text: I think policy one is better because kids actually get to have their phones with them. if they where to do policy two most kids would be ticked off because they don't get their phones at school at all and if they needed to call someone after school they wouldn't be able to because their would be no phones at school and would have to do something. kids would understand that they could use them at lunch and other times out of class more than just keep them at home. I would be mad if i had to keep my phone at home and i missed the bus and didn't have a way to call my parents. phones are an important part of allot of peoples life's. But most kids would just brake the rule if policy two was in place and would get in trouble if the teacher say the phone at lunch or something. that's a way why policy one should be in place.