title: New York Mutuals all-time roster
text: # New York Mutuals all-time roster
  
  The New York Mutuals baseball club, established 1859, played five seasons in the National Association, 1871–1875, and one in the National League, 1876. Here is a list of all their players in regular season games beginning 1871.
  
  † Bold names identify members of the National Baseball Hall of Fame.
  
  * Top
  * 0–9
  * A
  * B
  * C
  * D
  * E
  * F
  * G
  * H
  * I
  * J
  * K
  * L
  * M
  * N
  * O
  * P
  * Q
  * R
  * S
  * T
  * U
  * V
  * W
  * X
  * Y
  * Z
  
  ## A
  
  * Doug Allison
  
  ## B
  
  * Billy Barnie
  * George Bechtel
  * Steve Bellán
  * Eddie Booth
  * Bill Boyd
  * Jack Burdock
  
  ## C
  
  * Tom Carey
  * Bill Craver
  * Candy $Cummings^†$
  
  ## E
  
  * Dave Eggler
  
  ## F
  
  * George Fair
  * Bob Ferguson
  * Frank Fleet
  * Davy Force
  * Chick Fulmer
  
  ## G
  
  * Count Gedney
  * Billy Geer
  * Joe Gerhardt
  
  ## H
  
  * Jimmy Hallinan
  * John Hatfield
  * John Hayes
  * George Heubel
  * Nat Hicks
  * Dick Higham
  * Jim Holdsworth
  
  ## L
  
  * Terry Larkin
  
  ## M
  
  * John Maloney
  * Phonney Martin
  * Bobby Mathews
  * Pat McGee
  * John McGuinness
  * John McMullin
  * Al Metcalf
  * Charlie Mills
  
  ## N
  
  * Candy Nelson
  * Al Nichols
  
  ## P
  
  * Tom Patterson
  * Dickey Pearce
  * Nealy Phelps
  
  ## R
  
  * Jack Remsen
  
  ## S
  
  * George Seward
  * Jim Shanley
  * Orator Shaffer
  * Charlie Smith
  * Joe Start
  
  ## T
  
  * Fred Treacey
  * Pete Treacey
  
  ## V
  
  * Bob Valentine
  
  ## W
  
  * Billy West
  * Rynie Wolters
  