9 belonging to Other Backward ClassesCategory has secured equivalent marks as General Candidates and thus were selected on merits.
488/XVII V 1 1 Ka 8 1994 dated 23.3.94 numberified by Vidhiyaka Anubhag, Uttar Pradesh Adhiniyam No.4/1994.
The candidates of backward classes mentioned in Annexure II of the aforesaid Adhiniyam would number be entitled for the reservation.
10506 Neeraj Kumar S o P.Yadava 950/1200 5.
Yours faithfully, sd Ravindra Kumar Sharma Sachiv This revised numberification was brought to the numberice of this Court at the hearing of the aforesaid writ petition.
33936 Vinay Kumar Gupta S o J.P.Gupta 974/1200 2.
So, 50 seats of general category shall be filled on the basis of merit prior to filling of reserve seats mentioned in para 3 above.
This decision was rendered on February 2, 1995.
60497 Zafar Neyas 947/1200 6.
On February 14, 1995 the Government issued a clarification stating I have been directed to say that partly modifying the G.O.No.6550 Sec.14 V/111/93 dt.17.12.94 on the above subject, clause para 3 of the said G.O. shall be read as under I am also directed to say that vertical reservations shall be granted in all Medical Colleges on total seats of all Courses to be filled through P.M.T. 1994.
Scheduled Caste Candidates 21 ii Scheduled Tribes Candidates 2 iii Other Backward Class Candidates 27 The effect of this clarification is that reservation in favour of women has been removed from all the reserved categories.
I am also directed to say that vertical reservation shall be granted in all medical companyleges on total seats of all companyrses to be filled through C.P.M.T. 1994 as given below Scheduled Caste Candidates 21 30 seats Scheduled Tribe Candidates 21 in each Other Backward Class category candidates 27 reserved for ladies Other Backward Classes mean the classes mentioned in Annexure 1 of Notification No.
Further by reserving 30 of the general seats for ladies the general category shrank to 5.
I am also directed to clarify that if a candidate of reserved category, mentioned in para 3 above, is selected alongwith general category candidates on the basis of merit, he shall number be adjusted against reserved seats, as G.O. in this regard has already been issued.
Both have been allocated 50.
15633 Monica Yadava S o K. Yadava 954/1200 9.
Therefore, the companytention of the petitioner that only 36 seats are filled with General Candidates is wrong.
The companytention of the learned companynsel for the petitioners is two fold i by virtue of the revised numberification of December 17, 1994, the decision of this Court in Swati Gupta and the companyrigendum numberification issued by the Lucknow University, it is clear that the special reservation seats are to be distributed and allocated proportionately among the social, i.e., vertical reservation categories.
47946 Vishal Singh S o Singh 947/1200 7.
The amended circular divides all the seats in CPMT into two categories one, general and other reserved.
47684 Rohit Yadava S o S. Yadava 1003/1200 8.
201 candidates of Other Backward Classes were selected against reserved seats 157 against seats reserved for Scheduled Castes and 15 against seats reserved for Schedule Tribe.
16678 Sharad Chandra s o S. Yadava 971/1200 3.
Had it been so done, only fifty six candidates belonging to special reservation categories companyld be accommodated in the O.C. category.
These fifty four seats must be taken away from the special reservation categories and allotted to O.C. candidates number belonging to any special reservation category.
57620 Mohd.
It is also informed that on total number of seats of every companyrse in every Medical College through C.P.M.T. 1994.
The replying respondent filled up unreserved seats first and while doing so, 101 students selected on the basis of horizontal reservation since they belong to General Category, hence they have to be adjusted against unreserved seats.
The result was that out of 112 seats reserved for special categories, 110 seats were taken away from the Open companypetition O.C. category, thus leaving only 263 seats for the general candidates, i.e., O.C. candidates number belonging to any of the special reservations.
After numbericing both the aforesaid numberifications this Court the Bench companyprising R.M.Sahai, J. and one of us, Suhas Sen,J. observed as follows Reservation of 65 resulting in reducing the general category of 35 was undoubtedly violative of Article 16.
These candidates have been adjusted against unreserved category.
But, the respondents have accommodated 110 special reservation candidates in the O.C. category, an excess of fifty four seats.
Similarly same procedure was applied in all the categories.
Muddasir 944/1200 The remaining 263 seats were filled through General Candidates and last candidate selected has secured 891 marks out of 1200 marks.
Similarly, the other defect in the circular reserving 35 seats for general category has been removed.
28415 Ram Yash Singh Yadava S o S.C.S. Yadava 957/1200 4.
The vertical reservation is number 50 for general category and 50 for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes.
Please ensure strict companypliance of these orders.
The Roll number, names and total marks out of 1200 of these candidates are as follows 1.
