Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question
Q21869369
P364
Q11028
USER
Which information is considered to be the original language of creation of Gentleman on Time ?
(Q21869369,P364,c(Q11028))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q21869369
relation P364
type Q11028
['Q21869369', 'P364', {'concept': 'Q11028'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?o WHERE { resource:Q21869369 property:P364 ?o . ?o rdf:type ontology:Q11028 }
Gentleman on Time
action filter_type
action find
entity Gentleman on Time
relation original language of work
type information
['Gentleman on Time', 'original language of work', {'concept': 'information'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?o WHERE { resource:Gentleman_on_Time property:original_language_of_work ?o . ?o rdf:type ontology:information }
[]
information
Q21686005
SYSTEM
n/a (silent film)
Q21686005
(Q21869369,P364,c(Q11028))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q21869369
relation P364
type Q11028
[ANSWER] is considered to be the original language of creation of Gentleman on Time
['Q21869369', 'P364', {'concept': 'Q11028'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?o WHERE { resource:Q21869369 property:P364 ?o . ?o rdf:type ontology:Q11028 }
n/a (silent film)
N/a (silent film) is considered to be the original language of creation of Gentleman on Time
n/a (silent film)
action filter_type
action find
entity Gentleman on Time
relation original language of work
type information
['Gentleman on Time', 'original language of work', {'concept': 'information'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?o WHERE { resource:Gentleman_on_Time property:original_language_of_work ?o . ?o rdf:type ontology:information }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q21869369
P57
Q502895
USER
Who was the director of that work of art ?
(Q21686005,P57,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q21869369
relation P57
type Q502895
['Q21686005', 'P57', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k rdf:type ontology:Q502895 . resource:Q21869369 property:P57 ?k }
Gentleman on Time
action filter_type
action find
entity Gentleman on Time
relation director
type common name
['n/a (silent film)', 'director', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k rdf:type ontology:common_name . resource:Gentleman_on_Time property:director ?k }
[]
common name
Q1699196
SYSTEM
Karl Gerhardt
Q1699196
(Q21686005,P57,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q21869369
relation P57
type Q502895
The director of that work of art was the [ANSWER]
['Q21686005', 'P57', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k rdf:type ontology:Q502895 . resource:Q21869369 property:P57 ?k }
Karl Gerhardt
The director of that work of art was the Karl Gerhardt
Karl Gerhardt
action filter_type
action find
entity Gentleman on Time
relation director
type common name
['n/a (silent film)', 'director', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k rdf:type ontology:common_name . resource:Gentleman_on_Time property:director ?k }
[]
Quantitative Reasoning (All)
Quantitative|Min/Max|Mult. entity type
P144
Q11028 Q838948 Q3305213
USER
Which information do max number of works of art and paintings extend upon ?
(c(Q838948)|c(Q3305213),P144,c(Q11028))
action argmax
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q3305213
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q3305213'}], 'P144', {'concept': 'Q11028'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( MAX ( ?l ) AS ?y ) { SELECT DISTINCT ?q ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?l ) WHERE { ?a rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q3305213 ) } } GROUP BY ?q } } . FILTER ( ?z = ?y ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ?v ( COUNT ( ?e ) AS ?z ) WHERE { { ?e property:P144 ?v . ?e rdf:type ontology:Q838948 . ?v rdf:type ontology:Q11028 } UNION { ?e property:P144 ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:Q11028 . ?e rdf:type ontology:Q3305213 } } GROUP BY ?v } }
action argmax
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type painting
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'painting'}], 'based on', {'concept': 'information'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( MAX ( ?l ) AS ?y ) { SELECT DISTINCT ?q ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?l ) WHERE { ?a rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:painting ) } } GROUP BY ?q } } . FILTER ( ?z = ?y ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ?v ( COUNT ( ?e ) AS ?z ) WHERE { { ?e property:based_on ?v . ?e rdf:type ontology:work_of_art . ?v rdf:type ontology:information } UNION { ?e property:based_on ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:information . ?e rdf:type ontology:painting } } GROUP BY ?v } }
[]
information work of art painting
Q9309699
SYSTEM
Madonna and Child
Q9309699
(c(Q838948)|c(Q3305213),P144,c(Q11028))
action argmax
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q3305213
Max number of works of art and paintings extend to [ANSWER]
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q3305213'}], 'P144', {'concept': 'Q11028'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( MAX ( ?l ) AS ?y ) { SELECT DISTINCT ?q ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?l ) WHERE { ?a rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q3305213 ) } } GROUP BY ?q } } . FILTER ( ?z = ?y ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ?v ( COUNT ( ?e ) AS ?z ) WHERE { { ?e property:P144 ?v . ?e rdf:type ontology:Q838948 . ?v rdf:type ontology:Q11028 } UNION { ?e property:P144 ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:Q11028 . ?e rdf:type ontology:Q3305213 } } GROUP BY ?v } }
Madonna and Child
Max number of works of art and paintings extend to Madonna and Child
Madonna and Child
action argmax
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type painting
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'painting'}], 'based on', {'concept': 'information'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?v WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( MAX ( ?l ) AS ?y ) { SELECT DISTINCT ?q ( COUNT ( ?a ) AS ?l ) WHERE { ?a rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:painting ) } } GROUP BY ?q } } . FILTER ( ?z = ?y ) . { SELECT DISTINCT ?v ( COUNT ( ?e ) AS ?z ) WHERE { { ?e property:based_on ?v . ?e rdf:type ontology:work_of_art . ?v rdf:type ontology:information } UNION { ?e property:based_on ?v . ?v rdf:type ontology:information . ?e rdf:type ontology:painting } } GROUP BY ?v } }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Mult. entity type|Indirect
P144
Q11028 Q838948 Q15850590
USER
Which information do less number of works of art or theatrical genres extend upon than that information ?
(c(Q838948)|c(Q15850590),P144,c(Q11028))
action less
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q15850590
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Q9309699
relation P144
type Q838948
type Q15850590
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q15850590'}], 'P144', {'concept': 'Q11028'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?s WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?k ) ?s WHERE { ?p rdf:type ?a . VALUES ( ?a ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q15850590 ) } } GROUP BY ?s } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?r ) AS ?b ) WHERE { ?r property:P144 resource:Q9309699 . { ?r rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q15850590 ) } } } } . FILTER ( ?k < ?b ) }
action less
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type theatrical genre
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Madonna and Child
relation based on
type work of art
type theatrical genre
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'theatrical genre'}], 'based on', {'concept': 'information'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?s WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?k ) ?s WHERE { ?p rdf:type ?a . VALUES ( ?a ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:theatrical_genre ) } } GROUP BY ?s } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?r ) AS ?b ) WHERE { ?r property:based_on resource:Madonna_and_Child . { ?r rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:theatrical_genre ) } } } } . FILTER ( ?k < ?b ) }
[]
information work of art theatrical genre
Q483760 Q633534 Q51633
SYSTEM
Venus Anadyomene, Death of Cleopatra, Last Supper
Q625140 Q1821239 Q633534 Q483760 Q389211 Q1029715 Q13077250 Q5989722 Q3530155 Q2330123 Q124362 Q1005362 Q370665 Q1351991 Q494762 Q51633 Q488841 Q1004401 Q2509393 Q1029378 Q17331271 Q51628 Q3141419 Q625236
(c(Q838948)|c(Q15850590),P144,c(Q11028))
action less
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P144
type Q11028
type Q15850590
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Q9309699
relation P144
type Q838948
type Q15850590
[ANSWERS] less number of works of art or theatrical genres extend upon than that information
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q15850590'}], 'P144', {'concept': 'Q11028'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?s WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?k ) ?s WHERE { ?p rdf:type ?a . VALUES ( ?a ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q15850590 ) } } GROUP BY ?s } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?r ) AS ?b ) WHERE { ?r property:P144 resource:Q9309699 . { ?r rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q15850590 ) } } } } . FILTER ( ?k < ?b ) }
Marriage at Cana Day of Judgment Death of Cleopatra Venus Anadyomene Crucifixion in the arts Adoration of the shepherds Judith and Holofernes Penitent Magdalene Tobias and the Angel Amazonomachy Noli me tangere Bundahishn Sacred conversation Maestà Leda and the Swan Last Supper Adoration of the Magi Bridal theology Saint George and the Dragon the continence of Scipio Virgo inter Virgines Nativity of Jesus Jacob wrestling with the angel Calming the storm
Venus Anadyomene, Death of Cleopatra and Last Supper less number of works of art or theatrical genres extend upon than that information
Venus Anadyomene Death of Cleopatra Last Supper
action less
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation based on
type information
type theatrical genre
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Madonna and Child
relation based on
type work of art
type theatrical genre
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'theatrical genre'}], 'based on', {'concept': 'information'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?s WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?p ) AS ?k ) ?s WHERE { ?p rdf:type ?a . VALUES ( ?a ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:theatrical_genre ) } } GROUP BY ?s } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?r ) AS ?b ) WHERE { ?r property:based_on resource:Madonna_and_Child . { ?r rdf:type ?w . VALUES ( ?w ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:theatrical_genre ) } } } } . FILTER ( ?k < ?b ) }
[]
Clarification
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q633534
P180
Q16521
USER
Which taxons are demonstrated in that information ?
(Q633534,P180,c(Q16521))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q633534
relation P180
type Q16521
['Q633534', 'P180', {'concept': 'Q16521'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Q633534 property:P180 ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:Q16521 }
Death of Cleopatra
action filter_type
action find
entity Death of Cleopatra
relation depicts
type taxon
['Death of Cleopatra', 'depicts', {'concept': 'taxon'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Death_of_Cleopatra property:depicts ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:taxon }
[]
taxon
Clarification for simple ques.
Q51633
SYSTEM
Did you mean Last Supper ?
Q483760 Q633534 Q51633
(Q483760,P180,c(Q16521)) (Q633534,P180,c(Q16521)) (Q51633,P180,c(Q16521))
[ANSWER]
['Q483760', 'P180', {'concept': 'Q16521'}] ['Q633534', 'P180', {'concept': 'Q16521'}] ['Q51633', 'P180', {'concept': 'Q16521'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Q633534 property:P180 ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:Q16521 }
Venus Anadyomene Death of Cleopatra Last Supper
Did you mean Last Supper ?
Last Supper
['Venus Anadyomene', 'depicts', {'concept': 'taxon'}] ['Death of Cleopatra', 'depicts', {'concept': 'taxon'}] ['Last Supper', 'depicts', {'concept': 'taxon'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Death_of_Cleopatra property:depicts ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:taxon }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
USER
No, I meant Death of Cleopatra. Could you tell me the answer for that?
(Q633534,P180,c(Q16521))
Q633534
['Q633534', 'P180', {'concept': 'Q16521'}]
['Death of Cleopatra', 'depicts', {'concept': 'taxon'}]
[]
Q244377 Q572447
SYSTEM
Egyptian cobra, aspic viper
Q244377 Q572447
(Q633534,P180,c(Q16521))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q633534
relation P180
type Q16521
[ANSWERS] are demonstrated in that information
['Q633534', 'P180', {'concept': 'Q16521'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Q633534 property:P180 ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:Q16521 }
Egyptian cobra aspic viper
Egyptian cobra and aspic viper are demonstrated in that information
Egyptian cobra aspic viper
action filter_type
action find
entity Death of Cleopatra
relation depicts
type taxon
['Death of Cleopatra', 'depicts', {'concept': 'taxon'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?h WHERE { resource:Death_of_Cleopatra property:depicts ?h . ?h rdf:type ontology:taxon }
[]
Logical Reasoning (All)
Logical|Intersection|Single_Relation
Q8441 Q51633
P180
Q3305213
USER
Which paintings depict Last Supper and man ?
AND((c(Q3305213),P180,Q51633), (c(Q3305213),P180,Q8441))
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q51633
relation P180
action find_reverse
entity Q8441
relation P180
type Q3305213
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P180', 'Q51633'], [{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P180', 'Q8441']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a property:P180 resource:Q51633 . ?a property:P180 resource:Q8441 . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q3305213 }
man Last Supper
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Last Supper
relation depicts
action find_reverse
entity man
relation depicts
type painting
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'painting'}, 'depicts', 'Last Supper'], [{'concept': 'painting'}, 'depicts', 'man']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a property:depicts resource:Last_Supper . ?a property:depicts resource:man . ?a rdf:type ontology:painting }
[]
painting
Q128910 Q3208044
SYSTEM
The Last Supper, Last Supper
Q128910 Q3208044
AND((c(Q3305213),P180,Q51633), (c(Q3305213),P180,Q8441))
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q51633
relation P180
action find_reverse
entity Q8441
relation P180
type Q3305213
[ANSWERS] depict Last Supper and man
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P180', 'Q51633'], [{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P180', 'Q8441']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a property:P180 resource:Q51633 . ?a property:P180 resource:Q8441 . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q3305213 }
The Last Supper Last Supper
The Last Supper and Last Supper depict Last Supper and man
The Last Supper Last Supper
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Last Supper
relation depicts
action find_reverse
entity man
relation depicts
type painting
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'painting'}, 'depicts', 'Last Supper'], [{'concept': 'painting'}, 'depicts', 'man']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a property:depicts resource:Last_Supper . ?a property:depicts resource:man . ?a rdf:type ontology:painting }
[]
Logical Reasoning (All)
Logical|Intersection|Multiple_Relation
Q1404472 Q51633
P135 P180
Q3305213
USER
Which paintings demonstrate Last Supper and are linked with Italian Renaissance ?
AND((c(Q3305213),P180,Q51633), (c(Q3305213),P135,Q1404472))
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q51633
relation P180
action find_reverse
entity Q1404472
relation P135
type Q3305213
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P180', 'Q51633'], [{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P135', 'Q1404472']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?g WHERE { ?g property:P180 resource:Q51633 . ?g property:P135 resource:Q1404472 . ?g rdf:type ontology:Q3305213 }
Italian Renaissance Last Supper
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Last Supper
relation depicts
action find_reverse
entity Italian Renaissance
relation movement
type painting
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'painting'}, 'depicts', 'Last Supper'], [{'concept': 'painting'}, 'movement', 'Italian Renaissance']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?g WHERE { ?g property:depicts resource:Last_Supper . ?g property:movement resource:Italian_Renaissance . ?g rdf:type ontology:painting }
[]
painting
Q3208044
SYSTEM
Last Supper
Q3208044
AND((c(Q3305213),P180,Q51633), (c(Q3305213),P135,Q1404472))
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q51633
relation P180
action find_reverse
entity Q1404472
relation P135
type Q3305213
[ANSWER] demonstrate [ANSWER] and are linked with Italian Renaissance
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P180', 'Q51633'], [{'concept': 'Q3305213'}, 'P135', 'Q1404472']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?g WHERE { ?g property:P180 resource:Q51633 . ?g property:P135 resource:Q1404472 . ?g rdf:type ontology:Q3305213 }
Last Supper
Last Supper demonstrate Last Supper and are linked with Italian Renaissance
Last Supper
action filter_type
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Last Supper
relation depicts
action find_reverse
entity Italian Renaissance
relation movement
type painting
{'AND': [[{'concept': 'painting'}, 'depicts', 'Last Supper'], [{'concept': 'painting'}, 'movement', 'Italian Renaissance']]}
SELECT DISTINCT ?g WHERE { ?g property:depicts resource:Last_Supper . ?g property:movement resource:Italian_Renaissance . ?g rdf:type ontology:painting }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q3208044
P170
Q502895
USER
Which person is the creater of that painting ?
(Q3208044,P170,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q3208044
relation P170
type Q502895
['Q3208044', 'P170', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q502895 . resource:Q3208044 property:P170 ?y }
Last Supper
action filter_type
action find
entity Last Supper
relation creator
type common name
['Last Supper', 'creator', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:common_name . resource:Last_Supper property:creator ?y }
[]
common name
Q5827
SYSTEM
Pietro Perugino
Q5827
(Q3208044,P170,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q3208044
relation P170
type Q502895
The creater of that painting is [ANSWER]
['Q3208044', 'P170', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q502895 . resource:Q3208044 property:P170 ?y }
Pietro Perugino
The creater of that painting is Pietro Perugino
Pietro Perugino
action filter_type
action find
entity Last Supper
relation creator
type common name
['Last Supper', 'creator', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:common_name . resource:Last_Supper property:creator ?y }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q5827
P802
Q502895
USER
Who were that one a pupil of ?
(Q5827,P802,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q5827
relation P802
type Q502895
['Q5827', 'P802', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a rdf:type ontology:Q502895 . resource:Q5827 property:P802 ?a }
Pietro Perugino
action filter_type
action find
entity Pietro Perugino
relation student
type common name
['Pietro Perugino', 'student', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a rdf:type ontology:common_name . resource:Pietro_Perugino property:student ?a }
[]
common name
Q920115 Q5597
SYSTEM
Girolamo Genga, Raphael
Q920115 Q5597
(Q5827,P802,c(Q502895))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q5827
relation P802
type Q502895
[ANSWERS] were that one a pupil of
['Q5827', 'P802', {'concept': 'Q502895'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a rdf:type ontology:Q502895 . resource:Q5827 property:P802 ?a }
Girolamo Genga Raphael
Girolamo Genga and Raphael were that one a pupil of
Girolamo Genga Raphael
action filter_type
action find
entity Pietro Perugino
relation student
type common name
['Pietro Perugino', 'student', {'concept': 'common name'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { ?a rdf:type ontology:common_name . resource:Pietro_Perugino property:student ?a }
[]