['IN', 'THE', 'UNITED', 'STATES', 'DISTRICT', 'COURT', 'FOR', 'THE', 'EASTERN', 'DISTRICT', 'OF', 'PENNSYLVANIA', 'SHELDON', 'TABB', ':', 'CIVIL', 'ACTION', 'Vv.', 'PHILIP', 'MORRIS,', 'INC.,', 'R.J.', 'REYNOLDS', ':', 'NO.', '98-CV-3223', 'TOBACCO', 'COMPANY,', 'BROWN', '&', 'WILLIAMSON', 'TOBACCO', 'CORPORATION,', 'LORILLARD', 'TOBACCO', 'COMPANY,', 'INC.,', 'LIGGETT', '&', 'MYERS', 'INC.,', 'and', 'THE', 'AMERICAN', 'TOBACCO', 'COMPANY', ';', 'JURY', 'TRIAL', 'DEMANDED', ' ', 'MEMORANDUM', 'OF', 'LAW', 'IN', 'SUPPORT', 'OF', 'THE', 'MOTION', 'TO', 'COMPEL', 'OF', 'DEFENDANTS', 'I.', 'INTRODUCTION', 'Defendants,', 'R.J.', 'Reynolds', 'Tobacco', 'Company', '(“Reynolds”),', 'Philip', 'Morris,', 'Inc.,', 'Brown', 'and', 'Williamson', 'Tobacco', 'Corporation,', 'The', 'American', 'Tobacco', 'Company', 'and', 'Lorillard.', 'Tobacco', 'Company.', 'Inc.,', 'by', 'and', 'through', 'their', 'respective', 'counsel,', 'hereby', 'move', 'this', 'Honorable', 'Court', 'to', 'enter', 'an', 'Order,', 'compelling', 'plaintiff', 'to', 'produce', 'relevant', 'information', 'that', 'may', 'be', 'useful', 'to', 'defendants', 'and', 'their', 'expert', 'witnesses', 'in', 'assessing', "plaintiff's", 'claims', 'and', 'preparing', 'for', 'trial.', 'I', 'PROCEDURAL', 'AND', 'FACTUAL', 'HISTORY', 'In', 'his', 'Complaint,', 'plaintiff', 'avers', 'that', 'by', 'virtue', 'of', 'his', '“addiction”', 'to', 'smoking', 'cigarettes,', 'he', 'suffered', 'squamous', 'cell', 'carcinoma', 'which', 'has', 'caused', 'him', 'to', 'suffer', '“conditions', 'which', 'are', 'permanent', 'and', 'have', 'caused', 'and', 'will', 'in', 'the', 'future', 'cause', 'great', 'physical', 'and', 'mental', 'pain', 'and', 'suffering', 'to', 'plaintiff', '...”', "(Plaintiff's", 'Complaint,', '{16', 'and', '22).', 'Plaintiff', 'claims', 'that', 'he', 'was', '“addicted”', 'to', 'nicotine', 'and', 'smoked', 'from', '1939', 'until', '1979', 'or', '1980.', "(Plaintiff's", 'Complaint,', '{', '14.)', 'VL8VELI6']