In Blow to Monsanto, Arkansas Ban on Controversial Herbicide to Remain

GMO

Monsanto lost its bid to overturn Arkansas' ban on dicamba, a controversial weedkiller linked to extensive damage to famers' crops in the state as well as several other states.

The agribusiness giant makes a version of the herbicide called XtendiMax that's paired with its seeds that are genetically engineered to resist the product. DuPont Co. and BASF SE also sell their own dicamba-based formulations.


Pulaski County Circuit Judge Chris Piazza dismissed Monsanto's lawsuit Friday citing a recent Arkansas Supreme Court ruling which held that the state cannot be made a defendant in court.

"We are disappointed in the court's decision to dismiss our legal challenge of the plant board's restrictions, and we will consider additional legal steps that might be appropriate," Scott Partridge, the company's vice president of global strategy, told the Associated Press in a statement. "We look forward to the day when Arkansas growers can benefit from the latest weed-control technology on the market."

The AP further reported:

"Among other arguments, Monsanto claimed that the state did not consider the economic impact of the ban. The company also challenged the makeup of the 18-member board, arguing a state law that gives private groups such as the state Seed Growers Association power to appoint members violates Arkansas' constitution. Piazza said he wouldn't going to rule specifically on the request for a preliminary injunction in case his dismissal ruling is appealed and sent back to his court."

Monsanto—which expects farmers to plant 40 million acres of dicamba-tolerant soybeans and 6 million acres of a cotton version across the U.S. this year—sued the Arkansas State Plant Board over its decision to ban the herbicide's sale and use between April 16 and Oct. 31. The regulators made the decision after receiving nearly 1,000 complaints last year over dicamba damage.

The powerful and drift-prone herbicide has been blamed for damaging more than three millions of acres of non-target crops across the country. Other states such as Tennessee and Missouri—Monsanto's home state—have also imposed temporary bans or restrictions on the use of dicamba to curb further damage.

Although dicamba has been around for decades, Monsanto, DuPont Co. and BASF SE sells new formulations of the herbicide that's said to be less drift-prone and volatile than older versions when used correctly.

Monsanto has long defended its product, blaming growers for using older versions of dicamba or not following directions on the new product label.

The controversy will not die anytime soon. On Friday, public interest organizations representing farmers and conservationists made their legal case in a federal lawsuit against the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Monsanto, challenging EPA's approval of Monsanto's XtendiMax pesticide.

EcoWatch Daily Newsletter

California Condor at soaring at the Grand Canyon. Pavliha / iStock / Getty Images

North America's largest bird passed an important milestone this spring when the 1,000th California condor chick hatched since recovery efforts began, NPR reported Sunday.

Read More Show Less
The Roloway monkey has been pushed closer to extinction. Sonja Wolters / WAPCA / IUCN

The statistics around threatened species are looking grim. A new report by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has added more than 9,000 new additions to its Red List of threatened species, pushing the total number of species on the list to more than 105,000 for the first time, according to the Guardian.

Read More Show Less
Sponsored
Golde Wallingford submitted this photo of "Pure Joy" to EcoWatch's first photo contest. Golde Wallingford

EcoWatch is pleased to announce our third photo contest!

Read More Show Less
BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI / AFP / Getty Images

The campaign to re-elect President Donald Trump has found a new way to troll liberals and sea turtles.

Read More Show Less
Night long exposure photograph of wildifires in Santa Clarita, California. FrozenShutter / E+ / Getty Images

By Kristy Dahl

Last week, UCS released Killer Heat, a report analyzing how the frequency of days with a dangerously hot heat index — the combination of temperature and humidity the National Weather Service calls the "feels like" temperature — will change in response to the global emissions choices we make in the coming decades.

Read More Show Less
Sponsored
A Zara store in Times Square, Causeway Bay, Hong Kong. Timahaowemi / CC BY-SA 3.0

Green is the new black at Zara.

The Spanish fast fashion behemoth has made a bold move to steer its industry to a more environmentally friendly future for textiles. Inditex, Zara's parent company, announced that all the polyester, cotton and linen it uses will be sustainably produced by 2025, as CNN reported.

Read More Show Less
Pexels

By Gavin Van De Walle, MS, RD

Whether you enjoy running recreationally, competitively, or as part of your overall wellness goals, it's a great way to improve your heart health.

Read More Show Less
Text from the plaque that will mark the site where Ok glacier once was. Rice University

By Andrea Germanos

A climate change victim in Iceland is set to be memorialized with a monument that underscores the urgent crisis.

Read More Show Less
{"cc_re__cc_re__cc_by_sa_3_0_en": ["                    </div>\n                                </div></div></a></div><div class=\"widget__body clearfix sm-mt-1\"><div class=\"photo-credit\">\n        A Zara store in Times Square, Causeway Bay, Hong Kong. <em><a href=\"https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:HK_night_%E9%8A%85%E9%91%BC%E7%81%A3_mall_%E9%A6%99%E6%B8%AF%E6%99%82%E4%BB%A3%E5%BB%A3%E5%A0%B4_Times_Square_ZARA_department_store_sign_Causeway_Bay_clothing_Mar-2013.JPG\" rel=\"noopener noreferrer\" target=\"_blank\">Timahaowemi </a>/ <a href=\"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/deed.en\" rel=\"noopener noreferrer\" target=\"_blank\">CC BY-SA 3.0</a></em>\n    </div>\n<div class=\"body js-expandable clearfix js-listicle-body js-update-url css-listicle-body-2639302104\"\n        \n            data-elid=\"2639302104\"\n            \n                data-authors=\"Jordan Davidson\"\n            \n            \n                data-headline=\"Zara Pledges to Make All Its Clothes From Sustainable Fabrics by 2025\"\n            \n        >\n\n        <div class=\"body-description\" ><div class=\"widget__brief\"><p>Green is the new black at Zara. </p>\n<p>T"], "copyright__copyright__copyright": ["ced by 2025, as CNN reported.\n\nRead More Show Less\nPexels\n\nBy Gavin Van De Walle, MS, RD\n\nWhether you enjoy running recreationally, competitively, or as part of your overall wellness goals, it's a great way to improve your heart health.\n\nRead More Show Less\nText from the plaque that will mark the site where Ok glacier once was. Rice University\n\nBy Andrea Germanos\n\nA climate change victim in Iceland is set to be memorialized with a monument that underscores the urgent crisis.\n\nRead More Show Less", "ced by 2025, as CNN reported.\n\nRead More Show Less\nPexels\n\nBy Gavin Van De Walle, MS, RD\n\nWhether you enjoy running recreationally, competitively, or as part of your overall wellness goals, it's a great way to improve your heart health.\n\nRead More Show Less\nText from the plaque that will mark the site where Ok glacier once was. Rice University\n\nBy Andrea Germanos\n\nA climate change victim in Iceland is set to be memorialized with a monument that underscores the urgent crisis.\n\nRead More Show Less", "ced by 2025, as CNN reported.\n\nRead More Show Less\nPexels\n\nBy Gavin Van De Walle, MS, RD\n\nWhether you enjoy running recreationally, competitively, or as part of your overall wellness goals, it's a great way to improve your heart health.\n\nRead More Show Less\nText from the plaque that will mark the site where Ok glacier once was. Rice University\n\nBy Andrea Germanos\n\nA climate change victim in Iceland is set to be memorialized with a monument that underscores the urgent crisis.\n\nRead More Show Less", "ced by 2025, as CNN reported.\n\nRead More Show Less\nPexels\n\nBy Gavin Van De Walle, MS, RD\n\nWhether you enjoy running recreationally, competitively, or as part of your overall wellness goals, it's a great way to improve your heart health.\n\nRead More Show Less\nText from the plaque that will mark the site where Ok glacier once was. Rice University\n\nBy Andrea Germanos\n\nA climate change victim in Iceland is set to be memorialized with a monument that underscores the urgent crisis.\n\nRead More Show Less", "ced by 2025, as CNN reported.\n\nRead More Show Less\nPexels\n\nBy Gavin Van De Walle, MS, RD\n\nWhether you enjoy running recreationally, competitively, or as part of your overall wellness goals, it's a great way to improve your heart health.\n\nRead More Show Less\nText from the plaque that will mark the site where Ok glacier once was. Rice University\n\nBy Andrea Germanos\n\nA climate change victim in Iceland is set to be memorialized with a monument that underscores the urgent crisis.\n\nRead More Show Less"]}