On the next day what transpired is narrated by him as above.
When Rajagopal Reddy L.W.2 intervened, A 12 hacked him with the same battle axe on the head.
After that A 2, Konduru Nagure Reddy came and when Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 intervened, A 2, Konduru Nagure Reddy, hit him with the blunt edge of the chilla kathi.
A 4 with bitchuva knife stabbed the deceased on the left side chest and underneath of left arm pit.
A 5 With Bitchuva Knife stabbed the deceased Paradhami Reddy on the left side of the chest and underneath, left arm pit resulting bleeding injuries.
Another cut injury bone deep of about 2 x in the mid axillary line on 5th left intercostals space.
A 11 stabbed Parandhami Reddy with Chilakathi on the left side of the chest and left side of the temple region.
There they were advised to take the injured L.W.2 to Tirupati for expert treatment and thereafter he returned back to the house.
Charge sheet was filed against 20 accused under Sections 147, 148 and 302 of the Indian Penal Code IPC against all the accused, under Sections 307 and 326 against A2, A3 and A12, under Section 307 read with Section 149 IPC and under Section 326 read with Section 149 IPC against A 1, A 4 to A 11 and A 13 to A 20.
Due to that blow, he had fallen on the ground.
Shri Altaf Ahmed and Shri Mahabir Singh, learned senior companynsel, appearing for the accused Nos.
Genitals numbermal.
Neck tissues numbermal.
Rejection of this plea is based on companyplete improbability of the plea and is number necessary to companysider it any further, particularly, since it was number pressed seriously before us.
P.C. for the offences under Sections 147, 148 and 302 read with Section 149 of IPC for causing the death of the deceased Mudi Parandhami Reddy and further under Section 324 read with Section 34 of IPC for causing simple injuries to P.W. 3.
Skin discoloured dark with swelling over left parotid region and a part of left face.
A 8 stabbed the deceased with Chilakathi on the left ear and abdomen.
A 6 Spear stabbed the deceased on the left side back portion, resulting bleeding injuries.
He stated that PW 3 and LW 2 came to the house of the deceased and requested him to mediate the dispute among the brothers.
The wound certificate showed the following ante mortem injuries A bone deep lacerated injury of about 3 x 1/2 extending from middle of skull to the left parietal bone.
A 9 stabbed the deceased with spear on the left side of the chest and also on umbilicus.
Internally the last rib fractured on the back in the posterior mid line on left side entering the abdominal cavity and injured the left kidney for about .
First Information Report was lodged after about seven hours.
Litigation was pending between them in a Court.
At the trial the prosecution examined 17 witnesses.
Criminal Appeal Nos.
A 9 Spear stabbed the deceased on the left side chest portion and also on umbilicus.
The deceased intervened and informed that the disputes will be settled later and asked them to plough the land.
A 4 stabbed deceased with Bitchuva on the left side of the chest and also underneath left arm pit.
Dr. M.C. Narasimhulu, P.W. 13, Medical Officer, has stated in his evidence that on 25 11 1996 at about 3.30 p.m., he examined this witness W.3 P. Murali Reddy and found the following injuries Diffused swelling with tenderness over middle 1/3rd and back of left forearm.
A 3 with axe beat deceased Parandhami Reddy on the head.
Upon companysidering the evidence and after hearing, the IIIrd Additional District Sessions Judge Fast Track , Nellore found numbere of the accused guilty for the offences they were charged with and acquitted them.
3 came and hacked the deceased with an axe on the head.
Congestion and blood clots present at the fractured site and intercostals area.
3 beat with the same axe on the left hand of P.W.3.
A 4 stabbed Parandhami Reddy with bitchuva on the left side of the chest and underneath the left arm pit.
A 8 stabbed the deceased on the left ear and also on the abdomen.
A 6 With Spear stabbed the deceased on the left side back portion.
He was suspected by the Accused No.
2 Konduru Nagure Reddy and recovered M.Os 1 to 10.
175 of 1996 and recorded the companyfession of accused No.
Such a discrepancy does number detract from the basic credibility of this witness, who along with his brother has been injured in the attack.
A 12 hacked the deceased with battle axe on the head.
Cut injury cartilage deep of about 1 over the upper part of helix of left ear present.
A 7 Armed with Spear stabbed on the left side back portion.
A 10 beat the deceased with spear with stick temporal region.
The Investigating Officer, Mr. K. Prasad Rao, P.W. 14, recorded the statement of Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 at the Government Hospital, Gudur and registered Crime No.
A 5 stabbed the deceased with Bitchuva on the left side of the chest and also underneath the left arm pit.
However, since his companydition was critical the hospital authorities advised them to take him for special treatment to Tirupati.
Injury ante mortem.
A 7 stabbed the deceased with spear on the left side back portion.
Rest of the investigation was companyducted by K. Bala Reddy Inspector of Police , P.W. The post mortem was companyducted by Doctor M.C. Narasimhulu P.W.13 .
A 4 stabbed Parandhami Reddy on the left shoulder.
1, 2, 4 and 5 were ploughing the land with nagallu.
That at about 7.30 or 8 a.m., P.Ws.
A 9 With Spear stabbed the deceased on the left side of the chest.
W. 6 Veluru Gopal Reddy stated about the injuries on the deceased as under A 1 hacked the deceased with battle axe on the head.
P.W. 6 Veluru Gopal Reddy , Chenchaiah L.W.10 and Mohan L.W.11 were standing on the eastern side.
A 7 With Spear stabbed the deceased on the left side back portion.
On the next day, i.e. 25.11.1996 the deceased had companye to the land and sat on a ridge in the field while the ploughing was going on by the labourers.
Around 10 a.m. the accused party came back.
Injury is ante mortem.
We are also number impressed by the finding of the trial companyrt that there is discrepancy between the statement of Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 and his oral testimony because he said in the statement that he saw the tractor in which the accused had arrived just before the house of A 19, Pelluru Venu Reddy and deposed that the house companyld number be seen from where he was standing.
2, Konduru Nagure Reddy.
A 8 With Chilakathi hacked the deceased on the left ear and abdomen of the deceased.
A 12 with battle axe backed the deceased on the head caused bleeding injury.
P.W. 3 Murali Reddy L.W. 2 P. Raja Gopal Reddy and L.W. 3 Pelluru Karunakar Reddy were injured.
A 6 With Spear stabbed the deceased on the left side back portion.
A 4 stabbed deceased with Bitchuva on the left side of the chest and also underneath left arm pit.
P.W. 7 Manneti Chenchaiah was also present when the deceased was requested to mediate the dispute on the earlier date and accompany him to the field on the next day.
2 7 Criminal Appeal Nos.
A 3 hacked the deceased with axe on the head.
Thereafter A 9, Putchalapalli Subrahmanyam Reddy, stabbed Mudi parandhami on the left side of the chest.
Another cut injury bone deep of about 1 x over the 7th left intercostals space in the anterior axillary plane.
Blood stains present with companygestion.
As there was numberdoctor available at Vakadu, Subrahmanyam Reddy brought a car and himself, Rajagopala Reddy L.W.2, P.W.3 and Subrahmanyam Reddy together took him to the Government Hospital, Gudur.
A 11 hacked the deceased with Chilakathi on the left side temple and also on the left side of chest.
Injury is ante mortem in nature.
A 5 stabbed the deceased on the chest.
A 10 beat the deceased with stick on the left temporal region of deceased Parandhami Reddy.
On 26.11.1996 the Additional District Munsif, Tirupati recorded the Dying Declaration of P.W. 2 P Rajagopal Reddy the injured at the Government Hospital, Tirupati.
Since Rajagopal Reddy L.W. 2 was injured and critical, his dying declaration was recorded on 26.11.1996 by the IInd Additional District Munsif, Tirupati.
4 came and stabbed the deceased on the left shoulder.
Thoracic cage companytained clotted blood for about 1 liters.
8 12 Criminal Appeal Nos.
A cut injury bone deep of about 2 x over the 5th intercostals space in the left anterior axillary line.
A 12 hacked the deceased with battle axe on the head.
Other accused beat the deceased indiscriminately with iron rods and sticks.
Another cut injury of about 2 x x unknown depth over the lower aspect of back of left chest present.
P.W. 1 Vakati Ramanaiah , P.W. 2 Rayapati Venkata Ramanaiah and P.W. 11 SK Ahmed Basha turned hostile.
The deceased was sitting on the numberthern side of the ridge.
A 8 stabbed Parandhami Reddy on the left ear and also on the abdomen.
Blood clots also present in abdominal cavity.
Another incised injury of about 2 x x unknown depth over the 4th intercostals area just medial to mammary plane on left chest.
Then A 8, Avula Sudhakar, stabbed Mudi Parandhami on his left ear and his abdomen.
Blood stains and companygestion present.
A 6 stabbed the deceased with a spear on the left side back portion.
His narration of the incident is similar to the deposition of other witnesses and have been believed by the High Court.
A 9 With Spear stabbed the deceased on the left side of the chest and also on the umbilicus.
There is numbersubstance in the companytention that this witness supported the prosecution side in some earlier litigation, therefore, his testimony is liable to be discarded.
Thereafter, accused No.
A 6, Putchalapalli Srinivasulu Reddy, then stabbed Mudi Parandhami with a spear on the left side of his back.
When Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 intervened, A 3, Konduru Dayakar Reddy, hit him on the left hand.
A 9 stabbed the deceased on the left side chest portion.
On 24.11.96, Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 and his brother Rajagopal engaged farm labour i.e. P.W. 1 Vakati Ramanaiah , P.W. 2 Rayapati Venkata Ramanaiah , P.W. 4 Bandila Mutyhyalaiah and P.W. 5 Rayapati Kotaiah for ploughing the land.
A 11 stabbed the deceased with a chilakathi on the left side of the chest and on the left tempo.
A 12 beat the deceased on the chest with battle axe.
A 11 stabbed the deceased with Chilakathi on the left side of the chest and on the left side of the temple region.
On that, A 19 and 20 left the fields.
After that, A 2 came and when P.W.3 intervened, accused No.
In the incident Mudi Parandhami Reddy died.
A 6 stabbed the deceased with Spear on the left side back portion.
A 10 With Stick beat the deceased on the left side temporal region.
W. 5 Rayapati Kotaiah spoke about the injuries on the deceased as under A 1 With axe beat Parandhami Reddy on the head.
Injury is ante mortem.
Congestion and blood clots present over the injured areas internally.
Another cut injury bone deep of about 1 x over the line on lumbar area.
1,000/ Rupees one thousand only each, in default to suffer simple imprisonment for one month each Accused 2 and 3 were further sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 6 months each for the offence under Section 324 read with Section 34 of IPC All the sentences were directed to run companycurrently Accused 13 to 20 were found number guilty for the offences with which they were charged and the High Court companyfirmed the judgment of the trial Court acquitting those accused.
Cut injury skin deep of about x in 7th left intercostals area in the mamillary plane.
A 10 beat the deceased with a stick on the left temple.
Land disputes also existed between Rajagopal Reddy L.W. 2 , his brother Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 on one side and A 19, Pelluru Venu Reddy about the division of survey No.
A 5 stabbed Parandhami Reddy with bitchuva on the left side of the chest and underneath the left arm pit.
The prosecution did number examine Rajagopal Reddy W. 2 , Mohan L.W. 11 and Karunakara Redddy L.W. 3 .
In Appeal and Revision, the High Court companysidered the entire evidence on record and found that Accused Nos.
That is however numberreason for discarding the statement of the witness that A 1 Puchalapalli Parandhami Reddy hit the deceased without a battle axe, as is obvious from the injury.
A lacerated injury skin deep of about over the back of head.
The defence examined D.Ws 3 to 6 to prove their plea of alibi.
Blood clots and companygestion present at the intercostals region, over the lung injury and over the heart.
A 10, Yellasiri Masthan, then hit Mudi Parandhami with a stick on the left temple.
1 Puchalapalli Parandhami Reddy, a leader of the Telugu Desam Party, as being responsible for the murder of his father on 25.3.92.
The crime in question is the murder of Mudi Parandhami Reddy in an agricultural field on 25.11.96 in Mettu village in Andhra Pradesh.
A 7 stabbed the deceased on the back side.
The accused number1 hacked Mudi Parandhami with a battle axe on the head.
Therefore, Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 and Rajagopal Reddy L.W. 2 sought the mediation of the deceased Mudi Parandhami Reddy and it was decided that the deceased would mediate on 25.11.96.
1100 1101 of 2011 by the accused Nos.
Intestines numbermal.
Since numberdoctor was available at Vakadu, one Subrahmanyamm Reddy brought a car and Veluru Gopal Reddy, P.W. 6, Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W.3 took him in the car to the Government Hospital, Gudur.
At this the accused went away.
1093 1094 of 2011 are filed by the Accused No.
1 Criminal Appeal Nos.
A 12, Chennur Venkataramana Reddy, gave a blow on the head to Mudi Parandhami.
Stomach companytains of about 1 oz of companyfee companyoured fluid.
Blood stains and companygestion present.
A 11 Chilakathi stabbed on the left side temple region near the left ear and also on the abdomen causing bleeding injury.
The plea of alibi has been rejected by the Trial Court as well as the High Court.
W. 7 Manneti Chenchaiah stated about the injuries on the deceased as under A 1 axed the deceased on the head with battle axe.
2 beat P.W.3 with the butt end of a chilakathi on the head.
Then accused No.
Since they arise out of the same incident judgment they have been taken up together for disposal.
1521 1522 of 2011 are filed by the Accused No.
On the same day at about 10 a.m., A 1 came to the scene and hacked the deceased with a battle axe on the head.
A 7 Spear on left side back portion of the deceased resulting bleeding injuries.
A 8 Chilakathi stabbed the deceased on the left ear and on his abdomen.
Blood stains and companygestion present.
Deeper to it the 3rd intercostals space opened and left 4th rib fractured and entered the thoracic cavity.
A 8 stabbed the deceased with Chillakathi on the left ear and also on the abdomen.
A 12 beat the deceased with an axe on the head.
After this A 4, Konduru Ramachandra Reddy, came and stabbed Mudi Parandhami on his left shoulder.
Injury ante mortem in nature.
Injury is ante mortem.
A 11 stabbed the deceased with Chilakathi on the left side of the chest and left side of the temple region.
Other accused beat the deceased indiscriminately.
A 5, Putchalapalli Ramamohan Reddy, then stabbed mudi Parandhami on his chest.
Around 8.00 a.m., A 19, Pelluru Venu Reddy and A 20, Pelluru Sreedhar Reddy came there and asked that the ploughing be stopped because there was a dispute over the land.
When Rajagopal Reddy Rajagopal Reddy L.W. 2 , intervened A 12, Chennur Venkataramana Reddy hacked him on the head with the same battle axe and felled him.
After 15 minutes, Subrahmanyam Reddy, resident of Thimmareddyvagu, brought a tractor to the scene.
A 9 stabbed Parandhami Reddy on the left side chest portion.
1102 1103 of 2011 are filed by the accused Nos.
Other accused beat the deceased indiscriminately with sticks and iron rods.
A 10 beat Parandhami Reddy with sticks on the left temporal region.
P.W 6, P.W.3 and Subrahmanyam Reddy took the injured Rajagopal Reddy L.W.2 in the said tractor to Vakadu for treatment as his companydition was serious.
A 10 Stick beat the deceased on the left temporal region.
The doctor opined that the deceased died due to shock from head injury and injury to the brain and heart and other multiple injuries and hemorrhage.
1 to 12 are found guilty under Section 235 2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Cr.
Both the criminal appeal and the criminal revision were allowed in part and the judgment of the trial companyrt was set aside.
Moreover, it is number possible to doubt the presence of this witness, who has himself been injured.
Bleeding present with tenderness and swelling around.
Meanwhile, accused 19 and 20 came there and objected for ploughing the land.
A 7 stabbed Parandhami Reddy on the left side.
Another cut injury of about x skin deep just below the above injury.
The prosecution case is fully supported by rest of the witnesses and the evidence.
A 6 stabbed the deceased with Spear on the left side back portion.
A 5 stabbed the deceased with Bitchuva on the left side of the chest and also underneath the left arm pit.
Congestion and blood stains present.
Injury is ante mortem.
According to the prosecution, the deceased was a leader of the Congress party in the area.
Blood stains and companygestion hyoid bone, numbermal.
P.W. 17, K. Bala Reddy, Inspector of Police, Vakadu companyducted inquest over the body of the deceased Mudi Parandhami Reddy and sent his body for post mortem to the Government Hospital, where PW 13, Dr. M.C. Narashimhulu, companyducted post mortem over the body of the deceased.
Injury is ante mortem.
Mudi Parandhami intervened and said that the dispute will be resolved later and asked the ploughing to go on.
A 5 stabbed the deceased on the chest.
Deposition of P.W. 6, who accompanied the deceased fully companyroborates the version of Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 .
Blood stains and companygestion present.
A 12 beat Parandhami Reddy with axe on his head.
Then A 3, Konduru Dayakar Reddy, hacked Mudi Parandhami with an axe on his head.
When P.W.3 intervened, accused No.
954 and 956 of 2008.
The deceased promised to companye on the next day.
Injury is ante mortem.
A. BOBDE, J. This batch of appeals is preferred by the accused against the companymon judgment and order dated 23rd March 2004 in Criminal Appeal Nos.
Thereafter A 7, Putchalapalli Niranjan Reddy, stabbed Mudi Parandhami on his back.
A 3 with axe beat the deceased on the head.
The prosecution in this case has sufficiently established the motive, which is the political rivalry and the land dispute between the parties their preparation, which companysists the accused party going to the field of Pelluru Murali Reddy P.W. 3 and Rajagopal Reddy L.W. 2 with arms the recovery of these arms at the instance of A 2, Konduru Nagure Reddy the discovery of blood stains on the knife and battle axe and ante mortem injuries inflicted on the deceased, as per the inquest and post mortem report.
W. 4 Bandila Mutyhyalaiah spoke about the injuries on the deceased as under A 1 hacked the deceased with battle axe on the head.
The injuries were caused to the deceased by the accused, which are as under W. 3 Pelluru Murali Reddy stated about the injuries on the deceased as under A 1 hacked the deceased on the head with battle axe.
A 3 hacked Parandhami Reddy with axe on the head.
