Appeal by Special Leave from the Judgment and Order dated 11/12 11 1975 of the Gujarat High Court in L.P.A. No.
9313/45, dated the 24th July 1951.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION Civil Appeal No.
9313/45, dated 6th February 1950 and those in Government Resolution No.
5 6 and 8 11.
Government Resolution No.
463/76.
9313/45, dated the 6th Febru ary 1950.
N. Shroff, for the State of Maharashtra.
C. Bhandare, S.P. Nayar and M.N. Shroff, for the, State of Gujarat.
K, Garg and S.C. Agarwala, for Respondents Nos.
1157/99153 D Sachivalaya, Bombay, 30th July 1959 Read Government Resolution No.
9313/45, dated the 24th July 1951, in so far as they relate to the recruitment of Bombay Civil Service Executive Branch Deputy Collectors Upper Division and to direct that, as far as practicable, 50 per cent of the substantive vacancies occurring in the cadre with effect from 1st January 1959 should be filled in by numberination of candidates to be selected in accordance with the Rules appended herewith.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by KRISHNA IYER, J. This is a typical service appeal, by special leave, which prompts the topical question Is lit Wiser national policy to process disputes regarding seniori ty, promotion, termination and allied matters affecting the public services, through the docket bound, formalised, methodology of the judicature adopting its traditional, time consuming, tier upon tier system and handicapped by absence of administrative expertise, accessibility to criti cal information and other limitations on the mode and extent of relief, or, alternatively, through built in, high pow ered, but credibility wise less companymanding, agencies of companyposite skills and processes and flexible remedial juris dictions ?
1042 RESOLUTION Government had for sometime under companysideration the question of reviving the system of direct recruitment to the cadre of Deputy Collectors.
V. Patel, P.H. Parekh and Miss Manju Jetley for the Appellants.
The title of these younger incum bents to be eider in the Civil List is primarily founded on a basic Resolution of Government of July 30, 1959 regulating recruitment to the Deputy Collectors cadre by the then Bombay State adopting a quota basis.
113/74 .
