Tucker doesn't accept the proposal and breaks the relationship with Duncan. Heartbroken Duncan decides to place an add to say he wants to find a straight woman to marry. Enters Marilyn Samples , they become best of friends and start planning the wedding and wedding planner Peter Dalrymple. Peter and Duncan are attracted since the first meeting ... Duncan is loyal and always been clear with Marilyn. Marilyn also likes Duncan's ex Tucker brother , Ben. Things get complicated when tragedy strikes and Duncan gets confronted by Scout his sister. Duncan tries to be true to himself and makes changes including in a sense breaking Marilyn's heart.