Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question
Q5229525
P19
Q56061
USER
Where was Dave Parks born ?
(Q5229525,P19,c(Q56061))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q5229525
relation P19
type Q56061
['Q5229525', 'P19', {'concept': 'Q56061'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:Q56061 . resource:Q5229525 property:P19 ?i }
Dave Parks
action filter_type
action find
entity Dave Parks
relation place of birth
type administrative territorial entity
['Dave Parks', 'place of birth', {'concept': 'administrative territorial entity'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:administrative_territorial_entity . resource:Dave_Parks property:place_of_birth ?i }
[]
administrative territorial entity
Q981829
SYSTEM
Muenster
Q981829
(Q5229525,P19,c(Q56061))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q5229525
relation P19
type Q56061
Dave Parks was born in [ANSWER]
['Q5229525', 'P19', {'concept': 'Q56061'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:Q56061 . resource:Q5229525 property:P19 ?i }
Muenster
Dave Parks was born in Muenster
Muenster
action filter_type
action find
entity Dave Parks
relation place of birth
type administrative territorial entity
['Dave Parks', 'place of birth', {'concept': 'administrative territorial entity'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:administrative_territorial_entity . resource:Dave_Parks property:place_of_birth ?i }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|3 entities, 2 direct, 2(direct) are query entities, subject is indirect
Q981829 Q30 Q5638719
P17
Q15617994
USER
Is that administrative territory located in United States of America and Haghill ?
(Q981829,P17,Q30) (Q981829,P17,Q5638719)
action is_in
entity Q981829
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q30
relation P17
action find_reverse
entity Q5638719
relation P17
['Q981829', 'P17', 'Q30'] ['Q981829', 'P17', 'Q5638719']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q981829 property:P17 resource:Q30 . resource:Q981829 property:P17 resource:Q5638719 }
Muenster United States of America Haghill
action is_in
entity Muenster
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity United States of America
relation country
action find_reverse
entity Haghill
relation country
['Muenster', 'country', 'United States of America'] ['Muenster', 'country', 'Haghill']
ASK WHERE { resource:Muenster property:country resource:United_States_of_America . resource:Muenster property:country resource:Haghill }
[]
designation for an administrative territorial entity
SYSTEM
YES and NO respectively
(Q981829,P17,Q30) (Q981829,P17,Q5638719)
action is_in
entity Q981829
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q30
relation P17
action find_reverse
entity Q5638719
relation P17
[ANSWER]
['Q981829', 'P17', 'Q30'] ['Q981829', 'P17', 'Q5638719']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q981829 property:P17 resource:Q30 . resource:Q981829 property:P17 resource:Q5638719 }
YES and NO respectively
action is_in
entity Muenster
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity United States of America
relation country
action find_reverse
entity Haghill
relation country
['Muenster', 'country', 'United States of America'] ['Muenster', 'country', 'Haghill']
ASK WHERE { resource:Muenster property:country resource:United_States_of_America . resource:Muenster property:country resource:Haghill }
[]
Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question|Single Entity
Q19080971
P1433
Q5292
USER
Which encyclopedia has Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00) in it ?
(Q19080971,P1433,c(Q5292))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19080971
relation P1433
type Q5292
['Q19080971', 'P1433', {'concept': 'Q5292'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Q19080971 property:P1433 ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q5292 }
Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00)
action filter_type
action find
entity Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00)
relation published in
type encyclopedia
['Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00)', 'published in', {'concept': 'encyclopedia'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Dethick,_Gilbert_(DNB00) property:published_in ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:encyclopedia }
[]
encyclopedia
Q15987216
SYSTEM
Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)
Q15987216
(Q19080971,P1433,c(Q5292))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19080971
relation P1433
type Q5292
[ANSWER] has Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00) in it
['Q19080971', 'P1433', {'concept': 'Q5292'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Q19080971 property:P1433 ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q5292 }
Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)
Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900) has Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00) in it
Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)
action filter_type
action find
entity Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00)
relation published in
type encyclopedia
['Dethick, Gilbert (DNB00)', 'published in', {'concept': 'encyclopedia'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Dethick,_Gilbert_(DNB00) property:published_in ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:encyclopedia }
[]
Simple Question (Ellipsis)
only subject is changed, parent and predicate remains same
Q19094995
Q5292
USER
And how about Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)?
(Q19094995,P1433,c(Q5292))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19094995
relation P1433
type Q5292
['Q19094995', 'P1433', {'concept': 'Q5292'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { resource:Q19094995 property:P1433 ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:Q5292 }
Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
action filter_type
action find
entity Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
relation published in
type encyclopedia
['Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)', 'published in', {'concept': 'encyclopedia'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { resource:Reid,_John_(1809-1849)_(DNB00) property:published_in ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:encyclopedia }
[]
encyclopedia
Q15987216
SYSTEM
Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)
Q15987216
(Q19094995,P1433,c(Q5292))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19094995
relation P1433
type Q5292
[ANSWER]
['Q19094995', 'P1433', {'concept': 'Q5292'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { resource:Q19094995 property:P1433 ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:Q5292 }
Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)
Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)
action filter_type
action find
entity Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
relation published in
type encyclopedia
['Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)', 'published in', {'concept': 'encyclopedia'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { resource:Reid,_John_(1809-1849)_(DNB00) property:published_in ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:encyclopedia }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q19094995
P50
Q502895
USER
Who was the writer of that article ?
(Q15987216,P50,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19094995
relation P50
type Q502895
['Q15987216', 'P50', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Q19094995 property:P50 ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:Q502895 }
Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
action filter_type
action find
entity Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
relation author
type common name
['Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)', 'author', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Reid,_John_(1809-1849)_(DNB00) property:author ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:common_name }
[]
common name
Q15627255
SYSTEM
Alexander Hastie Millar
Q15627255
(Q15987216,P50,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19094995
relation P50
type Q502895
The writer of that article was [ANSWER]
['Q15987216', 'P50', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Q19094995 property:P50 ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:Q502895 }
Alexander Hastie Millar
The writer of that article was Alexander Hastie Millar
Alexander Hastie Millar
action filter_type
action find
entity Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
relation author
type common name
['Dictionary of National Biography (1885-1900)', 'author', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Reid,_John_(1809-1849)_(DNB00) property:author ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:common_name }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q19094995
P921
Q502895
USER
What was that article mainly about ?
(Q15627255,P921,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19094995
relation P921
type Q502895
['Q15627255', 'P921', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?l WHERE { resource:Q19094995 property:P921 ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:Q502895 }
Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
action filter_type
action find
entity Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
relation main subject
type common name
['Alexander Hastie Millar', 'main subject', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?l WHERE { resource:Reid,_John_(1809-1849)_(DNB00) property:main_subject ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:common_name }
[]
common name
Q14949010
SYSTEM
John Reid
Q14949010
(Q15627255,P921,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19094995
relation P921
type Q502895
Mainly that article was by [ANSWER] about
['Q15627255', 'P921', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?l WHERE { resource:Q19094995 property:P921 ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:Q502895 }
John Reid
Mainly that article was by John Reid about
John Reid
action filter_type
action find
entity Reid, John (1809-1849) (DNB00)
relation main subject
type common name
['Alexander Hastie Millar', 'main subject', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?l WHERE { resource:Reid,_John_(1809-1849)_(DNB00) property:main_subject ?l . ?l rdf:type ontology:common_name }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Mult. entity type
Q17625628
P608
Q2668072 Q1656682 Q502895
USER
Which people were exhibited at lesser number of collections and events than Deborah De Robertis ?
(c(Q502895),P608,c(Q2668072)|c(Q1656682))
action less
action union
action find_tuple_counts
relation P608
type Q502895
type Q2668072
action find_tuple_counts
relation P608
type Q502895
type Q1656682
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find
entity Q17625628
relation P608
type Q2668072
type Q1656682
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P608', [{'concept': 'Q2668072'}, {'concept': 'Q1656682'}]]
SELECT DISTINCT ?b WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?b ( COUNT ( ?t ) AS ?o ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?j ) { ( ontology:Q2668072 ) ( ontology:Q1656682 ) } . ?t rdf:type ?j } GROUP BY ?b } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Q17625628 property:P608 ?y . { { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q1656682 } UNION { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q2668072 } } } } . FILTER ( ?o < ?a ) }
Deborah De Robertis
action less
action union
action find_tuple_counts
relation exhibition history
type common name
type collection
action find_tuple_counts
relation exhibition history
type common name
type event
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find
entity Deborah De Robertis
relation exhibition history
type collection
type event
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'exhibition history', [{'concept': 'collection'}, {'concept': 'event'}]]
SELECT DISTINCT ?b WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?b ( COUNT ( ?t ) AS ?o ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?j ) { ( ontology:collection ) ( ontology:event ) } . ?t rdf:type ?j } GROUP BY ?b } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Deborah_De_Robertis property:exhibition_history ?y . { { ?y rdf:type ontology:event } UNION { ?y rdf:type ontology:collection } } } } . FILTER ( ?o < ?a ) }
[]
collection event common name
Q5040332 Q55192 Q4945678
SYSTEM
Carl Holty, Gertrude Abercrombie, Martha Edelheit
Q70006 Q6196481 Q4945678 Q16004451 Q4648360 Q7649008 Q16858002 Q6990118 Q16005428 Q27505608 Q15734237 Q2965423 Q5040332 Q6687160 Q5375139 Q16121375 Q55192 Q16968866
(c(Q502895),P608,c(Q2668072)|c(Q1656682))
action less
action union
action find_tuple_counts
relation P608
type Q502895
type Q2668072
action find_tuple_counts
relation P608
type Q502895
type Q1656682
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find
entity Q17625628
relation P608
type Q2668072
type Q1656682
[ANSWERS] were exhibited at lesser number of collections and events than Deborah De Robertis
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P608', [{'concept': 'Q2668072'}, {'concept': 'Q1656682'}]]
SELECT DISTINCT ?b WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?b ( COUNT ( ?t ) AS ?o ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?j ) { ( ontology:Q2668072 ) ( ontology:Q1656682 ) } . ?t rdf:type ?j } GROUP BY ?b } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Q17625628 property:P608 ?y . { { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q1656682 } UNION { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q2668072 } } } } . FILTER ( ?o < ?a ) }
Lotte Jacobi Jim Love Martha Edelheit Jennifer Bolande A. S. Baylinson Susie Bootja Bootja Napaltjarri Anne Mee Nellie Mae Rowe Andrea Bowers Wolfgang Sellinger Tony van Alphen Christian Lhopital Carl Holty Louis Ferstadt Ena Swansea Judith Lowry Gertrude Abercrombie Lydia Schouten
Carl Holty, Gertrude Abercrombie and Martha Edelheit were exhibited at lesser number of collections and events than Deborah De Robertis
Carl Holty Gertrude Abercrombie Martha Edelheit
action less
action union
action find_tuple_counts
relation exhibition history
type common name
type collection
action find_tuple_counts
relation exhibition history
type common name
type event
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find
entity Deborah De Robertis
relation exhibition history
type collection
type event
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'exhibition history', [{'concept': 'collection'}, {'concept': 'event'}]]
SELECT DISTINCT ?b WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?b ( COUNT ( ?t ) AS ?o ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?j ) { ( ontology:collection ) ( ontology:event ) } . ?t rdf:type ?j } GROUP BY ?b } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Deborah_De_Robertis property:exhibition_history ?y . { { ?y rdf:type ontology:event } UNION { ?y rdf:type ontology:collection } } } } . FILTER ( ?o < ?a ) }
[]
Clarification
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q55192
P69
Q3918
USER
Which university was that person educated at ?
(Q55192,P69,c(Q3918))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q55192
relation P69
type Q3918
['Q55192', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q3918'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?n WHERE { resource:Q55192 property:P69 ?n . ?n rdf:type ontology:Q3918 }
Gertrude Abercrombie
action filter_type
action find
entity Gertrude Abercrombie
relation educated at
type university
['Gertrude Abercrombie', 'educated at', {'concept': 'university'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?n WHERE { resource:Gertrude_Abercrombie property:educated_at ?n . ?n rdf:type ontology:university }
[]
university
Clarification for simple ques.
Q55192
SYSTEM
Did you mean Gertrude Abercrombie ?
Q5040332 Q55192 Q4945678
(Q5040332,P69,c(Q3918)) (Q55192,P69,c(Q3918)) (Q4945678,P69,c(Q3918))
[ANSWER]
['Q5040332', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q3918'}] ['Q55192', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q3918'}] ['Q4945678', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q3918'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?n WHERE { resource:Q55192 property:P69 ?n . ?n rdf:type ontology:Q3918 }
Carl Holty Gertrude Abercrombie Martha Edelheit
Did you mean Gertrude Abercrombie ?
Gertrude Abercrombie
['Carl Holty', 'educated at', {'concept': 'university'}] ['Gertrude Abercrombie', 'educated at', {'concept': 'university'}] ['Martha Edelheit', 'educated at', {'concept': 'university'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?n WHERE { resource:Gertrude_Abercrombie property:educated_at ?n . ?n rdf:type ontology:university }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
USER
Yes
(Q55192,P69,c(Q3918))
['Q55192', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q3918'}]
['Gertrude Abercrombie', 'educated at', {'concept': 'university'}]
[]
Q457281
SYSTEM
University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
Q457281
(Q55192,P69,c(Q3918))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q55192
relation P69
type Q3918
That person was educated by [ANSWER]
['Q55192', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q3918'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?n WHERE { resource:Q55192 property:P69 ?n . ?n rdf:type ontology:Q3918 }
University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
That person was educated by University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
action filter_type
action find
entity Gertrude Abercrombie
relation educated at
type university
['Gertrude Abercrombie', 'educated at', {'concept': 'university'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?n WHERE { resource:Gertrude_Abercrombie property:educated_at ?n . ?n rdf:type ontology:university }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|2 entities, one direct and one indirect, object is indirect
Q457281 Q4300810
P108
Q502895
USER
Is Donald Burkholder working for that university ?
(Q4300810,P108,Q457281)
action is_in
entity Q457281
action find
entity Q4300810
relation P108
['Q4300810', 'P108', 'Q457281']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q4300810 property:P108 resource:Q457281 }
University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign Donald Burkholder
action is_in
entity University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
action find
entity Donald Burkholder
relation employer
['Donald Burkholder', 'employer', 'University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign']
ASK WHERE { resource:Donald_Burkholder property:employer resource:University_of_Illinois_at_Urbana–Champaign }
[]
common name
SYSTEM
YES
(Q4300810,P108,Q457281)
action is_in
entity Q457281
action find
entity Q4300810
relation P108
[ANSWER]
['Q4300810', 'P108', 'Q457281']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q4300810 property:P108 resource:Q457281 }
Yes
action is_in
entity University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
action find
entity Donald Burkholder
relation employer
['Donald Burkholder', 'employer', 'University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign']
ASK WHERE { resource:Donald_Burkholder property:employer resource:University_of_Illinois_at_Urbana–Champaign }
[]