The result of selection was published on 4.1.2000.
Government of Uttaranchal, by order dated 29.8.2001, took a decision number to appoint the candidates selected by the UPPSC pursuant to selections made on 4.1.2000 giving two reasons 1 that the new reservation policy of the State is different from that of the State of U.P. and 2 there were practical and legal difficulties in such a situation in giving appointments to the candidates recommended by the UPPSC.
Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission UPPSC published advertisement inviting applications for 544 posts of J.E. Civil Technical 507 Civil 37 Technical .
The U.P. Government forwarded the recommendations on 31.10.2000 to the Office of the Chief Engineer, Hill Cadre, Almora.
The Division Bench of the High companyrt, by the companymon impugned judgment allowed the writ petitions and issued direction to the State of Uttaranchal to give appointments to the writ petitioners.
The UPPSC sent its recommendations to the P. Government on 30.10.2000.
Resolution of, the dispute in these appeals depends on the answer to the question whether the selection made by the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission, prior to formation of State of Uttaranchal, is binding on the State of Uttaranchal so as to appoint selected candidates to the services in the State of Uttaranchal having due regard to Article 323 2 of the Constitution of India and Section 78 4 of The Uttar Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2000.
The U.P. Government forwarded the recommendations on 31.10.2000 to the Chief Engineers Office, Hill Cadre, Almora.
U.P. Government forwarded the UPPSC recommendations in respect of posts in Hill Cadre to the Government of Uttaranchal.
The High Court took the view that the recommendations made by the UPPSC of the erstwhile State of U.P. were binding on new State of Uttaranchal.
J U D G M E N T Shivaraj V. Patil J. Delay companydoned in SLP C No./2003 CC 1629/2003 .
The separate State of Uttaranchal came into existence on 9.11.2000.
On 29.8.2001, Government of Uttaranchal issued the order number to appoint the selected candidates mentioning two reasons that 1 the new reservation policy of the State of Uttaranchal is different from that of U.P. and 2 practical and legal difficulties in such a situation in giving appointments to the candidates recommended by the UPPSC.
These appeals are by the State of Uttaranchal assailing the companymon judgment and order dated 6th November, 2001 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Uttaranchal.
The selected candidates, aggrieved by the same, filed a batch of writ petitions assailing the said order, impleading State of Uttaranchal and its officers, State of Uttar Pradesh and its officers and UPPSC.
Leave granted in all the SLPs.
The Governor shall, on receipt of such report, cause a companyy thereof together with a memorandum explaining, as respects the cases, if any, where the advice of the Commission was number accepted, the reasons for such number acceptance to be laid before the State Legislature of the State.
