title: Feminists Fighting Pornography
text: # Feminists Fighting Pornography
  
  Part of a series on :
  
  Feminism :
  
  History
  
  Feminist history
  
  History of feminism
  
  Women's history
  
  American
  
  British
  
  Canadian
  
  German
  
  Waves
  
  First
  
  Second
  
  Third
  
  Fourth
  
  Timelines
  
  Women's suffrage
  
  Muslim countries
  
  US
  
  Other women's rights
  
  Women's suffrage by country
  
  Austria
  
  Australia
  
  Canada
  
  India
  
  Japan
  
  Kuwait
  
  Liechtenstein
  
  New Zealand
  
  Spain
  
  Second Republic
  
  Francoist
  
  Switzerland
  
  United Kingdom
  
  Cayman Islands
  
  Wales
  
  United States
  
  states :
  
  Intersectional variants
  
  Fat
  
  Lesbian
  
  Lesbian of color
  
  Radical lesbianism
  
  Separatist
  
  Sex-positive
  
  Lipstick
  
  Stiletto
  
  Transfeminism
  
  Postgenderism
  
  Vegetarian ecofeminism
  
  Socialist
  
  Anarchist
  
  Queer
  
  Jineology
  
  Marxist
  
  Critical theory
  
  Standpoint
  
  Materialist
  
  Ecofeminist
  
  Postcolonial
  
  Global
  
  Transnational
  
  Xenofeminism
  
  Multicultural
  
  Africana womanism
  
  Black
  
  Hip hop
  
  Lesbian
  
  Ratchet
  
  Chicana
  
  Lesbian
  
  Indigenous
  
  Native American
  
  Multiracial
  
  Romani
  
  Womanism :
  
  Conservative variants
  
  Anti-abortion
  
  Anti-pornography
  
  Equity
  
  Eugenic
  
  Femonationalism
  
  Maternal
  
  Postfeminism
  
  Neofeminism
  
  Reactionary
  
  State
  
  Carceral
  
  Imperial
  
  Embedded
  
  Trans-exclusionary
  
  Victim
  
  White :
  
  Religious variants
  
  Atheist
  
  Buddhist
  
  Christian
  
  Mormon
  
  New
  
  Womanist
  
  Asian
  
  Neopagan
  
  Dianic Wicca
  
  Reclaiming
  
  Ecofeminist
  
  Hindu
  
  Islamic
  
  Jewish
  
  Orthodox
  
  Sikh :
  
  Movements and ideologies
  
  Analytical
  
  Anti-fascist
  
  Cyberfeminism
  
  HCI
  
  Networked
  
  Ecofeminism
  
  Individualist
  
  Liberal
  
  Difference
  
  Cultural
  
  Equality
  
  Social
  
  Labor
  
  Libertarian
  
  Post-structural
  
  French
  
  Postmodern
  
  Radical
  
  Political lesbianism
  
  Separatist
  
  Women's liberation
  
  Technofeminism :
  
  Concepts
  
  Literature
  
  Children's literature
  
  Discrimination against transgender women
  
  Effects on society
  
  Equality
  
  Female education
  
  Female genital mutilation
  
  Femicide
  
  Feminism in culture
  
  Feminist movement
  
  African-American women's suffrage movement
  
  Art movement
  
  In hip hop
  
  Feminist stripper
  
  Gender equality
  
  Girl power
  
  Honor killing
  
  Internalized sexism
  
  International Girl's Day and Women's Day
  
  Language reform
  
  Male privilege
  
  Matriarchal religion
  
  Media
  
  Men in feminism
  
  Misogyny
  
  Oedipus complex
  
  Opposition to feminism
  
  Pro-feminism
  
  Protofeminism
  
  Purplewashing
  
  Reproductive justice
  
  Sex workers' rights
  
  Sexual harassment
  
  Sexual objectification
  
  Toxic masculinity
  
  Transmisogyny
  
  Triple oppression
  
  Violence against women
  
  War on women
  
  Women-only space
  
  Women's health
  
  Women's rights
  
  Women in the workforce :
  
  Outlooks
  
  Bicycling and feminism
  
  Criticism of marriage
  
  Views on BDSM
  
  Views on pornography
  
  Views on prostitution
  
  Views on sexual orientation
  
  Views on sexuality
  
  Views on transgender topics :
  
  Theory
  
  Feminist method
  
  Gender studies
  
  Gender mainstreaming
  
  Gynocentrism
  
  Kyriarchy
  
  Male gaze
  
  Matriarchy
  
  Women's studies
  
  Men's studies
  
  Patriarchy
  
  Écriture féminine
  
  Areas of study
  
  Anthropology
  
  Archaeology
  
  Architecture
  
  Art
  
  Art criticism
  
  Literary criticism
  
  Film theory
  
  Science fiction
  
  Biology
  
  Composition studies
  
  Criminology
  
  Pathways perspective
  
  Economics
  
  FDPA
  
  Geography
  
  International relations
  
  Constructivism
  
  Legal theory
  
  Pedagogy
  
  Philosophy
  
  Aesthetics
  
  Empiricism
  
  Epistemology
  
  Ethics
  
  Justice ethics
  
  Existentialism
  
  Metaphysics
  
  science
  
  Political ecology
  
  Political theory
  
  Pornography
  
  Psychology
  
  Therapy
  
  Revisionist mythology
  
  Sex wars
  
  Sexology
  
  Sociology
  
  Technoscience
  
  Theology
  
  womanist theology :
  
  By country
  
  Albania
  
  Australia
  
  Bangladesh
  
  Canada
  
  China
  
  Democratic Republic of the Congo
  
  Denmark
  
  Egypt
  
  Ethiopia
  
  Finland
  
  France
  
  Germany
  
  Ghana
  
  Greece
  
  Hong Kong
  
  India
  
  Indonesia
  
  Iran
  
  Iraq
  
  Republic of Ireland
  
  Israel
  
  Italy
  
  Japan
  
  Latin America
  
  Argentina
  
  Brazil
  
  Chile
  
  Haiti
  
  Honduras
  
  Mexico
  
  Paraguay
  
  Trinidad and Tobago
  
  Lebanon
  
  Malaysia
  
  Mali
  
  Nepal
  
  Netherlands
  
  New Zealand
  
  Nigeria
  
  Northern Cyprus
  
  Norway
  
  Pakistan
  
  Philippines
  
  Poland
  
  Russia
  
  Syria
  
  Saudi Arabia
  
  South Africa
  
  South Korea
  
  Sweden
  
  Taiwan
  
  Thailand
  
  Turkey
  
  Vietnam
  
  Ukraine
  
  United Kingdom
  
  United States
  
  History of women :
  
  Lists and categories
  
  Lists
  
  Articles
  
  Feminists
  
  by nationality
  
  Literature
  
  American feminist literature
  
  Feminist comic books
  
  Feminist songs
  
  Conservative feminisms
  
  Ecofeminist authors
  
  Feminist art critics
  
  Feminist economists
  
  Feminist philosophers
  
  Feminist poets
  
  Feminist rhetoricians
  
  Jewish feminists
  
  Muslim feminists
  
  Feminist parties
  
  Suffragists and suffragettes
  
  Women's rights activists
  
  Women's studies journals
  
  Women's suffrage organizations
  
  Categories
  
  Women's rights by country
  
  Feminists by nationality :
  
  Feminism portal :
  
  vte :
  
  Feminists Fighting Pornography (FFP, pronounced /fip/) was a political activist organization against pornography. It advocated for United States Federal legislation to allow lawsuits against the porn industry by women whose attackers were inspired by pornography. FFP was based in New York, N.Y., was founded in 1983 or 1984, and dissolved in 1997.
  
  ## Issue positions
  
  FFP opposed pornography. It is defined as the sexualized degrading, dominating, humiliating, objectifying, subjugating, violating, annihilating, exploiting, or violence and is distinguished from erotica, which is based on mutuality of power and pleasure. According to FFP founder Page Mellish, pornography provides the training for incest, assault, and rape, results in the objectification of women, affects women's ability to get equal rights and equal pay and encourages men associate sex with violence. Mellish ultimately claimed that all feminist issues were rooted in pornography. In a 1986 letter to the editor of The Wall Street Journal, an FFP member asserted that the members are "not against love and not against sex."
  
  Mellish held all men and women who did not fight against pornography as accountable for violence against women, and claimed that women who enjoyed pornography or rough sex had "internalized the male definition of power".
  
  Positions on pornography have been debated outside of FFP, including with respect to porn's effect on crime and feminist definitions of porn.
  
  ## Leadership
  
  FFP's founder and organizer was Page Mellish, formerly of the staff of Women Against Pornography, and also formerly of Women Against Pornography and Violence in the Media and National Organization for Women, both of San Francisco, California.
  
  ## Legislative agenda
  
  Feminists Fighting Pornography supported the Pornography Victims Compensation Act of 1991. Though the bill had some support including from "many feminists", it was not supported by Andrea Dworkin, Catharine MacKinnon, and some other feminists. Supporting the bill, Mellish appeared on a Larry King show, where she credited executed serial killer of women Ted Bundy, who claimed pornography as an influence, with bringing attention to the issue. Under the bill, a person who was attacked after the attacker was substantially spurred by pornography could sue the pornography's producers, publishers, distributors, exhibitors, and sellers without needing a prior criminal charge for the pornography itself. To be pragmatic toward passage, the bill was limited to child pornography and obscene material. The bill has been criticized. FFP also supported an earlier bill, the Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1987, for which FFP listed as endorsers "many [other] women's and children's organizations" and had "signatures of thousands" of bill supporters.
  
  In other legislative matters:
  
  * FFP also supported the anti-pornography civil rights ordinance supported by Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon.
  * It did not support anti-obscenity laws, because, in FFP's view, they did not address the harm of porn.
  * Legislation alone was not a complete solution, according to Page Mellish; it was also necessary to remove "the need for porn".
  
  ### Congressional testimony
  
  Page Mellish, testifying to the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee in 1991 as "a professional activist .... employed ... [by] Feminists Fighting Pornography", stating that the porn industry is large and that "a majority of ... [the] product" of the porn "industry ... either degrades or violates women", spoke on "the real harm of pornography—its proximate cause to violence against women. This causal link was a primary finding of the Attorney General's Commission on Pornography upon examination of research which included a Michigan State Police study finding pornography was used or imitated just prior to or during 41 percent of the State's sexual assaults, a North Carolina State Police study that found 75 percent of the State's defendants in violent sexual assault cases had hardcore pornography in their homes or vehicles, and the FBI's finding that serial killers' most commonly shared trait was extreme pornography use." "The bill's proximate cause on incitement and influence is responsive to a Queen's University study in which 30 percent of sex offenders listed pornography as inciteful, preparatory, and instigative to the crime, and found rapists used pornography more than nonrapists." "[O]ne in four women respondents to Women's [sic] Day magazine ... reported being sexually abused as a direct result of pornographic materials .... [A] Yale University study ... found States with the highest pornography consumption had the highest rape rates, and lowest consumption, lowest rape rates." "Seventy-three percent [of "Americans in the Gallup poll in 1985"] affirmed sexual—note that there was no stipulation on violence—affirmed sexual magazines, movies, and books lead some people to commit sexual violence. In a Gallup poll of 1986, 76 percent mandated a ban of magazines containing sexual violence." In the balance of her testimony, she addressed the bill as noncensoring because it imposed "no prior restraint or State empowerment" and criticized the opposition.
  
  Congress is required to have a rational basis for legislation that, without it, might violate a right of a person under the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution's 14th Amendment but is not required to validate scientific conclusions to the same degree that may be required in academic science; rather, the legislative reasoning must not be arbitrary. This testimony stated the position in 1991 of Feminists Fighting Pornography and was noted by the American Bar Association's ABA Journal.
  
  ## Strategy
  
  FFP did not advocate burning porn parlors down, as was done in England, but advocated for men not going to such places. Mellish preferred to organize marches instead, because she believed her ability to be grassroots organizing: "Even bombing porn houses only gets their attention; then we have to change men's view of women, change their idea of power." FFP performed some little crimes, like destroying the ads of the pornographic magazine Penthouse, which advertised in New York City Subway stations. FFP aimed to drive pornography out of stores and theaters, acknowledging that the effect would be to drive it into the underground economy, but not to destroy it completely. Role-reversal, having women view men as mere sex objects, was also not part of their ideology.
  
  ## Activism
  
  The FFP advocated in a variety of ways:
  
  * Electoral campaigns:
     * It invited people to bring banners to New York Mayoral candidates' headquarters in 1985.
     * It assisted the election campaign of Green for Congress, reporting 100 FFP members doing so, in 1989. Bill Green was a Republican U.S. Representative for a district in Manhattan. He was re-elected that year. During his Congressional career, he introduced The Pornography Victims Protection Act as a bill.
     * Mellish demonstrated in 1992 against United States Senate candidate Geraldine Ferraro on the issue of her husband providing real estate to a pornographer. Whether the demonstration was the organization's is unknown.
  * Demonstrations and marches:
     * It marched on 42d Street, Manhattan, on Apr. 8, 1984. At the time, 42d St. was known for its many pornographic businesses.
     * On Oct. 20, 1984, 500 women marched in Times Square under the sponsorship of Feminists Fighting Pornography.
     * On Jan. 13, 1985, held a demonstration objecting to an award to an MTV vice president for contributing to fashion.
     * FFP demonstrated against what they believed to be the district attorney's sexism in a case where a woman was reported as killing her fiancé after he broke down her door.
  * Petitions and tabling:
     * In early 1984, FFP collected signatures on a petition protesting a store selling Snuff, the film, on cassette.
     * In 1984, Mellish was tabling daily to educate the public. In 1989, she said that "'[p]eople aren't aware of this [kind of pornography]'". FFP's tabling was sometimes confused by the public as being by Women Against Pornography. One book writer later recalled of 1984 a woman from Feminists Fighting Pornography was tabling in Manhattan and seeking signatures for a petition. "Beside her was a giant blowup of the notorious cover of Hustler that showed a woman's legs sticking out of a meat grinder."
     * In an unknown year, FFP tabled in Washington, D.C.
     * The group was known for openly displaying pornography as part of anti-pornography information tabling. There were "public complaints of their streetcorner display that had nude photos", including that it was "disgusting". In one instance in 1989, Page Mellish and FFP member Dee Vaughan were arrested and jailed, according to The National Law Journal. She said, according to the same newspaper, "'We've been arrested or had our pornography confiscated approximately seven times.'" Despite these reactions, "her group ... keeps setting up shop, hoping, she says, to educate the public", according to the newspaper then. That same year, according to USA Today, Page Mellish and Dee Vaughan asked a state judge to dismiss obscenity charges for the nude photos. Attorney Ron Kuby, then of Bill Kunstler's law firm, provided legal representation, according to The National Law Journal, and the New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU), according to the Virginia Law Review, provided legal services (whether on separate cases or together is unknown). The result was that the legal right to display such material was sought and established. American Civil Liberties Union President Nadine Strossen criticized FFP for seeking a right to display pornography while opposing others' doing so.
     * In 1987, in support of the Pornography Victims Protection Act, then a bill, Sen. Specter, as he was introducing it, said FFP "has collected signatures of thousands of concerned individuals supporting passage of this bill."
  * Other activism:
     * It named feminist and civil liberties organizations that, according to FFP, had received funding from Playboy Foundation, although it is not clear whether all such organizations applied for or accepted the funds.
     * It offered tours of 42d Street and an FFP slideshow.
     * It called for the boycotting of all stores that sell pornography.
     * FFP was critical of the American Civil Liberties Union with regard to child porn.
  
  ## Newsletter and press
  
  Its newsletter or magazine was The Backlash Times. It was being published by 1983 or 1984 and continued until at least 1989. The newsletter carried news reports related to pornography generally, such as on assaults, responses, finances, politics, and legislation. It also published images from pornography, for which the group was criticized ("ironically but perhaps necessarily disseminating it ["porn"] further"). In response, the group raised the need to make clear what it was opposing, such as violence against and degradation of women, and thereby distinguish it from what it was not opposing, especially erotica.
  
  In 1992 and after recent favorable "'attention'", Ms. Mellish said, "'[t]he press has censored our movement because the press has a vested interest in the First Amendment'", referring to the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and freedoms of speech and press.
  
  