110 116 172 643 607/75 m s. k. b. rohatgi d. n. gupta and v. k. jain advocates.
for respondent number 1 7 13 in wp.
number 1073 1086 respondent number 1 7 in wp.
691 and respondent number.
number 578 79 respondent number 4 5 in wp.
597 576 and respondent number 1 in wp.
the pattern of all the acts is similar.
number.
number 607 and 1088 89/75 i. n. shroff advocate.
8 in wp 598 646 respdt.
v. state of bihar decided on 11 march 1963 and reported in a.i.r.
number.
in wps.
number 689/75 o. p. sharma advocate.
1208 1300 g. n. dikshit senior advocate in wp.
576 577 578 584 and 607/1975.
number 645 695 respondent number 1 and 5 7 in wp.
number 690 and respondent number 7 in wp.
in wps.
number.
this companyrt in civil appeals number 16 and 17 of 1963 rai ram krishna ors.
602 respdt.
for respondent number 1 in wp.
646 689/75 m. n. shroff advocate with him .
1 5 in wp.
1 in wp.
734 736/75 b. r. g. achar advocate.
number 599 and 687 respdt.
number 1 7 8 in wp.
for respondent number 1 7 in wp 603 respondent number 1 5 7 in wp.
number 603 only o. p. rana advocate with him in all the petitions .
number 604 respdts in wp.
number.
number.
number.
number.
number 680 688 respondent number 1 5 in wp.
respondent number 6 in wp.
601 and 602/75 only n. n. goswami in wp 769 806/75 and r. n. sachthey in all other petitions advocates with him .
number 643 698 1110 1115 and respdt.
647 693 respondent number.
number 599/75 m. bhandare senior advocate in wp.
number 689/75 v. s. desai senior advocate in wp.
691 respondent number 1 9 in wp.
number 598 646 692 and for respondents.
number 577 1193 1210/75 balabhadra prasad singh advocate general for the state of bihar.
original jurisdiction writ petitions number.
reference may be made to the bihar act as typical of all the cases companyered by these petitions.
number 584 and for respondents in wp.
2 5 in wp.
1 in wp.
number.
the question raised in these petitions is whether the petitioners are liable to pay tax under bihar taxation on passengers and goods carried by public service motor vehicle act 1961 hereinafter referred to as the bihar act .
680 681 689 695 696/75 s. c. patel advocate in wp.
for respondent number 1 in wp.
and writ petitions number.
number.
number 600 respdt.
number.
in wp.
number 601/75 respondent number 1 3 4 in wp.
number 600 1073 86.
number.
number 1 3 4 6 8 in wp.
for the petitioners in wps.
number 685 and respondents 1 5/3 in wp.
the other petitioners raised similar question under maharashtra tax on goods carried by road act 1962 rajasthan passengers and goods taxation act 1959 madhya pradesh motor vehicles taxation on goods act 1962 punjab passengers and goods act 1952 the gujarat carriage of goods taxation act 1962 the mysore motor vehicles taxation on passengers and goods act 1961.
110 116 172 590 593 650 697 and respondent number.
number.
the judgment of the companyrt was delivered by ray c.j.
1 3 4.
for respondent number 1 fp.
number 696 respondents in wp.
690 693/75 c. k. ratnaparkhi advocate for the respondents in wps.
