《明史·列传·卷一百六十一》
后军将领左襄力看到贼兵从后边来了，吓得抢先逃跑了，其他各军也都跟着逃，官军于是被打得大败，只有高杰的部队损失很小。
后军左勷望见贼，怖而先奔，众军皆奔，遂大溃，杰所亡失独少。
The rear army general Zuo Xiangli, seeing the bandits coming from behind, panicked and ran first, and the other armies followed suit, and the imperial forces were resoundingly defeated. Only Gao Jie's forces suffered minimal losses.