《旧唐书·本纪·卷二十》
刘守文带着残余的部众返回魏州，被张存敬、葛从周乘机袭击，燕州军再次失败，仅仅刘仁恭父子脱逃。
刘守文以余众还魏州，为存敬、从周所乘，燕军复败，仁恭父子仅免。
Liu Shou-wen retreated back to Wei Prefecture with his broken army, and was attacked by Zhang Cun-jing and Ge Cong-zhou, and the Yan Prefecture troops failed again, with only Liu Ren-gong and his son escaping.