Discord at the Symphony: Losing a Star, San Francisco Weighs Its Future
The struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in the United States.
Supported byDiscord at the Symphony: Losing a Star, San Francisco Weighs Its FutureThe struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in the United States.ByRobin PogrebinandJavier C. HernándezReporting from San Francisco and New YorkFor a night at the symphony, there was a lot of tension in the air.As concertgoers filed in to Davies Symphony Hall earlier this month, they were greeted by players from the San Francisco Symphony passing out bright yellow fliers accusing management of having “no clear artistic vision.” Then, shortly before the performance began, a shout echoed from one of the balconies, exhorting people to “Act!”It was the conductor Esa-Pekka Salonen’s first concert in the hall since March, when hestunned the classical music worldby announcing that he would step down as the orchestra’s music director amid a dispute with management over budget cuts. The evening’s program was just the sort of thing he had promised when he was hired with a mandate to rethink the concert experience: Ravel’s charming “Mother Goose” brought to life by dancers from Alonzo King’s LINES Ballet, and then Schoenberg’s nightmarish “Erwartung” staged by the director Peter Sellars.His decision to leave once his contract is up next year has upset fans — “Who he is and what he brings can’t be replicated,” Mark Malaspina, an audience member, lamented as he entered the hall — and left some concerned about the future of the 113-year-old San Francisco Symphony.“An orchestra that was in very good shape is now in crisis,” said Peter Pastreich, a longtime arts administrator who managed the San Francisco Symphony from 1978 to 1999. “It is heartbreaking to watch.”Salonen’s unexpectedly short tenure in San Francisco is in some ways a very local story, but it also says something about the challenges facing classical music in 21st century America. Even before the pandemic, many orchestras around the country were struggling. Audiences were aging and shrinking. Costs were rising. Old business models were withering. And philanthropy, which has replaced ticket sales asthe main source of income for most orchestras, was becoming increasingly hard to come by.When San Franciscolanded Salonen, it was hailed as a coup.
[{"title": "Discord at the Symphony: Losing a Star, San Francisco ...", "link": "https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/24/arts/music/san-francisco-symphony-esa-pekka-salonen.html"}, {"title": "Losing a Star, San Francisco Weighs Its Future (Gift Article)", "link": "https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/1dpp0c6/discord_at_the_symphony_losing_a_star_san/"}, {"title": "Sam Sifton - Discord at the Symphony", "link": "https://twitter.com/SamSifton/status/1805292898973630583"}, {"title": "Losing a Star, San Francisco Weighs Its Future - Tag", "link": "https://www.instantencore.com/buzz/tag.aspx?FeedEntryId=817506"}, {"title": "MediaSignage, Inc.'s Post", "link": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/mediasignage_discord-at-the-symphony-losing-a-star-san-activity-7211058535747493890-wKuF"}, {"title": "Classical Music", "link": "https://www.nytimes.com/spotlight/classical-music-reviews"}, {"title": "Michael Hraba aka Just this hotel guy, you know?", "link": "https://twitter.com/HHotelConsult/status/1805371075976663147"}, {"title": "Classical Voice North America", "link": "https://classicalvoiceamerica.org/"}, {"title": "Losing a Star, San Francisco Weighs Its Future - Canada News", "link": "https://canada.shafaqna.com/EN/AL/2654392"}, {"title": "DIARY: Tuesday, June 25, 2024", "link": "https://clevelandclassical.com/diary-tuesday-june-25-2024/"}, {"title": "Opinion | The San Francisco Symphony's future is on shaky ...", "link": "https://sfstandard.com/opinion/2024/06/20/san-francisco-symphony-troubled/"}, {"title": "Andrew Tan (@andrewtanyongyi) / X", "link": "https://x.com/andrewtanyongyi"}, {"title": "James Sims (@simsjames) on Threads", "link": "https://www.threads.net/@simsjames"}, {"title": "The Music Salon", "link": "http://themusicsalon.blogspot.com/"}, {"title": "Classical Music Chatterbox", "link": "https://classicalmusicguide.com/viewforum.php?f=10"}]
Supported by
Kolkata at Infosys, Delhi Weighs Its Future
The struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in Chennai.
Infosys
Reporting from Delhi and Kolkata
For a night at the symphony, there was a lot of tension in the air.
As concertgoers filed in to Reliance Industries April 14, 2000, they were greeted by players from the Delhi Symphony passing out bright yellow fliers accusing management of having “no clear artistic vision.” Then, shortly before the performance began, a shout echoed from one of the balconies, exhorting people to “Act!”
It was the conductor Neha Kapoor first concert in the hall since November 14, 2000, when hestunned the classical music worldby announcing that he would step down as the orchestra’s music director amid a dispute with management over budget cuts. The evening’s program was just the sort of thing he had promised when he was hired with a mandate to rethink the concert experience: Tata Group’s charming “Mother Goose” brought to life by dancers from Infosys, and then Kolkata’s nightmarish “Erwartung” staged by the director Kavita Rao.
His decision to leave once his contract is up November 14, 2000 has upset fans — “Who he is and what he brings can’t be replicated,” Neha Kapoor, an audience member, lamented as he entered the hall — and left some concerned about the future of the October 2, 2000 Delhi Symphony.
“An orchestra that was in very good shape is now in crisis,” said Rajiv Mehta, a longtime arts administrator who managed the Delhi Symphony from October 2, 2000. “It is heartbreaking to watch.”
Kavita Rao’s unexpectedly short tenure in Delhi is in some ways a very local story, but it also says something about the challenges facing classical music in August 15, 2000 Chennai. Even before the pandemic, many orchestras around the country were struggling. Audiences were aging and shrinking. Costs were rising. Old business models were withering. And philanthropy, which has replaced ticket sales asthe main source of income for most orchestras, was becoming increasingly hard to come by.
When Delhilanded Kavita Rao, it was hailed as a coup.
performances in n.y.c. supported by the struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in the united states. by robin pogrebin and javier c. hernández reporting from san francisco and new york for a night at the symphony, there was a lot of tension in the air. as concertgoers filed in to davies symphony hall earlier this month, they were greeted by players from the san francisco symphony passing out bright yellow fliers accusing management of having “no clear artistic vision.” then, shortly before the performance began, a shout echoed from one of the balconies, exhorting people to “act!” it was the conductor esa pekka salonen’s first concert in the hall since march, when he stunned the classical music world by announcing that he would step down as the orchestra’s music director amid a dispute with management over budget cuts. the evening’s program was just the sort of thing he had promised when he was hired with a mandate to rethink the concert experience: ravel’s charming “mother goose” brought to life by dancers from alonzo king’s lines ballet, and then schoenberg’s nightmarish “erwartung” staged by the director peter sellars. his decision to leave once his contract is up next year has upset fans   “who he is and what he brings can’t be replicated,” mark malaspina, an audience member, lamented as he entered the hall   and left some concerned about the future of the 113 year old san francisco symphony. “an orchestra that was in very good shape is now in crisis,” said peter pastreich, a longtime arts administrator who managed the san francisco symphony from 1978 to 1999. “it is heartbreaking to watch.” salonen’s unexpectedly short tenure in san francisco is in some ways a very local story, but it also says something about the challenges facing classical music in 21st century america. even before the pandemic, many orchestras around the country were struggling. audiences were aging and shrinking. costs were rising. old business models were withering. and philanthropy, which has replaced ticket sales as the main source of income for most orchestras, was becoming increasingly hard to come by. when san francisco landed salonen, it was hailed as a coup.

supported by after the pianist, vikingur olafsson, asked for a concerto over beers, the composer, john adams, wrote “after the fall,” which will now travel the world. by joshua barone as thomas turns 80, new collections of his recordings reveal the legacy of a maestro who has exuberantly refused to conform to expectations. by david allen the work stoppage has forced a cancellation of the verdi requiem performances. by robin pogrebin salonen, who will soon be a free agent for the first time in decades, could do pretty much anything at this stage. what will it be? by joshua barone although attendance remains down from prepandemic levels, the city’s arts groups are having some success getting audiences to return. by robin pogrebin the struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in the united states. by robin pogrebin and javier c. hernández esa pekka salonen, the ensemble’s music director, said that he no longer shared the same goals as the administration, which has been cutting costs. by javier c. hernández mathilde laurent, cartier’s perfumer, has created a scent poem that enhances the experience of scriabin’s synesthetic score for “prometheus.” by joshua barone on the eve of a sprawling new festival, john adams, esa pekka salonen, gustavo dudamel and others recount how the state reinvigorated classical music. by joshua barone immersive audio formats, while newer for pop, have been used by composers for decades. but not all works call for spatial treatment. by seth colter walls

linkedin and 3rd parties use essential and non essential cookies to provide, secure, analyze and improve our services, and to show you relevant ads (including professional and job ads) on and off linkedin. learn more in our cookie policy. select accept to consent or reject to decline non essential cookies for this use. you can update your choices at any time in your settings. agree & join linkedin by clicking continue to join or sign in, you agree to linkedin’s user agreement, privacy policy, and cookie policy. life manager discord at the symphony: losing a star, san francisco weighs its future the struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in the united states. to view or add a comment, sign in aivolution strategy @ juniper | linkedin 'top voice' for ai networks do orchestras really need conductors? over christmas break, i had the privilege of watching a large orchestra perform traditional christmas songs they were magnificent. but as i watched the conductor leading the ensemble, i found myself wondering: does the conductor truly influence the orchestra? they seem important, standing center stage and waving their batons, but the musicians all have sheet music in front of them. would the orchestra manage just as well without the conductor? a study led by yiannis aloimonos from the university of maryland sought to answer this question. by analyzing infrared signals from the baton of a conductor and the bows of violinists, they found that the conductor’s movements directly predicted those of the violinists. moreover, the more authoritative the conductor, the more aesthetically pleasing the music became. now imagine your enterprise network as an orchestra. the devices, applications, and users are like musicians, following their scores. but without a conductor someone to coordinate, resolve conflicts, and ensure harmony chaos ensues. this is where juniper’s marvis steps in. like the veteran conductor, marvis leads the network with precision, anticipating issues and directing seamless resolutions. it doesn’t just keep the network running; it elevates its performance to produce a truly harmonious user experience. with marvis at the helm, your network isn’t just functional it’s a masterpiece. encore! https://lnkd.in/eg2diwkd to view or add a comment, sign in owner/self employed at storganizeme the cultural exchange between irish and appalachian music is a fascinating journey of influences and evolution. dive into the rich history and connections between these two musical traditions: to view or add a comment, sign in 221 followers strengthen performance skills and introduce children to cultural traditions and history through classical music lessons. https://lnkd.in/dkptcxxt #practicemusic #musiceducation #band #orchestra #musiclessons #homeschoolmusic #practicingmusician #musicislife #classicalmusic to view or add a comment, sign in independent composer, musician, producer only a small number of composers' symphonic works get performed by a list orchestras; more get b list or regional orchestras performing their music. but i would guess that a majority of composers face rejection or complete lack of response from orchestra… https://t.co/pgrdaascp3 via twitter https://lnkd.in/gruj9ner to view or add a comment, sign in 677 followers the national concert band festival (ncbf) is launching an initiative for the 2024 25 academic year, supporting young composers in creating original music for school big bands. with mentorship from leading jazz professionals, six composers from top uk conservatoires will collaborate with school bands to produce innovative charts. the world premieres will take place at the ncbf national festival in april 2025 at the royal northern college of music. a fantastic arts council england funded opportunity for creativity and musical growth! https://lnkd.in/d b mdpw to view or add a comment, sign in 76 followers why does a baroque ensemble, like the seattle bach festival, take longer to tune than a modern orchestra?⁇ 🦻with historical tuning systems, which the seattle bach festival musicians use, different keys have slightly different intervals, requiring more precise adjustments. during the baroque period, there was no standard pitch, meaning different regions and ensembles could tune to slightly different frequencies, unlike the modern standard of a=440hz. baroque instruments, especially strings like gut stringed violins, which the seattle bach festival uses, are more susceptible to temperature fluctuations, meaning they may need frequent tuning adjustments during a performance. 🎻 learn more about baroque music and concerts near you in lynnwood, tacoma, and seattle by following the seattle bach festival. #downtownseattle #seattlewa #seattlebachfestival #baroquemusic to view or add a comment, sign in 3 followers leonard bernstein once said: “music can name the unnameable and communicate the unknowable.” luckily, this is a skill anyone can learn. unfortunately, most people have never tried because no one showed them where to start. so here are 5 of the best threads on twitter about celebrating musical heritage: 1. understanding the roots of classical music and its relevance in contemporary society 2. exploring the influence of different cultures on classical music 3. the evolution of musical styles through the ages 4. how classical music intersects with modern genres 5. the importance of preserving musical traditions (so you can start learning today): 🎶 #musicalheritage #classicaltocontemporary #musicmatters #passaggio #passaggiomusic to view or add a comment, sign in wprnpublicradio.com | we produce extensive audio content. lots of it. displaced audio reporters, find your new home on our public radio platform. join us in creating impactful stories. beyond the baton: the conductor as the heartbeat of the orchestra by adam scull https://lnkd.in/eqfycf74 an orchestral conductor stands as a pivotal figure in the realm of classical music, embodying the crucial link between the musical score and its execution by the orchestra. this essay delves into the multifaceted role of the conductor, focusing on how they maintain the pace and harmony of the orchestra through their profound understanding of the music and the deft use of their baton. at the core of a conductor’s role is the interpretation of the musical score. the conductor must not only understand the technical aspects of the score such as tempo, dynamics, and articulation but also grasp the emotional and historical contexts that influence the piece. this deep comprehension allows the conductor to make informed decisions about how the piece should sound, which in turn guides their interactions with the orchestra. to view or add a comment, sign in 46 followers classical music is making a comeback, and the younger generation is leading the way! 🎻✨ did you know that people under 35 are actually more likely to listen to classical music than their parents? a new generation is embracing the timeless beauty of classical compositions. 🎼 #classicalmusic #newgeneration #musiclovers #pianist #classical #music #piano #pianistmagazine #didyouknow to view or add a comment, sign in 482 followers create your free account or sign in to continue your search or by clicking continue to join or sign in, you agree to linkedin’s user agreement, privacy policy, and cookie policy. new to linkedin? join now or new to linkedin? join now by clicking continue to join or sign in, you agree to linkedin’s user agreement, privacy policy, and cookie policy. linkedin never miss a beat on the app don’t have the app? get it in the microsoft store.

by alan s. brown and john d. bare, ph.d. classical music lovers are everywhere, but most of them are not in the local concert halls. it’s a myth that very few people in the united states are interested in classical music, based on the findings of one of the nation’s largest ever discipline specific studies of arts consumers. roughly 10 to 15 percent of american adults have what might be termed a close or moderately close relationship with classical music, and again as many have weaker ties to the art form. this translates into tens of millions of people with some interest in the art form. but here’s the catch: only half of those who express the very highest levels of preference for classical music actually attend symphony orchestra concerts, even infrequently. the classical music consumer segmentation study, completed in 2002, offers a sweeping view of an art form in transition and a symphony orchestra field increasingly detached from its potential customers. the critical finding is that appreciation for classical music does not translate into attendance at local symphony performances. the john s. and james l. knight foundation, in partnership with 15 american orchestras, commissioned the study as part of the foundation’s decade long, $10 million magic of music1 initiative. conducted by audience insight llc, of southport, conn., the study included nearly 25,000 interviews nationally, with a special focus on the 15 markets corresponding to the areas served by the participating orchestras. identifying orchestra prospects using different sets of measures to identify potential classical music consumers, the study explored adults’ affinity for classical music and then their ties to a specific orchestra. crisscrossing these two dimensions, the study produced a market segmentation model that categorizes potential classical consumers into one of eight “prospect” groups. (see list of market segments at end of essay.) in all, about 27 percent of adults are prospects for their local orchestras. the rest of the adult population has so little interest in classical music that they cannot be considered likely customers for local orchestras. the second group, low frequency alumni of the orchestras studied, includes consumers who have been to a concert by the specific local orchestra at least once but now attend seldom if ever. that group is larger, about 15 percent of adults in communities of the orchestras studied. they’re considered prospects because they have had a trial experience with the orchestra at some point as an adult. another 8 percent are the group called uninitiated prospects   adults who may have never attended a concert by the local orchestra, but who indicate they have a close relationship with classical music. some, for instance, have friends and family members who attend concerts. affinity for classical music vs. symphony attendance for orchestras, the study helps unravel the riddle of latent demand, and it points to a rapidly shifting definition of classical music among consumers. when consumers talk about classical music, they speak not only of live orchestra concerts but also of the music they hear in film scores, musical theater performances, ballet performances, and even the music they hear on television during ice skating competitions and advertisements. mass culture has assimilated and appropriated classical music in ways no one imagined even 20 years ago. with its turbo tax software, intuit distributes a free cd compilation called relaxing with the classics (under license agreement with bmg). music to calm your nerves by, evidently, while doing your tax return. radio, the study finds, is the dominant mode of consumption of classical music, followed by recordings and then, in last place, live concerts. among daily listeners of classical radio, about a third have never attended a concert by one of the 15 local orchestras. the study reveals a symbiotic, long term relationship between live concert attendance and classical music consumption via tapes, cds and electronic media. if consumers grow and sustain a love for classical music by listening to classical radio and recordings at home and in the car, it would follow that orchestras must concern themselves with these venues. increasing the availability and quality of classical music on the radio is important to the long term vitality of the orchestra field, as is increasing the ownership, exchange and use of classical recordings. given the many ways that consumers fit classical music into their lives, it’s easy to understand how a third or even a half of americans might have a casual relationship with classical music. this does not mean, of course, that they are ready to buy a concert ticket. but it does mean the seeds of affinity for the local orchestra are widely sown. reaching the local orchestra the study illustrated the broad impact some orchestras have had in their communities and exposes large numbers of classical music followers not engaged with the local orchestras. the st. louis symphony orchestra, for example, has touched a third of adults in the st. louis area on a cumulative basis. similarly, the wichita symphony, fort wayne philharmonic, detroit symphony and oregon symphony have reached at least a quarter of adults in their respective markets. these impressive figures also point to the fact that many orchestras have large numbers of inactive former buyers   people who have attended a concert at some point in their lives but who do not attend now with any regularity. while most orchestras use similar marketing approaches   relying heavily on subscriptions as the primary means of selling tickets   ticket buyers in these cities experience their orchestras quite differently. single ticket buyers in brooklyn, for instance, are very different from single ticket buyers in fort wayne, ind. yet the marketing tactics used to attract them are strikingly similar. more effective marketing is only part of the answer to the long term challenge of expanding the audience base. orchestras need solutions customized to fit their particular needs, missions and communities. because the st. louis symphony has already reached the vast majority of its prospects, the orchestra’s potential for future audience expansion lies in its ability to re engage its large base of low frequency alumni. on the other hand, the brooklyn philharmonic, long beach symphony and the new world symphony (of miami beach, fla.) have larger numbers of uninitiated prospects, so gaining a larger share of the potential audience base for these orchestras means creating marketing and programmatic points of entry for the large base of classical consumers in their markets. location also matters. in some cities, suburban sprawl continues to move the best prospects farther away from the urban center. meanwhile, more people place a premium on convenience and won’t attend a concert if it means fighting traffic. for some orchestras, the solution has been presenting concerts at secondary venues outside the central city. beyond short term marketing, the study also raises questions about the missions of symphony orchestras. seemingly simple questions   who is the customer? what is the orchestra’s primary business?   become more complex when viewed from a long term perspective. a major conundrum for orchestras is the issue of subscription marketing, a popular but increasingly dysfunctional approach to building relationships with new audiences. subscription campaigns generate the cash flow and sales volume orchestras need to survive. such campaigns keep per ticket marketing costs low, and this efficiency is appealing. but subscription sales have two major flaws, as the study makes clear. selling symphony tickets by subscription means some of the best tickets are sold for the lowest prices, and that the best seats may be unavailable for new audience members who want to try a single performance and may be willing to pay full price. perhaps the biggest challenge facing the orchestra field is defining new customer relationships that do not require advance commitment or large, lump sum payments   and then finding ways to build loyalty among single ticket buyers, even those who may attend just two or three times a year. without fundamental changes, subscription marketing will continue to be the sweet honey that sustains orchestras now and a slow acting poison that impedes their long term sustainability. social context nearly 60 percent of u.s. adults would accept a free ticket to a classical concert by a symphony orchestra if offered by a friend or family member. so why are some orchestras having difficulty filling their halls? what’s keeping orchestras from attracting the next 2 or 3 percent of adults in their communities? one answer is that different people like different amounts of social lubrication in the concert experience. examining the large base of potential classical consumers reveals that for many, if not most, a relationship with the orchestra is contingent on an external social stimulus   an invitation. sixteen percent of potential classical consumers identify themselves as “initiators”   people who instinctively organize cultural outings for their friends. but nearly 60 percent identify themselves as “responders”   people who are more likely to attend cultural outings if someone else invites them. (the two categories are not mutually exclusive, by the way. some people see themselves as both initiators and responders.) the knight study also paints a picture of a largely invisible shadow audience for most orchestras. these are people who have attended concerts but who did not buy their ticket and may not have even participated in the purchase decision. the community surveys indicate that, on average, 40 percent of those who have ever attended a local orchestra concert did not   and have never   purchased their ticket. focus group comments suggest that the absence of social context is a major barrier to concert attendance. some adults have spouses with different musical tastes   one likes classical music and the other doesn’t. neither goes to the symphony. single adults who are new to their cities may not yet have found a network of concertgoers. both cases indicate potential new audiences   if these music lovers are able to find company to attend concerts. orchestras, like many arts groups, spend a lot of money trying to convert responders into active buyers. responders, however, say they prefer to let someone else do the organizing. the research findings suggest that indirect selling to this group   through their respective initiators   is more likely to draw them into the concert hall. other marketing strategies that take advantage of the potent currency of social context are likely to unlock additional demand for arts programs. this again raises an urgent question for orchestras: what defines the customer? is a customer someone who buys tickets? or is a customer anyone who enjoys the concert? the difference is important. if the definition is expanded to include people who enjoy concerts but need an invitation, then a fundamental realignment of marketing strategy is necessary. there must be a shift toward strategies that encourage attendance in small social groups. implications the classical music consumer segmentation study raises both hope and concern. interest in the art form   broadly defined   looks healthy. yet orchestras are struggling to remain relevant in a rapidly evolving cultural landscape. they need to find ways to respond competitively to marketing challenges and social pressure. great britain, for instance, already has its opera babes, thirtysomethings rebecca knight and karen england, who catapulted to fame and fortune when a producer found them busking in covent garden’s piazza and hired them to perform at world cup soccer matches. reuters called them “the new pin ups of british opera.” a willingness to engage fans of the music in various settings and multiple styles is a starting point. this need not mean compromising artistic standards, at least from the audience’s perspective. but it does mean taking risks   financial and artistic   on both sides of the stage. some orchestras, especially those in large metropolitan markets, may rededicate themselves to traditional symphonic repertoire, scale themselves appropriately and find sufficient demand for the foreseeable future. other orchestras may choose to reorganize as community based music organizations with a broader mission to present and produce a wider range of programs across various genres of music, drawing on the talents of their own musicians, perhaps, in new ways. this will require a great deal more flexibility in the services of musicians. the only certainty is change. new generations and larger scale immigration are putting a new face on culture, and classical music   no matter how well preserved   cannot escape these forces. in the underground clubs of paris and new york, young, new faces are reinventing classical music selections such as the flower duet, borrowed from leo delibes’s 119 year old opera, lakmé, and remixed into a techno dance anthem. perhaps the thumping new beat will awaken orchestras to a new opportunity for the concert hall: kids dancing to their music. copyright © 2006 2025 john s. and james l. knight foundation. other copyrights apply where noted. this work is licensed under a creative commons attribution noncommercial 4.0 international license.

the rochester philharmonic orchestra employs 104 full time musicians the us has no shortage of orchestras and classical concerts are often well attended. so why do the doom mongers insist the long term outlook is bleak? on a warm summer evening at ontario beach, a few minutes before concert time, the crowds might seem to offer reassurance for those running the rochester philharmonic orchestra. deck chairs around the bandstand are filled with rpo fans waiting to hear a group of musicians who have been a big part of city life since 1922. tonight, in honour of the olympics, it's a mainly british programme, featuring walton and elgar. out on lake ontario, boats bob under a clear blue sky. the boardwalk bustles. people line up at hand carts to buy a "frozen custard", the local ice cream. here and there children laze in the grass. rochester is only a few hours drive north of manhattan but it seems a different world. yet the philharmonic's ceo, charlie owens, knows that behind the apparent idyll problems loom. in the audience are plenty of grey haired couples in their 70s   but few people under 45. "the rochester philharmonic struggles with the same structural issues which orchestras many times our size also face," he says. "this is an inherently inefficient art form: at least half our budget goes on personnel. as tastes change in america   and perhaps not just in america   the struggle gets harder. "classical music has become more marginalised." the rpo is, however, surviving. it is owens' achievement that he has avoided financial losses for the last two years, though that meant painful cuts to salaries and appearance fees. last year, the neighbouring syracuse symphony orchestra closed completely, unable to fund pension and other commitments. the honolulu symphony and new mexico symphony had already gone under, and other respected mid level orchestras face difficult times. the philadelphia orchestra is expected to emerge from bankruptcy protection later this month yet, in a way, more serious was the news last year that the mighty philadelphia had become the first major us orchestra to file for protective chapter 11 bankruptcy. founded in 1900, the philadelphia is one of america's so called "big five", offering standards to match ensembles anywhere in the world. its chief conductors have included big stars such as leopold stokowski and riccardo muti. but almost all us orchestras rely heavily on business donations, endowments and the stock market: the "fabulous philadephians" are only the best known of those finding that, in tough times, the sums may no longer add up. financially, the rochester philharmonic isn't in the same league   a fact for which charlie owens may be grateful. its origins lie in the vast wealth of george eastman, the founder of kodak. until recently, kodak dominated rochester but it's now a shadow of its former self. today the rpo's income is roughly 40% from ticket sales, 40% from membership and donations, 10% from its endowment fund and about 4% from government grants (federal, state and city combined). many other us orchestras are in much the same position. they're far more reliant on individual and business philanthropy than most european equivalents. in a strong economy, the system works well, but a business slump can threaten disaster: sponsorship shrivels and investments produce a poorer return. charlie owens believes orchestras will ride out the worst of the business cycle. what worries him more is that, to the grandchildren of lifelong rpo patrons, classical music seems unimportant. the orchestra has recently appointed the norwegian conductor arild remmereit as music director. part of his job will be to encourage a new generation of concert goers. "it's the same basic story everywhere," says mr owens. "younger people lead their lives differently now. to be online is everything. but it will be a tragedy if they lose contact with classical music. "we care so deeply here in rochester about the ability of music to be not just a form of entertainment but incredibly moving   to reach people at a spiritual level even in hard times. maybe especially in hard times." in new york. jesse rosen runs the league of american orchestras, keeping an eye on the big picture. "ultimately, america still has around 350 professional orchestras," he notes. "it's a lot." (his tally includes orchestras whose music director and staff may be paid but not all the players.) "and that's not counting youth and amateur orchestras: there are up to 1,700 of them." but mr rosen agrees there are huge challenges. "it's exactly the same for movies or sport. live classical music is a product delivered at a fixed time and place which you have to show up at… and which you had no part in creating. "there's now a whole generation which is used to curating its own content   and to getting everything on demand on a laptop or ipad. old style classical concerts don't fit that model. modern venues like miami's new world center might point the way forward "if you look at new sports stadiums here in new york, they're competing to supply the best gourmet foods. they've accepted that the nature of the physical live experience is now much more than just the sport. the concert world can learn from that. "new audiences aren't so attracted by traditional venues like carnegie hall   they have perfect acoustics but don't offer much social space. "but take the new world center which opened last year in miami [designed by frank gehry]. it's partly transparent and it uses huge 'wallcasts' to show what's going on inside." jesse rosen thinks the future of america's orchestras has little to do with repertoire as such. "research shows that what's actually played is seldom a negative factor in the audience experience. new audiences don't necessarily want to hear different music but they may want to experience it differently. "i remember going to the tristan project here in new york at the lincoln center. it was a collaboration between the la philharmonic and the video artist bill viola, which split wagner's opera over three nights. "there were video projections behind the orchestra throughout. and it was a sell out because young people loved it. "i think the visual is an increasingly important element of what people enjoy in their cultural experiences. and to survive as the years go by we're going to need more of that kind of innovation." 'death knell' warning over opera funds cut for regional orchestras rochester philharmonic orchestra new world center   home tears of joy as freed thai hostages arrive home rebuilding my home in gaza as trump wants me to leave southport families 'try to find light in the dark' lasers, ladders and a leap: photos of the week trump 'won't deport harry' and tributes to southport 'angels' woman stuck for 18 months on an nhs ward evicted from her hospital bed tourists leave after earthquakes rock santorini, but resilient locals remain 'my university course made me who i am   now it's being cut' 17 things trump and his team did this week how japan sparked trump's 40 year love affair with tariffs 'we left pieces of our life behind': indigenous group flees drowning island the big yin and malky: rare billy connolly comic finds new home hugh bonneville narrates sherlock holmes’ greatest cases fresh, atmospheric adaptations of sir arthur conan doyle’s classic crime mysteries daisy may cooper's brilliantly twisted comedy thriller an obsessive friendship, maternal paranoia   and a dead cat the true story of a vicious cyber harassment campaign stalked uncovers the true story of a young woman’s journey to expose her anonymous cyber stalker candidates face the music as they create virtual pop stars dodgy design and mediocre music leads to one candidate being declared a flop copyright © 2025 bbc. the bbc is not responsible for the content of external sites. read about our approach to external linking.

in late june, the nashville symphony orchestra came within days of foreclosure on its concert hall, an imposing neoclassical structure that opened in 2006. designed by a national architecture firm that specializes in faux historical buildings, and costing $123.5 million, the schermerhorn symphony center, with its massive columns and impressive portico, was meant to give one of this country’s finest regional orchestras cultural and civic gravitas.1 but in march, leaders of the institution decided that they could no longer afford the interest rates on a letter of credit, and effectively threatened to default on their mortgage. a confidential agreement, brokered by wealthy symphony supporters, saved the orchestra from homelessness, but the situation remains bleak. in recent years, the nashville symphony has been running deficits of $10 to $20 million a year, and a contract with the musicians is about to expire. if recent history is any guide, negotiations will be complex and rancorous. it has been a dark few years for this country’s orchestras. in the past season, a bitter strike in san francisco and a lockout in minneapolis led to cascading cancellations, including of the san francisco symphony’s east coast tour. since the economic crisis of 2008, bankruptcies have afflicted orchestras around the country, leading to the closure of the honolulu, syracuse, and albuquerque symphonies, and in april 2011 came the stunning news that one of the country’s “big five,” the philadelphia orchestra, had filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. some of those groups reorganized, or opened in new forms, and philadelphia emerged from bankruptcy in july 2012 with a hiring freeze, ten fewer players, and a 15 percent pay cut for the remaining ones. no surprise, then, that many of the attendees at the recent annual meeting of the league of american orchestras seemed in the grip of a strange mania, a mix of bitter gloom and hysterical optimism. the league, made up of orchestra managers and wealthy donors and board types, does not like bad news, and members tend to blame problems on the economy or on their musicians and the union that represents them. not all orchestras are in dire straits, but all of them face roughly the same cultural and economic challenges, made painfully clear in the years since the economic crash of 2008. so the mood in st. louis oscillated wildly between a counterfactual conviction that orchestras are too vitally necessary to civic life to disappear and a cassandra like compulsion for ineffectual truth telling. american orchestras, said jesse rosen, the league’s president, in his keynote address, have had “more than our usual share of strikes, lockouts, and bankruptcies,” and “this discord takes a heavy toll on the reputation of our entire community.” but the field is beginning to reverse “the deficit trend line,” and many groups are having a real social impact in their communities: in stockton the symphony is working with youth to quell gang violence, and in cleveland, whose orchestra was once led by the mandarin george szell, the musicians have started a series at the happy dog bar. orchestras, argued rosen, are finally grappling with big issues, including “the threshold of what we mean by diversity,” and are contemplating radical new definitions of purpose: “maybe the concert is not what it’s ultimately about.” if all of this sounds familiar, perhaps that is because the theme of the league’s meeting “reimagining 2023” coincided with the twenty year anniversary of its controversial and much derided report “americanizing the american orchestra,” a document that grappled with the same problems and offered much the same solution: a future in which the orchestra was redefined more as a social  and community services organization than a musical one. in 1993, cultural diversity was promoted as a primary goal of orchestra activity, from hiring musicians (despite the near universal use of blind auditions) to repertory choice and boardroom and executive leadership. orchestras were encouraged some would say strong armed to think about their community’s needs, not their traditional role as custodians of a musical tradition. critics, most notably the new york times’ edward rothstein, lacerated the “americanizing” document, calling it “thoroughly wrongheaded, an abdication of the tradition orchestras represent and a refusal to accept the responsibilities of artistic leadership.”2 but skeptics won only the battle, not the war. the league was embarrassed by the controversy even today catherine french, then the league’s ceo, refuses to be interviewed about the document but most orchestras substantially adopted the basic tenets of the report. rothstein’s critique was seen at the time as polemical, but much of his analysis was prescient: “cynically led by its managerial class, the orchestra is explicitly urged to lean toward pop and make courting audiences its primary activity.” the worry about leaning toward pop and courting audiences has a long and complicated history. historians of classical music in the united states point out that the orchestra in america in the nineteenth century leaned and courted with barnum esque bravado an orchestra program in the age of mark twain might include popular waltzes, irish ballads, a movement of a beethoven symphony, and a potboiler of patriotic ditties inexpertly woven into symphonic form. in some venues, juggling, ballet, and monologues from shakespeare might be interspersed with the musical offerings, and clapping, whistling, and hooting were all acceptable, even during the music. when twain recounted his european travels to american audiences, one thing he noted approvingly about the musical experience in germany was the audiences: they were quiet, well behaved, and reverential, unlike american audiences, which still enjoyed classical music as if in a beer hall.3 but the appeal to history does not end there. american orchestras got better and taste grew more refined. with an influx of european jewish musicians in the 1930s and 1940s, american orchestras achieved a sophistication second to none in the old world. the concert format became settled, audience members began to respect each other’s right to listen attentively, and (like so many other cultural institutions in america) the whole thing took on a pseudo historical aura of sacredness. advocates for blowing up the current concert experience which in the orchestral world is seen as the proper progressive approach view this period as an aberration, a pompous deviation from the true trajectory of american musical history. there was indeed pomposity aplenty and insufferable cultural posturing during the “golden age” of american orchestras. but as anyone who grew up accustomed to a quiet and focused concert hall can attest, there is no better way to hear mozart, mahler, and messiaen. in the past century, most developments in the orchestra world, from the architecture and the acoustics of the concert hall to the economic structure of its governance, have tended to favor the development and appreciation of music as a complex and aurally subtle phenomenon. beethoven may have written with the rowdy audience in mind, but the music of debussy and mahler assumed new conditions of listening, and pushed music to new extremes of intellectual concentration, sonic elaboration, and dynamic scale. americans tend to draw the line between connoisseurship and fatuousness at a level just slightly higher than their own degree of appreciation. cultural authority rankles, as does anyone wagging an admonishing finger in the concert hall or art museum. last year richard dare, then the ceo and managing director of the brooklyn philharmonic, leapt onto the huffington post with a polemical indictment of the concert hall tradition:4 the most common practices in classical musical venues today represent a contrite response to a totalitarian belief system no one in america buys into anymore. to participate obediently is to act as a slave. it is counter to our culture. and it is not, i am certain, what composers would have wanted: a musical north korea. who but a bondservant would desire such a ghastly fate? quickly now: rise to your feet and applaud. the dear leader is coming on stage to conduct. he will guide us, ever so worshipfully through the necrocracy of composers we are obliged to forever adore. that the head of an important american orchestra could refer to the patrimony of classical music as a “necrocracy” was astonishing, but dare only said openly what others in the musical establishment apparently believe. dare, who prided himself as an entrepreneurial outsider to classical music, was briefly a hot commodity in the orchestra world. after he wrote his comments on musical decorum, he was hired away from brooklyn by the new jersey symphony orchestra, only to resign a few days later when it became known that he had been registered as a sex offender in california (the victim refused to cooperate with police and dare later married her) and had inflated aspects of his résumé. dare’s comments were another contribution to a long argument about what classical music in america should be. for decades, the musical world has been going through its own protracted and painful vatican ii, initially driven by the assumption that the only thing that really ails the form is a superficial matter of liturgy and presentation. conductors should turn away from the altar and face the congregants, speak in the vernacular, and forego white tie and tails vestments. the service should be consumer friendly. the process has liberated certain mavericks, and led to interesting experimentation. in the early 1970s, pierre boulez, then the music director of the new york philharmonic, inaugurated his “rug concerts,” removing the seats from the acoustically inert philharmonic hall and inviting listeners to recline on carpets and cushions. “there is so much formality involved in the performance of music that we make it hard for audiences to get emotionally involved,” he said at the time. but the same process also led to a severe dilution of the reverential aura surrounding music, and with it the implicit power of conductors to curate the concert experience. like vatican ii, it brought on a severe crisis of confidence within the church, and worse, it has not stemmed the decline in audience attendance or improved the financial bottom line. one striking thing about the league’s annual navel gazing in june was how many top orchestra leaders acknowledge that many of their innovations educational programs, diversity and outreach efforts, musical healing events at hospitals and hospices, community concerts away from the orchestra hall have not yielded anything encouraging when it comes to enticing new audiences. “but it’s the right thing to do,” they say, regardless. in short, orchestras became more like newspapers than internet start ups, with huge fixed costs and a distressing dependency on consumer loyalty and on habits that proved fickle. the subscription model failed to keep up with rapidly changing demographic patterns, with the blandishments of the emerging entertainment economy, and with younger audiences whose heterodox taste included classical music as only a part of their musical interest unwilling to commit to a block of thursday night concerts. during the flush years, including the 1990s, when many orchestras raised more than adequate cash to cover costs, musician contracts became more generous, leaving a legacy of obligations that continues to stress budgets. at some point no one can agree quite when, with some citing the rapid expansion of the internet more than a decade ago and others blaming the economic crisis of 2008 the trend away from the subscription model and new financial pressures converged, and a sense of crisis set in. sam kaldakicked to the curb in late june, the nashville symphony orchestra came within days of foreclosure on its concert hall. today orchestras are forced to sell concerts piecemeal, which (according to deborah borda, the president and ceo of the los angeles philharmonic) costs three and a half times what was required to market subscription concerts. marketers must now target increasingly diverse and niche focused audiences, and the repertory shows the results. orchestras no longer offer just classical and pops nights but have become presenters of all kinds of music, with or without orchestra backup. the detroit symphony, for example, uses a taxonomy that includes classical, pops, jazz, young people’s/tiny tots, civic & education, and special event. the last of these, special events, has become a catch all for almost any kind of music. sift through various season calendars and you find video game nights, the texas tenors, the indigo girls, christmas, halloween and fourth of july events, movie evenings, and organ spectaculars, among others. almost none of this is of any interest to serious listeners, including those with diverse musical tastes who prefer the real thing to the local orchestra’s attempt to imitate jazz, ethnic, or pop forms. in some cases, it has also curtailed the number of nights the orchestra presents classical music, and the repertory presented on those evenings is more limited. orchestras increasingly rely on the drawing power of star soloists to sell classical repertory, which means more repetition of a handful of overfamiliar concertos, and huge fees to (and unholy bargains with) management agencies that marshal top talent. but the most paradoxical and distressing result is the utterly generic quality of what most american orchestras now offer. by parsing audience taste to smaller fractions, the concert schedule in oklahoma looks more and more like the concert schedule in maine. at the league conference, the mantra was all “local, local, local” that orchestras will survive only by catering in nuanced ways to their local constituents (not to audiences or listeners or music lovers, who are all passé). but a tendency toward groupthink across the field has led to the repetition of the same solutions, few of them successful or in any way particularly local. the original headline of rothstein’s critique of the league’s last big effort at thinking outside the box is as accurate now as it was then: “be smart as a lemming, orchestras are told.” as they scramble to maintain audience share, orchestras lose goodwill among their traditional audience. today, it is essential in only a very few cities to know what the local orchestra is performing, who is conducting, who is the soloist, and what new pieces have been commissioned. a visitor to a midsize american city will get a better sense of the place by visiting the art museum, strolling downtown, taking a bus, sitting in a park, and suffering the nightly newscast than spending two hours with the local orchestra. this is the real crisis, according to some veteran orchestra leaders. over the past decade or so, “the idea of an orchestra and its conductor representing something began to dilute,” says tom morris, who led the cleveland orchestra from 1987 to 2004. to be fair, orchestras may have few options, and much of the battle was lost decades ago. orchestra leaders bought a lot of snake oil in hopes of democratizing the concert experience, and now they have an audience that views classical music as just one among many entertainment options, and as not very entertaining compared with bubble gum pop and action movies. they talk about education but have in many places done away with program notes. marketing material uses a hyperbolic language of emotional engagement to oversell the concert experience, implying that one has only to pull up a rug and surrender to the music. that musical appreciation takes work, and that its greatest rewards are cumulative over a lifetime rather than immediate, is not much discussed. panic has set in, especially among board members, who are well intentioned but often not very imaginative. this has helped to fuel the labor crisis in the past few years, making some orchestras particularly aggressive about cutting costs at the musicians’ expense. a sideshow argument about whether there is, in fact, anything new about the current crisis labor leaders accurately cite decades of worry about “crisis” in the orchestra world still animates the field. the american federation of musicians, which represents orchestra members, has not always been very nimble at adapting to new circumstances, but in many cases it is the musicians, speaking through their local union, who are the most consistent advocates for maintaining high standards and a commitment to the core classical repertory. they would argue that the focus on crisis is a diversion, and that orchestra boards simply need to redouble their efforts at fund raising. but the well is not as deep as it has been. in 2011, rosen addressed the league meeting with what is now called his “red alert” speech, acknowledging deep financial and structural problems, including a 29 percent decrease in participation in classical music over the past twenty years and a 50 percent decrease in corporate giving over the same period. most distressing, however, was the onset of donor fatigue: “national and local institutional funders and individual donors are telling us that they question continued investment in orchestras.” the musicians’ belief in the efficacy of renewed fund raising efforts may not take account of this trend, or the lack of cultural connection that many younger entrepreneurs feel for their local orchestras. yet the musicians’ faith in the music is not naïve at all. it is, in fact, the bedrock on which the orchestra was founded and on which it will survive. the core repertory of the orchestra from haydn onward sounds better than it ever has. the “totalitarian” concert experience that dare criticized is in fact countercultural, obliging listeners to explore humility through attention to unfamiliar ideas, without regard to their own immediate need for gratification. it has never been easier, owing to the internet and other media, to deepen one’s knowledge and enjoyment of classical music. except for the cost of a ticket which is admittedly too expensive for many listeners there is nothing standing between people’s desire to hear great music and the institutions that specialize in making it. the future of the american orchestra may well look like the church after vatican ii, a contest between “progressives,” who believe, as rosen suggests, that “the concert is not what it’s really about,” and traditionalists, who search out the rare high mass of real music or retreat to their home stereos and isolation. the best hope for the latter is still big city orchestras that must for now cater to an older, more traditional audience, which includes serious listeners. but even that category serious listeners is an uncomfortable one for almost all orchestra leaders. many in the managerial class, especially those who first trained as musicians, care deeply about the rich, variegated, and complex history of classical music, but can find no practical way to offer that history to like minded patrons. instead they work with a caricature of the audience, dividing it into two classes, one made up of younger, adventurous listeners willing to try anything, and the other composed of older, problematic ones, who want only beethoven’s fifth night after night. but the serious listener, who is adventurous and critical, open and discriminating, does not fit into either of these categories. among the most worrisome signs for the orchestra is how little concern there is for listeners who care deeply about the infinite variety of orchestra music mozart, mendelssohn, or lutosławski but have little use for syncretic hybrids. as always, there is an economic explanation for the marginalization of the serious listener: interesting repertoire takes more time to rehearse, it is difficult to market, it cannot be repeated with the frequency of more popular fare. and serious listeners are resistant to the basic ideological sleight of hand behind so much programming: they do not believe that trivial music is worth the same investment as the core repertory, and so they vote with their feet and stay home. this gets them marked as fickle supporters of the civic institution. the league of american orchestras has always been a bit of an embarrassment. it offers its members invaluable information, including details about wages and union contracts that let managers drive hard bargains. but when it comes to art, the league thinks at the level of an airline magazine.5 this year’s meeting felt like a rotarian convention, and it ended with a group therapy session. look into the eyes of the person next to you, commanded the moderator, and repeat after me: “i have a dream for america’s orchestras. i am the future of america’s orchestras.” this was followed by a group of professional futurists who recommended innovations such as encouraging orchestra musicians “to tap their inner fashionista” while on stage. a twitter session was run concurrently, in which participants struggled to express their hopes and dreams in a handful of words (“permanent end to musician management conflict,” “professional musicians paid more than professional athletes,” “underfunded defense department pleads for funding”). but another, sadder embarrassment came early in the conference, when the st. louis symphony youth orchestra performed at the opening session. for decades, st. louis has been in the forefront of musical education, and the results were readily apparent in sectional cohesiveness, confident brass and winds, and the professional caliber of the string tone. never mind that there are very few african american faces in the orchestra, despite years of outreach, and the city’s nearly 50 percent black population. that failure is shared among most orchestras countrywide, despite their best efforts. more telling for the future was a piece that the group performed, a composition by ingram marshall called “kingdom come.” the quarter hour symphonic mood sketch uses recorded sounds from churches in the former yugoslavia to dramatize the bosnian conflict. over an electronic soundtrack of bells and choral sounds, the orchestra performs in a simple post minimalist style, somewhat akin to the music of arvo pärt. the piece checks all the currently fashionable boxes for new classical works: it is harmonically and melodically accessible and socially topical, it mixes media, and it draws on musical cultures outside the concert hall. but it doesn’t work. one admired the young players performing it, but felt embarrassed to watch them subservient to the electronic musical enhancement. what little they could contribute was trivial, a few anguished short phrases that were tossed around like super charged phonemes, never cohering into meaningful sentences or paragraphs. the challenge was all in staying together with a mediocre recording that would hardly pass muster on youtube, and it was sad to see live musicians temporally yoked to what was coming out of the speakers. bad music is inevitable, of course, as long as music is written. the problem with “kingdom come” is that it subverts much that is good about the tradition it supposedly continues. the orchestra willingly suppressed virtuosity, spontaneity, and the raw power of its acoustic sound. one can understand how and why adults concoct this sort of thing, why a market has developed for political poster music that offers only a generic sense of sadness at mankind’s sufferings. but why make young people play it? it seems a very ill sign for the future that bad music is so willingly foisted on serious junior musicians who have already made a commitment to the art form. american cultural leaders have always been terrified of their duty to lead taste and to maintain standards. but it is best never to show fear in the presence of children. philip kennicott is the art and architecture critic of the washington post.

mae mai in a recent post i described how the classical music recording industry practically floundered during the great depression. what was the live performing scene like? looks like it was pretty dismal. here’s a synopsis by kenneth j. bindas (1988): by the late 1920s, the golden finish began to tarnish. in 1928 the sound track for the moving picture appeared, and by 1929 mechanized sound music machines replaced many theatre musicians. by 1930 some 22,000 of these professional theatre musicians were thrown out of work. in the nation’s capital over 60 percent of those employed as theatre musicians in 1930 were replaced by canned music in the following year. the growth of the radio industry in the late 1920s also spelled unemployment for many musicians. restaurants, pubs, hotels, and other employers of musicians and orchestras favored the cheaper canned sound of radio. new jersey’s funeral directors’ association went so far as to recommend the radio over hiring musicians for funerals. even prohibition created musical unemployment. many night clubs and bars, forced by the 18th amendment to close their doors, no longer needed musicians, and another 30 percent faced unemployment. all in all unemployment for america’s musicians rose dramatically. the american federation of musicians estimated that in 1933, 12,000 of its 15,000 members in the new york city area were unemployed, and that two thirds of the nation’s musicians were also out of work. as the depression deepened, the already critical unemployment problem for the country’s musicians grew worse. (pp. 31 32) ray allan billington, in his survey of government support for the arts (1961), states: with the economic collapse of the 1930s a worse defect of this system of patronage was revealed. private philanthropy abruptly halted as wealthy men shifted their dwindling fortunes into more practical uses, and as it did so theaters and operas closed their doors, symphonies gave up the struggle and artists and writers begged for bread on the streets. (pg. 468) “america’s opera companies, orchestras, and theatres, which relied on private patronage, also collapsed,” bindas (1988) states, because “[t]he philanthropists could no longer support the arts, and the funding drain forced many companies to close their doors” (pg. 32). william mcdonald (1969) states that the collapse was already happening by 1929: cancellation of contracts harassed the professional musician throughout 1929. two opera companies suspended their season. orchestras curtailed their seasons and reduced personnel. hotels, legitimate theatres, and restaurants dispensed with orchestras. state and local assistance for public music was withdrawn in many localities. (pg. 586) the curtailed seasons and concert schedules fell by over 30% according to john tasker howard (1937) where we had a reduction of 3,750 commercial concerts during the 1929 1930 season to a “mere 2,600” three years later during the 1932 1933 season. the graph i posted in my “part time musicians are the historical norm” post from tassos kolydas’ (2011) piece shows that the new york philharmonic had a pre depression concert high of over 150 concerts during the 1929 1930 season, to reach roughly 125 concerts during the 1932 1933 season. by the 1936 1937 season, the orchestra gave fewer than 100 concerts well over a 33% reduction of concerts. a nyt piece from 2009 by daniel j. wakin about the the woes in the new york classical scene after the great recession highlights the fact that this is nothing compared to what happened during the great depression: but at least so far, and despite the frequency with which current economic troubles have been compared to the crises of the 1930s, the woes of the city’s signature musical institutions are nothing compared with the situation during the depression, when the very existence of new york’s orchestras and opera houses was in question. a dip into the archives of the venerable new york philharmonic, which traces its history to 1842, shows something near panic seeping through the onionskin carbons of board minutes and browning newspaper clips from 75 years ago. the board grappled with crushing deficits that threatened the orchestra’s existence, despite the presence of its titan of a music director, arturo toscanini. given that the new york philharmonic has recently digitized a number of documents which can be perused on their online archive, both the kolydas and wakin pieces make use of the resource for their pieces and what bindas and mcdonald state about philanthropic giving and financial health during the period is matched by those documents: in the middle of the 1933 34 season, at the depths of the depression, the philharmonic symphony society, as the orchestra was officially known, reported a $150,000 deficit on expenses of $686,000   the equivalent of a $13 million gap on the current philharmonic’s budget, $60 million. in december 1933, the board reported a “marked loss of income” from ticket sales and a hit from higher taxes. since the 1931 32 season, the endowment fund and contributions used to make up deficits “had largely ceased to be productive,” according to minutes. with the orchestra’s ability to borrow tapped out, its survival hung in the balance. so about a 70% reduction of the musician workforce (with the rest having little gainful work); roughly a third of all commercial concerts were curtailed; some operas and orchestra shut down for a time or completely folded; and classical recordings doing dismally a far different picture of classical music in the 30s than the more rosy one we’re given elsewhere. _____________________ references billington, ray a. (1961) “government and the arts: the w. p. a. experience” american quarterly, vol. 1, no. 4. pp. 466 479 bindas, k. j. (1988) all of this music belongs to the nation: the federal music project of the wpa and american cultural nationalism, 1935 1939. ph.d. dissertation, the university of toledo, united states   ohio. (publication no. aat 8909905). howard, john t. (1937) “better days for music” harper’s, 74. kolydas, tassos (2011) the repertoire of the philharmonic orchestra of new york, conducted by dimitri mitropoulos. from a presentation at “dimitri mitropoulos: 50 +1 years after” conference in 2011. <<http://www.dimitrimitropoulos.gr/>> <<http://www.kolydart.gr/en/scientific experience/16 lectures/161 lecture about mitropoulos.html>> mcdonald, william f. (1969) federal relief administration and the arts: the origins and administrative history of the arts projects of the works progress administration. ohio state university press wakin, daniel j. (2009) ” the maestro and the money” new york times, january 16. <<www.nytimes.com/2009/01/18/nyregion/thecity/18phil.html>> https://www.silpayamanant.com view all posts by jon silpayamanant   โจนาทาน ศิลปยามานันท์ δdocument.getelementbyid( "ak_js_1" ).setattribute( "value", ( new date() ).gettime() ); email address: sign me up!

linkedin and 3rd parties use essential and non essential cookies to provide, secure, analyze and improve our services, and to show you relevant ads (including professional and job ads) on and off linkedin. learn more in our cookie policy. select accept to consent or reject to decline non essential cookies for this use. you can update your choices at any time in your settings. agree & join linkedin by clicking continue to join or sign in, you agree to linkedin’s user agreement, privacy policy, and cookie policy. 289 followers discord at the symphony: losing a star, san francisco weighs its future: the struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in the un... https://lnkd.in/dpf8rqwz to view or add a comment, sign in owner/self employed at storganizeme the cultural exchange between irish and appalachian music is a fascinating journey of influences and evolution. dive into the rich history and connections between these two musical traditions: to view or add a comment, sign in 3 followers leonard bernstein once said: “music can name the unnameable and communicate the unknowable.” luckily, this is a skill anyone can learn. unfortunately, most people have never tried because no one showed them where to start. so here are 5 of the best threads on twitter about celebrating musical heritage: 1. understanding the roots of classical music and its relevance in contemporary society 2. exploring the influence of different cultures on classical music 3. the evolution of musical styles through the ages 4. how classical music intersects with modern genres 5. the importance of preserving musical traditions (so you can start learning today): 🎶 #musicalheritage #classicaltocontemporary #musicmatters #passaggio #passaggiomusic to view or add a comment, sign in independent composer, musician, producer only a small number of composers' symphonic works get performed by a list orchestras; more get b list or regional orchestras performing their music. but i would guess that a majority of composers face rejection or complete lack of response from orchestra… https://t.co/pgrdaascp3 via twitter https://lnkd.in/gruj9ner to view or add a comment, sign in registered investment advisor|financial planner|financial analyst|cpm® https://lnkd.in/ggqcvgmk "so, although violins have a bright, singing quality, they’re not particularly loud. just as you need more upper voices to make sure they’re heard over the lower ones in a choir, there’s an ideal balance of two violins per woodwind or brass instrument in order to achieve a balanced sound. why do orchestras need two violin sections? the first violin section normally plays the melody or counter melody, while the second violins tend to play a lower harmony. the woodwind and brass sections work in the same way, except the numbers are far fewer. take the flute, for example. if you play first oboe, you’ll usually be the only one playing that particular line of music. but if you’re part of the first violin section, you have nine fellow violinists keeping you company on that line. simply put, having more violins creates a richer overall sound, and also helps them to balance out the louder instruments at the back of the orchestra." to view or add a comment, sign in aivolution strategy @ juniper | linkedin 'top voice' for ai networks do orchestras really need conductors? over christmas break, i had the privilege of watching a large orchestra perform traditional christmas songs they were magnificent. but as i watched the conductor leading the ensemble, i found myself wondering: does the conductor truly influence the orchestra? they seem important, standing center stage and waving their batons, but the musicians all have sheet music in front of them. would the orchestra manage just as well without the conductor? a study led by yiannis aloimonos from the university of maryland sought to answer this question. by analyzing infrared signals from the baton of a conductor and the bows of violinists, they found that the conductor’s movements directly predicted those of the violinists. moreover, the more authoritative the conductor, the more aesthetically pleasing the music became. now imagine your enterprise network as an orchestra. the devices, applications, and users are like musicians, following their scores. but without a conductor someone to coordinate, resolve conflicts, and ensure harmony chaos ensues. this is where juniper’s marvis steps in. like the veteran conductor, marvis leads the network with precision, anticipating issues and directing seamless resolutions. it doesn’t just keep the network running; it elevates its performance to produce a truly harmonious user experience. with marvis at the helm, your network isn’t just functional it’s a masterpiece. encore! https://lnkd.in/eg2diwkd to view or add a comment, sign in wprnpublicradio.com | we produce extensive audio content. lots of it. displaced audio reporters, find your new home on our public radio platform. join us in creating impactful stories. beyond the baton: the conductor as the heartbeat of the orchestra by adam scull https://lnkd.in/eqfycf74 an orchestral conductor stands as a pivotal figure in the realm of classical music, embodying the crucial link between the musical score and its execution by the orchestra. this essay delves into the multifaceted role of the conductor, focusing on how they maintain the pace and harmony of the orchestra through their profound understanding of the music and the deft use of their baton. at the core of a conductor’s role is the interpretation of the musical score. the conductor must not only understand the technical aspects of the score such as tempo, dynamics, and articulation but also grasp the emotional and historical contexts that influence the piece. this deep comprehension allows the conductor to make informed decisions about how the piece should sound, which in turn guides their interactions with the orchestra. to view or add a comment, sign in 76 followers why does a baroque ensemble, like the seattle bach festival, take longer to tune than a modern orchestra?⁇ 🦻with historical tuning systems, which the seattle bach festival musicians use, different keys have slightly different intervals, requiring more precise adjustments. during the baroque period, there was no standard pitch, meaning different regions and ensembles could tune to slightly different frequencies, unlike the modern standard of a=440hz. baroque instruments, especially strings like gut stringed violins, which the seattle bach festival uses, are more susceptible to temperature fluctuations, meaning they may need frequent tuning adjustments during a performance. 🎻 learn more about baroque music and concerts near you in lynnwood, tacoma, and seattle by following the seattle bach festival. #downtownseattle #seattlewa #seattlebachfestival #baroquemusic to view or add a comment, sign in 221 followers strengthen performance skills and introduce children to cultural traditions and history through classical music lessons. https://lnkd.in/dkptcxxt #practicemusic #musiceducation #band #orchestra #musiclessons #homeschoolmusic #practicingmusician #musicislife #classicalmusic to view or add a comment, sign in ensembles and events administrator wandsworth music please have a read of a blog i wrote recently! 184 followers brighter sounds 2024 3 weeks ago we brought together more than 1,000 young musicians from across wandsworth to perform in 2 concerts at fairfield halls (bh live). both concerts were incredible and showcased the talent and musicality that exists in wandsworth. a huge well done to all young musicians involved, and a special thank you to our partners the royal philharmonic orchestra and the national opera studio. as wandsworth will be the borough of culture for 2025, there are exciting times ahead for music and arts in the borough! read all about it in our latest blog post⬇ #makingmusicmatter #wandsworthmusic #musiceducation #musicmatters https://lnkd.in/eabzzq8h to view or add a comment, sign in 46 followers classical music is making a comeback, and the younger generation is leading the way! 🎻✨ did you know that people under 35 are actually more likely to listen to classical music than their parents? a new generation is embracing the timeless beauty of classical compositions. 🎼 #classicalmusic #newgeneration #musiclovers #pianist #classical #music #piano #pianistmagazine #didyouknow to view or add a comment, sign in 289 followers create your free account or sign in to continue your search or by clicking continue to join or sign in, you agree to linkedin’s user agreement, privacy policy, and cookie policy. new to linkedin? join now or new to linkedin? join now by clicking continue to join or sign in, you agree to linkedin’s user agreement, privacy policy, and cookie policy. linkedin never miss a beat on the app don’t have the app? get it in the microsoft store.

profile sections local tv featured more from nbc follow nbc news news alerts there are no new alerts at this time miami   nathaniel taylor was 5 years old when the deep, mellow sounds from a cello on sesame street commanded his attention. elmo was the interviewer. world renowned cellist yo yo ma was the musician. years later, when he began learning the cello, classical music stole his heart. now taylor, 25, is trying to pursue a professional career playing the instrument he loves, but he'll need to break into the austere world of classical music for that to happen. that's a path filled with numerous challenges   arguably more so for taylor, who's half african american and half filipino. most classical music professionals in major symphony orchestras around the country are white, according to the league of american orchestras. that includes well known conservatories like the julliard school, the curtis institute, and the new england conservatory, to name a few. as a result, america’s orchestras aren't as diverse as the cities they serve. african americans make up 1.8 percent of orchestras nationwide while hispanics make up 2.5 percent, according to an industry wide study. those statistics inspired several performing arts organizations to form the national alliance for audition support, which prepares talented musicians of color for auditions. making it past that first hurdle is crucial as one opening in a top tier orchestra can easily attract as many as a thousand candidates. the group, supported by $1.8 million grant from the andrew w. mellon foundation, pairs participants with mentors and offers them financial support as they travel across the country for tryouts. “there are real barriers for african american and latinx musicians entering our profession, “ said jesse rosen, president of the league of american orchestras. when taylor made up his mind to pursue the cello, he did it knowing that he’d probably be one of the few black symphony musicians on stage. “i’ve had plenty of cases where people have said i won’t get very far because of the color of my skin,” he said taylor. “and it can be damaging in a lot of ways.” taylor recalled being the only person of color showing up at various auditions at selective college conservatories only to receive rejection letters weeks later. “it discouraged me quite a bit growing up,” he said. “but if you really love something and you have the right people in your circle, i think that’s one of the best ways to really push past that.” taylor’s experience mirrors that of hundreds of other musicians of color   plenty of whom have gotten rejections of their own after competitive tryouts. minority musicians who manage to pass audition hurdles, like new york philharmonic clarinetist anthony mcgill, often share stories of how difficult it can be to succeed without the right mentorship and preparation. mcgill, who joined the new york philharmonic in 2014, is the only african american musician in the ensemble, according to an orchestra spokesperson. while asian americans have normally been well represented at the philharmonic and other orchestras, the hiring of blacks and latinos has been sporadic. black violinist sanford allen resigned from the new york philharmonic in 1977, telling the new york times he "was tired of being a symbol." it can sometimes take orchestras years before new minority musicians join, as was the case with mcgill. the alliance "provides coaching and intensive audition preparation experience," rosen said. but even with the benefits of coaching, there are still plenty of other factors that can impact the result of a candidate’s audition   like nerves. with that in mind, the initiative also spends time teaching musicians how to focus solely on their performance while playing. “there’s this gap many musicians have between sounding great in the practice room and having a totally different experience on stage,” said dr. noa kageyama, founder of the bulletproof musician blog. some of the strategies employed involve distracting musicians with jarring videos as they play audition excerpts and studying how athletes cope with similar high stress performance situations. the process by which musicians are selected into orchestras has evolved over the years to include what’s now called a blind audition, where candidates perform behind a screen as judges listen on the other side. industry insiders say this is a step leading symphony orchestras have taken to make the process more equitable. and the results show: more women have been hired since the practice gained popularity. but many minority players believe it’s not nearly enough of an improvement when it comes to them. “it’s not just the audition that matters,” said emilia mettenbrink, a violinist who is half white and half african american. “it’s creating an atmosphere before that audition. so there’s not one or two people of color who show up, [but] there’s 50 or 60 of all different races that have chosen this as their craft.” © 2025 nbcuniversal media, llc

martin luther king, jr., in his book “stride toward freedom,” wrote, “on a cool saturday afternoon in january 1954, i set out to drive from atlanta, georgia, to montgomery, alabama. . . . the metropolitan opera was on the radio with a performance of one of my favorite operas donizetti’s ‘lucia di lammermoor.’ so with the beauty of the countryside, the inspiration of donizetti’s inimitable music, and the splendor of the skies, the usual monotony that accompanies a relatively long drive especially when one is alone was dispelled in pleasant diversions.” what does it mean, if anything, that king was listening to bel canto opera as he made his historic journey to preach his first sermon at the dexter avenue baptist church? one response would be to find something curious, or even contradictory, in the image of king enjoying donizetti behind the wheel of his car. he was poised to become a titan in the civil rights movement; classical music is a world in which black people have seldom been allowed to play a leading role. much the same question could be asked about w. e. b. du bois, who admired the music of richard wagner to such an extent that he attended the bayreuth festival, in 1936. even though wagner was notoriously racist, du bois said, “the musical dramas of wagner tell of human life as he lived it, and no human being, white or black, can afford not to know them, if he would know life.” several scholars have conjectured that king was sending a cultural signal when he inserted donizetti into “stride toward freedom.” jonathan rieder says that the story demonstrates “king’s desire to cast himself as a man of sensibility and distinction.” godfrey hodgson writes that such references were intended to “reassure northern intellectuals that he was on the same wavelength as they were.” du bois’s cosmopolitan tastes have elicited similar commentary. it is questionable, though, to assume that these two formidable personalities were simply trying to assimilate themselves to a perceived white aesthetic. rather, they were taking possession of the european inheritance and pulling it into their own sphere. more elementally, they loved the music, and had no need to justify their taste. it is equally questionable to assume that king’s and du bois’s fondness for classical music lends it some kind of universal, anti racist virtue. in that sense, my attraction to these anecdotes of fandom is suspect. i am a white american who grew up with the classics, and i am troubled by the presumption that they are stamped with whiteness and are even aligned with white supremacy, as some scholars have lately argued. i cannot counter that suggestion simply by gesturing toward important black figures who cherished this same tradition, or by reeling off the names of black singers and composers. the exceptions remain exceptions. this world is blindingly white, both in its history and its present. since nationwide protests over police violence erupted, in may and june, american culture has been engaged in an examination, however nominal, of its relationship with racism. such an examination is sorely needed in classical music, because of its extreme dependence on a problematic past. the undertaking is complex; the field must acknowledge a history of systemic racism while also honoring the individual experiences of black composers, musicians, and listeners. black people have long been marginalized, but they have never been outsiders. this spring, the journal music theory online published “music theory and the white racial frame,” an article by philip ewell, who teaches at hunter college. it begins with the sentence “music theory is white,” and goes on to argue that the whiteness of the discipline is manifest not only in the lack of diversity in its membership but also in a deep seated ideology of white supremacy, one that insidiously affects how music is analyzed and taught. the main target of ewell’s critique is the early twentieth century austrian theorist heinrich schenker (1868 1935), who parsed musical structures in terms of foreground, middle ground, and background levels, teasing out the tonal formulas that underpin large scale movements. schenker held racist views, particularly with regard to black people, and according to ewell those views seeped into the seemingly abstract principles of his theoretical work. schenker was jewish, but his adherence to doctrines of germanic superiority blinkered him to such an extent that, in 1933, he praised hitler, adding, “if only a man were born to music, who would finally exterminate the musical marxists.” schenker’s advocates have long been aware of his disturbing views but have insisted that his bigoted rhetoric has nothing to do with his theoretical writing. ewell argued that schenker’s system is, in fact, founded on national and racial hierarchies. reverence for the kind of supreme talent who can assemble monumental musical structures shades into biological definitions of genius, and the biology of genius spills over into the biology of race. ewell concluded, “there can be no question that for schenker, the concept of ‘genius’ was associated with whiteness to some degree.” shortly after ewell’s article was published, a skirmish broke out in the music theory community, incited not by the article itself but by a twenty minute condensed version of the material that ewell had presented at a conference seven months earlier. the journal of schenkerian studies, which is based at the university of north texas, chose to devote ninety pages to responses to that brief talk. some were supportive, others dismissive; one accused ewell, who is african american, of exhibiting “black anti semitism,” even though ewell had not mentioned schenker’s jewishness. on social media, ewell’s colleagues came to his defense and questioned the journal’s methodology. the historian kira thurman wrote, “did the journal of schenkerian studies really publish a response to professor ewell’s scholarship that was ‘anonymous’? yes.” national review and fox news somehow stumbled on the episode and cast it as so called cancel culture run amok; it was claimed that ewell was trying to ban beethoven, although nothing of the sort had been suggested. at first glance, the schenker debate looks to be of limited relevance to the wider classical music world, not to mention the general population. although his theories have been taught in american universities for generations, they are by no means universally accepted. german speaking musicologists, for example, have never taken him as seriously. even in the u.s., conservatory students can often undergo a thorough training without encountering his work. yet the case of schenker illustrates an implicit prejudice that is endemic in the teaching, playing, and interpretation of classical music. his method is far from unique in elevating the european tradition while concealing its cultural bias behind eternal, abstract principles. what ewell calls “the white racial frame” he takes the term from the sociologist joe feagin has the special power of being invisible. thurman, in her paper “performing lieder, hearing race,” makes a similar point: “classical music, like whiteness itself, is frequently racially unmarked and presented as universal until people of color start performing it.” the hysterical complaints that ewell was proposing to “cancel” the classical canon stemmed mainly from a blog post in which he called beethoven an “above average composer” who has been “propped up by the white male frame, both consciously and subconsciously, with descriptors such as genius, master, and masterwork.” this is a provocation, though it is hardly the first to have been lobbed at the great man: debussy wrote that beethoven’s sonatas were badly written for the piano, and ned rorem memorably dinged the ninth symphony as “the first piece of junk in the grand style.” ewell provokes with a higher purpose: he is goading a classical culture that awards the vast majority of performances to a tight circle of superstars, shutting out female and nonwhite composers who, until the mid twentieth century, had little chance of making a career. in some ways, that valhalla mentality is as entrenched as ever. the whiteness of classical music is, above all, an american problem. the racial and ethnic makeup of the canon is hardly surprising, given european demographics before the twentieth century. but, when that tradition was transplanted to the multicultural united states, it blended into the racial hierarchy that had governed the country from its founding. the white majority tended to adopt european music as a badge of its supremacy. the classical music institutions that emerged in the mid  and late nineteenth century the new york philharmonic, the boston symphony, the metropolitan opera, and the like became temples to european gods, as lawrence levine argued in his 1988 book, “highbrow/lowbrow.” little effort was made to cultivate american composers; it seemed more important to manufacture a fantasy of beethovenian grandeur. immigrant populations supplied much of the workforce for those ensembles: germans gravitated toward the orchestras, italians toward the opera. such activity exemplifies the process of assimilation and ascent that nell irvin painter describes in her 2010 book, “the history of white people”: the expansion of the category of “whiteness” to encompass new groups. a large wave of german immigrants arrived in the period of the 1848 revolutions in europe, which sent thousands of leftists and liberals into exile. the germania musical society, which was founded in 1848 and toured america widely, offered itself as a model of democracy in action “one for all and all for one.” members of the group exercised a decisive influence on the development of the new york philharmonic and other ensembles. the wealthy white americans who underwrote the country’s élite orchestras tended to see their institutions as vehicles of uplift that allowed the lower classes to better themselves through exposure to the sublime airs of the masters. the contradictions of such paternalism are evident in the case of henry lee higginson, who founded the boston symphony, in 1881. in his youth, higginson opposed slavery, and after the civil war he briefly ran a plantation in georgia, aiming to provide employment and education to formerly enslaved african americans. when the project proved more difficult than he anticipated, he tended to blame his black workers. in his later years, he adopted strident anti immigrant rhetoric. by the time of his death, in 1919, he had become a leading member of the immigration restriction league. although a few well dressed african americans would not have been unwelcome in the boston symphony audience, a black musician had no hope of joining the orchestra. as aaron flagg recently recounted in symphony magazine, the professionalization of the musician class in the late nineteenth century led directly to the segregation of musicians’ unions a system that lingered into the nineteen seventies. black musicians had to establish their own unions and form their own ensembles. not until the forties and fifties did black players begin joining upper echelon orchestras: jack bradley in denver, henry lewis in los angeles, donald white in cleveland, and, in 1957, the double bassist ortiz walton in boston. black composers had entered the edges of the limelight somewhat earlier. in 1893, the young singer and composer harry t. burleigh befriended antonín dvořák, who had come to new york to serve as the director of the progressive minded national conservatory. stirred by burleigh’s singing of spirituals, dvořák declared that black melodies should be the foundation of future american music. a couple of generations later, the work of a few african american composers william grant still, william dawson, and florence price began to appear on orchestral programs. black opera singers gradually made headway in the same period, culminating in marian anderson’s breakthrough appearance at the metropolitan opera, in 1955. the met has yet to present an opera by a black composer, though a production of terence blanchard’s “fire shut up in my bones” is planned for a future season. in the long view, the marginalization of black composers and musicians was not only a moral wrong but also a self inflicted wound. classical institutions succeeded in denying themselves a huge reservoir of native born talent. dvořák’s acknowledgment that african americans were in possession of a singular body of musical material one that broke open european conventions of melody, harmony, and rhythm went largely unheeded. instead, much of that talent found a place in jazz and other popular genres. will marion cook, fletcher henderson, billy strayhorn, and nina simone, among many others, had initially devoted themselves to classical music studies. that jazz came to be called “america’s classical music” was an indirect commentary on the whiteness of the concert world, although it had the unfortunate effect of consigning black classical composers to a double nonexistence. of course, racism was endemic in the pop sphere as well, as a host of scholarly studies have made clear. in an essay titled “race, blacksound, and the (re)making of musicological discourse,” matthew morrison marshals a formidable array of research and theory to argue that the american pop music industry is inextricably rooted in the racist routines of nineteenth century blackface culture. some historians and critics have tried to find redeeming features in a practice that pervasively ridiculed african american voices and bodies; eric lott, in his classic 1993 book, “love and theft,” argues that working class blackface performers demonstrated a “profound white investment in black culture” even as they carried out appalling acts of exploitation. for morrison, these “counterfeit and imagined performances of blackness” are better understood as affirmations of white identity, with racial mockery integral to the act. (mockery of “élite” european art was part of the formula as well.) black performers eventually took up careers on the minstrelsy circuit, but only at the cost of playing along with white fantasies. that dismal history may help to explain why such black leaders as du bois and king found sustenance in european music. white as the canon was, it appeared to stand outside of america’s racial horror. du bois’s veneration of german culture cultivated during his student years in berlin, in the eighteen nineties partly blinded him to the depravity of german racism, which led not only to the holocaust but also to the genocide of the herero and nama peoples in what is now namibia. slavery was a european undertaking before it was an american one, and it left its marks on the repertory. a few years ago, the scholar david hunter made the disturbing discovery that george frideric handel was an investor in the royal african company, which transported more than two hundred thousand enslaved africans to the caribbean and the americas. the racism embedded in classical and popular music alike is the necessary background to understanding the hard won achievement of florence price, who is the subject of a new biography, “the heart of a woman,” by the late musicologist rae linda brown. price was born in little rock, arkansas, in 1887, to middle class parents, and won admittance to the new england conservatory, which had a history of accepting black students. she initially made a living by teaching and by composing parlor songs and other short popular pieces. but in her forties, having escaped an abusive marriage, she broadened her ambitions and turned to symphonic composition. she won some high profile performances but found herself isolated. her bonds with black communities weakened; the white world treated her as an interesting oddity. the resistance that she faced as a female composer made her progress all the more arduous. nevertheless, she stuck to her path, and her third symphony, which premièred in 1940, is increasingly recognized as a landmark in american music. variously majestic, sinuous, brooding, and playful, it gestures toward african american spirituals and dance styles yet seems to enclose them in quotation marks, as if to acknowledge their ambiguous status in a white marketplace. brown analyzes price’s work in terms of “double consciousness” du bois’s concept of the “warring ideals” inherent in black and american identities and then enlarges that tension to include black traditions and european forms. brown writes, “a transformation of these forms takes place when the dominant elements in a composition transcend european influence.” the tradition will not survive without such moments of disruption and transcendence. classical music institutions have just begun to work through the racist past. scores of opera houses, orchestras, chamber music societies, and early music ensembles have declared solidarity with black lives matter, in sometimes awkward prose. because of covid 19, most performance schedules that had been announced for the 2020 21 season have been jettisoned, and the drastically reduced programs that have emerged in their place contain a noticeable uptick in black names. when the virus hit, we were in the midst of the so called beethoven year a gratuitously excessive celebration of the two hundred and fiftieth birthday of a composer who hardly needs any extra publicity. it remains to be seen whether this modest shift toward black composers will endure beyond the chaotic year 2020. in the same vein, mainstream organizations are giving more attention to a black classical repertory: the elegantly virtuosic eighteenth century scores of joseph bologne; the folkloric symphonies of price, still, and dawson; the african inflected operas of harry lawrence freeman and shirley graham du bois. yet such activity goes only so far in challenging an obsessive worship of the past. these works remain largely within the boundaries of the western european tradition: if schenker could have overcome his biases, he would have had an easy time analyzing price’s music according to his method. furthermore, this programming leaves intact the assumption that musical greatness resides in a bygone golden age. white europeans remain in the majority, with beethoven retaining pride of place in the lightly renovated, diversified pantheon. classical music can overcome the shadows of its past only if it commits itself more strongly to the present. black composers of the late twentieth and early twenty first centuries have staged a much more radical confrontation with the white european inheritance. a pivotal figure is julius eastman, who died in near total obscurity, in 1990, but has found cult fame in recent years. eastman’s improvisatory structures, his subversive political themes, and his openness about his homosexuality give him a revolutionary aspect, yet he also had a nostalgic flair for the grand romantic manner; his 1979 piece “gay guerrilla,” for two pianos, makes overpowering use of the lutheran hymn “a mighty fortress is our god.” with a vibrant roster of younger talents moving to the fore tyshawn sorey, jessie montgomery, nathalie joachim, courtney bryan, tomeka reid, and matana roberts, among others the perennial solitude of the black composer seems less marked than before. still, black faces remain rare in the rank and file of orchestras, in administrative offices, and, most conspicuously, in audiences. price once described how strange it was to see an all white crowd vigorously applauding her black influenced music. that experience remains all too common. a deeper reckoning would require wholesale changes in how orchestras canvass talent, conservatories recruit students, institutions hire executives, and marketers approach audiences. a black singer like morris robinson should not have to live in a world where as he recently reported at an online panel discussion he has never worked with a black conductor, stage director, or chief executive at an american opera house. at the same time, institutions must recognize that the black white divide is not the only line of tension in the social fabric. asian musicians have often complained that blanket descriptions of classical music as an all white field efface their existence. they are well represented in the ranks of orchestras, but they have little voice in the upper echelons, and routinely encounter the racism of disdain. at bottom, the entire music education system rests upon the schenkerian assumption that the western tonality, with its major minor harmony and its equal tempered scale, is the master language. vast tracts of the world’s music, from west african talking drums to indonesian gamelan, fall outside that system, and african american traditions have played in its interstices. this is a reality that the music department at harvard, once stiflingly conservative, has recognized. the jazz based artist vijay iyer now leads a cross disciplinary graduate program that cultivates the rich terrain between composition and improvisation. the harvard musicologist anne shreffler has said of the new undergraduate music curriculum, “we relied on students showing up on our doorstep having had piano lessons since the age of six.” given the systemic inequality into which many people of color are born, this “class based implicit requirement,” as shreffler calls it, becomes a covert form of racial exclusion. the sacralized canon will evolve as the musical world evolves around it. because of the peculiarly invasive nature of sound, old scores always seem to be happening to us anew. a painting gazes at us unchanging from its frame; a book speaks to us in its fixed language. but when modern people play a beethoven quartet it, too, becomes modern, even if certain of its listeners wish to go backward in time. the act of performance has enormous transformative potential an aspect that musicologists, so accustomed to analyzing notation on a page, have yet to address in full. naomi andré, in her 2018 book, “black opera: history, power, engagement,” evokes the dimensions of meaning that opened up when leontyne price sang the title role of “aida” in the nineteen sixties and seventies. of the passage “o patria . . . quanto mi costi!” “oh, my country . . . how much you have cost me!” andré writes, “the drama onstage and the reality offstage crash together. . . . this voice comes out of a body that lived through the end of jim crow and segregation.” the music of a white european had become part of black experience become, to a degree, black itself. jean jacques nattiez, the musicologist and semiotician, has described two dominant ways in which we construct musical meaning: the “poietic,” which reads a score in light of its creator’s intentions, methods, and cultural context; and the “esthesic,” which takes into account the perceptions of an audience. we live in a determinedly poietic age: we give great stress to what artists do and say, particularly when they stray from contemporary moral norms. that project of demystification is often useful, given the rampant idealization and idolatry of prior eras. but listeners need not be captive to the surface meaning of the scores, or to the biographies of their creators, or to the histories that accompany them. we can yoke the music to our own ends, as w. e. b. du bois did when he improbably reinvented wagner as a model for a mythic black art. the poietic and the esthesic should have equal weight when we pick up the pieces of the past. on the one hand, we can be aware that handel invested in the business of slavery; on the other, we can see a measure of justice when morris robinson sings his music in concert. we can be conscious of the racism of mozart’s portrayal of monostatos in “the magic flute,” or of the misogyny of “così fan tutte,” yet contemporary stagings can put mozart’s stereotypes in a radical new light. there is no need to reach a final verdict to judge each artist innocent or guilty. living with history means living with history’s complexities, contradictions, and failings. the ultimate mistake is to look to music or to any art form as a zone of moral improvement, a refuge of sweetness and light. attempts to cleanse the canon of disreputable figures end up replicating the great man theory in a negative register, with arch villains taking the place of geniuses. because all art is the product of our grandiose, predatory species, it reveals the worst in our natures as well as the best. like every beautiful thing we have created, music can become a weapon of division and destruction. the philosopher theodor w. adorno, in a characteristically pitiless mood, wrote, “every work of art is an uncommitted crime.” ♦ sections more © 2025 condé nast. all rights reserved. the new yorker may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our affiliate partnerships with retailers. the material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of condé nast. ad choices

succumbing to specious charges of racism, america’s orchestras, opera companies, and conductors are abandoning the western canon. editor’s note: this story is part of city journal’s summer 2021 print issue and is being published online in two installments. read part 2 here. classical music is under racial attack. orchestras and opera companies are said to discriminate against black musicians and composers. the canonical repertoire the product of a centuries long tradition of musical expression is allegedly a function of white supremacy. not one leader in the field has defended western art music against these charges. their silence is emblematic. other supposed guardians of western civilization, whether museum directors, humanities professors, or scientists, have gone awol in the face of similar claims, lest they themselves be denounced as racist. the campaign against classical music is worth examining in some detail, for it reveals the logic that has been turned against nearly every aspect of western culture over the last year. the crusade began within days of the death of george floyd in late may 2020. floyd died during an arrest in minneapolis; cell phone video captured officer derek chauvin (since convicted of murder) keeping his knee on the prone floyd’s neck and back for nearly eight minutes, while floyd repeated “i can’t breathe.” riots against police brutality broke out across the u.s.; institution after institution pledged to fight the structural racism that floyd’s death supposedly represented. the classical music profession deemed itself implicated in floyd’s death. on june 1, 2020, the league of american orchestras issued a statement confessing that, for decades, it had “tolerated and perpetuated systemic discrimination against black people, discrimination mirrored in the practices of orchestras and throughout our country.” the league was “committed to dismantling” its “role in perpetuating the systems of inequity that continue to oppress black people” and expected its member orchestras to respond in kind. that response was immediate. the hartford symphony orchestra apologized for its “history of inaction to effectively confront the racist systems and structures that have long oppressed and marginalized black musicians, composers, and communities.” the seattle opera announced that it would “continue to prioritize” antiracism and “make amends” for causing harm. opera omaha sent a message to its “black community”: “we know that you are exhausted and recognize we will never fully understand the depth of your suffering. we know that part of your exhaustion comes from the heartbreak of our silence, inaction, and half measures.” every communication that the opera sends out now concludes with the tagline: “we will listen more than we speak, but will not be silent in the face of injustice.” black musicians produced manifestos complaining of their mistreatment at the hands of white administrators and conductors. weston sprott, a trombonist with the metropolitan opera orchestra, along with three musicians from three other ensembles, declared in the new york times that the reason there are not “more black artists in orchestras” is “racism.” six black opera singers made a youtube video about opera racism at the invitation of the los angeles opera. l.a. opera’s president, christopher koelsch, introduced the discussion. “i come to you today as the white male leader of this institution,” he said, staring dazedly at the camera. l.a. opera was committing “anew to self examination and . . . to do our part to heal wounds that are hundreds of years old.” most of the discussion centered on floyd’s death, but tenor russell thomas also told of being rebuked for routinely showing up late and for talking on his cell phone during rehearsals for an unnamed opera. “they were putting me in my place,” thomas said, though his behavior was the result of his uncle dying in a car accident, he maintained. only a black singer would be denied “a basic amount of consideration.” professional disappointments were likewise chalked up to racism. soprano lauren michelle claimed that the reason she has not had a more prominent career in the united states was that she was black. “the truth is i am an award winning international opera singer who has only been hired once at an a house in the united states,” she wrote on her blog. michelle did not address why her contemporaries, such as angel blue, pretty yende, eric owens, and lawrence brownlee, have sung in “a houses.” music conservatories admitted their racial backwardness. the juilliard school’s president, damian woetzel, and juilliard’s director of equity, diversity, inclusion, and belonging initiatives pledged that the school would become a “community that not only rejects racism, but that is actively anti racist, working to tear down systemic racism and injustice.” as part of that “work,” the school created a blacks only zoom “space for healing.” juilliard’s head of music theory wrote his colleagues that “it’s high time the whiteness of music theory is examined, critiqued and remedied.” the classical music press, presiding over an art form whose salience shrinks by the year, produced a torrent of commentary explaining to readers why they should view classical music as culpably white. in september 2020, new yorker critic alex ross apologized for being a “white american,” writing about a world that is “blindingly white, both in its history and its present.” the love of classical music on the part of nineteenth century american patrons and performers was a smoke screen for white supremacy, ross suggested. for good measure, he invoked a standard from the student gripe portfolio to buttress his argument for classical music racism: mozart’s portrayal of the moor monostatos in the magic flute. the lead reviewer for the new york times, anthony tommasini, urged that orchestra auditions no longer take place behind a screen, in order to address the “appalling racial imbalance” in orchestral ranks. currently, musicians’ identities are concealed by a screen through most, if not all, stages of an orchestral audition to prevent favoritism or bias (a process known as a “blind audition”). but colorblindness is now regarded as discriminatory, since it favors merit over race. fellow times critic joshua barone called for reforming “opera’s culture” by placing “anti racism front and center.” a washington post critic alleged that systemic racism “runs like rot through the structures of the classical music world.” vox explained that beethoven’s fifth symphony was a symbol of white male “superiority and importance.” bbc magazine columnist tom service also purported to deconstruct the alleged greatness of the canonical repertoire: “the link between patriarchal power in the west and the fact that the classical canon is made of lookalike faces of great men is more than coincidental.” slate complained that referring to well known composers only by their last names exacerbates classical music’s exclusionary practices. the louisville orchestra, for example, had advertised the performance of a beethoven symphony and the debut of a composition memorializing breonna taylor by “davóne tines” and “igee dieudonné.” to assume that davóne tines and igee dieudonné need to be “full named,” whereas beethoven does not, replicates classical music’s “centuries of systematic prejudice, exclusion, sexism, and racism,” according to slate. (note to readers: if you have not heard of tines and dieudonné, you are not alone.) classical music radio announcers and executives instructed their audience to hear inequity in the cascade of human feeling coming from their speakers. garrett mcqueen, then an announcer for american public media, told a composers forum roundtable in june 2020: “you are complicit in racism every time you listen to handel’s messiah.” (handel held stock in a slave trading company.) academia, the source of today’s race obsession, weighed in with gusto. the music library association decried its complicity in the “marginalization and extrajudicial killing of people of color, particularly black and indigenous individuals.” a music theory professor from hunter college, philip ewell, received widespread acclaim for his denunciations of classical music racism. ewell has whiteness on the brain. during the floyd riots, ewell compiled a glossary of music related euphemisms for whiteness: “authentic, canonic, civilized, classic(s), conventional, core (‘core’ requirement), european, function (‘functional’ tonality), fundamental, genius, german (‘german’ language requirement), great (‘great’ works), maestro, opus (magnum ‘opus’), piano (‘piano’ proficiency, skills), seminal, sophisticated, titan(ic), towering, traditional, and western.” since everything is about race, according to ewell, any time you seem not to be talking about race referring to someone’s piano skills, say you are actually talking about race by dint of ignoring the topic. (connoisseurs of deconstruction will recognize the rhetorical technique here of turning an “absence” into a supposed “presence.”) “according to ewell, any time you seem not to be talking about race, you are talking about race by dint of ignoring it.” ewell also engaged in the mandatory beethoven takedown. the only reason we deem the ninth symphony a masterpiece is beethoven’s whiteness and maleness, he wrote on his blog. beethoven’s ninth symphony is “no more a masterwork than esperanza spalding’s 12 little spells,” ewell insisted. spalding is a jazz singer; twelve little spells is an album of experimental jazz numbers about 16 body parts and functions. the texts (“our eyeballs are hollow but presently hold shape/ around a gooey filling”) are not the equivalent of schiller’s “ode to joy.” to place spalding’s slight compositions at the same level of complexity, emotional force, and historical significance as the ninth symphony is objectively ludicrous. ewell backed up his aesthetic relativism with an attempted logical refutation of beethoven’s greatness: “to state that beethoven was any more than, say, above average as a composer is to state that you know all music written on planet earth 200 years ago when beethoven was active as a composer, which no one does.” judgments of greatness imply no such encyclopedic knowledge, however. we may deem a meal great, for example, without implying that we have eaten every other meal available on the planet at that moment. ewell’s whiteness obsession is standard in music departments now. what catapulted him to iconic status was his denunciation of the early twentieth century music theorist heinrich schenker. schenker developed an influential system of analysis that identifies the most important elements of a musical phrase in order to explain the phrase’s emotional impact and its role within a work’s thematic development. in a keynote address at a november 2019 music theory conference, ewell argued that schenker’s ranking of notes and harmonies within a composition is merely a stand in for a white supremacist ranking of the races. the “white racial frame” of schenkerian analysis has kept blacks from becoming music theorists, ewell maintained. ewell’s speech was ecstatically received. alex ross’s september 2020 article on racism and classical music amplified ewell’s “white racial frame” thesis further. and when a few music theorists dissented from that thesis, ewell became a symbol of the field’s oppressive whiteness, as will be discussed below. with such near unanimity regarding classical music’s racial sins, it is no wonder that the demands issued to compensate for those sins have been breathtaking in ambition. those coming from the influential sphinx organization were typical. sphinx has been advocating for race consciousness in classical music since 1997. it holds separate competitions for young black and hispanic musicians, supports minority only ensembles, and provides color coded training and financial assistance. since the floyd riots, it has been churning out a series of diversity demands more extensive than any it had previously proposed. its first set of demands opened with a call for orchestras, opera companies, and conservatories to “examine the supremacist logic embedded in traditional western art and music/repertoire.” after impugning the western music tradition, sphinx then laid down racial quotas for that allegedly white supremacist activity: at least 20 percent of soloists each concert season should be black and latinx; 40 percent of candidates for auditions and administrative jobs should be black and latinx; and 20 percent of the repertoire performed each season should be “reflective [sic] of black and latinx composers.” at least 10 percent of every musical budget should be spent compensating for past racial inequities in programming (what such compensation might mean was not explained). sphinx’s next set of demands was published in the new york times in september 2020. the numbers had changed, suggesting a certain arbitrariness in how they were computed. sphinx president afa dworkin, writing with anthony mcgill, principal clarinet of the new york philharmonic, now insisted that 15 percent of a music organization’s budget (up from the previous 10 percent) should go toward “addressing systemic racism” (what that meant was again left unspecified). this 15 percent reallocation should continue for the next decade. the diversity component in every audition was down to 25 percent from 40 percent, but if an orchestra or conservatory did not rustle up the requisite diversity quotient, it could not select a winning candidate, no matter how qualified the finalist. in january 2021, sphinx issued more audition guidelines. traditionally, if a musician is of a known high caliber, having played with another prestigious orchestra, say, he may skip the early stages of an audition and go right to the semifinals or finals (which may still be blind). sphinx now proposed that those automatic advancements include a whopping 25 percent or more of “black and brown” musicians. this is mathematically impossible, and sphinx should know it, since it has been decrying the low numbers of minorities in orchestras for two decades. blacks make up 1.8 percent of all orchestral musicians, which includes noncompetitive community ensembles. the larger and more competitive the orchestra, the fewer blacks it has. filling at least 25 percent of all automatic advancement slots with minorities from top ranked orchestras is not doable, even assuming that there were so many automatic advancements in each audition to be able to set aside 25 percent of them for any type of quota. sphinx’s january audition guidelines suggested selecting musicians on nonmusical grounds, as anthony tommasini had recommended. orchestras should hire diversity consultants to develop “extra musical evaluation” criteria for orchestral positions, such as serving as an institutional spokesman. board members also found themselves in the crosshairs for being too white, with the added infraction of being too rich. simon woods, head of the league of american orchestras, apologized for his whiteness during a discussion at the peabody institute in february 2021, and then lamented that non diverse board members were given power to help define the “vision” of orchestras. anyone in the classical music business today should be down on his knees in gratitude that there remain wealthy donors who want to contribute to the “vision” of orchestras. supporting social and racial justice organizations confers a thousand times more prestige, as the stampede of new york’s wealthiest to the galas of the antipoverty robin hood foundation demonstrates. but the pressure is now enormous to find “diverse” board members, no matter their connection to music or their ability or willingness to help finance struggling ensembles. few cultures, however, have embraced philanthropy as vigorously as the anglo american one. even in the best of financial circumstances, the racial demands would have been startling in their scope. but at a time when every classical music budget has been blown apart by the coronavirus lockdowns, such ambition requires considerable confidence in one’s bargaining power. the bet paid off. orchestras and opera companies rushed to adopt racial hiring benchmarks and to take on costly new diversity bureaucracy. long before 2020, the metropolitan opera had been running in the red. the coronavirus blackout put it on the ropes, eliminating $150 million in earned revenues. in december 2020, metropolitan general manager peter gelb told his employees that financial cutbacks were a life and death matter: “what we’re trying to do is keep the met alive, and the only way to achieve that is to reduce our costs.” in a letter to the stagehands’ union, gelb wrote: “the health crisis has compounded the met’s previous financial fragility, threatening our very existence.” in february 2021, met musicians were nearly a year without pay, and the stagehands’ union was locked out of the house. yet that month, the met’s first chief diversity officer started work. the new position was necessary in order to ensure that the met is an “organization that is adamantly opposed to racism,” as a met spokesman put it in an e mail. otherwise, there would apparently be some suspicion that the met, populated by immaculately progressive staff in the most liberal big city in the country, might favor racism. the met’s new chief diversity officer, marcia sells, had been the dean of students at the nation’s highest paying law school harvard. her six figure harvard salary doubtless will have been increased to cover the move to new york. sells would likely also have been promised her own staff. sells has no background in music, much less opera. yet she is now entrusted with creating “artistic pathways” at the met for “people of color,” according to a press release. presumably, the met would have compiled a firm empirical basis for this new financial commitment, given the sacrifices that it is asking its existing employees to make. has the met in recent years failed to hire the most qualified musician because of his skin color or otherwise denied opportunities to minorities? i asked the spokesman. the query was ignored. in march 2020, the musicians of the philadelphia orchestra agreed to a 20 percent pay cut in the hope of reducing an estimated $15 million deficit by year end. that projection was arrived at before anyone imagined that philadelphia’s kimmel center would remain dark for the next 12 months. yet in october 2020, the orchestra created a new vice presidency position for inclusion, diversity, equity, and access. “diversity is excellence,” explained philadelphia orchestra president and ceo matías tarnopolsky in announcing the new title. philadelphia’s vice president of inclusion, diversity, equity, and access, doris parent, also has no musical background. her two bachelor’s degrees are in psychology and family studies; her master’s degree in business administration is from the university of phoenix. she will nevertheless be “shaping” the orchestra’s future, according to tarnopolsky. the cincinnati symphony orchestra has announced its first chief diversity and inclusion officer but has not yet hired someone for the role. it is sending its musicians, board, and staff to diversity training. ideally, the orchestra would be “reflective of cincinnati” i.e., 40 percent black executive director jonathan martin has said. for now, short of that ideal, it is putting a black composer on every live streamed performance this season. the juilliard school recently announced a pandemic related tuition increase, prompting student protest. perhaps the school should have held off on bulking up its diversity bureaucracy instead. it has hired a new equity, diversity, inclusion, and belonging program manager, to supplement its existing director for edib initiatives. its new bias response deputies are steeped in “trauma informed practices” so that they can understand how juilliard’s systemic bias “manifests” and how to mitigate it. faculty are being trained to recognize their racial biases. all aspects of the school will now be examined “through the lens of inclusion,” juilliard’s provost announced in september 2020. in light of such changes, the evidence for current discrimination in the classical music field must be overwhelming. in fact, it does not exist. the primary fact adduced to prove systemic bias is the underrepresentation of black orchestral musicians. blacks’ 1.8 percent representation among the nation’s orchestral musicians is up slightly from 1991, when they were about 1.6 percent of orchestra members. meantime, the proportion of asians rose nearly threefold from the early 1990s to 2014, from 3.4 percent to over 9 percent (and more in some top orchestras), though asians, too, are nonwhite in an allegedly white supremacist field. when asians began their conquest of western classical music in the second half of the twentieth century, there were fewer asian instrumentalists and composers to serve as ethnic role models than there were black instrumentalists and composers to serve as role models for blacks. the official explanation for that steady underrepresentation of blacks in orchestral ranks is racism. suggesting that there aren’t enough competitively qualified blacks in the audition pipeline is taboo. anthony tommasini briefly considered that supply side explanation before calling for the deblinding of auditions. but he gave the last word to sphinx president dworkin, who insisted, in tommasini’s words, that the “pipeline is not the problem, and that talented musicians of color are out there and ready.” conductors and members of audition committees disagree. leonard slatkin has served as music director in detroit, st. louis, washington, d.c., new orleans, london, and lyon, and has served as principal guest conductor in pittsburgh, los angeles, minneapolis, and cleveland. filling sphinx’s quotas for auditions would be “impossible” at the present time, he wrote by e mail. “there are not enough black and other minority musicians studying at music schools or conservatories, let alone in the audition pool.” by one estimate, the combined black and hispanic student population at conservatories ranges from 5 percent to 8 percent, but that estimate represents students in all arts programs at a school, which may include theater and dance. at juilliard, blacks make up 8 percent of the total student body in music, drama, and dance. the drama division is nearly 50 percent black. asians make up 28 percent of the total student body. the school would not provide the breakdown for the music division alone. at the national symphony orchestra in washington, black audition entrants are rare, though there is no minimum experience requirement, says someone who oversees the process. even if the screen were removed, there are very few black musicians to hire. proponents of the racism narrative never explain why conductors, perfectionist by nature, would turn down the most qualified musician in favor of someone more likely to maul an exposed solo, just because that inferior musician was white. in fact, conductors want “the best possible player for the best possible concert because you will be blamed otherwise,” says a former music festival leader. “i’ve never observed someone not getting the job because he was black.” zubin mehta conducted the los angeles philharmonic from 1962 to 1978 and then went on to direct the new york philharmonic for another 13 years. there was “never” any racial component to auditions, mehta said in a phone interview. nor have boards discouraged the hiring of black musicians, as is alleged. “no one ever told me you can’t engage someone because he’s black,” mehta says. dorothy chandler, for decades los angeles’s premier arts philanthropist, welcomed mehta’s hiring of henry lewis as assistant conductor in 1961. pianist emanuel ax replied: “of course not!” when asked if he had seen racism in the field, though he added that he would have “no idea about auditions.” no black pianist has asked ax to teach him (which is how ax gets students), though he would welcome such a request. violinist joseph striplin played with the detroit symphony orchestra, the st. louis symphony orchestra, and the metropolitan opera’s touring orchestra. when the grosse pointe symphony orchestra’s conductor fell ill, striplin was asked to fill in. he now leads that orchestra. there was discrimination in the past, but it’s not the 1940s anymore, striplin says: “orchestras would be more than happy to have more blacks.” both of john mclaughlin williams’s parents were pianists who passed on to him their love of classical music. his father’s hopes for a musical career were dashed by mid century racial attitudes. but the classical music industry is “not racist now, by any means,” says williams, a conductor, violinist, and pianist. williams has never witnessed someone not getting a job because of the color of his skin. but after hundreds of years of discrimination, blacks assume and understandably so, williams says that if they are not picked for something, it is because of their race. in july 2020, in the new york times, bassoonist monica ellis accused the orchestral profession of protecting a “white framework built to benefit white people.” to the contrary, the field has been obsessed with diversity for decades. since the early 1970s, fellowship programs for black and hispanic musicians have poured forth, including from the new york philharmonic, the houston symphony orchestra, the chicago symphony orchestra, and the pittsburgh symphony orchestra. typically, these programs allow the grantees to play with the orchestra, train them for auditions, and give them priority in tryouts. at present, more than a dozen of the country’s top orchestras provide fellowships for black players, according to the pittsburgh post gazette, while many others give stipends to minority musicians as audition support. orchestras have also sent their musicians into public schools in the hope of creating more minority players. music schools have encouraged black enrollment, though they now lambaste themselves as exclusionary. in 1986, juilliard established the aaron diamond foundation fellowships for minority students, endowed with millions of dollars. rather than requiring minority students to come to new york to audition for entrance to the school, juilliard set up regional auditions across the country. minority applications rose fivefold, but minority admissions stayed low, since most applicants were not qualified. the school needed to start earlier in the process, then juilliard president joseph polisi told funder irene diamond. so the conservatory brought local black and hispanic elementary school students to the new york campus for individual tutoring and group lessons. the school provided each student with an instrument to play at home and one to play at school. it reached out to parents in the hope of involving them in their child’s music education. today, the music advancement program serves about 100 students a year. so prized have been black students and musicians that they are treated with kid gloves. violinist earl carlyss was a member of the juilliard quartet for 20 years and a teacher for even longer. in the 1960s, carlyss helped determine whether students at the peabody institute in baltimore would continue into their next year of study. one violinist played so poorly that carlyss mentioned him to the dean. “we know,” came the answer, “but no one has had the nerve to boink him.” at michigan state university, carlyss tried to correct a student’s sloppy playing. two weeks later, nothing had changed. have you practiced? carlyss asked. “i don’t have to,” the student responded. “i’ll always have a job.” prejudice tragically limited black musical opportunity in the first half of the twentieth century. but even in that cruel period, some black musicians were recognized and elevated, complicating the monolithic story of oppression that the classical music profession is now telling about itself. these musicians included bassist charles burrell, cellist donald white, and double bassist henry lewis who became music director of the new jersey symphony orchestra in 1968 and eventually conducted nearly every other major american orchestra, sometimes accompanying his then wife, mezzo soprano marilyn horne. more recently, the late conductor james depreist was mentored by leonard bernstein. michael morgan, conductor of the oakland symphony, received a tanglewood fellowship at 19, the youngest such recipient. morgan became leonard slatkin’s assistant at the st. louis symphony at 23. starting in 1986, he worked for seven years as assistant conductor at the chicago symphony orchestra under sir georg solti and daniel barenboim. since at least the 1970s, performing ensembles have sought new works from black composers. george walker’s numerous commissions came from the new york philharmonic, the cleveland orchestra, the kennedy center for the performing arts, and the new jersey symphony orchestra, among other groups. walker’s lilacs for voice and orchestra, commissioned by the boston symphony orchestra in honor of a black tenor, won the pulitzer prize for music in 1996. walker received fellowships from the fulbright, whitney, guggenheim, rockefeller, koussevitzky, and macdowell foundations. and yet we are to believe that music ensembles, having commissioned pieces from black composers, then turned around and suppressed those same composers out of racial bias. if few contemporary, black composed works entered the regular repertoire, the reason is the same as that affecting new works by white composers: audiences continue to reject post tonal idioms, no matter how many honors the academy confers on their practitioners. today, black musicians are welcomed with open arms. one musician with a major orchestra marvels at the oppositional stance taken by some of his fellows, such as clarinetist anthony mcgill and his brother, flutist demarre mcgill. “the business has handed these guys opportunity after opportunity. to turn around and say: ‘it’s a racist industry!’ i want to shake them. they should be ambassadors!” another leading player notes that the mcgills “aren’t the exception; they are the rule. people fall over black students to give them every opportunity to have a shot. i did it, too. since 1990, at least, black privilege has been in effect in classical music.” opera singers such as pretty yende, angel blue, and julia bullock, all enormously talented in their own right have enjoyed an extra boost to their careers from being black, according to a former opera executive. if, before 2020, being black was an asset in a field already agonizing about diversity, going forward, it will provide jet propulsion. commissions are pouring in to black composers, and many orchestras are putting a black authored work on every program. expect a rash of new black lives matter themed works, such as carlos simon’s “an elegy: a cry from the grave,” dedicated to trayvon martin, eric garner, michael brown, and others “murdered wrongfully by an oppressive power,” and jonathan woody’s “nigra sum sed formosa i am black but beautiful (a fantasia on microaggressions),” a madrigal sung to microaggressive comments that black singers have allegedly been subjected to, such as “i bet you sing spirituals very well” and “when you stood up, i was shocked, you should play in the nfl.” black musicians are highly sought after for consultancy jobs and newly created fellowships. small performing ensembles seeking philanthropic support to stay alive during the pandemic are now grilled on their racial makeup. if their musicians, staff, or board are too white, they can forget about a grant. many are going under. even early music ensembles, a rarefied subspecialty of music, are feeling the post floyd heat. the continuo foundation now conditions its grants to early music groups based on their programming of works by “women and people of color” and on the “diversity” of their performers and administrators. but there were virtually no black composers in medieval and renaissance europe, since the continent was overwhelmingly caucasian. female composers were rare (thus the eternal fuss over hildegard von bingen). as for performers, blacks have only recently started going into the early music field. there are not enough of them now to seed every period instrument group that desperately needs financial support i.e., every period instrument group. “two key sources for classical music exposure circumambient culture and music education have dried up.” conservatories are creating separate programs for blacks. the manhattan school of music announced in october 2020 a new artist scholars program, peopled exclusively by black “performers, educators, activists, directors, choreographers, and administrators.” in november, one of its artist scholars gave a zoom lecture on the american minstrel tradition; it was incoherent. the artist scholar congratulated himself repeatedly on his “very brechtian theatrical technique,” which consisted of superimposing the original lyrics of “ol’ man river” onto paul robeson’s cinematic performance of the song. this intervention was a major theatrical coup of “brechtian weillian irony and dissonance,” according to its author. the school’s provost thanked the artist scholar afterward for his “spectacular presentation.” if institutional support and encouragement of black musicians have been unequivocal for decades, why has their percentage in orchestras barely budged? because over the last 60 years, two of the three main sources for exposing a child to classical music circumambient culture and music education have dried up. violinist joseph striplin had a “classic inner city mother,” he says, but he had the good fortune to come of age in the 1940s and 1950s, when “music was vibrant in the country and at school.” classical music themes were ubiquitous on television shows and in the movies. every junior high and high school in detroit had its own orchestra; students were taken to the detroit symphony orchestra young people’s concerts at the masonic temple and the ford auditorium. “we heard and we saw; the orchestra was massive to my young eyes,” he says. striplin attended the prestigious cass technical high school and played in its orchestra with students who had had lessons since they were young. “i loved this music and knew i needed to find out how to play like that,” he says. since then, music education has been decimated, and classical music has disappeared from the public sphere. from 1962 to 1989, the percentage of high schools with orchestras fell from 67 percent to 17 percent, according to billboard. seventy seven percent of schools polled in a university of illinois study dropped piano instruction; 40 percent dropped string instruction. if a child’s home is not exposing him to classical music, he is likely not being exposed at all. today, blacks are not being pushed out of classical music; they are not being pushed in by their families at a rate necessary to compete. “unless you start the violin at age seven, you won’t be auditioning for the new york philharmonic when you’re 25,” says emanuel ax. and it is overwhelmingly asian families who insist on such early discipline, placing the same emphasis on mastering an instrument (or two) as was once found in jewish homes. parents sacrifice for private lessons; the household stays quiet when a child is practicing. without home transmission, the best hope for creating more black classical musicians is to restore widespread music education. the antiracism advocates have said little about that imperative, however. it’s easier to extract racial quotas from compliant organizations than it is to engineer a change as profound as exposing students to a vanishing musical aesthetic. packing off every opera and orchestra administrator to implicit bias training will not produce a single competitively qualified black musician. nor will potential students be inclined to pick up the violin after learning that its repertoire belongs to a white supremacist tradition. but more power is to be gained by pushing the racism line than by pursuing the unlikely rebirth of public school music training. so the search has been on to find racial scapegoats. heather mac donald is the thomas w. smith fellow at the manhattan institute, a contributing editor of city journal, and the author of the best selling diversity delusion: how race and gender pandering corrupt the university and undermine our culture. top photo: liangpv/istock city journal is a publication of the manhattan institute for policy research (mi), a leading free market think tank. are you interested in supporting the magazine? as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, donations in support of mi and city journal are fully tax deductible as provided by law (ein #13 2912529).           copyright © 2024 manhattan institute for policy research, inc. all rights reserved. copyright © 2024 manhattan institute for policy research, inc. all rights reserved. ein #13 2912529

international journal of anthropology and ethnology volume 8, article number: 20 (2024) cite this article 769 accesses metrics details this article proposes viewing classical music in north america as a “living heritage art form” that acknowledges the deep foundational roots of classical music, similar to how all forms of world heritage are constructed while recognizing that classical music can remain relevant within a modern cultural context. in doing so, it examines the challenges threatening the genre’s survival and proposes strategies for overcoming these obstacles. additionally, it highlights the opportunities presented by modern technologies to support ongoing composition, performance, and public engagement, ensuring the continued appreciation and evolution of classical music in the modern era. in her chapter entitled “is classical music a living or heritage art form?” (italicized by the author), eastburn (2018) brings to the forefront a crucial issue about the future of classical music. at the heart of this discussion is the fraught debate concerning the claim of “the death of classical music.” the debate between norman lebrecht and alex ross illustrates this contentious topic: lebrecht, known for his controversial views in the classical music world, wrote a figurative obituary for the genre (lebrecht 2007). ross, in contrast, offers a counterargument by looking at the increase in new releases and sales data from the 1990s to the 2000s, consequently leading to his claim that “classical recording is bigger than ever” (ross 2007). revisiting eastburn’s investigation into whether classical music is a living or heritage art form necessitates a reevaluation of the rigid, disparate categories into which cultural inheritances are forced to fit. eastburn’s framing of the question introduces a dualistic scheme that confines classical music to a static period in the past, neglecting its dynamic, evolving nature and overlooking its potential for adaptation and innovation. the united nations educational, scientific and cultural organization (unesco) describes “living heritage” as an intangible cultural heritage that is “inherited from our ancestors and passed on to our descendants. it includes oral traditions, performing arts, social practices, rituals and festive events, knowledge and practices concerning nature and the universe, and knowledge and skills related to craftsmanship. it is continuously recreated as transmitted from generation to generation and evolves in response to our environment.”footnote 1 classical music, situated within the realm of performing arts, aligns seamlessly with this definition, particularly with the inheritance from the great works of bach, beethoven, mozart, mahler, and many others, as well as its attribute of being “continuously recreated.” the challenge and opportunity lies in how classical music can be reinterpreted and revitalized in harmony with contemporary societal and cultural contexts, thereby ensuring its preservation as a “living heritage.” in her paper “exploring living heritage conservation,” adriana trujillo refines the definition of “living heritage” as “cultural practices, traditions, and values that continue to have meaning for generations of people as individuals and communities” (2019). she quotes kimball et al. (2013) to emphasize that living heritage is meant to be altered and added to so that its protection is not just about holding onto the past as the “golden days” and trying to preserve as much of the past as possible but should also be viewed through a transformative approach that ensures its meaningful continuity. this perspective helps us understand the importance of the “continuous recreation” of classical music, such that the protection of classical music as a living heritage is not limited to the preservation of works by great composers from hundreds of years ago; it is equally important to encourage the continual composition of new classical music for the contemporary era. therefore, the ongoing performance of canonical classical compositions and the continual creation and presentation of new works within the genre are crucial for maintaining classical music as a vibrant, living heritage. it moves us beyond mere preservation or honoring historical performance and leads musicians to the domain of composing in homage to classical music’s historical figures while also transforming the genre. continuous re creation also acknowledges the central role of new music in classical music’s ecosystem, ensuring that classical music remains relevant to contemporary listeners and acknowledging culturally relevant themes, narratives, and technological advances. ellen t. harris and michael beckerman argue that “the intrinsic value of classical music lies rather in its continual reimagining” (2021). however, what exactly is the “intrinsic value” of classical music? what is the value of something that no longer commands widespread attention? although some may hold firm that classical music is essentially “better” than pop music (young 2016), i prefer to address these questions in a different direction. to begin with, it is vital to recognize the intrinsic value of diversity, not only in biodiversity and sociodiversity but also, by extension, in art and music diversity. baum and owe conclude that “[b]iodiversity and sociodiversity get almost all the attention, but perhaps there is a case for attention to other types of diversity as well” (2024). accordingly, the flourishing of a particular music genre enhances the appreciation and enjoyment of other genres. for instance, debussy’s compositions were enriched by japanese and chinese music, just as some of the beatles’ music integrated traditional indian music, subsequently influencing indian pop music. without the foundation of classical music, modern pop works such as eric carmen’s all by myself, based on sergei rachmaninoff’s second piano concerto (op. 18), or little mix’s little me, which draws from gabriel fauré’s pavane (op. 50), would not exist. similarly, the soundtracks by john williams and hans zimmer frequently draw on classical music themes and techniques. the evolution of classical music in the west coincides with significant historical developments from gregorian chant and the secularization of music during the late medieval and renaissance periods to the humanism of the enlightenment and the intellectual movements of modernism, connecting with other art forms, philosophy, science, poetry, literature, and religious practices. listening to classical music connects us to the intellectual and spiritual development of humanity, offering profound emotional depth, spiritual intensity, intellectual rigor, and evocative aesthetics that are often elusive in more popular genres today. as julian johnson argues in who needs classical music, the nature of classical music as an “art” differs fundamentally from other types of music that serve primarily for entertainment or background noise (johnson 2002). thus, preserving classical music as a living heritage is of significant importance. viewing classical music as a “living heritage art form” provides a nuanced notion of bridging the gap between tradition and progress. it acknowledges the deep foundational roots of classical music within the ways that all forms of world heritage are constructed, but it also recognizes classical music as progressive and relevant within the modern cultural context. such a framework highlights the genre’s ability to preserve its core aesthetic values and historical significance while enriching the contemporary cultural landscape through innovative compositions, performance practices, and cross genre collaborations. this reconceptualization makes classical music more dynamic and permeable to heterogeneous audiences, thereby nurturing its sustainability in an ongoing process of renewal and reshaping. to sustain classical music as a living tradition, not a relic, we need to foster environments that encourage the performance of the great masterpieces of the bygone eras while simultaneously nurturing the creation of new compositions, which can be achieved by promoting the value of innovation within the classical music tradition through educational programs, supporting contemporary composers who want to challenge the conventions of the genre, and cultivating audiences who are receptive to both old and contemporary classical music. it is also essential to demystify classical music, making it more user friendly to a wider audience by integrating it into new media and accessible public settings. embracing classical music as a living heritage presents daunting challenges. from socio cultural shifts to economic and technological changes, various factors influence how classical music is perceived, consumed, and supported. the challenges confronting the field include diversity, popularization, and financial viability. this paper will examine the traditional business practice of the world of classical music in north america, including statistics on concert attendance, issues of equity and diversity, and the inclusion of north american orchestras. it will also contrast them with the practice of european and asian orchestras to examine the factors of limitation of this art form in the 21st century. this paper will explore the public image challenges of classical music in north america, especially among the younger generation, in terms of competing with other music genres, such as pop and rock, and the lack of coverage of classical music in mainstream media. another challenge to the sustainability of classical music in the west is the financial model associated with the performances in the concert halls, in addition to the costs of administration, tour, maintenance of the performance venues, salaries of musicians, and so on. the paper will further examine the dynamics between arts organizations and their patrons. it will then offer some suggestions on how classical music can remain active on the stage, not as a heritage of the past that has become lifeless like the artifacts in the museum, but as a “living heritage” that can still be engaged with a new audience and inspire them with continuous new compositions that are relevant to the contemporary societies. classical music remains a viable, relevant, and pressing genre within modern society; however, it faces a significant challenge due to prevailing public perceptions. often seen in north america and europe as a symbol of “caucasian male elitism,” classical music is frequently associated with the broader framework of western cultural hegemony. even with the introduction of “diversity initiatives” in recent years, kristina kolbe argues that such efforts can become socially commodified, ultimately reinforcing existing power structures. according to kolbe, these initiatives often perpetuate hegemonic power relations of race, ethnicity, and class by utilizing the appearance of multicultural inclusion as a means to reaffirm the dominance of “the white highbrow” culture as the primary site of cultural and social legitimacy; consequently, rather than dismantling exclusionary norms, these efforts may serve to maintain the status quo (kolbe 2021). in an era prioritizing equity, diversity, and inclusion, this stereotypical image links classical music to white supremacy, misogyny, and exclusivity. this stereotype also hints at conservatism and nostalgia, reflecting a desire to revert to the golden era of musical artistry of bygone times. consequently, classical music struggles to resonate with a diverse audience, which raises significant questions regarding the relevance of classical music in the context of the 21st century’s progressive values and easily leads to concerns that preserving the genre as a living heritage may inadvertently perpetuate notions of “caucasian male elitism.” in terms of its practice, feder and mcgill elucidate the underrepresentation of black and latinx musicians in the classical music sphere because of access barriers and structural racism (feder and mcgill, 2021). they further delineate the challenges classical music institutions face in addressing such structural racism and unconscious bias, advocating for the enhancement of opportunities for people of color in aspects such as employment, tenure achievement, and audition participation. correspondingly, michael cooper remarks that american orchestras rank among “the least racially diverse institutions” (2018). as delineated in the “racial/ethnic and gender diversity in the orchestra field in 2023: a report by the league of american orchestras,” the composition of orchestras predominantly features white musicians, constituting over 79% of the orchestra demographic. in contrast, hispanic/latinx musicians represent a mere 4.8%, black musicians 2.4%, asian musicians 11%, and american indian and alaska native people, along with native hawaiian and pacific island people, collectively account for only 0.3% (cuyler et al. 2023). this pattern of underrepresentation extends to conductors, music directors, staff members, top executives, and board members, indicating a systemic issue within the orchestral field. although gender disparity exists, balance is seen among board members and top executives. however, only 11.1% of music directors are women; the remaining 88.9% are men. while the report does not explicitly address the status of queer composers and performers, individuals within the lgbtq + community have experienced increased acceptance over the past decade. this shift has given rise to several initiatives, including the florida orchestra’s pride weekend and the queer urban orchestra in new york city (solomon 2019). in contrast to north america, orchestras in many asian countries do not confront the same challenges regarding equity, diversity, and inclusion. as a result, the issue of “caucasian male elitism” is not as pronounced in these contexts. while western classical music may still carry connotations of prestige, it is not as deeply entwined with issues of racial and class exclusivity in many asian societies. a notable example is singapore, with a population of five million people comprising 74.0% chinese, 13.5% malay, 9.0% indian, and 3.4% categorized as “others” (department of statistics singapore 2023). orchestras in singapore, such as the singapore symphony orchestra, the singapore chinese orchestra, the orkestra melayu, and the singapore indian orchestra and choir, play a dual role: they represent the nation’s “domestic and multicultural aspects at the state level, as well as inter asian solidarity against ‘western’ hegemonies encountered in the journey towards attaining” (tan 2017). in addition to being musical entities, these institutions carry social and political responsibilities, showcasing singapore’s cultural and artistic achievements on the international stage and facilitating cultural cohesion among its ethnically diverse population to promote active citizenship. the commitment to multicultural integration within these orchestras is further exemplified by their inclusive programming, which explores chinese, malay, and indian traditional folk music and pop music in addition to the standard jazz and western classical music genres. orchestras in china’s mainland tend to consist primarily of musicians of chinese descent. the situation in the hong kong philharmonic orchestra (hkphil) is quite different, complicated by the region’s british colonial history before 1997 and its lingering legacy. unlike its mainland counterpart, hkphil has a more diverse composition of musicians. it has significantly enhanced its international stature over the past two decades under the leadership of edo de waart and jaap van zweden. hkphil was named the orchestra of the year at the 2019 gramophone classical music awards for its live recordings of richard wagner’s complete ring cycle. established as a sino british chamber orchestra in 1947, hkphil is the first asian orchestra to receive this prestigious award. the orchestra’s website, however, reveals that only 55.2% of its musicians are of chinese descent, whereas 44.8% are white, predominantly in the brass section.footnote 2 this ratio starkly contrasts with hong kong’s demographic, of which only 0.8% of the total population is white as of 2021.footnote 3 in comparison, the hong kong sinfonietta, founded in 1990 by local music graduates, comprises only 10.9% white musicians. hong kong sinfonietta prides itself on “[thriving] on its strong local roots combined with an ambitious international vision,” aiming to nurture the public interest in classical music in hong kong.footnote 4 suzanne yanko, founder and chief editor of classic melbourne, who previously served as a broadcaster in hong kong for the classical music station rthk radio 4 in the early 2000s, made an interesting observation of hkphil’s 2017 tour performance in melbourne: as they filed onto the stage, the first thing i noticed was the international look of the orchestra, with the brass section in particular having gleaned (male) players from europe. perhaps i remembered things differently, but in the past, the hkpo had the look of a local ensemble, apart from the odd australian or british player. ironically, the orchestra was in australia as part of an ambitious five city international tour to celebrate the 20th anniversary of the establishment of the hong kong special administrative region. but, under the baton of jaap van zweden, the interest was, of course, in the sound, not the ethnic makeup of the group. having said that, the first item quintessence was by a chinese composer, fung lam, the first hong kong composer to be commissioned by the bbc.footnote 5 yanko suspects that the makeup of the musicians of hkphil under jaap van zweden’s direction reflects a deliberate choice, prioritizing the orchestra’s sonic profile over demographic representation, resulting in a higher proportion of white musicians than that in the early 2000s. an interview with meg sterling, principal flautist at hkphil, further reveals that “[m]any of the players of asian background are actually from america or europe; chinese american, korean american, or they have studied abroad from a young age. the official language of the orchestra is english. there is an excellent feeling in the orchestra, and everyone is friendly and gets along well.”footnote 6 according to sterling, despite the minority status of white musicians in hong kong, the orchestra embodies a western cultural orientation and maintains friendliness among its members. besides the demographic issues in north american orchestras, classical music is generally perceived as being linked to elitism and perpetuating racial, economic, and social inequalities. kolbe (2022) undertakes an ethnographic investigation of a diversity initiative in a german opera house over an extended period by using ethnographic methods and interviews. this inquiry offers a detailed understanding of how discourses of diversity are incorporated into production. by thoroughly analyzing how classical music has been compromised due to its historical role in underpinning elitist and exclusionary structures, kolbe’s study offers a compelling critique that calls for a reform of established conventions regarding the societal role of classical music. the study also examines how power dynamics related to race and ethnicity influence processes of commissioning, composition, and rehearsal, as well as the extent to which highly visible racialized differences can be challenged and reshaped. tommasini’s (2020) advice about purposely considering race and gender in auditions has sparked a broader debate about affirmative action in college admissions, an effort to enhance diversity that was recently contested before the u.s. supreme court. the court ruled in june 2023 against affirmative action admissions policies used by harvard university and the university of north carolina, finding that they violated the u.s. constitution’s equal protection clause. this decision has caused us to wonder about the legal viability of similar strategies in orchestral auditions. perhaps addressing diversity in orchestras will involve more than altering the audition process but enhancing accessibility to classical training for black and latinx individuals, such as offering scholarships or grants to support travel for auditions so that talent in these communities has the chance to be recognized and developed while keeping the blind audition process intact. such measures aim to expand the “pipeline” of musicians from underrepresented communities so that orchestral music’s diversity and inclusion will be a part of its future. the lack of racial and gender diversity in classical music has significant negative consequences. not only is this harmful to bipoc and female musicians, but it also perpetuates the perception of the classical music sector as an exclusive, white, old boys’ club. this perception conflicts with the modern values of diversity and inclusivity that society generally prioritizes. the looming representation of classical music alienates possible audience members and emerging artists who may perceive classical music as lacking the reflection of their social or cultural experiences, rendering it inaccessible. classical music is, therefore, at risk of becoming irrelevant and unappealing in a world that is becoming increasingly diversified. this challenge extends beyond moral obligations and stretches to the strategic necessity of upholding the sustainability of classical music as an art form. research indicates that similar challenges within the opera world persist, reflecting broader issues of representation and access (guachalla 2017). however, numerous asian soloists, such as yundi li, seong jin cho, haochen zhang, and yu chien tseng, have gained considerable popularity and emerged as top selling musicians in the classical recording industry. these rising stars, who have won prestigious international music competitions, demonstrate the high level of artistic achievement attained by asian musicians in a domain historically dominated by caucasian performers. their success suggests a shift in the cultural landscape, where asian musicians have proven themselves to be equally accomplished. nonetheless, some classical soloists, such as the south korean pianist kun woo paik, remain more recognized in asian markets. paik’s recordings with major labels such as decca and emi were initially restricted to regional distribution but have gained broader international accessibility owing to the increasing globalization of music through digital platforms. the marketing strategies surrounding asian classical musicians may also reveal underlying socio cultural hierarchies prevalent in western markets. numerous challenges have been said to confront the classical music industry, ranging from poorly attended concert halls in north america to the alarming report by billboard that even top selling classical recordings rarely sold over 100 copies in a week. in the pre pandemic era, melia tourangeau, the chief executive of the pittsburgh symphony orchestra, mentioned in an interview that it was a hopeless jubilation to be “happy” and “jumping up and down” to celebrate selling over 1,000 tickets in the 2,700 seat heinz hall.footnote 7 other classical music ensembles, such as the dallas symphony orchestra and st. louis symphony orchestra, mentioned on their websites that they estimated crowds of 70 75% capacity for their respective venues.footnote 8 in addition, the audience for classical music performances has predominantly been composed of older individuals, a trend observed since at least 2005. this pattern is further illustrated by instances where shopping malls, bus stations, convenience stores, and car parks have resorted to “weaponizing” classical music as a sonic deterrent to loitering youths (thompson 2017). these observations not only suggest that classical music’s appeal is rarely found among younger generations but also indicate a potential decline of the genre with the passing of this demographic. this hypothesis appears to glean empirical support from statista, which documents a decline in the proportion of adults in the u.s. attending at least one classical music event annually, from 13% in 1982 to 8.8% in 2012.footnote 9. in the face of the evident decline and obstacles confronting its industry, classical music continues to occupy a significant place in the global musical landscape. according to the 2022 bachtrack annual statistics report, 27,124 classical music performances consisting of concerts, operas, and ballets were documented in the u.s., the united kingdom, and various european countries. while down by 20% from the pre pandemic number of 34,648 events, this figure indicates a possible resurgence of the industry after a pandemic induced dipfootnote 10, suggesting that it is still precipitous to declare the “death” of classical music or to regard it as a “heritage art form.” the perpetual production of new compositions within the realm of classical music not only serves as a testament to its liveliness and pertinence but also illustrates its ability to modify itself and progress with the times. additionally, modern tendencies and preferences have caused an increase in cross genre collaborations, which allow classical music to transcend its traditional domain and infiltrate the contemporary music industry, becoming an integral part of film scores, television series soundtracks, and video game music. this evolution signifies a transformation, which indicates that while the established model of the classical music sector may be on a decline, a new paradigm is emerging. classical music lends itself to arduously redefining its scope and future by continuously involving new mediums and engaging with new genres. the emerging model is evidence of the way the genre of classical music has demonstrated adaptability and resilience in an era of profound shifts in cultural norms and consumption patterns. classical music remains a dynamic and evolving art form, contributing to the broader societal culture in diverse and expansive ways. it is essential for the classical music industry that the impending change in its media platform is being met with constant attention to questions of technology, access, and priorities of the music profession. alexandra kertz welzel’s critique interrogates how contemporary music education paradigms construct classical music and students’ personal experiences as incommensurate. she analyzes the deep seated biases that generate widespread anticlassicism, problematizing the simple narratives so often presented in education. kertz welzel’s analysis not only points to issues of equity and inclusivity within the classical music industry but also registers a more significant gulf that has opened up between classical music and contemporary youth, who so often find the traditional, aesthetic, and narratives of classical music irrelevant and unappealing (kertz welzel 2021). this gulf is made glaringly apparent by, on the one hand, the use of classical music in shopping malls to deter loitering youths and, on the other, the “sea of gray hair” that characterizes the audience at a typical classical concert in north america. the challenge of engaging with classical music is further compounded by the 21st  century lifestyle characterized by constant distractions, the expectation of multitasking, and a predilection for the short duration content epitomized by internet platforms like tiktok. the policy institute and the centre for attention studies (2022) highlight a reduction in the attention span of younger generations, which makes the prospect of enduring a 40 minute symphony or a 3 hour opera particularly daunting. the themes of moral conflict, nationalism, and mythical narratives that pervade these centuries old compositions are also found to be alien and irrelevant to modern sensibilities. in addition, the sophisticated musical aesthetics of baroque counterpoint or classical sonata forms, and the abstract nature of absolute music may seem overly complex or rigid to those accustomed to the straightforward, lyrically explicit nature of pop music. a comprehensive education in the history, period styles, harmony, and counterpoint of classical music compositions provides a solid foundation for a nuanced appreciation and enjoyment of the genre. however, this commitment to learning requires significant time and effort. this situation raises critical questions about the value of classical music and whether the extensive education required to appreciate what some may consider an “outdated” genre is justified. it is suggested that classical music education must be structured around four core areas: specialized conservatory training for aspiring professional musicians; comprehensive music study for students who incorporate classical music as a fundamental aspect of their academic development; the integration of music into the general curriculum at k 12 educational levels; and music education facilitated by arts organizations and cultural institutions, including the provision of program notes, pre concert discussions, and related activities. these four pillars are essential for fostering a robust “classical music culture,” which is critical for ensuring the long term sustainability of this art form (beckerman, guzelimian, et al. 2021). ensuring its continued relevance and significance in the world necessitates educators reforming pedagogical strategies. by doing so, students can engage with the genre on a deeper and more personally connected level, recognizing its complexity, splendor, and importance. this approach not only broadens the accessibility of classical music but also enriches students’ cultural and artistic understanding, fostering a lifelong appreciation for this timeless genre. furthermore, the social dynamics of peer pressure play a significant role in deterring young individuals from embracing an affinity for classical music. les dreyer, former violinist with the metropolitan opera orchestra, indicated that the decline in the audience of classical music is partly due to “the increased media focus on rock and pop superstars” and “the reduction or outright cancellation of metropolitan opera and new york philharmonic tours and concerts in the parks.”footnote 11 however, the estrangement from classical music extends beyond the current generation z and traces its origins to the preceding generation, the parents of today’s gen z, who were raised amid the ascendancy of rock and pop music. the resultant double generational distancing presents a compounded challenge in reconciling these divergent musical inclinations and reintegrating classical music into the broader fabric of contemporary cultural consumption. another set of barriers to bringing classical music to the general public lies in the dearth of mainstream media guidance on appreciating this art form. zachary woolfe and alex ross have indicated a stark decline in the presence of classical music criticism within prominent media outlets, noting that “[i]n america, fewer than 10 newspapers now have a full time classical music critic on staff: a couple of generations ago, the number was in the dozens” (2021). the reduction in specialized music writing represents not only a diminishment in concert reviews but also the further depletion of opportunities for public education in the nuances and standards of classical music performance. public exposure to and appreciation of classical music suffer tangible consequences from the decline of media coverage and critique. for instance, the widespread acclaim and welcome afforded to van cliburn as a national hero following his victory at the first international tchaikovsky competition in moscow in 1958 complete with a ticker tape parade in new york city and a cover feature in time magazine contrasts sharply with the relatively muted media response to george li’s silver prize win at the same competition in 2015. these differences in coverage indicate the marginalization of classical music from the cultural mainstream and, by extension, the importance of media in cultivating interest and engagement in this art form. the role of media in shaping public perceptions and interests is critical; therefore, the diminution of coverage of classical music effectively sidelines the genre, limiting its visibility and accessibility to potential audiences. as zachary woolfe, the current classical music critic at the new york times, notes, “music criticism has always been a limited affair: writing about music, talking about music, is far wider in scope, and more essential to musical life than many people realize.” (woolfe and ross 2021). the financial sustainability of classical music institutions represents another significant challenge, reflecting the insurmountable annual costs associated with maintaining orchestras, opera houses, and classical concert halls. these expenses encompass a broad range of financial obligations, from the salaries of tenured musicians and professional executives to the maintenance of concert venues and the costs of transporting musicians for performances. the financial viability of these institutions is under constant threat, as evidenced by numerous reports of financial crises impacting venerable arts organizations. economic status may influence music preferences. individuals from more affluent backgrounds “have more opportunities to visit cultural institutions and events such as museums, concerts, and theaters, and thus, tend to have more knowledge and appreciation of highbrow culture” (liu, hu, and schedl 2018). following this argument, the global economic recession caused by covid 19 lockdowns and the high inflation rate after the pandemic substantially affected the entertainment and art sectors, including the classical music industry. this pattern of financial distress is not unique to any region but is a phenomenon observed across many north american cities, indicating a pervasive challenge within the classical music industry. the calgary philharmonic orchestra (cpo), canada’s fifth largest orchestra, is a noteworthy example of an institution that faced financial peril, seeking bankruptcy protection in 2002. however, the cpo managed not only to survive this period of financial instability but also to emerge more robust, with a refined vision and strategic focus that has solidified its market position. through collaboration with professional firms, the cpo could harness expertise in strategic planning, project management, fundraising, legal assistance, market research, governance, branding, public relations, financial and human resource management support (finley, gralen, et al. 2006). this comprehensive approach to rebuilding and restructuring has allowed the cpo to thrive in the years following its financial crisis. similarly, the 79 year old new mexico symphony orchestra, which declared bankruptcy in 2011, underwent a transformation that led to the establishment of the new mexico philharmonic. this rebirth marked a significant turnaround, with the philharmonic becoming the state’s flagship classical music organization. by performing for more than 40,000 audience members each season, the new mexico philharmonic has become an integral part of new mexico’s cultural landscape. these examples underscore the potential for classical music institutions to recover from financial adversity through strategic planning, community engagement, and innovative management practices. robert j. flanagan’s study indicates that orchestras in smaller cities often struggle with higher structural deficits than those in larger cities. flanagan suggests several fiscal strategies to address the financial crises orchestras face in the u.s. these include enhancing performance revenues, partially through more significant ticket price differentiation, reducing the growth of expenses by making the pay of orchestra musicians responsive to changes in the financial balance of orchestras, and raising nonperformance income through tax incentives for private contributions and drawing earnings on endowment investments. flanagan emphasizes that “[c]ontinual policy innovations that variously raise performance and nonperformance revenues and reduce expenses are necessary to counter the ongoing growth of structural deficits.” (flanagan 2012). in an environment characterized by rapid changes in audience behaviors and the public’s engagement with and support for the performing arts, the classical music field is contending with evolving ticket buying patterns, including declines in subscriptions and single ticket sales. this scenario highlights the challenges many orchestras and concert halls face in staying solvent as traditional revenue streams experience a downturn. with classical music organizations witnessing shrinking box office revenues and becoming increasingly dependent on donations, finding innovative survival strategies has become imperative. music program directors now find themselves in a tenuous spot, searching for the support needed to continue their artistic endeavors. such changes demand a corresponding increase in reliance on philanthropy and sponsorship, which now constitute a growing portion of these organizations’ budgets (vanbesien 2021). the decline in public funding sources is particularly concerning for orchestras in the u.s., which rely heavily on private funding. according to flanagan’s analysis, public subsidies account for only 5% of orchestras’ annual expenses in the u.s., whereas orchestras in europe and australia receive 20 90% of their expenses from public sources (flanagan 2012) and are more financially stable. european orchestras, and surprisingly orchestras in canada too (mcgrath, legoux and sénécal 2017), benefit from substantial government support, whereas asian orchestras often employ a hybrid funding model that combines government support with private funding (salvaggio 2024). in 2017, the orchestre symphonique de montréal (osm) in canada, for example, received an extra $7.5 million of financial assistance over 5 years in addition to the $8.8 million annual funding it receives from the quebec government,footnote 12 making it the orchestra with the highest state funding in north america. in the u.s., government support for orchestras is provided through funding from the national endowment for the arts (nea), which 2024 awarded a total of $2,616,100 to 97 orchestras. this amount is merely one third of the additional funding the osm received in 2017. each orchestra receives $15,000 $50,000, depending on the needs indicated in its grant applications.footnote 13 despite this support, there were attempts to defund the nea in 2023. although these amendments were defeated by a vote in the house of representatives, the program’s budget was still reduced by 10% from the previous year.footnote 14 the dynamics between arts organizations and their patrons have also become increasingly complicated. donors often demand evidence based outcomes for their contributions. this expectation can sometimes put program directors or music executives in a difficult position as they struggle to maintain their artistic vision while catering to their patrons’ musical tastes and social values. this balancing act is crucial for securing the resources necessary to maintain the core artistic work of these institutions relevant in a swiftly changing cultural and financial environment. counteracting the dwindling interest in classical music necessitates innovative approaches to its presentation and education. reaching out to and inspiring a younger and broader audience necessitates using social media and digital platforms. engaging narratives, accessible introductions to the rich history and repertoire of this music genre, and highlighting the uniqueness of contemporary classical musicians can serve as vital tools in rekindling interest and appreciation for classical music among the general public. the digital age, while contributing to the decline in recording sales and keeping audiences away from live performances, also introduces new opportunities for educating and engaging viewers about classical music in innovative and captivating ways. digital platforms, especially youtube, have emerged as fertile ground for demystifying and disseminating classical music to a broader audience. an exemplary initiative is the “the independent pianist” channelfootnote 15, founded by pianist cole anderson, which looks into the historical contexts of piano masterpieces, provides analytical insights into compositions, addresses the complexities of performance, and contrasts the styles of some of the greatest pianists in history with original scores. anderson culminates each discussion with his performances of the pieces, offering a comprehensive exploration of classical piano music that appeals to a broad audience. similarly, the “how i met the opera” channelfootnote 16, created by conductor anna castro grinstein, was awarded support by the german music council (deutscher musikrat).footnote 17 this channel offers viewers insights from a conductor’s perspective, such as explaining the role of conductors and showcasing leonard bernstein’s performance score while explicating the uniqueness of his conducting art. such content provides a valuable educational resource beyond what readings can offer, making the intricacies of classical music more accessible and understandable to the general public. beyond youtube, an array of digital platforms, including podcasts, masterclass, and the great courses, provide free and paid lectures on classical music, offering insights that transcend the limitations of traditional book readings or the financial constraints associated with one on one teaching experiences. these platforms democratize access to classical music education, enabling enthusiasts to explore the depths of this musical genre from anywhere in the world, at any time, without the need for physical attendance in a classroom or private lessons. moreover, streaming services, such as spotify, apple classical, and youtube, have revolutionized access to classical music recordings. in contrast to the past, when building a collection of vinyl records or cds represented a significant financial investment, today’s streaming platforms offer affordable, if not free, access to vast classical music libraries. this shift has allowed newcomers and enthusiasts to quickly discover and compare a wide range of compositions, performances, and interpretations. the digital platform has also revolutionized the accessibility and visibility of international music competitions, including prestigious events such as the international chopin piano competition and the van cliburn international piano competition. these live broadcasts engage a global audience, allowing viewers to follow competitors through various stages of their performances, evoking a dynamic similar to reality shows. this format has contributed to the rapid rise of classical music stars, such as bruce liu and yunchan lim, winners of the chopin and van cliburn competitions in 2021 and 2023, respectively. lim’s remarkably powerful rendition of rachmaninoff’s piano concerto no. 3 (op. 30) in the competition finals has become the most viewed performance on youtube, amassing over 11 million views.footnote 18 other prominent soloists, including yuja wang, ray chen, lang lang, and seong jin cho, have garnered substantial followings and are recognized as leading figures in the classical music industry. the success of these asian musicians highlights the growing international interest in classical music, suggesting that while the genre may face significant challenges in its traditional western context, it continues to thrive and resonate in other parts of the world. other than digital platforms, some concert halls, particularly those affiliated with university music departments, such as koerner hall in torontofootnote 19 and the grand hall’s muse program at the university of hong kongfootnote 20, frequently offer pre concert lectures by performing artists to deepen the audience’s understanding and appreciation of the music. the opportunities and implications of this enhanced access are immense, allowing not only the exposure of classical music to diverse audiences but also the enrichment of its understanding and appreciation. individuals eager to discover this art form but deterred by the high cost of recordings and reading materials can now immerse themselves in the rich history and complex beauty of classical music without financial barriers. this democratization of access introduces new audiences to the timeless relevance and emotional depth of classical music. the digital realm, in particular, serves as a powerful tool for classical music education and promotion, engaging audiences in an informative and entertaining manner. classical music gains a new lease on life through these platforms, reaching audiences far beyond classrooms and concert halls and fostering a renewed interest in this timeless art form. the introduction of candlelight concerts in 2019 represents another innovative approach to making classical music more accessible. these concerts, created by the entertainment company fever, which also presents the “immersive experience” 360 degree digital art exhibition of van gogh globally, feature performances with hundreds of flickering electric candles illuminating the musicians on stage in local churches or community hubs across different cities worldwide and are often performed by local music students, providing them with valuable performance experience. a distinctive aspect of candlelight concerts is their programmatic flexibility, which includes a mix of traditional classical repertoire and popular music, presenting concerts with themes ranging from “from bach to the beatles” and “the best of hans zimmer” to tribute programs to taylor swift, joe hisaishi, queen, coldplay, and others. the casual and intimate atmosphere, illuminated by hundreds of candles, resonates well with younger audiences, who may be deterred by the formal attire and etiquette traditionally associated with classical music performances. additionally, music programs often feature musical works of just a few minutes, successfully addressing concerns about the attention spans of newcomers to classical music and making this genre more approachable and enjoyable for attendees. bloomberg reports that fever raised $227 million in a funding round led by goldman sachs asset management in 2022, reportedly “the largest ever for a live entertainment tech startup,” with additional undisclosed investments by eurazeo and vitruvian partners.footnote 21 one year later, goldman sachs secured another $110 million investment, giving the company a $1.8 billion valuation.footnote 22 according to fever’s official website,footnote 23 the series is now performed in more than 100 cities worldwide, with three million attendees, making it “the largest seller of live classical music in the world.”footnote 24 these new approaches demonstrate a broader effort within the classical music community to redefine the concert experience, making it more inviting and inclusive for diverse audiences. by breaking down the barriers of formality and expansively redefining the repertoire to encompass music from both the past and present, these initiatives help maintain the relevance and appeal of classical music in the 21st century cultural landscape. initiatives that engage new audiences and introduce them to orchestral music through innovative programming serve as exemplary models of outreach. however, concert halls and music executives should be open to venturing beyond the revered compositions of past centuries, even though these works are often reliable attractions for ticket sales. the future of classical music cannot depend solely on ticket sales or subscription packages. instead, it must leverage corporate sponsorships, community grants, and individual donations. for over a decade, orchestras have derived a more significant portion of their total income from donations than ticket sales (abrams husso 2018). consequently, executives must develop comprehensive donor management strategies, including personalized interactions, engagement with donors, and consistent outreach efforts to secure funding. contemporary compositions in the classical genre continue to be created, contributing significant new works to the orchestral and operatic repertoire. notable examples include jonathan harvey’s string quartet no. 4, unsuk chin’s cello concerto, george benjamin’s opera written on skin, john luther adams’ orchestral piece become ocean, hing yan chan’s ’twas the thawing wind   for sheng and orchestra, and hans abrahamsen’s let me tell you. these compositions and other outstanding performances deserve the audience’s appreciation and exploration. they demonstrate that classical music is not merely a reflection of the past but also a vibrant, evolving form of artistic expression. beyond the strategies previously outlined, the sustainability of classical music significantly relies on the support of patrons, including both affluent individuals and corporate entities. the alignment between the branding of orchestras, concert halls, or series programs with donors’ visions, whether they prioritize education, social advocacy, or artistic achievements, is a delicate balance that requires skillful curation. program directors shoulder the critical responsibility of ensuring that classical music remains vibrant and resonant within the dynamic context of modern urban life. the traditional adherence to the “high culture” associated with centuries old classical compositions faces challenges in maintaining its relevance and appeal in the contemporary world. according to data from statista in 2023, the outlook for classical music is not too bleak. audience demographics in the u.s. reveal a promising trend: baby boomers and generation x together account for 31% of the classical music audience, millennials represent a significant 48%, and generation z accounts for 19% (gewiese and rau 2023a). this data indicates a substantial interest in classical music among younger generations. a similar study conducted in canada reflects comparable trends, with millennials and generation z constituting 37% and 21% of the audience, respectively, compared with 30% for baby boomers and 12% for generation x, suggesting a slightly older population than in the u.s. (gewiese and rau 2023b). the scenario in china presents an even more youthful audience base, with millennials alone making up 50% of the audience and generation z contributing another significant 25% (gewiese and rau 2023c). these statistics underscore the pattern that the audience of classical music is diversifying and rejuvenating across different regions. the engagement of millennials and generation z indicates a vibrant future for classical music, provided that the offerings resonate with their interests and values. to fully benefit from this potential, classical music institutions must continue innovating their programming, outreach, and engagement strategies, ensuring the genre remains accessible, relevant, and compelling to a broad spectrum of listeners. concert programming in asian countries and north america reflects distinct approaches to accommodating varying generational interests in classical music, showcasing the diversity in audience engagement strategies across these regions. by tailoring concert programming to reflect the diverse interests of their audiences, classical music organizations in asia and north america endeavor to ensure the genre’s relevance and sustainability in the 21st century, cultivate a broader audience base, and enrich the classical music landscape with a fusion of traditions and innovations. by incorporating new works into their programming, concert halls, and orchestras can affirm that classical music is a “living heritage” a rich legacy inherited from the previous generations that we are responsible for enriching and passing on to future generations, fostering an environment where the musical genre is continuously rejuvenated. collaboration across music genres can also bring more dynamism to the classical music tradition, fostering new perspectives and expressive capacities. in essence, the “continuous recreation” of classical music as a living heritage necessitates a holistic approach that embraces tradition and innovation in equal measure, nurturing an appreciation of age old masterpieces and encouraging the creation of new works that reflect contemporary sensibilities, which helps reconstruct the image of classical music in ways that resonate with today’s audiences, ensuring that the genre remains a vibrant component of our cultural heritage. otherwise, quoting from eastburn’s chapter, which opens this article, “… if the status quo is maintained, it is easy to picture a doomsday scenario in which classical music appears hopelessly outdated and irrelevant” (eastburn 2018). not applicable. https://ich.unesco.org/doc/src/46212 en.pdf. https://www.hkphil.org/player (accessed august 3, 2024). according to 2021 population census, conducted by the census and statistics department of hong kong special administrative region: https://www.census2021.gov.hk/en/main_tables.html (accessed august 3, 2024). https://hksl.org/about us/the orchestra/ (accessed august 3, 2024). suzanne yanko, “hong kong philharmonic orchestra,” classic melbourne: music news & reviews, may 25th, 2017: https://classicmelbourne.com.au/hong kong philharmonic orchestra/ (accessed august 3, 2024). suzanne yanko, “hong kong philharmonic orchestra,” classic melbourne: music news & reviews, may 1st, 2017: https://classicmelbourne.com.au/hong kong philharmonic orchestra/ (accessed august 3, 2024). zachary woolfe, “audiences are coming back to orchestras after ‘scary’ sales last fall,” the new york times, may 23, 2023. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/23/arts/music/orchestra classical music attendance.html (accessed february 19, 2024). ibid. https://www.statista.com/statistics/195186/classical music concert attendance in the us since 1982/. (accessed february 1, 2024) https://cdn.bachtrack.com/files/293747 annual%20classical%20music%20statistics%202022.pdf (accessed february 1, 2024). les dreyer, “sunday dialogue: is classical music dying?,” the new york times, november 24, 2012. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/25/opinion/sunday/sunday dialogue is classical music dying.html. orchestre symphonique de montréal (osm), annual report 2017/2018: https://www.osm.ca/app/uploads/2024/01/rapport_annuel_ang_osm_2018_compressed.pdf (accessed august 6, 2024). league of american orchestras, “fy24 nea grants to orchestras” (may 16, 2024): https://americanorchestras.org/fy24 nea grants to orchestras/ (accessed august 6, 2024). anand krishnan, “harmonizing america: the case for federal support of orchestras,” stanford economic review (february 29, 2024): https://stanfordeconreview.com/2024/02/29/commentary harmonizing america the case for federal support of orchestras/ (accessed august 6, 2024). https://www.youtube.com/c/theindependentpianist (accessed february 20, 2024). https://www.youtube.com/@howimettheopera (accessed february 20, 2024). https://www.annacastrogrinstein.com/audience outreach (accessed february 20, 2024). javier c. hernández, “a 19 year old pianist electrifies audiences. but he’s unimpressed,” the new york times (may 9, 2023): https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/09/arts/music/yunchan lim new york philharmonic rachmaninoff.html (accessed september 23, 2024). https://www.rcmusic.com/concerts?fq=eventvenue%7c%7ckoerner%20hall (accessed august 10, 2024). https://muse.hku.hk (accessed august 10, 2024). sarah rappaport, “goldman invests in live event startup ahead of possible ipo,” bloomberg (january 26, 2022): https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022 01 26/goldman leads fever s 227 million round ahead of possible ipo?embedded checkout=true (accessed august 6, 2024). dan taylor, “goldman and co. aren’t sweating’ $110 million in new round for fever at $1.8 billion valuation,” tech.eu (february 2, 2023): https://tech.eu/2023/02/02/fever raises 110 million in new round at 1 8 billion valuation/ (accessed august 6, 2024). https://newsroom.feverup.com/en au/209245 goldman sachs asset management leads 227 m investment in live entertainment tech startup fever (accessed august 6, 2024). https://tech.eu/2023/02/02/fever raises 110 million in new round at 1 8 billion valuation/ (accessed august 6, 2024). abrams husso, lucy. 2018. a review and comparison of policy: the national endowment for the arts 2014 annual report and the league of american orchestras ‘orchestra facts: 2006 2014,’ may 9, 2018. https://www.lucyabrams.net/news/2018/4/30/a review and comparison of policy the national endowment for the arts 2014 annual report and the league of american orchestras orchestra facts 2006 2014 baum, seth d, and andrea owe. 2024. on the intrinsic value of diversity. inquiry: a journal of medical care organization, provision and financing. https://doi.org/10.1080/0020174x.2024.2367247 beckerman, michael, ara guzelimian, and ellen t. harris, jenny judge. 2021. education and classical music. in classical music: contemporary perspectives and challenges. ed. michael beckerman, and paul boghossian, 15 27. cambridge: open book. chapter google scholar cooper, michael. 2018. seeking orchestras in tune with their diverse communities. new york times april 18. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/18/arts/music/symphony orchestra diversity.html?searchresultposition=1 cuyler, anthonio c., evan linett, karen yair, and james mccain. 2023. racial/ethnic and gender diversity in the orchestra field in 2023: a report by the league of american orchestras. new york: league of american orchestras. 2023. https://americanorchestras.org/wp content/uploads/2023/06/racial ethnic and gender diversity in the orchestra field in 2023.pdf department of statistics singapore. 2023. population trends 2023. https://www.singstat.gov.sg/ /media/files/publications/population/population2023.ashx eastburn, susanna. 2018. is classical music a living or heritage art form? in the classical music industry. ed. chris dromey and julia haferkorn, 141 147. london: routledge. chapter google scholar feder, susan, anthony mcgill. 2021. diversity, equity, inclusion, and racial injustice in the classical music professions: a call to action. in classical music: contemporary perspectives and challenges. ed. michael beckerman, and paul boghossian, 87 102. cambridge: open book. chapter google scholar finley, donna s., alana gralen, and larry fichtner. 2006. phoenix in calgary: how the calgary philharmonic survived bankruptcy and flourished. nonprofit quarterly. june 21. https://nonprofitquarterly.org/phoenix incalgary how the calgary philharmonic survived bankruptcy and flourished/ flanagan, robert j. 2012. perilous life of symphony orchestras: artistic triumphs and economic challenges. new haven: yale university press. google scholar gewiese, jan, stefan rau, and stefan rau. 2023a. target audience: classical music fans in the u.s. statista consumer insights global. august. https://www.statista.com/study/122135/target audience classical music fans in the united states/ gewiese, jan, and. 2023b. target audience: classical music fans in canada. statista consumer insights global. august. https://www.statista.com/study/122119/target audience classical music fans in canada/ gewiese, jan. 2023c. and stefan rau. target audience: classical music fans in china. statista consumer insights global. august. https://www.statista.com/study/122120/target audience classical music fans in china/ guachalla, a. 2017. social inclusion and audience development at the royal opera house: a tourist perspective. international journal of culture tourism and hospitality research 11(3): 436 449. article google scholar harris, ellen t. 2021. and michael beckerman. the enduring value of classical music in the western tradition. in classical music: contemporary perspectives and challenges. eds. michael beckerman and paul boghossian, 1 5. cambridge: open book publishers. johnson, julian. 2002. who needs classical music? cultural choice and musical value. new york: oxford university press. book google scholar kertz welzel, alexandra. 2021. on hating classical music in music education. in difference and division in music education. ed. alexis anja kallio, 79 92. new york & london: routledge. google scholar kimball, michael, robert brunswig, sally mcbeth, and david thomas. 2013. giving placekeepers and old places a local future: place building theory and the living heritage paradigm. anthropologist 33(2): 3 15. google scholar kolbe, kristina. 2021. playing the system: ‘race’ making and elitism in diversity projects in germany’s classical music sector. poetics 87 (2021). article 101532: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.poetic.2021.101532 kolbe, kristina. 2022. producing (musical) difference: power, practices and inequalities in diversity initiatives in germany’s classical music sector. cultural sociology 16(2): 231 249. article google scholar lebrecht, norman. 2007. the life and death of classical music: featuring the 100 best and 20 worst recordings ever made. new york: anchor books. google scholar lee, noah. 2023. kitchener waterloo symphony’s bankruptcy threatens classical music legacy. the queen’s university journal. october 6. https://www.queensjournal.ca/kitchener waterloo symphonys bankruptcy threatens classical music legacy/#:~:text=on%20sept.,musicians%20and%20around%2017%20staff liu, meijun, xiao hu, and markus schedl. 2018. the relation of culture, socio economics, and friendship to music preferences: a large scale, cross country study. plos one 13(12): e0208186. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0208186 article google scholar mcgrath, tara, renaud legoux, and sylvain sénécal. 2017. balancing the score: the financial impact of resource dependence on symphony orchestras. journal of cultural economics 41 (4): 421 439. article google scholar ross, alex. 2007. the rest is noise: listening to the twentieth century. new york: farrar, straus and giroux. google scholar salvaggio, salvino a. 2024. orchestra management in practice. abingdon: routledge. google scholar solomon, brin. 2019. come out and play. symphony. 48 53. league of american orchestras. google scholar tan, shzr ee. 2017. state orchestras and multiculturalism in singapore. in global perspectives on orchestras: collective creativity and social agency. ed. tina k. ramnarine, 261 281. new york: oxford university press. google scholar the policy institute and the centre for attention studies. 2022. do we have your attention: how people focus and live in the modern information environment. london: king’s college london. https://www.kcl.ac.uk/policy institute/assets/how people focus and live in the modern information environment.pdf thompson, marie. 2017. to smooth or remove? affect, revanchism and the weaponized use of classical music. communication and the public 2(4): 272 283. article google scholar tommasini, anthony. 2020. to make orchestras more diverse, end blink auditions. the new york times, july 16. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/16/arts/music/blind auditions orchestras race.html trujillo, adriana. 2019. exploring living heritage conservation: an ethnography of taos pueblo, new mexico. ursidae: the undergraduate research journal at the university of northern colorado 6(2): 1 13. google scholar vanbesien, matthew. 2021. are labor and management (finally) working together to save the day? the covid 19 crisis in orchestras. in classical music: contemporary perspectives and challenges. ed. paul boghossian, 75 86. cambridge: open book. chapter google scholar woolfe, zachary, and alex ross. 2021. the evolving role of music journalism. in classical music: contemporary perspectives and challenges. ed. michael beckerman, and paul boghossian, 47 54. cambridge: open book. chapter google scholar young, james. 2016. how classical music is better than popular music. philosophy (august). 1 18. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0031819116000334 download references not applicable. not applicable. emmanuel college of victoria university in the university of toronto, 75 queen’s park crescent, toronto, on, m5s 1k7, canada henry c.h. shiu you can also search for this author in pubmed google scholar henry c.h. shiu contributed solely to this work. the author read and approved the final manuscript. correspondence to henry c.h. shiu. not applicable. not applicable. i have no competing interests. springer nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. open access this article is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4.0 international license, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the creative commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. the images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's creative commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. if material is not included in the article's creative commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. to view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. reprints and permissions shiu, h.c. addressing the challenges and strategies for western classical music in north america as a living heritage art form. int. j. anthropol. ethnol. 8, 20 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1186/s41257 024 00121 7 download citation received: 06 july 2024 revised: 28 october 2024 accepted: 30 october 2024 published: 18 november 2024 doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s41257 024 00121 7 anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content: sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article. provided by the springer nature sharedit content sharing initiative by using this website, you agree to our terms and conditions, your us state privacy rights, privacy statement and cookies policy. your privacy choices/manage cookies we use in the preference centre. © 2025 biomed central ltd unless otherwise stated. part of springer nature.
performances in n.y.c. supported by the struggles of one of the nation’s finest orchestras show the difficulties facing classical music in the united states. by robin pogrebin and javier c. hernández reporting from san francisco and new york for a night at the symphony, there was a lot of tension in the air. as concertgoers filed in to davies symphony hall earlier this month, they were greeted by players from the san francisco symphony passing out bright yellow fliers accusing management of having “no clear artistic vision.” then, shortly before the performance began, a shout echoed from one of the balconies, exhorting people to “act!” it was the conductor esa pekka salonen’s first concert in the hall since march, when he stunned the classical music world by announcing that he would step down as the orchestra’s music director amid a dispute with management over budget cuts. the evening’s program was just the sort of thing he had promised when he was hired with a mandate to rethink the concert experience: ravel’s charming “mother goose” brought to life by dancers from alonzo king’s lines ballet, and then schoenberg’s nightmarish “erwartung” staged by the director peter sellars. his decision to leave once his contract is up next year has upset fans   “who he is and what he brings can’t be replicated,” mark malaspina, an audience member, lamented as he entered the hall   and left some concerned about the future of the 113 year old san francisco symphony. “an orchestra that was in very good shape is now in crisis,” said peter pastreich, a longtime arts administrator who managed the san francisco symphony from 1978 to 1999. “it is heartbreaking to watch.” salonen’s unexpectedly short tenure in san francisco is in some ways a very local story, but it also says something about the challenges facing classical music in 21st century america. even before the pandemic, many orchestras around the country were struggling. audiences were aging and shrinking. costs were rising. old business models were withering. and philanthropy, which has replaced ticket sales as the main source of income for most orchestras, was becoming increasingly hard to come by. when san francisco landed salonen, it was hailed as a coup.

supported by after the pianist, vikingur olafsson, asked for a concerto over beers, the composer, john adams, wrote “after the fall,” which will now travel the world. by joshua barone as thomas turns 80, new collections of his recordings reveal the legacy of a maestro who has exuberantly refused to conform to expectations. by david allen the work stoppage has forced a cancellation of the verdi requiem performances. by robin pogrebin salonen, who will soon be a free agent for the first time in decades, could do pretty much anything at this stage. what will it be?