Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question
Q18127927
P19
Q56061
USER
Which administrative territory was Xhevdet Shabani born at ?
(Q18127927,P19,c(Q56061))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q18127927
relation P19
type Q56061
['Q18127927', 'P19', {'concept': 'Q56061'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Q18127927 property:P19 ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:Q56061 }
Xhevdet Shabani
action filter_type
action find
entity Xhevdet Shabani
relation place of birth
type administrative territorial entity
['Xhevdet Shabani', 'place of birth', {'concept': 'administrative territorial entity'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:place_of_birth ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:administrative_territorial_entity }
[]
administrative territorial entity
Q248378
SYSTEM
Kačanik
Q248378
(Q18127927,P19,c(Q56061))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q18127927
relation P19
type Q56061
Xhevdet Shabani was born in [ANSWER]
['Q18127927', 'P19', {'concept': 'Q56061'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Q18127927 property:P19 ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:Q56061 }
Kačanik
Xhevdet Shabani was born in Kačanik
Kačanik
action filter_type
action find
entity Xhevdet Shabani
relation place of birth
type administrative territorial entity
['Xhevdet Shabani', 'place of birth', {'concept': 'administrative territorial entity'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:place_of_birth ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:administrative_territorial_entity }
[]
Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question|Single Entity
Q18127927
P106
Q12737077
USER
What is the profession of Xhevdet Shabani ?
(Q18127927,P106,c(Q12737077))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q18127927
relation P106
type Q12737077
['Q18127927', 'P106', {'concept': 'Q12737077'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Q18127927 property:P106 ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q12737077 }
Xhevdet Shabani
action filter_type
action find
entity Xhevdet Shabani
relation occupation
type occupation
['Xhevdet Shabani', 'occupation', {'concept': 'occupation'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:occupation ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:occupation }
[]
occupation
Q937857
SYSTEM
association football player
Q937857
(Q18127927,P106,c(Q12737077))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q18127927
relation P106
type Q12737077
The profession of Xhevdet Shabani is an [ANSWER]
['Q18127927', 'P106', {'concept': 'Q12737077'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Q18127927 property:P106 ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q12737077 }
association football player
The profession of Xhevdet Shabani is an association football player
association football player
action filter_type
action find
entity Xhevdet Shabani
relation occupation
type occupation
['Xhevdet Shabani', 'occupation', {'concept': 'occupation'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:occupation ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:occupation }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|2 entities, one direct and one indirect, object is indirect
Q937857 Q1407449
P106
Q502895
USER
Does William Cullom have career as that occupation ?
(Q1407449,P106,Q937857)
action is_in
entity Q1407449
action find
entity Q937857
relation P106
['Q1407449', 'P106', 'Q937857']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q937857 property:P106 resource:Q1407449 }
association football player William Cullom
action is_in
entity William Cullom
action find
entity association football player
relation occupation
['William Cullom', 'occupation', 'association football player']
ASK WHERE { resource:association_football_player property:occupation resource:William_Cullom }
[]
common name
SYSTEM
NO
(Q1407449,P106,Q937857)
action is_in
entity Q1407449
action find
entity Q937857
relation P106
[ANSWER]
['Q1407449', 'P106', 'Q937857']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q937857 property:P106 resource:Q1407449 }
No
action is_in
entity William Cullom
action find
entity association football player
relation occupation
['William Cullom', 'occupation', 'association football player']
ASK WHERE { resource:association_football_player property:occupation resource:William_Cullom }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|3 entities, all direct, 2 are query entities
Q18127927 Q6727163 Q551697
P27
Q15617994
USER
Is Xhevdet Shabani a civilian of Maders and Griesstätt ?
(Q18127927,P27,Q6727163) (Q18127927,P27,Q551697)
action is_in
entity Q18127927
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q6727163
relation P27
action find_reverse
entity Q551697
relation P27
['Q18127927', 'P27', 'Q6727163'] ['Q18127927', 'P27', 'Q551697']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q18127927 property:P27 resource:Q6727163 . resource:Q18127927 property:P27 resource:Q551697 }
Xhevdet Shabani Maders Griesstätt
action is_in
entity Xhevdet Shabani
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Maders
relation country of citizenship
action find_reverse
entity Griesstätt
relation country of citizenship
['Xhevdet Shabani', 'country of citizenship', 'Maders'] ['Xhevdet Shabani', 'country of citizenship', 'Griesstätt']
ASK WHERE { resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:country_of_citizenship resource:Maders . resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:country_of_citizenship resource:Griesstätt }
[]
designation for an administrative territorial entity
SYSTEM
NO
(Q18127927,P27,Q6727163) (Q18127927,P27,Q551697)
action is_in
entity Q18127927
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q6727163
relation P27
action find_reverse
entity Q551697
relation P27
[ANSWER]
['Q18127927', 'P27', 'Q6727163'] ['Q18127927', 'P27', 'Q551697']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q18127927 property:P27 resource:Q6727163 . resource:Q18127927 property:P27 resource:Q551697 }
No
action is_in
entity Xhevdet Shabani
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Maders
relation country of citizenship
action find_reverse
entity Griesstätt
relation country of citizenship
['Xhevdet Shabani', 'country of citizenship', 'Maders'] ['Xhevdet Shabani', 'country of citizenship', 'Griesstätt']
ASK WHERE { resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:country_of_citizenship resource:Maders . resource:Xhevdet_Shabani property:country_of_citizenship resource:Griesstätt }
[]
Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question|Single Entity
Q937857
P361
Q847017
USER
Which sports club is association football player a part of ?
(Q937857,P361,c(Q847017))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q937857
relation P361
type Q847017
['Q937857', 'P361', {'concept': 'Q847017'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { resource:Q937857 property:P361 ?q . ?q rdf:type ontology:Q847017 }
association football player
action filter_type
action find
entity association football player
relation part of
type sports club
['association football player', 'part of', {'concept': 'sports club'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { resource:association_football_player property:part_of ?q . ?q rdf:type ontology:sports_club }
[]
sports club
Q476028
SYSTEM
association football club
Q476028
(Q937857,P361,c(Q847017))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q937857
relation P361
type Q847017
Club [ANSWER] is association football player a part of
['Q937857', 'P361', {'concept': 'Q847017'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { resource:Q937857 property:P361 ?q . ?q rdf:type ontology:Q847017 }
association football club
Club association football club is association football player a part of
association football club
action filter_type
action find
entity association football player
relation part of
type sports club
['association football player', 'part of', {'concept': 'sports club'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { resource:association_football_player property:part_of ?q . ?q rdf:type ontology:sports_club }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Single entity type
Q576926
P1923
Q847017 Q1478437
USER
Which football tournaments did more number of sports clubs contest in than 2006 Russian Premier League ?
(c(Q1478437),P1923,c(Q847017))
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation P1923
type Q1478437
type Q847017
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q576926
relation P1923
type Q1478437
[{'concept': 'Q1478437'}, 'P1923', {'concept': 'Q847017'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?t ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?g ) WHERE { ?t property:P1923 ?p . ?p rdf:type ontology:Q847017 . ?t rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 } GROUP BY ?t } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?l ) AS ?u ) WHERE { resource:Q576926 property:P1923 ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 } } . FILTER ( ?g > ?u ) }
2006 Russian Premier League
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation participating teams
type football tournament
type sports club
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity 2006 Russian Premier League
relation participating teams
type football tournament
[{'concept': 'football tournament'}, 'participating teams', {'concept': 'sports club'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?t ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?g ) WHERE { ?t property:participating_teams ?p . ?p rdf:type ontology:sports_club . ?t rdf:type ontology:football_tournament } GROUP BY ?t } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?l ) AS ?u ) WHERE { resource:2006_Russian_Premier_League property:participating_teams ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:football_tournament } } . FILTER ( ?g > ?u ) }
[]
sports club football tournament
Q19915706 Q13410151 Q16466751
SYSTEM
2015–16 Russian Premier League, Russian football championship 2013–14, 2014–15 Russian Premier League
Q19915706 Q377902 Q13410151 Q539530 Q16466751 Q933610 Q301194 Q697143 Q1084791
(c(Q1478437),P1923,c(Q847017))
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation P1923
type Q1478437
type Q847017
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q576926
relation P1923
type Q1478437
[ANSWERS] more number of sports clubs contested in than 2006 Russian Premier League
[{'concept': 'Q1478437'}, 'P1923', {'concept': 'Q847017'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?t ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?g ) WHERE { ?t property:P1923 ?p . ?p rdf:type ontology:Q847017 . ?t rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 } GROUP BY ?t } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?l ) AS ?u ) WHERE { resource:Q576926 property:P1923 ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 } } . FILTER ( ?g > ?u ) }
2015–16 Russian Premier League 2012–13 Russian Premier League Russian football championship 2013–14 2011–12 Russian Premier League 2014–15 Russian Premier League 2010 Russian Premier League 2008 Russian Premier League 2005 Russian Premier League 2009 Russian Premier League
2015–16 Russian Premier League, Russian football championship 2013–14 and 2014–15 Russian Premier League more number of sports clubs contested in than 2006 Russian Premier League
2015–16 Russian Premier League Russian football championship 2013–14 2014–15 Russian Premier League
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation participating teams
type football tournament
type sports club
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity 2006 Russian Premier League
relation participating teams
type football tournament
[{'concept': 'football tournament'}, 'participating teams', {'concept': 'sports club'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?t ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?g ) WHERE { ?t property:participating_teams ?p . ?p rdf:type ontology:sports_club . ?t rdf:type ontology:football_tournament } GROUP BY ?t } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?l ) AS ?u ) WHERE { resource:2006_Russian_Premier_League property:participating_teams ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:football_tournament } } . FILTER ( ?g > ?u ) }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Single entity type|Incomplete
Q1229493
P1923
Q847017 Q1478437
USER
And also tell me about 1992 Russian Top League?
(c(Q1478437),P1923,c(Q847017))
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation P1923
type Q1478437
type Q847017
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q1229493
relation P1923
type Q1478437
[{'concept': 'Q1478437'}, 'P1923', {'concept': 'Q847017'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?d ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?f ) WHERE { ?d property:P1923 ?a . ?d rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q847017 } GROUP BY ?d } . FILTER ( ?f > ?w ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?j ) AS ?w ) WHERE { resource:Q1229493 property:P1923 ?j . ?j rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 } } }
1992 Russian Top League
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation participating teams
type football tournament
type sports club
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity 1992 Russian Top League
relation participating teams
type football tournament
[{'concept': 'football tournament'}, 'participating teams', {'concept': 'sports club'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?d ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?f ) WHERE { ?d property:participating_teams ?a . ?d rdf:type ontology:football_tournament . ?a rdf:type ontology:sports_club } GROUP BY ?d } . FILTER ( ?f > ?w ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?j ) AS ?w ) WHERE { resource:1992_Russian_Top_League property:participating_teams ?j . ?j rdf:type ontology:football_tournament } } }
[]
sports club football tournament
Q19915706 Q13410151 Q16466751
SYSTEM
2015–16 Russian Premier League, Russian football championship 2013–14, 2014–15 Russian Premier League
Q19915706 Q377902 Q13410151 Q539530 Q16466751 Q933610 Q301194 Q697143 Q1084791
(c(Q1478437),P1923,c(Q847017))
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation P1923
type Q1478437
type Q847017
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q1229493
relation P1923
type Q1478437
[ANSWERS]
[{'concept': 'Q1478437'}, 'P1923', {'concept': 'Q847017'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?d ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?f ) WHERE { ?d property:P1923 ?a . ?d rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q847017 } GROUP BY ?d } . FILTER ( ?f > ?w ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?j ) AS ?w ) WHERE { resource:Q1229493 property:P1923 ?j . ?j rdf:type ontology:Q1478437 } } }
2015–16 Russian Premier League 2012–13 Russian Premier League Russian football championship 2013–14 2011–12 Russian Premier League 2014–15 Russian Premier League 2010 Russian Premier League 2008 Russian Premier League 2005 Russian Premier League 2009 Russian Premier League
2015–16 Russian Premier League Russian football championship 2013–14 2014–15 Russian Premier League
action greater
action find_tuple_counts
relation participating teams
type football tournament
type sports club
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity 1992 Russian Top League
relation participating teams
type football tournament
[{'concept': 'football tournament'}, 'participating teams', {'concept': 'sports club'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?d ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?f ) WHERE { ?d property:participating_teams ?a . ?d rdf:type ontology:football_tournament . ?a rdf:type ontology:sports_club } GROUP BY ?d } . FILTER ( ?f > ?w ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?j ) AS ?w ) WHERE { resource:1992_Russian_Top_League property:participating_teams ?j . ?j rdf:type ontology:football_tournament } } }
[]
Clarification
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q13410151
P641
Q349
USER
Which sport was that football tournament a part of ?
(Q13410151,P641,c(Q349))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q13410151
relation P641
type Q349
['Q13410151', 'P641', {'concept': 'Q349'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { ?t rdf:type ontology:Q349 . resource:Q13410151 property:P641 ?t }
Russian football championship 2013–14
action filter_type
action find
entity Russian football championship 2013–14
relation sport
type sport
['Russian football championship 2013–14', 'sport', {'concept': 'sport'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { ?t rdf:type ontology:sport . resource:Russian_football_championship_2013–14 property:sport ?t }
[]
sport
Clarification for simple ques.
Q16466751
SYSTEM
Did you mean 2014–15 Russian Premier League ?
Q19915706 Q13410151 Q16466751
(Q19915706,P641,c(Q349)) (Q13410151,P641,c(Q349)) (Q16466751,P641,c(Q349))
[ANSWER]
['Q19915706', 'P641', {'concept': 'Q349'}] ['Q13410151', 'P641', {'concept': 'Q349'}] ['Q16466751', 'P641', {'concept': 'Q349'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { ?t rdf:type ontology:Q349 . resource:Q13410151 property:P641 ?t }
2015–16 Russian Premier League Russian football championship 2013–14 2014–15 Russian Premier League
Did you mean 2014–15 Russian Premier League ?
2014–15 Russian Premier League
['2015–16 Russian Premier League', 'sport', {'concept': 'sport'}] ['Russian football championship 2013–14', 'sport', {'concept': 'sport'}] ['2014–15 Russian Premier League', 'sport', {'concept': 'sport'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { ?t rdf:type ontology:sport . resource:Russian_football_championship_2013–14 property:sport ?t }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
USER
No, I meant Russian football championship 2013–14. Could you tell me the answer for that?
(Q13410151,P641,c(Q349))
Q13410151
['Q13410151', 'P641', {'concept': 'Q349'}]
['Russian football championship 2013–14', 'sport', {'concept': 'sport'}]
[]
Q2736
SYSTEM
association football
Q2736
(Q13410151,P641,c(Q349))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q13410151
relation P641
type Q349
As [ANSWER] was that football tournament a part of
['Q13410151', 'P641', {'concept': 'Q349'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { ?t rdf:type ontology:Q349 . resource:Q13410151 property:P641 ?t }
association football
As association football was that football tournament a part of
association football
action filter_type
action find
entity Russian football championship 2013–14
relation sport
type sport
['Russian football championship 2013–14', 'sport', {'concept': 'sport'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { ?t rdf:type ontology:sport . resource:Russian_football_championship_2013–14 property:sport ?t }
[]