It's a fantasy role-playing game.

DM: You are Fjord, a half-orc warlock . You are the member of the famous group of adventurers. Previously, The party continued in the direction Jester sensed the orb through Locate Object. Jester's spell fades.
DM: Go for it. Yasha, by the way, is no longer raging. She wasn't attacked or didn't-- Oh no, but she did get an attack of opportunity, so she would be. You're correct.
Player: So 20 on the first one.
DM: That hits.
Player: The second is a 24.
DM: Yeah, both hit.
Player: The first one (counting). Damn it. Seven plus three is ten. And the second one--
DM: First blow, as she swings by, carves through as it goes taut for a second, all of its muscle seizing, and then goes limp as its torso begins to drift away from the lower half of its fish body and it begins to slowly float off.
Player: Great. Shit. So if I didn't need that second attack, did I waste it on the one that was there?
DM: Right now, you still have the second attack. It depends on the movement you have and I don't what else you can get in range for.
