He was companyfirmed w.e.f.
Executive Engineer and was promoted as Executive Engineer on October 8, 1973.
From the Judgment and order dated 9.7.1984 of the Punjab Haryana High Court in Civil Writ Petition No.5371 of 1981.
The recruitment to the service is made by the government as per Rule 5 1 a by direct recruitment b by transfer from any other services of the State Govt.
R. Sheoran who was shown junior to the appellants, field Writ Petition No.
On reference, a Division Bench of the High Court by its judgement dated July 9, 1984 agreed with the ratio laid down in M.S. Mighlani v. State of haryana Anr.,
The Governor, in exercise of the power under proviso to Art.
1960 for short the Rules companystituting the Punjab Service of Engineers, Class I, P.W.D. Roads and Buildings Branch , After the formation of State of Haryana w.e.f.
Raje Ram Sheoran was recruited and appointed directly as Asstt.
This appeal on leave arises against the judgement of the Division Bench.
The rest are yet to be companyfirmed.
Executive Engineer and the appellants and the proforma respondents are number members of the service and directed the learned Single Judge to dispose of th matter on merit.
November 1, 1966, the rules are called Haryana Service of Engineers, Class I, P.W.D. Roads and Buildings Branch .
1983 1 S.L.R. 421 and held that R.R. Sheoran was a member of the service from the date of his initial appointment as Asstt.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION Civil Appeal No.4094 of 1984.
July 11, 1973, December 11, 1974 and December 9, 1975 respectively.
The services companysist of Asstt.
and Janendra lal for the appellants.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by RAMASWAMY, J. The appellants and the proforma respondents, thirty in number are employed in the Punjab Service of Engineers, Class II.
He too was given relaxation of the length of service of five years as Asstt.
309 of the Constitution of India framed the Punjab Service of Engineers, Class I, W.D. Road and Buildings Rules.
P. Rao, Sr.
The appellants for short the promotees from Class II Service were promoted as Executive Engineers by relaxing five years length of service as Class II Engineers in officiating capacity on various dates between January 6, 1969 to May 29, 1971, There of them, namely, A.N. Sehgal, Raj Kumar and H.C. Sethi were companyfirmed as Executive Engineers w.e.f.
All the appellants except M.R. Gupta were further promoted as Superintending Engineers on different dates between 1980 to 1984 and Mr. Sheoran was promoted as Superintending Engineer on March 4, 1987 A.N. Sehgal was further promoted as Chief Engineer, Equally Mr. Sheoran was also promoted as Chief Engineer but the validity was challenged and it is number necessary to refer any further as it is subject matter of proceedings in the High Court.
C. Gupta, Rajinder Sachhar, Sudarshan Goyal, Vivek Bhandari, S.C.Patel, mahabir Singh and C.M. Nayar NP for the Respondents.
Executive Engineer w.e.f October 25, 1971.
December 22, 1976.
5371/81 and sought a writ of mandamus directing the second respondent, State Government to companysider his case for promotion as Superintending Engineer from the date on which the respondents were promoted to quash the gradation list to assign the seniority over the appellants and the companysequential reliefs.
