text: I have read your two possible policies. Policy one is a good policy the reason why is because know a days all students have a phone. It would be better for you just to let them have a phone because if you don't students will go in their own risk of consequences just to have their phone in handy. If you could notice, also know a days all students really care about is having their phone. That is a really special object to any teenager, your students from your school will really appreciate it if you allow them to use their phone during free time or lunch periods. I can ensure you that is you let this policy go students gradually will love you, and knowing that they can use their phone in those free minutes they will not have the need to use it during the class time. I would have to choose policy one as the most reasonable and it would be fair for both you as the principal and the students of your school.