text: I think that your fist policy is the best because if kids don't bring their phones to school then well they are not be able to call for help during a emergency like if the power went out or if the teacher is gone and there is a break in or if some staff member needs medial treatment and the power is out or if school gets out and a friend ask if you can come over after school. If you chooses the other on people are still going to bring their phones to school anyway so why not let them have it at school just have rules for them not consequences.