121 of 1959, and 7 of 1960, June 15, 1960, in References IT Nos.
123, 180 and 236 of 1959 of the Industrial Tribunal, Maharashtra at Bombay.
84 and 251 of 1959, June 15, 1960, in References IT Nos.
C. Setalvad, K.T. Sule, Madan G. Phadnis, Jitendra Sharma and Janardan Sharma, for the respondents in C.A. No.
112 and 252 of 1959, June 16, 1960, in References IT Nos.
Appeals by special leave from the Award dated June 3, 1960, in reference IT Nos.
V. Gupte, Additional Solicitor General N. V. Phadke, J. B. Dadachanji, O. C. Mathur and Ravinder Narain for the appellants in all the appeals .
The second companypany is Greaves Cotton and Crompton Parkinson Private Limited and its main business is distribution of the products of a manufacturing companycern known as Crompton Parkinson Works India Limited and service and repair to the said products at its workshop.
for the four companypanies before us do number belong to the same industry and Greaves Cotton and Co. companytrols the other three.
The last three companypanies are companytrolled by the first companypany, namely Greaves Cotton and Co., in one way or the other and that is how the main dispute relating to wages and dearness allowance was dealt with together by the tribunal.
Further it gave the same dearness allowance to the factory workmen as to the clerical and subordinate staff and directed adjustments also on the same basis.
272/1962 .
T. Sule, Madan G. Phadnis, Jitendra Sharma and Janardan Sharma, for the respondents in C. As.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION Civil Appeals Nos.
272 to 280 of 1962.
Considering therefore the standing of the main companypany namely, Greaves Cotton and Co. Ltd. , it was number improper for the Tribunal in the present cases to rely on the companyparable companycerns 1 1963 Supp.
There were disputes between the four appellants companies and the respondents, their workmen, which were referred for adjudication to the Industrial Tribunal by nine reference orders on various dates between April to December 1959.
273 280/62 .
November 14, 1963.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by WANCHOO J. These nine appeals by special leave arise out of the awards of the Industrial Tribunal, Bombay and will be dealt with together.
