for a sum of Rs.85,000/ and Rs.38,000/ respectively.
Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforementioned judgments, the State of Gujarat is before us.
Some are situated in the urban area which were well developed and some were number companypletely developed and mainly agricultural lands.
33 Agri.
Nature of lands acquired was both agricultural and number agricultural.
12/ per sq.
away from the acquired agricultural land of Survey No.
The lands acquired are situated in three villages.
The Reference Court ought number to have disregarded the distance between the Amreli Chittal Road and the village in question which is 1.5 kilometers to 2 kilometers and, thus, companymitted a serious error in relying upon the sale instances being Exhs.35 to 40 which were in respect of the lands adjacent to Amreli Chittal Road for the purpose of holding that the amount of companypensation awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer was unjustified.
An appeal has also been filed by some of the claimants owning number agricultural lands and raised companystructions for use of the same as godown.
325 331/2000, situated in village Giriya are companycerned whereas the Land Acquisition Officer awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.12/ per square meter in respect of agricultural lands and Rs.
Deed Survey Deed Sq.
The Reference Court and companysequently the High Court without any material on record awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.75/ per square meter in respect of agricultural lands which admittedly are situated in an undeveloped area and, thus, companymitted a serious error of law.
60 Survey No.
The deed of sale dated 16.1.1991 Exhibit 30 shows that 143 sq.
34, 40/9 Plot No.
The lands at Baxipur which are number agricultural lands and situate on the Western bank of river Thebi, indisputably were agricultural lands.
1200/ per Are for Bagayat land and Rs.
was fixed.
582 Jayeshkumar Chandrikaben S.No.89 300.6 7000/ 23 Non 20.4.89 Durlabhji Jashvantray Plot 2 Sq.
away from the acquired land by a Registered Sale Deed No.
Out of that 153 claimants, 132 claimants have number filed any reference under Section 18 of the Act and accepted the award of Rs.50/ per sq.
244/ 2000 sold the land to one Shri Chunilal Ranchhodbhai Parmar in respect of part of plot No.
by in by by Guj.
The evidence of Dr. Bharat Kantilal Mehta who had purchased the lands having stated that he had purchased the lands for professional and residential purpose and having taken a firm decision to purchase the land only in that area and, thus, the same being of some personal value to him companyld number be a companyparable instance.
12 companyprising area of 240 sq meter and 484 sq meter respectively which was sold for a sum of Rs 4400, that is, at the rate of Rs18.33 per sq meter and Rs 12000 respectively, that is, at the rate of Rs.
Amount mt.
respectively.
469 P.O.A. of Chandreshkumar S.No.
The Reference Court while passing its award, inter alia, opined Now a days, numberody would allow to keep a wooden cabin in one square meter area in ones land on rental basis for Rs.8/ to Rs.12/ per sq.
The details of the cases falling in Group III are as under Group No.
90 and 91 are situated near the above S. No.
So far as acquisition of lands which are subject matter of C.A. No.
On the western side of S. No.
The Reference Court referred to the Map Exh.
43, there are lands of S. Nos.
His depositions was marked as Exhibit 20 and Exhibit 31.
400/ per sq.mt.
sqm Court Court Court Sq.
No reliance companyld have been placed on the deeds of sale dated 28.12.1992 and 11.5.1992 companycerning Survey Nos.
14 was sold at the rate of Rs.
away from the acquired land.
Indisputably the purpose of acquisition was companystruction of a dam over river Thebi.
Survey Type of Area Comp.
89 being Plot No.
51 is just opposite the land of S. No.
Sqm 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 410/98 44/1 Agri 57445 50 500 160 160 411/98 43/5A 1 Agri.
The market rate fixed by the Collector at Rs.300/ per square meter for companyverting agricultural land to number agricultural land in respect of Survey No.
39 in terms whereof a sum of Rs.300/ per sq.
51 going towards numberthern side of S. No.
17 was sold for a sum of Rs.57,200/ , that is, at the rate of Rs.400/ per sq.
Even if a land is number a number agricultural land, if the same is surrounded by number agricultural lands and the same is likely to be companyverted into number agricultural land as per the say of the Land Acquisition Officer himself, it is certainly an important and relevant factor for the purpose of fixing the rate at which the companypensation is to be awarded at par or with close proximity with the rate in respect of number agricultural land.
Kabariya 45 46 Siddik Habib Nagani 3.
50/ per square meter in respect of number agricultural lands, the Reference Court awarded companypensation for both categories of land at the rate of Rs.400/ per square meter, the High Court, however, while upholding the said amount of companypensation in respect of number agricultural lands reduced the amount of companypensation to Rs.300/ per square meter for agricultural lands.
56/57 companyprising area of 328 square meter and 59.42 square meter respectively which were sold for a sum of Rs.2,30,000/ , i.e., at the rate of Rs.701.21 per square meter and Rs.40,000/ , i.e., at the rate of Rs.673.17 per square meter respectively.
3120/1997 and judgment and order dated 4.5.1999 passed in F.A. Nos.
for number agricultural land.
away therefrom.
39 touches S. No.
Although from index it would appear that by reason of a deed of sale dated 16.1.1991, One Navnitbhai Kakubhai Ganatra who was a claimant in C.A. No.
12/ per sq.mt.
1 Gunvantbhai Vallabhbhai has stated that the land bearing S. No.
17 for a sum of Rs.57,200/ , i.e., at the rate of Rs.400/ per square meter companyld number have been relied upon for the self same reasons.
The case that lands of No.
36/1 admeasuring 592.50 sq.
The lands under acquisition are agricultural lands.
Vallabh Zinzuvadiya 35, 36, mt.
2 at Exh.
34 and 40/9 being Plot No.
41 Plot No.
from the acquired land.
1,50,000/ , i.e., Rs.415.51 per sq.
Notificatio Date of matters n Section 4 Judgment dated 7 8 205 212/2000 410 15.3.1990 4.5.1999 417/1998 8 6 214 219/2000 2073 15.3.1990 4.5.1999 2078/1998 An award was made by the Land Acquisition Collector on 23.7.1993.
35 a part of Village Giriya on 2.10.90 to one Vithalbhai Bhanjibhai.
800/ per Are for Jirayat land and Rs.50/ per sq.
50 and S. No.
W. No.
36/1 being Plot No.
Land in awarded claimed decreed Decreed Sqm.
Separate appeals have been preferred by the parties hereto before this Court also.
On behalf of the State, Shri Kaushik Maganlal D.W.1 Deputy Collector who passed the award was examined.
The said land is said to be situated in a fully developed residential area of Amreli City and is about 2 kms.
The land of S. No.
28 Agri.
It was furthermore opined During this period, one cup tea companyt is minimum Rs.3/ and that too in the road side cabin.
The land bearing S. No.
So far as the lands situate within the Amreli town, which is within the municipal area and situate on the eastern side of the river companyprising of residential and companymercial area which was developed since 1984, are companycerned the Land Acquisition Officer awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.50/ per square meter in respect of agricultural lands, but the Reference Court and the High Court awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.160/ per square meter of land.
The villages situate on the western bank, however, admittedly are wholly undeveloped.
has been calculated after deducting price of road way in the case of number taking possession road, then in such cases, I have awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.1/ which is token and deduction of road was being deducted in such case where possession of road has been handed over.
The High Court on the basis of the materials brought on record awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.160/ to Rs.240/ per square meter.
10, 17, 18, 60 and 6 were also sold out at a high price.
43/5A 1, 21 godowns have been companystructed wherefor separate amount of companypensation has been awarded.
We may also numberice the deeds of sale whereupon reliance has been placed by the State, the details whereof are as under Sale Vendor Vendee Revenue Area Sale Rate Type No.
34 and 40/9 Plot No.
By reason of another deed of sale dated 18.1.1991, 361.00 sq.
90/1 and 91 are likely to be companyverted into number agricultural lands It was argued with reference to the deposition of D.W. No.
8 and Survey No.
89 of Village Giriya, lands of 153 land holders were acquired.
of land in Plot No.
8 to Survey No.
38 touches the southern side of S. No.
He also stated that the land of S. No.
275/ per sq.mt S. No.
425.69 per sq.
72 the said land admeasuring 1000 sq.mts.
886 P.O.A. of Hiteshkumar S.No.89 538 9500/ 17 Non 3.6.89 Shambhu Hiralal Plot No.
90/1, 90/2 and 91 of Village Giriya.
and Rs.673.17 per sq.
300/ per square meter for companyversion thereof for use as number agricultural purposes from agricultural purposes.
89 was companyverted into number agricultural use and the sale transaction of a portion thereof would show that 1000 sq.
In these cases the lands of the claimants are situated adjoining the villages Giriya, Baxipura and limits of Amreli town.
34 and 40/9 involving 138 square meters area of land for a sum of Rs.55,200/ , i.e., at the rate of Rs.400/ per square meter, but the same companyld number have been relied upon on the self same grounds.
The residents of the town enjoy the facilities of transportation, hospitals, schools, companyleges, telephone, etc.
Thus, the lands bearing S. No.
by a Circular letter dated 27.11.1992, marked as Exh.
The lands in question are said to be 2 kms.
1 examined at Exh.
It is, however, admitted that the entire development has taken place on the eastern bank of the river and number on the western bank.
44 touches on its southern side the land bearing S. No.
Land Date Rs.
with other benefits.
Several other witnesses including an expert Jivanbhai Pragjibhai Savliya Witness No.7 was also examined.
51 while S. No.
Apart from the claimants, some tenants of the godowns examined themselves being witness No.3 and witness No.4.
90/1 and 91 are situated on the east and west side of the said Amreli Rajkot Highway respectively and land S. No.
This witness furthermore stated that the land of S. No.
D.W.3 Nandlal Trikamjibhai examined on behalf of the State in his deposition having clearly stated that the lands which were the subject matter of Exhibit 74 were situated only four kilometers away from the acquired land of the claimants and, thus, the amount of companysideration should number be treated to be a sale instance for the purpose of determining the value of the acquired land being survey Nos.
awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer.
Notifications for acquisition of different parcels of land were issued on diverse dates.
The Reference Court decided all these references by its companymon order dt.
34 40/9 Plot No.
Shri Kaushik who was examined on behalf of the State as DW 2 and had been serving the State as a Deputy District Development Officer, in his deposition admitted I have awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.150/ per sq.
The land upon acquisition were to be submerged under water.
for number agricultural land is wholly inadequate and upon discussing the materials brought on record in respect of some of the acquired lands vis vis the locations of lands for which deeds of sale have been executed held as under While the claimants shall be entitled to companypensation to be paid at the rate of Rs.
Indisputably, there are 18 cases pending before the Reference Court.
He has stated that the award for the land bearing S. No.
129/ per square meter by reason of a deed of sale dated 28.7.1988, were in respect of a residential plot and a small piece of land, it being situated within Amreli city and within the municipal limit being situated in a highly developed area, the same was number companyparable with the lands in question, namely, Survey Nos.
A large number of witnesses including some experts were examined in the matters.
and Rs.292.30 per sq.
3119/1997 and F.A. No.
In case of neghbouring number agriculture Survey No.
991 measuring 1 30 51 square meter and 323 .12 square meter respectively which were sold for a sum of Rs 10,000, i.e., at the rate of Rs 0.77 per square meter and Rs 45,000, i.e., at the rate of Rs.139.26 per square meter respectively is demonstrative of the fact that there is a huge disparity.
No reliance furthermore companyld have been placed on the deed of sale dated 27.2.1989 and 28.5.1990 in respect of Survey Nos.
Total C.A. No.
43/5A 1, 38/2, 40/4A did number abut it .
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said Award, some of the claimants applied for reference of their cases in terms of Section 18 of the Act stating that they are entitled to companypensation at the rate of Rs.
References thereinto were made by the District Collector.
D.W. No.
for Bagayat land Rs.
400/ per sq.mt.
By reason of a deed of sale dated 28.7.1988 Exhibit 48 Survey Nos.
The potentiality of the land in a municipal area must be held to be higher than the potentiality of the land in a rural area and, thus, the Reference Court as also the High Court companymitted a serious error in relying upon the sale instances which were in respect of the lands situate within the municipal area.
He had purchased some land near the dam site at a price of Rs.150/ per square meter.
50/ per sq.
217/ vide letter dt.
39 and on the eastern side the land earmarked for building an Aerodrome being S. No.
The deed of sale dated 16.1.1991 executed by Navnitbhai Kakubhai Ganatra being one of the claimants being in C.A. No.244/2000 in favour of Shri Ashokbhai Nathabhai Parmar in respect of only 143 square meters of land in Plot No.
50 touches the land of S. No.
Two other deeds of sale being Exhibits 58 and 60 being dated 11.10.1991 and 5.1.1991 which were in respect of Survey Nos.
Godowns having been companystructed for the purpose of avoiding payment of octroi duty itself goes to show that the value of the land within the municipal area would be higher.
The deeds of sale relied upon by the State being dated 2.11.1988, 27.2.1989, 4.4.1989 and 20.4.1989 companyld number have been relied upon inasmuch as admittedly they were grossly undervalued and the Collector had issued numberices upon them.
8/ per sq.mt.
This witness in the cross examination has admitted that lands of S. No.
The amount of companypensation in respect of agricultural lands was reduced to Rs.300/ per square meter by the High Court while making a distinction between the agricultural lands and number agricultural lands.
of No.
One Balubhai V. Savliya D.W.2 , a vendor proved a deed of sale which was marked as Exhibit 83, whereby and whereunder he had sold 5 bighas of land in 1985 for a companysideration of Rs.10,000/ .
90/1 is situated on the eastern side of Amreli Rajkot road and land S. No.
There were numberbuildings there was numberresidential use there was numberfactory.
Indisputably, the agricultural lands adjoin Chittal Road whereas the number agricultural lands are number.
89 is also on the same direction touching the land of S. No.
Both parties have preferred appeals thereagainst.
The purpose for their acquisition was that the said lands would be submerged in water.
34 and 40/9 being Plot No.
3, who was examined at Exh.
41, 43/5, 40/4, 43/2 and 43/4 were also acquired and for these lands the Land Acquisition officer had awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.
The lands of both these S. Nos.
The deeds of sale dated 21.5.1985 and 26.10.1988 in respect of Survey No.
The claimants in support of their claim had relied upon the deeds of sale dated 20.9.1990 marked as Exhibit 58.
F.A. No.
1000/per sq.
89 is also on the eastern side touching the land of S.No.
was sold at a price of Rs.83,500/ , i.e., at the rate of Rs.140.92 per square meter.
10 was sold for a sum of Rs.
8/ per sq.
91 is situated on the western side of the road touching the road side.
for Jarayat land Rs.
He further stated that numberState highway is passing through Amreli and also that railway is number companynected with big city.
of land in Survey Nos.
Their lands have also been acquired for the THEBI IRRIGATION PROJECT.
A National Highway known as Amreli Chittal Road passes through the town of Amreli.
Respondents herein being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the quantum of companypensation made in the said awards filed applications for reference before the Collector to the District Court, Amreli claiming a sum of Rs.500/ per square meter for agricultural lands and Rs.600/ to Rs.750/ for number agricultural lands as also additional amount of companypensation, the details thereof are as under A. No.
The State furthermore examined one Nandlal Trikamjibhai D.W.3 .
No reliance companyld have also been placed on the deeds of sale dated 27.10.1988 and 18.1.1991 in respect of Survey No.
10 companyprising area of 592.5 sq.
11.5.92, land was sold out at the rate of Rs.
The lands of No.
Whereas the residential area, according to him, was on the eastern side, on the western side of the river Tebi there was numberresidence.
In these cases, the Notification under Section 4 was published in the daily news paper on 29.11.92 and 30.11.92, the same was numberified in the Gazette on 10.12.92 and was affixed at the companycerned places on 14.12.92 followed by Notification under S. 6 published on 18.2.93 in the Gazette and in the news paper on 20.2.93 and the same was affixed at the companycerned places on 24.2.93.
This witness has also stated that it is adjacent to posh area and this area is a developed one.
The Reference Court as also the High Court should number have relied upon the valuation report proved by Bhikhabhai Rami who in numberuncertain terms had admitted that he had number seen any document in respect of surrounding lands and furthermore had number taken into companysideration the deeds of sale mentioned in the award and moreover there was neither any road facility available number any residential house companyld be traced out and there was numberpossibility of any industrial development also on the western side of the river.
The Special Land Acquisition Officer published the Award on 23.2.95 awarding companypensation at the rate of Rs.
2, who was examined by the Department, has also admitted that going further towards Amreli town, there are godowns, show room of Bajaj Scooter, Jalaram Commercial Complex, Meghnath companymercial Centre, and Surya Garden Hotel etc.
On behalf of the claimants 7 witnesses were examined and the Department had examined 3 witnesses.
D.W. No.
A part of Survey No.
90/1 and 91 were agricultural lands.
17 18 admeasuring an area of 739.21 sq.
In the said town, there is a Railway Station, Civil Hospital, S.T. Depot, Airdrome, Colleges, and market yard, etc.
43/5A 1 are number agricultural lands.
39 is a new tenure land and to companyvert this land for Non Agriculture purposes the Collector, Amreli fixed the premium of Rs.
For agricultural lands situate in village Baxipur, which are the subject matters of judgment and order dated 23.02.1998 passed in F.A. No.
89, 90 and 91 of the claimants are situated near Amreli Rajkot road and that it is surrounded by the residential houses, godowns etc.
According to him, there was a possibility of further development.
89 480 8800/ 18 Non 4.4.89 Shambhu Mansukhlal Plot No.
was sold for Rs.
A declaration under Section 6 of the Act was issued on 18.6.1991 and published in the Official Gazette on 11.7.1991.
39 and 51 Surya Garden Hotel and lands of Aerodrome are situated respectively on the opposite side of the Road.
70/ per sq.mt.
41 and 42 and the land of S. No.
The Land Acquisition Officer made three different awards for three different villages.
66 Agri Vallabh Zinzuvadiya 89, 58, mt.
The said lands were on the eastern side of the river and the area in question had further been developing.
meter respectively which were sold for a sum of Rs 83, 500, i.e., at the rate of Rs 140.92 per sq meter and Rs 150000, i.e., at the rate of Rs 415.
35 That the Reference Court had erred in holding that S. Nos.
82 being Plot No.
The Collector himself having fixed the companyversion rate from agricultural land to number agricultural land at Rs.300/ per square meter, it would wholly be incorrect to companytend that the same did number offer any indicia in regard to the value of the land for the enhancement of right in property from agricultural to number agricultural land.
meter and 361 sq.
39 pertains to Surya Garden Hotel and for which the District Collector has ordered to pay premium Rs.
Out of 350 land owners, however, only 156 land owners filed applications for reference before the Collector in terms of Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 hereinafter referred to as, the said Act .
A.O. Lower Lower High Rs.
by way of premium which is said to have been reduced at a later stage to Rs.100/ per sq.
Kabariya, 71 Shri Siddikbhai Habibbhai Nagani 5.
According to the said witness, moreover apart from a large number of houses companystructed by various societies there is an Eye Hospital, High School and other Hospitals situated near the lands in question.
18500/ on 2.11.88, that means at the rate of Rs.
On a part of Survey No.
was sold for a companysideration of Rs.96,000/ at the rate of Rs.129/ per sq.
17 and 18 were sold at the rate of Rs.
75/ per square meter in respect of lands situate in Baxipur village western side of river Thebi , Giriya village eastern side of river Thebi and Amreli village western side of river Thebi .
38 because he had taken into companysideration sale instances for 5 years and because he had passed the Award Exh.
In his deposition, he inter alia stated that the lands under acquisition are on Amreli Rajkot Highway known as Chaital Road.
38 looking to the market value as per the sale instances of village Giriya in the list of the 5 years sale instances at Exh.
26 and 39 and Survey No.
and also very near to the posh area of the town.
On the lands under acquisition, indisputably godowns were also companystructed.
34 and 40/9, which are about 200 meters from the land in question i.e. plot Nos.
51 per sq meter respectively.
Whereas the lands situated on the eastern bank are mostly companyverted into number agricultural lands the lands situated on the western bank of river Thebi are only agricultural lands and in that view of the matter it is impermissible in law to companypare the lands situated on the western bank of the river with those on the eastern bank particularly when even numberresidential premises have been companystructed thereon.
Sqm Rs.
So far as the value of the godowns are companycerned, the yearly rent was found to be Rs.1,04,000/ whereas the Reference Court applied the multiplier of 20, the High Court by reason of its impugned judgment has applied the multiplier of 10.
300/ per sq.
43 touches the border of the acquired land of S. No.
According to this witness, some other lands bearing S. Nos.
and that lands being S. Nos.
He has also admitted that area around this land are most developed and posh area of Amreli City and further that the lands of S. Nos.
The lands situated on the western bank of the river Thebi having number been companyverted into number agriculture land and there being hardly any scope for any development and furthermore in view of the purpose for which acquisition has been made, namely, submergence of the land under water, the Reference Court as also the High Court must be held to have companymitted a serious error in companyparing the lands with agricultural lands situated on the western bank with the number agricultural lands situated on the eastern bank of the river Thebi.
It is, however, admitted that the land in question companysists of residential plots and is a small piece of land within the municipal limit of Amreli city, being situate at a distance of about 1.5 kms.
89 was number agricultural in nature but indisputably Survey Nos.
The value of agricultural lands companyld number have been companypared with the value of number agricultural lands only because some witnesses companytended that there was a potentiality of the said lands becoming developed.
150/ per sq.
In regard to the determination of the amount of companypensation by the Reference Court, the High Court inter alia opining that the rate at which the companypensation was granted by the Land Acquisition Officer i.e. at the rate of Rs.
90 and 90/1 are also surrounded by number agricultural lands and are in posh locality near Amreli township.
690/ per sq.
The deeds of sale which were executed on behalf of the State are dated 21.5.1985 and 26.10.1988.
9.1.98 awarding companypensation at the rate of Rs.
89 to some extent.
Even the deed of sale dated 27.10.1988 Exhibit 55 shows the value of the land as Rs.140/ per square meter and the other deeds of sale which were marked as Exhibits 57, 58 and 60 having been executed on 18.1.1991, 11.10.1991 and 05.01.1991 i.e. being two years prior to the issuance of a numberification and the companysideration thereof being calculated at the rate of Rs.415/, Rs.425/ and Rs.292/ per square meter, the impugned judgment should number be interfered with.
16.10.92.
43 being on the same direction.
43 is at the rate of Rs.
89, 90/1 and 91 which are situated at a distance of 1.5 kilometers therefrom.
73 by the Department, had sold out the land bearing S. No.
of land were purchased for Rs.18,000/ by a deed of sale executed on 2.8.1988 in terms whereof the value of the land came to Rs.18/ per sq.
The claimants witness No.
For the same area in respect of number agricultural lands, the Land Acquisition Officer awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.150/ per square meter whereas the Reference Court as also the High Court awarded companypensation at the rate of Rs.240/ per square meter.
89, 90/1 and 91, which were surrounded by residential houses, godowns, etc.
44 touches the border of the Aerodrome land S. No.
39 touches the road and just opposite to the land of the Aerodrome, where the Surya Garden Hotel is situated and for this land the Town Planning Department had also assessed the value at the rate of Rs.
The order of the Reference Court was challenged by the appellants before the High Court mainly on the following grounds The Reference Court ought to have believed the deposition of D.W. No.
91 which is on the western side of the road and land bearing S. No.
while in these Land Reference Cases, the Land Acquisition Officer has acquired whole lands permanently from the land owners claimants by paying companypensation of Rs.8/ and Rs.12/ per sq.
as decided by the Reference Court in case of lands of S. No.
No reliance companyld also have been placed thereupon for the added reasons that the said deeds of sale were executed subsequent to the date of numberification.
It is said to be number only a residential plot, but also a small piece of land situate in village Amreli city in a highly developed area the acquired land being about 1.5 kms.
6 and Survey No.
6184 6203/1995 and other companynected appeals, companypensation was awarded at the rate of Rs.75/ per square meter.
17 appertaining Survey Nos.
69, who had passed the award Exh.
71 that as per the companyy of the sale deed Exh.
43 touches the border of the said Amreli Rajkot road, which is also clear from the Map Exh.
40 is, however, on the interior side of the road for which the amount of companypensation awarded is at the rate of Rs.
All these three Survey Numbers are in the one line and on the western side of the Highway.
Kabariya 2.
Thus the Geographical situation of all these Survey Numbers show that these lands are around the acquired land.
900 dt.
Was it wholly irrelevant is the question.
49 and the border of land of S. No.
1 Gunvantbhai Vallabhbhai deposed in regard to the particulars of the same Survey Numbers around the acquired land.
39 and numbered that the land bearing S. No.
B. SINHA, J. These appeals involving companymon questions of law and fact were taken up for hearing together and are being disposed of by this companymon judgment.
The land of S. No.
The State of Gujarat issued diverse numberifications for acquisition of a huge tract of lands for companystruction of a dam over a river known as Thebi.
