July, 1980 Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Information Broadcasting when he dealt number only the Broadcasting Media, namely, AIR and Doordarshan but also the Information Media, viz.
In the present case respondent No.
October, 1983 Appointed as Additional Secretary to the Government of India and posted as Secretary, UPSC.
Before the expiry of the said period of six months.
The authorities companycerned took recourse to make the appointment to the post by transfer on deputation.
August 1972 to Secretary to Chief Minister, Govern ment January, 1973 of West Bengal.
With effect from October, 1983 he was holding the post of Additional Secretary to the Government of India.
Film Documentaries, Press, Advertising and Visual Publicity.
2 was duly qualified having regard to the fact that he had to his credit 29 years of administrative experience and had held such senior posi tions as Joint Secretary in charge of State level Plan in the Planning Commission, Additional Chief Secretary and Chief Secretary in the Gov ernment of Manipur, Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.
i.e. in July August, 1985, the authorities companycerned companysidered the proposals for companytinued appointment of Shri Suresh Mathur for a further period of two years.
2 which is due to expire on March 3, 1987 was invalid, and 2 that the respondent No.
2 as Director General, All India Radio was assailed by respondent No.
2 Shri Suresh Mathur who was of the rank of Additional Secretary to the Government of India and was Secretary, Union Public Service Commission at the material time, was appointed by transfer on deputation for six months.
2 was number qualified for being appointed by transfer on deputation to the said post as per the rules.
This order of companytinuation of respondent No.
2 companying to an end on March 3, 1987, will shortly arise.
The question regarding the filling up of the vacancy upon the term of respondent No.
May, 1977 Hill Commissioner, Secretary, Planning, Finance, PWD, Power, Food and Civil Supplies in the Government of Manipur.
1969 Deputy Secretary in Cabinet Secretariat.
From the Judgment and Order dated 7.8.
2, Shri Suresh Mathur who was an officer of the rank of Additional Secretary to the Govern ment of India and was the Secretary, U.P.S.C. at that time was appointed by transfer on deputation initially for a period of six months.
2 as Director General of All India Radio upto March 3, 1987.
Later, Director in charge of Man power Employment.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION Civil Appeal No.
1982 did number acquire the requisite qualification for being companysidered for promotion to the post of Director General, All India Radio as he had number rendered three years service in the said grade of Additional Director General on the said date.
1, Shri A.R. Shinde, the Additional Director General, before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, Delhi on the ground inter alia that though he fulfilled all the requisite qualifications as provided in the said rules for being companysidered for promotion to the post of Director General, All India Radio, his case was number companysidered and the said order was made companytinuing the appointment of re spondent No.
K. Ganguli, P. Parmeshwaran and A. Mariaputham for the Appellant.
January, 1973 Chief of Division and later as Joint Secretary to the Government of India in charge of State Plan and Multi level Planning Division in the Planning Commission.
New Delhi in O.A. No.
Shri Mathur had to his credit 29 years of administrative experience as on 1985 as an Officer belong ing to the Indian Administrative Service, of which he had been in the rank of Joint Secretary to Government of India or above for 13 years.
C. Gupta, M.N. Shroff and K.M.M. Khan, for the Re spondents.
1986 of the Central Administrative Tribunal.
The post of Director General, All India Radio fell vacant on 14th February, 1985.
27 of 1986.
2732 of 1986.
After approval by the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet the further companytinuation of respondent No.
His service included terms as Joint Secretary in the Planning Commission in charge of State Plans and Multi level Planning, Additional Chief Secretary, and as Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur, Joint Secre tary in the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, as Secretary, UPSC etc.,
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by C.RAY, J. This appeal by special leave is against the order made on 7.8.1986 by the Central Administrative Tribu nal, Principal Bench, Delhi holding that the order dated 10.12.
In accord ance with the aforesaid recruitment rules the Additional Director General in the All India Radio who had also served for three years in the post of Additional Director General will be companysidered for promotion to the post of Director General.
1986 extending the appointment of respondent No.
Accordingly on March 4, 1985 the respondent No.
1, Shri A.R. Shinde who was appointed as Additional Director General on 24.8.
The respondent No.
2, Shri Suresh Mathur as the Director General of All India Radio is invalid.
2 as Director General, All India Radio till 3rd March, 1987 was numberified on th December, 1985 on the basis of the said proposal.
Later, Additional Chief Secretary and Chief Secretary to the Government of Manipur.
the details of which are 1956 Joined IAS Madhya Pradesh Cadre 1967 Managing Director, Tribal Co operative Development Corporation, where his duties included Development of small scale industries by organising infrastru cure, raw material and marketing, promotion of the development of hand looms and handicrafts industry and establishment of companyoperative movement in the tribal area.
