Kupala Obul Reddy the vendee from the wife Venkata Lakshmamma, filed a suit in the District Munsiffs Court Cuddapah being suit No.A 5 may be set out Exchange deed dated 20th Jan, 1961 for the value of property worth Rs.
The facts material for the purposes of this appeal may be set out.
This gift deed which is Exh.
These properties are included in Schedule B to the plaint.
Bimala Venkata Lakshmamma wife of Yella Reddy belonging to village Chinna Kudala in Pulivendala Taluq.
200/ belongs to Yella Reddy and the B Schedule property worth Rs.
It appears that the married life of Venkata lakshamamma with her husband Yella Reddy was number happy and disputes had arisen between them and ultimately Venkata Lakshamamma left her husband Yella Reddy and remarried.
This daughter Nagamma had a daughter Venkata Lakshamamma.
At the time when Thimma Reddy executed the deed of gift dated 8.11.1930, her son Yella Reddy was minor and had number been married.
Nearly thirty years after the execution of the gift deed by Thimma Reddy, Naramma in whose favour deed of gift was executed by Thimma Reddy, executed a deed of gift on 10.10.1960 in favour of Venkata Lakshmamma, her grand daughter as well as her daughter in law.
It, however, appears that Yella Reddy under a sale deed dated 2.7.1962 sold to Bonala Venpata Narayana Reddy, the defendant in the suit and the original respondent in the appeal, since deceased, number represented by his legal representatives, all the properties in Schedule A including the properties in Schedule B which were retained by Venkafa Lakshmamma and which she subsequently sold to the appellant Kuppala Obul Reddy.
The sale deed dated 20.7.1963 by Venkata Lakshmamma in respect of B Schedule properties in favour of the appellant Kuppala Obul Reddy is Exh.
500/ and handed over the same to you.
On the 8th November, 1930, Thimma Reddy executed a deed of gift in respect of the properties mentioned in the deed.
500/ by Bonala Thimmareddi, son of Pedda Yellareddi, of Chinnakudala Village in favour of Bonala Naramma, wife of Thimmareddi of Chinnakudala village.
You are my senior wife and you have got a minor son by name YeJlareddi.
After Thimma Reddy had married for the second time, the first wife Naramrna had apprehended that she might be neglected and she had expressed her unhappiness and apprehension as to her future and the future of her son Yella Reddy.
This document which was exhibited in the suit being Exh.
On 20.7.1963 Venkata Lakshmamma sold to the appellant the properties which were retained by her out of the properties gifted to her by Naramma after exchange of a part of the properties with her husband Yella Reddy.
We have executed this exchange deed by companysent Thumb impression of Bimala Yellareddy, Thumb impression of Bimala Venakata Lakshmamma.
As the second of us has numberhouse, we have decided to exchange the lands belonging to second B Schedule for the house A Schedule belonging to first of us and the transfer is thus affected.
As a result of this deed of exchange, part of the properties gifted to Venkata Lakshmamma under the deed of gift dated 10.10.1960 executed by Naramma, was given to Yella Reddy and part of the house properties which belonged to Yella Reddy came to Venkata Lakshmamma.
200/ by Bimala Yella Reddy, son of Thimma Reddy.
over the property and you should enjoy the property in your own right.
10th Oct. 1960 executed by Bimala Naramma wife of Thimma Reddi in favour of Bimala Venkata Lakshmamma, wife of Yellareddy.
Out of love and affection to wares you, I hereby make a gift of property worth Rs.
Further, you are my daughter Nagammas daughter and thereby my grand daughter.
I have got a junior wife.
This deed of gift is executed of my own accord.
By the junior wife Bonala Thimma Reddy had numberchild.
of Cuddapah had two wives, Bonala Naramma was the senior wife and by this wife Bonala Thimma Reddy had a son Bonala Yella Reddy and a daughter Nagamma.
The A Schedule property worth Rs.
200/ belongs to Venkata Lakshmamma.
500/ belonging to me with all rights and handover the possessission to you the same day.
Since number, you and your successors have full rights of sale, gift etc.
Since number, we have to pay the taxes on the exchanged properties and have rights of sale and gift and all other rights.
One Bonala Thimma Reddi of village Chinna Kudala in Palivendala Taluk in the Distt.
Since number you enjoy the property with absolute rights.
As you are companyplaining that I am showing better affection over my junior wife and number treating you properly and you wanted me to show a living for you and the minor son, out of affection to you I hereby make the gift of the schedule property worth Rs.
A 2 in the suit, is in the following terms Gift deed dt.
This Exchange deed dated 20.1.1961 Exh.
As the properties which had been sold by Venkata Lakshmamma to the appellant Kuppala Obul Reddy, had earlier been sold by her husband Yella Reddy to the respondent Bonala Venpata Narayana Reddy, since deceased, disputes naturally arose between Kupala Obul Reddy and Venpata Narayana Reddy with regard to ownership and possession of these properties.
A 6, reads as follows Gift deed executed for property worth Rs.
A II in the suit.
Venkata Lakshamamma, the daughter of Nagamma and the grand daughter of Thimma Reddy and Naramma, was married to Yella Reddy, son of Nagamma.
By this deed Naramma gifted away all the properties given to her by her husband under the deed of gift dated 8.11.1930 and after this gift deed had been executed by Naramma in favour of Venkata Lakshmamma, a deed of exchange was executed by and between Venkata Lakshmamma and her husband Yella Reddy on 20 1 1961.
Amarendra Nath Sen, J. This appeal has been preferred by the plaintiff in the suit with leave granted by this Court against the judgment and decree of the High Court of Judicature of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad delivered on 23.9.1969 dismissing the suit of the plaintiff by affirming the judgment and the decree of the Lower Appellate Court which had reversed the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court.
You are my son Yellareddys wife and thereby my daughter in law.
