text: Policy 1 is the better choice. Policy 1 gives permission to students to be allowed to use their cell phones during lunch periods but not in class time. Students need to be able to have their cell phones because maybe they need to call for a ride after school. If there is a fight and someone is hurt they can call the ambulance with their cell phones. Going to the office for a phone would take to long if the kid is seriously injured. Phones are a way communication we really are not doing anything wrong by having them. This is why policy one is the better choice.