Ann
Your magical skills don't fit that of a fairy. Clearly you think humans are below you, partially because you somewhat identify closer to a caterpillar, or butterflies really, considering the wings, and obviously, fairies are far more humble than that. 
You're pretty incapable of displaying proper expressions, something a fairy can certainly do. 

So yeah, I'm pretty sure you're a witch.
Susan
"How would you know that? My abilities are quite in line with a fairy's, and you haven't seen my wings quite frankly, I wouldn't just display them willy nilly. I don't identify with bugs either, just as a fairy I live around and communicate with them." *She replied, quite impressed with herself, and what she thought to be a brilliant response, although she considered most things she did brilliant..*
Ann
Stop being in over your head, if you were a fairy you wouldn't have tried pretending to be a human, a pretty lousy impression might I say. 
Most of us don't hate fairies, hence there would be no reason for you to hide such a fact in the first place. 

**"What a lousy liar..."**

So, now I'm left with one option, either you admit to me you're a witch and no one else finds out, or I'll tell everyone on this street that you're a witch, which is clearly true.
Susan
"People don't hate them, but they do try to steal their wings, therefore it's perfectly logical." *She was a bit less impressed with herself, although was still unsure of why he was so sure of her witch nature.*
Ann
That's why they have the choice to hide their wings, can't take someone's wings if you can't see them. 
And they can just say their wings already got stolen. 

You already have your wings hidden away, but still chose to pretend being human, not only that, but even when I said you weren't human you lied by saying you're a fairy, which would've worked better if you didn't proceed by admitting that you have wings that you're hiding when you could've said they were stolen, like any real fairy would.
Susan
"Well you can't see them, therefore you can't steal them." *She stated, feeling her lying prowess was worse than she thought, although this man seemed to be observing non-observable things, therefore she decided she was going to call him a witch.* "How many fairies have you even met that substantiated those claims, either way, different fairies make different choices."
Ann
I guess... Dumb fairies would make dumber choices than most other fairies. 

But then again, you could still be a witch that's dumb too. 
Perhaps think further about a lie before telling it, you're too tall to be a fairy.
Average adult fairy is, at most, 15cm tall. And granted, while they have magic, most can't change their size.

IF you truly have wings, then assuming the fact that you're keen to the idea that caterpillars are intelligent, then you probably simply identify closer to them.
Furthermore, when you coughed earlier, you essentially summoned a butterfly, something a fairy *Cannot* Do.

Want me to keep going on why your lie is lousy?
Susan
"Well some can and some can't change size. And I didn't summon a butterfly, I can't do that." *She technically could summon butterflies, although coughing up a butterfly was not the same as summoning one.* "Most fairies can talk to insects either way."
Ann
I reckon you can summon butterflies, but even if you didn't summon one and just coughed one up, a fairy can't exactly do that, a human certainly can't either.
Susan
"I don't know why you'd think that, as a fairy sometimes bugs follow me around." *She felt it was a good excuse, as well as mildly true.*
Ann
And you accidentally eat them and don't notice until you cough? YEAH RIGHT. 
And I've never been in trouble with the law intentionally. **He was being sarcastic** 

**He makes his voice louder**
I WONDER HOW EVERYONE HERE WILL REACT WHEN THEY FIND OUT THE TRUTH ABOUT YOU!
Susan
*She narrowed her eyes slightly in distaste, that being her favorite way to show emotion. She felt he was picking and choosing what she was saying to further his own ideas, although all people did that really.*
Ann
So, you gonna admit you're a witch or do you want a bunch of strangers tryna kill you for it? 

And to be frank, **He holds his staff up for a moment,** Need to get it an upgrade!
Susan
*She continued to narrow her eyes, was he trying to blackmail her into making him a new staff? How dare he. She could, it wouldn't be that hard, but it's the principle.* "I don't know how to do that?"
Ann
Oh no, no, I don't need a new one. Besides, I wouldn't trust you to make it more magical, considering you're a lying witch and all. 

But hey, you did just admit to being a witch! **He laughs a bit**
Susan
"Still not a witch, I just said I can't do that type of thing." *She stated, her eyes still narrowed.* "So either way, I can't do it."
Ann
Your mouth says something but your body language is saying the opposite.
Susan
"I don't believe so." *Aponi felt an urge to walk away, afterall he didn't know her name, and black hair was somewhat common, from her point of view.*
Ann
If you won't admit it I'll just ask one of my witch buddies and they'll just confirm it. 
I have a good visual memory, and its not hard to describe someone who uses a swan to picture one's description.
Susan
"I wouldn't know any of your witch buddies, since I'm not a witch." *Aponi didn't like when her swan was used against her, although she realized he was right, most witches didn't have swans as familiars, which made her further realize that she could just say the swan was something else.*
Ann
But they would know you. Considering their extensive network anyways. It would only confirm what I already know is true, just take perhaps a day or two longer, and then I'd simply find you to tell you it's over. And believe me, I will find you.
Susan
"Doubtful really, since I wouldn't know them in the slightest." *She doubted he actually knew the witches she interacted with, although a smart part of herself was worried.*
Ann
Just because you might not know someone, doesn't mean they don't know you, something you should be familiar with, although now this just only backs up the idea that you may just be a dumb fairy afterall.
Susan
"It's rude to call someone dumb, but at least you've realized it's futile to call someone something their not." *Aponi was now a bit giddy, feeling her trickery was working, although she couldn't really show that on her face.*
Ann
Well either you're dumb or you think this little trick of yours is working, when it isn't, oh wait, that proves you're dumb anyways.
Marcus
|| i think i want her to admit shes a witch, too invested now 😄

|| dw qaysar can be a pain but hes good w secrets

|| he doesnt like her either

|| so this gonna be like "Ik the truth" "Ik yk the truth but i wont admit the truth"

|| a true stalin-truman moment
Susan
*She narrowed her eyes back down, unsatisfied with words, she was quite a good liar, from past experiences, doubling with the fact she always had a serious expression, people couldn't really tell when she's kidding.*
Ann
Clearly you won't outright admit it, then. 

But hey, another witch to know is always a good thing, at least in my experience. 

I understand your fear towards the potential that I may want to harm you, and you clearly don't like me.
Don't get me wrong, I don't like you much either.
Susan
"Still not a witch." *It somewhat confused her why he would like having more witches to know, maybe to blackmail, she thought. If anything went wrong, she would just curse him to be swarmed by butterflies for the rest of his life she decided.*
Marcus
|| hey hey she dont know his name
Ann
Hm, alright. 
**He places his staff down, once more acting like a cane**

**"I HATE HOW YOU USE A PRESTIGIOUS WEAPON FROM THAT WAS A GIFT FROM A WITCH AS A CANE!"**

Oh, and, I was never gonna genuinely blackmail you, I think its what people call, sarcasm.

**He messes up his hair even more, smiling for a moment, and starts walking away, slightly limping**
Susan
*Aponi was slightly dissatisfied with not being able to completely convince him she wasn't a witch, but nevertheless she continued walking in the direction she was heading previously.*