"gold futures climb for first time in four sessions" Does the news headline compare gold with any other asset? No

"gold eases on steady selling; silver recovers" Does the news headline talk about a general event (apart from prices) in the future? No

"gold gains give edge to bay street" Does the news headline talk about price in the past? Yes

"gold etfs soar as russia probe closes in on trump's inner circle" Does the news headline talk about price in the future? No

"gold ends lower; silver leads losses among metals" Does the news headline talk about price in the past? Yes

"Gold prices fall for the day, but post a second straight monthly gain" Does the news headline talk about price going up?