i 


'  . ,  '  r 


\ 


Ik*- 


■  ■  V 


CIHM 
Micfofiche 
Series 
(Monographs) 


IdMH 

Collection  de 
microfiches 
(monographles) 


Canadian  Inatltuta  lof  HIatoclcal  M!(>ro«(KO<luctlo«»  /  Inatttui  canaWan  da  mlcrtHaprodiKttona  hiatoriqoaa 


• 

I 

-■ :    • 

' '  ■  '-f. 


/•, 


( 


TwiintMl  «i4  IIMtoflrtpiita  No«M  /  Htm 


•t  biMloflfaptK^WM 


TiM  iMtitwM  hm  ammplarf  to  obta«n  ttM  fcm 
Mpy  •vMtaM*  (or  ftlwimf.  Fmiimm  o(  iHit  m^ 
may  ba  MMtefraptitaaHy  un^M.  w«Mcl«  may  alMi 
el  Hm  MiadH  (n  Itia  ra^odwction,  of  wM«ft  muf 
itpiiftaanHy  chanfa  tlta  VMial  mathod  of  f  MnHnf. 
fllMdiad  bakN*.  , 


L'ltNtttut  a  Milcro(llin4  la  maillawr  aaam^atr*  qu'll 
kli  a  «tA  iMNtiMa  db  «a  procurer    Lai  <M«atl«  tfa  cat 
aMaMiiplatra  «|u«  tont  paut  4tr«  uwqxat  4u  point  4a  «ya 
yjHograptimw.  «Mt  pativani  modifiar  una  Imafi 
raprodutw.  ou  ^1  paw«an(  aiiitaf  una  modtflcation 
4mn  la  mAttmda  nomuh  4a  IMmafa  tont  In4lsu*t 


iquM 


QColourad  aovart/ 
Couvartiira  4 


0 

D 


Covart 
Couvartura 


Covart  raiterorf  aiMl/or  laminalMl/ 
Couvartura  rattaur4a  at/ou  paNioiMa 


□  Covar  titia  mtaaln«/ 
La  titra  da  eowvartura  mangut 


D 
D 
D 
D 


D 


CoiouradiM 

Cm«m  ftotraphiquaa  m  coulaur 

f 

Colouiad  ink  (i.«.  othar  than  Mua  or  Mack)/ 
Encra  da  eouktir  (i.a.  autra  qu*  Maua  ou  noira) 

Colourad  platat  and/or  Mluttratlom/ 
PlanelMt  at/ou  illuttrationi  an  eoulaur 

Bound  with  othar  matarial/ 
RaM  mac  d'autrat  documants 

Tight  bindintmav  mum  shadow*  or  distortion 
alonfl  intarior  marfin/ 

La  raliura  tarrte  paut  causar  da  i'ombra  ou  da  la 
distortion  la  Ion*  da  la  marga  intAriaura 

Blank  laavas  addad  during  restoration  may  appMr 
within  tha  taxt.  Whanav«r  possiMa.  thata  hava 
baan  omittad  from  (ilniint/ 
II  sa  paitt  qua  carttinas  pagat  Manchas  aiouttet 
kin  d'una  rattauration  apparaissant  dans  la  taxta. 
mait,  lorsqua  cala  *tait  potsiMa.  cas  paffH  n'ont 
pas  M  film4ift. 


□  Colourad  pagas/ 
PagM  da  coulaur 


0 

D 


restored  and/or  laminated/ 
restaur*es  M/oti  peNicwIAes 


Pagn  discoloured,  stained  or  foxed/ 
Pagat  dtcolorAet.  tachatAet  ou  piquAas 


□  fagn  detached/ 
Pagat  d*tach«es 

0Showthrough/ 
Tr«„paran«a 

QQuility  of  print  varies/ 
Qualit*  in4gala  da  ^'impression 

r~~V  Continuous  pagination/ 
I 1  Pagination  continue 


n 


Includes  index(es)/ 
Comprend  un  (des)  index 

Title  on  heeder  taken  from:  / 
Le  titre  de  I'en-ttta  provient: 

Title  page  of  issue/ 

Page  de  titre  de  la  livraiton 


D 

I       I  Caption  of  issue/^ 


Titre  de  depart  da  la  livraitoh 


D 


Masthe«d/ 

G4n4rique  (piriodiquas)  da  la  livraiton 

Pagination  is  as  follows:  p.  [1543-175. 

0Additk>nai comments:/         Wrinkled  pages  may  film  slightly  out  of  focus, 
commentairet suppiimentMret'ii^g^g  ^^g  50^  creases  in  the  middle  of  p«ges. 

This  item  is  fibhad  at  tlia  raduMion  ratio  checked  betow/ 

Ce  document  *st  f  ilm4  au  taux  da  reduction  incNquA  cirdessous. 


■  .  f»~ 

10X 

-  ■ 

14X 

itx 

22X 

26  X 

XX 

7 

12X 

11IL 

^      aOX                             24X                            2tX 

32X 

.'. 

.^     " 

* 

/"; 

t 

r.. 

..^«' 

I 

r 

^1   1 

, 

-, 

• 

Ji^      » 

'••W    •'"W^ 


,(  ' 


TiM  oopv  f UmMi  hf  hM  h—n  r«firodw««d  th«n«i« 
to  th«  goMKMlty  of: 

Motropoiltan  Toronto  Mfor^nco  Library 
•aldMln  Room 

Tho  Imogoa  appooring  hara  ara  tha  baat  quality 
poaaibia  oonaMarlng  tha  condition  and  laglbillty 
of  tha  original  copy  tnd  in  kaaping  wHh  tha 
fllmlnf  contract  ^ppacifloatlona. 


Original  copiaa  in  printad  papar  oovara  ara  f llmad 
baglnning  with  tha  front  oovar  and  anding  on 
tha  loat  paga  with  a  printad  or  llluatratad  Impraa- 
alon.  or  tha  back  cover  whan  approprlata.  All 
othar  original  copiaa  ara  flln^  baglnning  on  tha 
firat  paga  with  a  printad  or  llluatratad  impraa- 
alon.  and  anding  on  tha  laat  paga  with  a  printad 
or  illuatratod  Impraaaion. 


Tha  laat  racordad  frama  on  aaoh  microficha 
ahaii  contain  tha  aymbol  ^^^  I  moaning  "CON- 
TtNUED").  or  tha  aymbol  ▼  (moaning  "END"). 
wMohtvar  appliaa. 

Mapa.  plataa.  oharta.  ato..  may  ba  fllmad  at 
dlffaront  roduotlon  ratloa.  Thoaa  too  larga  to  ba 
antlraly  Includad  in  ona  axpoaura  ara  filmad 
baglnning  in  tha  uppar  laft  hand  cornar,  iaft  to 
right  and  top  to  bottom,  aa  many  framaa  aa 
raquirad.  Tha  following  diagrama  illuatrata  tha 
mothod: 


#  ■ 


L'aHamplalra  fUmA  fut  raprodult  grtoa  i  la 
i4n4roalta  da: 

Matropolltan  Toronto  Rafarancte  Library 
Baldwin  Room 

Laa  imagaa  auhrantaa  ont  4t4  raprodul^  avac  la 
plua  grand  aoin.  compta.  tarui  da  la  condition  of 
da  la  nattatA  da  I'aiiampiaira  fllma.  at  an 
conformlta  avao  laa  conditiona  du  contrat  da 
fUmago^' 

Laa  aiiamplalraa  orlglnaux  dont  la  couvartura  mn 
papiar  aat  imprlm4a  sont  flinr«4a  1%  commandant 
par  la  pramiiV  plat  at  an  tarminant  aolt  par  la 
darniara  paga  qui  oomporto  uno  ampralnta 
d'impfjMaion  ou  d'lHuatratlon.  aolt  par  la  aacond 
plat,  aalon  la  oaa.  Toua  laa  autraa  axamplalraa 
orlglnaux  aont  fllmaa  li  commandant  par  la 
pramlira  paga  qui  oomporta  una  ampralnta 
d'impraaaion  ou  d'lHuatratlon  at  an 'tarminant  par 
la  darnlAra  paga  qui  i;omporta  uno  toNa 
ampralnta. 

Un  daa  aymbolaa  auKranta  apparaftra  aur  la 
tftrnlAra  imaga  da  chaquamloroflcha.  aalon  la 
oaa:  la  aymboia  — ^  algnifla."A  SUIVRE".  la 
aymbola  y  algnlfia  "FIN".  ^  ^ 

Laa  oartaa.  planohaa.  tablaaux.  ato..  pauvant  Atra 
fllmAa  A  daa  taux  da  rMuctlon  dlffAranta. 
Loraqua  la  documant  aat  trop  grand  pour  ttra 
raprodult  w  un  aaul  ollohA,  II  aat  film*  i  partir 
da  I'an^  aupArlaur  gauoha.  da  gauoha  A  drolta. 
at  da  haut  an  baa.  an  pranant  la  nombra 
d'imagaa  n4ioaaaaira°.  Laa  diagrammaa  aUlvanta 
llluatrant  la  m4tl|iNla. 


n  * 


I 


1 


6 


'  J»i,!i»a«t.-iti».!Ml'i«jiiiJi»Ji!i«(Wi5B.' 


'>;,     «Sii&^a...9 


MKMUTION  T«T  CNAtt 


(AMI  and  ItO  TltT  CHAUT  Na.  1) 


1.0 


I.I 


I 


1.6 


^ 


/iPPLIED  INA^GE    Inc 

tt&J  Linl  Main  strMi 

KMhnitf,  Nm  rork       Maot      UM 

(7I«)  4«2  -  OJOe  -  Phww 


(»1i) 


l-f«i 


\ 


"\ 


,/ 


*  , 


.    SUr  )t':^^iy^.a^t^-,Co 


Toronto  Public  Library. 


Reference  Depertment. 


TMIt  MOOR  MyiT  NOT  •!  TAMtN  OUT  Or  TMt  ROOM. 


\     JAM  5    1933 


lfi3a-?:sSil^.£Sg-,-S.i3;;;z::;.- 


:'-J^V, 


"^ 


/ 

/ 

/ 

/ 

V 


; 


4 

1        ^' 

■ 

« 

\ 

• 

\ 

• 

^ 

L—' 

. 

'  # 

«. 

\.    . 

* 

'  y'~ 

■N 

_^■  ■ 

,  \     ./ .  ■■.    '  ■-■ 

i,    •  •  .        ■'..'■■ 

• 

'•^-%  •. 


SiimmtPsmmv 


V         •      -     -     •■*«" 


^6f^ 


0^: 


M't 


•^ 


CASES 

AHOOEO  AND  ItirrRBMINtl 

.    iN|;rin:  (  ourt  op  kings 


♦I 


york'upper  camim, 

I 
IN 

1^  TNI  WFfM  f  Ml  W  OiO^  l» 


No.  IV. 


JUDGES, 

tT;  hT.  '••»  »^»A*«j,*r';i"^ 

Tat  HM    l)'A«CV  itlVLTUM. 


i       ' 


»<l: 


JOHN  ■  RO|iKM)N,  Ai4   iilMrwy  9mti^, 

BY  TUOMM  TAYLOR,  Eu 


r«iat«»  BV  lOMIt  CAHCY. 

rojiJr. 

■■■ 
1824. 


^-. 


.:^' 


,^^^ 


^ 


% 


.'V 


9o^b^o. 


4^" 


n  5    1933 


-l^'' 
^ 


■^;' 


V-  -ikA- 


.#*■ 


.   .*"■ 


>' 


>••# 


:^- 


vl  ' 


\: 


i  » 


X-  H. 


'0' 


•* 


•-■  -— 'V- 


^ji__i 
,     r- 


'  Wm-' 


,^ 


CASES 

AKOUED  AND  DrrE^|IINED  IK  THE 

COURTOF  KING'S  BENCH, 
YORK,  Sfc. 


Y 


1824 


HAOERMAN  againHSmT 

Boutom,  SoUcitor  General,  had  obtain-  J.j.^  i.  ta. 
ed  a  rule  to  .hew  cauM,  why  two  .f  veral ...  ^.^.u 
.urns  of  £75  0  0  and  £19  18  0,  -hould  p.,^Mwu,. 
not  be  deducted  from  the  amount  requir-  «•  wjicii^..^ 
ed  to  be  levied  under  the  writi'of  fieri  bTSL^i,  thi 
^ia«  issued  in  this  cause.  htoauctimto 

The  ground  of  the  application,  as  slat-  "^•'^•fir 
ed  upon  affidavit,  was,  that  the  defendant  l^^jj^t: 
had  paid  the  plaintiff  the  said  sums  in  jj.u.^jj.- 
part  satisfaction  of  the  judgment  obtain-  ••ij|||^«  »;^^J« 
ed  against  him,  under  the  authority  of  uLuoi  toow. 
which  the  fi:  fas:  had  issued.  That  at 
the  lime  of  defendant's  paying  the  same, 

the  piiinliff  did  not  object  to  receive  the 
said  sums  in  part  satisfaclion  oi  the  said 
iudgraent,  or  eipress  any  wish  to  apply 
the  same  to  any  other  account  or  demand. 

At  the  time  of  making  these  p^ym^nU, 


■    V.-' 


■■* 


r.-,:^.';.  ^' 


Xj* 


'(  -  h. 


*4>. 


"TL 


vv.«» 


L,/ 


I 


>. 


r 


Y^' 


V 


It 


Milk. 


«».'. 


y" 


CAM*  III  BAat«A  mm.  .  <. 

t^e  der«)nd«nt  wm  lfid«ht«d  to  the  ptftiil*, 

(iflll  in  other  ■uma  upon  promiMory  not«t, 
to  account  of  which  Uie  plttiiitifT  had  plac- 
ed thcnc  pajmentf^eicept  a  imaH  balance 
which  he  had  placed  to  the  account  of  the 
judgment.  The  plaintitTntatcd  upon  af- 
fidarit,  that  when  the  defendant  made- 
these  payments,  he  hud  not  given  him  anj 
instructions,  us  to  what  account  they 
should  be  placed. 

Rohintoth  Attorney  General,  ahewed 
cause.  He  contended,  that  no  instniciions 
having  been  given  to  the  plaintiff;  or  any 
arrangement  made  as  to  the  account  to' 
which  the  monies  paid  shouhl  he  placed, 
that  be  was  entitled  to  place  the  same,  to 
what  account  be  pleased ;  4*  relied  upon 
Newmarsh  against  Clay^  and  others,  and 
the  authorities  there  referred  to.  In  that 
case  certain  acts  had  taken  place  which 
clearly  evinced  the  intention  of  both  par- 
ties ;  but  here  there  was  nothing  of  the 
kind.  The  general  rule  as  laid  down  in 
the  cases,  was  clear  that  a  creditor  might 
place  money  paid  to  him  by  his  debtor,  4o 
any  account  he  pleased,  unless  there  was 
ap  express  stipulation  to  the  contrary, 
cither  by  words,  or  acts  sufficiently  de- 

*l«£Mtt««. 

■  ■  • 


<■*? 


■,.&■■ 


?v.»^ 


■•«(il 


*^     J^- 


•lldtffig  tiMi  intentfaM  d  bothMrtict.  • 
'      Chi^JuHiet,  Bf  th«  fr^ch  law  •  oro- 
ditor  who  r«ceif«!l  »  ptj^nl  from  •  pcr- 
■on  indrbted  to  lllm  uMb  two  account! 
muiit  apply  It  in  tatiaraibtion  of  the  rooit 
onc^tw  debt;  but  by  the  law  of  England 
the  creditor  Aay  make  hit  elccliont  uiUcsi 
the  debtor  apeciOcally  declares  at  the 
time  of  payment,  to  which  acco^lht  itnliall 
be  applied.     In  thia  caae  if  the  defendant 
had  intended  that  these  paytoents  should 
ha?e  gone  in  discharge  of  the  judgment, 
he  should  have  made  them  to  the  SherifT, 
or  taken  a  special  receipt  from  the  plain- 
tiff 

P$r  curiam — Rvl'  diichargtd. 


tekli 


A] 


April  SOih 


Thc  Hpn.  O.  H.  MARKLAND,  JOHN  KERBY. 

AMP  JOHN  MACAULEY,  Comnuwionert  uid 

Ttuttcci,  th«  Boutl  Tor  ictUing  the  ufiain 

or'the  PwTEHDED  Bin*  or  UffE» 

Canada,  agaitut  D  ALT  ON. 

Washhumy  on  a  former  day  had  obtain- 
ed a  rule  to  shew  cause  why  the  judg 
ment  of  non.  pros,  for  not  going  to  trial, 
signed  in  this  cause,  and  the  fi.  fa.  issued 
thereon  against  the  plaintiffs,^  should  not 
be  set  aside  for  irregularity,  on  the  ground 


The  dvclara- 
tloa  aithetnU 
of  •  Curpor*- 
lion  named  rh* 
ladivlduali 

compMliigr  ", 
«ud  alio  d«*> 
crihed  Ihea  In 
Ihflrcorpwata 
capacUlM-TiM 
breach  was  t* 
Iheir  aaiaa  aa 
lndlvl«l«alaM< 
\j.  TheCMirt 
held  that  a  uuii 
proa  olfht  be 
lignad  aad  ei. 
ecatioo  laaaa 
afainat  them 
In  their  prlvat* 
capactllee. 


i 


•V'  ->C  i 


'^f'lmf- 


ife^*r'-**f 


I 


H^'  ■?  *-_^  fj 


MarkiaM 

ft  o«llMr« 


1*1  ()*•■•  IN  IMVM  fOUI. 

1024  tlint  (li«  %vM  b«irin|[  betn  commencod  by  * 
Umih  m  CoaminioiMra  iiul  Truatact  un- 
<^  tier  tb«  act  of  Ui«  Prdvi»ci«l  Parliament, 
a  nonauU  could  noi  be  entered,  and  eie-' 
cution  iMued  against  them,  in  their  pri« 
vate  capacitie«»aiid  he  iiwtanced  the  caaea 
v^  ofBankrupt*aaiMignees,  andof  Eiecutort. 

BouUon,  Solicitor  General,  contra — con- 
tended, that  the  plaiiitiflTii  were  authorized 
by  the  Statute  to  bring  actions  as  a  cor- 
poration only,  not  in  their  namei  as  indi- 
viduals,^ thej  have  done  in  this  case, 
which  being  erroneous  they  had  not  cho- 
sen to  go  to  trial— that  their  situation  as 

1  a  corporation,  was  not  analogous  to  that 

'  of  executors  or  assignees  of  bankrupts, 
who,  notwtthstaAding  their  situations  as 
Such,  must  be  sued  as  A.  B.  and  C.  D.  kc. 
Thiit  the  plaintifTshaving  concluded  their 
dcclalralion  without  adding  the  descrip-^ 
tion  wbieh  they  had  used  in  the  com- 
mencement^ was  conclusive  as  to  the  cor- 

.      -  ri^ctnc.88  of  the  plaintilPs  taking  out  exe- 

cution in  thei''  ndqaea  as  indiriduah. 

HWA^wm,  contra,  contended,  that  these 

plaintiffs  had  not  sued  as  ifidividuals,  and 

)^        '  therefore  were  not  liable  to  he  nonsuited 

,  as  such;   that  their  names  pl'eceeding 

:  :■   ■  '  .  ■■  ■•     ■•         \    .' X. 


A 


ed  by 
n  un- 
mentf 

r  prl-  . 

CMC! 

utort. 

--GOfl-    »' 

>rized 
K  cor- 
I  indi- 
cate t 
t  cho- 
on  M 
o  that 
Tupts, 
)n8  an 

O.&LC. 

\  their 
Bcrip-^ 
com* 
le  cor- 
lexo- 
I. 

these 
•,aad 
suited 
ledi  ng 


W^ 


..4 


;*- 


nk  fkg  rivta  ?■«•  or  •■•.  nr.  IM 

their  detcription,  (which  waa  in  the  verjr      1824 
worda  of  the  atatute  appointing  them    j^^. ^^^ 
commiaAioner»,)could  not  alter  their  char-  *MbM«,  c«» 
acler  aa  plamtimi;  and  , though  their  den-     ^«"'< 
criplion  waa  omitted  in  the  concluMion  of 
the  declaration,  ita  having  been  used  in 
the  commencement  and  tbioughout,  wan 
iufficient  to  couple  it  with  their  namea  in 
the  conclusion. 

P§r  turiam — RuU  diteharged. 


MITCHELL  «fMiM<TEIfBROEK.  <HM  fe. 

The  defendaixt  in  this  case  was  an  At- 
tomej  of  ihis  court,  had  been  sued  bjr 
bill  and  proceeded  against  to  judgment. 
The  bill  bad  been  filed  in  the  office  of 
the  Clerk  of  the  Crown  in  the  London 
districtr  find  the  subsequent  proceedings 
and  verdict,  had  in  that  District. 


Mlh  Apdf. 


Wli«r««blll 
had  bMa  «l«4 
NMaMM  At. 
loTMjr  fa  llM 
•fl««  of  •■  on- 
lardialrlotMd 
pracMdiaf* 
.  ud  Ikwrnpoa 
to  v«r4l«t  Md 
'HdfaMat,  lb* 
Court  roAiMd 
to  Mt  than  ft» 
•Mo  for  Irrtf - 
nUrity. 


Macaulej/i  had  obtained  a  rule  nisi  to  set 
these  proceedings  aside,  as  being  altoge- 
ther irregular  and  defectiTe,  on  the  ground 
that  the  Bill  should  have  been  filed  in  the 
principal  office  at  York. 

Boultoni  Solicitor  General,  and  Roiphi 


*«■■ 


PSi^i. 


f 


•V 


'hi. 


^l-iief? 


vf.'* 


*4 


f\,f     1 


19' 


h'  ■•  i 


»■ 


tM 


IH14 

MMrWII 

iifmlmtt 

lr»l>rwrfc 


ihewe<!  ctutt.  Thmy  coalemlftt,  that  the 
wor«U  ofthe  lUtute  «rer«  si^riciid/ ge- 
neral, lo  admit  ofprocAcdiiifs  betiig  tiled 
agaiuat  an  Atlornejr  in  lh«  dinti'ict  ollice- 
Tba4  •<>  Attoniejr  maj  wait«  hia  privi- 
lege altogeilicr,  and  if  the  procc«dio|(^ 
waa  incorrect,  he  haa  waivad  it  ll  ii  a 
mere  matter  of  practice.  If  tlie  defen- 
dant had  applied  al  a  proper  atagt  of  Um 
proceedings  to  have  had  the  bill  filed  at 
York  with  a  view  to  a  trial  at  bar,  or  in 
the  Home  diitrict,  hin  application  might 
have  been  attended  t0|  but  that  after 
verdict  and  judgment,  it  wia  clearljr^too 
late. 

P«r  curiam    R^  iitchargHi. 


3(Hb  April 


MTCR8  againit  RATHBURN. 


tMraiHcd  *"•■  Upon  the  application  of  Macaulej. — 
b^m^ultl^  The  Court  (upon  the  authority  in  8.  T.  R. 
3**.To/^i!;;:J  where  a  writ  waa  amended  which  had  by 
|7!*«j^  «rii  Qiist^e  been  made  returnable  in  C  B 
instead  of  K  B)  allowed  the  writ  of  capias 
I  ad  respondendum  issued  in  this  cause,  to 

be  amended  by  striking  out  the  direction 
«»To  William  Brown,  Constable,**  and  in- 
serting *♦  to  the  Sheriflfof  the"  by  striking 


k'-'"' 


h 


i^'hfW'  r!^  %*'    1 


t 

•1 

ai 

th 

ou 
1  ti 

th 

/ 

to 

• 

juc 

Ulfl 

iss 

. 

lai 
»h< 
ree 

V 

) 

in 
lar 

an 
be 

de 
ha< 
an 
ou 

4' 

ttei^w-i. 

j^K^n^.,  ^/ 

^B^r^^rw 


4 


t.    ■. 


V'  1 


>iijg  filed 
cl  ollic«« 
liit  privi- 

liii  ft 
m  d«liBn' 
Kt  of  lh« 
I  filed  ftt 
«r,  or  in 
on  might 
lat  after 
•arlrj^too 

Kkarg«d. 


f. 

mauley. — 
1 8.  T.  R. 
h  had  by 
inC  B 
of  capias 

cause,  to 
lirection 
**  and  in- 
striking 


IV  Tws  ftptit  #tA»  or  «M.  tv. 

•Ul  ¥  in  a  plea  of  debt  of  eighty  pounds,^ 
•lid  itwertiiig  •*  In  a  plea  of  trespaae  on 
the  case  up<}n  promises  {**  and  by  striking 
out  **  bcfor*  us  thia  a3d  day  of  February 
lH24t  in  the  fourth  year  of  odr  reign*"  in 
the  teste,  and  inserting  in  lieu  thereof 
Thirty  first  day  of  January  in  the  fifth 
year  of  our  reign.*" 


BOIJLTON  agaimM  RANDAU.. 


110 


I8S4 

HaiMMr*. 


*i 


AyrllSOUi 


iCmH. 


tu  this  case,  Rolph  applied  for  a  rule  Tin.  < 
to  shew  cause  why  the  proceedings  and  «•  iHrTZT'Sr 
judgment  should  not  be  set  aside  for  irreg-  jH^iLwr*!* 
ularity,  and  why  the  writ  of  fieri  fiicias  Thi^.SIS 
issued  upon  the  said  judgment  against  the  2^^^!!!!!!!^  ^ 
lands  and  tenements  of  the  defendant,  jJ^IL^JfUlJjJJJ 
should  not  be  superseded  with  costs,  and  ^'  ' 
restitgliou  made  to  the  defendant.  ' 

^  A  judgment  by  default  had  been  signed 
in  this  case,  and  eiecution  issued  and  tha 
lands  sold  under  it  several  yearn  ago,  and 
!  an  application  similar  to  the  present  had 
been  made  by  Stewart  of  Counsel  for  the 
defendant,  who,  in  Michaelmas  term  1 82 1 1 
had  obtained  a  rule  nisi,  but  which,  upon 
argument,  had  been  discharged.  V|iri- 
ous  irregularities  were  upon  the  present 


« 


( ■ , 


■  ^W" 


Kl 


«aM  If  tAffCA  tflM' 


IIm4«II 


llSi  '^pplicalioft  pointed  <hiI  bjr  Mr.  Rolpti, 
MOM  of  which  had  probaMy  iiol  h«<!fi  in* 
•iiit«<l  upon  bjr  Mr.  SUwart  upon  th«  for- 
in«r  rootioo.*  Tho  Coumk-I  now  wont 
con«i<l«robljr  o(  Itnftb  jnto  ■II  (lio  aup. 
p<M«a  irr<»guUritie0,  and  alio  rood  on 
oAdavIl  (which  wm  AUnI)  conUlning  n 
•totrment  of  Ihotn  irrrguUriliwi  mwl  of 
th«  focU  and  mflfltt  of  lh«  •pplicont's 
MM,  odforting  oIm>  (o  the  partial  want  of 
conaid«fratlon  for  th«  dobl  u|K)n  which  the 
judgment  waa  obtaiiiod.  lie  alio  cited 
muij  CMM  ol  BOW  triola  ol  low  and  re< 
hearing*  in  equitjr  which  ho  conoidored 
oa  aaalogoui. 

HAiHion,  Attorney  General,  contro— 
read  an  affidavit  rebutting  ttioae  factn  and 
circumatancea,  but  relied  upon  the  oni- 
▼eraal  practice  of  Courte  of  loV^  (to 
which  no  one  eiception  coold  bo  foynd) 
which  doea  not  permit  a  eouao  ooco  de- 
termined upon  motion  and  orgomont  to 
bo  again  brought  forword  either  upon  the 
ground  of  the  aame  or  other  irregolaritiea 
not  before  insiited  ttpovL'  Ho  cited  and 
rood  the  rule  of  Hilary  Torin,  3d  Jomea 
lit,  by  which  It  is  ordered,  **Thotif  any 
*c«uto  ihall  fini  bo  moved  io  court  in 


"*i^* 


u.- 


.:^r" 


•  • 


MmiIm* 

llM4«il. 


» till?  prtt«itc«  of  iht  c<iutti«l  of  boili  |»*f» 

*  liMi  ami  ib«  court  •Imll  iImii  tb^rrupon 

*  order  liMtiv««n  thoM*  partic*,  if  tti«  Mino 

*  caiiM  •ball  «Kaiit  b«  itiovtd  coiitrtry  (o 

*  IImI  rtiia  «o  fivtii  b/  Um  eourt  tbrit  aii 

*  tttiMibnMitit  •liali    go  AgiiiiMt  biro  wbo 

*  tbatt  imKSiirt  llict  motion  to  bo  mado 

*  contrary  to  tbo    rule  of  court  to  firvt 

*  OMilt,   aiMl   tbat    tbe  couimcI  who  io 
«  movea,  hnvitig  notico  of  th«  Mid  forroor 

*  rulo,  tbitil  not  be  heard  here  in  couK 

*  in  anj  cause  in  that  term  iti  which  thai 
»  cau««  ihall  be  no  moved  contrary  to  lb« 

*  hile  of  court  in  form  aforesaid.** 

Tbt  eounatl  dto  cited  aathoritief  to 
■haw  that  no  motion  can  be  made  upon 
tbe  ground  of  irreguUritiet  not  noticed 
upon  a  iiml  motion. 

CamjtiMU  J^-Upon  the  opening  thii 
matter  I  thought  it  ilrange  and  wai  Iji- 
dignant,  that  the  irregularitiee  pointed 
out  by  tbe  defendant'e  counsel  should 
baft  tak«B  place.  v 

Whatever  w«r«  the  grounds,  it  now  ap. 
pears  those  irregutarHies  have  been  discus 
^ed  6i  decided  upon  for  many  terms  back. 

The  counsel  ly*  referred  to  ^umber 


K' 


*  ■'' 


>«■ 


♦•A 


•--f-; 


1|B^ 


IM 


•«•••  !■  li«»fW||  flM, 


1814 


of  AQthoriliM,  whirJi  U  mm  lo  be  fuppcuh 
•i  Im  nkrtwd  to  «•  upon  •  int  nppUes* 
jpi<M<  Hon  mmI  Uiaruiuiion,  birt  M  •[pp«ar«  tlitil 
VMiMltbtteaM.  irtlMf  fNNilob«c«fi< 
•id«f«Nl  M  fumuihiii|  attthoritjr  fur  ufMm- 
iof  tod  i«ronM4t«niif  iiM(l«f«  ftltMidy 
iImciimm^  ami  (l«fri<ir<l  upon,  (h«jr  do  ttoi 

Upon  r«r<irf*n<'<f  to  th«  onl<tr  in  llilnrj 
T«niit  :t(l  JacDM  Itt— it  apiMara  tuch  m- 
ooimI  <liii4''UMuoiM  c:«jiiK>4  b«  |MBraiitt«(]. 
Wvrt  it  iioC  lur  thia  Milulary  nil«,  ttotliing 
could  b«  more  unc«rtain  than  th«  pr»- 
OMditif  •  aiMl  dcciaioua  of  Courts  of  Jum- 
tic«.  Th«ff  it  alio  »  pmialtj  attAoh«d 
lo  th«  breach  of  th«  rule,  whichf  aa  thii 
<  k  th«  Ant  time  it  haa  bc«n  attempted  to 
be  infringed  in  thie  Court,  I  ahould  not 
wiah  to  aee  enforced  ;  but  upon  anj  future 
•(tempt  of  the  kind,  I  should. 

CKUf  Jmtieti^l  concur  with  my  brother 
Campbell,  and  for  the  reason  g ifen  bj 
him,  I  abo  consider  thai  the  penalty 
may  be  dispensed  with. 


fs^cr 


■:t  , 


■iP*: 


^p. 


IH 


•  «   fill   MtfN  f«««  At   H99.   tV. 


t         I 

OOe  Off  TfK»  MiMM  «r    MTAKHflRLD  «f«^Mi 

AmIms  for  Ibt  MkIUihI  «jwiH(!i  C^'IZ 


TW  &»!•  on  (Im  n«H  of  IImi  kaMir  of^""^****'^ 
lli«  plftinlifTwirre*  lh«l  Diuiifil  Wohburn  •—- «"r 
under  whom   ti«  cUMnr<l,  twine  in  ixm.  •••  ii^  v**^!** 
MMion  of  th«  pntmiana  Irft  (hia  country  *-*  iMi«tM». 
nn<l  wmil  in  18      to  th«  United  HtaUt  •»•  **    *** 
wberfl  ho  dirt],  l««viii(  ono  Short  in  Iho 
p<Mt«»aaion  mtul  rhargo  o(  tho  (irrniiaiMv— 
That  Simoon  Waahbam  wai  hia  Brother 
•iHl  Heir  al  Uw.    Tbat  Daniel  Weah- 
bum  being  at   the  time  of  hia  death,  in* 
debted  to  tho  leaaom  of  the  plaintifl*  in  a 
cooMiderable  aum,  hia  heii  at  Uw,  Simeon, 
bj  the  advice  ofCounael,  hjr  bargain  and 
aale,  tranaferred  the  property  to  them  in 
aatiafarrtion  of  the  debt.     Thia  deed   it 
appeared  had  not  been  rtgiaterod  until 
aAer  the  commencement  of  the  suit.     It 
further  appeared  in  evidence,  tbat  Whit- 
ney tho  defendant,  became  tlie  tenant  in 
poaaeaaiou  by  breaking  into  the  premiaea 
afier  the  death  of  D.  Waahburn,  and  be- 
fore any  entry  had  been  made  by  hia  heir 
Simeoa  Waahbq^i  but  after  the  bargaio 


j^i 


■m 


^ 


•  '^ 


^l. 


•• 


•  ♦ 


Ml  AMVYM  flMfe 


Ib«  ^mi«««  WM  ttiMi«r  •  •i«iH|«(;«i  tn«il« 
hy  0Mti«l  WMhtmm  to'liiM«  mm!  w\nak 

AUom«3r  un<l«r  •»!  ♦<<ipf«»<Mii<w  iImI  it  wtt 
ntf>«tMir)r  t«  nmkm  ooi  hia  lIlU  bf  pwr- 
ifif  llw  oHitiiMl  granl  Irmn  th«  crowm 
■ml  wlikb  ••  w«U  M  •«tbM(|ii«iil  convt jr- 
taMf  lo  UmmI  W«»hbimK  Im  proauoMNl 
wo«M  htir#,te«n  provAtI  hf  lli«  pUititifTi 
lowur.  lo,1iif»|Mirt  lii«  owti  litl«.  Imd  not 
given  lb«  <U«U  of  roort||»g«  In  •videiic*, 
Mid  th«  Jury  h^d  in  cotM«<iuciic«  found 
Ibr  lb«  pl«M»tUK 

Jlfru^%,  had  in  •  foimffr  t«rai  obtain- 
•d  a  ruto  niti  to  •«!  aaidn  tb«  verdict  and 
to  grant  a  new  trial  on  lh«  ground— -Flrtti 
tb«t  thf!  IcMor  of  thr  platnti((j||()u)^  h<iv« 
commrnri^tlm  proof  of  hl( 
duciog  lii«  original  grant  fr 
~^S«cofKlljr,  tlmt  till*  bargain  and  lalo 
made  bjr  Simeon  Wiivhbam  to  the  plairv 
tifr«  kworf,wai  void— Itt,  a«  being  with- 
•tit  t:oniiideration  Ac  nutium  padumMhfiug 
maJftupona  general  preaumption  that  the 
ImRii  in  the  hands  of  the  heir  were  liable 
to  the  anceator*t  timple'  contract  debta, 
ifhich  wif  not  tnw  an  l^ncral  propoai- 


'*i||ii  'J    S«*>^"* 


« 


piffN  «i«a  ##  (141  If. 


i 


iiii  to  b«  p^cimUrf.— Mljr.  m  itol  Imn 
Inn  r^|iat#rt»il  twfon  •rlliin  brmi(lil.o* 
4lMjr*  for  ttti««Halfit]r  MiMi  Im»ii«(  diw 

iMicMitMi  tb«  Utir  ^imMl}  IVMbbtirm 
conkl  •(>(  mull*  m  |ill«  lM»fbni  •tiiry  u|HNt 
IImi  IiuhK  hU  ••U4«f  l>«Uig  alMitfKl  bjr  Um 

Thirdl/^  *m  lh«  Krouiul  of  mkliikc  in 
liif  l|i!f<iiHl«9(*t  couiimI,  wliidhorH|tiuit«d 
la  •  tarpHM,  (b«  pltUiitifTV  Aiioni«j 
having  given  notice  lo  produca  Ulk 
4t«»<]a  which  h«^  <)i<l  not  aHarward*  call 
fbr«  on  ■  prmiimption  of  hia  doing  which 
^Ihr  df  friidaiit  (lid  not  coma  |»r«parod  to 
|i|pve  (hem. 

foorthty*  Ottilia  gf^imt  of  mcritf,  thir 
dafcndant  hAving  a  clear  title  under  hia 
mortgago. 

Rohiiuon^  Attioniejr  Cl^neml,  nowahaw- 

«d  caaao.     If  /inlica  Km  bean  done  the 

coort  will  not  grant  a  now  trial  upon  mk 

tiquated    technical  pointi  of  low,  aa  •• 

'  iMtement,  diMeinin  ire.  oapeciaUy  when 

thojr  ware  not  movod  or  roat rv«d  at  tho 


* 


t 


I 


» 


1  > 


1,;  .A«-^..fc  as-Ayj  .. 


I '      'I. 


■■•\* 


'■^   h,'' 


t%1 


1 


I82i 


Dm. 


t 


I 


mtamf 


4.  ' 


I:.* 


:.*i: 


%. 


i 

t 


%A9M  III  BAtTM,TUUI. 

trial.*  The  01U7  reMnraltoai  wore  whe- 
ther the  pUiiitid'**  leMon  »boilld  not 
have  ^ne  back  with  bi«  title  to  the  KiugHi 
3eed,  and  whether  the  bargtin  aiMl  sale 
to  him  Arom  the  heir,  was  not  void  for 
want  of  consideration. 

Ab  to  the  first,  it  is  clearly  Jaid  dowa 
as  well  by  Mr.  J.  BuHert  as  in  Phrllips* 
evidence,  that  it  is  sufficient  to  commence 
the  proof  of  a  title  bj  the  death  and  se- 
isin of  the  aiioestor ;  .as  to  the  second  ob- 
jectipn,  the  want  of  consideration,  I  con- 
Aider  that  it  was  good  and  valuable,  a 
debt  doe  from  the  ancestor  to  the  plain- 
tiflTs  lessor  ihe  bargainee,  and  which 
debt  the  lands  of  Simeon  Washburn,  the 
heir  o(  the  bargainor,  were  chargeable 
with  under  the  5  Geo.  2d.  The  adrltnta* 
ges  the  plaintiff  has  obtained  bjr  this 
verdiiBt  are  no  other  than  he  should  have 
had  without  it ;  namely,  being  a  defend- 
ant nstead  of  a  plaintiff,  for  the  defend - 
an%it  entitled  shduld  have  brought  his 
action  and  not  have  forced  Staosfieid  to 
become  Iplaiotiff'  by  a  forcible  entry. 
The  reasooli  for  refusing  new  trials  upon 

1  f- R.  ^EdflMUMv,  MmMI: 
1  Boa.  a  PkI.  338.  Cox  «:  Kltokoa. 
t  BoUN.P.lOS. 


#• 


4 

h' 

^  >---^..<tA.rr-  -*  isaeS 

^m^^^R^ 

'^K. 


~^«? 


/ 


IN  TNI  flfTM  VtAK  99  9^0.  IV. 


101 


lechnicil  objections  a ppl J  mote  strongly     IM4 
to  cases  of  «»jeciincnt  than  to  any  others    ^J]J^^ 
is  the  ju<lgm«nt  is  not  conclusive  as  Ifid 
down  in  10  Mod  202.  .     . 

jyiaenuley  conin^    The  cases  urg<!dV 

the    Attorney  General  would  apply  in 

tliis,  if,  as  In  those,  a  fair  trial  had  been 
had ;  but  the  defendant,  in  fact,  has  had 

00  trial  at  alL  —  — ;        -  -    -  --  -  -      -    • 

His  Attorney  received  notice  from  th^ 
plaintilTs  attorney,  to  produce  the  origin- 
al title  d9t($%  froni  which  he  presumed 
thc7  would  ^  called  for  by  the  plaintifT's 
counsel,  and  did  not  therefore  bring  wit- 
nesses to  prove  them  ;  but  the  plaintiff^ 
instead  of  begiunhig  his  title  with  these 
deeds,  commenced  by  the  death  and  ueix- 
in  of  Daniel  WuHhbum,  the  counsel  for 
the  diefendant  erroneously  supposing,  that 
it  was  necessary  lor  the  plaintifi*  to  com- 
mence his  title  by  proving  these  original 
deeds,  and  being  unprepared  with  such 

Srodf  gave-  up  his  case,  and  the  defen* 
•B^  was  tliereby,  in  tact,  deprived  of  a 
trial.  The  entry  of  Whitney  has  also 
been  urged  as  an  obje<Hioii ;  if  it  was  An 
independent  iact,  it  might  make  against 
himi  but  coupled  as  it  was  with  fl  good 
title  and  the  possession  of  deeds,  it  was 


lf',!» 


'■'#" 


***  y'"'* 


■-^trr 


8.iJi,.M 


"M 


%'4- 


■^>' 


^ih 


'!„ 


<»3f* 


ill 


ftMi 


OAtaf  i«        ^^ 

M^     •fcirt.H.rti^n^lfcl.riikt    If  the  ii,Ter.| 

fc»  o»9*^«i#  lo  ai«  pla«iir.  UII.I1MI  Imnni 

•jMWi    J^t^d  !«•?«•.  or  upon  ••pmsiiJT.rtiicI, 

niiMfi    I  kni^t  without  doubi  lMkf0  gone  inlotbeM 

•Hjaod  I  coticeire  I  majr  do  m  if  thej 

■pp««f  upQ5  a»  ^udfi^  nolf,, 

Tkwv  ^•  iwm/ oMw  ol  new  Irilrft  b«l 
ijl  ifikit«i  upoii  gnoumlii  not  HMVed  Ai 
tlie  trial  where  the  endt  oT  jbttiM  Nqtiifw 
•«t  it  ;     / 

h  StHtdnligiilMt  MildMlIt  e.Mfr  i>itl 
;*??ff*^  tht  ifofeatot  .peti  g<o„di^ 
iHiloh  br  the  iwitiJw  of  «•  e^tJii^^^^ 
ootnotiMd  •lAotfkl,  •Ddin0iA«** 
l«r  HPititt  T#bi»t  Uio  ooort  gfwitod.4 

■•w  irifcl  on  oocoont  of  lilt  mStUAo  ofoft 

•f  <i.iHliwl|(  ,.■  -:_',  ..^.;,. 

b  tho  ctMf  o^C^s  aipiifiKiiQl^  ' 
E^oiMoa  egaMwt  BfMdM||^p4  «ih«r  014. 
thoritiet  cited^  (ho  cooH  frfiiiJil  OHii 
newtnAopoo  pdBiiw^j,,^^^*^ 

tny^bocoowi  thejcoowlffod  thotioMieo 
J^AlbHo  dopo,  «f  thotlho  p,^,^ 

iuildi  •  aot^iaie  1^  ^1^  1^  ^^ 
gjy^y  long  hirfbro  (ho  ploiatiir  UmH 


.1^ 


Sf 


hit  d« 
■iich< 
of  bo 

Id 

nlMuk 
origin 
h«ro( 


Lord 
hoTi^ 


_  Wt. 

^'■- ioo,n 

iiigr 
oCduj 

gohi 
Uih( 
inpc 
wore 
Iher 
lyoi 


'^^Ig?' 


^ 


ther 

\b  be-     ^.w' 


m 


'^^ 


iiit 


'■^2' 


"t  k: 


wBSJ 


< 


i»  rwi  nv^Kfliift  or  •••  ir.         \ 

liudeed,  the  r«rj  Uking  Which ,  under  Itli 
•uch  circooMUuicM,  •ubjeott  to  the  cheifs  — ~ 
of  bojing  ap  a  pretended  title.       /  — '^^ 

I  coBceiTtt  Uiet  the  leftor  of  the  ple^otiff 
vkottldlinre  ooagyoMoced  hit  title  with  the 
origiuAl  gniDt  firom  the  orowo.  The  title* 
here  ere  tact  apoo  theBUHe  footing  with 
tibote  io'Englmd-^therc  •  teoeot  ii  pre- 
•omed'to  be  in,  with  the  coonent  of  the 
Lord  of  the  fee,  bnt  here  e)l  the  lendi 

heTkif  been  in  the  ^rowii  within  tbty 
jM!«,  4hel^N«soiJiption  fUb,  4nd  e  grent 
A«ni  the  orown  ■bedld  be  proiped.  Oq 
tfaii  gromd  tbe  pleintif;  I  oeneeive,thea|d 
heve  betn  nemiiited.  Shorts  peps^ition 
ioo,  WM  net  inch  •■  to  be  thel  efb.  Wash- 
l^um'i :  1m  •bonld  have  been  a  tenanl  |pay- 
iiig  rent,  whereai he  waia  mere  caioal 
obdupant  not  recogniaed  bjr  the  law. 

gain  i>  aale  tApluiitiii;  fobd  |r  ▼aloaUe, 
il  thotld  bare  beeo  shewo  that  tbe  landt 
iapoMiMioti  6f  Daniel  WaabbiirQ*a  heir, 
wera»  in  fiM)t,  Uable  to  hit  debt*,  andW 
Iher  that  the  oomiderilioii  lijis  n  peeonia- 
tf  0M»  fii  laid  down  ii^lOn^  difoat.  fol 
Ai  and  ako  in  the  8th  leperi 


^•4 


»      ♦ 


■  ■  4    ,j 


"*\ 


.y-0 


M 


-4fl»i- 


tl         *       . 


w^ 


A 


^Mt"^ 


/♦■  4n 


..      '--(:l 


V 
I 


m 


I8f4 

OM.Ut« 

jmtmii 


m 


m  lAiriMi  Timt. 

[Boulton  /.—You  ui«y  tbrw  «  pecuniary, 
coniidrmlion,  natiNfied  in  0»en  or  olli«r 
vnhiablvil  ^ 


*  t 


Tbia  lMlrani«nt  ia  vpid  (oo  f  contend 
for  flite^rtninlj ;  it  deacribea  no  land  Sn 
particnlnr,  but  all  ihe  land  Dnitid  Waah- 
bum  died  puaneaard  of.  I  eonoervA  It  waa 
void  too  for  want  of  regiatry.  1'be  Eng. 
liah  atntntea  appoint  a  time  witliin  which 
deedk  uiuvt  be  enrolled,  and  alter  ngiuiry 
the  title  ia  retroapeciive ;  but  here  no 
lime  ia  appointed,  froiii%b<}nce  it  may  b« 
iairlj  concluded,  that  tli«  ikl*  ia  not  com- 
plete  until  the  deed  ia  regiatered.  Thia 
inatniment  indeed  could  not  be  properlj 
regiatered,  for  it  meliUona  no  count j  in 
which  the  landaiie.    , 

Upon  these  grounds  of  objection  to  th^ 
titte  of  tbf  lei8oi^th*i)Iwntiffi  ^  r  ^^ 

Upon  iluit  of  merita  w1>ich  it  clMrty 
with  the  defendai)^  and  upon  the  broad 
principle  laid  down  bj  Mr.  Justice  Buller 
in  Eatwick  against  Cailland,*>«that  upon 
the '  application  lor  a  new  trial  the  only 
question  ia,  whether  under  all  the  ciicum^ 
stances  of  the  case,  the  renlict  be  or  ^ 
not  a4:c;Qrdi|ig  to  the  justice  of  the  case^ 


'.^'W/'f 


•  T.  R.  4U. 


^^rhflr 


t^_ 


'r^  ^"i. 


m^mm 


pocuruiry, 

m  or  oilier 

-  ■  **  .»•■  <  t     •'■I 

»  I  contend 
no  Uod  Sn 
itlel  Waih- 
serve  It  was 
the  Eiig. 
Ithin  whicit 
ier  nguttrfi 

ut  here  no 
•  it  maj  h& 
ia  not  corn- 
red.  Thia 
»c  property 
)  county  in 

:tiontotlK 

I  if  clearijr 
the  broad ' 
tice  Buller 

^'(hatnpon 
J  the  ofiYy^ 

becircom* 
^  be  orire 
the  caaij,**^ 


Ht 


'dt  -'i^ 


r"w  I    f  i—t f^ J" 


'• 


I  conreire  that  the  defendant  ia  entitled      lftl4 


■"■■■    ■    y*«' 


%M  '  "    t'i 


to  a  now  trial. 

.••■-  .r»-.  ■  ■ ;  ..   '.;:■  '  .'^V* 'N^-i^  •,>»»«,!■ 

l^o^Wm,  Attorney  Oeiienili  hi"  reply. 
UjbimpoHant  to  the  real  jiiHticeof  thia 
caa«  that  ibe  defendant  ahould  not  hav« 
an  opportunity  of  hringing  forward  the 
antiquated  doctrine  of  abatement  disaeia-- 
ikif  ^c.  and  therefore  1  contend  that  these 
points  not  having  been  moved  at  the  trial 
ahould  not  now  be  taken  into  considera- 

tlOll*' ,    ^-     •    ,   .  '        y     ■' 

■  '^  'i/ii -i /**»;  '■  •■   '•  '■■  ■  ..        '■  •  .    y       ■.   * 

Were  tbji  a  caae  in  which  juatico 
cbutd  not  be  done  without  considering 
thenir  I  might  not  perhaps  object  to  their 
consideration ;  but  it  is  not  so.  Injustice 
would  take  place  by  allowing  the  defen* 
dant  to  take  advantage  of  his  own  wrong 
in  making  a  forcible  entry.  Justice  is 
not  his  object)  but  he  wishes  to  meet  us 
with  defects  in  our  title.  The  aeiain  of 
D.  Washburn  is  sufficiently  substantiated/ 
It  is  not  necessary'ior  a  person  to  be  con- 
fined t6  his  house  to  continue  the  poss^- 
8100  of  it ;  if  he  baa  fiAy  houaea  he  may 
move  from  the  one  to  the  otiier  and  con- 
ti0«e  hii  p9S8esaion  by  haTingaen  agent 
or  servant,  6r  ev(}n  by  keeping  a  key.— 
There  is  no  occasion  for  a  pfraon  claim- 


'M 


eai-      ju» 


¥^^ 


m 


•MM  la  lAtTtm  v«a». 


'»•'  I 


1  k« 


/ 


■^'    ', 


J^'t, 


f 


IHA  iaf  tiiU  to  go  Uck  fkHli«r  than  to  the 
dtmtk  or  Misio  of  the  ftncmtor  ber«,  oiort 
tfi»n in Kflfland.    H«  knot  obliged  by 

MJpMMJWII  lua  proof*  boyond  thai,  to. 

^All^ftlUMolf  to  mako  ili^  or  brtachot 
'  is  tl|t  «buM  of  ikiib  •■ .  .^' ''  '-^ 

^^The  anctoiUlr*!  djing  teiied  makef  tbo.v^ 
boli^  title  prMM  yocM  good,  and  it  mjhf  4 

tha  A^bmAmM  in  ■haiHr  a  lKtil*#  |itla.r^ 

Tllf)  >'#ii|HKstion  to  waul  •■  i6gialviiug 
hat  been  takeo  fros  •  toppoaed  anologf 
between  oiir  regitlrjr  Actat  aad  the  Eng- 
ffii^  ttatutea  ^r  the  enrolhnent  of  deeda 
of  bargain^  lale;  no  Mich  analogj  in  (tuek 
exista  1  there  are  registry  a^ta  in  Riiglaod 
at  well  at  here,  upon  the  Mme  principle 
and  for  tbe  Mune  pqrposea  i  namely,  thai 
pf  gtringnotice  (0  fubtequent  piirchaaert, 
but  not  to  tulMiantiate  of^oafum.tk$0kti' , 

IW  coH^4er«lioQ  for  the  plaa^ir*a 
4ee4  waa  tbe  heal  poaaible ;  Ihere  wM  i 
jml  debt ,  due  by  the  anceator,  to  which 
tbt  \n4»  were  liable  under  |he  Otb  Gee. 
i|^^  tN  ifmm^^ nmtioB  nay  be  noM^y 
otmimf^^^''*tf^  •^  lud  down  by  nf 
Lov4Ceil»i  Who  mya,  that  a  baifaipaji 
m^  aver  wnm^J  or  other  Taloablea  Hi 
the  ceQMdMitU«K    If  the  defendaol  bis 


n^fib 
ment, 
Arst. 

COUIMH 

n^  JlvorUij 

''mm 

%»  ai 

Beql(4 
are  of 
lNs4is< 

%: 
'■'.  ■ ' .  /  ■ 

lathi 
•daJui 

ft  cat^ 

t^      Boulfo 

set  the  I 

this  writ 

ol 

M 

general 
only  poll 
ylaiotifla 


h: 


"   JV 


'lift'  . 


♦ 


«»Hli»  ^  In  )i|,  m^  ^y  j,^  ^  ^^^ 


CV  AniMr-Th*  point*  orna  by  lh« 
coun.«|  for  Om,  defendant,  .pp^r  to  be 
jrortfcj^cowWenitioo,  b<rt  Um  trki  bad, 

•n  opportuiutj  of  bru^nM^  ^rward 
^^•njr  mrilB  b«  amy  hair,,  upon  an  eject. 
«*Ht  to  be  brought  hf  hlm-^lf,  the  Court 
•w  of  opinioa  that  th«  rule  nki  .houid 
b«4Mcharged. 


'.I 


■!i.^' 


Pit  turiam^Jbu^  dMiargtd. 
JOHNSON  i^iiMI  iMADia. 


t'. 


'1 


•daJudgiii«itof,.g«;i^^l^i^^21ilL»r  * 

ft  cai.it:  apott  it  Siw  aTw  ' 

'     ,^?^  Solicitor  GenenJ.  «ored  to^'S?^       . 

IJlt'!!!^ "^"^ ""  '^^  ««>«»<>'  thatSsr; 

«Mwnt  did  m  lie  for  a  defeodaot,  tha  •"  •** 

^^..f  ^  '^^"^  •uthoriaing  it  being 

«>«PI  to  plaintifi,  wKl  not  iufficientir 
general  to  embrace  defeodaota.     Thcr 

•nlj  point  out  the  affidaiit  to  be  made  hr 


%S3S5i;-'P^ 


f  # 


*  • 


,¥ 


^■' 


I*' 


J*  %•,.  -  (       .        '       ■  *  •■  '  i^  j 

C'A^  7<itlf<     T***   c.ot*»  in  lliit  <»ii 

_    t^«  •Otitlcd   to  llifl  Mmm  rtfncJf  • 
pl^iyr  nM|ht  bur*  bad  if  b«  had  r<jc<rr- 

fditt-lin  •IW^^'H.-'   '    '•*f^'»'^'*  '"^  ***" 

•■'•■..1  rtr  ■«*''' k     ^''•"' 


tarfMAliurMf  ■        '^        '"""''"""^1 

S*"^tiJ^::n                EXPARTE  RADTimUllif .     |#^ 
iwu«r««r  . 

AiNwr    «•     Mr.  TiioiiAt  RAWWHOTit*  tpplwd  tbit 
2SI-V"-  U.rin  to  be  jMlmiiiilttd  an  M^J' 

•^•^  "^     Mr.  RWwit  wttH  wh#*il'1ia  bMn 

,        articled  being  oliMsnt  from  ibe  pr©fiiic#, 

.    the  Ckwi*  •dmiMed  »f r.  lUdtohurit  ttpbn 

.bb  own  »ifid*f  it  of  iervlce  for  flw  y«M» 

*  without  the  usual  certificate.  •  , ' 


■«■ 


fc^i 


_y  L 


"*    v^ 


* '     ,    ^^^ 


-:^„ 


•%"-}^r 


ff^5^-: 


s 


\i^ 


^ 


:^ 


V  I 


I-        .  ■.       -r- 

,....»,  ^^.  ._.-.  ^^  -.^  _ 

— 

^i- 

— 

■'s         ■    , 

-,  -J-*;;;- 

' 

- 

■  ■_ " V i 

B.      '    '■        .  ■ 

r 

0 

■'-■.-  ■'■'   ■■■    '\  ■' 

'    ' 

•- 

^ -■'■■:■' 

'■    ■   -^     ^ 

^ 

• 

•' 

"'  ■•     •  ♦'  /  ::r '  '■■■■' ' 

^;:  •■ 

>x             'tiknM>v 

ATf^ 

,    , 

t 

'^  ir 

\ 

»  ..    1  idft  ' 

> 


Jl-11^ 


