Answers.Body: <p>The relevant sections from <a href="https://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=208&amp;view=article" rel="nofollow noreferrer">https://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=208&amp;view=article</a>:</p>
  
  <blockquote>
    4.2.1
    
    <p>Only the player having the move may adjust one or more pieces ...</p>
    
    4.2.2
    
    <p>Any other physical contact with a piece, except for clearly accidental contact, shall be considered to be intent.</p>
    
    4.3
    
    <p>Except as provided in Article 4.2, if the player having the move touches on the chessboard,with the intention of moving or capturing:</p>
    
    4.3.1
    
    <p>one or more of his own pieces, he must move the first piece touched that can be moved</p>
    
    4.3.2
    
    <p>one or more of his opponent’s pieces, he must capture the first piece touched that can be captured</p>
    
    4.3.3
    
    <p>one or more pieces of each colour, he must capture the first touched opponent’s piece with his first touched piece or, if this is illegal, move or capture the first piece touched that can be moved or captured. If it is unclear whether the player’s own piece or his opponent’s was touched first, the player’s own piece shall be considered to have been touched before his opponent’s.</p>
  </blockquote>
  
  <p>Article 4.2.2 establishes that any non-accidental contact shall be considered intent, so touching the opponent's bishop with your knight establishes intent to capture. At that stage, you've touched both your knight and your opponent's bishop - that is, you've touched <em>"one or more pieces of each colour"</em> -  so article 4.3.3 dictates what happens next.</p>
  
  <p>Let's break down article 4.3.3, then. It first says you must:</p>
  
  <blockquote>
    <p>capture the first touched opponent’s piece with his first touched piece</p>
  </blockquote>
  
  <p>(nope, you can't do that - it's an illegal move)</p>
  
  <blockquote>
    <p>or, if this is illegal</p>
  </blockquote>
  
  <p>(it is)</p>
  
  <blockquote>
    <p>move or capture the first piece touched that can be moved or captured</p>
  </blockquote>
  
  <p>Since your knight cannot be moved, the "first piece touched that can be moved or captured" is your opponent's bishop. Therefore you must capture it.</p>
  
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-04-06T17:24:16.660Z
Answers.LastActivityDate: 2019-04-06T17:24:16.660Z
Answers.UserDisplayName: Mark Amery
Answers.Body: <p>Article 4.3.2 clarifies this -</p>
  
  <blockquote>
    <p>4.3 Except as provided in Article 4.2 [j'adoube], if the player having the move touches on the chessboard,with the intention of moving or capturing:</p>
    
    <p>4.3.2 one or more of his opponent’s pieces, he must capture the first piece touched that can be captured</p>
  </blockquote>
  
  <p>In the scenario you describe you touch your knight and your opponent's bishop with the intention of capturing the bishop with your knight. Moving the knight is illegal hence you may not capture the bishop with the knight. However capturing the bishop with some other piece, your queen, is legal. Therefore you must capture the bishop with that piece.</p>
  
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-02-15T22:59:13.040Z
Answers.Text: In the [lawbook I found](https://www.fide.com/FIDE/handbook/LawsOfChess.pdf), there is a section right after this which I think is much clearer. "[If a player deliberately touches...] one piece of each colour, he must capture the opponent’s piece with his piece or, if this is illegal, move or capture the first piece touched which can be moved or captured."
Answers.UserDisplayName: amalloy
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-02-15T23:35:24.187Z
Answers.Text: @amalloy The reference you have given is for the FIDE Laws of Chess before 1st July 2014. Since then they have changed 3 times. The current version, valid from 1st January 2018, is here - https://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=208&view=article. That is the version the OP references and it is the one that should be used for current competitions.
Answers.UserDisplayName: Brian Towers
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-02-16T00:16:12.890Z
Answers.Text: Indeed. Then from that reference, it seems law 4.3.3 is the relevant one: 4.3.2 appears intended to apply to when you have only touched an opponent's piece, touching no piece of your own.
Answers.UserDisplayName: amalloy
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-02-16T03:09:26.320Z
Answers.Text: And what happens if there's nothing that could capture the bishop?
Answers.UserDisplayName: Alexander
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-02-16T10:09:58.447Z
Answers.Text: @amalloy The last line of the OP's question says - "Reference in FIDE Rules is Article 4.3.3 but it still seems it doesn't explain this scenario well enough."
Answers.UserDisplayName: Brian Towers
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-04-06T17:25:51.323Z
Answers.Text: I believe that the conclusion here is correct but that the reasoning is faulty. It looks to me like the scenario described in the question is governed by article 4.3.3, not article 4.3.2, as I argue in my answer below; article 4.3.2 only applies in the scenario where the player has *only* touched his opponent's pieces, and none of his own color, and is therefore not relevant here. @amalloy got this right, and telling him to "brush up on his reading skills" in your comment above was unwarranted.
Answers.UserDisplayName: Mark Amery
Answers.ContentLicense: CC BY-SA 4.0
Answers.CreationDate: 2019-02-15T16:21:05.180Z
Answers.LastActivityDate: 2019-02-15T16:21:05.180Z
Answers.UserDisplayName: Brian Towers
Body: <p>This is the scenario: I pick up my Knight to capture my opponent's Bishop (touching the Bishop). I then realise my Knight was pinned to my King in the first place, so moving it would be illegal. However, I have already touched my opponent's Bishop with my Knight. Since I have touched my opponent's Bishop, would I have to capture the Bishop with another piece of mine (in this case my Queen can legally capture the Bishop instead), or am I allowed to just move any other piece entirely? Reference in FIDE Rules is Article 4.3.3 but it still seems it doesn't explain this scenario well enough.</p>
  
Tags: <rules>
Title: Touch-move when move is illegal but opponent's piece can be captured by another piece
ThreadText: # Touch-move when move is illegal but opponent's piece can be captured by another piece
  
  (Asked by: username_0 on 2019-02-15)
  
  This is the scenario: I pick up my Knight to capture my opponent's Bishop (touching the Bishop). I then realise my Knight was pinned to my King in the first place, so moving it would be illegal. However, I have already touched my opponent's Bishop with my Knight. Since I have touched my opponent's Bishop, would I have to capture the Bishop with another piece of mine (in this case my Queen can legally capture the Bishop instead), or am I allowed to just move any other piece entirely? Reference in FIDE Rules is Article 4.3.3 but it still seems it doesn't explain this scenario well enough.
  
  **Tags:** rules
  
  
  ---
  
  ## 2 answers
  
  ### Answer by username_2 on 2019-02-15. Score: 15 | Accepted answer
  
  Article 4.3.2 clarifies this -
  
  > 4.3 Except as provided in Article 4.2 [j'adoube], if the player having the move touches on the chessboard,with the intention of moving or capturing:
  >
  > 4.3.2 one or more of his opponent’s pieces, he must capture the first piece touched that can be captured
  
  In the scenario you describe you touch your knight and your opponent's bishop with the intention of capturing the bishop with your knight. Moving the knight is illegal hence you may not capture the bishop with the knight. However capturing the bishop with some other piece, your queen, is legal. Therefore you must capture the bishop with that piece.
  
  > **Comments:**
  > **username_3**: In the [lawbook I found](https://www.fide.com/FIDE/handbook/LawsOfChess.pdf), there is a section right after this which I think is much clearer. "[If a player deliberately touches...] one piece of each colour, he must capture the opponent’s piece with his piece or, if this is illegal, move or capture the first piece touched which can be moved or captured."  
  > **username_2**: @username_3 The reference you have given is for the FIDE Laws of Chess before 1st July 2014. Since then they have changed 3 times. The current version, valid from 1st January 2018, is here - https://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=208&view=article. That is the version the OP references and it is the one that should be used for current competitions.  
  > **username_3**: Indeed. Then from that reference, it seems law 4.3.3 is the relevant one: 4.3.2 appears intended to apply to when you have only touched an opponent's piece, touching no piece of your own.  
  > **username_4**: And what happens if there's nothing that could capture the bishop?  
  > **username_2**: @username_3 The last line of the OP's question says - "Reference in FIDE Rules is Article 4.3.3 but it still seems it doesn't explain this scenario well enough."  
  > **username_1**: I believe that the conclusion here is correct but that the reasoning is faulty. It looks to me like the scenario described in the question is governed by article 4.3.3, not article 4.3.2, as I argue in my answer below; article 4.3.2 only applies in the scenario where the player has *only* touched his opponent's pieces, and none of his own color, and is therefore not relevant here. @username_3 got this right, and telling him to "brush up on his reading skills" in your comment above was unwarranted.  
  
  ---
  
  ### Answer by username_1 on 2019-04-06. Score: 2
  
  The relevant sections from <https://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=208&view=article>:
  
  > 4.2.1
  >
  > Only the player having the move may adjust one or more pieces ...
  >
  > 4.2.2
  >
  > Any other physical contact with a piece, except for clearly accidental contact, shall be considered to be intent.
  >
  > 4.3
  >
  > Except as provided in Article 4.2, if the player having the move touches on the chessboard,with the intention of moving or capturing:
  >
  > 4.3.1
  >
  > one or more of his own pieces, he must move the first piece touched that can be moved
  >
  > 4.3.2
  >
  > one or more of his opponent’s pieces, he must capture the first piece touched that can be captured
  >
  > 4.3.3
  >
  > one or more pieces of each colour, he must capture the first touched opponent’s piece with his first touched piece or, if this is illegal, move or capture the first piece touched that can be moved or captured. If it is unclear whether the player’s own piece or his opponent’s was touched first, the player’s own piece shall be considered to have been touched before his opponent’s.
  
  Article 4.2.2 establishes that any non-accidental contact shall be considered intent, so touching the opponent's bishop with your knight establishes intent to capture. At that stage, you've touched both your knight and your opponent's bishop - that is, you've touched *"one or more pieces of each colour"* - so article 4.3.3 dictates what happens next.
  
  Let's break down article 4.3.3, then. It first says you must:
  
  > capture the first touched opponent’s piece with his first touched piece
  
  (nope, you can't do that - it's an illegal move)
  
  > or, if this is illegal
  
  (it is)
  
  > move or capture the first piece touched that can be moved or captured
  
  Since your knight cannot be moved, the "first piece touched that can be moved or captured" is your opponent's bishop. Therefore you must capture it.
  
  
  ---
  
  