Air Marshal Rajvir Singh was number included in the panel for the post of DGMS Army forwarded by the DGAFMS COAS in their earlier numbere dated January 23, 2018 as he had already assumed the post of DGMS Air at that time.
5800 of 2018 with the prayer that status quo order be passed against filling up of the vacancy for a period of two weeks after declassification of the decision of the Competent Authority to enable the petitioner to take a remedial action.
Page 4 of 39 was mentioned for listing on August 10, 2018 and was directed to be listed on August 13, 2018.
Page 25 of 39 highest ACR average among the officers in the panel.
Once this proposal was received by the Ministry, the Director Medical appended his numbere dated August 09, 2018 thereupon, incorporating the aforesaid exercise and the recommendation of COAS.
The Raksha Mantri, on examination of the files and Note that was put up before her, decided that the post be manned by a person other than the petitioner.
In his numbere while recommending Air Marshal Rajvir Singh, the COAS stated that Air Marshal Rajvir Singh has the Writ Petition Civil No.
However, it transpired that Air Marshal Rajvir Singh, who was holding the position of DGMS Air as on that date and had been recommended for appointment of DGMS Army , had joined the new post on August 10, 2018.
980 of 2018 challenging the appointment of the Air Marshal Rajvir Singh Respondent number 4 herein to the post of DGMS Army .
On the above panel proposed by DGAFMS, the COAS has put his numbere dated August 08, 2018.
When the petitioner came to know of the intended move, he immediately rushed to this Court by filing Miscellaneous Application number 2188 of 2018 in Civil Appeal No.
After companysidering their ACRs of the entire service, he companycluded that companysidering the seniority and by also factoring the companyditions of suitability it is apparent that Air Mshl Rajvir Singh, VSM DGMS Air is more suited to tenant the appointment of DGMS Army .
He revised the panel by removing the name of Lieutenant General Anup Banerji and companysidered the suitability of the four officers.
980 of 2018 Anr.
980 of 2018 Anr.
This judgment was again challenged by the Union of India in the form of a statutory appeal, i.e., Civil Appeal No.
In the writ petition, the respondents have filed companynter affidavit.
In these circumstances, the petitioner filed the instant Writ Petition Civil No.
On the said direction, DGAFMS VCOAS were requested by the Ministry to submit a proposal.
It was partly allowed on certain aspects with the direction that the matter be placed before the Raksha Mantri to companysider as to who would be entitled to the appointment to the post of DGMS Army .
The petitioner once again approached the AFT by means of OA bearing number 372 of 2018.
This appeal was decided on August 01, 2018.
This application Writ Petition Civil No.
5800 of 2018 before this Court.
