Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question
Q1878644
P106
Q12737077
USER
Which occupations are the professions of Lydie Auvray ?
(Q1878644,P106,c(Q12737077))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q1878644
relation P106
type Q12737077
['Q1878644', 'P106', {'concept': 'Q12737077'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:Q12737077 . resource:Q1878644 property:P106 ?i }
Lydie Auvray
action filter_type
action find
entity Lydie Auvray
relation occupation
type occupation
['Lydie Auvray', 'occupation', {'concept': 'occupation'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:occupation . resource:Lydie_Auvray property:occupation ?i }
[]
occupation
Q639669 Q177220
SYSTEM
musician, singer
Q639669 Q177220
(Q1878644,P106,c(Q12737077))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q1878644
relation P106
type Q12737077
The professions of Lydie Auvray are a [ANSWERS]
['Q1878644', 'P106', {'concept': 'Q12737077'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:Q12737077 . resource:Q1878644 property:P106 ?i }
musician singer
The professions of Lydie Auvray are a musician and singer
musician singer
action filter_type
action find
entity Lydie Auvray
relation occupation
type occupation
['Lydie Auvray', 'occupation', {'concept': 'occupation'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { ?i rdf:type ontology:occupation . resource:Lydie_Auvray property:occupation ?i }
[]
Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question|Mult. Entity|Indirect
Q639669 Q177220
P180
Q838948
USER
Which works of art express musician and singer ?
(c(Q838948),P180,Q639669) (c(Q838948),P180,Q177220)
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q639669
relation P180
type Q838948
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q177220
relation P180
type Q838948
[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, 'P180', 'Q639669'] [{'concept': 'Q838948'}, 'P180', 'Q177220']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { VALUES ( ?v ) { ( resource:Q639669 ) ( resource:Q177220 ) } . ?k property:P180 ?v }
musician singer
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity musician
relation depicts
type work of art
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity singer
relation depicts
type work of art
[{'concept': 'work of art'}, 'depicts', 'musician'] [{'concept': 'work of art'}, 'depicts', 'singer']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { VALUES ( ?v ) { ( resource:musician ) ( resource:singer ) } . ?k property:depicts ?v }
[]
work of art
Q3047015 Q19015792 Q18086751
SYSTEM
Odalisque with Slave, Altarpiece of the Resurrection of Christ, The Singer
Q19015792 Q19347596 Q22132524 Q19257244 Q3047015 Q18086751
(c(Q838948),P180,Q639669) (c(Q838948),P180,Q177220)
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q639669
relation P180
type Q838948
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q177220
relation P180
type Q838948
[ANSWERS]
[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, 'P180', 'Q639669'] [{'concept': 'Q838948'}, 'P180', 'Q177220']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { VALUES ( ?v ) { ( resource:Q639669 ) ( resource:Q177220 ) } . ?k property:P180 ?v }
Altarpiece of the Resurrection of Christ Egyptian Harpist Saint Pierre Homer Odalisque with Slave The Singer
PROBLEM PLURALIZE
Odalisque with Slave Altarpiece of the Resurrection of Christ The Singer
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity musician
relation depicts
type work of art
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity singer
relation depicts
type work of art
[{'concept': 'work of art'}, 'depicts', 'musician'] [{'concept': 'work of art'}, 'depicts', 'singer']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { VALUES ( ?v ) { ( resource:musician ) ( resource:singer ) } . ?k property:depicts ?v }
[]
Clarification
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q3047015
P135
Q2198855
USER
What cultural movements were that work of art associated with ?
(Q3047015,P135,c(Q2198855))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q3047015
relation P135
type Q2198855
['Q3047015', 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Q3047015 property:P135 ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q2198855 }
Odalisque with Slave
action filter_type
action find
entity Odalisque with Slave
relation movement
type cultural movement
['Odalisque with Slave', 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Odalisque_with_Slave property:movement ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:cultural_movement }
[]
cultural movement
Clarification for simple ques.
Q3047015
SYSTEM
Did you mean Odalisque with Slave ?
Q3047015 Q19015792 Q18086751
(Q3047015,P135,c(Q2198855)) (Q19015792,P135,c(Q2198855)) (Q18086751,P135,c(Q2198855))
[ANSWER]
['Q3047015', 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}] ['Q19015792', 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}] ['Q18086751', 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Q3047015 property:P135 ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q2198855 }
Odalisque with Slave Altarpiece of the Resurrection of Christ The Singer
Did you mean Odalisque with Slave ?
Odalisque with Slave
['Odalisque with Slave', 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}] ['Altarpiece of the Resurrection of Christ', 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}] ['The Singer', 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Odalisque_with_Slave property:movement ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:cultural_movement }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
USER
Yes
(Q3047015,P135,c(Q2198855))
['Q3047015', 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
['Odalisque with Slave', 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
[]
Q42865 Q14378
SYSTEM
Orientalism, neoclassicism
Q42865 Q14378
(Q3047015,P135,c(Q2198855))
action filter_type
action find
entity Q3047015
relation P135
type Q2198855
That work of art were associated with [ANSWERS]
['Q3047015', 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Q3047015 property:P135 ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:Q2198855 }
Orientalism neoclassicism
That work of art were associated with Orientalism and neoclassicism
Orientalism neoclassicism
action filter_type
action find
entity Odalisque with Slave
relation movement
type cultural movement
['Odalisque with Slave', 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?a WHERE { resource:Odalisque_with_Slave property:movement ?a . ?a rdf:type ontology:cultural_movement }
[]
Verification (Boolean) (All)
Verification|one entity, multiple entities (as object) referred indirectly
Q21065425
P135
Q838948
USER
Are Anthyakoodasha linked with those cultural movements ?
(Q21065425,P135,Q42865) (Q21065425,P135,Q14378)
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Q21065425
relation P135
['Q21065425', 'P135', 'Q42865'] ['Q21065425', 'P135', 'Q14378']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q21065425 property:P135 ?g . VALUES ( ?g ) { ( resource:Q42865 ) ( resource:Q14378 ) } }
Anthyakoodasha
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Anthyakoodasha
relation movement
['Anthyakoodasha', 'movement', 'Orientalism'] ['Anthyakoodasha', 'movement', 'neoclassicism']
ASK WHERE { resource:Anthyakoodasha property:movement ?g . VALUES ( ?g ) { ( resource:Orientalism ) ( resource:neoclassicism ) } }
[]
work of art
SYSTEM
NO
(Q21065425,P135,Q42865) (Q21065425,P135,Q14378)
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Q21065425
relation P135
[ANSWER]
['Q21065425', 'P135', 'Q42865'] ['Q21065425', 'P135', 'Q14378']
ASK WHERE { resource:Q21065425 property:P135 ?g . VALUES ( ?g ) { ( resource:Q42865 ) ( resource:Q14378 ) } }
No
action is_in
entity prev_answer
action find
entity Anthyakoodasha
relation movement
['Anthyakoodasha', 'movement', 'Orientalism'] ['Anthyakoodasha', 'movement', 'neoclassicism']
ASK WHERE { resource:Anthyakoodasha property:movement ?g . VALUES ( ?g ) { ( resource:Orientalism ) ( resource:neoclassicism ) } }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Single entity type
Q18688188
P135
Q2198855 Q340169
USER
Which medias are associated with approximately the same number of cultural movements as Two Nude Studies of a Man Storming Forward and Another Turning to the Right ?
(c(Q340169),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q340169
type Q2198855
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q18688188
relation P135
type Q340169
[{'concept': 'Q340169'}, 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?y ( COUNT ( ?q ) AS ?r ) WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q340169 . ?q rdf:type ontology:Q2198855 . ?y property:P135 ?q } GROUP BY ?y } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?m ) AS ?k ) WHERE { resource:Q18688188 property:P135 ?m . ?m rdf:type ontology:Q340169 } } . FILTER ( ?r = ?k ) }
Two Nude Studies of a Man Storming Forward and Another Turning to the Right
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation movement
type media
type cultural movement
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Two Nude Studies of a Man Storming Forward and Another Turning to the Right
relation movement
type media
[{'concept': 'media'}, 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?y ( COUNT ( ?q ) AS ?r ) WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:media . ?q rdf:type ontology:cultural_movement . ?y property:movement ?q } GROUP BY ?y } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?m ) AS ?k ) WHERE { resource:Two_Nude_Studies_of_a_Man_Storming_Forward_and_Another_Turning_to_the_Right property:movement ?m . ?m rdf:type ontology:media } } . FILTER ( ?r = ?k ) }
[]
cultural movement media
Q19862183 Q19862171 Q993743
SYSTEM
Dutch Cavalier, Study for "The Tulip Folly", Self-portrait
Q7809990 Q3698232 Q3904414 Q18686193 Q18688622 Q18688645 Q18688665 Q18688189 Q993743 Q2709726 Q18686033 Q23955631 Q3605555 Q19969179 Q19862183 Q19862186 Q2471531 Q18688187 Q19862167 Q18688192 Q18688191 Q18688190 Q8254439 Q7628419 Q18688656 Q3922633 Q18688638 Q3976305 Q3213096 Q215486 Q5197377 Q19862171 Q19969176 Q19862182 Q18688188 Q19862179 Q18687922 Q19862169
(c(Q340169),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q340169
type Q2198855
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q18688188
relation P135
type Q340169
[ANSWERS] are associated with approximately the same number of cultural movements as Two Nude Studies of a Man Storming Forward and Another Turning to the Right
[{'concept': 'Q340169'}, 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?y ( COUNT ( ?q ) AS ?r ) WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:Q340169 . ?q rdf:type ontology:Q2198855 . ?y property:P135 ?q } GROUP BY ?y } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?m ) AS ?k ) WHERE { resource:Q18688188 property:P135 ?m . ?m rdf:type ontology:Q340169 } } . FILTER ( ?r = ?k ) }
Titian Self-Portrait Crucifixion Pietà for Vittoria Colonna A Kneeling Nude Woman with her Left Arm Raised Head of An Apostle in the Transfiguration Reading Madonna and Child in a Landscape between two Cherub Heads Nude Studies Three Standing Men in Wide Cloaks Turned to the Left Self-portrait Epifania Marshal of France Portrait of Adrià Gual Adoration of the Shepherds Studies of an outstretched arm for the fresco 'The Drunkenness of Noah' in the Sistine Chapel Dutch Cavalier Man Walking on a Road The Virgin and Child with St Anne and St John the Baptist Studies for a Holy Family Study for "Diogenes" Lamentation Seated Young Male Nude and Two Arm Studies Pietà Study of five grotesque heads Study of a Kneeling Nude Girl for The Entombment Young Man Carrying an Old Man on His Back Bust of a Warrior Madonna of the Pomegranate Study of a woman's hands The Temptation of St Anthony Vitruvian Man Lallans Study for "The Tulip Folly" Studies of a Horse with Two Nude Riders and a Male Torso Study for "Slave Market at Rome" Two Nude Studies of a Man Storming Forward and Another Turning to the Right Study for "Socrates Looking for Alcibiades in the House of Aspasia" Half-Length Figure of an Apostle Study for "Slave Market"
Dutch Cavalier, Study for "The Tulip Folly" and Self-portrait are associated with approximately the same number of cultural movements as Two Nude Studies of a Man Storming Forward and Another Turning to the Right
Dutch Cavalier Study for "The Tulip Folly" Self-portrait
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation movement
type media
type cultural movement
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Two Nude Studies of a Man Storming Forward and Another Turning to the Right
relation movement
type media
[{'concept': 'media'}, 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?y WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?y ( COUNT ( ?q ) AS ?r ) WHERE { ?y rdf:type ontology:media . ?q rdf:type ontology:cultural_movement . ?y property:movement ?q } GROUP BY ?y } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?m ) AS ?k ) WHERE { resource:Two_Nude_Studies_of_a_Man_Storming_Forward_and_Another_Turning_to_the_Right property:movement ?m . ?m rdf:type ontology:media } } . FILTER ( ?r = ?k ) }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Single entity type|Incomplete
Q19862176
P135
Q2198855 Q340169
USER
And how about Arab Standing in Prayer?
(c(Q340169),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q340169
type Q2198855
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19862176
relation P135
type Q340169
[{'concept': 'Q340169'}, 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?o ) WHERE { ?i property:P135 ?y . ?i rdf:type ontology:Q340169 . ?y rdf:type ontology:Q2198855 } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?k ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Q19862176 property:P135 ?k . ?k rdf:type ontology:Q340169 } } . FILTER ( ?o = ?a ) }
Arab Standing in Prayer
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation movement
type media
type cultural movement
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Arab Standing in Prayer
relation movement
type media
[{'concept': 'media'}, 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?o ) WHERE { ?i property:movement ?y . ?i rdf:type ontology:media . ?y rdf:type ontology:cultural_movement } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?k ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Arab_Standing_in_Prayer property:movement ?k . ?k rdf:type ontology:media } } . FILTER ( ?o = ?a ) }
[]
cultural movement media
Q18341239 Q2072801 Q591128
SYSTEM
New Year's Greeting with Three Witches, Portrait of a Young Fiancée, Portrait of Isabella d'Este
Q18341259 Q18341254 Q19913859 Q591128 Q18341251 Q19862185 Q18341239 Q2238709 Q3291553 Q20020115 Q20088062 Q1272037 Q19968909 Q14852097 Q3373694 Q2072801 Q19862187 Q18685798 Q3842599 Q5506360 Q1968805 Q18341245 Q2148059 Q2918420 Q699552 Q3949529 Q20639898 Q3464466 Q14819521 Q3985177 Q14856532 Q18685788 Q19862176 Q17064861 Q14851350 Q19862190
(c(Q340169),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q340169
type Q2198855
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Q19862176
relation P135
type Q340169
[ANSWERS]
[{'concept': 'Q340169'}, 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?o ) WHERE { ?i property:P135 ?y . ?i rdf:type ontology:Q340169 . ?y rdf:type ontology:Q2198855 } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?k ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Q19862176 property:P135 ?k . ?k rdf:type ontology:Q340169 } } . FILTER ( ?o = ?a ) }
The Women's Bath Young couple on horseback Wailuku Falls, Hilo Portrait of Isabella d'Este Angel playing the lute Study of Lions New Year's Greeting with Three Witches The Trees have Ears and the Field has Eyes Marie Antoinette Led to Her Execution Portrait of a Young Man Mme Loubens au Lit Self-portrait Study of a Standing Dancer with an Outstretched Arm Man in basket, old woman with pliers and children Arno Valley Landscape Portrait of a Young Fiancée Portrait of an Egyptian Fellah Madonna and Child with Saint Madonna of the Animals Fruit Dish and Glass The Tree-Man Head of a man Fools' kitchen The Owls' Nest Praying Hands A Saint on Horseback Seated Male Nude Saint Barbara A Woman Spinning and an Old Woman Head of Leda Two monsters Saint Fidelis of Sigmarigen and Saint Joseph of Leonessa Arab Standing in Prayer Portrait of a Young Woman Hell scene and monsters Turkish Soldier
New Year's Greeting with Three Witches Portrait of a Young Fiancée Portrait of Isabella d'Este
action approx
action find_tuple_counts
relation movement
type media
type cultural movement
action count
action filter_type
action find
entity Arab Standing in Prayer
relation movement
type media
[{'concept': 'media'}, 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?y ) AS ?o ) WHERE { ?i property:movement ?y . ?i rdf:type ontology:media . ?y rdf:type ontology:cultural_movement } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?k ) AS ?a ) WHERE { resource:Arab_Standing_in_Prayer property:movement ?k . ?k rdf:type ontology:media } } . FILTER ( ?o = ?a ) }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Mult. entity type
Q252801
P135
Q2198855 Q838948 Q502895
USER
Which cultural movements were approximately the same number of works of art or people associated with as Kanō school ?
(c(Q838948)|c(Q502895),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q502895
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Q252801
relation P135
type Q838948
type Q502895
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q502895'}], 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?n ) AS ?q ) ?i WHERE { VALUES ( ?r ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q502895 ) } . ?n rdf:type ?r } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?p ) WHERE { { ?f rdf:type ?z . VALUES ( ?z ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q502895 ) } } . ?f property:P135 resource:Q252801 } } . FILTER ( ?q = ?p ) }
Kanō school
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type common name
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Kanō school
relation movement
type work of art
type common name
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'common name'}], 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?n ) AS ?q ) ?i WHERE { VALUES ( ?r ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:common_name ) } . ?n rdf:type ?r } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?p ) WHERE { { ?f rdf:type ?z . VALUES ( ?z ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:common_name ) } } . ?f property:movement resource:Kanō_school } } . FILTER ( ?q = ?p ) }
[]
cultural movement work of art common name
Q212611 Q173782 Q207445
SYSTEM
COBRA, Art Deco, De Stijl
Q1962478 Q576913 Q3818926 Q1745141 Q102932 Q166713 Q2477787 Q207445 Q1401605 Q3272569 Q1147263 Q478774 Q3562740 Q160218 Q477134 Q933661 Q837024 Q11050078 Q3408836 Q516316 Q273495 Q277466 Q782129 Q8055874 Q3501307 Q11811815 Q3577791 Q3577793 Q1159870 Q830891 Q589655 Q939559 Q15941800 Q1133329 Q979160 Q1474884 Q443153 Q842183 Q519443 Q1351977 Q1842924 Q55995 Q466521 Q5898564 Q9033935 Q753683 Q1335478 Q10336318 Q42865 Q847847 Q943853 Q207103 Q845421 Q186030 Q1164982 Q156460 Q1994273 Q941875 Q46825 Q330369 Q10857409 Q5509243 Q180902 Q584084 Q851869 Q378604 Q154432 Q3108623 Q252801 Q466675 Q4888026 Q47783 Q1628039 Q3782252 Q632355 Q1378978 Q1472236 Q166593 Q2107376 Q3357314 Q848365 Q203209 Q878985 Q4692 Q1518145 Q173436 Q1400843 Q2096208 Q2566149 Q3484823 Q369418 Q695830 Q2352880 Q26689759 Q1054254 Q915841 Q843393 Q4414064 Q3032335 Q212611 Q372600 Q173782 Q20020039 Q478717 Q1338153 Q191970 Q16191884 Q2415073 Q846094 Q1879488 Q382056 Q221375 Q174988 Q211884 Q217213 Q19953536 Q6889076 Q122960 Q7063969 Q108908 Q200034 Q10822316 Q1989975 Q18086896 Q143357 Q1777842 Q182331 Q1136545 Q889525 Q5095653 Q1444581 Q2487023 Q4322399 Q935292 Q765606 Q1569950 Q42934 Q276308 Q994776 Q597365 Q150091
(c(Q838948)|c(Q502895),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q502895
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Q252801
relation P135
type Q838948
type Q502895
[ANSWERS] were approximately the same number of works of art or people associated with as Kanō school
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q502895'}], 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?n ) AS ?q ) ?i WHERE { VALUES ( ?r ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q502895 ) } . ?n rdf:type ?r } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?p ) WHERE { { ?f rdf:type ?z . VALUES ( ?z ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q502895 ) } } . ?f property:P135 resource:Q252801 } } . FILTER ( ?q = ?p ) }
Post-painterly Abstraction Arte Povera Northern Mannerism Fantastic Realism avant-garde Post-Impressionism American Impressionism De Stijl Russian avant-garde Luminism Lyrical Abstraction purism Volcano School New Objectivity Antwerp Mannerism Novecento Italiano social realism Lingnan School Proto-Cubism Young British Artists École de Nancy historicism fantastic art Yoruba art Troubadour style New Sculpture Crozant School École de Dakar Luminism Inuit art neo-expressionism Photorealism Ghent-Bruges school Young Poland Proto-Renaissance High Renaissance Early Netherlandish painting Shin-hanga Orphism Stuckism Prehistoric art naturalism kinetic art Hoosier Group Brazilian modernism metaphysical art Katsukawa school Neo-primitivism Orientalism synthetism Hudson River School constructivism Neoplasticism contemporary art Color Field degenerate art Flemish Baroque painting Rayonism Gothic art Arts and Crafts movement realism Funk art socialist realism School of Fontainebleau pictorialism new media art Biedermeier Cuzco School Kanō school American Renaissance Benin art postmodernism Utrecht Caravaggism Post-romanticism Archaic Greek sculpture Cretan School Early Renaissance fauvism Antwerp school Florentine School primitivism conceptual art modernism renaissance Sōsaku-hanga minimalism Cubo-Futurism Pioneer Group relational art simultanism Hard-edge painting Viennese Actionism Dutch Golden Age painting abstract realism Informalism vorticism Mail art abstract impressionism Heidelberg School COBRA Tachisme Art Deco Yushan School Amsterdam Impressionism 20th-century classical music suprematism Neo-Grec Daedalic style Decadent movement Russian symbolism Pont-Aven School Hellenistic art Generation of the 30s Byzantine art action painting neo-Pompeian Modern sculpture rococo Nouvelle tendance Fluxus Pointillism concrete art Nihonga Egyptian Revival Barbizon school severe style Op art Costumbrismo Cloisonnism Chicago Imagists Superflat divisionism New British Sculpture Neo-Dada Orientalist painting Internet art cubism Nouveau réalisme brutalism yamato-e Neo-impressionism
COBRA, Art Deco and De Stijl were approximately the same number of works of art or people associated with as Kanō school
COBRA Art Deco De Stijl
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type common name
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Kanō school
relation movement
type work of art
type common name
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'common name'}], 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?n ) AS ?q ) ?i WHERE { VALUES ( ?r ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:common_name ) } . ?n rdf:type ?r } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?p ) WHERE { { ?f rdf:type ?z . VALUES ( ?z ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:common_name ) } } . ?f property:movement resource:Kanō_school } } . FILTER ( ?q = ?p ) }
[]
Comparative Reasoning (All)
Comparative|More/Less|Mult. entity type|Incomplete
Q842183
P135
Q2198855 Q838948 Q502895
USER
And how about Shin-hanga?
(c(Q838948)|c(Q502895),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q502895
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Q842183
relation P135
type Q838948
type Q502895
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q502895'}], 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?c ) AS ?m ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?l ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q502895 ) } . ?c rdf:type ?l } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?h ) WHERE { ?f property:P135 resource:Q842183 . { { ?f rdf:type ontology:Q838948 } UNION { ?f rdf:type ontology:Q502895 } } } } . FILTER ( ?m = ?h ) }
Shin-hanga
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type common name
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Shin-hanga
relation movement
type work of art
type common name
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'common name'}], 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?c ) AS ?m ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?l ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:common_name ) } . ?c rdf:type ?l } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?h ) WHERE { ?f property:movement resource:Shin-hanga . { { ?f rdf:type ontology:work_of_art } UNION { ?f rdf:type ontology:common_name } } } } . FILTER ( ?m = ?h ) }
[]
cultural movement work of art common name
Q212611 Q173782 Q207445
SYSTEM
COBRA, Art Deco, De Stijl
Q1962478 Q576913 Q3818926 Q1745141 Q102932 Q166713 Q2477787 Q207445 Q1401605 Q3272569 Q1147263 Q478774 Q3562740 Q160218 Q477134 Q933661 Q837024 Q11050078 Q3408836 Q516316 Q273495 Q277466 Q782129 Q8055874 Q3501307 Q11811815 Q3577791 Q3577793 Q1159870 Q830891 Q589655 Q939559 Q15941800 Q1133329 Q979160 Q1474884 Q443153 Q842183 Q519443 Q1351977 Q1842924 Q55995 Q466521 Q5898564 Q9033935 Q753683 Q1335478 Q10336318 Q42865 Q847847 Q943853 Q207103 Q845421 Q186030 Q1164982 Q156460 Q1994273 Q941875 Q46825 Q330369 Q10857409 Q5509243 Q180902 Q584084 Q851869 Q378604 Q154432 Q3108623 Q252801 Q466675 Q4888026 Q47783 Q1628039 Q3782252 Q632355 Q1378978 Q1472236 Q166593 Q2107376 Q3357314 Q848365 Q203209 Q878985 Q4692 Q1518145 Q173436 Q1400843 Q2096208 Q2566149 Q3484823 Q369418 Q695830 Q2352880 Q26689759 Q1054254 Q915841 Q843393 Q4414064 Q3032335 Q212611 Q372600 Q173782 Q20020039 Q478717 Q1338153 Q191970 Q16191884 Q2415073 Q846094 Q1879488 Q382056 Q221375 Q174988 Q211884 Q217213 Q19953536 Q6889076 Q122960 Q7063969 Q108908 Q200034 Q10822316 Q1989975 Q18086896 Q143357 Q1777842 Q182331 Q1136545 Q889525 Q5095653 Q1444581 Q2487023 Q4322399 Q935292 Q765606 Q1569950 Q42934 Q276308 Q994776 Q597365 Q150091
(c(Q838948)|c(Q502895),P135,c(Q2198855))
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q838948
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation P135
type Q2198855
type Q502895
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Q842183
relation P135
type Q838948
type Q502895
[ANSWERS]
[[{'concept': 'Q838948'}, {'concept': 'Q502895'}], 'P135', {'concept': 'Q2198855'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?c ) AS ?m ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?l ) { ( ontology:Q838948 ) ( ontology:Q502895 ) } . ?c rdf:type ?l } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?h ) WHERE { ?f property:P135 resource:Q842183 . { { ?f rdf:type ontology:Q838948 } UNION { ?f rdf:type ontology:Q502895 } } } } . FILTER ( ?m = ?h ) }
Post-painterly Abstraction Arte Povera Northern Mannerism Fantastic Realism avant-garde Post-Impressionism American Impressionism De Stijl Russian avant-garde Luminism Lyrical Abstraction purism Volcano School New Objectivity Antwerp Mannerism Novecento Italiano social realism Lingnan School Proto-Cubism Young British Artists École de Nancy historicism fantastic art Yoruba art Troubadour style New Sculpture Crozant School École de Dakar Luminism Inuit art neo-expressionism Photorealism Ghent-Bruges school Young Poland Proto-Renaissance High Renaissance Early Netherlandish painting Shin-hanga Orphism Stuckism Prehistoric art naturalism kinetic art Hoosier Group Brazilian modernism metaphysical art Katsukawa school Neo-primitivism Orientalism synthetism Hudson River School constructivism Neoplasticism contemporary art Color Field degenerate art Flemish Baroque painting Rayonism Gothic art Arts and Crafts movement realism Funk art socialist realism School of Fontainebleau pictorialism new media art Biedermeier Cuzco School Kanō school American Renaissance Benin art postmodernism Utrecht Caravaggism Post-romanticism Archaic Greek sculpture Cretan School Early Renaissance fauvism Antwerp school Florentine School primitivism conceptual art modernism renaissance Sōsaku-hanga minimalism Cubo-Futurism Pioneer Group relational art simultanism Hard-edge painting Viennese Actionism Dutch Golden Age painting abstract realism Informalism vorticism Mail art abstract impressionism Heidelberg School COBRA Tachisme Art Deco Yushan School Amsterdam Impressionism 20th-century classical music suprematism Neo-Grec Daedalic style Decadent movement Russian symbolism Pont-Aven School Hellenistic art Generation of the 30s Byzantine art action painting neo-Pompeian Modern sculpture rococo Nouvelle tendance Fluxus Pointillism concrete art Nihonga Egyptian Revival Barbizon school severe style Op art Costumbrismo Cloisonnism Chicago Imagists Superflat divisionism New British Sculpture Neo-Dada Orientalist painting Internet art cubism Nouveau réalisme brutalism yamato-e Neo-impressionism
COBRA Art Deco De Stijl
action approx
action union
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type work of art
action find_reverse_tuple_counts
relation movement
type cultural movement
type common name
action count
action filter_multi_types
action find_reverse
entity Shin-hanga
relation movement
type work of art
type common name
[[{'concept': 'work of art'}, {'concept': 'common name'}], 'movement', {'concept': 'cultural movement'}]
SELECT DISTINCT ?i WHERE { { SELECT DISTINCT ?i ( COUNT ( ?c ) AS ?m ) WHERE { VALUES ( ?l ) { ( ontology:work_of_art ) ( ontology:common_name ) } . ?c rdf:type ?l } GROUP BY ?i } . { SELECT DISTINCT ( COUNT ( ?f ) AS ?h ) WHERE { ?f property:movement resource:Shin-hanga . { { ?f rdf:type ontology:work_of_art } UNION { ?f rdf:type ontology:common_name } } } } . FILTER ( ?m = ?h ) }
[]
Simple Question (Direct)
Simple Question|Mult. Entity|Indirect
Q212611 Q173782 Q207445
P135
Q502895
USER
Which people are associated with COBRA, Art Deco and De Stijl ?
(c(Q502895),P135,Q212611) (c(Q502895),P135,Q173782) (c(Q502895),P135,Q207445)
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q212611
relation P135
type Q502895
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q173782
relation P135
type Q502895
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q207445
relation P135
type Q502895
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P135', 'Q212611'] [{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P135', 'Q173782'] [{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P135', 'Q207445']
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { ?d property:P135 ?n . VALUES ( ?n ) { ( resource:Q212611 ) ( resource:Q173782 ) } }
COBRA Art Deco De Stijl
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity COBRA
relation movement
type common name
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Art Deco
relation movement
type common name
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity De Stijl
relation movement
type common name
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'movement', 'COBRA'] [{'concept': 'common name'}, 'movement', 'Art Deco'] [{'concept': 'common name'}, 'movement', 'De Stijl']
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { ?d property:movement ?n . VALUES ( ?n ) { ( resource:COBRA ) ( resource:Art_Deco ) } }
[]
common name
Q451400 Q151803 Q160422
SYSTEM
René Lalique, Piet Mondrian, Theo van Doesburg
Q152793 Q2843600 Q2308298 Q83578 Q2866310 Q262273 Q3891589 Q229351 Q451400 Q3261329 Q2926823 Q18603572 Q3436103 Q13641206 Q2943690 Q954875 Q3171870 Q3164573 Q21481356 Q3426229 Q7287533 Q2456198 Q3141913 Q11919388 Q3188504 Q24275200 Q3288979 Q26702231 Q665935 Q11644640 Q3547795 Q4489860 Q151803 Q160422 Q160435
(c(Q502895),P135,Q212611) (c(Q502895),P135,Q173782) (c(Q502895),P135,Q207445)
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q212611
relation P135
type Q502895
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q173782
relation P135
type Q502895
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q207445
relation P135
type Q502895
[ANSWERS] are associated with COBRA, Art Deco and De Stijl
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P135', 'Q212611'] [{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P135', 'Q173782'] [{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P135', 'Q207445']
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { ?d property:P135 ?n . VALUES ( ?n ) { ( resource:Q212611 ) ( resource:Q173782 ) } }
Karel Appel Lotti van der Gaag Else Alfelt Asger Jorn Erik Thommesen Jean-Michel Frank Alix Aymé Tamara de Lempicka René Lalique Louis Bouquet Bruno Guillermin Thelma Saks Bradford Ingersoll Robert Poughéon Geo Henderick Cecil de Blaquiere Howard Jacques-Émile Ruhlmann Jean Dupas Jean-Bernard Descomps Eugène Belville René Gabriel Ralph Gerganoff Leon Hoet Hubert-Denis Etcheverry Enrique Estévez Ochoa Jules Criqui Maurice Alet Marcel Gaumont Bruno Zach Isidore Odorico Mounet Satomi Ugo Cipriani Antony Kok Piet Mondrian Theo van Doesburg Gerrit Rietveld
René Lalique, Piet Mondrian and Theo van Doesburg are associated with COBRA, Art Deco and De Stijl
René Lalique Piet Mondrian Theo van Doesburg
action union
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity COBRA
relation movement
type common name
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Art Deco
relation movement
type common name
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity De Stijl
relation movement
type common name
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'movement', 'COBRA'] [{'concept': 'common name'}, 'movement', 'Art Deco'] [{'concept': 'common name'}, 'movement', 'De Stijl']
SELECT DISTINCT ?d WHERE { ?d property:movement ?n . VALUES ( ?n ) { ( resource:COBRA ) ( resource:Art_Deco ) } }
[]
Clarification
Simple Question|Single Entity|Indirect
Q151803
P1038
Q502895
USER
Who is a relative of that one ?
(c(Q502895),P1038,Q151803)
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q151803
relation P1038
type Q502895
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P1038', 'Q151803']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k property:P1038 resource:Q151803 . ?k rdf:type ontology:Q502895 }
Piet Mondrian
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Piet Mondrian
relation relative
type common name
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'relative', 'Piet Mondrian']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k property:relative resource:Piet_Mondrian . ?k rdf:type ontology:common_name }
[]
common name
Clarification for simple ques.
Q451400
SYSTEM
Did you mean René Lalique ?
Q451400 Q151803 Q160422
(c(Q502895),P1038,Q451400) (c(Q502895),P1038,Q151803) (c(Q502895),P1038,Q160422)
[ANSWER]
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P1038', 'Q451400'] [{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P1038', 'Q151803'] [{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P1038', 'Q160422']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k property:P1038 resource:Q151803 . ?k rdf:type ontology:Q502895 }
René Lalique Piet Mondrian Theo van Doesburg
Did you mean René Lalique ?
René Lalique
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'relative', 'René Lalique'] [{'concept': 'common name'}, 'relative', 'Piet Mondrian'] [{'concept': 'common name'}, 'relative', 'Theo van Doesburg']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k property:relative resource:Piet_Mondrian . ?k rdf:type ontology:common_name }
[]
Simple Question (Coreferenced)
USER
No, I meant Piet Mondrian. Could you tell me the answer for that?
(c(Q502895),P1038,Q151803)
Q151803
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P1038', 'Q151803']
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'relative', 'Piet Mondrian']
[]
Q2894581
SYSTEM
Frits Mondriaan
Q2894581
(c(Q502895),P1038,Q151803)
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Q151803
relation P1038
type Q502895
A relative of that one is [ANSWER]
[{'concept': 'Q502895'}, 'P1038', 'Q151803']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k property:P1038 resource:Q151803 . ?k rdf:type ontology:Q502895 }
Frits Mondriaan
A relative of that one is Frits Mondriaan
Frits Mondriaan
action filter_type
action find_reverse
entity Piet Mondrian
relation relative
type common name
[{'concept': 'common name'}, 'relative', 'Piet Mondrian']
SELECT DISTINCT ?k WHERE { ?k property:relative resource:Piet_Mondrian . ?k rdf:type ontology:common_name }
[]