the family recipe.” although each author is a distinctive character, all are nurturers with encouraging stories intended to establish intimate relationships with their readers, the chef hovering at their elbow at every step. cooking, as gopnik sagely observes, is “something more than just assembling calories and nutrients.” a cookbook dies, he says, “without living cooks to illuminate its principles. unsupported by your mom, the cookbook is the model of empty knowledge.” collaborative conversation a recipe is the essence of collaboration and hospitality; hardly anybody cooks, or eats, alone. among the principals 32 recipe﻿﻿ in the dialogue are the author/chef and members of the vast, variable, ever changing community of other chefs, cooks, eaters, food producers and purveyors (gardeners, farmers, butchers, grocers . . .), past, present, and to come. dorie greenspan, for instance, acquires recipes from home cooks, famous chefs, market vendors, readers, her hairdresser, her daughter in law. the lively conversation on recipe websites expands the dialogue as home cooks validate, tweak, or reject the recipe under consideration and substitute their own or someone else’s ingredients or cooking techniques. moreover, cooks talk to themselves all the time as they cook, in the process of making the recipe their own. right? stories recipes tell stories. as pepin observes “[e]ach recipe is a small story, a complete entity in itself with a beginning, a middle, and an end.” however engaging the story, we don’t want to hear the same tale over and over again any more than we want to eat the same dish night after night. from their individual perspectives, recipe writers tell different stories about the same recipe. different stories create and cater to different tastes. as pepin says, “this intimate element determines the originality and concept of the dish,” for recipes are “friendto friend explanations” of how to attain the goal “not to punctiliously follow instructions on a printed page,” but “to duplicate a taste.” ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 33 literary qualities, themes the recipe’s story emerges not only in the language of the recipe itself, but in the language of the entire cookbook or website. the principal character is the chef as narrator, functioning as creative mastermind, technical expert, guide, interpreter, translator, and coach. the narrative arc (the plot line) of any recipe is its step by step scaffolding that leads to the successful preparation of a delicious dish, despite mishaps that may occur during the process. the focus of these bitesized success stories is diverse; common themes invite the offstage readers to listen up as well as to chow down. themes may focus on the recipe’s origin (what country, culture, ritual, individual it came from and the author’s relationship to these); the discovery or invention of a new taste, ingredient or combination of ingredients, or new method of preparation; a rationale of health, nutrition, or diet; celebration of the food’s context or tradition and appreciation of the people who eat it. these are not mutually exclusive. reader collaboration chefs trade and adapt recipes all the time, acknowledged and unacknowledged; why shouldn’t readers do the same? pepin explains the implicit mentoring process when mom is not at hand: “by understanding the writer’s ideas, the essence or concept of the recipes, and by cooking them again and again, the cooks will ‘improve’ the recipes and eventually make 34 recipe﻿﻿ them their own with their own personal touch and creativity. that is what good cooking and good eating are all about.” no recipe recipes sam stifton’s the new york times cooking: no recipe recipes carries collaboration to its ultimate extreme. he invites readers to stare into their refrigerators and pantries “until the muse lights on your shoulder and then proceed to make a meal out of what you have or what you desire” here’s the critical part “guided by your experience with actual recipes.” aha! like jazz musicians who “know the scales and know the rules,” says stifton, home cooks can draw on their prior knowledge of the basic conventions and how to make tasty “mixtures of salt, sweet, bitter, sour and savory” to “let the music take them where it takes them.” these paradoxically titled no recipe recipes omit quantities of identified ingredients although they provide directions on how to put them together. yet even when making soups, salads, stews, stir fries from scratch it helps to know the ideal quantities and ingredients in order to riff on them. as we’ll see in the next chapter, practiced improvisers can comfortably handle the omission of quantities, but why complicate the guesswork when dredging porkchops in flour “mixed with chili powder, salt, black pepper, smoked paprika and red pepper flakes, or with lawry’s seasoned salt or old bay seasoning or any spice you like, really.” what about ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 35 newbies who need precision? or harried parents trying to cook amidst the distractions of active children? does norecipe recipes signal the end of recipes as we know them, or is it merely a romp off the leash? “a drizzle of red wine vinegar,” “a few glugs of olive oil” would be far too casual for fannie farmer, “the mother of level measurements,” who proclaimed the foremost principle of good cooking taught throughout cooking classes in american schools since 1896 “[c]orrect measurements are absolutely necessary to insure the best results.” unlike, say, a handful (whose hand? how full?), standard measurements are reliable and repeatable. she acknowledges what stifton takes for granted: that “good judgment, with experience, has taught some to measure by sight,” but reality check  “the majority need definite guides.” yet cooks also use what comes to hand. without measuring spoons, the rural virginia family of esteemed southern chef edna lewis used coins, “piling baking powder on pennies, salt on dimes, and baking soda on nickels” (moore). with these perspectives in mind, we turn now to salads, hospitable to stifton’s relaxed understatement; then to cre﻿̂pes, far more exacting and thus in need of encouraging stories. salads, especially green salads as a menu category are a mix of tradition, inspiration, and ad hoc eclecticism. farmer’s analysis of american 36 recipe﻿﻿ salads is surprisingly contemporary: “they are now made in an endless variety of ways, and are composed of meat, fish, vegetables (alone or in combination) or fruits, with the addition of a dressing.” in contrast to today’s casual salad composition, in farmer’s repertoire virtually all of these ingredients sit on tidy mounds, nests, or beds of lettuce leaves. nevertheless, her advice endures: “salads made of greens should always be served crisp and cold,” with dressings added in moderation just before serving. although there is no single right way to make most salads, and little chance of disaster as long as the result tastes good, cooks’ conversations frequently concern principles, proportions, and rules for creating salads and dressings. the 2019 joy of cooking anticipates stifton’s norecipe recipe perspective: “with a few simple guidelines in mind, recipes for green salads are nearly superfluous.” joy’s principles summarize the prevailing culinary wisdom. slice, shred, chop or tear sturdy, crisp greens; tear the tender. allow 1½ 2 cups of greens per serving. make dressings from scratch. the classic ratio (often ignored) is 3 parts oil: 1 part vinegar or citrus juice. add other seasonings sparingly and incrementally, tasting as you go. “use just enough to lightly coat the greens.” nosrat, who learned how to make salads from apprenticeship to the legendary alice waters, urges readers to “[d]ress ­salads properly, by tossing ingredients in a bowl with your hands because your fingers will feel when all of the leaves are coated.” every version of various salads, such as ­avocados ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 37 paired with “all sorts of crunchy and acidic fruits and ­vegetables,” will be improved by “the counterpoint of a big pile of herbs, some shaved fennel bulb, or a handful of arugula.” nosrat’s creed: as long as green salads maintain the ideal balance of tastes and textures salt, fat, acid, crunch, umami you can’t go wrong. kimball’s rule no. 2 (of 75) adds, “­tenderize tough greens with salt . . . raw greens can be off puttingly tough, massaging the leaves with kosher salt tenderizes them.” kimball applies this to chopped kale salad with cilantro and walnuts, a derivative of the georgian recipe for ekala pkhali which hercules provides in kaukasis. both recipes tenderize 10 cups of raw greens and attain a distinctive flavor by dressing them with a fragrant paste made of 1 or more cups of walnuts and 2 cloves of garlic and spices. yet their differences in spices and preparation yield surprisingly different results. 1. greens preparation. hercules blanches ekala (a wild, foraged georgian green) or purslane, swiss chard, beet greens, or spinach two minutes or less, depending on their texture; spinach just gets a “dip in and out of boiling water.” kimball “firmly” massages curly kale with 2 teaspoons salt and 2 tablespoons oil until it darkens in color and the volume reduces by half, and finely chops it in a food processor, 10 pulses. 2. dressing. with a mortar and pestle, hercules makes pkhali, a fragrant paste, of 1 ½ cups walnuts, garlic, 38 recipe﻿﻿ sea salt, cayenne, blue fenugreek, 2 tablespoons white wine vinegar and honey. no oil. kimball incorporates 1 ¼ cups of toasted walnuts into the paste, uses 1/3 cup of red wine vinegar and ¼ teaspoon cayenne, substituting a mixture of coriander, mustard, and fennel for the more elusive blue fenugreek to achieve the salad’s “unique flavor.” 3. results. despite their comparable exotic taste, the salads look quite different. hercules’ version, composed of long, slender, paste coated tendrils, serves 2; kimball’s crisp chopped salad accented with the reserved ¼ cup of walnuts serves 4. as ekala pkhali illustrates, any salad, however simple, can have innumerable variations, in either the base or the dressing or both. the iconic caesar salad is built of romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan, and croutons. its distinctive dressing may incorporate garlic, worcestershire sauce, oil (olive or vegetable), vinegar or lemon. optional ingredients may include raw egg, anchovies, dijon mustard, mayonnaise, more parmesan, spring onions, radishes, fennel bulbs, mushrooms, black pepper, and salt (sea or kosher). (food & wine’s over the top any season caesar salad comes not to praise caesar but to bury him under this entire list.) yet in general, green salads remain so casual that as long as the greens are crisp and the dressing tangy, neither cooks nor diners quibble over the proportions, or specifics, which may be scarcely detectable. nosrat considers this salad an ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 39 “ideal balance of tastes and textures,” reiterated in alexa wiebel’s new york times guide on “how to make cooking substitutions.” her principles for substituting and combining greens include: “consider their flavor and texture. are they bitter or mild? sturdy or tender?” substitute greens from the same category for one another: mild and tender (chard, lettuce, mâche, mesclun, spinach, tatsoi); mild and firm (bok choy, cabbage, collard greens); bitter and tender (arugula, endive, frisée, mizuna, radicchio, radish greens, watercress); bitter and firm (escarole, kale, mustard greens, turnip greens). eat tender greens raw, cook sturdy ones.” laborers’ stories that recipes don’t tell half of the 2.5 million agricultural workers in america are undocumented immigrants, according to the usda; growers and labor contractors estimate 75%. although the us bureau of labor statistics identifies the median 2020 agricultural wage as $13.89 per hour, migrant laborers may be paid only half that much, with no benefits, no health insurance, no paid time off. working long hours, exposed to extreme heat, pesticides, dangerous machinery, and discrimination, they harvest the fruits and vegetables that more comfortable americans take for granted will show up in our supermarkets, on our tables, and in our recipes food that they themselves cannot afford.(lakhani). whether we as individuals, as a nation are willing to pay higher wages and thus higher prices for food to help agricultural workers 40 recipe﻿﻿ afford a better slice of american life is beyond the scope of this book. yet this remains a persistent issue for all quality of life for the workers, quality of conscience for the nation that benefits from their labor simple cre﻿̂pes stories pastries and baked goods in contrast to salads involve more precision, dedication to the process, opportunities for conspicuous invention, disaster (rarely could a salad be considered a failure unless it caused food poisoning), occasions for triumph, and thus for dialogue. we’ll focus here on cre﻿̂pes, the ultimate discomfort recipe, whose preparation flipped and flambéed arouses so much agonized discussion that chefs are inspired to calm their readers with comforting stories and reassuring directions. cre﻿̂pes, they agree, are a simple food, easy to prepare, delicious and versatile. after all, cre﻿̂pes are simply very thin pancakes composed of eggs, flour, milk (or water), a little salt, a bit of butter or oil, and perhaps a splash of alcohol, blended until the batter becomes, says chef gabrielle hamilton, “as smooth as a new can of paint.” after the batter has rested at room temperature for a couple of hours, or in the refrigerator overnight, it is ready to be cooked, a quartercup at a time, in a cre﻿̂pe pan or small nonstick skillet over medium heat, about one minute on each side. the art (the frightening part) comes in swirling the batter on the skillet, ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 41 flipping the pancake over, sliding it off the pan and onto a plate, public side up, to be served with or without a topping. this doesn’t always work; the lament, “la première crêpe est pour le chien” (lucky dog!) persists. although all the chefs discussed here hamilton, child, greenspan, pepin, and perelman are precise, positive, and sympathetic to the readers’ efforts, their recipe stories are as different in the telling as in the eating: in a norman market town, at home, on a paris boulevard, in a connecticut backyard, and at a brooklyn brunch party. every one promises success, naturellement! gabrielle hamilton: casual cooking, communal eating the narrative of hamilton’s new york times recipe for buckwheat galettes comple﻿̀tes, “crepes don’t have to be fancy to be delicious,” is designed to demonstrate that home cooks shouldn’t be intimidated by the “tuxedo and white glove [reputation of] the utilitarian, sturdy, totally accessible crepe: it’s a pancake, after all. a freakin’ pancake (pardon my french).” she continues: “one gray wet winter, i worked in a creperie in a real cow town in brittany where even the fog smelled of manure. the guy who worked the big black cast iron flattops wore only a t shirt, loose dungarees, and an often dirty apron. [jean claude created] galettes de sarrasin, large savory buckwheat crepes as big as hubcaps, made with only buckwheat 42 recipe﻿﻿ flour and topped with various things . . . gruye﻿̀re, and ham, and a sunny side up egg: the complète. sometimes made even more complète with a garlicky, acidic escarole salad mounded right on top. . . . without even measuring,” he substituted norman hard cider or beer for milk in the buckwheat mixture, didn’t chill it at all, and cooked it quickly. . . . [the whole town] farmers and farmers’ wives, truck drivers and their families, weekend soccer clubs . . . sat without formality, at bare tables, on rough, rattan chairs, and ate these gorgeous, tasty galettes at any hour of the day. before church. after school. the bank teller came for his lunch break.” if jean claude could produce such casual magnificence, so can times readers, is the implicit message. the aim, hamilton says, is to “quickly tilt the pan in a clockwise motion to swirl the batter all the way to the edges into a perfectly round, very thin pancake.” she reassures readers that “the first few never work out. straight out of the gate your confidence is rattled.” hamilton soothes, “it’s this way for all of us. you’ll always lose a few in the first couple of rounds. but once you get used to the swirling motion, the amount of batter to add and the hotness of the pan,” everything will be in alignment and voilá, you can make six savory crepes in six minutes, a process replicated in hamilton’s swirling, rhythmic prose. julia child: a cre﻿̂pe for all seasons child’s story of french pancakes, a.k.a. crepes, is intended to show how versatile cre﻿̂pes are, how integral they are to french ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 43 culture, and how economical (leftovers!) and easy they are to prepare, despite their terrifying delicacy (her measurement is 1/16th of an inch). she begins, “every french household makes use of cre﻿̂pes, not only as a festive dessert for mardi gras and candlemas day, but as an attractive way to turn leftovers or simple ingredients into a nourishing main course dish.” if an entire nation can make these embodiments of french thinness, surely an alert american home cook can also undertake the characteristic cre﻿̂pe repertoire: simple cre﻿̂pes; entrée cre﻿̂pes, including the spectacular ga﻿̂teau de cre﻿̂pes a﻿̀ la florentine (a mound of french pancakes filled with cream cheese, spinach, and mushrooms); and dessert cre﻿̂pes (cre﻿̂pes sucrées). child then gets down to business, showing graphically, with vigorous verbs and adverbs (emphasis mine), how to cook the cre﻿̂pe: “quickly tilt the pan in all directions to run the batter all over the bottom of the pan in a thin film.” then, how to turn the cre﻿̂pe without tearing it: “jerk and toss pan sharply back and forth and up and down to loosen the cre﻿̂pe.” the drama is in the delivery, a vigorous athletic struggle: “turn the cre﻿̂pe by using 2 spatulas; or grasp the edges nearest you in your fingers and sweep it up toward you and over again into the pan in a reverse circle; or toss it over by a flip of the pan.” dorie greenspan: a stroll through paris crepes are both a social and a snack food. greenspan’s around my french table recipe for butter and rum crepes, 44 recipe﻿﻿ fancy and plain, begins with the origin story of crepes suzette, a mistake transformed into a miracle. when at a dinner in monte carlo for the prince of wales a tableside pan of liqueurs accidentally went up in flames, a quick witted waiter quickly slid crepes into the pan of boiling liquid, twirled them around, and with extraordinary elan, presented them to the royal diners as “crepes princesse,” soon renamed suzette in her honor. greenspan then invites readers to stroll on the paris streets, where crepe stands abound, some the size of a telephone booth, along with “mobile crepe and waffle trucks, usually with lines of eager snackers” devouring crepes topped with simple ingredients: sugar and butter, jam or marmalade, grand marnier, or “nutella, for a splurge.” folded into a four layer triangle and wrapped in waxy paper, the crepe “is not just delicious, but the best hand warmer on a winter’s day.” to make the crepes, greenspan advises novices to “pour in more batter than the 2 3 tablespoons you need, quickly swirl the pan,” pour off the excess batter and “cook until the top of the crepe is set.” run a small spatula around the crepe’s edges to allow “a look at the underside: if it’s browned, flip it over, a job best done with your fingers.” jacques pepin: rhubarb in the garden, a cautionary tale in contrast to the paris boulevards, pepin’s equally evocative tales that embrace pannequets (cre﻿̂pes) with strawberry﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 45 rhubarb nectar are domestic, paternal. he explains how he makes breakfast cre﻿̂pes for his young daughter and her friends: “all children love cre﻿̂pes stuffed with jam.” in the crucial step, he would simply “flip the cre﻿̂pe or turn it over with your fingers and a fork” no picture, no problem. he also serves cre﻿̂pes for dessert, their “crunchy, buttery edges” surrounded by strawberry rhubarb nectar made with rhubarb grown in his connecticut kitchen garden: “i have rhubarb in my garden in the spring.” but, he cautions, rhubarb leaves are poisonous, so remove them before briefly boiling four “thick bright red ribs” for the sauce. deb perelman: a crepe party! perelman’s popular smitten kitchen blog emanates from her tiny brooklyn apartment kitchen, radiating enthusiasm for kinder, küche, and conviviality. her recipe for “failproof crepes” (with that title you know there have been failures) accompanies plans for a brunch party with make ahead crepes and embellishments fruit, jam, cheese, yogurt and more. perelman’s breezy, easy success story begins by disputing the bad rap for crepes, that “they’re difficult, they require planning ahead, they’re fussy (cough french), they rip easily, the first one always goes in the trash but i respectfully disagree, especially about that last bit (it goes in the nearest mouth).” her recipe is the best (every humble cook’s claim) 46 recipe﻿﻿ because it’s “four ingredients in one bowl, everything in at once, no fuss, easier than most.” it has slightly more heft and “a little less terrifyingly fragile laciness, which is to say it’s completely headache free to cook. the batter takes 120 seconds to assemble, it can be prepared 1 hour or 4 days before you need it” and here she personifies the food, “it doesn’t mind rushing or neglect.” cooked crepes don’t stick to each other, and they “reheat like a charm.” perelman knows her audience, the beautiful and the doomed. her “quick directions for the confident,” 28 words, resemble pepin’s: “heat skillet over medium low. butter skillet. ladle in 1/4 cup batter, roll around. cook until golden underneath, flip. repeat.” “detailed directions for the nervous,” 270 words ten times more than the confident need, anticipate problems (holes, tearing, flipping) and provide instant solutions: put a spatula “in each hand, use the first one to lift as much as possible, and the second one to get under the crepe further and finish the job. if it folds or crinkles, don’t fret, it’s surprisingly easy to stretch out wrinkles and shimmy the crepe back flat.” unseen participants in the recipe’s creation recipes or the language and visual elements of the presentation are continually changing, hence the endless cascade of cookbooks. today’s professional chefs participate ﻿﻿“you say tomato, i say tomahto” 47 in a nonstop conversation with each other, production teams, and their readers, their disagreements largely below the public’s radar. although beaming chefs in aprons adorn current cookbooks, today’s recipes are likely to be created by a team, such as the producers of kimball’s new rules and america’s test kitchen, which performed “countless tests” (rumor says 50) to discover the perfect way to boil eggs. testers, says tester patti cook, ensure that the recipes fulfill their promises. a recipe must be reliable, accurate, indicate a clear, sensible, efficient method and timing of preparation, and accurately estimate the number of servings. above all, it must be delicious. the team principals are sometimes acknowledged on the title page, as with ottolenghi’s coauthors of simple, tara wigley and esme howarth. more often, credits roll in the acknowledgments. as with film production, today’s professional cookbook production requires food stylists, photographers, prop stylists, designers, rewriters, editors, publicists, in addition to the chef ’s perennial supporters family and friends involved in testing and eating numerous iterations of a single recipe in the process of getting it right. yet, as with illustrious film actors, each distinguished chef is recognizable in style and in substance. each recipe a mosaic piece in the portrait that emerges, of good nutrition, good sense, good will, and hospitable good cheer. every cookbook is a signature story. 48 recipe﻿﻿ 3 a taste of home the recipe for comfort cooking in tough times there is food in the bowl, and there is nourishment in the heart, to feed the wilder, more insistent hungers. we must eat.  m.f.k. fisher deliciousness is possible against the backdrop of a national emergency, for deliciousness improves moods and inspires hope. deliciousness sends a message. someone cares.  sam stifton recipes for survival and sustenance just as there are no atheists in foxholes, there are no dieters during devastation. in times of crisis we eat and cook for comfort, for distraction, and ultimately for survival of body and soul. our everyday lives, reasonably predictable, percolate along in a more or less orderly fashion, over which we have some control, whether planning and preparing meals or sticking to a diet. when crisis storms in a breakup, a job loss, a death, a natural disaster, a pandemic it throws individuals, communities, whole nations off balance. the world as we have known it is gone, we can’t take for granted what’s new and ever shifting, or make sense of things that don’t make sense. we can’t control our fate, or the fate of those we love. but we can still control our cooking. history the focal recipe of this chapter, to be examined later in detail, is mac & cheese, but feel free to swap in your own favorite as you contemplate comfort. this savory dish “creamy, rich, ooey gooey, super cheesy, with those crispy browned cheese edges,” swoons soul food blogger eden westbrook  is america’s quintessential comfort food, simple to prepare, uncomplicated to cook, and easy to eat. it has a proud heritage. thomas jefferson, a renowned connoisseur of french cuisine 50 recipe﻿﻿ and wine, served this succulence at a white house dinner on february 6, 1802, made from a french recipe copied in his own hand (monticello​.o​rg). before the civil war, enslaved cooks in white southern households prepared this delicacy for their masters. after emancipation, says food historian adrian miller, “macaroni and cheese took on new life and multiple identities within the black community. it became a celebratory dish, a convenient comfort food, and a meal stretcher for impoverished families.” in prosperous black households, the most revered family members, an auntie or grandma, merited the honor of cooking splendid, superpremium variations for celebratory and holiday meals, which westbrook identifies as “thanksgiving, christmas, easter, memorial day, juneteenth, 4th of july, birthdays, marriages, births, funerals. everything.” stability, sense of place recipes, savory links with the stable past, seasoned with hope for the future, can provide a soupçon of stability in a world devastated by war, plague, fire, flood, as well as minor disorientations. cheryl mendelson observes in home comforts, the 21st century’s answer to mrs. beeton’s 19th century housekeeping compendium, “cooking at home links your past and future and solidifies your sense of identity and place. when a home gives up its hearth, which in the modern world is its kitchen, it gives up its focus.” for mendelson and cooks everywhere, the comforts of home cooking cannot be ﻿﻿a taste of home 51 overstated: “good meals at home satisfy emotional hungers as real as hunger in the belly and nothing else does so in the same way.” survival when literal links to home are broken, the human spirit forges figurative bonds. during world war ii, starving jewish women in the theresienstadt concentration camp escaped their overcrowded, disease ridden barracks by reconstructing recipes that evoked prewar feasts: noodle pudding, stuffed goose neck, and rich desserts adrift in whipped cream and sugar food for the spirit, hope for the future. this secret cache of 70 recipes, its discovery punishable by death, emerged fifty years later as in memory’s kitchen: a legacy from the women of terezín, interpreted by a survivor as “an act of defiance and resistance, a means of identification in a dehumanized world. a life force in the face of death” (de silva, dickstein). likewise, in a japanese civilian prison camp in baguio, philippines, hungry american mothers found comfort in copying and trading recipes, and in telling their famished children bedtime stories about food in its mouthwatering absence. as natalie crouter wrote in forbidden diary: “gingerbread with whipped cream, apple sauce, whole wheat bread with gobs of butter, endless lines of dishes parade in our talks.” in peace and war, recipes for comfort foods have plumped up a century of american fundraising cookbooks, 52 recipe﻿﻿ reflective of widespread american dietary preferences. many, from school ptas and sports team support groups, to college sororities and alumnae associations, to 4 h and homemakers’ organizations, run heavily to desserts. (junior league cookbooks, both down home and upscale, tend to be more balanced.) in pandemic times, bon appetit lards the menu with recipes for “rich, aromatic chicken tikka masala over rice, soothing soups, and oh, tons of carbs. this is not the time to pretend like you want to eat a bright, zingy salad. you don’t. the heart knows what it wants, so do yourself a favor, and get cooking” (goldberg). what is comfort food? we understand comfort food in our bones and our hearts, even before we smell or taste it. we crave food we loved as children, and continue into adulthood to love when the chips are down, food that soothes us when we’re sick or sad or sorry, out of place or out of luck. chicken soup, mashed potatoes, pasta, pizza, ice cream, chocolate cake. chef boyardee mac & cheese, ditto; kraft. specific foods reinforce the tastes of home, whatever the nationality adobos, curries, dumplings, fry bread and breads of all sorts, noodles, bangers and mash, poutine, tacos (mexican and french oui!). with few exceptions, they satisfy what have been called the four canadian food groups carbs, fats, salt, and sugar. tasty, soft, and undemanding, they are easy to serve, no artichoke leaves to tug or lobster claws to ﻿﻿a taste of home 53 wrestle. they are easy to chew, slurp, gulp, or swallow and to gorge on, empty calories or not. comfort foods fill us up. comfort foods provide a bond of stability and connection across generations, cultures, nations. around the world, comfort foods reflect love for home real and ideal and for the cook, as reflected in the turkish terminology ev yemeği (“home dish”) and the nostalgic anne yemeği (“mother’s dish”). the national council of negro women’s celebrating our mothers’ kitchens elaborates: “mama in the kitchen is emblematic of all the nurturing and warmth of mothering. mama standing over the stove represents the generations of mothers who, from their kitchen kingdoms, dispensed their knowledge of the world, their strategies for survival, and their hopes for the future, along with airy angel biscuits, smothered pork chops, and bubbling pots of homemade soup.” the 60s pillsbury doughboy crooned, “nothing says lovin’ like something from the oven!” even if, like massproduced oreos (40 billion per year), the baked goods emerge from production lines. in 2020, when the world as we knew it was falling apart, the motto was updated: “this year has been rough. make some cookies.” although the overtones as well as some of the conversation in this chapter pertain to cooking and eating by people sheltering in place during the covid 19 pandemic, comfort food has existed for as long as people have needed its dependable nurture: solace, strength, security, and the pleasure and good cheer provided by robert burns’s “cup o’ kindness.” 54 recipe﻿﻿ comfort foods bring the taste of home and consequently, its comforts to wherever those who savor their native cuisine may be, whether old timers, new immigrants, or people displaced by war, exile, restlessness, adventure, or fear. gathering round the table, whether at norman rockwell’s iconic (parodies notwithstanding) family thanksgiving household, or at communal tables in churches, mosques, synagogues, fellowship halls and soup kitchens, enables the intermingling of fisher’s “food, and security and love,” offering camaraderie in good times, insulation against anxiety and grief in bad. as stifton observes in “deliciousness matters,” “food is comfort, especially now, as millions of americans are suddenly homebound. but people under stress, duress, in crisis need to eat. so food is also about survival.” the activities involved in connection with comfort food planning the menu, selecting (even stockpiling) the ingredients, preparing, sharing, and eating it make us feel good, or at least, better, about ourselves and give us a small measure of control in a refractory universe. recipes for comfort food the pleasure of comfort food lies as much in the process of cooking it as in the eating. within the past five years people have taken to anxiety baking, a.k.a. stress baking or quarantine baking, to reduce existential or workaday stress, and procrastibaking ”baking something completely ﻿﻿a taste of home 55 unnecessary” as a way to interrupt or postpone those very stress producing activities (mull). immersing oneself in an activity that is cheap, easy, soothing, and that yields delicious results for which the baker, even with rudimentary skills, can be praised such as “fear of success snack cakes” is enormously satisfying, even if it is also a form of distracting escapism. as new york times food writer julia moskin asks, “why work when you can procrastibake?” although the rules of the game are still evolving, such as “use only ingredients you have on hand, no shopping,” the preparation process is meant to be fun, whether the result is an essential meal component or a therapeutic, high calorie dessert. discussions of comfort foods prepared at home constitute the beating heart of this chapter. even before the covid 19 pandemic struck, contemporary professional chefs such as clark (dinner), greenspan (everyday dorie), ottolenghi (simple), and innumerable bloggers were accentuating their own casual, improvisatory home cooking, reflected also in bittman’s 1054 page how to cook everything fast. their simple, imaginative recipes were intended to provide comfort and pleasure for stressed out cooks, whether preparing an appealing meal on the fly after a demanding workday; or on the weekend when relaxing, entertaining, or gearing up for the next busy week. each of clark’s recipes, for instance, is “meant to be your dinner one fantastic dish that shines bright on the table,” whether za’atar chicken, asian grain bowl, or stovetop mac & cheese. 56 recipe﻿﻿ mac & cheese, the elemental comfort food bread hot from the oven, seductively fragrant, slathered with butter and jam, may be the ultimate comfort food for coping with illness in the household or pandemic in the world. but the recipes and detailed instructions for preparation, even with only four ingredients (flour, yeast, water, salt), can at times be too prissy and protracted for comfort. moreover, so many superstitions cling to bread baking that bread itself threatens to become a discomfort food. for instance, the caution that “eating hot bread will give you pleurisy” or some other dreaded disease has to be a threat calculated to preserve the loaf for dinner rather than an expression of concern for the snacker’s health. instead, we’ll concentrate on another simple, perennially popular comforting combination of carbs, protein, fat, and salt mac & cheese. even for people who now make this recipe from scratch, the packaged kraft dinner has been the default dish for generations of americans and brits; it is a canadian cultural icon. shelf stable, needing only the addition of milk and a little butter, its 1937 debut advertised an unbeatable “meal for four in nine minutes for an everyday price of 19 cents.” a cheap, gooey, bulky food made of dried pasta and bright orange cheese powder with chemical flavorings appears intrinsically disgusting. nevertheless, ballooning legions of fans from toddlers on up continue to relish it as ﻿﻿a taste of home 57 a delicious, creamy blend of cheese coated pasta. perelman prefaces her made from scratch recipe for quick, essential stovetop mac and cheese with the confession, “i’m sorry, were you waiting for me to call it terrible? a disappointment? a memory from childhood that did not hold up? it was anything but. i love orange cheese powder.” annie’s (est.1989) homegrown organic macaroni & cheese, made with real cheese instead of cheese powder and no gmo ingredients, could be considered a healthier rival. but in fact, either kraft’s or its alternative would be an ideal comfort food in an emergency. needing only a single pot, 3 6 cups of water, and a source of heat, this simple dish is quick cooking, flavorful, and nourishing a taste of home during disaster. yet during my own taste tests, which i am doing for the key recipe of each chapter, i realized that, at least to this home cook’s palate, all pastas, made of wheat, water, and salt both kraft and annie’s are high in sodium essentially taste the same. this is true even though the taste and texture are affected by the type of wheat, the cooking time, and the amount of salt in the water. it is the sauces that really make the difference. homemade wins the rave reviews, with substantially more fat heavy cream blending with lush cheeses but it’s much heftier. annie’s weighs in at 270 calories per one cup serving, kraft dinner at 346 calories, svelte in comparison with homemade recipes where the calorie count can exceed 850, double the calories in premium ice cream. dietetic recipes replace the cream with such substitutes as almond milk and 58 recipe﻿﻿ chicken broth, slimming the dish down to 300 calories, but what’s the point? the comfort lies in consuming the calories. the platonic ideal of mac & cheese would satisfy moskin’s “fantasy of what the dish should be: nothing more than tender elbows of pasta suspended in pure molten cheddar, with a chewy, golden brown crust of cheese on top” (“winter cook”). there are two prevailing ways to prepare this divine dish. one is to simply mix up the ingredients so that the liquid (milk and/or cream) and cheese coat the cooked pasta, as the kraft version also directs. the alternative is to layer the macaroni with béchamel based cheese sauce, made separately, and possibly other ingredients. contemporary chefs rise to the kraft challenge, as signaled by clark’s opening claim for stovetop mac & cheese “if your go to mac and cheese comes from a box, this recipe just might change your life. not only is it as quick to make as the boxed stuff, it’s also about a thousand times tastier,” thanks to the two tablespoons of heavy cream per serving, “and adults like it as much as kids do. the trick is to whisk the cheeses into the heavy cream, which instantly turns into the most velvety, luscious cheese sauce you can imagine.” both clark and bittman proffer simple recipes for the simple version. clark’s is the least complicated. three ingredients: 8 ounces macaroni (for 2 3 servings), 1/3 cup heavy cream, 1 ¼ cups grated cheddar cheese; plus salt, nutmeg, and black pepper, to taste. two steps: 1) cook the pasta to al dente in lots of heavily salted water. drain. 2) in the now empty pot, add the cream and cook until it’s thick and ﻿﻿a taste of home 59 reduced by half, about two minutes. whisk in the cheese. then stir in the pasta, season, and serve no crumbs, no browning. in bittman’s version, “[i]nstead of making béchamel, you use the heat of the pasta to melt a load of cheese; a splash of milk makes it saucy. bread crumbs and a spin under the broiler make it crisp.” mix the cheese and milk (the liquid of choice in most recipes) into the cooked pasta, he says; then transfer the mixture to a baking dish, sprinkle it with parmesan and breadcrumbs, and brown it under the broiler 2 5 minutes. variations on the basic recipe why would any cook searching for comfort choose to make the more complex version, with béchamel sauce which has to be made separately, when the simple versions are so sumptuous and satisfying? the answers may lie in taste and tradition encoded in the numerous béchamelbased recipes revered in family celebrations, ensconced in fundraising cookbooks such as celebrating our mothers’ kitchens and in comfort food compilations such as comfort foods: rachel ray’s 30 minute meals and the little big book of comfort food, among others. everyone aims, as annie’s “homegrown” advertises, for “easy, cheesy wins for all,” feel good bombshells of creaminess, crunchiness, and taste. individual cooks determine variations on the basics: what kind of pasta; which cheeses, liquids, seasonings, and optional ingredients to use; and the ratios of liquid to cheese to pasta. 60 recipe﻿﻿ macaroni serves as the generic label for all sorts of small tubular, twisty, or ruffly pastas that will scoop up globs of sauce corkscrews, elbows, ears (orecchiette), penne, radiatori (yes, little radiators), shells, ziti. cheese for the sauce (the glue!) may be cheddar medium, sharp, extra sharp, smoked, or white; monterey jack; gruye﻿̀re; swiss. or gasp! it may be american, even velveeta, which since 2002 must by law be labeled as a “pasteurized prepared cheese product” rather than the real thing. parmesan and/or pecorino constitute the topping, along with bread crumbs or croutons. although it isn’t (yet) sprinkled into distinguished recipes, the ultimate concession to popular toppings is kraft mac n cheese cheddar cheese powder, available in bulk for around $1.43/ounce. why anyone would choose an even more expensive, chemically complicated alternative to excellent real cheeses defies the imagination. liquids usually include milk whole, 1%, 2%, and/ or heavy cream or yogurt; vegetable or chicken broth and condensed tomato soup sneak into the diet versions. salt and pepper are de rigueur; other seasonings, arranged here in ascending order of intrusiveness, are sweet paprika, bay leaf, nutmeg, sautéed onion or garlic, hot pepper sauce. other optional ingredients include dairy (sour cream, eggs); vegetables (fresh tomatoes, broccoli, asparagus, bell pepper, scallions); condiments (chili, salsa); and meat (bacon, lobster). and on and on, with each chef or food blogger adding a variation, whether flamboyant lobster or barely ﻿﻿a taste of home 61 detectable seasonings, that will allow them to stake out a new recipe. improvisatory, no recipe recipes for (almost) anything invention is the spice of life, and inventions, culinary and otherwise, often begin with the ultimate end in mind. for home cooks the panic question is likely to be: what can i make for dinner? right away, with whatever i have on hand? the chefs encourage home cooks, especially if they can’t get to the store, to use up ingredients that have been lounging in the cupboards or lurking in the refrigerator’s depths. people should mess around with what they find until they come up with a happy surprise. or, lacking the original ingredients, they can invent a tasty alternative to a familiar favorite. improvisation will work as long as the substitutions adhere to the following principles. the ingredients should fill the same general category as the original i.e. leafy greens or even more specific, delicate or sturdy leafy greens. they should be equivalent in volume or weight and perhaps texture to those in the original. they should have flavors, including seasonings, that are in the same palate as the original and thus complement each other in similar ways. nosrat offers philosophical, chemical, and practical guidance for improvisatory cooking and liberation from 62 recipe﻿﻿ recipes, focusing on the “four basic factors that determine how good our food will taste: salt, which enhances flavor; fat, which amplifies flavor and makes appealing textures possible; acid, which brightens and balances; and heat, which ultimately determines the texture of food.” for example, “acid is salt’s alter ego. while salt enhances flavors, acid balances them, acting as a foil to salt, fat, sugar, and starch.” these principles, assures nosrat, enable home cooks to feel confident “in any kitchen, with any ingredients, while cooking any meal, using recipes like professional cooks do  for the inspiration, context, and general guidance they offer.” michael pollan affirms, in introducing nosrat’s philosophy, “we no longer have to cling to a recipe like a lifeboat; now we can strike out on our own and begin to improvise.” stifton’s nyt cooking blogs, emanating from “substitution city” throughout the covid 19 pandemic, abound in norecipe recipes: “with everyone out of this pantry item or that one, recipes have become mere suggestions of where you might start. they’re like assembly charts from ikea when you have only 60 percent of the fasteners.” reinforced by nosrat’s principles, stifton, in a low key, reassuring manner, makes a virtue of necessity with cheerful suggestions for substitutions in existing recipes, and improvisation where no recipe has gone before. consider “there’s no need for recipes now”: “good morning. i roasted some black sea bass, the fillets painted with a mixture of mayonnaise and sesame oil, oyster sauce, a dash of lime juice, another of honey. i served the fish over rice with a stir fry of cabbage and pickled chiles. it was fantastically ﻿﻿a taste of home 63 delicious and required no recipe because i was cooking off the top of my head. i just stared into the pantry for a while and waited for the muse to arrive with her gift. and then there it was: dinner, salty sweet crunchy spicy rich. so great!” stifton’s narrative models both the principles and process of improvisation. he starts with a main ingredient black sea bass. then he searches for a new combination of flavors for the roasting fish, a cook’s familiar creative process that involves choosing a little of this, a little of that in judicious proportions, items plucked from his imagination as well as his pantry, to come up with something indeed “salty sweetspicy rich,” new, surprising, and with a nod to nosrat  “fantastically delicious. my muse is condiments, i suppose.” the result, a blend of lime juice and honey, is invigorating, ramped up with the unexpected: oyster sauce, sesame oil, and who would have thought? mayonnaise. for a meal, this knockout sauce requires a neutral starch (plain rice) as a foil to the fish, but then stifton can’t resist jazzing both up with another unusual combination, stir fried cabbage with pickled chiles the whole enchilada. he doesn’t expect readers to have those exact ingredients on hand, or to replicate his meal but to use his process as a point of departure for their own improvisatory cooking; recipes would be beside the point. as stifton demonstrates, the only way to find out whether anything works is to experiment with flavor, proportion, balance, and then taste the results: “it’s good to cook without recipes, with only ingredients and a running idea of how you might use them. cooking this way is the 64 recipe﻿﻿ translation of ideas into action and, because it’s inexact, it rewards your personality particularly. it results in food that is inescapably yours” one way for home cooks and signature chefs alike to develop new recipes. the enduring hug comfort foods provide a platterful of stability in a turbulent, ever changing world beset by traumas and tribulations, sending their aromatic message that everything’s going to be all right. as long as proust’s madeleine rests, expectant, in the saucer of memory; as long as mac & cheese wafts from the oven and our pantries are packed with possibilities, we know that we have lives beyond the moment. disaster is democratic, but so are recipes. everyone, anyone can invent, adapt, or modify a recipe to fit what’s in the fridge, the garden, the budget, or a free floating imagination. comfort dwells also in heritage recipes, written by mothers and grandmothers in copperplate script, then passed along to the next generations to be immortalized in church and school fundraising cookbooks. the most enduring recipes have now migrated to food blogs and become part of the ongoing conversation among home cooks and professional chefs, ready to share and serve up the best food anyone seeking succor could ever eat. the recipe’s deep background, out of sight in the text but embedded in culture, embraces and comforts us all. ﻿﻿a taste of home 65 66 4 joys of cooking  and eating the great american thanksgiving celebration recipe we do not invite each other simply to eat and drink, but to eat and drink together.  plutarch i wish the bald eagle had not been chosen as the representative of our country. the turkey is a much more respectable bird and a true, original native of america.  benjamin franklin don’t mess with it. what most people make for thanksgiving dinner is what their mothers made, and you stray from this at your peril.  nora ephron celebrations and food we can’t celebrate without food. imagine a birthday party without a cake, hanukkah without latkes, italian christmas eve without the feast of the seven fishes, or ramadan without tagine or biryani. foods essential to new year’s celebrations include hoppin’ john (black american rice and black eyed peas); tamales (mexico); toshikoshi soba noodles (japan); king cake (greece, france, bulgaria also essential to new orleans mardi gras). for the lunar new year, tteoguk (sliced rice cake soup, korea); and fish, dumplings, spring rolls, and longevity noodles (china). a celebration without the anticipated foods would be like a celebration without a favorite guest, something missing at the heart. the united states is the only country in the world with a national holiday centered on a national meal, the thanksgiving dinner. therefore, after exploring the holiday’s historical and cultural evolution, this chapter will treat the entire thanksgiving menu as a single recipe, the great american thanksgiving gestalt, stuffed with comfort foods. so tightly integrated are its central components turkey, 68 recipe﻿﻿ stuffing, potatoes, gravy, cranberry sauce, green beans, pie  that we can’t consider the salient aspects of preparing one dish without the rest. history and values children learn in school the legend of the meal embedding the heritage and diversity (however mythologized) that the pilgrims shared with native americans in 1621, giving thanks for an abundant harvest and the amity that enabled their survival during a very harsh winter. in 1789, george washington, grateful for “tranquility, union, and plenty,” decreed thanksgiving a national holiday. everyone who has grown up celebrating thanksgiving understands in their bones the dynamics of america’s national holiday, both public what this meal means in the culture generally and private what it means to one’s own family. from infancy onwards americans imbibe its cultural significance, its celebration of family, friendship, and plenty. as a nation we gobble up the practice of eating to excess that, as cultural analyst priscilla parkhurst ferguson says, “has nothing to do with fear of famine and everything to do with proclaiming one’s allegiance to the country that set the table.” friendsgiving notwithstanding, thanksgiving is a family holiday, with the concept of family stretched to embrace not only relationships extended and blended by marriages and births, but by the desire to include friends, newcomers, even strangers in what many consider the best holiday of the year. ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 69 even in ordinary times when food insecurity hovers at 11%, americans proclaim their country as ”the land of plenty” with considerable justification, judging from 2019’s 1.1 trillion dollar agribusiness. “america the beautiful” extols the land’s abundance, its “amber waves of grain” and “fruited plain” evidence of divine blessing, symbolized in thanksgiving. this “belief in the never ending bounty of the earth is essential to any understanding of the distinctive ways” americans have always thought about food, says ferguson. “one striking characteristic of american ways of eating is the preoccupation with volume of food and size of servings,” double the size of european portions. the national values of massive girth and supersize servings are reflected in “all you can eat” restaurants, “belly buster” buffets, and ballooning obesity from 30.5% in 1999 to 42.4% in 2020. so it is not surprising that americans are eager to belly up to the thanksgiving table, immortalized in norman rockwell’s rendition of freedom from want. rockwell actually began painting the large turkey (it looks like an eighteen  to twenty pounder) on thanksgiving morning in 1942, the roasted bird a symbol of american excess in a wartime world plagued by food shortages and famines, yet balanced by the empty plates in the same picture. the bird’s bulky centrality in the national feast promised then as now not only that there would be enough food to feed the nation but proclaimed that overabundance rather than simple adequacy best suits the country’s ideals. highlighting the spirit of the day, one genial family brackets the dinner with guests weighing in at the 70 recipe﻿﻿ front door on arrival and departure: the person who gains the most during dinner wins a prize. the meal itself let’s talk turkey. the thanksgiving feast is everyone’s birthright, a source of cultural as well as caloric sustenance, its components inseparable in imagination as on the festive table. writer nora ephron observes of “this most amazing holiday[,] it’s a miracle that once a year so many millions of americans sit down to exactly the same meal as one another, exactly the same meal they grew up eating, and exactly the same meal they ate a year earlier. the turkey. the sweet potatoes. the stuffing. the pumpkin pie. is there anything else we all can agree so vehemently about? i don’t think so.” stifton’s key concept of the meal is “bounty”: “the bird should be bigger than you need. there should be at least three, and ideally five, side dishes” not only cranberry sauce, green bean casserole, and mac & cheese, but a richness of other cultural and family preferences. neighbor jeanette’s creamed spinach. uncle bahram’s tabbouli. newcomer parwin’s kurdish eprax (grape leaves casserole). stifton continues, “there should be rivers of gravy and mountains of dressing. pies should be visible in the distance, on sideboards, many of them. bounty is at the essence of cooking thanksgiving well” (rosenstrach). bounty is corroborated in a host of cookbooks serving up the national ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 71 menu, from amelia simmons’s american cookery (1796) to fannie farmer’s boston cooking school cook book (1896), james beard’s american cookery (1972), the junior league of philadelphia’s bicentennial cookbook (1975), all joy of cooking editions, and stifton’s thanksgiving: how to cook it well (2012) which proclaims, “this is not a place for health. this is thanksgiving.” this quintessential thanksgiving meal, with the turkey as its heart, the nation as its soul, and politics as its platter, has been served at the white house for nearly 150 years. inspired by lincoln’s 1863 thanksgiving proclamation, intended to restore “peace, harmony, tranquility, and union” to a nation torn apart by civil war, americans dine in union with the carver in chief (since 1989, turkey pardoner as well). in 1897, for example, the affable mckinleys stuck to the traditional turkey (with oyster stuffing) and predictable trimmings. a dozen years later president taft, a gargantuan eater, complemented his 30 pound turkey with a 26 pound opossum and a 50 pound mince pie (shapiro). the deliberate austerity of presidential thanksgiving menus during world wars i and ii and during the depression (soup, turkey, a few sides, pumpkin pie) was in 2016 supplanted by the feast the obamas (not ordinarily given to excess) hosted after their family helped serve midday dinner at the armed forces retirement home. their politically delicious meal incorporated international appetizers (chicken satay, pizza bites, fresh veggies and hummus); four meats (turkey, ham, prime rib, chicken wings); eclectic sides (oyster stuffing, 72 recipe﻿﻿ cornbread stuffing with chorizo and roasted peppers, mashed potatoes, sweet potato gratin, green bean casserole, mac & cheese, braised winter greens, kale caesar salad); and six pies banana cream, coconut cream, pumpkin, apple, pecan, and cherry. the obamas’ largesse offers liberty for every taste and cultural predilection (seipel). as the president dines, so dines the nation. the social dynamics traditions dictate the celebration’s configuration, hardwired into the more general culture and honored, with variations, by the celebrants. every native understands through total immersion in the event from birth onward what newcomers to the family, the culture, the country, must learn in order to merit a seat at the table. for example, ana menéndez explains the gradual process by which her cuban immigrant family transformed the holiday they initially called “tansgibin” into a thanksgiving of their own. in cuba, she says, “the center of the party was, of course, the pig,” 50 delicious pounds, marinated overnight in mojo a quart of sour orange juice spiked with garlic, salt, cumin, and oregano then roasted all day over a grill. over time, as the family shrank, “a whole pig seemed an embarrassing extravagance,” and they switched to turkey, its succulence assured through “treating the bird exactly as if it were a pig,” also steeped overnight in a mojo marinade. ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 73 the classic thanksgiving celebration looks like this as with most celebrations, many decisions were made before the participants were even born. where and when most (90%) people expect to eat at someone’s home rather than a restaurant. whatever the distance they travel during this busiest holiday period of the year (55 million hit the road in 2019), they know when they should show up at the table, whether it’s 2, 4, or 6 p.m. guests from babies to great grandparents, attendees are preordained by family membership, friendship groups, custom, and special invitation. yet as families blend, separate, split, and realign, even the a list is subject to change, welcome and not. the b list, endlessly fluid, may include friends, colleagues, or relatives of the a listers; single or displaced persons, such as students, international visitors, ex spouses. if more people are invited than the main table can seat, tables will be added rather than guests subtracted. 74 recipe﻿﻿ host in contrast to martha stewart’s guilt inducing perfectionism, stifton, advocates a relaxed holiday meal. he observes in thanksgiving, “social engineering is as much a part of setting the thanksgiving table as ironing napkins and polishing silver.” despite relatives jockeying for pride of place, the family matriarch will likely do the honors if she has the energy, space, and money, menu the hostess will also dictate the menu, subject to tradition but nibbled away at by others with significant family clout. minutiae as well as major items are at stake: will there be ham as well as turkey? marshmallows on the sweet potatoes? will seaweed turn up as the new kale? can spices such as harissa or za’atar sneak in? expectations guests expect to have a hand in the meal by bringing sides or desserts, wine, or flowers. some give thanks, others don’t, but everyone expects to overeat, if not except for the legendary uncle to overdrink. everyone expects leftovers. to counteract the overabundance, some will run a 5k charitable turkey trot or serve in a soup kitchen beforehand; more may go for a walk (or waddle) between the main meal and dessert or play touch ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 75 football before watching tv. after the meal many expect to pitch in with the cleanup before heading out for early holiday shopping, turkey carcass simmering for tomorrow’s soup. food fest the nation has great expectations for this feast, piling on comfort food upon comfort food 3000 4500 calories of soft, relatively bland choices, easy to heap onto a plate for first, second, even third helpings. the american farm bureau figures a modest six dollars per person from relish tray to pie only fifty cents more than a big mac cost in 2021, making the complete thanksgiving dinner america’s cheapest celebratory meal, although big spenders could provide an extravaganza of oysters, heritage turkey, and champagne. because the menu’s core constituents are predetermined, we’ll focus here on cooks’ major considerations in how to select and prepare these traditional foods briefly limned here, but often the subject of protracted debate and negotiation in print, online, and around the table. turkey the meal’s centerpiece is, of course, the great american bird, whose substantial size intimidates many a cook. “you can go your whole life and then wake up one morning and look in the refrigerator at this animal carcass the size of a 76 recipe﻿﻿ toddler and think: i have to cook that today. there is no need to worry,” stifton reassures, “thanksgiving does not have to be a drag.” during the holiday season the butterball turkey talk hotline, now available on social media, live chat, texting, and alexa, answers 100,000 questions in english and spanish, many addressing the bird’s size, number of guests, and available equipment. can you really cook a turkey in a microwave? or in an instant pot? turkey deliberations which turkey? true to its heritage, the wild turkey hunted by shotgun or bow and arrow is, hunters swear, among the tastiest wild game on the planet. second in savoriness are fresh, domesticated, freerange organic or commercially farmed turkeys, “markedly better than frozen” (joy 2006). nevertheless, cook’s illustrated argues that unless you’re buying the bird fresh from a local farm, a frozen turkey is the better bet because the quickfreezing process prevents ice crystals from forming and damaging the meat. lowest on the food chain, and by far the cheapest, is the frozen supermarket turkey, whose taste and texture can be compromised by added water, phosphates, and “funky tasting spices,” warns cook’s illustrated, opting for freerange fresh despite their own caveat. if the meat is smothered in stuffing and gravy, can diners really discriminate among these gradations? ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 77 how big? how to cook? all recipes allow one generous pound per diner, so do the math. all preparations aim for a “beautifully browned, intensely flavorful” juicy bird (joy 2006). will the bird be brined in advance of being roasted, spatchcocked (backbone removed and meat flattened), smoked, grilled on a rack or rotisserie? or deep fried in 6 gallons of oil in a 40 quart pot a hazardous outdoor endeavor requiring two intrepid heavy lifters, silicone gloves, and long handled tongs. still, even roasting, the most familiar method, requires decisions. breast side up in a roasting pan? this utterly sedate method risks a dry breast, but frequent basting adds juices. via turkey wrangling in which the cook, wearing gloves and using tongs, flips the bird from side to side every half hour? or breast side down then up for the final browning? what else will intensify the flavor of an essentially bland, commercially raised fowl? cooks often insert herbs, onion, lemon, celery under the skin, and inside the cavity of an unstuffed bird. but the best flavor enhancement lies in the stuffing. what temperature and technique will keep all parts equally juicy, since dark and light meat cook differentially? there is no consensus on how to decide when to turn the heat up or down among the recommended temperatures: 450⁰ (lopez alt), 425⁰ (claiborne), 350⁰ (beard), 325⁰ (tipton martin). is special equipment, large vessels that will be used only once or twice a year, worth the cost? your call. how to know 78 recipe﻿﻿ when the turkey is done via wiggling a leg, observing the juice, or inserting an instant read thermometer in the thickest part of the thigh at 185⁰ (claiborne), 180⁰ (tiptonmartin), 170⁰ (joy 2006), 175⁰ at the thigh, 160⁰ in the breast (cook’s illustrated). can the pop ups be trusted? no, say the pros, they emerge either too early or too late. stuffing/dressing this requires only two major decisions: what kind, and whether or not to cook it inside (stuffing) or outside the bird (dressing). if stuffing wins, to avoid food poisoning, all the chefs advise three major safety precautions. stuff the turkey just before cooking; cook it thoroughly; unstuff the bird and serve immediately. nevertheless, food network’s alton brown exhorts, “stuffing is evil” make dressing instead (npr). stuffing/dressing recipes, which usually contain a major starch bread, cornbread, rice, bean thread noodles are infinitely capacious, adaptable to a world of tastes. joy’s basic bread stuffing (2019) allows ¾ cup per serving and recommends the ratio of 2 starch: 1 vegetables: 1 liquid: 1 2 ¼ savory elements. use twice as many cups of bread cubes to onion and celery; enough chicken stock with (or without) beaten eggs to moisten the dressing, say, 1 2 ½ cups total; and seasonings to taste parsley, sage, thyme, salt, black pepper, nutmeg, cloves. the basic bread stuffing recipe can be adapted to a nut/fruit mixture: 1 cup of chopped nuts ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 79 (walnuts, pecans, brazil nuts, chestnuts) and/or 1 cup of dried fruit (raisins, cranberries, cherries, diced prunes). other variations include a pint of oysters, or a pound of mushrooms, or a pound of pork sausage and 4 cups tart apples. families pledge allegiance to their favorite stuffing. cornbread dressing (in which succulent cornbread supplants stale white bread), “is a litmus test on class, race, regional loyalties and grandmothers,” concludes kim severson in “how i mastered the art (and politics) of cornbread dressing.” it’s “[t]he third rail of southern home cooking.” adrian miller says that historically, southern white cornmeal was naturally sweeter and of higher status than yellow, “fit only for ‘chicken feed,’” but tastes and status changed when black people moved north. arguments erupt over sugar: “asking a southern cook whether sugar belongs in cornbread is like pouring gasoline on a smoldering fire,” says tipton martin. edna lewis, doyenne of southern cooking and a white cornmeal no sugar purist, incorporates 3 cups of pecans into her cornbread dressing, the gold standard. immigrants’ stuffing recipes are cultural blends. the new york times’ “american thanksgiving” reports standouts: italian spinach stuffing with a blend of frozen spinach baked with mushrooms, chicken gizzards, and 4 eggs; and hmong egg roll stuffing that transplants egg roll filling into the turkey: shredded green cabbage and carrots, bean thread noodles, chopped onions and cilantro, 3 eggs, garlic and oyster sauce. 80 recipe﻿﻿ gravy gravy is as much a process of frantic whisking as it is a byproduct of cooking the turkey: stock, pan juices, vegetables that escaped during the roasting, and possibly minced giblets. joy’s kinetic advice, the template of every gravy recipe, urges bringing a quart of defatted, strained turkey stock to “a furious boil. then pour it all at once into the roux (4 tablespoons butter and 4 tablespoons flour, whisked together until toasty brown), whisking as you pour. whisking constantly, bring the gravy to a simmer over medium heat and cook for 1 minute.” a slug of sherry extra for the cook is optional (2006). mashed (white) potatoes all recipes aim for light, fluffy, buttery, moist potatoes  buttery looking yukon golds preferred, russets/idahos second. the right tool, a hand potato masher, ricer, or food mill, adds air to the pot of boiled or baked potatoes and eliminates lumps. sara moulton cautions, “just don’t mash them in the food processor unless you want an irretrievable gluey mess.” the classic thanksgiving version requires skins off, and, says moskin, “be openhanded with salt and butter”  about 2 tablespoons butter: 1 pound potatoes “but stingy with milk, which will flatten out the bright, earthy potato taste.” use ¼ cup milk: 1 pound potatoes (although many cooks add much more milk). nothing else. fancier additions can gussy up simpler meals but would be lost in the wealth ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 81 of thanksgiving opportunities. they include roasted garlic (anathema to stifton), saffron threads, duxelles, caramelized onions, chopped herbs, or grated swiss, gruye﻿̀re, or cheddar. the over the top version is drummond’s “instant pot mashed potatoes,” in which butter (½ pound), cream cheese (12 ounces), and half and half and heavy cream (1/2 cup each) overpower 5 pounds of potatoes. sweet potatoes naturally “sweet as the first kiss,” according to tiptonmartin “so why do we add sugar, molasses, maple syrup, or fruit juice to this luscious vegetable?” this soul food classic evolved, she explains, from the practice of sugar cane workers throwing their sweet potatoes into the boiling syrup pot to cook for a half hour before devouring them for lunch voilá, candied sweet potatoes. but some cooks can’t leave well enough alone, and even this sturdy dish can buckle under the weight of high calorie sweetness piled on: heavy cream, honey, chopped pineapple, pecans, coconut, along with condiments like sherry, ground ginger, lemon zest, raisins, cinnamon, or nutmeg. marshmallows, an angelus marketing promotion in 1917, are regarded today as either cute or disgusting; minimalist beard warns, add “at your own risk.” in contrast, bittman’s sweet potato recipes are remarkably restrained, the savory vegetable sautéed in olive oil with paired flavorings garlic/sugar, chipotle/lime, or ginger/soy. period. 82 recipe﻿﻿ green bean casserole there is only one recipe here, beloved for salt, fat, and crunch. emerging from campbell’s test kitchen in 1955, green bean casserole became an instant essential for thanksgiving dinner, with 20 million served in 2020. the classic version, promoted by campbell’s and reaffirmed with tweaks by mainstream cookbooks reads: combine a 10.5 ounce can of campbell’s condensed cream of mushroom soup (a sacrilegious version substitutes tomato soup, hard to imagine), ½ cup milk, and 2/3 cup of canned french fried onions. pour over 1 pound of cooked green beans, bake at 350⁰ for 25 minutes, top with another half cup of onions and bake for 5 more minutes until browned. the 2019 joy allows homemade alternatives to these “old convenience” products. these specifications lend a false sense of precision; sloppiness works just as well, for the amounts of all ingredients can vary considerably without an appreciable difference in taste. perelman’s version uses homemade crispy onions. paula deen freshens up with diced onions, raw mushrooms, and cheddar cheese. but campbell’s reigns. cranberry sauce likewise, there is a single enduring recipe on every one of the ocean spray packages: 1 cup each of sugar and water, 12 ounces fresh cranberries. boil gently for 10 minutes, stirring ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 83 occasionally. cool before serving. so ubiquitous is this recipe that most cookbooks don’t include it; even ocean spray’s 101 all time favorite cranberry recipes has only a single recipe for sauce. ocean spray, the nation’s largest cranberry source, estimates that 80 million pounds, 20% of the total harvest, are sold during thanksgiving week, when americans consume over 5 million gallons of jellied cranberry sauce. only 25% of households prepare this simple dish from scratch; the rest choose either canned sauce or the jellied cylinder that emerges with striations from the can to undulate on the table. the dolly parton among sweet betty crockerish cranberry concoctions is “mama stamberg’s cranberry relish,” a recipe presented annually on npr, likely the most bracing dish on the thanksgiving table. this flamboyant concoction owes its panache to horseradish, raw onion, and to sour cream that turns the dish pepto bismol pink. adapted from craig claiborne’s 1959 recipe, stamberg uses 2 cups cranberries, 1 small onion, 3/4 cup sour cream, 1/2 cup sugar, and 2 tablespoons grated horseradish. coarsely grind the cranberries and onion; add everything else, mix and freeze. thaw several hours before serving. other sides there is more latitude in the sides than in the rest of the meal. menus evolve as diners choose vegetarian and vegan options and special diets, and as guests contribute their favorite sides from their home region, culture, or country. the obamas’ 84 recipe﻿﻿ menu provides a glimpse of the inter/national spectrum. other family preferences dictate a host of options among vegetables branchy, knobby, spiky, squishy, and round: orange (carrots, squash), green (broccoli, brussels sprouts, spinach), and white (cauliflower, celery, mushrooms, onions). salads, like soup and appetizers, strike some as superfluous; why fill up with lettuce on turkey day? yet salads do appear, leafy, vegetably, fruity even the retro jell o mold with mandarin oranges. pie pie is inevitable. recipe’s concluding recipe, for the best blueberry pie, is calculated to invoke pie lust. johnny appleseed’s dispersal of apple seedlings throughout the new nation established the foundational fruit in the larder of american culture. abolitionist henry ward beecher extolled apple pie order, declaring that “no other fruit can pretend to vie with the apple as the fruit of the common people.” a new york times editorial proclaimed in 1902: “pie is the synonym for american prosperity. pie is the food of the heroic. no pie eating people can ever be vanquished.” epitomized in “as american as apple pie” and delineated on numerous pie charts, apple is consistently voted the thanksgiving favorite, followed by pumpkin, chocolate crème, cherry, and pecan. nevertheless, pumpkin pie reigns at the thanksgiving table, as it has for two centuries, and cooks are still trying to ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 85 get the recipe right. “over the river and through the wood” (1844) cheers “hurrah for the pumpkin pie.” the great pumpkin pie recipe celebrated in sally’s baking addiction echoes this sentiment. this “rich, luxurious texture, silky smooth, creamy, absolutely heavenly” pie blends canned pumpkin (15 ounces), 3 eggs, 1 cup heavy cream and ¼ cup milk, cornstarch, the characteristic spices cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, cloves and sally’s secret ingredient, a pinch of pepper (mckenny). yet for many, as with cranberry sauce, the commercial product outweighs homemade. despite a wealth of recipes and robust canned pumpkin sales, costco sells 1.75 million supersize (12”) 3.8 pound pumpkin pies during the three days preceding thanksgiving, at $5.99$6.99 depending on location, acclaimed by connoisseurs as a delectable bargain, even the crust. the ideal pie crust is flaky, tender, and sturdy, the promise of thousands of recipes. greenspan makes the aspiration attainable, recommending all butter pie dough as “the right recipe for all pies, from fruit to cream and custard. because it’s made with only butter (2 sticks: 3 cups flour), it’s flavorful as well as sturdy. and because it’s got a sufficient amount of both sugar (¼ cup many recipes don’t use sugar) and salt (1 ¼ tsp.), it’s got character. i like it,” she says, “when a crust makes as strong a statement as the filling” (baking). to satisfy everyone, any family worth its salt feels free to add whatever they want to the barebones menu limned above, but they can’t omit a sacred dish or tamper with a revered 86 recipe﻿﻿ recipe without provoking rebellion. every family has stories of sulking and umbrage, violation of taboo and tradition too personal and painful to recount here. so, some households add to the groaning table cheesecake, carrot cake, mock apple pie with a ritz cracker filling (no kidding! yet that bizarre filling actually tastes like apple pie), ice cream atop the pie, a last blast of calorie overload before the diners stagger off. thanksgiving sandwich ah, the ecstasy and the gluttony of leftovers. leftovers accompany guests, fill the freezer, turn up at tomorrow’s breakfast, lunch, and dinner. the essentials of the traditional meal can be piled into the jaw stretching thanksgiving sandwich (“the pilgrim” or “the gobbler”), available yearround at diehard diners: leftover sliced turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, cranberry sauce, gravy. in restaurants, where the sandwich can cost more than an entire frozen turkey, recipes may add such items as green beans, fresh spinach, brussels sprouts slaw, provolone, or marinated kale. what exactly are we celebrating? expectations for a perfect celebration may be, as samuel johnson says of a second marriage, a triumph of hope over experience. we approach our own thanksgivings through ﻿﻿joys of cooking and eating 87 idealized memories of ancestral feasts and edited national history, family rifts smoothed over and transgressions tabled, appetites whetted by tv cooking shows and inspiring fivepound cookbooks. during times of steady income and full cupboards we may take this bounty for granted. yet on this day of national celebration, stifton reminds us to give thanks, from trailer homes to mansions, not for the food but for the community gathered together: “simply by its utterance, thanksgiving provides the meal with a moment of grace. look around the table now, into the eyes of everyone assembled. you see? that is what we’re looking for in this feast, ultimately: a moment of grace, born of thanksgiving. don’t forget that. it matters” (rosenstrach). or, in the spirit of henry david thoreau, diners could extend the gratitude to eternity: “i am grateful for what i am and have. my thanksgiving is perpetual.” 88 recipe﻿﻿ 5 “please, sir, i want some more.” the recipe as a manifestation of power, politics, poverty, and punishment everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well being of himself and of his family, including food.  united nations, universal declaration of human rights hunger the hungry always want more. hunger reverberates in the desperate request of dickens’s wretched waif, oliver twist. “having suffered the tortures of slow starvation for three months, desperate with hunger,” he begs for another helping of flavorless, watery gruel, “please, sir, i want some more.” hunger is etched in the iconic image of the great depression, the haunting face of dorothea lange’s “migrant mother,” an itinerant dust bowl harvester struggling to feed her seven children. hunger is carved in the skeletal images of millions of victims of war throughout the centuries, civilian and military. hunger, the grim reaper, still stalks the world, haunting the long lines of refugees worldwide, waiting always for meager bowls of gruel, 84 million people forcibly displaced as a result of conflict, persecution, war.1 climate change, conflict, and the covid 19 pandemic have affected the entire world. in particular 47 countries are on the precipice of famine, experiencing severe food insecurity and its devastating consequences  bland language for devastation, desolation, and death. the global hunger index identifies the world’s hungriest countries in 2021: haiti in north america, timor leste and yemen in asia, and seven in africa: somalia, central african republic, chad, democratic republic of congo, liberia, madagascar, and sierra leone. a single shocking example will represent the whole. after 30 years of civil conflict somalia, the hungriest country on the precipice of famine, has been identified as having 59.5% of the population undernourished, 31.9% of the children stunted, and an 11.7% child mortality rate. see also vongrebmer et al. world food program data in 2021 indicate that “2.7 million people cannot meet their daily food requirements, 1 90 recipe﻿﻿ desperation dictates that the basic recipe of this chapter will be for porridge oliver twist’s gruel a generic label for cheap, nourishing, grain based food intended to keep people alive. although the un’s 1948 universal declaration of human rights asserts that adequate food is a human right, like many other provisions of this idealistic document, this is sanctioned but not enforced. feeding the hungry might appear to be a simple, humanitarian concern, but in practice this is an enormously complicated issue, intertwining matters poverty, power, politics, and punishment. who gets what food? do human beings intrinsically deserve it, or do they have to earn it? what kind and quality? how much, a barebones minimum or enough for recipients to thrive? where will the food be grown, harvested, and processed, and by whom? who will select it, pay for it, transport it, store it, distribute it? would cash be better? if so, how much? what should it be used for? do the recipients, perennially suspected of being profligate ne’er do wells who if not restrained might spend the money on tattoos, lingerie, or gasp cruises, have any say or agency in these matters (kenny)? or are these decisions made top down, by various factions with agendas cooperative or competitive: government agencies, international or national relief organizations, welfare 5.6 million people are food insecure, and 12.3 million require humanitarian assistance” (“these are the world’s hungriest countries in 2021.” see also unwfp, “nearly 60%. . .”) ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 91 agencies, religious or community groups, or local food pantries? these complex considerations, with no firm or enduring answers, underlie the discussion that follows, tip of the iceberg here because the subject is so vast and deep in an ever changing world. having reduced world hunger significantly by 2014, the world health organization aimed to eradicate it entirely by 2030, but instead the covid 19 pandemic caused hunger to spike. the food and agriculture organization of the un reports in state of food security and nutrition in the world 2021 that “between 720 and 811 million people in the world faced hunger in 2020,” and that “of the 2.37 billion people facing moderate or severe food insecurity, half (1.2 billion) are found in asia, one third (799 million) in africa, and 11 percent (267 million) in latin america and the caribbean” as well as 8% of the population of northern america and europe. in the wealthy united states, 1 in 6 people (50.4 million), including 1 in 4 children (17 million) 54% of households with children went hungry in 2020, figures nearly tripled to 38% from 2019 because of the pandemic. in “food insecurity during covid 19,” public health researchers wolfson and leung obsrve that “among adults with incomes less than 250% of the 2020 federal poverty level, 44% of all households were food insecure, including 48% of black households, 52% of hispanic households, and 54% of hoursholds with children. the numbers cited throughout this chapter, although staggering, are imprecise because of volatile world politics, 92 recipe﻿﻿ pandemic issues, ongoing strife and wars, and unstable and conflicting sources of information. the important thing to remember is that the numbers are huge. food security to sustain an active and healthy life, people need food security regular access to sufficient, affordable, safe, and nutritious food that suits their individual tastes and cultural preferences. men need around 2500 calories daily, women 2000. food security means that economically secure people don’t need to worry about where their next meal is coming from, nor do they have to choose between eating, paying the rent, and medical care. they don’t need to skimp on food quality or skip meals or go entire days without food. they can afford to feed themselves and their families in the present and in the foreseeable future, to enjoy treats and hospitality. even when worldwide hunger mounts, as lappé and collins say in world hunger, the secure don’t know the “anguish, grief, humiliation, and fear” that millions of people who are food insecure experience routinely. food insufficiency as defined by the united states department of agriculture (usda) food insufficiency is simply bottom line hunger. people don’t have enough to eat. within a given week, sometimes or often they skip meals or go whole days ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 93 without food. food insufficiency is more severe than food insecurity, a broader term applicable to all two billion people with inadequate diets. even if people can get enough food to sustain their energy level and keep them from feeling hungry, they can still be food insecure if the food isn’t nutritious, lacks variety, or the supply is erratic. paradoxically, over 40% of americans with food insecurity are obese, and another third are overweight. common snack foods are engineered to provide instant hits of high fructose corn syrup and salt, as highly addictive as heroin or cocaine, and to keep eaters craving more, says melissa kravitz of ecowatch. the more you consume, the more you want. has anyone the willpower to eat just one potato chip? consequently, reports journalist adrian nicole leblanc, also a macarthur fellow, “[f]ood insecurity no longer looks like a skinny mother in a tent or children with rickets and kwashiorkor” (severe malnutrition), it looks obese. the body of food insecurity has bulked up around the world, with 378 million children and two billion adults overweight (one third of them obese), experiencing sky high incidences of diabetes, high blood pressure, and coronary heart disease, among other devastating consequences. as spelled out in the food and agriculture organization of the uns 2019 report, the economic costs of malnutrition are enormous two trillion dollars annually in increased health care costs and lost economic productivity. the 2020 report projects that costs will exceed 1.3 us dollars by 2030. 94 recipe﻿﻿ food assistance programs such as the us supplemental nutrition assistance program (snap electronic food stamps) fall short by about 50 cents per meal. so to fill up, families, perhaps segregated by food apartheid, choose what they can afford from what’s available where they live. these may be food swamps, areas teeming with fast food franchises, junk food outlets, convenience stores, and liquor stores that overpower healthful food options; or food deserts, lacking grocery stores and a readily available variety of wholesome foods.2 the available junk foods are cheap, high in calories, saturated fats, cholesterol, sugars, and salt, and low in the nutrients provided by more expensive fresh fruits, vegetables, and dairy products. for instance, a “combo meal” at mcdonald’s big mac (two hamburger patties), medium fries, and medium coke totals 1080 calories, nearly half the daily requirement. a 12 ounce can of soda has between 150 and 200 calories. sugar sneaks into everyone’s diet; americans average 42.5 teaspoons (800 calories) per day, mostly added unobtrusively to food. feeding the poor the well fed have fretted for centuries about feeding the poor. from onset of the english poor laws in 1601 to see cooksey stowers, schwartz, and brownell. 2 ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 95 america’s current politicians, the affluent righteous contend that only the deserving poor (preferably employed) warrant the charity of handouts widows, the old, the infirm, some people with some disabilities. even orphans, symbolized by dickens’s oliver twist, “the humble, halfstarved drudge,” are suspected of being unworthy of this grudging bounty and thus deserve to be “cuffed and buffeted through the world despised by all, and pitied by none.” in contrast to these victims of circumstance, say the strict constructionists, the undeserving poor boozers, gamblers, loafers, all by definition morally corrupt  should work for their pittance. society’s bountiful are expected, indeed pressured, to provide enough food to keep the less fortunate alive, but not enough to sustain a robust life unless the recipients work to earn their keep, as ziegelman and coe explain in a square meal. that the sharp edge of hunger has a moral virtue has been the standard conservative argument from the 1930s to the reagan and trump administrations. congressman paul ryan’s scrooge like assertion sums up this stance: if people had enough food to eat they’d enjoy being on the dole, “not even thinking about working or learning the value of work” (covert). these views of the poor as lazy and morally derelict ignore the realities of poverty in the us and throughout the world. dickensian conditions persist. in addition to people unable to earn a living wage in the long term, newly or temporarily poor people are thrown out of work or displaced 96 recipe﻿﻿ by economic depression, pandemic, drought, fires, floods, and other disasters. food is an immediate, urgent, and persistent need not only for the existing population, but for the 20.5 million newborns with low birthweight who, if they survive beyond the age of five, have a high chance of growing up stunted (unicef and who). the economic costs of malnutrition are huge. the food and agriculture organization of the un report offers a comprehensive analysis of the causes, effects, and possible solutions to world hunger from multiple perspectives, including agriculture, food, health, water, sanitation, social protection, development planning and economic policy. to end world hunger by 2030, the un aims through international policy decisions and economic planning to eradicate extreme poverty, reduce inequalities, and ensure living wages and inclusive economic growth, matters too detailed for discussion here. the immediate process of getting food from farm to bread line or food pantry can be complicated and costly, with many hands stirring the pot. among the influences are governmental food policies and farm subsidies; commodity price negotiations; tariffs and tax deductions; international relief programs such as the un’s world food programme (recipient of the 2020 nobel peace prize), as well as other nutrition oriented charities, both collaborating and competitive; transportation, whether halfway around the world via ships and airlifts, or locally sourced and delivered by trucks, camels, even drones. ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 97 crop yields and thus prices are affected by availability of fertilizers and harvesters, human or mechanical; climate conditions, including storms, floods, and drought; erosion of the harvest through disease, pests, graft, and theft. despite the staggering amount of food insecurity, hunger and malnutrition that affects every country in the world, the food and agriculture organization of the un estimates in “food loss and food waste” that “one third of all food produced globally is lost or goes to waste.” an estimated 14% of food production is discarded, incinerated, or otherwise disappears during the three to six months it takes for food to travel from farm to storage to market. another 20% is squandered in markets, restaurants, and home kitchens. in addition to discarding unused and leftover foods, fresh produce deviating from optimal size, shape, or color is often tossed, as are canned goods whose “sell by” date has expired. saving just one fourth of this total, says the un, could end world hunger. the food itself international the food in the above discussion is not considered cuisine but commodities, destined to feed huge numbers of people, diets of desperation that are designed to provide maximum nourishment in minimal contexts, often crowded, hot, 98 recipe﻿﻿ unsanitary. whatever the feeding programs, whether centuries old or contemporary, the foods have to be lowcost, available in bulk, easily portable, storable (some for up to two years) without deterioration, refrigeration, or contamination such as by insects, rot, or mold. moreover, the foods must be simple to prepare with minimal skill or equipment, capable of being watered down to accommodate large numbers of starving people, and easy to eat with a spoon, or fingers. difficulties of storage and supply have kept fresh foods  meat, fruit, vegetables, dairy off international tables until recently. however, as charles kenny’ explains in “give poor people cash,” in 2019, 2 billion in cash or vouchers made it possible for up to 20% of the food distributed through the world food programme to be purchased or grown locally, by 34 million people in 64 countries, saving shipping and storage costs and cutting out graft. consequently, people eat more and better food and are healthier, the money (raised through organizations such as givedirectly and usaid) circulates in the local economy, and surplus funds are spent on health care and school fees, in some indian villages doubling the percentage of girls aged 14 to 18 staying in school. win win win win! foods and food supplements provided internationally  such as bulgur, corn, dry beans or peas, lentils, milled rice, and wheat flour have to meet strict usda and who standards. among the ready to use supplementary foods are “highly fortified, nutrient dense pastes” designed to ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 99 treat and prevent acute malnutrition in young children; whey protein concentrate; and high energy biscuits for older children and adults that are also required to look good, smell good, and taste good. made from a proteinrich blend of wheat flour, potato flour, sugar, shortening, and skim milk, and fortified with an alphabet of vitamins and minerals, these life saving biscuits can be eaten dry, an advantage in the absence of dishes, or crumbled in liquid as porridge. united states american feeding programs, whether private charities or the alphabet soup of government acronyms (snap, wic, csfp, nslp, sfmnp) have multiplied since the depression era, under precise specifications. according to the usda food and nutrition service, the range of foods allocated by the usda has expanded well beyond the 1930s nonperishable breadline basics of beef, bread, coffee, and sugar, or the austere diet allotted to a family of five in the 100 pound monthly relief boxes: flour, split beans, cracked rice, coffee, cornmeal, lard, bacon, and a half gallon of molasses ( ziegelman and coe). foods distributed 2015 to 2020 include juice, milk, cereal, cheese, eggs, canned fish, rice, pasta, peanut butter; a cash allocation for fresh fruits and vegetables can also be spent on the high calorie beverages and sweets that contribute to obesity. the largest program, snap, served 28 million people in 2019, 12% of 100 recipe﻿﻿ the us population, and 42 million in 2021.3 sources are careful to specify that three quarters of the recipients are working thereby implying that they deserve the handout. at the same time, wic (women, infants, and children) served 6.9 million people per month. school lunch and school breakfast programs, feeding 5 million and 2.5 million/year, respectively, provide a literal lifeline not only for the 1 in 7 children they serve directly, but for the families whose food dollars can stretch farther when they’re not responsible for every meal. even when the foods are varied, as in the us, the major food that sustains hungry people worldwide is porridge. the recipe: porridge porridge grain mixed with water or milk is a cheap, humble, nutritious food that has nourished people the world over, from paleolithic times to the present, in sickness and in health, from the cradle to the grave. neither romantic nor dramatic (except as a goldilocks lure), porridge sits soothingly in the bowl, serving as both the ultimate comfort food and the essence of survival: high in carbs, dietary fiber, protein, fat, phosphorous, food and nutrition service, usda snap data tables, national level annual summary. 11/21/2021. 3 ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 101 calcium, iron, and vitamin a. the grains that porridge is made from oats, rice, wheat, maize, millet, sorghum, barley have been wrestled into edibility through boiling, chopping, crushing, or grinding harsh preparation for such a bland result. legumes lentils, beans, and peas (as in “pease porridge hot”) require less effort. like many other simple, essential foods, porridge was part of the diet before there were recipes, and remains today a staple of cooks who either don’t read or don’t need recipes. it is also gushed over by bubbly chefs and bloggers determined to counteract negative memories among the well fed over their childhood avoidance of a viscous substance that congealed into lumps if they dawdled at the table. the world of porridge recipes any porridge recipe, whatever the grain, is a blank slate awaiting embellishment hence its appeal. there are at least a hundred iterations of any basic dish, and nested within like matryoshka dolls, hundreds more variations of each of the originals, and more inside those, spanning the wide world of options. these names, however, designate categories of porridge, and are further refined by geography, ingredients, and individual taste. rice, for instance, congee, hong kong’s name for the soupy, savory rice porridge that is a welcome staple of asian diets, has a multitude of other names depending on its country of origin: juk (china, n and s korea), okayu (japan), 102 recipe﻿﻿ burbur (indonesia), lugaw (philippines), kanji (india), chok (thailand), and many more. corn is a porridge mainstay throughout africa. variations exist for ugali (so named in kenya, tanzania, and eastern uganda), such as pap or mielie pap (south africa highlands), nshima (malawi, zambia), ogi (nigeria), nufundi (congo); and various north and south american cousins, including cornmeal mush, grits (southern u.s.), atole (mexico), mamalinga (serbia), and polenta (italy). oats, wheat, millet, sorghum, and other grains also cover the world’s tables in rich profusion. oatmeal is the common appellation for oat porridge throughout north america and parts of europe. the basic recipe for cooking all grains is essentially the same. bittman boils it down to three steps: 1. wash the grains. 2. combine grains and water, with a pinch of salt. bring to a boil and then turn the heat down to a simmering bubble. 3. cook until tender; the cooking times vary depending on the grain. the ratio of grain to liquid depends on the country, the culture, and the cook; that formula varies considerably. enhancements grains are bland, even when cooked in salted water, broth, milk, or other liquids. recipes address the need for flavor and variety by recommending innumerable additions to the basic grain, sometimes mixed with it, otherwise served ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 103 on top, or in small adjacent dishes. they often specify the ingredient (spring onion greens) or seasoning (ginger, fresh or preserved), but are casual about the quantity “1 handful spinach washed,” “berries, almonds, chia seeds for topping.” porridge recipes that employ precise specifics (2 scallions  inexact because scallions vary in size) give novice cooks an artificial construct to grab onto until they are comfortable enough to let go and swing out, free form, into the amorphous realm of grains as people encounter them the world over. although americans and western europeans consider porridge as a breakfast food, throughout africa and asia porridges that begin the day can serve as savory main dishes, as well. many of the ingredients mostly toppings that bittman suggests to pep up grains render them suitable for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. these include grated or crumbled cheese, chopped nuts or dried fruit, other grains (cooked beans, peas, or lentils), tomato sauce or salsa, chopped scallions, assorted spices, and more. even though many of these additions may seem a stretch to americans used to ascetic oatmeal or cream of wheat with milk or cream and a bit of fruit, in fact this broader palate of accompaniments is found in porridges everywhere and appears in american porridge bowls as well. oatmeal the essential oatmeal porridge recipe is 1 part of rolled oats boiled with 2 parts of water or milk, cooked from 1 to 104 recipe﻿﻿ 5 minutes for various “instant” oatmeal varieties, 30 minutes for steel cut oats. ella eaton kellogg’s (wife of battle creek health sanitarium physician john kellogg) 1897 recipe for granola mush used this 1:2 ratio, cooked for 2 3 minutes, then served hot with cream and raisins, sliced peaches, apples, bananas, or blueberries (see white, johnson). kellogg’s surprisingly modern recipe is echoed in share our strength’s food pantry granola recipe that blends 2 cups old fashioned rolled oats, mixed with honey, canola oil, cinnamon, a sprinkling of sliced or chopped almonds with ½ cup dried fruit (raisins, cranberries, apricots, dates, or prunes). this recipe, composed of non perishable ingredients, reflects not only good nutrition but the fact that food pantries don’t necessarily stock fresh food. the golden ratio for steel cut oats chewy little nuggets instead of the rolled flakes is 1:3. oatmeal gruel changes the ratio to 1:4, but in starvation circumstances it can be watered down even more. the barebones recipe for oliver twist’s coveted workhouse gruel (1872) is a soupy 1:4 ratio, 16 ounces of oatmeal cooked in 8 pints of water, flavored with 4 ounces of treacle and a hint of allspice. quaker oats reigns. among its 491 website recipes (75 for breakfast oatmeal) are baked oatmeal, cranberry almond granola parfaits, and overnight oats (including cherry vanilla, carrot cake, piña colada, and more). in 2012 oatmeals, “the world’s first all oatmeal café,” opened in greenwich village, paying homage to porridge made from steel cut oats. custom toppings included fruits, nuts, sun ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 105 dried tomatoes, goat cheese, sriracha, and crystallized ginger. signature bowls baby bear, mama bear, and papa bear, of course proffered truffle risoato, the elvis (banana, peanut butter, bacon), and chinese style congee porridge (poached egg, scallions, seasonings). sadly, oatmeals succumbed to covid 19 in january, 2021. congee chinese cooking expert fuchsia dunlop proclaims in land of fish and rice that congee is “the most universal of comfort foods, a caress of the mouth and stomach.” a breakfast mainstay throughout asia, in times of famine it can stretch to feed multitudes. dunlop’s basic recipe calls for “¾ cup thai fragrant rice or sushi rice; ½ tsp salt; 2 tsp cooking oil; 2 ½ quarts water. rinse and drain the rice. mix it with the salt and oil and set aside for 30 minutes. rinse and drain again.” in every grain of rice, dunlop expands her explanation that congee requires slow cooking until the rice grains “dissolve into a voluptuous, satiny mass, a soft porridge.” how long? she suggests an hour and a half, but slow can range from 1 2 hours to overnight if a rice cooker is used. how much water? although ratios vary  dunlop’s is approximately 1:5, but other recipes recommend 1:4, 1:6, even 1:12 as with risotto or any other slow cooked rice dish, cooks understand from trial and error when they need to add more liquid until the mixture is as soupy or as firm as they like. 106 recipe﻿﻿ dunlop’s every grain recipe for congee with chicken and shitake mushrooms reflects both the essential nature of the dish and a practiced cook’s indifference to a recipe’s artificial precision, a no recipe recipe without the label: soak some dried shitake mushrooms in hot water from the kettle for 30 minutes. slice some raw chicken and marinate in a little soy sauce, finely chopped ginger, cooking oil and potato flour mixed with water. slice off and discard the mushroom stalks and slice the caps. add the mushrooms and chicken to your hot congee and boil for about five minutes. cover and leave to steep for another 10 minutes or so before serving with a garnish of spring onion greens, sesame oil and pepper. although plain congee is “good if you are feeling delicate,” in land of fish and rice, dunlop suggests additions to the basic recipe: other seeds and grains, cooked with the rice, such as presoaked mung or azuki beans and lotus seeds; peanuts, walnuts, dried chinese dates, wolfberries, and black glutinous rice, for a deep purple color. dandelion leaves can be added late in the cooking. “perky little relishes” and side dishes might include pork ribs chopped into bitesized pieces; chopped raw garlic or hot red chiles; coriander leaves; chinese pickled cabbage; fried or poached hen’s eggs; chopped preserved duck eggs with slivers of ginger and thinly sliced spring onions common embellishments of other chinese dishes, as well. ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 107 thai, vietnamese, and american adaptations vary the rice to water ratio; they combine rices, such as half jasmine and half sweet (glutinous); they incorporate an entire chicken, or chicken parts, such as whole legs or thighs; or slices of chicken and peanuts. as discussed in food & wine’s “9 recipes for congee, the cozy porridge you can eat at any time of day,” different cooks and cultures add a variety of savory ingredients into the cooking rice which would also be right at home with oatmeal dishes: kimchi, kabocha squash, dried scallops and fresh shrimp, spicy pork shoulder. or they cook the additions separately and incorporate them as toppings: pork meatballs and chili, bacon and onion, garlic beef and onion; and for assertive sweets, dried tangerine peel, candied ginger, or goji berries​. kun​un gyada, a beloved nigerian spiced peanut rice porridge, can be served thick for breakfast, or thinned to a lassi like liquid and, brightened by tamarind paste, then drunk throughout the day, says chef yewande komolafe. she observes that, like other hausa recipes, this “transcends borders and national identities.” ugali known by at least sixty other names, from akamu (nigeria) to xima (mozambique), ugali is maize porridge, the lifesustaining food throughout africa. with a 1:2 ratio of flour (corn meal, maize, millet, sorghum, cassava, or a mixture of these) to water, it is the thickest of all porridges twice as stiff as polenta. traditionally there is no salt or other seasoning in 108 recipe﻿﻿ the basic dish, which can be eaten by itself for breakfast or as the starch at dinner or lunch, accompanied by meat and fish dishes and vegetables. the recipe is simplicity itself just mix the corn meal and water but the ten minute process of cooking the mixture requires practice in order to produce the traditional smoothtextured, mounded cake rather than a large lump, full of lesser lumps, that sticks to the pan. replacing elders as the source of cooking advice, mulunga’s detailed youtube video explains “how to cook the perfect ugali.” pour the meal into rapidly boiling liquid in a sufuria (deep pot), whisking it at first and incorporating more maize flour. as the mixture thickens, keep mixing and stirring with a hefty, flat wooden spoon (thicker than the scottish porridge spurtle, it resembles a small oar). then the hard work begins. holding the sufuria with a cloth or kitchen mitts to keep from burning your hands, fold the thickening mixture over and over into itself, keeping it away from the sides of the sufuria, turning it around, folding it over and underneath as the meal at the bottom of the pot begins to brown and the aroma smells faintly of popcorn. turn the heat to very low, cover, and let the mixture rest for about five minutes. then wet the spoon so the ugali won’t stick and press all the cooked meal together to form a round mass inside the pot. invert the pot over a plate; the contents should fall out intact. shape the mass into a thick round cake. cut it into wedges to serve. diners pull off a piece, roll it into a ball in their right hand, poke a thumb shaped indentation in the ball, use it ﻿﻿“please, sir, i want some more.” 109 as a spoon to dip up accompanying stew or vegetables, and swallow it whole. they repeat until full, a feeling that  more than taste satisfies expectations. as with diners everywhere, what they eat with it depends on the region or country; the occasion breakfast, lunch, dinner, banquet, snack, or leftovers; the seasonal and local availability of particular foods; the cook’s and diners’ expectations and preferred methods of preparation; and the host’s affluence or poverty. african options for ugali include meats: stews of beef, mutton, goat, chicken, oxtail; curries of fish or chicken; and mopane worms dried moth caterpillars soaked and cooked with onions, tomatoes, and paprika. among vegetable dishes are rape, pumpkin, mustard or jute leaves; okra, kale, cabbage; peanuts, soy chunks. dairy includes yogurt, sour milk, and eggs. agnes makhanu, a kenyan mother of six interviewed by sarah small while preparing a pot of ugali for her schoolchildren’s lunch, epitomizes african devotion to this life sustaining staple, and by extrapolation, the devotion of each culture to its preferred porridge, be it oatmeal, congee, or ugali: “’ugali is my life and i can’t live without it. if i miss eating ugali in any single day, then i feel like i did not eat any food at all.’” 110 recipe﻿﻿ 6 play with your food, the recipe as jazz nine of every ten persons say they love chocolate. the tenth lies.  brillat savarin a balanced diet is chocolate in both hands.  anonymous always serve too much hot fudge sauce on hot fudge sundaes. it makes people overjoyed, and puts them in your debt.”  judith olney why do we love chocolate? chocolate looks good, smells good, tastes good; the scent, texture and instant gratification of melt in your mouth chocolate are irresistible. chocolate makes those who eat it feel wonderful alert, alive, comforted, sexy. hundreds of chemicals and compounds found in chocolate may enhance these feelings, among them caffeine, dopamine, and serotonin, but fiction and cookbooks explain the chemistry more sweetly. in roald dahl’s charlie and the chocolate factory, timid young charlie is given a transformative mug of “rich warm creamy chocolate” and discovers bliss: “as it ran down his throat his whole body began to tingle with pleasure, and a feeling of intense happiness spread over him.” chocolate plays well with others foods, flavors, and those who savor them, full of complements and surprises. babette’s feast (1987), rendered in gabriel axel’s film even more opulently than in isak dinesen’s story (1958), is an exquisite, protracted, sacramental meal that thaws the skeptical diners’ hearts and makes them “perfectly happy.” their ecstasy culminates in nesselrode pudding topped with whipped cream, glazed chestnuts, and inevitably, chocolate sauce. whether liquid or solid, hot or cold, chocolate’s many forms  beverages, bars, chips, syrups, icings, batters, pastries, ice creams, mousses encourage creativity and play, innovation, invention, and indulgence. “try me. test me. taste me,” call the chocolate figures displayed in la celeste praline in joanne harris’s chocolat: a novel, each of them “cats, dogs, rabbits with sugar flowers between their teeth. and mice. on every available surface, mice.” vianne, the chocolatier whose wares gratify the villagers’ souls hungry for the love that their formulaic religion cannot satisfy, soothes the young and stimulates the old with 112 recipe﻿﻿ strong dark chocolate, laced liberally with kahlúa and cream and chocolate chips, their heart’s desire. harris says of her work, “i could do with a bit more excess.” at the intersection of bitter, sweet, and succulent, chocolate is an irresistible medium for flirtation, seduction, apology, and reconciliation, in fact and fantasy, in autobiography, fiction, and film. whether we’re cooking with chocolate, eating it, or contemplating its next appearance, there are more opportunities for chocolate in its many incarnations to stimulate the imagination as well as the palate than for any other food on earth. google hits for chocolate related key words, although redundant, affirm chocolate’s popularity by the billions: chocolate, chocolate recipes, chocolate cookies, chocolate cake, hot chocolate. in the millions are chocolate bars, chocolate desserts, chocolate ice cream, chocolate sauce, with chocolate icings, chips, syrups, sodas, and sundaes trickling on down. “why do people love chocolate?” engenders nearly five billion answers, with variations on the charms and chemical cravings identified above. chocolate at play in american culture versatility chocolate is the most versatile food imaginable in dessertoriented cultures, and the most playful. before we weigh in ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 113 with the best chocolate recipe ever, let’s examine chocolate’s mischievous significance. even its designation, fruit or vegetable, is subject to foolery. barkeater chocolates claims, in a mock press release dated april 1, 2017, that the fda “declared that chocolate has met the federal guidelines for being a vegetable,” and that chocolate will henceforth occupy a new, central category in the dietary guidelines, overlapping with all other food groups. as we see from the great british baking show and other foodie favorites, chocolate encourages culinary grands­ tanding and welcomes all sorts of modes of preparation and construction. unique among foods, its vast repertoire justi­ fies an obscene number of tantalizing cookbooks. chocolate can be baked beaten blended brushed creamed churned curled swirled cracked stacked crumbled jumbled chipped chopped dripped dropped dipped draped drizzled swizzled drunk dunked frozen frothed grated layered melted moussed mounded pounded paddled piped poured rolled shaved slathered sliced spread trifled truffled torched whipped. these tortures from the baterie de cuisine result in the most delicious of outcomes, the most beautiful, and the most enjoyable. chocolate celebrations chocolate imparts a sweetness to our lives, from childhood to old age. it is the essence of hospitality and holidays, courtship and seductions, nurturing and nostalgia, making a 114 recipe﻿﻿ pretty penny for the chocolatiers as it works its magic dark if not black at 72% cacao. holidays chocolate happily whoops it up on american holidays. chocolate sales in the us in 2019 were $138 billion, onefifth of sales worldwide. chocolate fuels the beating heart of valentine’s day, 58 million pounds in 36 million heartshaped boxes, a marketing tactic since 1861. easter baskets brim with 65 million pounds of reese’s peanut butter chocolate eggs, cadbury creme eggs, and chocolate rabbits. halloween trick or treaters spirit away 90 million pounds of century old favorites reese’s peanut butter cups, m&m’s, snickers, hershey’s, and kit kat snacks, which reappear at christmas along with hershey’s kisses and chocolate santas. on thanksgiving tables, hefty chocolate turkey centerpieces rival the real thing. in addition, on all gift giving occasions a stunning variety of high end confections swells truffles, bark, bean to bar and artisanal chocolates, the darker the better, dressed for the ball in shimmering foil. international imports such as valrhona, “the rolls royce of chocolates,” from france, are sold in various forms at trader joe’s, one 3.5 ounce bar for $2.99. knipschildt chocolatier, which also uses valrhona, sells a 1.5 ounce dark chocolate truffle with a french black truffle inside for $250. that comes to $2600 per pound, a steep price for conspicuous consumption designed to disappear. ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 115 chocolate fountains, like all fountains, encourage play whether spectacular (24 feet for fancy parties) or run of themill (2 4 feet for kitchen counters). an archimedes screw elevates melted chocolate to the top tier of graduated cones, where it cascades as wedding or party guests scramble with chocolatey fingers to skewer the fruit, cake, or fondant for chocolate fondue in process before the excess lands in a basin heated for recycling. the only other food suitable for fountains nacho cheese lacks chocolate’s cachet. other celebration days in addition to these holidays, there are either 32, 38, or 72 days of the year (choose your calendar) devoted to celebrating chocolate, not to mention entire weeks and months. these do not arise because of discoveries, historical events, or popular acclaim, but presumably from marketing strategies that encourage in store promotions of particular products on the celebratory day world nutella day (february 7), national oreo day (march 6), national m&m’s day (october 16). because the principal way to celebrate a designated food is to eat it, national chocolate cake day (january 27), national truffles day (may 2), and national chocolate chip cookie day (august 4) seem made for sales promotions involving instore samples and cooking demonstrations. the exception is national chocolate covered insect day (october 14). fdaapproved chocolate can have up to 60 insect fragments per 100 grams, so why not make a virtue of necessity and chow 116 recipe﻿﻿ down on chocolate covered crickets or cicadas? indeed, the un fao is promoting insects as the food of the future: high in protein, low in carbs, moderate in fat, more economical per acre of grazing land and water than beef. however, jenna jadin, evolutionary biologist author of cicada licious: cooking and enjoying periodical cicadas (2004), reminds us to beware that the insects themselves haven’t been chowing down on pesticide laden foliage. chocolate dipped cicada grubs are a particular delicacy, though deep fried grubs on skewers, served with “turnip greens, celery and garlic paste to look like cicadas climbing out of a mud pie into green foliage” make tasty appetizers if they don’t scare off the diners first (dankelson). playfulness among foods, chocolate is outstandingly sculptural, the perfect medium for play. although molded gelatins and aspics (now dated and declassé) used to grace fancy dinners, molded chocolate stand alone sculptures now take the cake. judith olney’s joy of chocolate shows how to create “the giant chocolate cabbage cake filled with luscious whipped cream.” she advises, “coat the backs of 5 nice cabbage leaves with chocolate by spreading it on with a pastry brush” before cooling and then gently unmolding “the prettiest knockem dead creation guests have ever seen.” easier to make is olney’s apricot cream in a chocolate sack, “one of the handsomest and most amusing presentations i know.” coat ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 117 a paper bag with chocolate, let it harden, then peel away the paper before filling the chocolate sack with apricot bavarian for an elegant dessert. america’s test kitchen’s master recipes for ganache frosting and chocolate buttercream illustrate subtle differences in the processes of transforming solid chocolate to a sculptural medium, flexible and nuanced. to convert a pound of solid chocolate to ”decadent” ganache (“the richest chocolate frosting”), whisk in 2 cups of boiling heavy cream, then whip it up to “an airy, mousse like consistency.” to morph chocolate into “rich, creamy chocolate buttercream frosting, the perfect crowning touch for most any chocolate cake,” whip 1 cup sugar, 5 large egg whites, and 28 tablespoons of softened butter into 14 ounces of melted bittersweet chocolate. perfect for play. for bakers aspiring to sculptures more nuanced and with sharper edges than the appealing swoops, swirls, peaks, and dips of chocolate buttercream, modeling chocolate (1 pound of melted chocolate plus 1/3 cup corn syrup) is the more flexible, moldable medium, a cinderella paste custom sculpted to graceful wedding cake roses, bouquets, sprays, leaves, and models of the nuptial couple. there are sculptures for every taste: chocolate elvis, abe lincoln, michael jackson, barack obama, rodin’s thinker, statue of liberty, eiffel tower, and kings louis xiv, tut, and kong. body parts (g  to x  rated) include edible brains, skeletons, eyeballs and a hyper realistic human heart. the chocolate imagination encompasses vehicles planes, trains, 118 recipe﻿﻿ cars (bmw, ferrari); furniture, a bed with pillows but no chocolate thereon; creatures great and small whales, giant cephalopods, lobsters, dogs, cats, spiders. and sex: the recipe for homemade chocolate body paint (8 ounces chocolate, ¼ cup whipped cream, 2 3 drops orange, tangerine, or peppermint essential oils) ends coyly with, “use with paintbrush or fingers” to apply, location unspecified by the recipes with essential oils bloggers, two homeschooling mothers. matters of life and death by chocolate “death by chocolate” and other favorite games chocolate versions of monopoly, scrabble, and trivial pursuit offer transient fun, for, as gamesformation (the seller) suggests, while “playing your favorite board game you can be snacking on some of the pieces!” reenactors of the death by chocolate murder mystery can perform in costume (motley odd hats), partake of themed dinner parties (booo ring recipes provided), perhaps stimulated by two rival death by chocolate mystery series which, despite high calorie titles such as death by chocolate cherry cheesecake, seem fairly lightweight. the original death by chocolate dessert, a seven layer chocolate torte that if done right takes three days ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 119 to make, was invented by marcel desauliners of the trellis restaurant in williamsburg, virginia. outclassing these trivial pursuits of decadent delight, demise by luxurious eating is clearly a desirable way to die, as the menu proclaims, buried under “layers of moist chocolate cake, dark chocolate ganache, crunchy chocolate meringue, and an airy chocolate mousse, then coated in a glaze of dark chocolate and served on a pool of chocolate sauce with milk chocolate ice cream, topped with a white chocolate truffle dusted with white chocolate powder.” actual death and desperate life by chocolate issues of poverty and food insufficiency examined in the previous chapter acquire human faces when we examine the shameful production of cocoa in western africa, exploitation fitfully addressed by manufacturers and largely ignored by consumers and cookbook authors. the stakes are high. the food empowerment project reports that to keep prices competitive, a 100 billion dollar a year cocoa bean harvest is produced by a combination of severely underpaid adults earning less than the world bank’s extreme poverty designation of $1.90/day and by 2.1 million child laborers, many abducted, trafficked and enslaved. seventy per cent of the world’s supply comes from côte d’ivoire and ghana, where as many as 1.8 million child laborers ages 5 to 16 (43% of all their children) labor to grow and harvest it. 120 recipe﻿﻿ routinely beaten, deprived of family, school, sufficient and nutritious food, drinkable water, and health care, these children climb pesticide laden trees to cut the bean pods with large, heavy machetes; then drag hundred pound sacks of pods weighing more than they do through the forest. international agencies and commissions dictate protocols to safeguard children’s rights and eliminate child labor; governments and powerful manufacturers make promises, which are neither monitored nor enforced. the rate of child labor continues unabated as production soars. the food empowerment project quotes drissa, a recently freed slave who had never tasted chocolate, when asked what he would tell people who eat chocolate made from slave labor: “when people eat chocolate, they are eating my flesh’” (web). as a besotted devotee of 72% cacao confections resulting from the confluence of imperialism, genocide, exploitation, cruelty, and divine recipes, do i have to give up chocolate  my favorite food next to homegrown tomatoes? if as a woke consumer i choose indulgence over boycott, and make sure to buy chocolate labeled fair trade or rainforest alliance (both promoting sustainable, ethical agriculture and labor practices, a designation hard to police although 33 million pounds are sold) that’s not much of a dent in america’s annual chocolate consumption of 2.8 billion pounds (see lorr, rosenblum). will contributions to organizations combatting child slavery be adequate blood money? there is no satisfactory answer. ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 121 life by chocolate diplomacy although gift boxes of chocolate can sweeten negotiations personal and political (“candy is dandy”), an american pilot’s spontaneous gesture in the berlin airlift of 1948 led to a year of life sustaining diplomacy by chocolate. initially, about thirty hungry children (ultimately, hundreds), kept off the runway by a barbed wire fence, watched as between five and eight thousand tons of flour, coal, and other essentials were being unloaded daily at tempelhof airport. pilot gail “hal” halvorsen explains in the berlin candy bomber, observing that “they had nothing,” wanted to give them something to eat but found only a couple of sticks of gum in his pockets, which the children broke into little pieces and shared. moved by their claim, “we can get by on a little food, but if we lose our freedom, we may never get it back,” halvorsen and his crew pooled their rations of chocolate and chewing gum into three bundles, each with a handkerchief parachute, and dropped them during the next day’s food delivery. as the word spread, a massachusetts college student, mary c. connors of chicopee, coordinated donations totaling 23 tons mostly of hershey’s chocolate dispatched by 250,000 parachutes. this sweet, significant contribution to german american postwar reconciliation was repeated in later years in candy bar drops in war ravaged bosnia, kosovo, albania, baghdad, and elsewhere. 122 recipe﻿﻿ cookbooks cookbooks at work a cookbook like tv chefs, bloggers, and podcasters has to provide utterly reliable recipes that will produce consistent results time after time after time, in a mix of dishes familiar and innovative. the author not only needs deep knowledge of the subject but a logical mind to explain the sequence of steps in a process and the necessary techniques involved at each step, from the simultaneous perspectives of the expert chef and a continuum of readers, from novices on up. the author’s writing style reinforces her culinary signature, so that an engaging personality is standing by the cook’s side a cheerleader brimming with enthusiasm, energy, and a sense of play. although luscious food styling and photography enhance many recent cookbooks, language invariably does the heavy lifting, especially in the explanatory headnotes, the conversations between author and reader that precede the actual how to doit directions, by such personable chocolate cookbook authors as maida heatter, judith olney, marcel desaulniers, and dorie greenspan. america’s test kitchen, the corporate author of everything chocolate: a decadent collection of morning pastries, nostalgic sweets, and showstopping desserts, also has an accessible voice, aiming for recipes and results “clear, resonant, and at their best.” test kitchen omits the personal anecdotes, supersensual language, puns, and playful perorations of the ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 123 individual cookbook authors below, choosing state of the art elegance instead. cookbooks at play chocolate enthusiasts don’t feel the need to justify their passion, they simply celebrate the obvious and invite others to join the party. in baking chez moi, dorie greenspan introduces chocolate covered toffee breakups: “the candy is great fun to make and everyone i’ve ever made it for has not only loved it, but asked for the recipe so that they can make it themselves. i think of the recipe as a chain letter that’s never been broken. the first link in the chain was my friend nick malgieri,” himself author of chocolate: from simple cookies to extravagant showstoppers, which opens with the fanfare, “if cakes mean celebration, chocolate cakes mean extra special ones.” the food itself is presented as sociable. olney’s mocha ice cream is “a perfect balance of chocolate and coffee, those happy companions.” maida heatter’s book of great chocolate desserts feeds readers’ fantasies of “chocolate addictions, chocolate splurges, chocolate dreams, uncon­ trollable cravings and hunger for the stuff.” she’s the selfproclaimed chairperson of the board of the chocolate lovers association of the world: “i started as a brownie and worked my way up.” consequently, her headnotes, in introducing the recipes, celebrate communities of cooks, networks of hospitality, homemade gifts given and received, 124 recipe﻿﻿ hosts and guests bonding over meals that end, triumphantly, with chocolate. for instance, heatter begins dolly’s crisp toffee bars by introducing “my friend dolly (mrs. andy) granatelli, a superb cook and hostess who says that asking her not to cook would be like asking her not to breathe.” having conveyed the intimate, expansive essence of the friend and the friendship in 31 words, heatter presents the charming totality of the cookies in another single, succulent sentence, 30 words, two sets of rhythmic triplets that identify texture, mouth feel, ease of preparation, storage, durability, and communal impact: “these cookies are one of her specialties, chocolate chip butter bars, extremely crisp and crunchy, chewy and buttery, quick and easy; they keep well, mail well, and everyone loves them.” the language of chocolate emphatically not the language of health food, chocolate is rarely mentioned in the same breath as anything wholesome, nourishing, or healthful. whereas recipes for most foods have ancestral and/or descriptive names, the appellations of many chocolate concoctions imply excess, indulgence, and the guilt that many dieters experience when breaking the calorie barriers and enjoying themselves immensely in the process. the numbers escalate from double chocolate cake with black velvet icing to triple chocolate mousse cake to quadruple (or quintuple) chocolate cake to sextuple chocolate cookies. given the american emphasis on abundance, it’s ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 125 surprising that bulky americans consume a modest 11 pounds of chocolate a year, in comparison with the svelte french (16 pounds) a precarious reputation given their rising rate of obesity and the rugged swiss (22 pounds).1 recipes at play chocolate recipes are invitations to overeat, and to play in the process. thus, they often emit whiffs of indulgence, naughtiness, transgression, decadence all in good fun, of course. devil’s food cake, the antithesis of angel food, is so venerable that its sinful connotations barely register, nor do the bordello esque overtones of red velvet cake. the more explicit titles of contemporary recipes still leave much to the imagination decadent (a favorite adjective, but never debauched or depraved) chocolate cake, heaven and hell cake (“devilishly good”), chocolate better than sex cake, and oreogasm poke cake (not what you think!). written with a wink and a nod, chocolate titles and recipes encourage the world population review (2021) cites figures from the center for disease control (cdc) which estimates that 74% of americans are either obese or overweight, based on data 2015 16. this percentage has idoubled from three decades ago. (web). the organisaton for economic co operation and development (oecd observes that as of 2020 “obesity rates in france are among the lowest in the oecd, but have been increasing steadily. about 1 in 10 people is obese in france, and almost 40% are overweight (including obese). (web.) 1 126 recipe﻿﻿ cooks not only to play with their food but to damn the diets and full speed ahead. characteristic of recipe writing, the language of chocolate recipe headnotes is full of appeals to the senses. good looks also matter. olney’s “delicious” almond roca cake has “rough and rugged good looks” and her “spectacular” chocolate raspberry torte “looks like a large chocolate raspberry flower.” appetizing odors matter. america’s test kitchen observes of chocolate croissants, “the only thing better than waking up to the smell of buttery pastries is waking up to the smell of buttery pastries filled with chocolate” repetition doubling the pleasure of aroma and texture. greenspan’s introduction in baking to carrément chocolat, the fancy cake pulls out all the sensory stops sight, touch, texture, sound: “a shiny square of soft chocolate cake layered with chocolate mousse, chocolate cream, chocolate crunch and whisper thin sheets of snap at atouch chocolate, finished with a glossy chocolate glaze.” other headnotes amplify the sexual innuendos identified above. heatter’s chocolate mousse heatter headnote concludes with a passionate superlative: “it has been said that chocolate is the sexiest of all flavors. if so, this is the sexiest of all desserts.” molten chocolate cake all recipes are full of stories, mostly hidden or taken for granted, of their history, terroir, travels, and especially, human ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 127 interactions. cooks open their kitchens and sometimes their hearts, and share their inventions, shortcuts, and with chocolate especially, lavishness and largesse. that chefs are a notoriously rivalrous and hot headed tribe is not apparent from the cookbooks and websites consulted here; these recipes exude generosity and good humor. the exemplary recipe that concludes this chapter on a high note embeds many of these themes. i selected molten chocolate cake from the billion of glorious chocolate recipes competing for attention on google “try me, taste me” for its simplicity, sensuality, and utter deliciousness. with only five ingredients and five preparation steps, we might expect little if any variation, but in fact there are innumerable tweaks among the millions of google iterations as various chefs and food bloggers put their stamp on the original. overview this delectable decadent dessert, made in portion sized ramekins, is warm, soft, cakey on the outside, “with an irresistible center of warm, dark chocolate” that flows out to greet better yet, astonish the delighted diner who will eat it. origin if recipes could be traced through dna, their history would be simpler. jean georges vongerichten, award winning french chef and restaurant impresario, claims to have invented this 128 recipe﻿﻿ in 1987 when he pulled a sponge cake from the oven before it was done and discovered that surprise! the center was runny and the result eminently edible. not so fast, disputes rival french chef jacques torres, claiming pride of place, while in england tv chef and star gordon ramsay gets all the credit for the same dessert, called chocolate fondant. status recipes aren’t static, but full of life as long as people continue to enjoy the results. a well written recipe, concise and accurate, is a reliable map pairing the excitement and adventure of seeking a new destination with the assurance that a trusted guide will lead the way. over its 30 plusyear life span, vongerichten’s version although currently considered a menu cliché never became totally passè (like flambé dishes), because even when the novelty faded it remained a menu staple of both high end vongerichten’s restaurants and low end chili’s. greenspan reimagined the recipe in 2014 in soft centered chocolate teacup cakes, whose origin she attributes to yet another french chef, michel bras. in 2019 perelman, not fond of “warm, oozy desserts,” finally made “chocolate puddle cakes.” amidst family ecstasy her husband lamented, “if i had known how to make them all along, why had i waited” a dozen years to do so? the beat goes on, continued in 2020 by martha stewart’s molten chocolate espresso cupcakes, a variation on her 2010 warm chocolate cakes. ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 129 ingredients this list includes only the most common and consequential ingredients and quantities. i’m omitting outrageous alterations, such as adding an extra cup of powdered sugar, substituting ½ cup of mayonnaise for half the chocolate, and the many subtle but insignificant variations that appear in any recipe that circulates. for 4 servings: ½ cup butter, unsalted; 4 (or 6) ounces bittersweet or semisweet chocolate (not chocolate chips), preferably valrhona, or half and half of each, chopped coarsely (or in small pieces); 2 large eggs plus 2 egg yolks; ¼ cup granulated white sugar (or powdered or light brown); 2 teaspoons flour. extra butter and flour (or a little cocoa) to prepare four 4 or 6 ounce ramekins. some recipes add ingredients to melt as a surprise in the middle of each filled ramekin: 1 tablespoon cold butterscotch, caramel or raspberry sauce, or frozen berry coulis; traces of espresso powder, mint extract, citrus or orange zest; 2 tablespoons grand marnier; white or milk chocolate chunks; a small frozen chocolate truffle. preparation 1. heat oven to 450⁰f just before you’re ready to eat the cakes. (the uncooked mixture can be refrigerated for 3 hours or longer, some recipes say up to 2 days.) liberally butter and flour the ramekins so the cakes will slip out when tapped. put empty ramekins on a rimmed baking sheet. 130 recipe﻿﻿ 2. melt the butter in a medium bowl in the microwave, then add the chocolate and stir until melted. or melt both ingredients in the top of a double boiler over simmering water, stirring. 3. beat the eggs, extra yolks, and sugar until light and thick with a whisk or by electric mixer up to 5 minutes. 4. combine with chocolate and whisk/beat until smooth and glossy for a minute or more (20 30 beats). quickly beat in the flour, until combined. 5. bake 7 12 minutes, depending on how firm you want the cakes and how jiggly the centers. (note: baking at 450° takes 10 18 minutes to achieve the desired result.) 6. let rest for one minute, then protecting your hand with a potholder, put a plate on top of the ramekin and invert it. let it sit for 10 seconds, tap, and the cake should slide out. serve when the cake is hot but not dangerous to eat (recipes often ignore the possibility of burns and scalds), with or without ice cream, sorbet, or whipped cream. yield a recipe supplies the bridge between hope and fulfillment, for a recipe offers innumerable opportunities to review, revise, adapt, and improve, to make the dish the cook’s and ﻿﻿play with your food, the recipe as jazz 131 eater’s own. cooks and readers of delectable recipes expect the process, the play of improvisation, preparation to be fun. the playful prospect of the sensory overload vongerichten promises upon cutting into his classic molten chocolate cake is irresistible: “these cakes are truly a treat for the senses. the rich chocolaty scent, the decadent taste and, of course, the satisfying surprise of seeing the river of warm chocolate pour out when you cut into them.” we expect a recipe to deliver what it promises, something delicious to eat. if a recipe is a story, its ending should always be happy. the last word, from devotee anonymous: “i’d give up chocolate, but i am not a quitter.” 132 recipe﻿﻿ ﻿lagniappe the best blueberry pie i’ll send you to the kitchen with a recipe for the best blueberry pie, so delicious and so easy to make that i have shared both the food and the recipe with hundreds of delighted guests over the years. i’m also giving it to the librarian who drew a wedge of blueberry pie on my checkout slip for pie poet kate lebo’s pie school: lessons in fruit, flour, and butter, with the exultant label “pie! ha ha!!” this pie quick recipe  consists of a thick, cooked blueberry sauce (2 cups of berries, 3/4 cup sugar, 1/4 cup water, thickened with cornstarch) over an abundance of fresh blueberries (2 more cups in a baked pie shell), the quintessence of summer no matter when you eat it. the blueberries are best right from the bush. before we moved to boston, i picked them at nearby crooke’s orchard a heritage farm in the connecticut countryside  while i sat under the bushes in the soft summer sunset as the swallows swooped, just before the stars came out. frozen blueberries (i laid in a year’s reserve during july and august) will work for the sauce but the base whether blueberries (strawberries, peaches, or nectarines may be substituted for the base or the sauce or both) must be absolutely fresh for a pie that is robust rather than mushy, and sweet enough to eat without sugaring the fresh berries. the recipe calls for four cups of fresh fruit altogether, but i often throw an extra heaping cup into the waiting piecrust, for as mae west sagely observed: “too much of a good thing can be wonderful.” the step by step recipe to eat this pie is like eating fresh berries, only better. use the largest, plumpest berries to fill the pie shell. serves 6 8. preparation time (exclusive of crust): 10 min. plus 2 hours for cooling. 4  5 cups fresh blueberries 1 2 tbsp. cornstarch 1 9” pie shell, baked and cooled 1 tsp. butter 1/4 c. water 1 tbsp. grand marnier (optional) 3/4 c. sugar 1/4 c. fresh raspberries (optional) ½ tsp. salt 1. distribute 2 1/2 cups fresh blueberries evenly in cooled pie shell. 134 recipe﻿﻿ 2. cook water, sugar, salt over medium heat until sugar is dissolved. 3. add remaining blueberries (2 2 ½ cups) and stir over low heat until the mixture thickens less than five minutes. some of the berries will burst during this process, turning the mixture beautifully blue. avoid cooking them to mush. 4. if the sauce is too runny, mix 1 tablespoon cornstarch and 1/4 cup cold water, then briskly stir in a few tablespoons of the hot mixture until blended. 5. whisk this slurry into the cooking berries and continue whisking for about a minute until the mixture thickens as desired. repeat if necessary. 6. remove from heat. add butter and grand marnier. 7. when cool but not congealed, pour the sauce over berries in the shell. chill until ready to serve. decorate with fresh raspberries, if desired. has reading either or both versions made you good and hungry? i hope so. if a recipe is good enough to read, it’s good enough to eat. to write this i have spent the morning making forays into cookbooks. i’ve googled countless food blogs and online recipes for fresh blueberry pie and best blueberry pie. i remain convinced that my recipe which is also my dear friend susan’s by way of her cherished friend chrissie is in ﻿﻿lagniappe 135 fact the very best, for this pie is the most elegant, the simplest and, with or without a lattice crust, the most beautiful of all. furthermore, at 275 calories for a generous slice, it’s almost a health food in comparison with a 750+ calorie serving of the stay at home chef ’s most amazing chocolate cake with, naturally, chocolate cream cheese buttercream frosting. i would like to take credit for this succulent creation, but no one owns a recipe, and everyone who copies it nibbles away to alter its shape. in fact, i have just now rewritten this recipe seven times in the process of making it clear and unambiguous. if it were strictly bare bones i’d have left out “turning the mixture beautifully blue,” but a recipe should be easy to visualize as well as to taste. if i had time to join the blogosphere’s ongoing conversation i would explain the inevitability of my current version, but writing this has made me so hungry that i have to stop here for an early lunch. care to join me? we’ll have blueberry pie for dessert. 136 recipe﻿﻿ ﻿acknowledgments w hy is it that when we are enjoying a good meal, sometimes at home but more often at a restaurant, we spend quality time talking about other good meals we have experienced? why not savor the food on our plates and stop comparing what we’re eating at this moment with alternative variations, both possible and platonic? dedicated eaters and imaginative home cooks just can’t help themselves; their dialogue incorporating culinary lifetimes of practices and prejudices is indeed a joy of cooking. even with a simple chicken cutlet dish we debate the merits of dredging with flour, flour and panko, breadcrumbs, or breadcrumbs and parmesan. do we want to add chili powder to the flour? smoked paprika? would sesame seeds or sunflower seeds or both pep up the panko? should we serve the cutlet with lemon wedges? with dipping sauce for tonkatsu (japanese pork cutlet) that works just as well with chicken? (i had to look up tonkatsu sauce, a mixture of ketchup, worcestershire sauce, granulated garlic, rice vinegar, and oyster sauce, but perhaps you already knew this sauce.) what else would be good to swap in or out, in what stage of the preparation? working on recipe has been enormous fun because so many people love the subject and crave the results. bringing regional and international perspectives to this ongoing conversation as i was writing recipe were recipe commentators, testers, and tasters caroline boynton, sylvia bullock, kathy clark, julie harmon, kay litten, veronica makowsky, katherine meyer, sybil miller, barbara roggeveen, anneliese rosenfeld, blanche serban, and anne weaver. a bouquet of blooms martin, laird, sara, paul, beth, vicki, bard, and lavender have been carrying on comparable conversations throughout our family’s lifetime as we’ve played with our food, experimenting with ingredients, recipes, and equipment (an outdoor grill in all seasons, even snowstorms); sharing the cookbooks welcomed over years of christmas and birthday celebrations; and spending days constructing gingerbread replicas of notre dame, the eiffel tower, and fallingwater. using family kitchens as test kitchens for recipe spiced up the dialogue along with the food itself as the cuisine became progressively more international. food manufacturer sidney farnsworth offered insights into the entire pickle production process, from cucumbers on the farm to jars of pickles on the store shelves and, by extrapolation, other foods, such as mayonnaise and necco wafers. the needham (massachusetts) free public library staff never missed a beat even during remote covid 19 delivery, supplying with eager interest all the requested research materials; chelsea brown decorated the checkout slips with happy drawings of pie. peter fischer weighed in from florence, italy. jane cook, janet corkins, and jenny wilder, 138 acknowledgments﻿﻿ excellent cooks and writers themselves, read and reread the entire manuscript for accuracy, flavor, and wit. throughout the exacting processes of editing and proofreading, a band of angels provided succor and sustenance; you know who you are and you know why you matter so much. both the book and the author have benefited greatly from the expertise, precision, and compassion that bloomsbury editors haaris naqvi, chris schaberg, rachel moore, dhanuja ravi, and zeba talkhani have brought to the editorial process, from start to finish. indeed, the bloomsbury object lessons team is the most understanding and thoughtful group of editors i’ve ever worked with in an exciting (yes!) lifetime of publication. in keeping with recipe’s spirit, i proffer each of those acknowledged a figurative box of truffles, made of valrhona chocolate, 72% fair trade cacao, decorated with swirls and flourishes to please the exacting palate. my husband and best friend martin bloom, himself a distinguished writer and meticulous editor, vetted multiple drafts. he always made them better. also a happy baker, over the years he made four loaves of bread often baguettes every week. he augmented gift loaves with dorie greenspan’s world peace cookies, chocolate of course. the day before his unexpected death in june of 2021, martin celebrated a grandson’s graduation by baking an old fashioned chocolate cake, described by america’s test kitchen as “a traditional chocolate layer cake with a tender, airy, open crumb . . . of course filled and covered with luxurious chocolate frosting.” the best cake ever, and the cookies, were martin’s just deserts, sustained here in recipe. ﻿﻿acknowledgments 139 bibliography “9 recipes for congee, the cozy porridge you can eat at any time of day.” foodandwine​.co​m. 23 may, 2017. web. “american thanksgiving.” nytimes​.co​m. 11 nov. 2016. web. america’s test kitchen. everything chocolate: a decadent collection of morning pastries, nostalgic sweets, and showstopping desserts. boston: america’s test kitchen, 2020. barkeater chocolates. “fda declares chocolate a vegetable.” barkeaterchocolates​.co​m. 1 april 2017. web. beard, james. james beard’s american cookery. boston: little, brown, 1972. bittman, mark. how to cook everything fast. boston: houghton mifflin harcourt, 2014. brillat savarin, jean anthelme. the physiology of taste, or meditations on transcendental gastronomy. 1825. translated by m.f.k. fisher, 1949. new york: knopf, 2009. centers for disease control and prevention. “overweight & obesity: adult obesity facts.” cdc.go​v. 30 sept. 2021. web. child, julia, louisette bertholle, and simone beck. mastering the art of french cooking. vol. 1. new york: knopf, 1961. clark, melissa. dinner: changing the game. new york: clarkson potter, 2017. concernusa.org. “these are the world’s 10 hungriest countries in 2021.” 10 oct. 2021. web. cooksey stowers, kristen, marlene b. schwartz, and kelly d. brownell. “food swamps predict obesity rates better than food deserts in the united states.” international journal of environmental research and public health. v. 14(11) november 2017. web. cook’s illustrated. the new best recipe. brookline, ma: america’s test kitchen, 2002. covert, bryce. “the myth of the welfare queen.” newrepublic​.co​m. 2 july 2019. web. crouter, natalie. forbidden diary: a record of wartime internment, 1941 45. ed. lynn z. bloom. 1980. reissued in north american women’s diaries and letters, alexandria, va: alexander st. press, 2001. dahl, roald. charlie and the chocolate factory. 1964. new york: puffin, 2013. dankelson, annie. “cicada licious cooking.” today​.umd​.edu​.​com. 23 april, 2021. web. desaulniers, marcel. i’m dreaming of a chocolate christmas. new york: john wiley, 2007. desilva, cora. in memory’s kitchen: a legacy from the women of terezin. northvale, n.j.: jason aronson, 1996. dickens, charles. oliver twist. 1838. project gutenberg. gutenberg.org. 1996. rev. 24 may 2021 web. dickstein, lore. “hell’s own cookbook.” nytmes​.com​. 17 nov. 1996. web. drummond, ree. the pioneer woman cooks: the new frontier. new york: william morrow, 2019. dunlop, fuchsia. every grain of rice: simple chinese home cooking. new york: norton, 2012. dunlop, fuchsia. land of fish and rice: recipes from the culinary heart of china. new york: norton, 2016. ephron, nora. “thanksgiving dinner.” huffingtonpost​.co​m. 23 nov. 2005. web. ﻿﻿bibliography 141 farmer, fannie merritt. the 1896 boston cooking school cook book. 1896. new york: random house value, 1997. ferguson, priscilla parkhurst. word of mouth: what we talk about when we talk about food. berkeley: u of california press, 2014. food and agriculture organization of the united nations. “food loss and food waste.” fao.org/food loss and food waste 2021. web. food and agriculture organization of the united nations. “the state of food security and nutrition in the world 2019.” fao. org/publications/sofi/2021/en/ 2019. web. food and nutrition service, us department of agriculture. snap data tables. fns.usda.gov/pd/supplemental nutritionassistance program snap 12 november 2021. web. food empowerment project. “child labor and slavery in the chocolate industry.” foodispower​.or​g. 2021. web. global hunger index 2020. one decade to zero hunger; linking health and sustainable food systems. globalhungerindex.org. web. global hunger index 2021. hunger and food systems in conflict settings. globalhungerindex.org goldberg, elyssa. “86 comfort foods for cold nights, broken hearts, and wednesdays.” bonappetit​.co​m. 25 mar. 2020. web. gopnik, adam. the table comes first: family, france, and the meaning of food. new york: vintage, 2012. greenspan, dorie. around my french table: more than 300 recipes from my home to yours. new york: houghton mifflin harcourt, 2010. greenspan, dorie. baking chez moi. boston: houghton mifflin harcourt, 2014. greenspan, dorie. everyday dorie: the way i cook. boston: houghton mifflin harcourt, 2018. halvorsen, gail s. the berlin candy bomber. springville, utah: horizon publishers, 2010. 142 bibliography﻿﻿ hamilton, gabrielle. “crepes don’t have to be fancy to be delicious.” cooking​.nytimes​.c​om. 25 march 2020. web. harris, joanne. chocolat. 1999. new york: penguin books, 2000. hassan, hawa with julia turshen. in bibi’s kitchen: the recipes & stories of grandmothers from eight african countries that touch the indian ocean. new york: ten speed press, 2020. healthierkitchen. “grandma evie’s jewish penicillin.” food52​.co​m. 4 april 2010. web. heatter, maida. maida heatter’s book of great chocolate desserts. new york: knopf, 1981. hercules, olia. kaukasis: a cookbook. a culinary journey through georgia, azerbaijan & beyond. san francisco: weldon owen, 2017. hovland, marit. bakeland: nordic treats inspired by nature. vancouver, b.c.: greystone books ltd 2018. johnson, sarah wassberg. “the real kellogg recipe: granula v granola?” thefoodhistorian.com. 14 aug. 2019. web. kenny, charles. “give poor people cash.” theatlantic​.co​m. 15 sept. 2015. web. kimball, christopher. milk street: the new rules: recipes that will change the way you cook. new york: little, brown, 2019. komolafe, yewande. “sugared and spiced, this creamy porridge comforts.” cooking​.nytimes​.c​om. 9 april 2021. web. kravitz, melissa. “food companies are making their products addictive and it’s sickening (literally).” ecowatch.com. 26 mar. 2019. web. lakhani, nina. “meet the workers who put food on america’s tables but can’t afford groceries.” theguardian​.co​m. 13 may, 2021. web. lappé, frances moore and joseph collins. world hunger: ten myths. new york: grove press, 2015. lawson, nigella. “thai chicken noodle soup.” nigella​.co​m. 2011. web. ﻿﻿bibliography 143 leblanc, adrian nicole. “how hunger persists in a rich country like america.” newyorktimes​.co​m. 2 sept. 2020. web. lee, vivian. “the chicken soup of chinese aunties.” tastecooking. co​m. 26 april, 2018. web. lewis, edna. the taste of country cooking. new york: knopf, 1976, 2020. lorr, benjamin. the secret life of groceries; the dark miracle of the american supermarket. new york: avery/penguin, 2020. mckenny, sally. “the great pumpkin pie recipe.” sal​lysb​akin​gaddictio​n​.com 26 oct. 2014. web. mendelson, cheryl. home comforts: the art and science of keeping house. new york: scribner, 1999. menéndez, ana. “celebrations of thanksgiving: cuban seasoning.” 2004. rpt. american food writing: an anthology with classic recipes. edited by molly o’neill. new york: penguin, 2007. 708 710. miller, adrian. soul food: the surprising story of an american cuisine, one plate at a time. chapel hill: university of north carolina press, 2013. monticello​.or​g. “4 foods jefferson helped popularize in america.” monticello.org/site/blog and community. n.d. web. moore, brett. “edna lewis: the grande dame of southern cooking.” thespruceeats​.co​m. 3 july 2020. web. moskin, julia. “classic mashed potatoes.” cooking​.nytimes​.​com. n.d. web. moskin, julia. “why work when you can procrastibake?” new york times. 15 may 2018. web. moskin, julia “the winter cook; macaroni and lots of cheese.” new york times. 4 jan. 2006. web. moulton, sara. sara moulton cooks at home. new york: broadway books, 2002. mull, amanda. “the rise of anxiety baking.” theatlantic.com. 18 dec. 2018. web. 144 bibliography﻿﻿ mulunga. “how to cook the perfect ugali.” nairobikitchen. blogspot​.c​om. 15 july 2017. web. national council of negro women. celebrating our mothers’ kitchens: treasured memories and tested recipes. memphis, tn: national council of negro women, 1994. nosrat, samin. salt fat acid heat. new york: simon and schuster, 2017. npr. “turkey tips from alton brown: don’t baste or stuff.” npr. org. 13 nov., 2012 olney, judith. the joy of chocolate. new york: barron’s, 1982. organisation for economic co operation and development [oecd]. “obesity and the economics of prevention: fit not fat   france key facts.” 2021. web. ottolenghi, yotam. simple. new york: ten speed press, 2018. “pasta alla carbonara.” wikipedia (italian). 2 dec. 2021. web. pepin, jacques. chez jacques: traditions and rituals of a cook. new york: stewart, tabori, and chang, 2007. perelman, deb. “failproof crepes + a crepe party.” smittenkitchen.co​m. 3 may 2016. web. perelman, deb. “grandma style chicken noodle soup.” foodandwine​.com​. 26 nov. 2016. web. perelman, deb “quick, essential stovetop mac and cheese.” smittenkitchen​.com​. 27 feb. 2018. web. perelman, deb the smitten kitchen cookbook. new york: knopf, 2012. rennard, barbara o., et al. “chicken soup inhibits neutrophil chemotaxis in vitro.” chest 118: 4 (2000): 1150 1157. web. rombauer, irma s. the joy of cooking. new york: simon & schuster, 1931. rombauer, irma s., marion rombauer becker, and ethan becker. joy of cooking. new york: scribner, 2006. rombauer, irma s., marion rombauer becker, ethan becker, john becker, and megan scott. joy of cooking. new york: scribner, 2019. ﻿﻿bibliography 145 rosenblum, mort. chocolate: a bittersweet saga of dark and light. new york: north point press, 2005. rosenstrach, jenny. “a few thanksgiving questions for sam stifton.” part 1. dinneralovestory​.c​om. 8 nov 2012. web. seipel, brooke. “here’s what’s on the white house thanksgiving menu.” thehill.com/blogs/in the know/in the know. 24 nov. 2016. web. severson, kim. “how i mastered the art (and politics) of cornbread dressing.” nytimes.com. 8 nov. 2016. web. shapiro, ari “evolution of the presidential thanksgiving (feat. cooked possum).” npr​.or​g. 26 nov. 2015. web. stamberg, susan. “mama stamberg’s cranberry relish recipe.” npr​.or​g. 23 nov. 2006. web. stifton, sam. “deliciousness matters.” nytimes​.co​m. 18 march 2020. web. stifton, sam. “a no recipe recipe manifesto.” nytimes​.co​m. 3 march 2021. web. stifton, sam. “substitution city.” nytimes​.com​. 29 april 2020. web. stifton, sam. thanksgiving: how to cook it well: a cookbook. new york: random house, 2012. stifton, sam. “there’s no need for recipes now.” nytimes​.co​m. 25 march 2020. web. “these are the world’s 10 hungriest countries in 2021.” concernworldwide us. concernusa.org 14 oct., 2021. web. tipton martin, toni. jubilee: recipes from two centuries of african american cooking. new york: clarkson potter, 2019. unicef and who. “low birthweight estimates: levels and trends 2000 2015.” geneva: unicef and who may 2019. unicef.org/documents/unicef who low birthweight estimateslevels and trends 2000 2015. web. unwfp [united nations world food program usa]. “nearly 60% of the world’s hungriest people live in just a few countries. why?” wfpusa.org/articles 8 nov. 2021. web. 146 bibliography﻿﻿ vongerichten, jean georges. “jean georges’ molten chocolate cake recipe.” today​.co​m. 9 feb. 2019. web. vongerichten, jean georges. “molten chocolate cakes.” foodandwine​.co​m. july 1999. web. weibel, alexa. “how to make cooking substitutions.” n.d. cooking.nytimes​.com​/gui​des. web. westbrook, eden. “(soul food) southern baked macaroni and cheese.” 19 june 2019. sweetteaandthyme​.co​m. web. white, edward. “the other kellogg: ella eaton.” the paris review 11 aug. 2020. theparisreview.org.web. wolfson, julia a. and cindy w. leung. “food insecurity during covid 19: an acute crisis with long term health implications.” american journal of public health. dec. 2020. 110 (12): 1763 1765. web. world food program 2021. these are the world’s hungriest countries. world population review. “obesity rate by state. 2021.”/ wor​ldpo​pula​tion​review​.co​m​/web. ziegelman, jane and jack coe. a square meal: a culinary history of the great depression. new york: harper, 2016. ﻿﻿bibliography 147 index agricultural labor exploitation, working conditions 40 1, 120 1 america’s test kitchen 24, 48, 118, 127, 139 everything chocolate: a decadent collection of morning pastries, nostalgic sweets, and showstopping desserts 123 babette’s feast (gabriel axel) 112 bacon 2, 4, 17, 61, 100, 106, 108 baking 8, 57, 139 anxiety baking a.k.a. procrastibaking 55 6 becker, ethan. joy of cooking 21, 37, 72 becker, john. joy of cooking 37, 72 becker, marion rombauer. joy of cooking 21, 37, 72 bittman, mark 10 11, 18 19, 59 60, 82, 103 4 how to cook everything fast 56 blogs see cooking blogs bon appetit 29, 53 bread 13, 16, 52 3, 57, 79 80, 100, 139 breakfast 4, 46, 87, 101, 104, 105 6, 108 10 brillat savarin, jean anthelme. physiology of taste 16 cake 53, 68, 87, 116, 118, 127 carrot 87, 105 chocolate 53, 113, 117 20, 125 7, 136, 139 molten chocolate cake 127 32 celebrations birthdays 51, 68, 138 christmas 51, 68, 115, 138 easter 51, 115 halloween 115 hanukkah 68 juneteenth 51 marriage 51, 116 new year 68 valentine’s day 115 see also thanksgiving chefs 5, 9, 23 4, 62, 65 conversations among 32 3, 48, 65, 123 culinary persona 31 2, 34, 48, 124 see also bittman, child, dunlop, greenspan, hamilton, heatter, komolafe, lawson, lewis, nosrat, ottolenghi, pepin, perelman, stifton, vongerichten chicken 17 19, 26, 53, 56, 72, 80, 107 8, 110, 137 child, julia 9, 32, 43 4 french chef, the (television series) 24 mastering the art of french cooking 8, 13, 17, 19, 28 chocolate 111 32 cake (see cake) celebrations, holidays 114 17 cooking with 114, 117 20, 123 5 courtship and seduction 112 16, 119 death by chocolate 119 20 diplomacy berlin candy bomber 122 eating 111 13, 126, 132 fountains 116 harvesting exploitation 120 21 language 125 7 playfulness 112 20, 124 7, 132 sculptures 118 versatility 113 17, 125 6, 129 clark, melissa 56, 59 cocoa harvest cruelty, exploitation, genocide, imperialism 120 21 see also agricultural labor comfort food 4, 50 65, 68, 76, 101, 106 see also mac & cheese, porridge, soup, thanksgiving cookbooks 88, 112, 135, 138 basic recipe 12 chocolate 114, 123 5 ﻿index﻿ 149 construction of 8, 123 4 conversation among chefs, cooks 3, 23 5, 28 33, 47 8, 124 8 culinary philosophy 8, 10, 63 fundraising 52 3, 60, 65 illustrations 19 20 language 26, 34, 123 7 omissions 19 21 playfulness 124 7 readers, collaboration with 34 4 thanksgiving 71 2 cooking american celebration see thanksgiving casual 56 cultural context 10, 29 34, 93 103 and passim see thanksgiving economy 20 2 history 4 5, 10, 50 1, 69, 88, 127 8 home cooking 56, 65 see also home cooks, perelman, stifton improvisation 5, 10 11, 34 5, 56, 62 5, 132 southern (us) cooking 36, 51, 81, 103 cooking blogs 12, 28, 31 2, 50, 123, 135 150 ﻿﻿index casual cooking 8, 56, 104 equipment demonstration 22 3 influence on cookbooks 19 lessons 17, 23 5 nutrition information source 22 nyt cooking (stifton) 55, 63 5 production of 24 0 replace index cards 3 sally’s baking addiction 86 smitten kitchen (see deb perelman) success story 8, 132 cooking shows 19, 24 5, 88, 123, 129 cooks conversations among 32 3, 65, 134 36 home cooks 3, 24, 30 3, 35, 42, 62 3, 65, 137 see also chefs cooksey sowers et al 95 cook’s illustrated 2, 77, 79 covid 19 50, 53 4, 56, 63, 90, 92 3, 97, 106 crepes 41 8 dahl, roald. charlie and the chocolate factory 112 dairy 61, 95, 99, 110 desaulniers, marcel 119 20, 123 dialogue 9, 29, 32 3, 41, 137 38 see also conversations among chefs dickens, charles. oliver twist 90 1, 96, 105 dinner 1 2, 26, 45, 51, 56, 62 4, 68, 70 2, 76, 83, 87, 104, 109 10, 117, 119 drummond, ree. pioneer woman cooks: the new frontier 9, 23 4 dunlop, fuchsia every grain of rice 106 7 land of fish and rice 106 7 eaters 3, 10, 13, 28, 33, 72, 94, 132, 137 8 ephron, nora 68, 71 fisher, m.f.k 1, 3, 49, 55 food allocations 91, 95 8 deserts 95 diet see porridge extravagance 22 human right 89, 91 insecurity 21, 90 8 insufficiency 90, 120 junk food 95 security, sufficiency 93 suitable for aid programs international 98 100 us 100 1 survival 5, 50, 52 5, 69, 101 swamps 95 see also hunger, porridge food & wine 29, 39, 108 foodies 3, 9, 13, 114 fruit 46. 79 80, 82, 85 6, 99, 104 5, 114, 116, 134 famine 5, 8, 69 70, 90, 106 farmer, fannie 14, 36 7 boston cooking school cook book, the 13, 72 “the mother of level measurements” 36 fda (see us food and drug administration) ferguson, priscilla parkhurst. word of mouth 69 70 gardens 45 6, 65 gopnik, adam 7, 17, 23, 32 great british baking show 25, 114 greenspan, dorie 33, 42, 123, 129, 139 around my french table 18, 44 5 baking chez moi 86, 124, 127 ﻿index﻿ 151 bonne idee 18 everyday dorie: the way i cook 56 halvorsen, gail. the berlin candy bomber 122 hamilton, gabrielle 41 3 harris, joanne chocolat: a novel 112 13 hassan, hawa with julia turschen. in bibi’s kitchen 30 heatter, maida 123, 127 maida heatter’s book of great chocolate desserts 124 5 hercules, olia. kaukasis: a culinary journey through georgia, azerbaijan & beyond 30, 38 9 hovland, marit. bakeland: nordic treats inspired by nature 30 hunger 5, 8, 52, 90 9, 124 causes 90 consequences 90 countries 90 definition 90, 93 feeding the hungry, issues in 91 100 152 ﻿﻿index food assistance programs american 100 101 snap 95 un fao 94, 98 un world food programme 97 100 us aid 99 see also usda, us food and drug administration food delivery 97 98 food waste 98 global hunger index 90 malnutrition 94, 97 8, 100 numbers of hungry people 90, 92 3 poverty 90 98 world health organization 97, 99 immigrants, undocumented 40 improvisation see cooking, recipe inspiration see recipe jefferson, thomas 4, 50 kellogg, ella eaton 105 kenny, charles 99 kimball, christopher. milk street: the new rules 15, 30, 38 9, 48 komolafe, yewande 108 kravitz, melissa 94 labor, exploitation 40 41, 120 1 lappé, frances moore and joseph collins. world hunger: ten myths 93 lawson, nigella 10 leblanc, adrian nicole 94 lee, vivian 15 16 lewis, edna 36, 80 lincoln, abraham 72, 118 lorr, benjamin the secret life of groceries 26, 121 lunch 43, 82, 87, 101, 104, 109 10, 136 mac & cheese see pasta meat 2, 13 14, 16, 26, 37, 61, 77 8, 99, 109 see also chicken menéndez mendelson, cheryl. home comforts. 51 2 menéndez, ana 73 merano, vanjo 15 milk 15, 41, 43, 57 61, 81, 83, 86, 100 1, 103 4, 110 miller, adrian soul food 51, 80 moskin, julia 56, 59, 81 new york times 2, 29, 35, 40, 42, 56, 80, 85 no recipe recipes see recipe nosrat, samin 5, 7 8, 32, 37 9, 62 4 salt fat acid heat 11, 14, 29, 62 3 olney, judith 111, 117 18, 123 4, 127 ottolenghi, yotam 8 9, 27 simple 48, 56 pandemic see covid 19 pasta 28, 53, 57, 100 mac & cheese 4, 50 62 homemade 4, 50, 56, 59 60, 65 packaged 53, 57 8, 61 thanksgiving side dish 71, 73 spaghetti carbonara 2 4 pepin, jacques 27, 31, 33 4, 42, 45 7 chez jacques 31 perelman, deb (a.k.a. smitten kitchen) 26, 42, 46 7, 58, 83, 129 pie 85 87 apple 73, 85 best blueberry 133 6 dough 19, 86 mock apple 87 ﻿index﻿ 153 pumpkin 69, 71 3 thanksgiving 69, 71 3, 85 7 porridge 8, 91, 100 10 congee 10, 102, 106 8, 110 enhancements 103 4 gruel 90 1, 106 oatmeal 103, 104 6, 108, 110 granola 105 polenta 103, 108 recipes 101 3 ugali 103, 108 10 mulunga video 109 10 poverty see agricultural labor, hunger recipe format 11 12, 18 headnote 10 11, 18, 26, 127 illustrations/pictures 5, 19 20, 28, 46, 70 list of ingredients 11 name 9 narrative 134 5 preparation steps 2, 11 12, 17, 59, 103, 124, 128, 134 5 preparation time 10, 134 serving directions 18 step by step 2 3, 134 5 recipes blogs 3, 8, 12, 19, 22, 24, 28, 63, 65, 123, 135 154 ﻿﻿index chef ’s philosophy 8, 10, 63 conversation 10, 28 33, 54, 136 cultural ,social context 8, 10, 29 30, 42 3, 69, 71, 80, 93 definition of 8 9 directions, instruction 7 12, 17 19 improvisation 5, 56, 62 4, 132 inspiration 8, 12, 36, 63 language 8, 11, 26, 28 9, 34 5, 47, 90, 123, 125 7 literary characteristics 3, 31, 34 culinary character 31 2 voice 31 lessons 5, 17, 24 no recipe recipe 36, 62 4, 107 omissions from 20 23 origins, transmission 21, 29, 6, 48 platonic ideal 31, 59 playfulness 123 7 public life 1 3 readers 12, 25 6, 28 35, 37, 41 3, 45, 48, 64, 123 4, 132 secret life 3 5 story 7 8, 26, 33 4, 43, 45 6, 48, 132 variations from basic recipe 13 19, 30 1, 36 9, 51, 61 2, 73, 78 80, 103 4, 130 rockwell, norman 55, 70 rombauer, irma joy of cooking (1931) 8, 14, 21, 28, 72 joy of cooking (2019) 37, 72 joy of cooking, 75th anniversary edition (2006) 21, 72 salads 2, 10, 35 41, 43, 53, 85 caesar 39 40, 73 chopped kale salad with cilantro and walnuts 38 9 dressing 37 8 ekala pkhali 30, 38 9 green 37 40 principles of salad construction 39 40 scott, megan 37, 72 smitten kitchen blog 46 7 see also: deb perelman soup 72, 76, 85 cancer fighting soup 22 chicken soup 9, 12 16, 53 chicken stock 12 13, 18, 21, 26, 79 grandma evie’s jewish penicillin 9, 14 grandma style chicken noodle 26 spicy vietnamese chicken noodle 18 19 tteoguk 68 stewart, martha 75, 129 stifton, sam 37, 49, 71, 82, 88 new york times cooking: no recipe recipes, the 35 6 nyt cooking blogs 55, 63 5 thanksgiving: how to cook it well 72, 75, 77 thanksgiving 67 88 chocolate turkey centerpiece 115 cost 76 cultural components 73 6 dressing/stuffing 79 80 gravy 69, 71, 77, 81, 87 green bean casserole 71, 73, 83 mac & cheese 51 mashed potatoes 53, 73, 81 2, 87 pie see pie sides 84 5 ﻿index﻿ 155 sweet potatoes 71, 73, 75, 82 turkey see turkey guests 74 history 69 73 host 75 menu, great american gestalt 69, 71, 75 cranberry sauce 69, 71, 83 4, 86 7 mama stamberg’s cranberry relish 84 thanksgiving sandwich 87 thoreau, henry david 88 values 69 71, 87 8 turkey basting 78 choosing 77 leftovers 87 stuffing 79 80 thanksgiving 68, 70 3, 75 9, 81, 85 united states department of agriculture (usda) 21, 40, 93, 99 100 156 ﻿﻿index usda (see united states department of agriculture) us food and drug administration (fda) 114, 116 vegan, vegetarian 25, 29, 84 vegetable/s 10 11,14,18 9, 37 40, 61, 79, 81 2, 85, 95, 99, 100, 105, 109 10, 114 vongerichten, jean georges 128 32 waters, alice 37 westbrook, eden 50 1 wolfson, julia a. and cindy w. leung 82 world health organization (who) 92, 99 ziegelman, jane and jack coe. a square meal: a culinary history of the great depression 147 michael browner [email protected] address: be the first to receive exclusive offers and the latest news on our products and services directly in your inbox.

sorry, we just need to make sure you're not a robot. for best results, please make sure your browser is accepting cookies.
i live! for chocolate! and certainly have heard the phrase ‘death by chocolate.’ but this is the first i’ve heard about who was responsible   ironically, after his death. death by chocolate. well, that was unexpected   never knew that either! good story about him…also didn’t know it took days to create! and here’s the amazing looking recipe (which i first thought your link went to), for thems that want to make it. gift link, natch death by chocolate, which by name suggests that it’s so rich and decadent that it may cause one to simply expire, commonly takes the shape of a trifle dessert it consists of layers of crumbled brownies or chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and whipped... what a way to go! many years ago i spent a few days in williamburg. the governors torte at the williamsburg inn was remarkable (and very chocolate) but i did have to have dinner one night at trellis for the death by chocolate. i think i went to williamsburg for the history, but the food especially the desserts were truly noteworthy. i remember him from many years back with a food show on early cable tv. plus his cookbooks were always on the shelf at bookstores. he was a very upbeat happy spokesperson on camera trying to demystify the joy of chocolate baking to layman. the article really captured his zeal. rip. you weren’t a foodie in the 80’s? i do have one of his books and certainly looked up to him early in my career but don’t think i’d heard he passed, so thanks for sharing.