《明史·列传·卷一百四十》
总兵里面，河南左良玉有功，陕西曹变蛟、左光先没有功，山西虎大威、山东倪宠、江北牟文绶、保定钱中选有劳无功，河南张任学、宁夏祖大弼没有功也没有过。
总兵则河南左良玉有功，陕西曹变蛟、左光先无功，山西虎大威、山东倪宠、江北牟文绶、保定钱中选有劳无功，河南张任学、宁夏祖大弼无功过。
Among the generals, Zuo Liangyu of Henan has made contributions, while Cao Biangjiao and Zuo Guangxian of Shaanxi have made no contributions. Hu D 威 of Shanxi, Ni Chong of Shandong, Mou Wenshou of Jiangbei, Qian Zhongxuan of Baoding, Zhang Renxue of Henan, and Zu of Ningxia The big assistant has no merits and no faults.