Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question
Q744057
P19
Q56061
USER
Which administrative territory was David Spergel born in ?
(Q744057,P19,c(Q56061))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q744057
relation P19
type Q56061
['Q744057', 'P19', {'concept': 'Q56061'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?w WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P19 ?w . ?w rdf:type ontology:Q56061 }
David Spergel
action filter_type
action find
entity David Spergel
relation place of birth
type administrative territorial entity
['David Spergel', 'place of birth', {'concept': 'administrative territorial entity'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?w WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:place_of_birth ?w . ?w rdf:type ontology:administrative_territorial_entity }
[]
administrative territorial entity
Q49218
SYSTEM
Rochester
Q49218
(Q744057,P19,c(Q56061))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q744057
relation P19
type Q56061
David Spergel was born in [ANSWER]
['Q744057', 'P19', {'concept': 'Q56061'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?w WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P19 ?w . ?w rdf:type ontology:Q56061 }
Rochester
David Spergel was born in Rochester
Rochester
action filter_type
action find
entity David Spergel
relation place of birth
type administrative territorial entity
['David Spergel', 'place of birth', {'concept': 'administrative territorial entity'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?w WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:place_of_birth ?w . ?w rdf:type ontology:administrative_territorial_entity }
[]
Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question|Single Entity
Q744057
P69
Q163740
USER
What is the nonprofit organization where David Spergel was educated ?
(Q744057,P69,c(Q163740))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q744057
relation P69
type Q163740
['Q744057', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q163740'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P69 ?d . ?d rdf:type ontology:Q163740 }
David Spergel
action filter_type
action find
entity David Spergel
relation educated at
type nonprofit organization
['David Spergel', 'educated at', {'concept': 'nonprofit organization'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:educated_at ?d . ?d rdf:type ontology:nonprofit_organization }
[]
nonprofit organization
Q13371
SYSTEM
Harvard University
Q13371
(Q744057,P69,c(Q163740))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q744057
relation P69
type Q163740
The nonprofit organization David Spergel was educated is at [ANSWER]
['Q744057', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q163740'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P69 ?d . ?d rdf:type ontology:Q163740 }
Harvard University
The nonprofit organization David Spergel was educated is at Harvard University
Harvard University
action filter_type
action find
entity David Spergel
relation educated at
type nonprofit organization
['David Spergel', 'educated at', {'concept': 'nonprofit organization'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:educated_at ?d . ?d rdf:type ontology:nonprofit_organization }
[]
Simple Question (Ellipsis)
only subject is changed, parent and predicate remains same
Q3102961
Q163740
USER
And what about Paul Alan Cox?
(Q3102961,P69,c(Q163740))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q3102961
relation P69
type Q163740
['Q3102961', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q163740'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Q3102961 property:P69 ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:Q163740 }
Paul Alan Cox
action filter_type
action find
entity Paul Alan Cox
relation educated at
type nonprofit organization
['Paul Alan Cox', 'educated at', {'concept': 'nonprofit organization'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Paul_Alan_Cox property:educated_at ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:nonprofit_organization }
[]
nonprofit organization
Q332498 Q13371
SYSTEM
Brigham Young University, Harvard University
Q332498 Q13371
(Q3102961,P69,c(Q163740))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q3102961
relation P69
type Q163740
[ANSWERS]
['Q3102961', 'P69', {'concept': 'Q163740'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Q3102961 property:P69 ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:Q163740 }
Brigham Young University Harvard University
Brigham Young University Harvard University
action filter_type
action find
entity Paul Alan Cox
relation educated at
type nonprofit organization
['Paul Alan Cox', 'educated at', {'concept': 'nonprofit organization'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?t WHERE { resource:Paul_Alan_Cox property:educated_at ?t . ?t rdf:type ontology:nonprofit_organization }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|one entity, multiple entities (as object) referred indirectly
Q7287300
P69
Q502895
USER
Are Ralph C. Hancock an alumni of those nonprofit organizations ?
(Q7287300,P69,Q332498) (Q7287300,P69,Q13371)
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Q7287300
relation P69
['Q7287300', 'P69', 'Q332498'] ['Q7287300', 'P69', 'Q13371']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q7287300 property:P69 ?s . VALUES ( ?s ) { ( resource:Q332498 ) ( resource:Q13371 ) } }
Ralph C. Hancock
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Ralph C. Hancock
relation educated at
['Ralph C. Hancock', 'educated at', 'Brigham Young University'] ['Ralph C. Hancock', 'educated at', 'Harvard University']
ASK WHERE { resource:Ralph_C._Hancock property:educated_at ?s . VALUES ( ?s ) { ( resource:Brigham_Young_University ) ( resource:Harvard_University ) } }
[]
common name
SYSTEM
YES
(Q7287300,P69,Q332498) (Q7287300,P69,Q13371)
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Q7287300
relation P69
[ANSWER]
['Q7287300', 'P69', 'Q332498'] ['Q7287300', 'P69', 'Q13371']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q7287300 property:P69 ?s . VALUES ( ?s ) { ( resource:Q332498 ) ( resource:Q13371 ) } }
Yes
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Ralph C. Hancock
relation educated at
['Ralph C. Hancock', 'educated at', 'Brigham Young University'] ['Ralph C. Hancock', 'educated at', 'Harvard University']
ASK WHERE { resource:Ralph_C._Hancock property:educated_at ?s . VALUES ( ?s ) { ( resource:Brigham_Young_University ) ( resource:Harvard_University ) } }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|3 entities, all direct, 2 are query entities
Q49218 Q1977916 Q31487
P190
Q486972
USER
Is Rochester a sister city of Wiązownica Mała and Kraków ?
(Q49218,P190,Q1977916) (Q49218,P190,Q31487)
action is_in
entity Q49218
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q1977916
relation P190
action find_reverse
entity Q31487
relation P190
['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q1977916'] ['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q31487']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q1977916 . resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q31487 }
Rochester Wiązownica Mała Kraków
action is_in
entity Rochester
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Wiązownica Mała
relation sister city
action find_reverse
entity Kraków
relation sister city
['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Wiązownica Mała'] ['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Kraków']
ASK WHERE { resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Wiązownica_Mała . resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Kraków }
[]
human settlement
SYSTEM
NO and YES respectively
(Q49218,P190,Q1977916) (Q49218,P190,Q31487)
action is_in
entity Q49218
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q1977916
relation P190
action find_reverse
entity Q31487
relation P190
[ANSWER]
['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q1977916'] ['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q31487']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q1977916 . resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q31487 }
NO and YES respectively
action is_in
entity Rochester
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Wiązownica Mała
relation sister city
action find_reverse
entity Kraków
relation sister city
['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Wiązownica Mała'] ['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Kraków']
ASK WHERE { resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Wiązownica_Mała . resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Kraków }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|2 entities, both direct
Q744057 Q26699308
P106
Q12737077
USER
Is mayor of Argecilla the profession of David Spergel ?
(Q744057,P106,Q26699308)
action is_in
entity Q26699308
action find
entity Q744057
relation P106
['Q744057', 'P106', 'Q26699308']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P106 resource:Q26699308 }
David Spergel mayor of Argecilla
action is_in
entity mayor of Argecilla
action find
entity David Spergel
relation occupation
['David Spergel', 'occupation', 'mayor of Argecilla']
ASK WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:occupation resource:mayor_of_Argecilla }
[]
occupation
SYSTEM
NO
(Q744057,P106,Q26699308)
action is_in
entity Q26699308
action find
entity Q744057
relation P106
[ANSWER]
['Q744057', 'P106', 'Q26699308']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P106 resource:Q26699308 }
No
action is_in
entity mayor of Argecilla
action find
entity David Spergel
relation occupation
['David Spergel', 'occupation', 'mayor of Argecilla']
ASK WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:occupation resource:mayor_of_Argecilla }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|3 entities, all direct, 2 are query entities
Q13371 Q49111 Q1857413
P159
Q56061
USER
Does Harvard University have the principal seat at Cambridge and Lake Lillian ?
(Q13371,P159,Q49111) (Q13371,P159,Q1857413)
action is_in
entity Q13371
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q49111
relation P159
action find_reverse
entity Q1857413
relation P159
['Q13371', 'P159', 'Q49111'] ['Q13371', 'P159', 'Q1857413']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q13371 property:P159 resource:Q49111 . resource:Q13371 property:P159 resource:Q1857413 }
Harvard University Cambridge Lake Lillian
action is_in
entity Harvard University
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Cambridge
relation headquarters location
action find_reverse
entity Lake Lillian
relation headquarters location
['Harvard University', 'headquarters location', 'Cambridge'] ['Harvard University', 'headquarters location', 'Lake Lillian']
ASK WHERE { resource:Harvard_University property:headquarters_location resource:Cambridge . resource:Harvard_University property:headquarters_location resource:Lake_Lillian }
[]
administrative territorial entity
SYSTEM
YES and NO respectively
(Q13371,P159,Q49111) (Q13371,P159,Q1857413)
action is_in
entity Q13371
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q49111
relation P159
action find_reverse
entity Q1857413
relation P159
[ANSWER]
['Q13371', 'P159', 'Q49111'] ['Q13371', 'P159', 'Q1857413']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q13371 property:P159 resource:Q49111 . resource:Q13371 property:P159 resource:Q1857413 }
YES and NO respectively
action is_in
entity Harvard University
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Cambridge
relation headquarters location
action find_reverse
entity Lake Lillian
relation headquarters location
['Harvard University', 'headquarters location', 'Cambridge'] ['Harvard University', 'headquarters location', 'Lake Lillian']
ASK WHERE { resource:Harvard_University property:headquarters_location resource:Cambridge . resource:Harvard_University property:headquarters_location resource:Lake_Lillian }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|3 entities, all direct, 2 are query entities
Q49218 Q12103277 Q721381
P190
Q56061
USER
Is Rochester twin city of Dimoiu and Nandej ?
(Q49218,P190,Q12103277) (Q49218,P190,Q721381)
action is_in
entity Q49218
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q12103277
relation P190
action find_reverse
entity Q721381
relation P190
['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q12103277'] ['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q721381']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q12103277 . resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q721381 }
Rochester Dimoiu Nandej
action is_in
entity Rochester
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Dimoiu
relation sister city
action find_reverse
entity Nandej
relation sister city
['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Dimoiu'] ['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Nandej']
ASK WHERE { resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Dimoiu . resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Nandej }
[]
administrative territorial entity
SYSTEM
NO
(Q49218,P190,Q12103277) (Q49218,P190,Q721381)
action is_in
entity Q49218
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q12103277
relation P190
action find_reverse
entity Q721381
relation P190
[ANSWER]
['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q12103277'] ['Q49218', 'P190', 'Q721381']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q12103277 . resource:Q49218 property:P190 resource:Q721381 }
No
action is_in
entity Rochester
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Dimoiu
relation sister city
action find_reverse
entity Nandej
relation sister city
['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Dimoiu'] ['Rochester', 'sister city', 'Nandej']
ASK WHERE { resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Dimoiu . resource:Rochester property:sister_city resource:Nandej }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|3 entities, all direct, 2 are query entities
Q744057 Q21578 Q75478
P108
Q163740
USER
Does David Spergel have Princeton University and New York University Tandon School of Engineering as its employer ?
(Q744057,P108,Q21578) (Q744057,P108,Q75478)
action is_in
entity Q744057
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q21578
relation P108
action find_reverse
entity Q75478
relation P108
['Q744057', 'P108', 'Q21578'] ['Q744057', 'P108', 'Q75478']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P108 resource:Q21578 . resource:Q744057 property:P108 resource:Q75478 }
David Spergel Princeton University New York University Tandon School of Engineering
action is_in
entity David Spergel
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Princeton University
relation employer
action find_reverse
entity New York University Tandon School of Engineering
relation employer
['David Spergel', 'employer', 'Princeton University'] ['David Spergel', 'employer', 'New York University Tandon School of Engineering']
ASK WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:employer resource:Princeton_University . resource:David_Spergel property:employer resource:New_York_University_Tandon_School_of_Engineering }
[]
nonprofit organization
SYSTEM
YES and NO respectively
(Q744057,P108,Q21578) (Q744057,P108,Q75478)
action is_in
entity Q744057
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Q21578
relation P108
action find_reverse
entity Q75478
relation P108
[ANSWER]
['Q744057', 'P108', 'Q21578'] ['Q744057', 'P108', 'Q75478']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q744057 property:P108 resource:Q21578 . resource:Q744057 property:P108 resource:Q75478 }
YES and NO respectively
action is_in
entity David Spergel
action intersection
action find_reverse
entity Princeton University
relation employer
action find_reverse
entity New York University Tandon School of Engineering
relation employer
['David Spergel', 'employer', 'Princeton University'] ['David Spergel', 'employer', 'New York University Tandon School of Engineering']
ASK WHERE { resource:David_Spergel property:employer resource:Princeton_University . resource:David_Spergel property:employer resource:New_York_University_Tandon_School_of_Engineering }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q744057
P463
Q811430
USER
Which construction was that person a member of ?
action filter_type
action find
entity Q744057
relation P463
type Q811430
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { ?q rdf:type ontology:Q811430 . resource:Q744057 property:P463 ?q }
David Spergel
action filter_type
action find
entity David Spergel
relation member of
type construction
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { ?q rdf:type ontology:construction . resource:David_Spergel property:member_of ?q }
[]
construction
Q463303
SYSTEM
American Academy of Arts and Sciences
Q463303
action filter_type
action find
entity Q744057
relation P463
type Q811430
[ANSWER] was that person a member of
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { ?q rdf:type ontology:Q811430 . resource:Q744057 property:P463 ?q }
American Academy of Arts and Sciences
American Academy of Arts and Sciences was that person a member of
American Academy of Arts and Sciences
action filter_type
action find
entity David Spergel
relation member of
type construction
SELECT DISTINCT ?q WHERE { ?q rdf:type ontology:construction . resource:David_Spergel property:member_of ?q }
[]