title: Social feminism
text: # Social feminism
  
  Part of a series on :
  
  Feminism :
  
  History
  
  Feminist history
  
  History of feminism
  
  Women's history
  
  American
  
  British
  
  Canadian
  
  German
  
  Waves
  
  First
  
  Second
  
  Third
  
  Fourth
  
  Timelines
  
  Women's suffrage
  
  Muslim countries
  
  US
  
  Other women's rights
  
  Women's suffrage by country
  
  Austria
  
  Australia
  
  Canada
  
  India
  
  Japan
  
  Kuwait
  
  Liechtenstein
  
  New Zealand
  
  Spain
  
  Second Republic
  
  Francoist
  
  Switzerland
  
  United Kingdom
  
  Cayman Islands
  
  Wales
  
  United States
  
  states :
  
  Intersectional variants
  
  Fat
  
  Lesbian
  
  Lesbian of color
  
  Radical lesbianism
  
  Separatist
  
  Sex-positive
  
  Lipstick
  
  Stiletto
  
  Transfeminism
  
  Postgenderism
  
  Vegetarian ecofeminism
  
  Socialist
  
  Anarchist
  
  Queer
  
  Jineology
  
  Marxist
  
  Critical theory
  
  Standpoint
  
  Materialist
  
  Ecofeminist
  
  Postcolonial
  
  Global
  
  Transnational
  
  Xenofeminism
  
  Multicultural
  
  Africana womanism
  
  Black
  
  Hip hop
  
  Lesbian
  
  Ratchet
  
  Chicana
  
  Lesbian
  
  Indigenous
  
  Native American
  
  Multiracial
  
  Romani
  
  Womanism :
  
  Conservative variants
  
  Anti-abortion
  
  Anti-pornography
  
  Equity
  
  Eugenic
  
  Femonationalism
  
  Maternal
  
  Postfeminism
  
  Neofeminism
  
  Reactionary
  
  State
  
  Carceral
  
  Imperial
  
  Embedded
  
  Trans-exclusionary
  
  Victim
  
  White :
  
  Religious variants
  
  Atheist
  
  Buddhist
  
  Christian
  
  Mormon
  
  New
  
  Womanist
  
  Asian
  
  Neopagan
  
  Dianic Wicca
  
  Reclaiming
  
  Ecofeminist
  
  Hindu
  
  Islamic
  
  Jewish
  
  Orthodox
  
  Sikh :
  
  Movements and ideologies
  
  Analytical
  
  Anti-fascist
  
  Cyberfeminism
  
  HCI
  
  Networked
  
  Ecofeminism
  
  Individualist
  
  Liberal
  
  Difference
  
  Cultural
  
  Equality
  
  Social
  
  Labor
  
  Libertarian
  
  Post-structural
  
  French
  
  Postmodern
  
  Radical
  
  Political lesbianism
  
  Separatist
  
  Women's liberation
  
  Technofeminism :
  
  Concepts
  
  Literature
  
  Children's literature
  
  Discrimination against transgender women
  
  Effects on society
  
  Equality
  
  Female education
  
  Female genital mutilation
  
  Femicide
  
  Feminism in culture
  
  Feminist movement
  
  African-American women's suffrage movement
  
  Art movement
  
  In hip hop
  
  Feminist stripper
  
  Gender equality
  
  Girl power
  
  Honor killing
  
  Internalized sexism
  
  International Girl's Day and Women's Day
  
  Language reform
  
  Male privilege
  
  Matriarchal religion
  
  Media
  
  Men in feminism
  
  Misogyny
  
  Oedipus complex
  
  Opposition to feminism
  
  Pro-feminism
  
  Protofeminism
  
  Purplewashing
  
  Reproductive justice
  
  Sex workers' rights
  
  Sexual harassment
  
  Sexual objectification
  
  Toxic masculinity
  
  Transmisogyny
  
  Triple oppression
  
  Violence against women
  
  War on women
  
  Women-only space
  
  Women's health
  
  Women's rights
  
  Women in the workforce :
  
  Outlooks
  
  Bicycling and feminism
  
  Criticism of marriage
  
  Views on BDSM
  
  Views on pornography
  
  Views on prostitution
  
  Views on sexual orientation
  
  Views on sexuality
  
  Views on transgender topics :
  
  Theory
  
  Feminist method
  
  Gender studies
  
  Gender mainstreaming
  
  Gynocentrism
  
  Kyriarchy
  
  Male gaze
  
  Matriarchy
  
  Women's studies
  
  Men's studies
  
  Patriarchy
  
  Écriture féminine
  
  Areas of study
  
  Anthropology
  
  Archaeology
  
  Architecture
  
  Art
  
  Art criticism
  
  Literary criticism
  
  Film theory
  
  Science fiction
  
  Biology
  
  Composition studies
  
  Criminology
  
  Pathways perspective
  
  Economics
  
  FDPA
  
  Geography
  
  International relations
  
  Constructivism
  
  Legal theory
  
  Pedagogy
  
  Philosophy
  
  Aesthetics
  
  Empiricism
  
  Epistemology
  
  Ethics
  
  Justice ethics
  
  Existentialism
  
  Metaphysics
  
  science
  
  Political ecology
  
  Political theory
  
  Pornography
  
  Psychology
  
  Therapy
  
  Revisionist mythology
  
  Sex wars
  
  Sexology
  
  Sociology
  
  Technoscience
  
  Theology
  
  womanist theology :
  
  By country
  
  Albania
  
  Australia
  
  Bangladesh
  
  Canada
  
  China
  
  Democratic Republic of the Congo
  
  Denmark
  
  Egypt
  
  Ethiopia
  
  Finland
  
  France
  
  Germany
  
  Ghana
  
  Greece
  
  Hong Kong
  
  India
  
  Indonesia
  
  Iran
  
  Iraq
  
  Republic of Ireland
  
  Israel
  
  Italy
  
  Japan
  
  Latin America
  
  Argentina
  
  Brazil
  
  Chile
  
  Haiti
  
  Honduras
  
  Mexico
  
  Paraguay
  
  Trinidad and Tobago
  
  Lebanon
  
  Malaysia
  
  Mali
  
  Nepal
  
  Netherlands
  
  New Zealand
  
  Nigeria
  
  Northern Cyprus
  
  Norway
  
  Pakistan
  
  Philippines
  
  Poland
  
  Russia
  
  Syria
  
  Saudi Arabia
  
  South Africa
  
  South Korea
  
  Sweden
  
  Taiwan
  
  Thailand
  
  Turkey
  
  Vietnam
  
  Ukraine
  
  United Kingdom
  
  United States
  
  History of women :
  
  Lists and categories
  
  Lists
  
  Articles
  
  Feminists
  
  by nationality
  
  Literature
  
  American feminist literature
  
  Feminist comic books
  
  Feminist songs
  
  Conservative feminisms
  
  Ecofeminist authors
  
  Feminist art critics
  
  Feminist economists
  
  Feminist philosophers
  
  Feminist poets
  
  Feminist rhetoricians
  
  Jewish feminists
  
  Muslim feminists
  
  Feminist parties
  
  Suffragists and suffragettes
  
  Women's rights activists
  
  Women's studies journals
  
  Women's suffrage organizations
  
  Categories
  
  Women's rights by country
  
  Feminists by nationality :
  
  Feminism portal :
  
  vte :
  
  Social feminism is a feminist movement that advocates for social rights and special accommodations for women. It was first used to describe members of the women's suffrage movement in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries who were concerned with social problems that affected women and children. They saw obtaining the vote mainly as a means to achieve their reform goals rather than a primary goal in itself. After women gained the right to vote, social feminism continued in the form of labor feminists who advocated for protectionist legislation and special benefits for women. The term is widely used, although some historians have questioned its validity.
  
  ## Origin of term
  
  William L. O'Neill introduced the term "social feminism" in his 1969 history of the feminist movement Everyone Was Brave: The Rise and Fall of Feminism in America. He used the term to cover women involved in municipal civic reform, settlement houses and improving labor conditions for women and children. For them, O'Neill said, "women's rights was not an end in itself, as it was to the most ardent feminists". O'Neill contrasted social feminism with the "hard-core" feminism of women such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony who saw obtaining women's rights or women's suffrage as the main objective. Social feminists typically accepted traditional views of women as compassionate, nurturing and child-centered, while O'Neill's “hard-core feminists” were often alienated from these conventions.
  
  Naomi Black in Social Feminism (1989) distinguishes social feminism from "equity feminism". Equity feminism may be liberal, Marxist or socialist, but it demands equal rights for women within the male-defined framework. Social feminism, either maternal, cultural or radical, is based on female values. It aims to expand the role of women beyond the private sphere, and to fundamentally transform society. Social feminist organizations should therefore exclude men to maintain their distinctive female characteristics. They should not attempt to be like men, since their distinctive nature may be a strength in politics. There is inevitably a risk that social feminists will align with conservative causes. In the short term social feminism is separatist, but in the longer term it is transformative, since men have lost the exclusive power of decision-making.
  
  Social feminism is sometimes associated with maternal feminism. This philosophy considers that mothering should be used as a model for politics, and women's maternal instincts uniquely qualify them to participate in a "female" sphere. However, feminists are not all necessarily maternalist, and maternal thinking does not necessarily promote the goals of all forms of social feminism.
  
  ## Activities
  
  ### France
  
  In France in the 1890s feminism was mainly confined to bourgeois women. Women such as Eugénie Potonié-Pierre try to broaden the movement by combining their social concerns with their feminism, and to bring working-class women into the feminist movement. The Fédération Française des Sociétés Féministes was founded at the start of 1892 and held a well-attended congress in 13–15 May 1892, with both social feminists, mainstream feminists and socialists. The congress did not succeed in developing practical proposals or a coherent policy. Their cautious attempts at social feminism were not successful. Instead, a working women's movement developed within the socialist movement.
  
  A final attempt to create a social feminist movement in France was made by Marguerite Durand, founder of the social feminist paper La Fronde, who arranged the 1900 international women's rights congress. Durand saw social feminism as more than an expression of concern about social issues, but as a means to expand the base of the feminist movement. She felt that working women would create the feminist revolution, although bourgeois women would remain in control. She included moderate socialists on the organizing committee.
  
  Most of the 500 attendees at the congress were wealthy women. They were willing to vote for an eight-hour day for factory workers, but baulked at giving the same terms to their maids. There were two socialist women, Elizabeth Renaud and Louise Saumoneau, who were not willing to simply accept Durand's lead. In the end, the congress finalized the split between feminists and working women. Saumoneau became hostile to feminism, seeing the class struggle as more important. She denounced "bourgeois" feminism and took little interest in problems unique to women.
  
  ### America
  
  Social feminists in the US around the turn of the century were more interested in broad social issues than narrow political struggles, and saw early feminists like Anthony and Stanton as selfish in their demand for the vote for its own sake. They saw the vote as a means by which they could improve society. The social feminist and conservative Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) led by Frances Willard (1839–98) was not interested in women's suffrage, and perhaps actively opposed, until around 1880. At that time it came round to the idea that suffrage was the only way to gain the changes in legislation needed to advance temperance. The goal was still temperance, and suffrage was an expedient means to achieve that goal. In the long term the WCTU brought more women into the suffrage movement, but in the short term it was a competitor to suffrage organizations.
  
  In America the mainstream of the women's rights movement were social feminists. Often they saw women as inherently different in their point of view from men. They campaigned for social improvements and protection of the interests of women. Issues included education, property rights, job opportunities, labor laws, consumer protection, public health, child protection and the vote. Florence Kelley (1859–1932) and Jane Addams (1860–1935) exemplified social feminists. They believed that gaining the vote was essential for them to achieve their social objectives.
  
  In the early 20th century social feminist leaders of the National American Woman Suffrage Association (NAWSA) such as Maud Wood Park (1871–1955) and Helen H. Gardener (1853–1925) worked for women's suffrage. Their approach involved quiet lobbying of leading male politicians, while the more radical National Woman's Party took a more aggressive approach with demonstrations and picketing. Social feminism endorsed many traditional views of gender roles, did not threaten patriarchal power and may even have reinforced traditional arrangements, but the strategy was successful in 1920 in the campaign for the vote. After this breakthrough the National Woman's Party proposed the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). The ERA was bitterly opposed by the social feminists who saw it as undermining many of gains they had made in the treatment of women workers.
  
  In the period after the vote had been won there was a decline in social feminism in the US. According to William O'Neill "Adventure was now to be had, for the most part, in struggling against not social problems but social conventions. Drinking, smoking, dancing, sexual novelties, daring literature and avant-garde art now filled the vacuum created by the collapse of social feminism." However, Labor feminists continued to agitate for reform in the workplace. Labor feminists did not want to end all distinctions based on sex, only those that hurt women. For example, they felt that state laws that put in place wage floors and hour ceilings benefited women.
  
  * Elizabeth Cady Stanton supported various reform causes before focusing exclusively on women's rights.
  * Jane Addams was a social feminist who supported women's suffrage.
  
  ## Critique
  
  The concept of social feminism is useful in defining a range of activities, but the idea that it is incompatible with radical feminism may be misleading. In The Ideas of the Woman's Suffrage Movement, 1890–1920 (1965), Aileen S. Kraditor contrasted belief in the natural justice of women having the right to vote, common among suffragists up to the end of the 19th century, with belief in the "expediency" of women having the vote so they could address social issues, more common in the early 20th century. However, Kraditor saw a gradual shift in emphasis from "justice" to "expediency" in the rationales for women's suffrage rather than a conflict between the two positions. Organizations such as the Woman's Christian Temperance Union were primarily social feminist while the National American Woman Suffrage Association was primarily "hard-core" in O'Neill's sense, but there was considerable overlap in their membership. Activists such as Mary Ritter Beard, Florence Kelley and Maud Younger fall into both categories.
  
  ## Citations
  
  * ↑ Cott 1989, p. 810.
  * ↑ Cott 1989, p. 811.
  * ↑ Buechler 1990, p. 118.
  * ↑ Buechler 1990, p. 119.
  * ↑ Calás, Smitcich & Bourne 2007, p. 88.
  * ↑ Dietz 2002, p. 44.
  * 1 2 Sowerwine 1982, p. 67.
  * ↑ Sowerwine 1982, p. 68.
  * ↑ Sowerwine 1982, p. 74.
  * ↑ Sowerwine 1982, p. 75.
  * ↑ Sowerwine 1982, p. 76.
  * ↑ French 2008, p. 43.
  * ↑ Geary 1989, p. 86.
  * ↑ Zerilli 2005, p. 7.
  * ↑ Buechler 1990, p. 52.
  * 1 2 3 4 Social Feminism, Oxford 2008.
  * ↑ Buechler 1990, p. 128.
  * ↑ Rose 1997, p. 202.
  * 1 2 Cobble 2005, p. 5.
  * 1 2 Cott 1989, p. 815.
  * ↑ Cott 1989, pp. 811–812.
  * ↑ Cott 1989, p. 812.
  * ↑ Cott 1989, p. 816.
  
  ## General sources
  
  * Buechler, Steven M. (1990). Women's Movements in the United States: Woman Suffrage, Equal Rights, and Beyond. Rutgers University Press. ISBN 978-0-8135-1559-5. Retrieved 2014-08-31.
  * Calás, Marta B.; Smitcich, Linda; Bourne, Kristina A. (2007). "Feminist Analyses of 'gender and entrepreneurship'". Handbook on Women in Business and Management. Edward Elgar Publishing. ISBN 978-1-84720-413-4. Retrieved 2014-08-31.
  * Cobble, Dorothy S. (August 2005). "The Forgotten American Feminists". Bulletin of the Society for the Study of Working Women. 48.
  * Cott, Nancy F. (December 1989). "What's in a Name? The Limits of 'Social Feminism;' or, Expanding the Vocabulary of Women's History". The Journal of American History. Organization of American Historians. 76 (3): 809–829. doi:10.2307/2936422. JSTOR 2936422.
  * Dietz, Mary G. (2002). Turning Operations: Feminism, Arendt, and Politics. Psychology Press. ISBN 978-0-415-93244-8. Retrieved 2014-08-31.
  * French, Marilyn (2008). From Eve to Dawn: Revolutions and the Struggles for Justice in the 20th Century. Feminist Press at CUNY. ISBN 978-1-55861-628-8. Retrieved 2013-09-20.
  * Geary, Dick (1989-04-17). Labour and Socialist Movements in Europe Before 1914. Berg. p. 86. ISBN 978-0-85496-705-6. Retrieved 2013-09-20.
  * Rose, Kenneth D. (1997-06-01). American Women and the Repeal of Prohibition. NYU Press. ISBN 978-0-8147-7466-3. Retrieved 2014-08-31.
  * Smith, Bonnie G., ed. (2008). "Social Feminism". Oxford Encyclopedia of Women in World History. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195148909. Retrieved 2014-08-31.
  * Sowerwine, Charles (1982). Sisters Or Citizens?: Women and Socialism in France Since 1876. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-23484-9. Retrieved 2014-08-31.
  * Zerilli, Linda M. G. (2005-10-03). Feminism and the Abyss of Freedom. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 978-0-226-98134-5. Retrieved 2014-08-31.
  