text: I agree with you on the first policy, the student would like to use their phone during lunch, but the student are going to see each other at lunch anyways, and that not going to stop them from having their cell phones on in class. If I were principal I would let the students use their cell phone at the last 5 minutes of class. If they use there phone before the 5 minutes they should be sent to detention. Another think you can do is take all the phone at the beginning of class, then you don't have to worry about anybody having their cell phones, and if they get caught with there cell phones the teacher get to keep it for a month.