text: Maybe a Social Studies group? Yes, there would be exceptions because of that certain club being a study club. But what about, for example, a Drama Club. What if certain boys and girls really liked to act or sing. Should they be allowed to show their passion for it. But, they would not be able to because they are averaging a C instead of an A or a B! And if a student was/is playing the flute in band (the only flute player in that band) would not be allowed to go to a contest because she is averaging a C in science. I strongly believe that you should keep it where it is. Students should be able to express themselves in what they like to do! There can still be exceptions it there completely failing, though!