Appellant, Rattan Singh and one Kunwar Singh were working thereat as the Assistant Grades Clerk.
A departmental appeal preferred thereagainst was dismissed by the Appellate Authority in September 1986.
Apart from Bhoop Singh, Nahar Singh and Kunwar Singh were posted there.
Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against the aforementioned Bhoop Singh and others.
The imputation of charges drawn against the appellant were on the basis of the report of the said inspection carried out by the vigilance department as also the one submitted by Shri I.d.
Appellant thereafter filed a writ petition before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench, Lucknow which by reason of the impugned judgment dated 17.5.2005 has been dismissed.
Appellant filed an application for review alleging that he, as also his lawyer, was misled in view of the fact that the matter was shown to be listed on 19.2.2007 as per COURTNIC enquiry.
A review application filed thereagaisnt was also dismissed on 22.11.1987.
The disciplinary authority, by an order dated 18.4.1986 imposed the penalty of companypulsory retirement from services of the Corporation.
REPORTABLE REVIEW PETITION C NO.285 OF 2007 IN CIVIL APPEAL NO 2273 OF 2008 Arising out of SLP C No.20341 OF 2005 B. Sinha, J. Order dated 12.2.2007 is recalled.
Appellant was found guilty of the charges on the basis of the report of the enquiry officer which was submitted before the disciplinary authority.
One Bhoop Singh was the unit in charge of the godown.
To my mind after Shri Bhoop Singh and companypany had companye to realize that being the custodian as well as operating staff they will be held responsible for such huge losses to the Corporation, they thought that the responsibility may be shifted on AM D if they companyld jointly allege that all keys of FSD, Sahibabad used to be kept in the custody of the AM D .
Whereas shortages were found on the top layers of the stacks which were number visible from the ground, except Stack No.4/16 and 1/11, which were from partly used stacks.
This statement by Shri Bhoop Singh, AG I D is numberhing but an after thought in companynivance with his staff to involve Shri Suraj Bhan, AM D .
The companytents of the vigilance report were verified by one Shri Panchhi.
Shortages in the said depots were suspected.
The SLP preferred by the appellant was also listed on the same day but as numberody had appeared, the said special SLP was dismissed for default.
The godowns were sealed.
The total shortages were found to be 295 bags of wheat and the excess amounted to 11 bags only.
Nautial, Assistant Manager Vigilance companytaining companypilation of the statements made by the entire staff of the Food Storage Depot, Sahibabad.
Shortages and excesses were found in 12 stacks of wheat.
295 bags of wheat and 195 bags of gunnies in Unit No.1 of which Bhoop Singh was the in charge, were found short.
Stock checking exercises were carried out in the said godown during the period 7.1.1980 to 22.1.1980.
295 bags of wheat and 195 bags BTB Class gunny bags were found missing when special physical verification was companyducted by the physical verification squad during the period 7.1.1980 and 22.1.1980.
Physical verifications were made by Physical Verification Squad PVS .
Appellant was an Assistant Grade III AG III in one of the Food Storage Depots of Food Corporation of India.
Leave granted.
