title: Collectivist anarchism
text: # Collectivist anarchism
  
  Part of a series on :
  
  Anarchism :
  
  History
  
  Outline :
  
  Schools of thought
  
  Feminist
  
  Green
  
  Primitivist
  
  Social ecology
  
  Total liberation
  
  Individualist
  
  Egoist
  
  Existentialist
  
  Free-market
  
  Naturist
  
  Philosophical
  
  Mutualism
  
  Postcolonial
  
  African
  
  Black
  
  Queer
  
  Religious
  
  Christian
  
  Jewish
  
  Social
  
  Collectivist
  
  Parecon
  
  Communist
  
  Magonism
  
  Without adjectives
  
  Methodology
  
  Agorism
  
  Illegalism
  
  Insurrectionary
  
  Communization
  
  Expropriative
  
  Pacifist
  
  Platformism
  
  Especifismo
  
  Relationship
  
  Syndicalist
  
  Synthesis :
  
  Theory
  
  Practice
  
  Anarchy
  
  Anarchist Black Cross
  
  Anarchist criminology
  
  Anationalism
  
  Anti-authoritarianism
  
  Anti-capitalism
  
  Anti-militarism
  
  Affinity group
  
  Autonomous social center
  
  Black bloc
  
  Classless society
  
  Class struggle
  
  Consensus decision-making
  
  Conscientious objector
  
  Critique of work
  
  Decentralization
  
  Deep ecology
  
  Direct action
  
  Free association
  
  Free love
  
  Freethought
  
  Horizontalidad
  
  Individualism
  
  Isocracy
  
  Law
  
  Mutual aid
  
  Participatory politics
  
  Permanent autonomous zone
  
  Prefigurative politics
  
  Proletarian internationalism
  
  Propaganda of the deed
  
  Refusal of work
  
  Revolution
  
  Revolutionary spontaneity
  
  Rewilding
  
  Security culture
  
  Self-ownership
  
  Social ecology
  
  Sociocracy
  
  Somatherapy
  
  Spontaneous order
  
  Squatting
  
  Temporary autonomous zone
  
  Union of egoists
  
  Voluntary association
  
  Workers' council :
  
  People
  
  Armand
  
  Ba
  
  Bakunin
  
  Berkman
  
  Bonanno
  
  Bookchin
  
  Chomsky
  
  Cleyre
  
  Day
  
  Durruti
  
  Ellul
  
  Ervin
  
  Faure
  
  Ferrer
  
  Feyerabend
  
  Godwin
  
  Goldman
  
  González Prada
  
  Graeber
  
  Guillaume
  
  He-Yin
  
  Kanno
  
  Kōtoku
  
  Kropotkin
  
  Landauer
  
  Liu
  
  Magón
  
  Makhno
  
  Malatesta
  
  Michel
  
  Most
  
  Parsons
  
  Pi
  
  Proudhon
  
  Rocker
  
  Santillán
  
  Spooner
  
  Stirner
  
  Thoreau
  
  Tolstoy
  
  Tucker
  
  Volin
  
  Ward
  
  Warren
  
  Zerzan :
  
  Issues
  
  Animal rights
  
  Capitalism
  
  Education
  
  Love and sex
  
  Nationalism
  
  Religion
  
  Violence :
  
  History
  
  Paris Commune
  
  Spanish Regional Federation of the IWA
  
  Cantonal rebellion
  
  Hague Congress
  
  International Conference of Rome
  
  Trial of the Thirty
  
  Haymarket affair
  
  May Day
  
  Congress of Amsterdam
  
  Tragic Week
  
  High Treason Incident
  
  Manifesto of the Sixteen
  
  Individualist anarchism in the United States
  
  1919 United States bombings
  
  Biennio Rosso
  
  German Revolution of 1918–1919
  
  Bavarian Soviet Republic
  
  Kronstadt rebellion
  
  Makhnovshchina
  
  Amakasu Incident
  
  Escuela Moderna
  
  Individualist anarchism in Europe
  
  Spanish Revolution of 1936
  
  Barcelona May Days
  
  Red inverted triangle
  
  Labadie Collection
  
  May 1968
  
  Provo
  
  LIP
  
  Kate Sharpley Library
  
  Australian Anarchist Centenary
  
  Carnival Against Capital
  
  1999 Seattle WTO protests
  
  Really Really Free Market
  
  Occupy movement :
  
  Culture
  
  A las Barricadas
  
  Anarchist bookfair
  
  Anarcho-punk
  
  Arts
  
  Culture jamming
  
  DIY ethic
  
  Films
  
  Freeganism
  
  Glossary
  
  Infoshop
  
  Independent Media Center
  
  The Internationale
  
  Jewish anarchism
  
  Lifestylism
  
  "No gods, no masters"
  
  Popular education
  
  "Property is theft!"
  
  Radical cheerleading
  
  Radical environmentalism
  
  Squatting
  
  Symbolism :
  
  Economics
  
  Communization
  
  Cooperative
  
  Cost the limit of price
  
  General strike
  
  Gift economy
  
  Give-away shop
  
  Free association
  
  Labour voucher
  
  Market abolitionism
  
  Mutual aid
  
  Mutual credit
  
  Participatory economics
  
  Social ownership
  
  Wage slavery
  
  Workers' self-management :
  
  By region
  
  Africa
  
  Albania
  
  Algeria
  
  Andorra
  
  Argentina
  
  Armenia
  
  Australia
  
  Austria
  
  Azerbaijan
  
  Bangladesh
  
  Belarus
  
  Belgium
  
  Bolivia
  
  Bosnia and Herzegovina
  
  Brazil
  
  Bulgaria
  
  Canada
  
  Chile
  
  China
  
  Colombia
  
  Costa Rica
  
  Croatia
  
  Cuba
  
  Czech Republic
  
  Denmark
  
  Dominican Republic
  
  East Timor
  
  Ecuador
  
  Egypt
  
  El Salvador
  
  Estonia
  
  Finland
  
  France
  
  French Guiana
  
  Georgia
  
  Germany
  
  Greece
  
  Guatemala
  
  Hong Kong
  
  Hungary
  
  Iceland
  
  India
  
  Indonesia
  
  Iran
  
  Ireland
  
  Israel
  
  Italy
  
  Japan
  
  Korea
  
  Latvia
  
  Malaysia
  
  Mexico
  
  Monaco
  
  Mongolia
  
  Morocco
  
  Netherlands
  
  New Zealand
  
  Nicaragua
  
  Nigeria
  
  Norway
  
  Panama
  
  Paraguay
  
  Peru
  
  Philippines
  
  Poland
  
  Portugal
  
  Puerto Rico
  
  Romania
  
  Russia
  
  Serbia
  
  Singapore
  
  South Africa
  
  Spain
  
  Sweden
  
  Switzerland
  
  Syria
  
  Taiwan
  
  Tunisia
  
  Turkey
  
  Ukraine
  
  United Kingdom
  
  United States
  
  Uruguay
  
  Venezuela
  
  Vietnam :
  
  Lists
  
  Anarcho-punk bands
  
  Books
  
  Communities
  
  Fictional characters
  
  Films
  
  Jewish anarchists
  
  Musicians
  
  Periodicals :
  
  Related topics
  
  Anti-corporatism
  
  Anti-consumerism
  
  Anti-fascism
  
  Anti-globalization
  
  Anti-statism
  
  Anti-war movement
  
  Autarchism
  
  Autonomism
  
  Communism
  
  Counter-economics
  
  Definition of anarchism and libertarianism
  
  Labour movement
  
  Left communism
  
  Left-libertarianism
  
  Libertarianism
  
  Libertarian Marxism
  
  Libertarian socialism
  
  Marxism
  
  Situationist International
  
  Socialism
  
  Spontaneous order
  
  Voluntaryism :
  
  Anarchism portal
  
  Politics portal :
  
  vte :
  
  Collectivist anarchism, also called anarchist collectivism and anarcho-collectivism, is an anarchist school of thought that advocates the abolition of both the state and private ownership of the means of production. In their place, it envisions both the collective ownership of the means of production and the entitlement of workers to the fruits of their own labour, which would be ensured by a societal pact between individuals and collectives. Collectivists considered trade unions to be the means through which to bring about collectivism through a social revolution, where they would form the nucleus for a post-capitalist society.
  
  The tendency was initially conceived as a synthesis of social equality and liberty, by the Russian revolutionary socialist Mikhail Bakunin. It is commonly associated with the anti-authoritarian sections of the International Workingmen's Association and the early Spanish anarchist movement, with whom it continued to hold a strong influence until the end of the 19th century. Eventually, it was supplanted as the dominant tendency of anarchism by anarcho-communism, which advocated for the abolition of wages and the distribution of resources "from each according to their ability, to each according to their needs".
  
  ## History
  
  Collectivist anarchism was first formulated within the International Workingmen's Association (IWA), under the influence of Mikhail Bakunin. Bakunin had been inspired by the traditional agrarian collectivism practiced by the Russian peasantry and wished to see its principles of mutual aid applied to industrial society, which he hoped to mobilise in favour of liberty and social equality. According to Friedrich Engels, Bakunin's collectivism represented a synthesis of Karl Marx's communism and Pierre-Joseph Proudhon's mutualism. Bakunin rejected the communist principle of "from each according to their ability, to each according to their needs", considering instead that resources would have to be distributed according to one's own labour. While Bakunin accepted Proudhon's organisational theory of federalism, he also rejected the mutualist centring of the independent artisan, instead considering the collective to be the base social unit for organising society.
  
  Bakunin's collectivism had widespread appeal in Spain, where industrial workers and rural peasants found inspiration in its precepts of decentralisation and direct action. From the outset of anarchism's introduction to Spain in 1868, Spanish anarchists largely subscribed to collectivism, inspired by Bakunin's anarchist doctrine, while also drawing from the anti-authoritarianism and federalism espoused by Francesc Pi i Margall. Pi's influence on the collectivists was most pronounced in the work of Juan Serrano Oteiza, an early convert to collectivist anarchism who envisaged a federal society that upheld the autonomy of the individual, trade union and municipality. But Serrano's collectivism differed from Pi's federalism by rejecting reformist political parties and instead upholding the working class as the agents of revolutionary change.
  
  By the 1870s, the Spanish Regional Federation of the International Workingmen's Association (FRE-AIT) had widely disseminated the doctrine of collectivist anarchism, with its principles being widely adopted by workers' societies, many of which were not even anarchist themselves. Following the collapse of the FRE-AIT, in 1881, the Barcelona branch reconstituted the organisation as the Federation of Workers of the Spanish Region (FTRE), which was established according to the principles of collectivist anarchism.
  
  ### Break with anarcho-communism
  
  While anarchist theory in Spain remained stagnant, with collectivist positions staying largely unchanged, the international anarchist movement developed towards anarcho-communism and many anarchists began to adopt the theory of propaganda of the deed, in a process spearhead by the Italian anarchists. Within the Jura Federation, collectivists led by Adhémar Schwitzguébel resisted the adoption of communism, but the transition from collectivism to communism went by largely without controversy. However, in Spain, where collectivist anarchists had been uniquely successful within the trade unionist movement, collectivism maintained its foothold for much longer than in other countries. It was only when their trade union activities began to be suppressed that the Spanish anarchists gravitated towards communism.
  
  The anarcho-communists criticized the collectivist model of workers' entitlement to the fruit of their labour, which they believed would disenfranchise non-producers and risk creating a new ruling class that determined wages. Instead, they advocate for the abolition of wage labour and its replacement with a system of solidarity, where all property was held in common. This development of collectivism into communism had been preceded by the writings of James Guillaume, who outlined a post-capitalist system where resources would be distributed "from each according to their ability, to each according to their needs", while the collectivist system would be used during the transition out of capitalism. In organizational terms, the communists opposed the trade unions advocated by the collectivists, viewing them as fundamentally reformist and bureaucratic, and thus as incompatible with anti-authoritarian models of organization. Instead, the communists preferred small affinity groups that could carry out violent attacks against the economic order, upholding the theory of propaganda of the deed.
  
  In 1884, the Seville Congress of the FTRE resulted in many anarchists leaving the organisation, as they no longer believed it to be the best vehicle for organising the working class towards a social revolution. This preceded a complete break between Spanish collectivists and communists, which took place the following year. Serrano attempted to defend the collectivism of the FTRE from the rise of communism, considering the two tendencies to be irreconcilably opposed to each other. But Serrano's arguments were unsuccessful in rallying support, as the more moderate collectivism began to give way to the more radical communism. Public debates on the merits of the two systems also lay the groundwork for the development of an intellectual tradition in Spanish anarchism.
  
  ### Decline of collectivism
  
  The rise of communism, which challenged the collectivist principles of the FTRE, eventually resulted in the organisation's dissolution. In 1888, the Catalan regional federation of the FTRE was reorganised into the Union and Solidarity Pact, which nominally retained a collectivist orientation, but accepted members from all tendencies. The collectivist Ricardo Mella opposed the formation of the Pact, as he considered it to be a fundamentally communist organisation and worried it would undermine the FTRE. The collapse of the FTRE marked the supplanting of collectivism as the dominant anarchist ideology in Spain, as the communists consolidated control over the movement. Mella hoped to reconstitute the FTRE, refusing to even recognise its dissolution and proposing its reorganisation along more decentralised lines. But his efforts were ultimately futile, as most Spanish collectivists supported the dissolution of the FTRE.
  
  In the years that followed, efforts were made in the libertarian press to reconcile the split. In the pages of El Productor [es], the collectivist Cels Gomis i Mestre [ca] made appeals against dogmatism. Anarchists that opposed the schism eventually went on to establish the tendency of "anarchism without adjectives", in order to overcome the ideological disputes between the two factions. The collectivist-communist debate also inspired Errico Malatesta to develop towards a pluralist conception of anarchism. Although he personally favoured anarcho-communism, he distinguished between his desired ends and the means by which the social revolution would take place, believing that the organisation of society should be left to spontaneous development. He thus proposed a union between communists and collectivists, based on a common tactical line, arguing against dogmatism as an authoritarian instinct. But in spite of his pluralist inclinations, Malatesta continued to argue against collectivism, considering it to be incompatible with anarchism.
  
  By the end of the 19th century, collectivism had been reduced to a minority tendency in Spain, subsumed by anarcho-communism. This also gave way to the development of anarcho-syndicalism, which united community and labour organizing, overcoming both the localism of the collectivists and the conspiratorial nature of the communists.
  
  ### Later developments
  
  Collectivist anarchism remained prominent in the rural areas of Andalusia, where local skilled workers were attracted to the promises of collective labour, with individual ownership over the fruits of that labour. During the Spanish Revolution of 1936, many of the ideas proposed by collectivist anarchism were put into practice, as the advance of the confederal militias gave way to the widespread collectivization of agriculture (around 35-40%) throughout the Spanish Republic.
  
  Modern descendants of collectivist anarchism include participatory economics, as advocated by Michael Albert and Robin Hahnel, which takes up the collectivist model of remuneration.
  
  ## People
  
  * Mikhail Bakunin
  * Ernest Cœurderoy
  * César De Paepe
  * Giuseppe Fanelli
  * Cels Gomis i Mestre [ca]
  * James Guillaume
  * Josep Llunas i Pujals
  * Ricardo Mella
  * Walery Mroczkowski
  * Adhémar Schwitzguébel
  * Juan Serrano Oteiza
  * Francesc Tomàs Oliver
  