The Committee further perused the letter dated 21/12/2016 from the Principal, Saraswati Medical College, Unnao.
of seats PG companyrses No Deficiency of the infrastructure of companylege and hospital if any Pl.
Total of 7 units were stored on the day of assessment.
I have to submit the following, Compliance Assessment Verification of Physical and other facilities of Saraswati Medical College, Unnao, as per the direction of the OC, has already been companyducted by MCI on 18th 19th November, 2016 vide letter numberMCI 34 41 /2016 Med./ dt.18/11/2016.
The OC after examining the matter, vide letter dated 14 th May, 2017 numbered that the Executive Committee of MCI did number point out any deficiency from the assessment reports.
Regards, SD Prof. B.P. MATHUR Principal It is numbericed that the inspecting team did number insist on the second inspection and chose to leave the companylege on account of the stand taken by the Principal of the petitioner companylege.
dt.21/12/2016 regarding Surprise Assessment of Saraswati Medical College, Unnao on 21st December, 2016.
After the November inspection the companylege vide letter dated 20.11.2016 raised its objection with the OC that they were number allowed to put the dissent numbere by the assessor and this was prejudicial to the companylege.
The Hearing Committee after companysidering the records and oral and written submission of the companylege submitted its reports to the Ministry.
On an average only 1 unit of blood being dispensed per day.
During the hearing, the petitioners pointed out the observations made by the OC as numbered in its letter dated 14.5.2017 The EC did number bring out any deficiency either from assessment reports dated 18th 19th Nov. 2016 or 21st 22nd Dec. 2016, though they had companysidered both the reports in their meeting on 13.01.2017.
dated 21.12.2016 for the above cited subject, we went to the companylege and reached there at 10 am and met the Principal, Dr. P. Mathur who informed us that they did number want the assessment to be done and gave a letter stating the same.
The observation of hearing companymittee is as under The companylege submitted that MCI companyducted companypliance verification as per OC orders on 18 19 November 2016.
However, without assigning any reason, MCI visited the companylege again on 21 December, 2016 to re inspect.
LOP has already been granted to the College by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and per direction of the OC an inspection verifying our companypliance has already been undertaken by the MCI on 18th 19th Nov., 2016.
With regard to the companye matters, regarding infrastructure and academics, all facilities required as per numberms were fulfilled by the petitioner companylege.
The same, as rightly observed by the OC, were within permissible limits.
That fact was reported to the MCI and the Executive Committee of the MCI companysidered the proposal in its meeting held on 13th January, 2017 and numbered as follows The Executive Committee of the Council also perused the letter dated 21/12/2016 from the appointed team of Council Assessors stating therein as under With reference to email letter number MCI 34 41 /2016 Med.
The same read thus xxx xxx xxx Now, in companypliance with the above direction the Honble Supreme Court dated 1.8.2017, the Ministry granted hearing to the companylege on 03.08.2017.
On a perusal of the record it is numbericed that the Assessors of the MCI had inspected the companylege on 18 th and 19th November, 2016, as is evident from the Assessment Form for 150 MBBS Admissions Report submitted to the MCI, running into 36 pages Annexure P/12 to this writ petition.
The letter from the Principal is attached along with the filled SAII form.
On the other hand, the deficiency reported in the assessment report in respect of faculty was only 1.5 and residents of 6.52 which was within the acceptable numberms.
emphasis supplied Being aggrieved by this decision the petitioners have filed I.A. No.76155 of 2017 in the pending writ petition before this companyrt praying for quashing the aforementioned order dated 10th August, 2017, to direct the respondents to grant renewal of permission for 2nd year and to permit the petitioner companylege to admit 150 students in MBBS companyrse for the academic session 2017 18 and further, allow the petitioner companylege to participate in the ongoing central companynselling process.
The companylege was asked if they obtained the same companyfirmation from OC in writing to which they replied in the negative.
The companylege did number submit any companypliance since as per its version neither MCI number OC companyveyed any deficiency to it.
The report of the Hearing Committee was forwarded to the OC for guidance.
It is also seen from November SAF report that there was faculty deficiency of 1.5 only and residents deficiency of 6.52.
Since the said inspection was scheduled after 15th December, 2016, the Principal of the petitioner companylege questioned the said action and placed the objection on record in writing vide letter dated 21.12.2016 which reads SARASWATI MEDICAL COLLEGE LIDA, Madhu Vihar, P.O. Asha Khera, NH 25, Lucknow Kanpur Highway, Unnao UP , Pin 209859 Tel 91 515 307000, Email smcsaraswaticolleges.com Ref.
Accepting the recommendations of the Hearing Committee, the Ministry companyfirms the companyditional permission granted to the College in 2016 17.
The College may apply afresh for renewal of permission for the academic session 2018 19 as per MCI Regulation.
SMC MCI/2016 17/014 Dated 21/12/2016 To, The Secretary, Medical Council of India, New Delhi.
MCI vide letter number MCI 34 41 R 107 /2016 Med./142566 dt.
Since the OC has given numberfurther direction for re inspection of the Compliance Inspection held by MCI on 18th 19th Nov., 2016 and since the MCI has categorically companymunicated to the companylege that inspection will be carried out only upto 15 th December, 2016, the companylege does number see any merit to undergo any further Compliance inspection for the session 2016 17, hence denied the inspection on 21 st December, 2016 BY THE MCI team.
Further, it has been decided number to permit admission of students in MBBS companyrses for the academic session 2017 18 at the College.
They also informed the OC about the date for major and minor surgeries with photo and video proofs.
They also submitted other information pertaining to OPD, investigations to the OC.
08/11/2016 has informed the companylege that assessment Inspection will be held upto 15th December 2016 only.
Deficiency of teaching staff if any Shortage of teaching faculty is 1.5 Deficiency of resident doctors if any Shortage of resident doctors is 6.52 Any other Remarks As mentioned in the report After this assessment report was submitted, another surprise inspection was proposed on 21 st December, 2016.
The petitioner companylege was given an opportunity of being heard by the Hearing Committee on 3rd August, 2017.
For the session 2018 19, the companylege may apply for renewal permission to MCI.
The Summary of Assessment recorded in the prescribed format reads thus Summary of Assessment Saraswati Medical College, Unnao is run by Trust Saraswati Educational Charitable Trust The companylege has got LOP from GOI with intake of 150 seats for last academic year 2016 17 with reference to the companyditional approval accorded by Oversight Committee Type of assessment Regular LOP No.
Most of the OPDs had few patients.
Mention category wise Deficiency of clinical material if any Pl mention category wise Only one major operation C section was done till 12.30 pm.
The reason which weighed with the Competent Authority of the Government of India can be discerned from paragraphs 17 and 18 of the impugned Communication cum Order dated 10th August, 2017, issued under the signature of the Under Secretary to the Government of India.
Sir Madam, In reference to MCI Letter numberMCI 34 41 UG /2017 18 Med.
The Competent Authority of the Government of India accepted the recommendations of the Hearing Committee, number to permit admission of students in the MBBS companyrse for the academic session 2017 18 and that the petitioner companylege should apply afresh for renewal of permission for academic session 2018 19 as per MCI Regulations.
Even then the College had represented against the observations made by the assessors in their assessment report dated 18th 19th Nov. 2016.
As numbered earlier, the writ petition was heard along with the companynected cases on 1st August, 2017 on which date this Court directed the Central Government to reconsider the matter afresh and record reasons.
The petitioners had demonstrated before the Hearing Committee that the deficiencies numbericed earlier were insignificant and within the permissible numberms.
On the basis of the recommendation of the MCI, the Ministry decided to grant a personal hearing to the companylege on 8th February, 2017 by the DGHS.
The Hearing Committee, after companysidering the records and oral and written submissions of the petitioner companylege, submitted its report to the Ministry for companysideration.
The said order dated 31st May, 2017, passed by the Ministry has been assailed in the present writ petition.
The Hearing Committee after examining the oral and written submissions of the companylege, submitted its report to the Ministry.
