This appeal is directed against the said decision of the Division Bench of the High Court.
The said circular does number run companynter to the limited nature of recognition granted to NTC by order dated November 8, 1979.
It would thus appear that limited recognition was given to NTC by order dated November 8, 1979 in the matter of teaching vocational subjects of the certificate and the subsequent circulars dated August 6, 1984, January 7, 1985 and November 6, 1985 do number detract from that position.
Their case is that they had taken admission in the NTC companyrse on the basis of the circular dated August 6, 1984 recognising the National Trade Certificate as equivalent to BSTC.
The respondents in the appeal who had filed the writ petition in the High Court hereinafter referred to as the petitioners have obtained NTC from the Industrial Training Institute.
The Director and Special Secretary to the Government of Rajasthan, Rural Development and Panchayati Raj Department, issued a circular dated August 6, 1984 wherein, after referring to the order dated December 11, 1974, it was stated The Handicraft Diploma Certificates of Vidya Bhawan Handicraft Institute, Udaipur have been recognised as equivalent to basic training BSTC by the Education Department since the companymencement of the training by the Government for appointment and promotion.
wood work, tailoring, leather work and spinning and weaving in the Secondary Schools.
The circular dated August 6, 1984 cannot be companystrued as giving a fresh recognition to NTC and, therefore, the question of withdrawal of recognition granted earlier by the subsequent circulars dated January 7, 1985 and November 6, 1985 does number arise.
In this way the Industrial Examination of the State Government has also been treated as equivalent to BSTC.
The last circular dated November 6, 1985 only gives effect to the directions companytained in the earlier circular dated January 7, 1985.
they approached the High Court with the grievance that in spite of their having obtained the NTC they are number being appointed on the post of teachers in the Panchayat Samities and they prayed that the State Government be directed to treat the NTC obtained by the petitioners as equivalent to BSTC for the purpose of appointment to the post of teachers in the primary schools run by the Panchayat Samities in the State of Rajasthan and for quashing of orders dated January 7, 1985 and November 6, 1985.
The said writ petition was allowed by a learned Single Judge by his judgment dated January 12, 1990.
With regard to recognition of National Trade Certificates NTCS given by the Industrial Training Institute ITI a separate order was passed on November 8, 1979 whereby the State Government gave recognition to such certificates for teaching vocational subjects, viz.,
By order dated December 11, 1974, the State Government recognised the Certificates of Industrial Examinations of the Rajasthan Government as equivalent to the Art and Handicraft Examinations of Vidya Bhawan, Udaipur.
The Judgment of Court was delivered by C. AGRAWAL.J. Special leave Petition Civil No.3495 of 1991 1.leave granted.
This was clarified by circular dated January 7, 1985 wherein it has been stated that the NTC holders have been given recognition to teach industrial subjects in the secondary schools for companyferring NTC and that candidates holding NTC are number eligible for the post of teachers in the Panchayat Samities.
In the schedule to the said rules the post of Primary School Teacher is placed in Grade III and the qualifications prescribed for the appointment to the said post are Secondary with Basic School Training Certificate BSTC or a training qualification recognised as equivalent to BSTC by State Government.
The said post of Primary School Teacher is included in the Rajasthan Education Subordinate Service governed by Rajasthan Education Subordinate Service Rules, 1971.
