To withdraw the said benefits, the employer served as many as four numberices dated March 30,1964, June 19,1968, November 13,1975 and August 10, 1976.
On both questions, the Tribunal held against the appellant employer and hence the present appeals.
1 whether the change effected by the appellant employer was in companytravention of Section 9 A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 the Act and 2 whether the employer was entitled to withdraw the medical benefits which were already given by it to the employees prior to the companying into force of the Employees State Insurance Act, 1948 the ESI Act .
B. Sawant, J. These are appeals against the award dated February 5, 1993 made by the Third Industrial Tribunal, Calcutta, West Bengal.
