《魏书·帝纪·卷十一》
这年春季，冠军将军、直直业刺史兹坏塑指派他的部将坦童率领步兵骑兵三千人在王鳄攻打盖街的守将，擒获盖堑的尚书左仆射、仪同三司、云麾将军、逮兖二州刺史刘扭迦。
是春，冠军将军、南青州刺史茹怀朗使其部将何宝率步骑三千击萧衍守将于琅邪，擒其尚书左仆射、仪同三司、云麾将军、徐兗二州刺史刘相如。
In the spring of that year, General Champion and Ciye Prefectural Governor Zibadisu commanded his military commander Tantan to lead 3,000 foot soldiers and cavalry to attack the garrison at Gaixie. They captured the Commandant of the Left of the Minister of War at Gaixie, Imperial Consultant, General of Clouds and Banners, and Prefectural Governor of Yanzhou and Yuzhou Liu Niujia.