Public Lab Research note


Public Lab focuses on open science education at 2013 barnraising

by Shannon | October 23, 2013 14:37 23 Oct 14:37 | #9533 | #9533

Shannon was awarded the Photo Documentation Barnstar by herszel for their work in this research note.


Cross-posted from PBS IdeaLab blog

Co-authored by Shannon Dosemagen, Jessi Breen and Liz Barry

This year’s Public Lab Barnraising brought 50 people together in Louisiana for our annual, retreat-style community gathering. This is the closest thing we have to a Public Lab conference — but with an emphasis on “doing stuff together” rather than just presenting/talking. In the spirit of bringing a community together to collectively raise a structure such as a barn, Public Lab comes together in-person to develop tools, toolkits, supporting materials such as guides and tutorials, test the tools, and develop new research directions and projects. Participants represent a wide range of interests, from technologists and designers to social scientists and community organizers. As we prepared for the 2013 barnraising, we all crossed our fingers that we’d be storm free between the East and Gulf Coasts, unlike last year when Hurricane Sandy disrupted many travelers. However, we weren’t so lucky!

On October 3, with community members already in the air en route to New Orleans, we received news from LUMCON (the research center on the Gulf Coast where we would be lodging, meeting, and conducting research) that they were facing a potential 2-3 foot storm surge from Tropical Storm Karen and would be shutting their entire facility down and canceling our conference. Panic ensued, but only briefly. With some quick work and kind hearts, within a couple of hours gracious hospitality was offered to us by University of New Orleans TRAC and Propeller co-working space who agreed to house and host barnraisers joining us from as far away as Jerusalem and London.

Exploring Education

And so we convened. Following time-tested principles of Open Space Technology, the group gathered to explore this year’s theme of education. We proposed sessions that would enable us to arrive at the end of our time together with a workable plan for supporting education initiatives in the coming year. Some plenaries were agreed upon in advance — for instance, we reserved an entire morning to discuss our diverse community’s ethics of practice and to collaboratively write our value statement where we each contributed statements in the form of, “as a member of the Public Lab community I value …”

We also reserved afternoons for outdoor field trips, weather permitting, and the hands-on kite flying took advantage of the pre-tropical storm winds. Back indoors, breakout sessions ranged from mini-hacking sessions on ongoing projects like the thermal temperature bob (tested in a bathtub) and potentiostats, to discussions on structuring Public Lab tool workshops using dialogue education techniques.

Much progress was made by a dedicated group of teachers working to connect Public lab activities with U.S. federal standards for kindergarten-12th grade core curriculum. The diversity of sessions was representative of the diversity of individuals attending the barnraising — practitioners, NGO workers, journalists, activists, academics, designers, teachers.

Parking lot flare spectrometry

Throughout the three-day conference, the rhythm pulsed between plenary sessions attended by all to small group breakouts for getting work done, which kept the group fresh and productive. The “Rule of Two Feet” governed; as stated by Harrison Owen, “If at any time during our time together you find yourself in any situation where you are neither learning nor contributing, use your two feet, go someplace else.” The spirit of “Be Prepared to Be Surprised” infused our encounters with open mindedness. Each session had a note taker using the “Talk” page (etherpad) of the relevant Public Lab wiki page. All notes and photo/video documentation were gathered here.

The dialogue education group

We wrapped up our third and final day together by listing out the outcomes of all sessions and the commitments made by individuals and Working Groups. There is now a Writing Group, a Water Quality Group, and a revamped Education group specifically working towards adapting Public Lab tools to integrate with the U.S. science education standards and generate “hello world” type experiments for use in the classroom. New community members joined the Public Lab organizers, a group of nominated community leaders who meet weekly and guide the way our community collaborates and grows.

The Open Space Technology Experience

It is worth noting that contemporary unconferences in the tech world employ some but not all of the principles of open space technology. In an open space technology experience, people work towards solving a problem or answering a question in the context of complexity and diversity. This stands in contrast to standard tech world “birds of a feather” meetings, which emphasize homogeneity and breakout sessions featuring uni-directional presentations. In open space technology, everyone tackles issues that are part of the same overarching issue. Open space technology emphasizes not only setting the agenda, but within each session, collaborating on the shared goals that were established at outset. It’s about getting work done together.

We are already planning for next year’s barnraising. We are committed to gathering in the Gulf Coast, and have accepted the fact that once again we will likely have to call it a hurricane party!

The 2013 Barnraising was sponsored with generous support from Rackspace and the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.
{"cc_re__cc_re__cc_by_sa_3_0": ["//publiclab.org/conduct\" target=\"_blank\">Code of Conduct</a></b>, which applies to all online and in-person spaces managed by the Public Lab community and non-profit. You also agree to our <a href=\"/privacy\">Privacy Policy</a>.</p> \r\n\r\n<p>As an open source community, we believe in open licensing of content so that other members of the community can leverage your work legally -- with attribution, of course. By joining the Public Lab site, <b>you agree to release the content you post here under a <a href=\"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/\" target=\"_blank\">Creative Commons Attribution Sharealike license</a></b>, and the hardware designs you post under the <b><a href=\"http://www.ohwr.org/cernohl\" target=\"_blank\">CERN Open Hardware License 1.1</a> (<a href=\"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/\" target=\"_blank\">full text</a>)</b>. This has the added benefit that others must share their improvements in turn with you.</p>\n\n    <div class=\"col-md-12 form-group form-inline\" style=\"clear:both;padding-top:10px;\">\n        <!-- button for creating ", " we believe in open licensing of content so that other members of the community can leverage your work legally -- with attribution, of course. By joining the Public Lab site, <b>you agree to release the content you post here under a <a href=\"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/\" target=\"_blank\">Creative Commons Attribution Sharealike license</a></b>, and the hardware designs you post under the <b><a href=\"http://www.ohwr.org/cernohl\" target=\"_blank\">CERN Open Hardware License 1.1</a> (<a href=\"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/\" target=\"_blank\">full text</a>)</b>. This has the added benefit that others must share their improvements in turn with you.</p>\n\n    <div class=\"col-md-12 form-group form-inline\" style=\"clear:both;padding-top:10px;\">\n        <!-- button for creating new users -->\n        <button style=\"margin-right:8px;\" class=\"btn btn-lg btn-primary btn-save sranje\" id=\"signup-button\" type=\"submit\" tabindex=\"7\">Sign up</button>\n        <span>or <a id=\"toLogin\" href=\"/login\">\n          Log in\n        </a>\n        </span>\n\n      ", "f=\"/website\">About this website</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/sitemap\">Sitemap</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/stories\">Stories</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/glossary\">Glossary</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/authoring-help\">Authoring Help</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/privacy\">Privacy policy</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/licenses\">Licenses</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/stats\">Site statistics</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/feed.rss\">RSS</a></li>\r\n    </ul>\r\n  </div>\r\n  <div class=\"col-md-3\">\r\n    <p><a rel=\"license\" href=\"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/\"><i class=\"fa fa-creative-commons\"></i></a> This work is licensed under a <a href='http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/'>Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License</a>. Hardware designs on this site are released under the <a href='https://publiclab.org/ohl'>CERN Open Hardware License 1.2</a>. Read more about Public Lab's <a href='/licenses'>open source licensing here</a>. </p>\r\n  </div>\r\n  <div class=\"col-md-3 hidden-print\">\r\n    <p>Specific works on this site may be r", "i><a href=\"/glossary\">Glossary</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/authoring-help\">Authoring Help</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/privacy\">Privacy policy</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/licenses\">Licenses</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/stats\">Site statistics</a></li>\r\n      <li><a href=\"/feed.rss\">RSS</a></li>\r\n    </ul>\r\n  </div>\r\n  <div class=\"col-md-3\">\r\n    <p><a rel=\"license\" href=\"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/\"><i class=\"fa fa-creative-commons\"></i></a> This work is licensed under a <a href='http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/'>Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License</a>. Hardware designs on this site are released under the <a href='https://publiclab.org/ohl'>CERN Open Hardware License 1.2</a>. Read more about Public Lab's <a href='/licenses'>open source licensing here</a>. </p>\r\n  </div>\r\n  <div class=\"col-md-3 hidden-print\">\r\n    <p>Specific works on this site may be released or dedicated under different licenses, but only if such alternatives are clearly indicated by their authors.</p>\r\n    <p>T"]}