<p>If you had a simple slit spectroscope, and looked at an incandescent light, you'd see a smear of light with red on one end and blue on the other. This is because the filament is producing light by glowing from being heated.</p><p>If you looked at one of those orange colored sodium vapor street lamps, instead of a smear of color, you'd see a <a href="https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ca/Spectrum-hp-sodium.jpg">group of lines</a>. This light is produced by ionizing the gas.</p><p>The lines represent specific frequencies of light coming from the lamp. You could add a horizontal scale and find that the lines represent a specific frequency in the light spectrum.</p><p> If the street lamp was coming at you at a significantly high speed, the individual lines would be shifted in frequency towards blue, but would still have the same pattern. Conversely, if the light was moving away from you, you'd again see the same pattern of light lines, but their frequencies would be shifted toward red.</p><p>This is what's being measured when the spectra of stars and galaxies are measured: not just what the color looks like, but whether the spectra of things like hydrogen, helium and iron are shifted in frequency towards red or blue.</p><p>So, it's the specific line patterns produced by these elements when they are ionized in stars that helps us identify them. Comparing the light frequencies of locally ionized elements to the frequencies coming from distant stars that tell us if the stars themselves are approaching or receding.</p> </p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-10-25T22:50:18.690Z
"This light is produced by ionizing the gas". Untrue. An ionized gas would produce continuum emission punctuated by absorption edges. Line emission is of course due to transitions of bound electrons either within atoms or ions. In the particular case you cite - the sodium D lines - the source is neutral sodium atoms. And of course often what is measured, particularly if talking about starlight is *absorption* lines.
ProfRob
CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-10-25T23:22:40.500Z
@RobJeffries You're right. The question's about red/blue shift, though.
Howard Miller
CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-10-25T13:47:49.527Z
2015-10-25T13:47:49.527Z
Howard Miller
<p>If a star/galaxy is moving towards us, then its light is blueshifted, and if it is moving away from us, then its light is redshifted. How do we exactly know that the color we are seeing is not part of the fuel burnt by the star/galaxy, and is instead caused by the Doppler effect?</p>

<redshift><doppler-effect>
How do we know that light is redshifted/blueshifted and not the original light of a star/galaxy?
Madeyedexter
# How do we know that light is redshifted/blueshifted and not the original light of a star/galaxy?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2015-10-25)

If a star/galaxy is moving towards us, then its light is blueshifted, and if it is moving away from us, then its light is redshifted. How do we exactly know that the color we are seeing is not part of the fuel burnt by the star/galaxy, and is instead caused by the Doppler effect?

**Tags:** redshift, doppler-effect

---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2015-10-25. Score: 9 | Accepted answer

If you had a simple slit spectroscope, and looked at an incandescent light, you'd see a smear of light with red on one end and blue on the other. This is because the filament is producing light by glowing from being heated.

If you looked at one of those orange colored sodium vapor street lamps, instead of a smear of color, you'd see a [group of lines](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ca/Spectrum-hp-sodium.jpg). This light is produced by ionizing the gas.

The lines represent specific frequencies of light coming from the lamp. You could add a horizontal scale and find that the lines represent a specific frequency in the light spectrum.

If the street lamp was coming at you at a significantly high speed, the individual lines would be shifted in frequency towards blue, but would still have the same pattern. Conversely, if the light was moving away from you, you'd again see the same pattern of light lines, but their frequencies would be shifted toward red.

This is what's being measured when the spectra of stars and galaxies are measured: not just what the color looks like, but whether the spectra of things like hydrogen, helium and iron are shifted in frequency towards red or blue.

So, it's the specific line patterns produced by these elements when they are ionized in stars that helps us identify them. Comparing the light frequencies of locally ionized elements to the frequencies coming from distant stars that tell us if the stars themselves are approaching or receding.

> **Comments:**
> **username_2**: "This light is produced by ionizing the gas". Untrue. An ionized gas would produce continuum emission punctuated by absorption edges. Line emission is of course due to transitions of bound electrons either within atoms or ions. In the particular case you cite - the sodium D lines - the source is neutral sodium atoms. And of course often what is measured, particularly if talking about starlight is *absorption* lines.  
> **username_1**: @RobJeffries You're right. The question's about red/blue shift, though.  

---

