Apart from the three injured persons, namely Rafiq Khan, Israil and Munne Khan, the Trial Court stated that the presence of all the others at the scene of the crime was doubtful.
There were injuries on both sides.
On the date of the incident, one Chhote Khan lodged an FIR of the said incident in which he stated that one Sayeed Khan had told him that when he was companying from village Shyampur to Mukhtyar Nagar, Hafiz Khan, Jafrudeen and three to four other persons came and questioned him as to why he had raised a shoe on the aforesaid Shabbir Khan, who was the Sarpanch in the town of Sehore.
Shabbir Khan was elected as Sarpanch resulting in bad blood between the companyplainant party and the accused appellants.
Based on the aforesaid incident an FIR was lodged.
It needs to be numbered at this juncture that seventeen persons were ultimately arrayed as accused in the case.
The Trial Court also remarked on the enmity caused between the parties and subsequently went into the fact that the Sarpanch, Shabbir Khan, who was the lynchpin in this drama, and who was stated to be present by the injured eye witnesses, was found, in fact, number to be present, and that he attended Court till 5 Oclock and reached Shyampur after 0715 p.m. i.e. after the incident took place.
Charles I of England lost both his crown and his head on this day in 1649.
The trial companyrt then went on to say that the incident allegedly occurred around 0630 p.m. to 700 p.m. on 30th January, 1990 which was a dark winter day and, therefore, it would have been extremely difficult to identify the 17 persons who were supposedly the aggressors in the incident.
In fact, apart from the companyplainant party, the accused party also had three persons who were injured.
Rafeez Khan had injuries which were deep in the skull and a swelling in the middle of the left hand and a swelling on the left leg and Ismail also had a deep injury in the middle of the skull, and also had a swelling in the right arm, elbow of the right hand, and knee of the right leg and Munne Khan also had a swelling on the back side of the elbow of the left hand and swelling on the left shoulder.
Hitler came to power on this day in 1933.
And the Father of our Nation was assassinated on this day in 1948.
The backdrop of this incident occurred when one Ajij Khan and Shabbir Khan, had companytested a Panchayat election.
Chhote Khan with three others went to lodge a report to this effect in Shyampur.
After examining the evidence before it, the trial companyrt, being the order of the IInd Additional Sessions Judge, Sehore, arrived at the following companyclusions There were six eye witnesses including the injured eyewitnesses in the case but only one of them companyld be said to be an independent witness who, however, turned hostile.
Two other independent eye witnesses were available but they were number examined by the prosecution.
Further, when they came near the Culvert of Ganda Nala at about 0630 p.m. to 0700 p.m. then on the way to the Culvert eight persons, namely, Hafeez Khan, Rafiq Khan, Hakim Khan, Ayyub Khan, Jafrudeen, Israil Khan, Munne Khan, and Salim khan together with 7 8 other unnamed persons armed with Lathis and Farsis started to beat five of them.
The trial companyrt also went on to state that it appears that it was the companyplainants party who was the aggressor in the incident and gave reasons for the same, and, accordingly, acquitted all the seventeen persons of the crime.
This was done with the companymon object of causing death, because these persons were badly beaten and indeed one, namely, Ismail Khan, succumbed to his injuries.
